Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
COURT CASE IN REGARDS TO THE SECOND AMENDMENT UNITED STATES V MILLER 1939
first Second Amendment case to be heard by the Supreme Court noted that the Second Amendment did NOT protect the right of CITIZENS to own firearms that were not ordinary militia weapons Miller, had been charged with possession of an unregistered sawed off shotgun; the Court noted that it had no evidence that such a weapon constituted ordinary militia equipment
was a federal case the regulation of arms has been a state matter UNTIL............
The law
placed restriction on handgun registration, setting up a minimum waiting period before purchase many states had to change their laws based on this legislation
The second part of the Fourth Amendment talks about no warrants shall issue but upon probable cause. Probable cause=reason to suspect you
What is a warrant?
a formal document signed by a judge that allows police to search or arrest you Warrants allow law enforcement officers who have reason to suspect you (probable cause) to ask a judge for permission to interfere with your privacy.
PROBABLE CAUSE
again, a reasonable belief that a crime has or is being committed; the basis for all lawful searches, seizures and arrests. is a key factor in determining if a search is legitimate applies to states is the first component of due process due process: the principle that the government must respect all of the legal rights that are owed to a person according to the law. MORE TO COME ON DUE PROCESS
plain view characteristic: allows police to obtain evidence that is in sight of the investigators
EXCLUSIONARY RULE
determined that police may obtain only that evidence available through a legitimate search warrant other evidence found at the scene of the crime is not admissible in the trial; it must be EXCLUDED
Due Process
refers to how and why laws are enforced. It applies to all persons, citizen or alien, as well as to corporations.
HABEAS CORPUS
refers to the right of every prisoner to challenge the terms of his or her incarceration in court before a judge today, the most frequently discussed international habeas corpus controversy is the Bush administration's policy of imprisoning hundreds of suspected Afghan and Iraqi terrorist associates in Guantanamo Bay and other offshore U.S. prisons without trial or meaningful judicial review
The Fifth Amendment and Property Rights and the Takings Clause:
under this clause, referred to as the takings clause, the government can't simply claim eminent domain (the power of the government to take private property for public use with payment of compensation to the owner) and take a citizens property recent developments, however, (most notably, Kelo v. New London (2005))have weakened the takings clause considerably.
ARGUMENTS AGAINST:
participants in a trial which is being broadcast are aware theyre being watched, and this could very well alter the behavior of those involved; shifts the focus to attention seeking and away from finding someone guilty or innocent criminal trials are a very serious matter and not something that should be viewed for entertainment people have a right to privacy; just because you may have broken the law, you should still have a right to privacy opens up the media to scrutinizing the defendant-picking apart the participants in the case, which could the affect the outcome of the trial judges, jurors and attorneys end up playing for the camera instead of concentrating on the case victims may be less likely to give evidence of painful incidences if they know they are being televised
Not only must jury members not have improper biases before the trial begins, but they must also not be improperly prejudiced by the case or by media coverage of the case. Since juries are by definition made up of members of the community, and human beings in general tend to be good at developing prejudices, this can be a challenge.
Assistance of Counsel:
Everyone tried for a criminal offense is given the right to an attorney. Public defenders, who take on the cases of those who can't afford private lawyers, are often overworked, and underpaid. Attorney/Client Privilege: statements made by a client to his/her lawyer are confidential
In a Nutshell:
The Seventh Amendment requires JURY trials in civil lawsuits where ordinary damages (legal damages that a jury or judge awards a plaintiff to "compensate" them for their legal losses) are sought. ex. hurt in a car accident, fall down in the parking of Wal-Mart No Jury for Divorces: A jury is not required in family law cases (such as divorce and custody cases). No Consensus Required: A simple majority is enough.