Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Outline of talk
Shape: some definitions Memory expertise and structure Effective memorising of music advice and experiments Shared performance cues: understanding of compositional structure; effects on recall Beating time Shaping contour: bodily movement Summary and conclusion: mental representations revisited
pp
1. Relies on representation of table, theatre, house etc., and ability to walk round it
Memory expertise
Ericsson, Chase & Faloon (1980) Extended normal digitspan by utilising knowledge of running times to make associations e.g. 3492 = 3 minutes and 49.2 seconds, near worldrecord mile time
Tobias Matthay (1926). On Memorizing and Playing from Memory. Oxford University Press
Experiments
Benefits of analysis (Rubin-Rabson, 1937; Ross, 1964) Use of structural boundaries to guide practice: more so in skilled pianists; developed over course of practice sessions (Williamon & Valentine, 2002) singers (Ginsborg, 2002)
The opportunity
Projected performance of Stravinskys Cantata for soprano and tenor soloists, small instrumental ensemble and womens choir in December 2003 at Firth Hall, Sheffield Ricercar 1 for solo soprano and instrumental ensemble Conductor / rehearsal pianist: George Nicholson Soprano soloist: me
Theoretical framework
Performer attends to important features of the music while practising / rehearsing (basic, structural, interpretive, expressive) Some of these stop being perceived as important Others are attended to automatically The remainder are retained as retrieval or performance cues landmarks in the performers mental representation of the piece when performing from memory Converging evidence that attention to features that become performance cues determines what is practised and subsequently, what is forgotten
shiny sound
Count/listen
yearning
dancing
Count/listen
Count
Singer Section 1 Verse 1: The maidens came when I was in my mothers bower / I had all that I wolde Refrain 1: The baily berith the bell away The lilly, the rose, the rose I lay Verse 2: The silver is whit, red is the golde The robes thay lay in folde Refrain 2: The baily berith the bell away The lilly, the rose, the rose I lay Verse 3: And through the glass window shines the sone How should I love, how should I love, and I so young? Refrain 3: The baily berith the bell away The lilly, the rose, the rose I lay
Conductor
Verse 1: The maidens came when I was in my mothers bower / I had all that I wolde
Refrain 1: The baily berith the bell away The lilly, the rose, the rose I lay The silver is whit, red is the golde The robes thay lay in folde The baily berith the bell away The lilly, the rose, the rose I lay Verse 2: And through the glass window shines the sone Verse 2a: How should I love, how should I love, and I so young? Refrain 2: The baily berith the bell away The lilly, the rose, the rose I lay
Singer Section 1 Verse 1: The maidens came when I was in my mothers bower / I had all that I wolde Refrain 1: The baily berith the bell away The lilly, the rose, the rose I lay Verse 2: The silver is whit, red is the golde The robes thay lay in folde Refrain 2: The baily berith the bell away The lilly, the rose, the rose I lay Verse 3: And through the glass window shines the sone How should I love, how should I love, and I so young? Refrain 3: The baily berith the bell away The lilly, the rose, the rose I lay
Conductor
Verse 1: The maidens came when I was in my mothers bower / I had all that I wolde
Refrain 1: The baily berith the bell away The lilly, the rose, the rose I lay The silver is whit, red is the golde The robes thay lay in folde The baily berith the bell away The lilly, the rose, the rose I lay Verse 2: And through the glass window shines the sone Verse 2a: How should I love, how should I love, and I so young? Refrain 2: The baily berith the bell away The lilly, the rose, the rose I lay
Features (locations)
Structural start of section (9), switch (7), start of phrase (29) Basic prepare (count, listen, think, watch) (35), pronunciation of words (25), technical / breath (45) Interpretive meaning of words (29), dynamics / tempo (9) Expressive (15)
Start section
Start phrase
Type
Predictor variable
Type
Predictor variable
Type
Predictor variable
STOPS negative effects Structural Basic SPC Start of phrase PC Arrival/off SPC Score SPC REPETITIONS negative effects Structural Basic PC Start of phrase Prepare PC 5.184*** -3.674**** -3.497*** 15.468*** 3.509***
0.25
0 1 13 25 37 49 61 73 85 97 109 121 133 145 157 169 181 193 205 217 229 241
0.75
0.5
0.25
0 1 13 25 37 49 61 73 85 97 109 121 133 145 157 169 181 193 205 217 229 241
0.75
0.5
0.25
0 1 13 25 37 49 61 73 85 97 109 121 133 145 157 169 181 193 205 217 229 241
0.25
0 1 13 25 37 49 61 73 85 97 109 121 133 145 157 169 181 193 205 217 229 241
0.75
0.5
0.25
0 1 13 25 37 49 61 73 85 97 109 121 133 145 157 169 181 193 205 217 229 241
0.75
0.5
0.25
0 1 13 25 37 49 61 73 85 97 109 121 133 145 157 169 181 193 205 217 229 241
0.25
0 1 13 25 37 49 61 73 85 97 109 121 133 145 157 169 181 193 205 217 229 241
0.75
0.5
0.25
0.75
0.5
0.25
Predictor variable
Start of section Stress on words Prepare Dynamics/Tempo
Estimate
-0.038 -0.034 0.017 1.606
Standard Error
0.008 0.009 0.009 0.320
Z
-5.02*** -3.835*** 1.98* 5.023***
Ginsborg, J. and Chaffin, R. [forthcoming 2010]. Performance cues in singing and conducting: evidence from practice and recall. In I. Delige and J. Davidson (Eds), Music and the Mind: Investigating the functions and processes of music (a book in honour of John Sloboda). Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Singer Section 1 Verse 1: The maidens came when I was in my mothers bower / I had all that I wolde Refrain 1: The baily berith the bell away The lilly, the rose, the rose I lay Verse 2: The silver is whit, red is the golde The robes thay lay in folde Refrain 2: The baily berith the bell away The lilly, the rose, the rose I lay Verse 3: And through the glass window shines the sone / How should I love, how should I love, and I so young? Refrain 3: The baily berith the bell away The lilly, the rose, the rose I lay
Conductor
Verse 1: The maidens came when I was in my mothers bower / I had all that I wolde
Refrain 1: The baily berith the bell away The lilly, the rose, the rose I lay The silver is whit, red is the golde The robes thay lay in folde The baily berith the bell away The lilly, the rose, the rose I lay Verse 2: And through the glass window shines the sone Verse 2a: How should I love, how should I love, and I so young? Refrain 2: The baily berith the bell away The lilly, the rose, the rose I lay
Beating time
Aim: to investigate associations between singers practice and rehearsal behaviour (start-beats, stop-beats and repetitions) with different kinds of movement pulsing, conducting and gesturing, and no movement (NB independent judge) and musical features/performance cues Method: as before but with multiple rather than mixed hierarchical regression analysis
Outline of findings
Different kinds of body movement are associated with kinaesthetic learning at different stages of the process of preparing to perform from memory Beating a pulse provides framework for ensuring rhythmic accuracy Conducting during memorizing phase helps form metrical representation SHAPE Gesture once piece is learned and memorized underpins communication of semantic meaning (musical or verbal) Need for singer also to practise not moving in preparation for performance
Beating time
Ginsborg, J. (2009). Beating time: the role of kinaesthetic learning in the development of mental representations for music. In A. Mornell (ed.) Art in Motion. Vienna: Peter Lang.
To denote meaning
Describe action Illustrating metaphor Indicative or pointing gesture Repetitive motor gestures
To denote meaning
Describe action Illustrating metaphor Indicative or pointing gesture Repetitive motor gestures
Cassell (1998)
Iconic Propositional
Deictic or beat
Delalande (1988) of Glenn Goulds gestures Meditative, vibrant, fluid, delicate, vigorous
Deictic or beat
Participants
Name (singer & pianist)
Amanda & Colin Isobel & George Betty & Robert Sophie & Guy
Level of expertise
Professional Professional Student Student
Materials
Three songs by Ivor Gurney (1890-1937) Epitaph On the Downs I Shall be Ever Maiden Video-recordings of practice sessions, rehearsals and performances stored as DVDs Analysis using Noldus The Observer
Procedure
Session 1: familiar / same expertise
Professional A / Professional 1 Professional B / Professional 2 Student A / Student 1 Student B / Student 2
Analysis (1)
States Gesture
Glance
Analysis (2)
420.301",Betty & Guy","pianist","Glance other","Point","" "447.876","Betty & Guy","singer","Pulse hand","State start","26-35" "457.251","Betty & Guy","pianist","Gesture","Point","lifts hand" "467.770","Betty & Guy","singer","Pulse hand","State stop","" "467.770","Betty & Guy","singer","Still","State stop","" "467.770","Betty & Guy","singer","Pulse hand","State start","29-38" "477.834","Betty & Guy","pianist","Glance other","Point","" "478.133","Betty & Guy","singer","Pulse hand","State stop","" "478.477","Betty & Guy","singer","Glance other","Point","29-38" "480.144","Betty & Guy","singer","Gesture","Point","point "heart"" "481.066","Betty & Guy","pianist","Glance other","Point","" "482.083","Betty & Guy ","singer","Gesture","Point","point "was"" "513.205","Betty & Guy","singer","Gesture","Point"," = 'stop"' (error)" "513.682","Betty & Guy","singer","Pulse hand","State start","26-41" "514.039","Betty & Guy","singer","Gesture","Point",""heart"" "518.674","Betty & Guy","singer","Pulse hand","State stop","" "532.370","Betty & Guy","singer","Pulse head","State start","" "537.722","Betty & Guy","singer","Pulse head","State stop",""
"
Analysis (3)
States % of rehearsal time Pulsing with hand / hand Shaping with hand Conducting with hand Gazing at partner / elsewhere
Gesture
Glance at partner / elsewhere
Beats (deictic)
Metaphoric gestures