Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
The purpose of the day is to: re-examine the nature of classroom research share practice explore how innovative teaching and learning can be generated from the research activity develop guidelines and plans for future research within the programme
Session One
Classroom Research in Practice sharing experiences
Case Studies
Robin Bevan King Edward VI High School Mary Martin Comberton Village College Thalia Hinkley Sandbach High School and Sixth Form College
Discussion
COFFEE!
Session Two
Current and Future Research for School - Based Research
Research models Developing a focus Classroom observation Data gathering Data analysis Reporting on research School improvement processes
Reflect
My enquiry questioning is disrupted by my need to keep control in ways the class expects.
Record questions and responses on tap for a couple of lessons to see what is happening. Keep notes of my impressions in a diary.
Observe Observe
Act Act
Shift questioning strategy to encourage students to explore answers to their own questioning.
Try questions which let students say what they mean, what interests them.
Revise Plan
Reflect
Enquiry developing but students are more unruly. How can I keep them on track? By listening to each other, probing their questions? What lessons help?
Observe Act
Record on tape questioning and control statements. Note in diary effects on student behaviour
Identifying initial idea Reconnaissance (fact-finding and analysis) General Plan Action steps 1 Action steps 2 Action steps 3 Monitor implementation and effects Reconnaissance (explain any failure to implement, and effects
CYCLE 1
CYCLE 2
Monitor Implementation and effect Reconnaissance (explain any failure to Implement, and effects)
CYCLE 3
ACTION CYCLE 2
Etc....
Define problem
Redefine problem
Evaluate action
Needs assessment
Evaluate action
Needs assessment
New Hypotheses
Developing a focus
1. Start with a general idea about something that needs to be improved and centre your attention on:
What is happening now? In what sense is problematic? What can I do about it?
Developing a focus
2. Produce a list of ideas. These may relate to:
the schools Development Plan the schools aims, targets and mission statement Practical and immediate concerns
3. Evaluate the usefulness, viability and or importance of the individual issue by selecting an initial focus that:
is viable is discrete is intrinsically interesting involves collaboration is related in some way to teaching and learning and whole school concerns
Does Technology feature in the Schemes of work in all subjects? What definitions of Technology are used by heads of department? What is the students experience of Technology in other core subjects? This might include, respectively: document search; interview; student questionnaire.
2 An Evolutionary approach Take a broad area for investigation Gender issues in the provision of TAC
Analysis of enrolment data and exam results. Classroom observation of some Technology lessons. Unstructured interviews with teachers/ students. Why did more boys than girls enrol for this course this year? Are the practical activities appropriate or interesting to girls? This might include, respectively: student interview; structured observation and interview
TimeLine
Oct.-Dec.
Jan.-Mar.
Have students received 10% balanced TAC? Does the reality reflect the plan?
Staff; Students
Interviews; questionnaires
Co-ordinator; evaluator
Easter onward
Joint planning
Focus Establishing criteria Observation skills Feedback
Planning meeting
Feedback discussion
Classroom observation
Examples of Methods
Observation
Open Observation Focused observation Structured observation Systematic observation
Data Gathering
Field Notes
Advantages
Very simple to keep; no outsider needed
Disadvantages
Need to fall back on aids such as question analysis sheets, tapes and transcripts for specific information Conversation impossible to record by field notes
Provide good on- going record used as a diary they give good continuity First- hand information can be studied conveniently in teachers own time Acts as an aide- mmoire Helps to relate incidents, explore emerging trends Very useful if teacher intends to write a case study
Notebook works with small groups but not with a full class Initially time- consuming Can be highly subjective
Data Gathering
Audiotape Recording
Advantages
Very successfully monitors all conversations within range of the recorder Provides ample material with great ease
Disadvantages
Nothing visual does not record silent activities Transcription largely prohibitive because of expense and time involved Masses of material may provide little relevant information Can disturb pupils because of its novelty; can be inhibiting
Versatility can be transported or left with a group Can trace development of a groups activities Can support classroom assessment
Data Gathering
Pupil diaries
Advantages
Very Provides feedback from pupils perspective Can be either focused on a specific training episode or related to the general classroom climate Can be apart of a lesson
Disadvantages
May not be an established practice in the school Difficult for younger children to record their thoughts and feelings
Pupils may be inhibited in discussing their feelings with the teacher Pupils accounts are obviously subjective May raise ethical dilemmas
Can help in identifying individual pupils problems Provides a basis for triangulation
Data Gathering
Interviews:
Teacher/pupil (individually or in groups of 3 or 4)
Advantages
Teacher in direct contact with pupil Pupil(s) familiar with teacher, therefore more at ease
Disadvantages
Time-consuming May be carried out with some form of recording equipment, with attendant disadvantages
Teacher able to seek information he or she wants directly and not through a ream of irrelevant information Can be done in lesson time or outside the class Can follow up problems immediately when they arise and get information while minds are still fresh
Frequently difficult to get younger children to explain their thoughts and feelings
Data Gathering
Interviews: Observer/pupil (individually or in groups of 3 or 4)
Advantages
Leaves teacher free as the interviewer discovers initial information from the pupil(s) Pupil(s) frequently more candid with the outsider than with class teacher or teacher from within the school Outsider is likely to be more objective
Disadvantages
Pupil(s) unfamiliar with observer may be reluctant to divulge relevant information Mutual uncertainty If the teacher is the primary agent in the research, then he or she will get his or her information secondhand and subject to the biases of the interviewer
Outsider can focus the information provided along predetermined lines of investigation
The whole set up is time-consuming as information goes from pupil(s) to interviewer to teacher
Difficult to obtain a skilled outsider
Data Gathering
Interviews: Pupil/pupil
Advantages
Pupils may be more candid with each other Leaves teacher free Can occur during lesson time May produce unanticipated/unusual perspectives
Disadvantages
Pupils may find the activity too unfamiliar May encourage disruption Has to be recorded and played to teacher
Data Gathering
Video recorder and digital camera
Advantages
Video recorder Enables all situations to be constantly reviewed Origin of problems can be diagnosed Behavioural patterns of teacher and pupils can be seen Patterns of progress over long periods can be clearly charted Digital camera Advantage may be obtained by looking at images of kids working, or at end products of their work, and as a stimulus for discussion As an instrument which helps you get observation and comment from other teachers who were not present at the time
Disadvantages
Video recorder Can be very conspicuous and distracting If camera is directed by operator, it will only record that which he or she deems to be of importance; operator acts as editor
Digital camera Shows isolated situations; difficulty of being in the right place at the right time; concentrates on small groups and individuals, not classes; records nothing in depth Images may not truly depict activities of the children, if photographer is selective
Data Gathering
Questionnaires
Advantages
Easy to administer; quick to fill in Easy to follow up
Disadvantages
Analysis is time-consuming Extensive preparation to get clear and relevant questions
Data Gathering
Sociometry
Advantages
Simple way to discover social relationships in class Provides guide to action Can be integrated into class activity
Disadvantages
Possibility of compounding the isolation of some pupils
Documentary evidence
Advantages
Illuminate issues surrounding a curriculum or teaching method Provide context, background and understanding Provide an easy way of obtaining other peoples perceptions
Disadvantages
Obtaining documents can be timeconsuming Certain documents may be difficult to obtain Certain persons may be unwilling to share confidential documents
Data Gathering
Case Study
Advantages
A relatively simple way of plotting the progress of a course or a pupils or groups reaction to teaching methods
Disadvantages
In order for the case study to be of value it must be fairly exhaustive; this means that it will be timeconsuming in its preparation and its writing Feedback available to teacher only after considerable lapse of time
Information yielded by case studies will tend to give a more accurate and representative picture than will any one of the research methods detailed above; case studies draw on data gathered by many methods
Anticipatory
Data reduction
During Data displays Post
During
Post
= ANALYSIS
Data collection
Data display
Data reduction
Conclusions: drawing/verifying
Fieldwork Methodology
Classroom research
Data collection
Becker
Selection and definition of concepts
Validation Interpretation
Action
Write theory
Surveys
Questionnaires
Observations
Interviews
Documents
1 Data collection and the generation of categories or hypotheses 2 Validation of categories or hypotheses
3 Interpretation by reference to theory, agreed criteria, established practice or teacher judgment 4 Plan action for development
The evidence used to generate hypotheses and consequent action is clearly documented
Action taken as a result of the research is monitored
The reader finds the research accessible and that it resonates with his/her own experience
Phase One: Establishing the Process Phase Two: Going Whole School
Shared values A mandate from staff Leadership potential Identification of change agents Willingness to make structural changes Capacity for improvement
Curriculum Tour
WHOLE SCHOOL DEVELOPMENT PRIORITY An Enquiry into Teaching and Learning
Stage I
Curriculum Tour
Memory
Synectics
Moving to Scale
Cohorts of 6 - 8 Schools 6 - 8 Members of School Improvement Group
Year 1
PLAN |
Year 2
Year 3
Cohort A
| .
Cohort B
.........
Cohort C
| .....
Whole School Emphasis on High Expectations and Pedagogic Consistency Sharing Schemes of Work and Curriculum Across and Between Schools, Clusters, Districts, LEAs and Nationally
Discussion What are the implication of this presentation for our partnership? What guidelines can we generate for the programme?
LUNCH!
Session Three
Enriching Pedagogy for Personalised Learning
I know what good work looks like and can help myself to learn
I know if I need extra help or to be challenged to do better I will get the right support
My parents are involved with the school and I feel I belong here
I can work well with and learn from many others as well as my teacher
Learning experiences are composed of content, process and social climate. As teachers we create for and with our children opportunities to explore and build important areas of knowledge, develop powerful tools for learning, and live in humanizing social conditions.
Traditional Teaching
Disconnected Knowledge
Capacity to Learn
Principles of learning
Effort is a more important determinant of achievement than ability Given the right time and support, almost all can become proficient learners
Principles of teaching
High expectations and challenging targets should be set for all While the standards should remain constant, time and support should be varied according to individual student need
Are there standards in place and targets for all students? Do we vary time and support?
Constructing Knowledge
Principle of Learning
Knowledge is a constructive process: learners actively make meaning and construct ideas and the connections between them
Principle of teaching
Students should be encouraged to be active learners and problemsolvers
So
We teach not to produce little living libraries on a subject, but rather to get students to think mathematically for themselves, to consider matters as an historian does, to take part in the process of knowledgegetting. Knowing is a process not a product.
Adapted from: Jerome Bruner, Toward a Theory of Instruction (1966)
Personalised Learning is
An educational approach that focuses on every individual achieving their potential and enhancing their learning skills About designing teaching, curriculum and the school organisation to address the needs of the student both individually and collectively A system that is more accessible, open to customisation and involves the learner in their own learning A learning offer to all children that extends beyond the school context into the local community and beyond
Teaching Skills
Teaching Models
Reflection
Teaching Relationships
Teaching Skills
Content coverage
Consistent success
Active teaching
Structuring information
Effective questioning
Teaching Relationships
Expectation effects on student achievement are likely to occur both directly through opportunity to learn (differences in the amount and nature of exposure to content and opportunities to engage in various types of academic activities) and indirectly through differential treatment that is likely to affect students' self-concepts, attributional inferences, or motivation.
Good, T.L. and Brophy, J.E. (1994) Looking In Classrooms (2nd ed)
Teaching Models
Our toolbox is the models of teaching, actually models for learning, that simultaneously define the nature of the content, the learning strategies, and the arrangements for social interaction that create the learning contexts of our students. For example, in powerful classrooms students learn models for:
Extracting information and ideas from lectures and presentations Memorising information Building hypotheses and theories Attaining concepts and how to invent them Using metaphors to think creatively Working effectively with other to initiate and carry out co-operative tasks
doors?
CURRICULUM
PERSONALISED LEARNING
Joineduplearningandteaching
1. There are many teaching approaches that can impact powerfully on learning its all about fitness for purpose
Number of students
Achievement of students
Joineduplearningandteaching
1. There are many teaching approaches that can impact powerfully on learning its all about fitness for purpose 2. The most successful teaching patterns induce students to construct knowledge - to inquire into subject areas intensively
Powerful Learning
Is the ability of learners to respond successfully to the tasks they are set, as well as the task they set themselves In particular, to:
Integrate prior and new knowledge Acquire and use a range of learning skills Solve problems individually and in groups
All this has been termed meta-cognition it is the learners ability to take control over their own learning processes.
Curriculum Development
Problem solving
Group Investigation
Role Playing
Synectics
Simulations
Non directive
Rule using
Simulations
Concept Attainment
Inductive Thinking
Classifying
Inductive Thinking
Concept Attainment
Multiple discrimination
Inductive Thinking
Concept Attainment
Chaining
Mnemonic
Specific Responding
Mnemonic
Simulations
Joineduplearningandteaching
1. There are many teaching approaches that can impact powerfully on learning its all about fitness for purpose 2. The most successful teaching patterns induce students to construct knowledge - to inquire into subject areas intensively 3. Importantly, the most effective models of teaching are also models of learning they increase the intellectual capacity of every student
Learning Skill
Extracting information and ideas from lectures and presentations Working effectively with others to initiate and carry out cooperative tasks
Phase Four: Engaging students in learning activities Phase Five: Summary and review
Joineduplearningandteaching
1. There are many teaching approaches that can impact powerfully on learning its all about fitness for purpose 2. The most successful teaching patterns induce students to construct knowledge - to inquire into subject areas intensively 3. Importantly, the most effective models of teaching are also models of learning they increase the intellectual capacity of every student 4. The application of specific models of curriculum and teaching can greatly reduce the effects of gender, socio-economic status and linguistic background as factors in student learning
Whole Class
Hi SES Lo SES
Test Scores
20
0
60
Pretest
Test Scores
40
20
Posttest
1. There are many teaching approaches that can impact powerfully on learning its all about fitness for purpose 2. The most successful teaching patterns induce students to construct knowledge - to inquire into subject areas intensively 3. Importantly, the most effective models of teaching are also models of learning they increase the intellectual capacity of every student 4. The application of specific models of curriculum and teaching can greatly reduce the effects of gender, socio-economic status and linguistic background as factors in student learning. 5. Teaching strategies should also be adapted to individual need through Assessment for Learning.
Joineduplearningandteaching
Discussion
Discussion What are the implications of todays discussions for our partnership planning over the next months and beyond?
From today
What is your focus? What aspects of teaching and learning will you focus on? How will you organise the whole school approach What will be your first steps? What input or support will you need? What will you be able to share with the Leading Edge Partnership Programme in June?
Next Steps
The Practitioner Research Programme Spring and Autumn 2007
Key Milestones
March and April research activity Strengthening the network online and school to school May sharing progress 20th June - The Leading Edge Partnership Programme conference July - Contributing to the LEPP dissemination materials Autumn workshop
Paulo Freire once said No one educates anyone else Nor do we educate ourselves We educate one another in communion In the context of living in this world