Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Objectives
to identify the role of communication in crisis intervention to understand communication techniques for establishing rapport, calming, and defusing
to describe strategies for working with mentally ill, developmentally disabled, hostile people, & witnesses
to explain the effects of crises & trauma on officer health to identify practices for healthy communication with self and others for stress inoculation
Debriefing
Immediate Stress Response Post Traumatic Response Coping Methods & Skills
Officer Personality
Crisis Situation
Performance Effects
Impact on Family
Law enforcement is one of the very few professions that can drastically change a personality.
Guy Schiller, International Critical Incident Stress Management Foundation
Cops are the ones who are running toward, what everybody else is running away from
Nonverbal Communication
how people react to an interaction is largely dependent on the cues they pick up from you
the quality of the interaction strongly influences future interactions with you and other officers
some nonverbal behaviors, especially facial expressions, are consistent across cultures (sadness, anger, fear, surprise, disgust, happiness) young children respond faster to nonverbals people comply with speaker requests whose speaking rate is similar to their own touching lightly on the arm often increases compliance gestures vary considerably across people and cultures within known groups, you can assume certain nonverbals mean similar things
Gestures may not mean what you think they mean Cross-Cultural Nonverbals
1. 2. 3. 4. 5. eating, receiving or touching with the left hand pat or touch the heads of children curling index finger upward to call someone over direct eye contact with Latin Americans, Japanese, Koreans OK sign with thumb & forefinger to
6.
7. 8. 9.
nodding yes or no
sitting relaxed or foot crossed on knee firm, solid handshake thumbs-up
10. pointing with a finger 11. laughing 12. loud tone with expansive gestures
Defusing Anger
Nice Doggy
What are the differences between these two canines? How do dogs test & establish a connection? How would you deal with each?
Nonverbal Calming
dont stand with hands on hips or near weapon use open palm and open arm gestures
Defusing Anger
1. Acknowledge the feeling. keep your voice calm. Use eye contact, the person's name, and slow but firm gestures.
2.
3. 4.
5.
At first signs of anger, decide whether probing the content or acknowledging the feeling is preferable. Sometimes an open-ended of factual question redirects the party and allows them to cool down. In some situations, calling attention to the emotion at the moment of escalation can actually increase the intensity of the feeling.
6.
Don't allow abusive behavior to escalate and be even more difficult to handle. You will also be sanctioning the pain that they are inflicting on each other. Offer positive, encouraging suggestions: "Let's just stop for a minute and take a deep breath. You're feeling the tension of tackling some important and difficult issues. We're making some progress, though." Don't panic or conclude that the mediation is hopeless. Acknowledge to yourself and to the parties that intense feelings are a apart of resolving difficult issues.
7.
8.
9.
Normalize the feeling if not the behavior. "Most people I work with feel the way you do in this situation-- really between a rock and a hard place. It often seems hopeless just before things start to move ahead."
10. Rely on your relationships and the power of your position to maintain or regain control. Remind them that your responsibility is to keep them focused positively toward a resolution and that you intend to do this. 11. Finally, if you feel uneasy with intense anger, either co-mediate, or refer the parties to someone else. Know and respect your own limits.
12. Give the person time-- take the pressure off and allow cooling out time. People de-escalate at different rates. Usually, the more upset the person is, the longer it will take to calm down. Sitting quietly for a moment may be enough, or suggest a short break if necessary.
13. Don't try to discuss the content until the person is calm.
14. Don't threaten to take action unless you are prepared to carry it out.
15. Be aware that the person may become more easily aroused again -- and that the other person may escalate as well. Anger can have a contagious effect.
16. Use empathic statements carefully. Overstating or understating the intensity of the feeling may trigger the person. Some empathic statements can sound insincere or condescending, such as "I can tell you're feeling angry." 17. Ensure your own safety. Don't put yourself physically between two angry, out-of-control people. Rather, give them short, specific commands to help them regain control.
they may be compliant, nod & say they understand, but may not comprehend
they may have very limited vocabulary and abstract thinking
encephalitis/meningitis
epilepsy head/brain injury sensory handicaps
learning disability
developmental disability retardation chronic nervous system illness
What do we know about lying? 60% of people lie, males more than females (3x), average 25 times a day Officers and general public hold misconceptions about lying behavior Uncovering lying is easier for younger, women, trained people Actors are better than non-actors, and practice improves lying
Good liars may use details to make their stories believable, but may have to search for details, be inconsistent, or elaborate over time
Self-Talk
Recall Sound
Obtaining confessions
1. Feigned sympathy and friendship. 2. Appeals to God and religion. 3. Blaming the victim or an accomplice. 4. Placing the suspect in a soundproof, starkly furnished, room. 5. Approaching the suspect too closely for comfort. 6. Overstating or understating the seriousness of the offense and the magnitude of the charges. 7. Presenting exaggerated claims about the evidence. 8. Falsely claiming that another person has already confessed and implicated the suspect. 9. Other forms of trickery and deception. 10. Wearing a person down by a very long interview session.
False confessions
80% of crimes are solved due to obtaining confession, but 5-11% are wrongful convictions 80% of suspects waive their right to have lawyer present during questioning, & innocents are more likely if you put somebody in a situation they believe is hopeless, and give them a choice between two bad options, you can get him to say just about anything repeated direct questioning of children can impose false memories of events (e.g., McMartin School abuse case) a
long interrogations involving deprivation of sleep, food or breaks, repeated & leading questions, use of threats, intimidation, and promises or incentives, use of profanity, derision and name-calling, officers' unyielding expectation of guilt and refusal to accept contradictory information.
More confessions
People who are mentally ill may confess for attention, unrelated guilt, confusion, intimidation People who are developmentally disabled, learning disabled, illiterate, retarded, very young, often have a strong desire to please authority figures and are easily influenced
The type to confess? In 1995 a study was conducted to see just who would confess to an offense they didnt commit:
Students were asked to type letters as fast as they could be pronounced by the speaker, but avoid the ALT key that would crash the system. One minute into the study it was made to crash and the students were blamed told that the researcher had seen them hitting the key. The researcher gave them a hand written confession and told them to sign, the result being a serious verbal reprimand from their senior advisor.
Interviewing victims/survivors the typical interview involves 4 open-ended questions and 26 closed questions, delivered rapid fire
offer something (e.g., beverage) active listening avoid interrupting conduct in comfortable, quiet setting be careful using touch dont express your own anger about the violence express care, concern continue to reassure of safety & not alone allow silent periods; pause between questions take breaks if needed careful of loaded words (victim, closure, etc.) be careful not to blame (words, tone, expression) increase confidence by having person make small decisions follow the victims memory, not presequenced questions express appreciation for their willingness & effort
Eyewitness research
eyewitness testimony plays a part in 90% of convictions children & disabled people can be strongly influenced by recurrent or leading questioning lineup identification is seldom more than 50% accurate recollection is easily influenced by newspapers, police comments, discussion with other witnesses degree of confidence is a poor predictor of accuracy hypnosis, while aiding recall, can also implant new memories in a large study of childhood recollection, 50% had false memories; est. 10,000 wrong convictions/yr false memories are less vivid and have less detail
the greater the stressful event, the less accurate recall compared to true memories, lies are more vivid & detailed officers are more accurate than citizens, but may add more positive feedback increases confidence and distortion of recall
This study compared recall of 110 people who witnessed 22 bank robberies to police reports. Tellers were threatened with guns. Circumstances included time, day, date.
physically sick
anger, rage at victim guilt
Critical Incidents:
Sudden and unexpected disrupt our sense of control involve the perception of life threatening threat may involve physical or emotional loss
Above 175 bpm: irrational fight/flight freezing submissive behavior voiding bladder/bowel best gross motor skills
175 bpm: tunnel vision tunnel hearing loss of near vision loss of depth perception cognitive processing deteriorates vasoconstriction reduced bleeding 145 bpm: complex motor skills deteriorate 115 bpm: fine motor skills deteriorate 60-80 bpm: normal resting heart rate
115-145 bpm-- optimal survival & combat level complex motor skills visual reaction time cognitive reaction time
Stress and the Nervous System: Getting stuck in the on position Sympathetic Branch:
acute hearing visual scanning pupil dilation hyperalert inhibit salivation faster heart rate rapid breathing cold hands muscle tension adrenaline rush liver releases glucose loss of appetite slowed digestion contract sphincters constipation
Parasympathetic Branch
slower, deeper breathing slow heart rate constricts pupil warm extremities hunger, digestion tired, fatigued relaxed muscles contract bladder release sphincters
Rebound Reaction
58% heightened sense of danger 49% anger, blaming 46% sleep difficulties 45% isolation & withdrawal 44% flashbacks, intrusive thoughts 43% emotional numbing 42% depression 40% alienation 40% fear, anxiety 37% guilt, sorrow, remorse About 1/3 have mild or no reaction, 34% nightmares 1/3 have moderate reaction, and 28% stigmatized 1/3 experience a severe reaction 28% problems with the system 27% family problems 23% feeling crazy, lose control 18% sexual difficulties 14% alcohol/drug abuse
Alarm Stage 1
Recovery Stage 2
Exhaustion Stage 3
Acute or delayed reaction with or without help and eventual full recovery 8085%
Continued lifelong PTSD 3-4%
Percent
Respiratory
Muscular
Immune
Digestive
Upset stomach Acid reflux Diarrhea Constipation Hemorrhoids
Nervous
Stress
Performance
Stress Level
The organizational culture of some departments does more to create or contribute to stress than to prevent or resolve it. Its important to periodically conduct a culture audit of the department to see how it can be improved
10% of spouses report being abused and 40% have been involved in violent behavior toward spouse or children
The precise statistics vary according to which study you read, but the message is clear Officers are at increased risk of stress and therefore must practice good stress management
Defusing
1. Rotate emergency staff: 2 hours on, half-hour off, for no more than 10 hours. Phase in/out. 2. Defuse away from crisis scene before leaving, within 20 minutes to 2 hours after incident 3. Takes 30-45 minutes 4. Identify & explain what reactions to expect 5. Caution against ineffective coping techniques 6. Set expectations for more detailed debriefing & identify additional resources
Officer Self-Talk
Dont have time (next call) Others would take advantage Wouldnt get promotion Would affect performance ratings What would others think If I let out a little, it would be a lot Cops dont do this
Resulting Behavior
Dont show weakness Dont show real feelings Withhold intense reactions Control anger & disgust Stuff your reaction
Excessive force Property damage Outrage Recklessness Spouse abuse Intoxication Quitting Suicide
Risk Indicators isolation restricted social police action media cynicism disregard animals family secondary vest & pistol
Dangerous Opportunity:
Positive Outcomes of Family Stress Inoculation
Requires deliberate family interaction & planning Models & teaches effective coping skills Increases family cohesion Enhances self-mastery of children Increases community awareness Promotes relationship growth Teaches pride in service
Resilience the ability to bounce back after a setback, disappointment, stress, or trauma Use available supports Recall your personal assets & qualities Reaffirm your career goals & motivations Get organized & take one thing at a time Stay focused on the positive Identify what you have learned from it Get plenty of rest, exercise, & good nutrition Be cautious about big decisions during this time