R410A MRV II Benchmark

Vs
Feb.,2008
By Ivan Feng Yantao

History & Trends

Position in the products

Function
High

V series S series J series

Room air conditioner
Low Small
2

Plus system

Standard system

Small system

VRF
Area
Large

MRV Function
High

Position in the products

MRVII-C MRV II
H-MRV & MRVII-S Small system

Plus system

Standard system

MRV
Low Small
2

Area
Large

Outdoor units lineup

Type
Refrigerant

MRV II-C

New
Series (848HP)
R410A

V Series (842HP)
Plus System R410A

Plus System

Cooling Only
8HP 10HP 14HP

Heat Pump

8,10HP

12,14,16HP

8HP

10HP

14HP

High COP
New

8,10HP

12,14,16HP

Master

Slave

MRV II-C

Airstage V

(8HP)

(10HP)

(14HP)

(8HP)

(10HP)

(14HP)

Cooling Heating

4.24 3.95 3.85

3.2

3.2

3.01
3.41

4.28 3.80 3.25 3.69 3.7

Brief

Outdoor Combination

Number of CU
HP 5 HP 8 HP Haier MRV II 10 HP (22 12 HP models) 14HP 16HP Fujitsu 8 HP Airstage 10 HP V (16 14HP models) 1 5 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 2 1 1 1 1 2 2 1 1 2 1 1 1 1 1 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 2 2 1 1 1 1 2 3 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24 26 28 30 32 34 36 38 40 42 44 46 48

1 1 2

2 1

1 2

1 1

2 1 2

1 2 3

Up to 64 indoor units can be connected;

Max. Connectable indoor units Capacity 8HP 10-16HP 18-28 30-42 42-48 MRV II-C Airstage V

13 16~26 29~46 50~64 64

15 16 32 48 --

Out of 10 types and 42 models, you can select indoor units design and capacity to be desired and well matched to your room.

10 Types 42 models, indoor line-up

Console type

11 Types 54 models

700X700 4-way

4-way cassette

Ceiling & Floor

Slim duct

Standard duct

Hi-static pressure duct

High wall

High wall

Indoor units line-up

Series Brand HP 0.8 Kw 2.2 1 2.8 1.25 3.6 1.7 4.5 2 5.6 2.3 6.8 2.5 7.1 30 8 3.2 9 4 11.2 5 14 8 22.4 10 28

4-Way cassette type

Haier
Fujitsu

Ceiling Concealed Duct

Haier Fujitsu

Medium Static Duct

Haier Fujitsu

High Static Duct

Haier
Fujitsu

Wall Mounted (V series) Wall Mounted ( comfort)

Haier Fujitsu Haier Fujitsu

LCD display

Wall Mounted (R series)

Haier
Fujitsu

Console

Haier Fujitsu

Floor & Ceiling

Haier Fujitsu

MRV II -C
Energy saving
Higher Cooling EER

MRV II-C has high COP in cooling mode

Cooling
3.95 3.6 3.8 3.69

3.32 3.2 3.2 3.2 3.2 MRV II-C Airstage V 3

2.8

10HP

20HP

30HP

42HP

Outdoor unit-Fujitsu

Dual Casing Bell Mouth A noise shut-off layer is built.

DC Inverter & Scroll Compressor High Efficiency heat exchanger Anti-corrosion treatment Fix speed Compressor

Pure inverter ! system

DC Fan Motor
Compared to conventional AC motors, a DC fan motor offers greater operating efficiency, especially during lowspeed rotation. The efficiency could be 90%.

High Efficiency heat exchanger

High efficiency DC Vector control Inverters

High Efficiency DC Inverter Scroll Compressor

3 kinds of MRV system

100%Load 50%Load

100%Load

50%Load

1 3
INV Comp

All Inverter
Haier (MRVII-C)
INV Com p

1
INV Com p

1
INV Comp

2 3
Fix Comp

Fix Comp

Part inverter Fujitsu ( Airstage V) Digital Scroll

Less parts ,low failure rate.

SAMSUNG

1
DS Co mp

2
Fix Co mp

* DS:digital scroll,Others are fixed speed compressor

Outdoor unit combination

Low running cost (8HP)

a) Power consumption in a year b) Power consumption in 5 years

Haier 32.6 %
Less

Fujitsu

It makes a profit of

after using our products for 5 years

a year power consumption

120000 100000 80000 60000 40000 20000 Kw/h 0 1 2 3 Year 4 5 Haier Fujitsu

15,840
kW/h

21,000
kW/h

working 10 hours per day ,300 days per year;

The difference of Inverter and Fixed speed unit

By using all inverter-driven compressors, Haier is able to significantly reduce the electrical and mechanical stresses that are placed on fixed-speed compressors during start-up.

Leakage

Friction between two pipes (fixed speed system)

Design work
Flexible to meet sophisticated condition of buildings or various requirements of customers

MRV II-C advantage on piping

Piping length Farthest piping from 1st branching Height between indoor units Max capacity of combined indoor units MRV II-C 40 m 15 m 50-130 Airstage V 60 m 15m 50-150

Outdoor unit

Max. drop between indoor and outdoor

When outdoor is lower than indoor units, the Max. drop is 50m

The first manifold pipe

Indoor units
Max. single pipelength L1+l<150m Max. pipe length first manifold manifold l<60m Max. pipe length after the after first pipe

Max. drop between indoor units

Easy install & Cost saving

Piping diameter Haier

MRV II-C

Fujitsu
Airstage V

Liquid Pipe ( mm )

8 HP 10 HP

9.52 9.52 12.7

12.7 12.7 12.7

14 HP
Gas Pipe (mm)

8 HP 10 HP 14 HP

19.05
22.2 25.4

22.2 22.2

28.58

Easy install & Cost saving

Piping diameter Haier

MRV II-C 15.88 19.05 19.05 19.05

Fujitsu
Airstage V
15.88 19.05 19.05

Liquid Pipe ( mm )

22HP 30 HP 36 HP

42HP
Gas Pipe (mm)

19.05

22 HP 30 HP 36 HP 42HP

28.58 31.8 38.1 38.1

34.92 34.92 41.27 41.27

Comfortable & Flexible

4-way cassette type spec.

Item Cooling capacity (Btu/h )
7000 9000 12000 16000 18000 20000 24000 28000 30000 38000

Sound level (dBA) MRV II-C

29/30/32 29/30/32 29/30/33 30/32/34 31/34/35 31/35/37 31/35/37 31/35/37

Air volume (m3/h) MRV II-C

700 700 700 1020 1020 1020 1920 1920

Power consumption(W) MRV II-C

80 80 80 80 80 80 150 150

Airstage V
31/35/38 31/35/38 -34/37/41 34/37/41 35/38/44 33/37/41 35/40/43 37/43/46 38/42.5/47 41/46/48.5

Airstage V
530/480/410 530/480/410 580/520/460 580/520/460 640/540/470 1000/840/700 1100/940/780 1250/1050/840 1500/1300/1100 1550/1350/1100

Airstage V
28 28 52 52 50 104 124 140 175 190

48000

35/39/42

43.5/47.5/51.5

1920

1700/1420/1200

150

219

Ceiling concealed duct type spec.

Item Cooling capacity (Btu/h )
7000 9000 12000 16000 18000 24000 28000 30000 38000 48000 72000 96000

Sound level (dBA)

MRV II-C
35/32/30 35/32/30 35/32/30

Air volume(m3/h)
MRV II-C
400 400 500

E.S.P (Pa)
MRV II-C
0-20 0-20 0-20

Power consumption (W)

MRV II-C
30 30 45

Airstage V
29/27/24 31/29/27 30/28/25

Airstage V
330/300/270 370/340/310 560/500/420

Airstage V
0-50 0-50 0-50

Airstage V
31.2 32.6 55

36/33/31
36/33/31 39/37/35

31/29/26
40/35/30 29/26/24

850
1250 1250

610/550/470
990/790/620 1100/1000/900

0-20
0-20 0-20

0-50
0-50 0-80

50
110 110

63
103 155

43/37/35
43/37/35 45/40 45/40 54/49 54/49

40/38/36 45/38/32 49/45/42 49/45/42 50/-/-

1470
1900 1600 2100 3300 4050

1400/1300/1200 1800 2040 3500/3000/2460 3950/-/-

0-96
0-96 0-196 0-196 0-196 0~196

30-150 100-200 100-250 100-250 100-300

100
100 320 360 500 500

172 405 427 427 970

Ceiling & floor type spec.

Item

Sound level (dBA)

MRV II-C
48/46/44 48/46/44 48/46/44 48/46/44 51/49/47 53/51/49 53/51/49

Air volume(m3/h)
MRV II-C
750 750 750 750 800 1500 1800

Power consumption (W)

MRV II-C
60 60 60 60 100 100 100

Cooling capacity (Btu/h )

9000 12000 16000 18000 24000 28000 30000

Airstage V
40/37/34 40/37/34 46/41.5/37 48/44/40 42/39/35 45/42/37 48/46/41 52/50/46

Airstage V
640/560/480 640/560/480 780/650/550 880/740/630 1450/1280/980 1660/1500/1270 1850/1660/1430 2200/2000/1800

Airstage V
57 57 88 88 124 144 160 180

38000
48000

Wall-mounted type spec.

Item Cooling capacity (Btu/h )
7000
9000 12000 16000 18000 24000 30000

Sound level (dBA)

MRV II-C
34/30/29 34/30/29 35/32/29 38/36/32 38/36/32 -

Air volume(m3/h)
MRV II-C
600 600 630 760 760 -

Power consumption (W)

MRV II-C
40 40 40 50 50 -

Airstage V
30/28/26 33/30/27 37/36/34 38/37/35 41/36.5/33 45/41/37 47.5/44/39.5

Airstage V
410/380/350 450/410/370 520/500/470 540/510/490 800/650/550 970/870/750 1040/910/730

Airstage V
26 30 35 39 38 50 60

Conclusion:
Item
Large capacity

Haier
Outdoor units from 8HP to 48Hp ,each 2 hp have one model totally 22models; Haier use PURE DC inverter system design ,high efficiency and save energy cost than conventional VRV system; Haier have good advantage in 4way cassette type and some big size wall-mounted type,10 series 42 models Haier units can use small size pipe and big capacity installation ; Need less refrigerant than Fujitsu

Fujitsu
Outdoor units from 8HP to 42Hp , totally 16 models

Conclusion
Haier have more choice than Fujitsu for outdoor units

High performance

Fujitsu use DC inverter +constant speed system ,cost operation energy Have good advantage in Convertible type and ceiling concealed duct type ,12 series 54 models Pipe size is bigger ; Need more refrigerant quantity;

Haier units can save 30% that of the energy than Fujitsu units (take 8HP outdoor units as an example) Haier has less models than Fujitsu

Indoor units

Design and installation

Haier save 10% cost than Fujitsu during installation;

Thanks