Sie sind auf Seite 1von 312

IVU>R^ GW GK GN

IUQN% U]UN

A/JTXNRJTNRIZVK/A
VE
H QN3RZ X]YKU94 R
Y SRWNEN
I,E4N IMNR MIRQN'N 

LUVU>R^ V=VWGR3K ]V RNZJNE LK


ZMNRNL G V]UN GN ]UTIM Q%Z
E J>VH

IUQN% U]UN

A/JTHN3H/A
A/JTXNRJTNRIZVK/A
VE
H QN3RZ X]YKU94 R
Y SRWNEN
I,E4 N  IMNR MIRQN'N 

;RZNR( Z>=E HWE A A

*UVKGNURH
3]G3J>VHGNIWHEJIUQN%U]UN

VE

H QN3RZ
VE
HQN3RZX]YKU94 R
YSRWNENI,E4N+IMNRMIRQN'N
LQUPZ[$',Q/AVTORN$Z6UPE<T8OJ5ZPDX9GQ$WZUV,URI
L]OZE<T8O PS5 %ZUT>




Visit us at: www.jagatgururampalji.org
e-mail: jagatgururampalji@yahoo.com

  A/ IW3N ^XK/A


AAAAAAAAAAAAA 
+ *UVK ZIRNGN JT  VNW%N AAAAAAAAAAAAA

+
+

%NZ IHM9 RNZ GN LJ%N M"  AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA

%NZ E"' WNE IWQHVKQ. G E-K ,R^RK LN'HNRK AAAAAAA 

+ I3T 3 1K RX%N  AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA 

+
+
+
+
+
+
+

QNVZNW. HNE G  LNE IW= X  IHW $  _KQ. AAAAAAAA 


TK STMZN LK TK IW3'^ LK QV TK I3WLK GK 7>VJ=VKAAAAA 
IV] %  U> '  HK M% AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA



 STMZ HNE  GK QIWQHV RIM' GK JTIV=IUQN AAAAAAAAA 


STMZN GN QNJ' IJVN HNE  GK JTNJVK E-K V% AAAAAA 
ZNVN G>RUN  G>QNRN STMZN %^] 3RNJ G'N AAAAAAAAAAA 

 IW3'^ GN QNJ' IJVN HNE  GK JTNJVK E-K JT(N% QV

+
+
+
+
+
+
+

ZNVN GN Q3KRWNG JN7> ' N AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA



 JRSTMZ G =V 3]\ STIMZ]Y. GK (NJ%N AAAAAAAAAAAA 


 JIW=VR Q(RWWG IW=X I3T31K RX%. GN JTZN' AAAAAAAA 
 JIW=VR IR=UWG IW=X I3T31K RX%. GN JTZN' AAAAAAAAA 

 JIW=VR 3TKZGGWK ZM.J>RN' IW=X I3T31K RX%. GN JTZN' AAA 


 JIW=VR I3W ZM.J>RN' IW=X I3T31K RX%. GN JTZN' AAAAAA 
 JIW=VR 3TKZ=G*UWV UKVN LK IW=X I3T31K RX%. GN JTZN'AAA 

 JIW=VR SN-KSE W JIW=VR H>RN' 3RK_ IW=X I3T31K RX%. GN


GN JTZN'
N' A 

 J^L HSKR JTZ3WR HIWRGW  LK GK Q]IZTVSN'K IW=X I3T31K

    RX%. GN JT Z N' AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA



 QNGR'K-$ URKSGN NIMS LK GK Q]IZTVSN'K IW=X I3T31K

    RX%. GN JT Z N' AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA

+



QNGR'K-$ %N%H NIMS LK GK Q]IZTVSN'K IW=X I3T31K RX%.

    GN ] H  V  AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA



 M
R ]V. G>QNRN I3T31K RX%N GK G]V H(N AAAAAAAAAAA 

+ H' V(N H"N M" H>E GN ZNIEH AAAAAAAA 

+
+
+
+
+

 QNGR'K-$ ;RZGN NIMS LK HSKR JTZ3WR


 G 3NH3K AAA 
WR
 QNGR'K-$ GNG^ NIMS LK HSKR JTZ3WR
 G 3NH3K AAAAA 
WR

 QNGR'K-$ ZE^HGN NIMS LK HSKR JTZ3WR


 G 3NH3K AAA 
WR
 QNGR'K-$ URKSGN NIMS LK HSKR JTZ3WR
 G 3NH3K AA 
WR

 QNGR'K-$ %N%H LK G>QNRN


U>R^ UT]( NIMS
NIMS

 IW=X HSKR

    JT Z  3 WR
 GN JT Z N' AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
WR



 JT*^ HSKR LK % WNZK RNZN%]G LK %^] V=VWIUQN% Z0NI-QN A 

+JIW= V R 3NVR WK HIWRG W  HSKR JT Z  3 WR


G  3NH3K AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA 
+ HSKR NIMS XNR
$ >=U. IW=X QN7>$G M% A  

+
+
+

 V>=U IW=X HIWRGW HSKR NIMS  GN V>HIRV %NZ V


$ JTU1A
 VTVN>=U IW=X HIWRGW HSKR NIMS  Z>I%]GR %NZ %NE JTU1 A 
 G>QNJR>=U IW=X HIWRGW HSKRNIMS  GN HR>'NZ %NZ

   %NE JT U 1 AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA



 HSKR NIMS HIWRGW  GN HE>=U IW=X JTU1 AAAAAAAA 

+ J^R' ]V GK JIMXN' JIW=VR GUT](. V


$
J^ R ' ] V  GK JIMXN'  AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA

 IV]% WNR IW=X %NZ LNJ G' GN JTZN' AAAAAAAAAAAAA

+ ] V  VN7> '  GK 3,N AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA


+ *= 1 IHQ. %^ ]  ZNRU IW3  AAAAAAAAAAAAAAA

+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+

 JT*^ IJQN *UV S]V I][ "%K %^] ZNRU IZE'N  AAAAAAA 
 QG*>V HIR3ZN AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA 

 Q'M
'K HKVK JTZ3WR % AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA 
 JT*^ % >'K URKS. GK AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA 
 *UWN% M
W V. Q"N AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA 

 E>=I1Q. J>I1Q. %^] MNRN AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA 

 ]V M
W V. Q"N AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA 

 QNJ' *UV %^] ;RZRNL G GRSNR V


$ 6>YWN7>'N AAAAAAAA 
 J^R' JTZNVZN N;H %^] I*QN%H R
U V
$ Z>HV HRH 7>ZR W;N

   IG] G N M"  AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA

+
+



 *UVZVK 3>3KEN GKQ. Q=\ PKH HR%N AAAAAAAAAAAA 

 IV]% VNJ %^] J^R' JTZNVZN MK PKH HR HGN M" AAAAAAAA 

+ HSKR NIMS GK HNE %NE WNRVN AAAAAAA 


+ IW3W IWLVN ]V  AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA 
]V RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL GK QI;QH3VN IW=X IM]G^VN% IW3W

 ;RZ U>R^ G R^J IW=X JTIVI3PV M


-UN  AAAAAAAAAAAAA 

+
+
+

 ]V RNZJNE LK G IW3 IW=X

%3VT
%3VTGZ
Z

 GKQ. *IW=\SN'KQ. AA 


 %VTGZ G ZR(% IW=X M
R *IW=\WHVN GKQ. *IW=\SN'KQ. A 
 ]V RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL GN ]\IJV JTKX" AAAAAAAAAAA 

+ JTZN' G E-K G\


 _
1
 HNJK AAAAAAAAAA 
+ (NR( IUQN% JTHN3
N3 IW3
IW3AAAAAAAAAAAA
A AAAAAAAAAAA 

+
+
+
+
+
+
+

 JTZ3WR G IW3 IW=X 3NVR HK G=G M%  AAAAAAAAA 
 JIW=VR UKVN LK GN IUQN% IH% IHMN AAAAAAAAAAA 
 3TKZG*UWV UKVN NR AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA 
IV]%
$ U>' HK M% JTZN' IMV AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA

  J>RN' WNH. GN NR AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA 


 IVTU>' ZNI-QN LKW %^] Z>HV %MK$ M
' IG]GKAAAAAAAAAA 

 M
R GWIVQ. RLU>' STMZ. LK VU>' IW3'^ LK VZU>' I3WLK

   GK J^LN S>=;KMK' MK HRG M% AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA 

 JIW=VR XNR
$ WG. Q%>NR N;%N GN JIR'NZ HWE WRU

   ZM.WRU JTNJVK Z>HVK %MK$ AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA 

+
+
+
+
+

 3NVR IW;K IWR>; N;%N JV% GN HNR' AAAAAAAAAAA 


 3RN; H=<' WNE IJ=VR S'%U Z>HVK %MK$ AAAAAAAAAA 

 V=VWIUQN% JTNJVK G IJ=6


$ MK *UVK QNR]* M>]GK M" AAAAAA 

 UKVN IUQN%GNVN STMZ GN I-31 J^,GW  J^R' STMZ M" AAA 
 STMZ GN N;H STMZ %^] V(N J^R' STMZ GN N;H J^R' STMZ

   %^] MK JTNJV M>]GN M" AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA 

+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+

 STMZ 6R J>R3  GK N;%N Q%>7>VZ [1KQN  M" AAAAAAAA


 3] H N ZN;N% AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
 U=GK V(N ZM]V JT]JRN GK LN'HNRK AAAAAAAAAAAAAAA

 JIW=VR VKR( V(N ;NZ GK LN'HNRK AAAAAAAAAAAAAAA


 WRU GK JIR*N3N HK M" AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA

 UKVN IUQN%GNVN GK 7>VJ=VK GN ]HV AAAAAAAAAAAAAA

 HSKR NIMS G>QNRN IW*K3' V(N Z]G


GRK %^] 3R' IW=X E"'N AAA
 G>QNJR >=U IW=X I-]GRZVK %^] 3R' IW=X E"'N AAAAAAAAAA
 JIW= V R J> R N'. GN RM=   AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA

+ 3NVRQR( IW3  AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA


+ *1IHQ. %^ ]  VZNRU AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA

%8 L PNZ
 Q%NIG HNE V
$  MK ZN%W JRZ 3.VK > = \  V  QZRVW GK \
,  IWX
E= I UQN M
I -QN M"  7> M  QNJ'K ZR= ( N G  Q%>  NR H
I 33 HRGN QN
IRMN M" EIH% 7>GK I-M XNMV HG J^RK %MK$ M
 JN RMKQILMN I-
E-K M" IH 7>%]^ I- XNMV %]^ JTNJV HR% G ZNRU GN J^R% IUQN%
%MK$ M"* JTN'K XNM>]G M% IH 7>%]^ H
-K HNRL %N HR%N JW \N'
%^ ]  3WNIG31 *
L % IZE   JIM%' %^ ]  > ] G R WVR IZE' RIM' %^ ]
QNEK3N% *W% M
W []>Z' %^] >]GR JNRH M
' Z]%
R]L% HR% G E-K
Z;> R A ] U KV M
W    %= X K- A UN-K-   \ E K- A H> = G K-   Z , AZ3VK Z%N-K-
QV  HG  SKZNR %N M
- K-   HG  S> = <   %N M
- K-  QV  HG  IZT V ^  %N M
W 
QNIGA JT]V^ IL ]NR IWX QK$ RIM RM M. I-=( QILMN IHV %,R
%MK$ QN7> $ GN QV  %N MK Q"  N ] * W M"  IH7$> I H I-M E
H  %N3WN% M"
QV I- E
H GK MR WV^ *K %N3WN% M" QV I- E
H GN RNLN STMZ
HNE M"  L
 IH I-H E= \  ZN%W G  ^ \ 3Z RKR \.GN M"  7>  %  *
JTN'KQ. %]^ HRZA*RZ QV JNJAJ]>% R^JK LNE IWX 7>E0N H IV]% E
H
G  IJ] , R  IWaX H" G  HKVN M
I -QN M"   HSKR NIMS HIM] G   M% IHA
HSKRVK%E
HIJ],RN*I-QNJNJJ>]%G
 ,NE
*KLKW*
L%*-I-H\N% WNENHNE@
URKSI-HJNJKI-=HJ>]%KQNI-QNI-HM" ^ZGEER
IS%N*L%H
-KHNZ%NQNW=*M" LZHK,ER@
7> M  %MK$ XNM] > G N IH H
- K JT N 'K I- IJ] , R  R^ J K H" G  IWaX
$  SNMR
I%HE LN-7>M I-M WK %MK XNM]>GN IH LKW QNVZN %]^ QNJ' I%=L [R
VE
H GN JVN X=E I-E-K 7>M QNJ'K IVTU>'K ZNI-QN %NE MR LKW
%] ^  *T I ZV HKVN M
I -QN M"  IFR ZN%W %^ ]  I-M XNMV IH(
$  7> V J] %  M
- K
M" I-=( QILMN H>0 %MK$ M>]GNI-=( QK$ *% ZR%N M" * G>=\K V
Q3.V M.IL I(VK %] ^  QK$ I-= (   JT N JV HR%N XNM] > G   M. QILMK
I(VK IW=X QK$ QNJ' I%=L [R VE
H IWX RIM]G KHNE STMZ G
E
H  IWaX QNH  F U-  QV  QNJ'  I%= L  [R GN RNVN *= > E  U- 
HSKR NIMS HIM] G   M% IH/AA
I-=6NR^JK\E%QNI-QNVNV"$>=\NUR%MK$JNI-QN
I- HNE STMZ G E
H IW=X 3.VK V >=\ GN %NZ
$I%3N% %MK$ M"
IVT U > ' K ZNI-QN V
$  7> V J] %  HNZ HT
;  E
*  Z
M  QM] H NR RNUAGW" 3 
MR3A3
H  %_NA%> H N% ZN'AWIYQN-K R^ J K Q U > '  MR LKW %^ ]  JT  3 N%
HKVN M
I-QN M"I-a( I-=H LKW G^L LKW %]^ ZNR H \N L.GN M" 3
3'
HRGN M" I-=,V E>=1 E"$GN M" ;]% E=>1 E"$GN M" 3.VK 6K' E"$GN M"I-=(

XNR
$  VRF Q= U  E= U K M
- K M"  L H R QNJ 3.VK %NE RIM'N XNM
U   V.
G^R QNJ%]^ RIM' %MK$ G'UQNJG %N XNM]>G M
- WK X
R X
RK HR H
E" L.GN M" YNH^ YNHN ZNR E" L.GN M" G>R[1%N [1 L.GK M" IHN%
GK _E ?RNS M
 L.GK M" WJNRK GN WJNR P=J M
 L.GN M" RNL GN
RNL \
M IEQN L.GN M" W=( RKR IW=X SKZNRK E=U L.GK M" QR(NV
I-= (   H
- K WK WV^  > R = I \QV %MK$ M"  RNILQ. G  RNL I-= , VGNR. GK
I-=,V ;]%WN% GN ;]% VNHVWR GK VNHV QV I-=(
$ V=H IH NY *
G RKR QXN%H \
M E- L.G M% ZNVNAIJVN G NMZ' LWN% S1N
AS1K ZR L.G M% G>=; JK$G S=IXQ. %^] R
$GAISEHG 6=YH ZNVNAIJVN
ZR L.G M% LWN% *"'N IW;WN M
 L.GKQ. M% QV JMN9 WRU G>=\.
%] ^  *
U ' E-K Z,S^ R  M
 L.G  M.IWXNR HR
 HK I-M LU4 N  RIM' G
ENI-H M" EIH% QK$ Z,S^RK W= I-=( RIM RM M. IH7>$IH I- HNE
G  IJ] , R  IW= X
$  SNMR I%HE' GN H
- K RNVN %,R %MK$ QN7> $ GN QV
N%] ^  G^  IRQ. %] ^  G> = \ K HR% GK QV  G> = \  IM' GK QNGV ILMK S'
U-KIH7$IH QK$ QNJ' I%=L [R %]^ *>=E U- M.7>M JRZ 3.VK QV
>=\ I-=( %N M
H I%=L [R VE
H IW=X M" IL=( %N L%Z M" %N IZTV^ M"
%N S><NJN %N G>=\ %N H
-K E9N-KA0U9N M" %N H
-K SKZNRK M" %N
J"N %N H
-K E"'AG' %N ISLEK GN IS=E *R%N %N Z]%
R]L% G N;%
?TKG'N M"7>a( * JTZNVZN W=E
$ I%3>EH QV Q\]Y M"S]GK6
9 URKSGN
LK ZMNRNL GK SN'K IWX JT Z N' M"  IH/A
IS% MK Z> = \  NR] U  RNU > '  IS% MK V] V K VNR
IS%. >R QEU
L SL"$ %UR %NX [>ZNR@
[]1N SNL"$ VNE %U Z]LKR YF 0N0
Z>REK Z;^R >MNW%K I%WNR QR N0@
SK% IWM]UZ WNLIM VRH VZS^R VKR
RNU \]Y %MK$ M
V M S]I;QN RIMV ZKR@
VRH %MK$ V
RN %MK$ %.MK H3K3 HSNS
Q] I ZT V  IJQNE  Z; JKW" $  IL7> $  *N1K XW" $  3RNS@
ZVWNE
ZVN%J>R
UEKA
U>E,NR@
3]\ 3RNSK IFRV M"$ XE
 VN S,NR@
3]\A3]\ JV%K %NX"$ UNW 3SG >*N%
X]GR SG% ^RLZ>=\K %.MK ZN% U>ZN%@
]\ IM]Y
E %^R %U 0^E ]V M,^R
V?V ;%K H JN HR -N Z>EH LM^R @
%GK %NW %NE SU 6^1"$ F>MNR ^]%
*R M
G RWR GN %MK$ JNJ %MK$ J>]%@
%N H
-K I*\3H GN% G %N H
-K MNR IWWMNR
%N H
-K L%Z ZR -N G3 MZNR@
,M.3]\
IEMRZMRHK7>JL"HIMRLM.%MK$H
-K
GNURKSQXEQIW%N3K>=\HNNUR
-K@

VE
H IWX IRF I-=H R JRZ 3.VK V =>\ M"LG
$ V=H QK$ VE
H
%MK$ LNW.U 7>G
$ V=H QK$ JRZ3.VK >=\ V QZRVW GK JTNJVK %MK$
HR HGVE
H IWX LN'N V. MK ]*W M
 HGN M" LG
$ QK$ J^R%
]V V
$ 7>JG3 E" H J^R% JTZNVZN GK QLKW% *UVK HRG RMK-I-
J>VH G ZNI;QZ V
$ L
 QK$ ]G3 G'N XNM]>G M. 7> IW=X IH GWK
A GWVN V ;RZ GK S>RN-K %N HRH RW JIW=VR ;RZ UT](. IW=X 6>=J
U^94 RM= %]^ 7>LNUR HRH (NR( *UVK ZNRU G='N XNIMQN M" L
 IH
WRVZN% G ]V ZM]V V QXNRKQN U>R^ NIMSN% 3NVR. IW=X 6>=J U^94
RM=   %^ ]  Z0 %MK JN-  HSKR NIMS QNJ'K SN'K IW= X  HIM] G   M%
IH
IH/ASGHVS0^P %N*N-K0^P M"$L
 Z0 %NMK$
IL HNR' *UV ZNL %^ ]  SM> V  MN%K M
 RMK M"  * QNJ'
Q%> Z N% V
$  V  U> R ^ Q . G> Q NRN G=  K U-K 3NVR IWR> = ;  N;%N HRG
M%IL %NE %N ZN%IH 3.VK IZEGK M" QV %N MK RKIRH =>\ %N
MK [R V HNR
SNR IWX EN* M>]GN M" V %N MK JTZ3WR GN 3N\3NVHNR
M>]GN M" QV %N MK Z
?3 JTNJVK M>]GK M" QV I-M * =>\ IHW$ IZE V(N
I-M LN%' G E-K Z"$ H' M. IH=(
$ QNI-QN M. IH7>$ L%Z E"$GN M.
IH7> $  ZRGN M. QV  IH7> $  G= > \  *
U GN M. QNI\R I-M * H '  HRWN
IRMN M" QV JTZ3WR H' M" H"N M" V(N H" IZEUN QV STMZN IW3'^
QV I3W G ZNVNAIJVN H' M% QV IH JTHNR HNE STMZ GK L4E V
$
6=>1HNRN JNH QK$ QNJ' I%=L [R VE
H  IW=X WNJ LN HG M.
I-M * H>0 I- J>VH G ZNI;QZ RNMK$ GRNI-QN IUQN M" V. IH
I-%] ^  J94 H   QNZ *UVQNVZN GN HIEQN' ] * W M
 H  I-M J>  VH
IVU> R ^  RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL G  JT W X%. GN ] U T I M M"  L
 IH V= ( . 7> a V
QN;NIRV M"N%]^ J^R% IW3WN M" IH L
 JNPHL% R^XK V I%RJ=\ *NW
%NE J94 H   Q%> 3 R% HR U N7>  GN HIEQN' ] * W M" 
QNVZJTN'7>GNRMK$-N;RZ%MK$QR
H
I1Q;WZ[=UHEZN%N*R@
*NWQR(/AL H R I-= H  QNVZN %] ^  V*UVK ZNRU V  EUNH  7>  GN
QNVZ HIEQN' HRWN IG= V N LNW  V. HR
9  QW3WZ [  = U  GN _E
IZEGN M" QV 7>G SRNSR H
-K WK ;RZ %MK$ M"HSKR NIMS HIM]G
M% IH Z R N I-M IUQN% L H R H
- K IUQN%K J> R 3 M
-  U N V. I-%^ ]
>'H IMRG IW=X WN E-UN QV LHR Z^R\ M
-UN V. 7>GK Z0 V
$
SNMR M" 
HSKRIUQN%KM
 V
 IMRG EUN-KZ^R\M
 V
 UZ%NJN-K

*UVK ZIRNGN
LKW MZNRK LNVK M" ZN%W ;RZ MZNRN
IM]G^ Z>IEZ I=\ I-N-K ;RZ %MK$ H
-K I%QNRN@
IJQNR  *UVL%
$ 
Q=L V
$ EU*U J]L M,NR NE JIME. H
-K WK ;RZ L. M
R ]JTGNI- %MK$
K %N IM]G^ %N Z>IEZ %N I=\ QV %N H
-K I-N-K K HWE ZN%W ;RZ
K *GN I-=H MK ZN%W;RZ K V M" EIH% ILW$A HE>=U GN JT*NW W=;GN
IUQN V. IVW$A NY IWX Z=VA*G M
' E=U HNR% IR_ I-M K IH ;NRIZH
H>=E U>R^Q. G>QNRN 3NVR. IW=X IE\K U-K XN-K %]^ GSN IG=VN IUQN HNR%
XNM WNR( M
W L. 7>J=RK IG\NWN ILG JTZN' R^J Q=L I-=H ZN%W ;RZ G
XNR ;RZ V M
R SM>V ]JTGNW. S' X>=HKQ. M% IL G HNR% QNJ IWX Z=V*
G M
'N >*NIWH M" * GN JT*^ *UWN% RNZ Q=E4N R=S UY \>GN JTZ3WR
I-=H MK M" L
 IH *N3N I*]% JTN-WNXK 3SG M" * Z]%G M% IH *GN ZNIEH
I-=H M" JR IFR WK I-M QE=UA ;RZ ]JTGNW. IH7>$
I-M U=E ISEH>E PKH M" IH * GN ZNIEH  R=S  \>GN Q=E4N UY RNZ
JT Z  3 WR I-= H  MK M"  ILGN WNVIWH %NZ HSKR M"  QV  7> M  QNJ'  VE
H 
V;NZ =X\]Y IW=X ZN%W >IGT3 WR^J IW=X QNHNR IW=X RIM]GN M" EIH% M>'
IM]G^ V. HIM]G M% IH NYN RNZ W=YN M" Z>IEZ HIM]G M% IH NYN Q=E4N W=YN
M" -KN-K HIM]G M% IH NYN -KNZKM W=YN M" QV I=\ HIM]G M% IH NY
U>R^ %N%H NIMS LK W=Y M% I-]0 HIM]G M% ILW$ XNR %NGN% S=X HIM]G M%
IH I-M ZR JNJN G^LN HMUN I-M ZR JNJN M% VR %MK$ M% VKRN HMUN I-M
ZR IJVN LK M% L
 * V
$ W=YN M" QV IFR X(N HMUN IH %GN%
$C I-M ZRN Y"YK
M" V>MNYN %MK$ M" LG
IH 7>%4. XNR. G IJVN 7>MK I-=H MK M"  I-%4. %NGN%
S=IXQ. GK VR4. Q=L NYN NRN ZN%W ZNL E9 IRMN M"
H
-K HM MZNRN RNZ S9N M" H
-K HM \>GN-K R
H
- K HM  MZNRN -KNZKM S9N M"     SN1N RM  EUN-K R @
LGIH NY NR ;NRIZH UT](. V 3N3VR. IW=X 7> I-=H JT*^ ZNIEH
R=S \>GN Q=E4N RNZ NIMS UYJTZ3WR GK JTV=\ %NZ IE=\ H ZIMZ. UN-K
M" IH 7>M I-=H ZNIEHJT*^ HSKR NIMS M% L
 VE
H IW=X ZN%W >IGT3 WR^J
IW=X QNHNR IW=X RIM]GN M"
WG UKVN H>RN' QV U>R^ UT]( NIMS I-M * EU*U IZEGAL>EG MK
M% L>RWG G Q/  G E
H %]+ IW=X NZWG G ]I\QN %]+
IW=X Q=(RWWG G H.Y %]+ G Q%>WNH  G E
H %]+ IR=UWG G Z]+ Q/ V
>HV  G E
H %]+ G HSKR %NZ IE=\H G= I QN M"  IH J^ R ' ST M Z HSKR LK
M% L
 VE
H  IW= X  QNHNR IW= X  RIM] G N M"   UKVNLK XNR
$  W G . GN ] \  I JV NR
M"   UKVN LK WK 7> M K IVJ> R 3 J^ R ' ST M Z HSKR LK VRF I-3NRN HRGK M" 
UKVN LK G  Q/ G  E
H  %] + A Q/ G  E
H  %] +  Q+ G  E
H

*UVK ZIRNGN

%] +   V
$  V(N  IW= X  Q/ G  E
H  %] +  IW= X  7>    J^ R ' JT Z NVZN GK
*UVK HR% GN I-3NRN HKVN M" T K  U> R ^  U] T (  NIMS G  JT 3 P %] +   7> a V  V(N
JT 3 P %] +  7> a V  %NZ IE\ H  HSKR NIMS GK ZIMZ. HKVK U-K M"   I-
JT H NR H> R N' QV  SN-KSE I-=H MK
MK 3NVR Z0
$ G
%4
$ EU*U I-=H MK ]G3
IG] G   M% IH 7>   HSKR Q= E 4 N  GK ZIMZN ISQN% HR
 ILGK 3HVK %NE I-M
* I3T 3 1K XENI-ZN% M"   H> R N' 3RK_ G  ^RV F>=RHN%K %]+ GK QNI-V %]+
 V
$  V=H HSKR% ?SKRN
?SKRN HSKR^  QNIG 3SG IE\H  7>  K I-= H  HSKR Q= E 4 N
GK JNIH ISQN% HKVK M
- K M"  IH Q"  J" U ] S R Z> M ] Z G  C 7>   HSKR Q= E 4 N  GK
JNIH ISQN% HR
 IL%  6  IG%. IW= X  QNJ'K 3HVK %NE I3T 3 1K RXH  V  = V W
$ IG% V?V 7> a V  LN IWRNLN QR(NV VE
H  IW= X  LNH  IW3RNZ HKVN 7> M
Q= E 4 N  JT * ^  HSKR M"   I-  GN JT Z N' SN-KSE G  Q] G R 7> V J= V K UT ] (  IW= X
IT 3 1K HRZ IW= X  SN-KSE G  JT N R] *  IW= X  MK = V  IG% GK RX%. IW= X
/A/ IW= X  M" 
* ]V. W UT](. GN NR I-MK M" IH J^R' U>R^ ILG H
E IV]%
$ %NZ M
' QV
%NZ G' GN QI;HNR WK M
W V
$ %NZ E" H LKW %^] L%ZAIZTV^ R^JK R
U V
$ 6=>1HNRN
JN7>'N XNMKGN M" IH7>$IH NYN 7>G3 QNJ%]^ HNE GK HNRNUNR V
$ 6>=1WN IH
QNJ' Z^E ZNIEH HIWRGW HSKR NIMS  G VE
H %]^ JTNJV HRWN7>'N M"
HIWRGW% QNJ'KSN'KIW=XIHMNM" IHI-=HLKW%]^ HNEN;%.V
$M1NH J^R%
U>R^ G JN IEQNH IV 7>JG3 IGWN7>' GN J]>% I-]%N M]>GN M" IH IL]%N IH HR
9
U.W.AS=HR QNIG JTN'KQ. %]^ HN-K V
$ 6>=1WN7>' GN M]>GN M" IH7>$IH I-M QS
;
ZN%W RKR ;NRK JTN'K UEV U>R^Q. G>QNRN G=K U-K 3NVR IWR=>; N;%. %NE
HNE G LNE IW=X FIQN RIMH %N LN' IH]% G>=\GN-K XRNK E=\ ^%KQ. G H31
%^] 0=EGN RIM]GN M" LG I-M LKWQNVZN HIWRGW HSKR NIMS  GK 3R' IW=X
J^R U>R^ G ZNI;QZ %NE QN L.GK M" %NZ %NE L>9 L.GK M" V. IFR I-GN L%Z
V(N IZTV^ GN H31 GN G E-K ZNJV M
 L.GN M" QV VE
H IW=X WNVIWH
JRZ 3.VK %]^ JTNJV HRGN M"
M>' JT3% QN7>$GN M" IH Q=LH=E G U>R^ I,QNGN V
$ I,QNGN I33 S'NH
QNJ'K 
UVN GN JTZN' IG\N7>$G M% QR(NV MR H
-K XNR H(N I=\ E"$GN M" QV
HIM]GNIHZ"$WK%NZG IG]GNM.QV *
EKQNVZNW.%]^ HNEG LNEIW=XJNIG]GN
M" IH7>$IH 3NVR. G IWR=>; %NZ 7>JG3 G' WNE QV L=J' WNE * I%3IXV
MK %RH G QI;HNRK M
'U V 7>%4. %]^ %RH IW=X 7>E1N E1HNI-QN LNWUN I-M
H(% 3NVR UKVNWG V RW UT](  MK G=G M% I- H(% %^] I=; HR% G
E-K I-=H ]\IJV H(N G=GN M.
I-H Z$ GK U=E M" IH * %]^ JVN X=IEQN IH RNLN JRKH3V %]^ =VW$ IG%
=J Y=UN QV 7>GK IZTV^ M
-UK I- U=E GN JVN E=U' 7>aV * % 
IXQN
IH =V IG%. V=H RNLN JRKH3V %]^ *NUWV GK H(N >'N-K LNW V.IH I-GN I-(
$
Z
M M=1 LNW QV JT*^ G IX]V% IW=X E=U LNW IH7>$IH ZRG Z$ ILGK L"K
*NW%N M]>GK M" 7>M 7> %]^ JTNJV M]>GN M" * % IHMN IH QIV 7>V=Z M" EIH%
M>' H(N HR H'  I- JT3% 7>aV JT3%WNXH IX]%4 E=U L.GN M" 7> Z$ 7>a(
7>JI(V * ZM.IR3KQ. % I-=(
$ V=H IH TKZG *NUWV >;NNUR G RXNI-VN

IUQN% U] U N

ZM.IR3K W G  IWQN LK %  WK QNJ'  QNJ%] ^  WK H(N > ' 7> '  G  
U  %MK$
ZI0QN IH7>$IH 7>%4. %]^ JVN K IH NY Q]GR I-M ZR=(VN %MK$ M" I-E-K
IH7>$IH I-=H LKW G LKW% %]^ %31 HRH JNJ G *NUKGNR S'$ IH7>$IH =VW
$ IG% JIR'NZ QN7>'N K I-E-K =V IG% V=H H(N >'N7>' GK IH GK IM]ZV
%MK$ J-K IH7>$IH * %]^ QNJ'K QHNV GN JVN M" WRU V
$ >a\GW LK %]^
*NUWVGKH(NHR%G E-KS>ENI-QNIUQNQV VGRNLNJRKH3VGNZ
MI-=(
$
MI1QN QV WRU GK JTNJVK M
-K WRU IW=X =>\ *
U' G SNQG WNIJ %RH
IW=X QV IFR E=\ XRNK IW=X X=HR H=1UN I-M I-=( GN MNRY Q"$Y _N1 R^E
M" QR(NV Q1=E I%Z M" I-M 7>JE=*;K WK IV]% E
H G J^R' U>R^ IS%. JTNJV
%MK$ M
 HGK
PKH I- VR4. LG IH  (N% V  JT ; N% Z] V RK QN IRMN M
W   V. 7> % 4 .  G
QN7> '  V
$  JIME. G
A IV] %  SM> V  Q= 6   WHVN UNI-H V  VSE A S" $ L^  W,N7> ) ' WNE
M] > G   M% L
 SM> V  3> R KEK QV  QHT I 3H QNWN, %NE GR3H. %^ ]  JT * NIWV HRG
M% E I H% 7> M  L
 HIM RM  %  7> % 4 .  IW= X  I-= H  U= E  *K HR% IW= X  HNIWE %MK$
M% E I H% LG
$  JT ; N% Z] V RK QN7> $ GN M"  V. 7> M  [= 1  V
$  [= 1  3SG. IW= X  HIM] G N
M"  IH QNUR  IW= X  I-] 1 T % " 3 %E HNEL S'WN G W
  X] Y KU94  IW= X  I-] 1 T % " 3 %E
^ % KWRI1K S'WN G W
 QNIGA IRF I-] % N MK HIMH  JK+Q" a Z+ NIMS XE
L.G  M%7> % 4 . G  HIM'%NEQUE  IG%MK7> M HNRLJT N R] * M
 L.GNM"  IH7> $ IH
7> % 4 .  G  WX% IW= X  3HVK M"  QV  I-MK U= E  QNJ 7> a V  Z R   ILMN QNZ IWQNHVK
HM  V. NYK W= Y K Z^ R ?VN M
W  U K IH7> $ IH NY  WX% IW= X  I-] % K 3HVK %MK$
M"   LGIH JT ; N%Z] V T K  G  E-K I-M * ;NR' U= E  M" 
I-%4. V=(. %]^ JTZNI'V HR% G E-K H>0 I%Z%IEI\V SN'KQ. ,R^R J9
4 QV
UIM' IWXNR HR
 V(N QIV 3K[R U> R ^  Z] V R JTNJV HR

HSKRJ]IYVQRZ3NEXKG
%4
$^0 %NMK$Q
R
$% HR$X.G%NQNJQ];R ZNMK$@
HSKRHR%KVLH(%KH("$QIUQN%KIG%RNVH>HRIL7>$*
$HVIFR"$>%K>%N-KSNV@
URKSSK,HHKSNV.HM"$SK,H%NMK$MN(IJT(WKYS%7>V=RHIMAHIMZKPKSNV@
URKSSK,HHKSNV.HM"$SK,H%NMK$JNQ$R
 H
 JTZ
;MK$QNJ'XE I%RN3@
URKSH(%K$H3^R[%H("$Q1]SRIUQN%SNMRLWNSQNW"%MK$EKGHR"$Z"GN%@
H(NHR%NV %NZ7>JG3G'NH
-KS=IXQ.GN\E4 %MK$M" IHE-KHN\IW=X
J
(KXE
 Z"$WKH(NHRIG]GNM.XE
 Z"$WKRNZNI-'GNJNPHRIG]GNM.UKVN
LK GN JNP HR IG]GN M. UT]( NIMS GN JNP HR IG]GN M. QR(NV IV]U HR
IG]GN M. QV %NZ WK G IG]GN M. QNIGA J^R' ]V %^] MK H(N HR% V 7>JG
3G'GNQI;HNRM]>GNM" QV 7>H(NGN3ZNJ%WK7>MKHRHGNM"IH7>$IH
J^R' ]V G 3SG IW=X HVK M]>GK M" ILW$ 3>\GW IR3K G SG IW=X K ILW
$ H
-K IV]U HR QV Z]% EW
 7> IW=X Q]S GK ZIMZN G= IH Q]S SM>V IZ=PN
M]>GN M" _E. GN RNLN M]>GN M" 7>GN R]U JKEN M]>GN M" QNIGA QV L H
-K QN
H HM IH IEQN *N-K Q]S G7> V. 7>M IV]U HR% WNEN HM IH ZR H
E V.
Q]S %MK$ M" IFR E"' WNEN HM IH IH(
$ IZEUN  7>%]^ LWNS IZE IH JVN
%MK$ Q]S V. I%RNHNR M" 7>M IG\N-K (
94N IG]GN M" IFR E"' WNEN HMUN IH
QR %NGN% C LG VR H
E Q]S M" MK$ %MK$ QV %N MK V"%]^ I-M JVN IH Q]S IH=(
$

*UVK ZIRNGN

IZEUN %NE MK HIM IRMN M" IH 7>M I%RNHNR M" V. SQR( IW=X 3
R IH7>$
ZXN7>$GN IFRGN M"$  HIM' GN ZVES I-M M" IH V=VWIUQN% RIMV V IS%.
QI;HNRK H(N HR% WNE V 7>G Z>=\ V
$ >'% WNE NR %RH G QI;HNRK M>]G
M%
L H
-K IWQHVK QNJ' QNJ MK U>R^ S'H I33 S'N E"$GN M" V. Z0
 QNJ'
IR 7>aV *NR X94N E"$GN M" IH7>$IH JTZ3WR GN I%Z M" IH LG V=H I33 JNR
%MK$M
-UNVGV=HU>R^ %]^ WNRAL%ZE"$G RIM'NJ"$GNM"J^R%U>R^ Q;^R I33.
V
$ 6>=1HNRN JN7>' E-K Q"K EKE4N HIRQN HRG M% IL V
$ QIUQN%K I33. %^]
U>R^ G JTIV %_RV M
 L.GK M" ILW$ HSKR NIMS LG
$ HN3K IW=X JTU1 M
- K
7> Z$ HSKR NIMS G X$M1 E=\ I33 S' U- % 7>%4. GK JTKI\QN E"' E-K
HSKR NIMS % HN3K 3IMR GK I-=H Z3M^R W3WN %]^ V]U Z0N7>' G E-K
7>G [R LN'N 3>R^ HR IG=VN IL%]^ G\ V >'H XIEQ. G IGE IW=X U>R^ JTVK
I[T'N J"GN M
 U-K QV * GN QNJ' U>R^ G JTVK IW3WN3 1>=1 IUQN HWE G
 %]^
6=YH 
* I33 U>R^ SMK' M
 U- IVU>R^ URKSGN LK ZMNRNL LK GK SN'K IW=X
*
JTZN' M"/A
URKSX]YNEKHX$HZ$IVU>R^S"PLN-X)$PEN\UNRVU-G
RMIVU>R^JN-@
*9WN*9WN*HM"$LN%V%MK$\LGNURKSHSKRHRZS.1VIRHNS0@
QK$ QNJ%]^ I-MK JTN(%. HR%N XNM>]G M% IH 
X IWXNR H GN HR
 NZ
WG G E
H %]/ IW=X G=IQN M" IH LKW GK Z>HVK IV]% %.W. %NE M
WUK
JT(Z 8Z G^RN IV%NZ V=V  QV VKRN NR%NZ IV  I-M UKVN LK WK
JTZN' IG]GK M" IHA8ZAV=VAIV QV DTK U>R^ UT]( NIMS WK - IV%NZ L=J'
GN I-3NRN HR IRMN M" IV%NZAIV%NZ H
-K L=J' V. LNJ %MK$ M" I-M V.
7>%NZGKVR_I-3NRNHRIRMNM" L
 I-=H=XN%NZM"I- VR4.I-MNR%NZ
WK I-=HEN 8Z Z]VR IH H]Z GN %MK$ M" I-M IV]%
$ %NZ V %NZ G' GK
QNIUQN Z"%^] ZR U>R^ GW WNZK RNZGWN%]G LK ZMNRNL G>QNRN S?I33 M" L

HSKR NIMS V
$ JK94K GR JK94K XEGK QN RMK M" JIME. QNJ IV]U >'
 
WN HR
 IL V
$ QNJGN *UVK R^JK ?V ]WR LNWUN
HSKRZN%>3L%ZJN-H%MK$R1VMIR%NZL"H^QNLEIS%.\>GBNI-QNIHHNZ@
HSKR-HMIRH%NZIS%.RNLNIR3SM
-ZN1K<
WH>]ZMNRHK[N%NYNEH
-K@
I-V
$ SNQG QNJ%]^ ]WNR M
- \V IW=X SK, SK,'N JWUN
N 3NVR. HSKR
NIMS GK SN'K WG UKVN J>RN' H>RN' ;RZGN NIMS QNIG ]V. GK SN'K
G QI;Q"% V
$ Z>HVK %MK$ M
-UK I-%4. * 3NVR. GN I-=H MK NR I%X
9
M" IH J^R' Z>HVK E-K J^R% JTZNVZN HSKR NIMS G JTIVI%I; ]V IL%]^ 7>%4.
G U>R^ G>QNRN %NZ G' GK QNIUQN M
W  V
$ %NZ 7>JG3 E"H QNVZ HIEQN'
HRN7>'N XNMKGN L %NZ %N IEQN V./A
 %NZ IS%N ^%N %UR JI9QN 3HE Z$ 3
R
E^1 %N E^1K S]GUK M
 IUQN M]N *R@
QGEK QNRVK QGE Q,^ % K %NZ IS%. M"  HNN ] ^ % K
0^ P K HNN \NE E> M NRN I-] U EN IJ] U EN 3> 3 Z% GB N RN
IHT V ['K *^ E   %R E
- K LN [1 I%3X"  %NZ %N M
- K

IUQN% U] U N


 %R HK1 JV]U *^L]UN XRNK Z$ ;R M" Q]UN
L SK, %MK$ SKI,QN V. QNVZ. R^JK \V GK U>YN-K QR(NV IVQNRK HR%N
IWQR( M
I-QN HIM' GN *NW I-M M" IH I-V
$ QNJ%]^ IUQN% M
UN L
 IH ,R^RK
M"JT]V^ J^R'U>R^ G>QNRN%NZ7>JG3E"'NQR(NVSK,SK,'NWKQIV,R^RKM"
%NZ WK 7>MK L=J'N M
UN L
IH U>R^ %N%H NIMS % L=IJQN URKSGN NIMS %
L=IJQN ;RZGN NIMS QNIG ]V. % L=IJQN I-G QIVIRHV M
R %NZ. V
$
LKW GK Z>HVK %MK$ M
-UK
I-E-K QNJ *% %NZ 7>JG3 E"H QNJ'N *UVK R^JK ;]% L9%. QNR]*
HR%N XNMKGN QV M
R. %]^ WK G='N XNMKGN M" IL]%N LEGK M
 H 7>%. LEGK
IH7>$IH %N LN' HG QV IH Z$ I- RKR GN J^RN M
' GN Z. QN LNW U>R^
%N%H GW LK WK HIM]G M% IH/A
%N LN% HNE HK HR YNR IH IW=; <E LN JNN W
IL]%4. G IR V" ZV \>9UGK 7>%4. %]^ IHM9N MNN W@
    HSKR NIMS HIM]G M% IH/A
HSKR >W.A7>W. Z$ %NZ LJ
 IWQR( >W. ZV \-
%N LN% I- >W. HN QNW% M
 H %N M
-@
IVU>R^ 
-K L
 NR%NZ IGT9NW" QR U>R^ H
-K HNZ %N QNW
NR%NZ
IS % 
J>R3
* U W N % 
GT
MK#
QR(NVL
 U>R^ NR%NZL.NR3SG%MK$IG]GNM" L.7>%]^ QNJ' U>R^ G>QNRN
%NZ G' GN QI;HNR QNIUQN  %MK$ M" QR(NV 3NVR. G QI;Q"% V
$ L H
-K
Z%Z=>\K U>R^ I-M %NZ WK IG]GN M" V. WK 7>M U>R^ QV 7>G I33. %]^ %RH IW=X
JNI-QN LN-UN 7>M U>R^ *UWN% GN G>3Z' M" IWGT
MK M" 7>%]^ *UWN% G
GRSNR IW=X 7>E1N E=1HNI-QN LNWUN
M>' *UV ZNL IW=X %HEK U>R^Q. ]V.  G>QNRN I-=H UEV ;NR'. F"ENQ
R=\K M" IH I-=HWNR U>R^ ;NR' HR% V
$ IJ=6
$ G^LN U>R^ %MK$ SGE'N XNMKGN ,RN
IWXNRHRH G\
 IHU>R^ NY L%ZAIZTV^ R^JKR
UH=1'WNENW"GM]>GNM"L I-=H
W"GV
$NYNR
U%MK$H=1GNM" V.QK$G^L X]U W"G YNH1R G H
ELNW.U IL
V
$ NYN LN%EWN R
U PKH M
 H ILW$ ;RZGN NIMS LK G JIME U>R^ DTK
R^JGNLK%EIH%LG;RZGNLK%]^ JVNE=UNIHI-MU>R^ J^R'Z>HVKGNVN
%MK$ M" V. V>R]V IVQNUH J^R' SDTMZ JTZ3WR IVJ>R3 HSKR NIMS %]^ QNJ'N
U>R^ S'NI-QN V J^R% Z
\3 VE
H IW=X JTNJV HKVN PKH I- VR4. Q;^R U>R^
%]^ V>R]V IVQNU G'N XNMKGN M"
0^PU>R^HJH3H
VLV%HKLWNIR#
 U>R^ V %NZ ZIMZN GK SN'K
URKSIS%7>JG3QX]*M"IH7>$LKWVM"$JTN'IS%*UVKHMNPRM"%R%NIM]JN3N'@@
URKSI-=HMIR%NZIS%.%NRKH>=VKQNM
-UEKA*$HVIFR1^H%NYNE H
@@
URKSSKSKJ9GRMK$(KIY7>YKEUVKSNRUNV7>UN9IFRVKM"S%H=V
> KQNSN,NR@@
URKS%HSR%HS%KJMRVMNRMZE]G
> RK>%MK H=V
> KQN S%K>I%NIMSH\E@@

*UVK ZIRNGN

HSKRMIRH %NZIS%.RNLNIR3*M
-ZN1KEG" H>]Z4NRH[N%NYNE H
-@@
HSKRRNZIHT%H'S9N7>%4$*KU>R^HK%MVK%E
HHW;%KU>R^QNUQN;K%@@
HSKRUT*

UWRU>R^IS%NENUNMIRHKWHIMHSKRWRUFRIGQN>\GW
@@HSKRRNLNL%H%NZEHK%4K$MIRHKW J^LN HMHSKRS"HP
>] Z$7>E1IZE
>\GW@@HSKRIVU>R^ H7>JGHNENI-QN-HIWXNRLIVU>R^ IZEV%MK$LNVN
%RHGWNR@@HSKR%RHGWNRZ$G^V*HRV\K$XNVN%7>%VHSM^] %N6^1VNIFR
IFRVNXNR
$\N%@@HSKRXNR\N%K$Z$*TZVNHSM]^ %NEUVNJNR
FRNSIZ=1
IUQNIVU>R^ H7>JHNR@@HSKRNVZ]G
> RHKZKHR]^ E\%KHR^] SI%RN-;RVKHN
HNUGHR^] U>R^ U>'IE\N%NLN-@@HSKRU>R^S9U
IS]GZ%Z$G\IWXNRMIR
>ZR 
 RIMU-U>R^ *L M
- JNR@@HSKRU>R^ U
IS]GG
7> \9HNH ENU^ JN-
SIEMNRKU>R^QNJ%IL%U
IS]GGK-IZEN-@HSKRMIRHR^PVNU>R^HKR%Z$LN-
HSKRU>R^LR^PLNMIR%MK$M
VMN-@

%NZ IHM9 RNZ GN L=J'N M"#


%NZ
UKVN LK G QI;QN- %]/  GN E
H %]/
GW  I-Z   J> R 3   E
H    3RM X QH3T .  - W  X 3T M  T W NI' *^ V N%K
H^1=(M QH3TM 7>XV@
Q%>WNG/ I- ]NR IW=X G
 JTHNR G *UWN% M% %N3WN% QV QIW%NK
I-M ]J^R' *^VJTN'KQ. G RKR V. %N3WN% M% QV LKW QNVZ. QIW%N3K IHMN
L.GN M"
UKVN LK G QI;QN- %]/  G E
H %]/
 7> V ZM J> R 3M V^ ]   Q%] -    JRZNVZ.I-VK 7> G NRV M  M E
H VRZ
QNIW3M IS*RIV QWM -K3WRM@
Q%>WNG/ 7>VZ *UWN% V. H
-K M
R M" L
 IV]%. E
H. IW=X JTW3 HRH *GN
;NR'AJ
' HRGN M" QV QIW%NK JTZ3WR JTZNVZ. I- JTHNR IHMN IUQN M"
HSKR QH3R J> R  I-H J 9  M"   I%R] L % WNHK YNR
IVTGWN STMZ.IW3'^I3W 3N\N*-JNV*I-QN]NR@
HSKR VK% GWH
 * H-K I;QNW X( GWHN ZRZ %N JNW
  X(N 6NY J]XZ I;QNW" HM
 HSKR 
 MZR QNW"@
HSKR VK% U>'% HK *UVK Z$ *^E JR
 ]NR
   HM  HSKR I%L %NZ IS% H    7> V R $  JNR@
HSKR 8$HNR %NZ STMZ HNE  HN M HRVN ZIV LNI%
    NXN 3SG HSKR HN JRGN ZNIM]  JIMXNI%@
HSKR VK% E
H  * RNZ LJV M" $  LN% Z> H IV H
 ;NZ
RNZX]GRWI31U>R^ HKQNIV%HNIM>%NI-7> %NZ@
HSKR RNZ IHT3% QWVNR M"$ I-%HN %NMK$ ]NR
IL%NIMS]NRIHQN
 IH%M> %NL%ZI-QN%NIR@
H S K R   X N R  * ^ L N H   * L % Z    * ^ E  JR    *  ] V 
     HS KR N  ^ Z I R  V N ^  H
  LN H  * > LN  Q% ] V @
HSKR WI331 Z^%K  VVWVN IUQN%K 3
; HR EU% ;R"

IUQN% U] U N

     KVN MR' ZR' GR( H


  W' W' RNZ IFR" @
H S K R    Z ] > G R  J N I 1  E ] H N  U -     K V N  H
 * R V N R 
  VNIM QUV Z> % K JK IU7>   I-%Z $  H
 HRVNR@
HSKR U
W R;% IH3% LK 7> P NI-QN GT
' NIURK M%^ Z ] V 
  3 3  %NU S IT 3 1K 7> P N-K I-%Z  H
 *UW] V @
U R K S   G > R W N 3 N  H
J   VM .   Z 0  % N  Q N - K  % K X 
  6 = J %  H
I 1   N G W  H 1    ZX K  R ^ ; R  H K  H K X @
H S K R   HN 1   S ] ; %  I W J I V  Z  $   H I P %  H K Q N  ] U T N Z 
  XK%M
$  R  %R JT ' N-KQ. UR> 9  S9
 HK RNZ@
H S K R   HM   H S K R  IX V  X  V M ^   S G  H R
 I % R > W N R 
   TK RNZ X]GR H
 HRVN HMV M"$ *^E JR
 ]NR@
HSKR IL% RNZ IHT% I%R]L% HKQN 
 V
 HRVN I%QNR
 Q] ; N  I U Q N %  % N  S ^ 0 - K   HM   H S K R  IS X N R @
HSKRVK%U>'% STMZNIW3'^I3W HK*UVKZ$*^EJI97>]NR
 HM   H S K R  I% L  % N Z  IS % .   H"    7 V R
 J N R @

@3SG@ ]V RNZJNE GN G>QNRN RIXV

>;
= LKVHRJ.YW\>3KM>- QJNRI-]GRJT(IHU=GKJR>I;31RHKRHNR-H
IG%QRL>%J^6VN>%IHT3%*UWN%-HSNRIFR>%NG7> W
I%TZEUKVNIUQN%@@
[ZNN%>;
= HHNR'*^EJ9KMZ
M
 IL7$>HNIV7$>HIM%N*UW%VI%H%NQ]VRM
-@
 @
IR3KZ>%KQRGWVN*H
RMV>Z\N-I-%H
*K%MK$69NQNJ%RMV>ZN4 RNMKU>'UN
@@ IHT3% S
E QRL>%   UEVK IH7>$ HK$%4 - I%RZE IUQN% H
 *>E
=  IUQN
S>;
= KMK%@@QSZ^0 *KH>0NG%MK$*>EJ9K%KGN%IL7>$HNIV7>$7>UKVNHNZ"$%MK$
HRHVNU>'UN%@@W"$DKT IHT3%H
NG%MK$QRQRL>%H
;ZHN-S>;
= KHNEHMN(M"
XNMIVTEH

K%N(HMENW@@IUQN%MK%JTXNRHNIUQN%H($IG%RNVL
RWH
\N%
WNENHM$7>KHKSNV@@*HM$*UWN%IHTJNE^M"IHTJNHR$IGQNEILHK*J^LN
HR$WW"$HM"Z"$HNE@@ZNR"\NW"*H
WMH"NIHTJNEH>V
=  U;^RS%NW"M"IFR*K
GK%IGQNE@@SNI-SEWGH>RN%M"L" X.GJTHN3^RLIUQN%HSKRHNHR"IVZR
HN%N3@@RNZJNENXKHM"HR
IWWHIWXNRIV%NZWNR%NZMKZ]VRM"
NR@@HSKRMZNRNRNZM" W
 M" GK%IGQNE]H1Z
X%H31MR%U>'UNW
RNZJNE@@

@3SG@ ]V RNZJNE GN G>QNRN RIXV

STMZNIW3'^IWM"$VK%E
HJT;N%Q31]UKI-%HKZNVNMQRIJVNHNE*UWN%@@
-HEN\H
HNEI%V\NWK%NVN%STMZNS'NWIW3'^JNE"I3WHRGHIEQN'@@
QRL>%YRHJ^6VNM"MH'R^J*UWN%HMI%R]L%Z"$HNEM^]SH
QNI-QN\N'
@@STMZ%NZI-KHNM"WGHRU>'UN%L%ZZR'XRNKI-HN]IW;N%@@
XNRRNZHK*UVKZ$EURMN]NRJNXW$RNZHNIUQN%%MK$L
JNR7>VNR%MNR@@
STMZ.AIW3'^AI3WVK%
$U>'M"$G^RNJTIHTVKHNLNEEN\LKWI%=V*=\3'HRRNZVKRN
HNE@@QH3RJ>R3M"RNZX(NL"X]GRZNLN%J.XW.RNZHSKRM"L"7>G"M>QN

*UVK ZIRNGN

*N%@@RNZGWN%]GU>R^LKHRU-%,RI%MNEIV%NZHNIGQN\,N%NSRV"
RNZJNE@

%NZ E"' WNE IWQHVKQ. E-K ,R^RK LN'HNRK

+J^R'U>R^ GKJIMXN'/AQ=LHE=>UIW=X*UVZNLG NMZ' J^R'U>R^


GK JIMXN' HR%N * V
$ Z>IHE JT3% SI'QN M
I-QN M" EIH% I-GN SM>V
MKE[^ QV ;NR'
ILMN7>VR
= M" IHL
 U>R^ 3NVR.G Q%>NR*UVKHRGNM" QV
;NR'ILMN7>
QNJ' XIEQN QR(NV I33. V
$ HRWN7>$GN M" 7>M MK J^R' ]V M" IH7>$IH *UVK
ZNRU GN ]IW;N% ;NRIZH 3NVR ILW$A HSKR NIMS GK SN'K %N%H NIMS
LK GK SN'K ]V URKSGN LK ZMNRNL LK GK SN'K ]V ;RZGN LK NIMS
GK SN'K W G  UKVN J> R N' H> R N% JIW= V R SNI-SE QNIG M% L
 WK ] V
3NVR. G Q%>NR *UVK N;%. G=GN M" QV *UV ZNL %]^ ZNRU GR3% HRGN
M" V. 7>M J^R% ]V M" %MK$ V. 7>M *UV ZNL GN [
R G>3Z' M" L
 3NVR. G
IWR=>; N;%. HRWN IRMN M" I- Q%Z
E ZN%W L%Z %NE I\EWN9 HR IRMN M"
Q" U>R^ L. ]V %]^ *UWN% G GRSNR IW=X [
R %RH IW=X 7>E1N E1HNI-QN LN-
UN
7>GMNR' E-K ILW$ H
-K QI;QNJH IES JNPHTZ  V
$ SNMR GK I=I\QN
IG]GN M" V. 7>M 7>%4. IW=IGQNR(KQ. GN G>3Z' M"
UKVN QI;/%]+  G E
H %]+ 
%ZNZG>3IHTV%MZ^9NJTJ]V%RN;Z.MZNNQJIMVIUQN%NMQN>RZ
*NWZQNI-3TVNM@
Q%>WNG/ ZNI-QN G G>QNRN IL%4. GN IUQN% MIRQN LN X>=HN M" QILM Q3>R
>*NQ %^] ;NR' HR M- Z%>=\ %KX G^I3VHRZ HR% WNE Z^R\ Z"%]^ %MK$ *LG
QR(NV 7>M IV]%. U>'. RLU>'ASTMZN VU>'AIW3'^ VZU>'AI3W  GK N;%N
HRG RIM]G M%
L>RWG QI;/ %]+  3E
H %]+ ]V RNZJNE LK G>QNRN RIXV /
Q]%GWNM^M]*WNG]I%M>R]*WNVI-VK3>R3>Z;KRN'.%VIGWXXI3R@@
J]LNSK Q%>WNG/A JTZNVZN G SNR IW=X ZN% R^J IW=X I%RNHNR QR(NV HG
%N L%Z% WNEN HIM]G M% G^RN QNHNR IW=X QR(NV L%Z E"H QWVNR R^J
IW=X QN7>' WNEN HIM]G M% L
 I1HN7> QR(NV J^R' IUQN%K X]UK JTHNR >'N7>$G
M%7>%4.%]^ I-JTHNRMKVRV 7>MKZR^JQR(NV(NR(R^JIW=XI*]%AI*]%
R^J V
$ JV=\ IUQN% HRWN7>$G M%
UKVN QI;QN- %]+  GN E
H %] /
V=VIW*IGJTI'JNV%JIRJT3%%WN
7>JGH3]IVVIUQN%ZIUQNI%%MVVWGRI3%M@
Q%>WNG/A 7>%4. %]^ Z0 7>%4. J^R' JTZNVZ. G IUQN% V ZN;N% %]^ LN%'
WNE ]V. %]^ *EK*.VK G]YWV JT'NZ HR% %NE 7>%4. GK WN HR% %NE QV HJ1
6=YH REVNJ^RWH JT% HR% %NE 7>M JTZNVZ V=VW %]^ *EK*.VK LN%' WNE
IUQN%K ZMNVZ. V"%]^ 7> V=VWIUQN% GN 7>JG3 HR'U
+ %3KEKQ. WV^Q. GN W% I%3; /A M>=HN 3RNS SKQR V]SNH^ SK9K

IUQN% U] U N

IUR 1  M^ E N > ] [ 'N U^ 1 HN ZN Q] Y N > E _N Q_KZ U.,. QV  M
R
%3KEKQ. XKL. GN W% V. G^R IRMN IH %^] %3KEKQ. XK,. IEQNH WK %MK$
G'K M" S]GK69 URKSGN LK ZMNRNL I-%4. * %3KEK WV^Q. %]^ SM>V S>RN
G=G M
- QNJ'K SN'K IW=X HIM]G M% IH/A
^RNJN%Z=;Z.NMNRKUZ%HR"*
U JR%NRK=VRL%ZH1VM"$3K3]NH3KNIMSM"LUGK3@
JRGBNRNI-VRKHN\
E =VRL%ZQ];NM
W Y
E
 ZIGRNJKWH9WNJN'K=VT L%Z3BN%HLN%K@
URKSM=>HNMRGZJKWVENEIZENW;^RI-Z3]3M"%MK$L%ZIJ6E^R@@
URKS%NRKLNRKHR^RNJN%
SNR-HIXEZM=>HN*RY^SHNEK;NR@@
URKS^RU7^H
\NVM*UVKISM^%$RNY*.UV]SNH^\NU-
XNSVM"$MNY@@
URKS*.UV]SNH^JKWMK$^RNJN%"MVU
VZ=1K\N-HRL]UEKS%$JTV@@
URKSJN%V]SNH^XNSMK$%N%NHZ$GV
V
I-RN%U-IL7>$*]Y*^LHNRV@@
URKS*.UV]SNH^JKWMK$U
VUENHSNSZ
RIZTUH]^*\VM"$GU$HM.LWNS@@
+ VKR( (N%. 7>aV LN' I%3; A/ IH VR4. GN H
-K WRV %MK R=\'N M"
H
-K VKR( NVRN %MK$ HR%K %N H
-K U]UN %MN7>'N QNIG HR%N %N IHK M
R
;NRIZH(=E7>aV I-3%N%V GR3%E-KLN'NM"IH Z]GRV I-31;NZIW=X
J^LN V *UVK G *NW %NE %MK$ LN'N IH I- Z]GR IW=X *UWN% M" *UWN% H
-K
J3^ V. M" %MK$ IH 7>%^] J^LNRK LK % Z]GR IW=X S]%4 R=I\QN M" *UWN% V.
H'AH' IW=X IWQNJH M" I-M * N;%NW. 3NVR. G IWR=>; M%
LRN IWXNR HRH G
\
 HK I-M * VKR( (=E ILW$ LU%%N( GN Z]IGR
SGRK%N( MIRG> Q NR Z= H NAZGK%N QZR%N( W" 3 '
 G W K IWT ] G .W% Z(^ R N
SRN%N Q
I;QN RNZ Z]IGR H.3K ;NZ 6^YN%K ;NZ QNIG  Z]IGR ZILG
U>R^G>QNRN XRX V I-31 ;NZ QNIG Q" (=E M% IL=( H
-K ]V RIM]G %
7>M 7>a( QNJ'K *UVK N;%N HRH QNJ'N *UVK R^JK ;]% L
9 HRH RKR 6=YH
QNJ' I-31 GW G E
H XE U- VG IJ=6
$ 7>%4. GK NGUNR %^] JTZNI'V R=\'
G E-K 7>a( IH % Z]GR IHK % ZILG IHK % U>R^G>QNRN IHK % XRX
L. IH % ;RZ3NEN QNIG S'WN IG=VK V.IH 7>%4. GK NG S'K RM QV NY
ILM V>6 JTN'KQ. %]^ JTZN' IZEGN RM IH N%]^ QILM HRZ HR% XNMK- ILW$ IH
I-M ZMN% QNVZ.W. % HKV M% I-M * ;NRIZH (=E N%]^ *%^] I-MK ]G
3 IG]G M% IH ILW$ *UVK N;%. I-%4. %NZK ]V. % HKVK M" Q"K MK QNJ HR

I-G E-K QNJ I-K VRKH N;%. HR% WNE V G=' WNE ]V. %^] VEN3 HR

QV IFR L"N 7>M HIM' W"N MK HR


 EIH% SNQG IW=X 7>%4. (N%. GK MK J^LN
QNR]* M
 U-K L
 HK ISEH>E IWQR( M" QV 3NVR. G IWR=>; M"
I-M NR (N% V. I-=H Q" (N% GK VR4. M% IL=( IH MEWN-K % *=PK
S'NH LESK E=Y^ QNIG S'NH QNJ \NH QV QNJ' UAN(KQ. %]^ I\ENH XE
U- 7>V
$ SNQG 7> (N% 7>aV %N V. MEWN-K M" V %N MK ZIPQN-K IFR
V. 7>a(  HWE *=PK MK M" 7>M %N V. N%]^ IZPN-K S'N7>'N I\N HGK M" V. %N
MK NYN J1 7>GR  *R HGK M" M>' H
-K HM IH QN7> *N-KC QNJ%]^ 7>M *=PK
IG\NH IEQN7^$UN IL=( I-=H MEWN-K % ZIPQN-K S'N-K K XE
 XEG M. 7>a(
LNH 7>*=PK%]^ G\IEQNQV 7>G =VX=HRWKH=1QN-HKQNJ%^] ZIPQN-K
IZEK HK QNJ%^] ZIPQN-K S'N7>' GK IW;K G=' WNEN MEWN-K IZIEQN I-G

10

*UVK ZIRNGN

E-K QNJ% W"N MK MEWN-K \


L'N M
WU
 N L
 * V
$ JIME. QNJ%]^ ZIPQN-K I\EN-
QV S'N7>' GK IW;K WK G=
  IFR ILW$ 7>M HM HWE 7>MK HR%N M
R H>0 %MK$
PKH I- VR4. VKR( (N%. GK J^LN %N HRH W" MK ]V. GK VEN3 HR
 L

3NVR. G Q%>NR J^R' JTZNVZ. HSKR NIMS GK *UVK HRG V G=G M
' IFR
ILW$ 7>M HM HWE 7>MK HR%N QNJ'K Z% ZN%K %MK$ HR%K
NZWG ]I\QN %]+  7>VNIXTH QI;+ %]+  \]Y %]+  E
H %]+  ]V
RNZJNE LK G>QNRN *N3NA*N3  /A

*GRNWVRNZ]N&WN%
ZMN%HIWRI%WX%NI%3]%
QNWXWXZW
MJ>ZN%
IWXH3'
LNUTIWRGWWKV@@
Q%>WNGA XV>R IWQHVKQ. % QNJ' WX%. G>QNRN J^R' JTZNVZ. J^R'
STMZ  GK J^LN GN IVZNRU GR3% %N HRH Q]IZTV G (N% 7>aV QNZ 7>JN%.
ILW$ *^V J^LN IJ=VR J^LN 3RN; H=<'N IV]%
$ U>'. GK J^LN RLU>'ASTMZ.
VU> ' AIW3'^   VZU> ' A3] H R  V(N ST M ZAHNE GK J^ L N Z] G RAZILGAU> R ^ G > Q NR
AXRX. V VKR(AWRV V=H GK 7>JN3%.  R^JK F9 QV L?Z V
$ I%HE ZWNG %]^
QNGR G %NE QNXZ% HRN RM M]>G M% 7>%]^ JTZ>\GNI-H J^R' STMZ HSKR
NIMS IMRKR N;NR' *3*^3N IW=X WVR GN QR( M" *3*^3NA]V *N3N
IW=X I-%]^ X
EN WK HIM]G M% ILW$ H
-K ]V RKR IVQNU L.GN M" V. HIM]G
M% IH ZMNVZ. V. X
EN 6=Y U-#  VE
H WNE RKR G ZN% G^RN V,J>]L
GN RKR ;NR' HRH QNZ IWQHVK GK VR4. LKW% LKQH H>0 IG% ]NR IW=X
RIMH  QNJ'K 3SGAN?KQ. G  ZNI;QZ %NE IVIUQN% QIUQN% %^ ]  WR'%
HRH J^R' JTZNVZN G I6J M
- WNVIWH IVIUQN% V(N *UVK %]^ LNUIRV
HRG M%
     UKVN QI;QN- %]+ G E
H %]+/
M3NVTIWI;Z7>VTLWTVVHNZHNRVM%M
II;GZQNWJ%
VK%^\Z%JRNZUIVZ@
Q%>WNGA/ L
 J>R3 3NVR IW;K %^] IVQNUH QNJ'K I-=6N %NE Z%ZN%N
QNXR' HRGN M" 7>M %N I=;K %]^ JTNJV M]>GN M" %N MK JRZUVK %]^ QV %N =>\ %]^
MK
     UKVN QI;QN- %]+ GN E
H %]+/
%QIVQ3T%VMV^
UMQIV%X-H.VZ
Q%3T%VM%XQIVWJ%KELNUTVM%-WXQRL>%@
Q%>WNG/A M QRL>% C I-M 
U QR(NV *UVK %NV. SM>V \N' WNE GN QV
%N ISEH>E %N \N' WNE QV %N SM>V -H.V (N% 7>aV QN3' EUNH N;%N HR%
WNE GNV(N%NSM>V'WNE G >*NQWNE GNV %NGNLNU'WNE GNMKI=;
M]>GN M"
J^ L " $  G I - ;NZ H
  3K3 MENW  L
  URKSGN NXK HM"   MG HNIFR M"  
@
HSKRU]UNHNP[RHR"JKWI%RZE%KRZ>HV%MK$MRK%NZIS%IVU>R^ HM"$HSKR@
HSKRVKR(HRAHRLUZ^WN7>Y" JN%K%MN-RNZMK%NZ%NLJNHNE[K1LN-@
URKS JKVE MK HN (NE M" JKVE HN E
1N L94 Z^RV H
 J^LV$ QNWUN 1
1N@
URKSJKVEXZXNJ^LK-L
 (NEJR
L94 Z^RVIHHNZHKZIVRM
 *R
@

IUQN% U] U N

11

HSKRJTSVJRSVZ"$IFIRQNHNR'QNJ'RNZRNZRK\L%IZEIL%NR*HNZ@
 IJ=VR J^LN I%3;/A IH VR4. GK IJ=VR J^LN 3RN; H=<'N QNIG %MK$
HR%N *UWN% 3TK IHT3% LK % WK I-%4. IJ=VR. GK V *^V. GK J^LN HR% V
$ NF
Z%4N HKVN M" UKVN QI;QN- %]+ G 3E
H %]+ IW=X IHMN M" IH A
.IVGWWTVNMGWN%IJ=VTIRU%.IVIJVTWTVNM
*^VNI%.IV*^VLNMZ;NIL%MQIJZNZ@
Q%>WNG/A GWIVQ. %]^ J^L'WNE GWIVQ. %]^ JTNJV M]>G M% IJ=VR. %^] J^L'
WNE IJ=VR. %]^ JTNJV M]>G M% *^V. %]^ J^L' WNE *^V. %]^ JTDNJV M]>G M% QV ZV
Q%>NR J^L' HR% WNE *UV ZR V
$ MK EN*IW]V M]>G M%
 S]GK6
9 URKSGN LK ZMNRNL V HSKR NIMS LK ZMNRNL WK HIM]G M%/A

URKS*^VRZ
*^VM"GWRZ
GWRNZRZ
RNZM">%
HE>R*W@
I-E-K 7> J^R' JTZNVZN  JTZ3WR GK *UVK HR
 IL V
$ J^R' Z>HVK
M
W 7>M JTZNVZ. J^R' STMZ IVJ>R3 IV HSKR  M" I-GN JTZN' UKVN LK
G QI;+ %]+ G 3E
H %]+ IW=X M"
VMJTWIT V*^VN%.%TWIZG]VVZWHTZ'.VZ*XTII;4ZIW]GIVZN%W4@@
Q%>WNG/ IL JTZ3WR V
$ ]J^R' JTN'KQ. GK 7>VJ=VK M
-K M" V ILV
$ I-M
ZV LUV IWQNJV M" 7> JTZ3WR GK QNJ' >*NIWH HRZ. G>QNRN J^LN
HRH Z%=>\ JRZI=;K %]^ JTNJV M
 L.GN M"@@
  UKVN LK GN QI;QN- %]+ GN 3E
H %]+  A/
VZW3T'ZU=6TW*NW%*NRV
V=VJTNGNVJTNZ3.IVZ(N%ZJTNJNI3N3WVZ@@
Q%>WNG/A M *NRVW]3
*]GTW QRL>%C V]^ RW*NW %NE 7> -K3WR GK MK
3R' IW=X XEN LN 7>GK IHTJN %NE V]^ JRZ3.VK ]NR V
$ RW(N 7>JIRV
%]^ QV QIW%N3K JRZJG %]^ JTNJV M
 LNWUN
RW*NWGNQR(M" IHH
-KM
RJ^LN%NHRH Z%AHRZAWX%V
$I-=H
JTZ3WR IW=X QN3(N R=\'N
         UKVN QI;QN- %]+  GN 3E
H %]+ /A
J>R^3MMJRMJNR(*HVNE*MV>Q=%%N
Q%VM(NI%*^VNI%%TWZI-GZVVZ@@
Q%>WNG/A M JT(N%]G% QRL>%C ]J^R% JTN'K ILG Q]VRUV M% V ILV
$
]J^R% ]NR IWQNJV M" 7>M JRZ J>R3 JTZNVZN V. Q%]% *UVK %NE JTNJV
M
' 
U M"
Q%]%*UVK GN QR( M" I-=H JTZ3WR J^R' STMZ  GK *UVK HR%N G^R
G W KAG W V.W. QR(NV IV] %
$  U> ' . RLU> ' AST M Z. VU> ' AIW3'^   VZU> ' AI3W
GK %MK$ HR%K UKVN LK G QI;QN- %]+  GN E
H %]+ V
$/A

7>R;TWZ^EZQGM3N\ZQ3WV(ZJTNM>MQWZ
6%G.IJT'NI%MVZWGMWGIWV@@
Q%>WNG/A 7>J=R %]^ L94 WNE V %KX %]^ 3N?N WNEN QIW%N3K IW3VIRV IST?
M" [
9 ILMN ZLS^V ILG 6
1A6
1 IM= L. 1MI'Q. J=V HM M% 7> ]NR R^J
IST? %]^ L
 I- JTHNR LN'GN M" 7>M *UV J^R' IUQN%K M"

12

*UVK ZIRNGN

      UKV QI;QN- %]+  G E


H %]+ 
Q;MX7>R;ZJTTVNMV3N\NMU>'JTW=T;NMIW3JTWNENM
Q;RXZ^ENI%Q%>]VVNI%HRZQ%>S];KI%Z%>3E
H@@
Q%>WNG/A7>IST?GK%KX QV 7>J=RIV]%
$U>'STMZNARLU>'IW3'^AVU>'
I3WARLU>' R^JK F"EK M
-K IWHNR HNZ HT
; Z
M E
* QM]HNR R^JK H
JE YNEK
STMZ. IW3'^ I3W MK LKW %]^ HRZ. X S]%4' GK WK L94. QR(NV Z^E HNR% M%
V(N Z%=>3 E
H WRU %RH E
H IJT(WK E
H IW=X %KX XRNK E=\ L^%KQ. IW=X
7>J=R IWWIV HKV M
- M%
          UKV QI;QN- %]+ G E
H %]+
%R^JZQ-MV(N7>JE=SV%Q]VM%XQNIGM%X
]JTIV3PVNQ3WV(Z-%Z>IWR^9Z^EZQ]U3VT'GT<%I6VWN@@
        Q%>WNG / I- RX%N GN %N 3>R^QNV V(N %N Q]V M" W"N R^J JNI-QN
L.GN M" V(N I-=( IWXNR HNE IW=X QR(NV ZR G>QNRN IG=VN LN IRMN UKVN
IUQN% IW=X J^R' LN'HNRK Z"%^] WK %MK$ M" IH7>$IH RW STIMZ]Y. GK RX%. HKVK
X]UK VR4. I(VK GN Z"%^] WK IUQN% %MK$ M" X]UK VR4. (N-K I(VK WNEN Z,S^V
WR^J WNE I%REJ V=VWIUQN% R^JK IGT9 3N3VR V
$ QR(NV I%RZE V=VWIUQN%
G G>QNRN H=1H QR(NV I%R]L% GK *UVK %^] 6I'H LN'H 
     UKVN QI;QN- %]^  GN E
H %]+ 

VVMJGZVVJIRZNRIUWZZIZ%UVNM%I%WRV]IV*^M
VZ-WXQGZJ>>R^3ZJTJGVMJTWT=IVMJTTVNJ>RN'K@@
Q%>WNGA/ 7>V
$ SNQG 7> JRZJG JTZNVZN GK ?
, HR%K XNMKGK M"
IL%]^ JTNJV M
- Z%=>? I_R ]NR IW=X %MK$ QN7>$GN QV ILV
$ Q%NIG HNE V
$
X=EK QN7>' WNEK I-M I3T31K IWVNR %]^ JTNJV M
-K M" 7> QNIG J>R3 JTZNVZN
G MK Z"$ R' IW=X M.
I-JTHNR ?>G *UWN% 3TK IHT3% % I-]GR L
 GWKAGWIVQ. GN RNLN M" IH
J^LN WK 6=YWN H 7> JTZNVZN GK *UVK HR% G E-K MK JTR%. IG=VK K IL
HNR' 7>%4. % U
WR;% JRSV %]^ X=>H H I-]GR G U>= V
$ ISTL WNKQ. GK R=I\QN
HKVK K
URKSI-]GTX9NISTLY^S
W%*KUN*KV%NEW
I-]GTH<N-KM
VLUVZ$J^LN\NU-GW@
HSKRI-]NRH
Z0N7$^H"SNR
J^6L
JH9*9HK7>VRNXNMJNR@
     + U>R^ QNIUQN GN JNE' /AU>R^GW LK GK QNIUQN G IS%N [R IW=X IHK
WK JTHNR GN ;NRIZH J^LN %MK$ HRN7>'K ILW$ S]GK6
9 QNJ'K SN'K IW=X G=G
M%IH/A
M%IH/AU>R^IS%=UMW%L
HRMK$IZ=(QNLNWHSM]^%NFEMK$#
HSKRU>R^IS%ZNENFRVU>R^IS%GVGN%
U>R^IS%G
%
4$I%3FEM"$J^6
WGJ>RN'@
 + ZNVN ZN'K J^L'N I%3; /A QNJ' \V IW=X S'K IHK Z9K L. IH
\9 QNIG GK L. IH M
R GWVN GK ZN; WK %MK$ J^L'K$ M" ZN; XNM IH
GK WK M
W ISEH>E %MK$ J^L'K M" M
R H
-K 7>JN%N %MK$ HR%K M" I-=(
$ V=H

IUQN% U] U N

13

IH IV]%
$ U>'. STMZ. IW3'^ I3W  GK J^LN WK %MK$ HR%K M" HWE U>R^ LK G
G= RNM 7>aV X=E'N M"
UKVN QI;QN-  GN E
H %]+ 
%ZNZG>3HTIV%MZ^YNMJTJG]V%RQ;ZNM
ZNNQJTMVUN%NMQN3>RZ*NWZQNI3TVNM@
Q%>WNG/AZNN G G>QNRN IL%4. GN IUQN% MIRQN LN X=>HN M" QILM Q3>R
>*NQ %]^ ;NR' HKV M
- Z%>=\ %KX G^I3V HRZ HR%WNE Z^R? Z"%]^ %MK$ *LG
QR(NV 7>M IV]%$ U>'. RLU>'ASTMZN VU>'AIW3'^ VZU>'AI3W  GK N;%N
MK HRG RIM]G M%
HSKRZN-KZN'K3<3KVEN*"RW*^VM%]^Z]VJTZNVZ.7>%G^RM"L
I-%H
J^L]V@
HSKR
WR3V
IVU>R^HKWNI-=HIG%QN%7>JNKW
QJRN;KQNVZNJRHNEHK
F.K@U>R^H
VL"*L
QN%NV.JD^Q.H
F
H1IUQN%N@
+ ]H1 Z
X% HSKR NIMS M"$/A HRZH31 ]H1  M
' 7>aV H
-K M
R I-31
GK L. ZNVN ZN'K QNIG GK WK J^LN %MK$ HR%K M" %N IH JTHNR GK J>=6 E"'K
M" HWE S]GK 69 HSKR NIMS %^] J^L'N M" L
 NR G>=\. %]^ MR' WNE ]H1 Z
X%
M%
NZW G  ] I \QN %] +   7> V NIXRH QI;/ \] Y  %] +   E
H  %] +  ] V
RNZJNE LK G> Q NRN *N3NA*N3 /A
Z%K3K*KMJWVJ>RW4HIWT%R4I*RVMJIRH
3.QI3GV
IVTV%NZL%]%Z;>3RI%]GTWN]^\NNWR;]@@
Q%> W NG/A%NV% QR(NV QIW%NK HSKR JT Z  3 WR IMRG  V
$  XNM> '  WNE
3R;N %NE *UVK HR% WNE  *UVQNVZ. %] ^  IV] %  Z] V R 7> J G 3  G H   JIW= V R
HRH  L%Z V  IZT V ^  V
$  RIMV HRGN M"  V(N 7>  G  JT N ' QR(NV LKW%A> W ..
%] ^  L
 ]  NRW3 QNJ'  IZ= V T  QR(NV *UV G  IU'VK G  JN-  M] > G   M% %] ^  QNJ'
*] Y NR V
$  J^ R ' R^ J  %NE W;N7> $ GN M"   IL HNR% V
$  JT Z   WR G  WNVIWH
QN%] G  %] ^  QNJ'  QN3KRWNG JT 3 NG V
$  JT N JV HRWN7> $ GN M" 
HSKRGWKGWP.Y*-MZH
PRSVN7>L
Z>0 HSKR H
J^L%MK$7>%H
E^1
\N7>@
HSKRHNEL
JKJK%NL
RNM"JI%MNRG
QEZ]L^RM"$IVU>R^HGRSNR@
+ Q' QNW3H GN% I%3;/A IHV WK QV IH %]^ GN% R^J IW=X H>0 %MK$
G'N M" %N J"N %N IS%N IIEQN M
I-QN H=J9N QNIG H>0 %MK$ G'N M" L H
-K
GN% R^J IW=X H>0 Z]U' QNW V. 7>%]^ \N'N I\EN IG7> XNM G=>; E=K QNIG
IJEN IG7> JT]V^ G'N H=>0 WK %MK$ M" %N LN'$ 7>M I*?NRK 7> J" GN G>R7>J
U
HR ILW$ I-=H IWQNHVK % IH I*?NRK %^] 7>GK 0^PK HMN'K IL IW=X 7>M HIM
IRMNKHKZR S=X I-ENLIS%.V9JRM M%H>0J" G'GKIHTJNHR
 %^] >'H
*NW%N W=3 M
IH  R>/ G IG=V 7>M I*?NRK JIME. J7^QN JK$GN K 7> IG%
7> IWQHVK % Q=;K S
VE 3RNS JKVK QV QNJ'K JV%K %]^ H=>1 IG=VN 7>GK
JV%K % S=IXQ. IMV QNVZ M=IVQN HR E-K QNJ G>QNRN HKVN M
I-QN 7>M
GN% 7> JIRWNR G %N3 GN HNR% S' IUQN L QNJ XNM>G
]  M
 V. IH QILM G=\
> K
IWQHVK JIRWNR GK ZGG HRK- LNW V. 7>G S=X %]^ YNH1R V
$ GWN-K GWN IG7>
J" %N IG7>

14

*UVK ZIRNGN

HSKRU>R^IS%ZNENFRVU>R^IS%GVGN%
U>R^IS%G
%4
$I%FEM"$J^6
WGJ>RN'@#
+ L^PN4  \N'N I%3; /A Q" IWQHVK GN L^PN %MK$ \N'N M" L
 IH 3RNS ZN
V]SNH^ Q]YN SKQR Q_KZ U.LN QNIG GN W% HRGN M
W
+ IVE
H UZ% GM.V  G SNQG IHIRQNAHRZ I%3;/AAL JIRWNR G
IH GK ZV M
 L.GK M" IXVN IW=X QU%K H
-K *K G HGN M" [R GN L. M
R
V(N QU%K JTLWIEV HRG Z$ Z]UENXR' S
E G' V. 7>G F>=E QNIG H>0 %MK$
7>PN7>' M% L 7> (N% %^] N_ HR%N QI%WNRK- M" V. 7>%4. Q(KQ. %^] 7>PNH
W"$ MK IHK (N% 7>aV XEG JN'K IW=X WMNQ G' 7> Z$ Z]UENXR' 7>XNR'
HR G' %N IJ]Y QIG *RWN7>' M% %N VR4WK$ %N 6ZNMK EN%N SRK IJ]Y
WK %MK$ *RWN7>' M% V(N 3RN; QNIG H>0 %MK$ HR%N M" IHK *K M
R IWQHVK
V
$ MW% QNIG %MK$ HRWN7>'N M" S];K V(N IR3VGNR. QIG L
 3
H IWQHV
HR% QN- 7>%4. G E-K H
-K *K I-=H IG% I%>HV HR% 7> IG% JTVKIG% HR%
WNEN I%=VI%Z HR% L
VK LNIUTV HR% I_R RW %^] \N'N I\EN8 L QNJ%
7>G ZR% WNE G  %NZ V H>0 ;RZ HR%N M" V. QNJ' U>R^GW LK GK QNIUQN
E"H S]GK 6
9 URKSGN LK ZMNRNL GK Q]IZTVZ-K SN'K GN Q\]Y JNP HRN7>'N
XNMKGN M" L JNP HR% GK QNIUQN %N IZE V. JIRWNR G 7>JG3K *UV XNR
IG%L.=VIG%[RIW=XI-=HQ\]YL
VG3K[KGKLEN7>'V(NSTMZUNI-VRK
Z]VR JTVKIG% XNR WNR HR% V(N I-=H WNR G Z]VT GN GN% ]HEJ VE
H WNK
%^] HR% L"N 7>aIXV Z0 I-=H G
 IV]% V=H Z]VT G LNJ GN _E 7>%^] GN%
HR% JTVKIG% GK VR4. L
VK V QNRVK %NZ IZR% HRG RIM'N M" I-M NG
R=\G M
- HK/A
HSKRN(KMZNRXEU-MZ*KXNE%MNRH
- HNULZ$SNHKRIMRMKVNVENURMKWNR@
HSKRGMJ9KV
IHQNM>QN0^PN*KJ1K1J]6K7>aIYQNQNHN3H^] XEVNHRIUQNSK1@

HRZ H.Y G IW3 IW=X IV H(N#

ZR ]V RNZJNE GN G  J^L U>R^GW WNZK RNZ GWN%]G LK ZMNRNL LK
%]^ 
E4. NE GK 7>ZR IW=X IHK ZMNVZN GN IV]U >' H W"RNU M
 IUQN K
I-=HIG%7>M\V.IW=XU- M
- %%9 MKL]UEK7>ML]UEIW=XLNH IH
IZTV LN%WR GKQ. M=YKQ. G H
E QNJ' H=J9 FN9H >=1 L.G M% QV QNJ
ZMNVZN LK G %NE XE LNG M%
LG7>%4.GK\
,M
-KV.7>%4.G [RWNIEQ.% GI\QNIHL]UEIW=XM=YKQ.
G H
E F1 M
- H=J9 J- M% V. 7>%4. % 
IXQN IH IH L]UEK LN%WR % 7>%4.
%]^ \N IEQN M" 7>%4. H=JI9Q. V(N M=YKQ. %]^ X=>HH [R E" QN7>$G M% QV Q]IVZ
]HNR HR IG]G M% 7>V
$ SNQG V4RWK$ V(N 6ZNMK HRG M% QV IFR 7>%4.
G 3RN; 3>R^ M
 L.G M%
LG
$ ZR J^LQ U>R^GW LK SM>V IST; M
 X=>H % V. 7>M I-=H WNR QNJ' [R
QN U- 7>G
$ 7>%4. G [R WNIEQ. %]^ JVN X=IEQN IH 7>M ,KWV M% V 7>M [R
6=YH XE U- % 7>%4. % G=IQN IH LG I-M [R 6=YH XE U- % V. I-%4.
GK \
L M
-K L]UE IW=X I-%4. G H=J9 IZE 7>%4. H
E H>0 M=YKQ. J-KQ. K

IUQN% U] U N

15

V. QK$ 
IXQN IH IH L]UEK LN%WR % I-%4. %]^ \N IEQN M" QV 7>%4. H=JI9Q.
V(N M=YKQ. %]^ [R IEQN H Q]IVZ ]HNR HR IG=VN
IFR Z"$ ]V RNZJNE LK GN %  ZR J^L U>R^GW G 6
1 *N-K GK JV%K
V
$ J=>I6QN IH LG NY U>R^GW [R 6=YH XE U- % V. QNJ% IJ=6
$ HK HKVN
7>%4. % G=IQN IH LG
$ Z"$ IWQNMK QN-K K V. 7> Z$ Z"%^] I-%4. G 3RN; H=<'
%^] IZE % Z"$ QNJ' M=(. %NE I-%4. G EU*U  3RN; H=< X=>HK M. 7>%
G=IQN IH LG WK [R IW=X H
-K %>HN% M
 L.GN K ILW$ Z=0 GN G>=; %N G'N
(' IW=X ?RNSK QN LN'N H
-K M
R %>HN% M
 LN'N QNIG V. QK$ S^0 JWN7>'
L.G K V. 7>M HIM]G K IH QNJG [R IW=X H
-K I%R]VN% Q'Z"IRY  ZIRQN
M
I-QN M" QNJ%]^ 7>M G>=\K HR IRMN M" IFR QK$ 7>G H=J9 QNIG IG]G K
IFR Z"$ IHMN IH I-M G>%KQ. GN 7>GNR HR RM M% I-M IH%]^ G=>\ G RM
% I-M V. >=\GNVN M% IFR Z"$ IHMN IH M>' V. I-M QNJG NMZ' M% M>'
V. I-M _NEV^ N;%. ILW$ 3RN; H=<' QNIG S]G HR IG8 V. 7>% IHMN IH
I-M V. J>RN' IRWNL M" I-M IHW$ 6=Y GW. QR(NV QK$ QNJ' J>RN'K IRWNL.
IW=X I-]% EK% M
 X=>H M. IH 7>M UEV HR RM M% IFR WK QK$ 6=Y %MK$ HG
 I-V
$ JTZNI'V M>]GN M" IH 3RN; H=<'N IJ=VR J^LN HR%N QNIG * H>0
IWQR( M%
+ S=X G L%Z V 3NVR IWR=>; J^LN I%3;/A S=X G L%Z V H
-K 61K
QNIG %MK$ Z%N7>'K M" ^VH G HNR' JTIVIG% GK VR4. HR% WNEK J^LN *UVK
QNRVK L
V LUN7>'N QNIG S]G %MK$ HR%K M"
I- G ]S]; IW=X I-=H ]\J H(N G=GN M. IH I-=H IWQHVK GK 3NGK G
G NE IJ=6
$ J=>VR M
I-QN K J=>VR G M
' V 7>% SM>V \>3K Z%N-K A
IJ]Y. IW=X *
L% G E-K S>ENI-QN QV SM>V MK UN'NASLN7>'N M
I-QN QR(NV HNFK
J"N?RXHKVNIFRI-=HNEV
$SNQG7>J>V
= RGNGM.VM
 L.GNM"IFR7>MK
JIRWNR1=HR.ZNRH R
$G.M" QV QNJ' G>R*NU%]^ H
GNM"I-E-KHSKRNIMS
N%^] G=G M% IH/A
HSKRS1NLNI-QN\>3KM>-KSM>VSLN-(NEQN%NLN%NEUIRMNIL7>$HK9KHN%NE@
HSKRJV09QNWVG\HRS%R
- Z%ZNIM7^XKYNEKJNV(QSJKEM
M
L.IM@
HSKRJNV09]VN^] HM">%S-KVR>WRRN-QSHIS69%MK$IZEN%NLN%HM.IUR$U
LN-@HSKRVR>WRHIMVNJNV^%
JNV-HSNVM.HKMRKVKM"-HQNW-HLNV@
+ G-K ;NZ V SNE 7>VRWN7>' LN'N I%3;/A S=X G IHK G-K ;NZ 7>aV
WNE 7>VRWN' %MK$ LN'N M" LG WNE W=Y M
 U- H1WN H =>1 GW
 I-=H Z]GR
IW=X GI\QN IH 3R;NE^ QNJ' E9HN L. E9HK G WNE 7>VRWN7>' E-K QN- L

7>a( %N-K K 7>% SNMR G R1 V


$ IV]% U>'. I,QNGN J" E- QV I-=H H"$XK *R
SNE H=1H ZNVNAIJVN %]^ G IG=V 7>%4. % 3R;N %NE Z]IGR IW=X X94N- J^LNRK
% I-=H ("E IW=X JN E- RNV %]^ 7>PNH G^R -H.V (N% 7>aV =>1 IG=V I-M
IRF %N1H SNLK M"   IH7> $  %N JIME. GK VR4 .  > * NIWH VRKH  %NE WNE
7>VRWN7>$G RMK- V(N SNMR >=1 G-K- JTZNVZN %NZ V
$ JT3]% M]>GN M" J\]Y V
$
%MK$
+ %NZ LNJ %NE =>\/A %NZ 7>JG  HWE G>=\ I%WNR% G IGT31KH
' %NE %MK$

16

*UVK ZIRNGN

E"'N XNMKGN SEIH QNVZ HIEQN' G E-K E"'N XNMKGN M" IFR IZR% %NE
RW =>\ QNJ' QNJMK QN L.G M%
HSKR IZR%   * = > \  M
V  M"   IZR%   G> = \  LN- 
HIM HSKR IZR% IH- .-K Z.M ZN-@#
+ IW*XNR I%3;/A JRN-K I-VRK %]^ Z.AS1KA*"' GK IGT31K %NE G
\'N XNMKGN M" IW*XNR ZM.JNJ M" ILW$/A
URKSJRG>QNRNI-VTKHN\
E
 =VRL%ZQ];NM
Y
E@
 ^RNJN%Z=;ZNNMNRKUW%
HR$*
U"$JR%NRK@=VRL%ZH1VM"$3K3ZNH3KNIMSMLUGK3Z@JR%NRK%N
JRK7> $  ZN%
 WX% MZNR *W% XV^ R G3 VN IR IVT E
H K HN *NR@
JR %NRK %N JRK7> ^%
 3SG EV]V ;RZ RN- H \]*  QR;Z=>\K E1H]V@
+ I%]GN >'%N V HR%N I%3; /A QNJ' U>R^ GK I%]GN *=>EH WK %MK$ HR%K
QV %N MK >'%K M" >'% GN *NW I-M M" IH LHR H
-K QNJG U>R^ LK G SNR
IZI(QN U=E. HR V. 7> %NE E9%N %MK$ M" SEIH I-M Z0'N XNMKGN M" IH I-M
IS%. 
X S
E IRMN M" QR(NV
QR(NV 0^P S
E IRMN M"
      U>R^ HK I%]GN >% L
 HN%N VNH
 I%3X %RH I%GN%N@
      QNJ% Z>=\ I%]GN L
 HRMK 3>HR 3WN% UR* Z$ JRMK$@
I%]GN V. IHK GK WK %MK$ HR%K M" QV %N MK >'%K M" XNM 7>M QNZ
IWQHVK IH7>$ MK %N M
W HSKR NIMS HIM]G M% IHA
IV%HNHSM^%NI%]GK-L
J.WVEM
HSM^7>PQNI\%J9JKR[%RKM
@
+ U>R^ GR3 GK ZIMZ. /A IV]U IW=X Z$ IZEG MK QN7>' GK H
I33
HR
 QV IV]U IW=X %?R ZN'AWIYQN-K  HR% %MK$ QN7>'N SEIH QNJ'
QNJ%]^ ISZNR Z0H QNW ILW$ IH I-=H ISZNR IWQHVK XNM IH]% MK J" WNEN
M
W XNM IH 7>aX J=GWK WNEN M
W LG 7>M MJVNE L.GN M" V. 7>GN 7>G3
IR_ R
U Z>HV M
'N M>]GN M" IL=( YNH1R E1' %^] HM E1 L.GN M" S"P' E-K
HM S"P LNGN M" SNMR LN' GN I%RG3 IZE V. SNMR XEN LNGN M" I_R Q]GR
QN7>' G E-K QNWN, QNW V. X=>J HRH Q]GR QN L.GN M" PKH I- VR. LG
$
QNJ IV]U IW=X QN7>$G M
 V. QNJ%]^ IV]U IW=X QN7>' GN EN* IZEUN %MK$
V. QNJGN QN7>'N I%3_E M" IV]U IW=X IL=( S"P' %^] IZE 7>a( S"P LN- L

\N' %^] IZE 7>%]^ JTZNVZN HSKR NIMS GK RLN %NE JTNG Z0H \NH JT3]%IX=V
RM

HSKR]VIZE'H
XNEK-VLZNI-QNQI*ZN%L
AL
HGZQNUR=\ W
MK=UZN%@
HSKR]VIZE'H
LN-K-IG%Z$H-KAH-KSNRQN
LHZMIL7>$['NHR7>JHNR@
HSKRGR3%N;^HNJTZNVZ.QNWNGE\Z$W
MK[9KSNHKHIG%SNQG@
HSKRGR3%N;^HNZ>=\JRS>MNUGR37>%MK$H
M
VMIL%HJ^R'*NU@
+ U>R^ ZIMZ. /A L IHV JNP L. IV]U X=E IRMN M
W L. QNJ U>R^ LK
G GR3%. E-K L.G M
 V. * V
$ JIME. U>R^ LK %]^ G]YWV JT'NZ E]SN E1H
HR%N XNMKGN M" SNQG IW=X IV UT]( NIMS V VWKR. ILW$ NIMS HSKR LK
GK Z^RVKAURKSGN LK GK V WNZK RNZ GWN%]G LK QV U>R^ LK GK Z^RVK %]^
JT'NZ HR
 IL %NE IRF QN(N S'K RMUK Z^RVK J^LN %MK$ HR%K M" IR_
JT'NZ HR%N J^LN IW=X %MK$ QN7>$GN I-M V. *UV GK 3R;N S'N-K R=\' IW=X

IUQN% U] U N

17

IM
U IG]GN M" J^LN V. W\V U>R^ LK V %NZ Z]VT GK HR%K M" L
 JNR EUN-
UN
HSKRU>R^U
IS]GG
7>\9HNHENU^]JN-
SIEMNRKU>R^QNJ%NIL%U
IS]GIG7>IZEN-@
HSKRU>R^S9M"U
IS]GZ%Z$G\IWXNRMIR>ZR
RIMU-U>R^*LM
-JNR@
HSKRMIRHR^PV.U>R^HK3R%Z$LN-HSKRU>R^L"R^PL.MIR%MK$M
VMN-@
HSKRNVZ]>GRHKZKHR^E\I%HR]^SI%RN-
;RVKHNHNU,HR^]V
U>R^U>'IE\N%NLN-@
+ ZN \N'N I%3;/A Q]YN L. ZN \N'N L. LKW IM]N %MK$ HR%K I-M
ZM.JNJ M]>GN M" ILW$ HSKR NIMS LK V URKSGN LK ZMNRNL % G=IQN M"/
HSKRLKWM%IM]NHRJTU1JNJIRM
-
 I%UZJ^I%- JNJV$I*VIUQN%NIMH
-@

HSKRIVE*RZ6EK\N-HH
I1U7^GGN%HN3KHR
$VEZRV
WK%RHI%GN%@
HSKRS=HRKJNVK\NVM"VNHKHN<K\NEL
S=HRKH
\NVM"IV%HNH
%MWNE@
HSKRUENHNI1HEZN*RHKQNHMMENENIMSE\NZ.UKVSM
KH
%MWNE@
HSKRIG%H
R
,NRMVM$"RNVM%VM"$UN-M\^%WMS]GUKHM^]IH7>$\>3K\>GN-@
HSKRHSKRNV-KJKRM"$L
LN%JRJKRL
JRJKR%LNI%M"
HNI_RSJKR@
HSKR\^S\N%NM"\KX9KZ.MKJR1>HE%Z.JRNI-QN\N-HUENH1NWH%@
HSKRZ>EZN%ZNRHRG
IM]G^ZNRVRWNRHM"HSKRG
%
IZIEL"M"$ZHGWNR@
HSKRZ.QMNRKZN%WJTV\
= 3RNH33LNI%VNIH]UIVZVHRM
-K*UVKZ$MN%K@
HSKRZ.\N-V<9SZGJKW
%KXH>EHKG>RZIVJRMR"RNZHM
7^X@
HSKRZ.Z=6EKQ.\NVM"$>RNJN% MVV %R%RH LNIMUZNVNIJVNZV@
HSKRLKWIM]NL
HRVM"LNQNUHNJNJH]1HL^%KILMN%Z"$K$M*9K-Q
R.J@
0
1 SHR Z>RU VN-KE\N *MK EV U>N-K
IZTU Z
R ZNR ZMZ]VNQXRN XR M" LKW Q%]V.@
LKMWN WNV IM= V   JT N %N%KZN %N3 IUQN MZ LN%N@
VKVR EWN S^1RK XK9KQN\^%K ZNR S9 QUI9QN@
QGE  SGE  E \   E \ N Z0 G \  > %  IUQN% IWW H N@
URKS 3SG MZNRN ZN%K7>   Q
R  > % V  M
 %R %NIR
LKW IGQN IS% H>FR M" XE LZN%N MNIR@
Q%LN% IW=X M
-K IM]N GN JNJ %MK$ E=UGN S]GK6
9 HSKR NIMS HIM]G M%/
I-=6NHRZNR%MK$IS%I-=6NZRLN-HMHSKRVNHNJNJ%MK$EUN-@
+ U>R^ ;
TMK GN ]JRH I%3;/A L H
-K *UV U>R^ LK %NE ;
TM U>R^ LK V
$
SZ=>\ M
 L.GN M"  HRGN M" ZM.JNJ GN *NUK M
 L.GN M" L IH %]^ ZNRU X]UN %N
E=U V.QNJ'NU>R^ SGEHGNM"L 7>MQNJ' JIME.WNE U>R^ %NEW"RV I%]GN
HRGN M" V. 7>M U>R^ ;
TMK HMN7>$GN M" QILM IWQHVK %NE *UVK XRXN HR%
IW=X 7>JG3K %]^ G
3 E=UGN M" 7>GK *UVK ZNJV M
 L.GK M"
URKSU>R^G
TMKHKJ"9JRLJUQNWWKRXRNKI%3X"J9IVU>R^HM$HSKR@
HSKRLN%S^0NXKVLHR0^P%MLNHK]UVMJT*^WJ%Z$*K%NG@
QR(NV U>R^ ;
TMK G H
E LN' WNEN *UVK RIMV M
H %RH V E=\ XRNK
L^%KQ. IW=X XEN L.GN M"

18

*UVK ZIRNGN

+ L^QN I%3;/A L^QN V VN3 HG %MK$ \E4'N XNMKGN
HSKRZN*\Q
RZGJK-;%W"QN
\N-L^QN\IEX
RKHR"Q]VZ^ENLN-@
+ %=X'AUN' I%3;/A IH WK JTHNR G \>3K G ZH V %=X'N QV Q3EKE
UN' UN'N *UVK *NW G IWR=>; M" ILW$ I-=H Z$ I-=H IW;WN *"' IHK \>3K
G ZH 7>aV QNJ' IR3VGNR G [R U-K M
-K K NR \>3K %NE %=XAUN RM K
QV 7>M *"' I-=H JN S"PH JTZNVZ. G IX]V% IW=X E=UK M
-K K IFR 7>%4. G
IR3VGNR. % 7> V
$ J=>I6QN IH QNJ I- VR4. IH7>$ S"P M
QNJ WK NY W.U
%=X
 UN8 V \3K Z%N8 I-M >'H 7>M *"' HIM' E=UK IH Z"$ IH GK \>3K
Z%NW. ZRN IW;WN GN I-=H MK S1N K 7>M *K *UWN% %]^ IJQNRN M
 X>=HN M"
M>' HK \>3K M" ZR E-K PKH I- VR4. I- HNE G E
H IW=X MRH IWQHVK GK
I(VK M" I-=( U>R^ %N%H GW LK GK SN'K M" IH/A
%NLN%  HNE HK HR YNR"   IH IW; <E LNW  JNN W 
IL%4N G IR ZV \^9UGK 7>%4. %]^ IH94N MNN W@
N;IZE NYK3NGK \>3K M]>GKIW69G.IGEUKRK G=>\ W
Q \ G   % N % H  > %
 L M N % N   Z 3 I H E  M N E  _ H K R K  W  @
HSKR NIMS LK ZMNRNL WK HIM]G M% IH/A
HSKR0^P=>\H
=>\HMZN%IRMNZ%Z
G
3HEXSK%.HNEHNH>6Z>=\Z$H>6U
G@
HSKRS1NLN-N\3KM>-KSM>VSLN-(NE
QNW'LN'NEURMNIL7>$HK9KHN%NE@
IW3 3 /AI-VRK V(N J> R 3 G
% 4
$  MK JT Z NVZ. JT N JVK G  QI;HNRK M%
I-VRKQ. %]^ ZNIH ;RZ (Mainces) G IG%. IW=X QNJ'K G"I%H J^LN L
VK
EUN7>'N QNIG S]G %MK$ HR%N XNMKGN M" %N MK IHK G GM.V L. L%Z V WK
G"I%H J^LN HRZ S]G %MK$ HR%N M"
%
1 /AL
 *UVL% I-%4 .  I-= H K QNG 3 N GN JNE' %MK$ HR U N 7>  GN %NZ
ZNJV M
 LNWUN L Q%LN% IW=X UEVK M
 WK L.GK M" V. 7>M Z>QN_ M
 L.GK
M" QV L LN% S>0H H
-K UEVK HKVK M" V. 7>M *UV %NZ RIMV M
 LNGN M"
I U>I
I-GN ZN;N% I-MK M" IH QNJ'
R^GW V
$ I3ZN NX%N HRH G>QNRN %NZ 7>JG
3 E"'N M
WUN

IUQN% U] U N

19

I3T31K RX%N

3^?3Z WG V
$ I%3HR3 R^J I3T31K RX%N GN WR'%
JT*^ JTZK QNVZNW. JT(ZWNR I-M I%Z% I331K GK RX%N %]^ J94%U
V. Q"  N E= U  U N IH I-M ILW $  H
- K G] V  H(N M"   JT ] V ^  RW JIW= V R
GUT](. G JTZN'. %]^ J94H G]GN (=E 7>$UEK GSN7>$U IH I-M WNVIWH
Q]IZTV IUQN% IH=( 6=>IJQN K IHTJN ;KR, G %NE J94G RM
 V(N I-
Q]IZTV IUQN% %]^ >R=I\QV R=\'N QNJGKQ. I-=H 
 I-=H JK94K V=H H]Z
QNW U N JIW= V R QNVZNW. IHT J N IV%RNI-' QIW%N3KJT * ^  IVJ> R 3
GQNRN RXK I331K RX%. GN WNVIWH IUQN% J9
4
+J^ R ' ST M Z/A I-M I3T 3 1K RX%N IW= X  IVJ> R 3AIVE
H  GN
WNZK JT*^  QE\ J>R3AQE\ E
H GN WNZK JT*^  QUZ J>R3AQUZ
E
H GN WNZK JT*^  V(N Q%NZK J>R3AQ%NZK QHIM E
H GN WNZK
JT*^  V. I-=H MK J^R% STMZ M"  L
 WNVW IW=X QIW%N3K JT*^ M" L

I*] % A R^ J  ;NR% HRH  QNJ'  XNR


$  E
H . IW= X  RIM] G N M"   ILG
Q] V RUV Q] \  ST I MZ] Y  QN7> $ G  M%
+JRSTMZ/A I-M HWE =V ]\ STIMZ]Y GN WNZK JT*^  M" I-M
QH3R J>R3 WK HMN7>$GN M" JT]V^ I-M V(N I-G STIMZ]Y WK WNVW
IW= X  QIW%N3K %MK$ M%
+STMZ/A I-M HWE I-=HK STIMZ]Y. GN WNZK JT*^  M" I-%]^ 6R
J>R3 L
VK I%R]L% HNE QNIG 7>JZN %NE LNI'QN L.GN M" I-M V(N
I-G  RW ST I MZ] Y  WK %N3WN% M%
7> J R
H V IV] %
$  J> R 3. JT * ^ Q .  GN JT Z N' JIW= V R T K ZG *UWV
UKVN Q/ E
H  A IW= X  *K M" 
+ ST M Z./AST M ZN I-K ST M Z GN L P N J> = V R M"   IW3'^  Z= ;  WNEN
J>=VR M" V(N I3W Q]IVZ VKRN J>=VR M" I-M IV]%
$ STMZ G J=>VR H
WE I-=H STIMZ]Y IW=X I-=H IW*NU U>'  G WNZK JT*^  M% IWIVTV
WR'% G  E-K IHT J N J94
 I%Z% IE\V I3T 3 1K RX%N/A
HIWRG W  HSKR JT Z  3 WR  %  ^ \ Z W G  QR(NV HSKRSN'K IW= X
QNJ' G>QNRN RXK I3T31K GN IUQN% QNJMK G=IQN M" L
 I%Z%IE\V
M" /A
* V
$ JIME. HWE I-=H (N% Q%NZK Q%NZ  E
H  K IL
%] ^  QHIM E
H  WK IHMN L.GN M"   J^ R ' JT Z NVZN 7>   Q%NZK E
H  IW= X
I-H= E N RIM] G N K 7>   JT Z NVZ. GN WNVIWH %NZ HIWRG W  QR(NV
HSKR JT Z  3 WR M"   * QNVZNW. 7>   J^ R ' ;%K G  RKR IW= X
ZN-KQ. M
I -Q. % I-  HIWRG W  GN 7> J ZNVZH JGWK GN  %NZ
Q%NZK J>R3 M" J>R3 GN QR( JT*^ M]>GN M" JT*^ % Z%=>\ %]^ QNJ' MK
WR^ J  IW= X  S'NI-QN M"   I-E-K ZN%W GN %NZ WK J> R 3 MK IJQN
M"  Q%NZK J>R3 G I-=H R
Z H^J GN JTHN ]\ ^RL. GK R3%K V
$ WK

20

I3T 3 1K RX%N

IUQN% U] U N

21

ILQNGN M" 
IW33/AILW$ IH G3 G QNGR'K-$ JT;N% Z]VRK LK GN RKR GN
%NZ H
- K M
R  M] > G N M"  V(N JG GN 7> J ZNVIZH JGWK GN  GN %NZ
JT;N%Z]VRK M]>GN M" H-K WNR JT;N% Z]VRK LK QNJ' H
E H
-K IW*NU
R=\ E"$G M% VG IL WK IW*NU G GVNW,. 7>aV GV?V HRG M%
V. 7> Z$ 7>K JG %]^ IE\G M% ILW$ UTIMZ]VTNE G GVNW,. 7>aV
GV?V HR%U V. QNJ' %^] UTIM Z]VRK IE\'U 7>a( 7>K IWQHVK
G GV?V GK 3HVK H]Z M>]GK M" I- JTHNR HSKR JTZ3WR HIWR
GW  GK R3%K IW=X Q]VR I*]%A E
H. M]>GN L.GN M"
PKH I- JTHNR J^R% JTZNVZ. HIWRGW HSKR JTZ3WR  % %KX
G IV]% M
R E
H. QUZE
H Q\E
H VE
H  GK RX%N 3SG WX%
%NE HKVK I-MK J^ R % ST M Z JT Z NVZN HIWRG W  HSKR JT Z  3 WR  MK
QUZE
H  IW= X  JT U 1 M
I -QN V(N HIWRG W  HSKR JT Z  3 WR  QUZE
H
GN WK WNZK M" V(N 7>a( I-%4. GN 7>JZNVIZH JGWK GN  %NZ QUZ
J> R 3 QR(NV QUZ JT * ^  M"   I-  QUZ JT * ^  GN ZN%W> I GT 3  RKR M"
SM>V V,
Z-K M" ILG I-=H R
ZH^J GK R3%K ?RS ^RL. GK R3%K V
$
WK ILQNGN M" 
I-M J^ R % JT Z NVZ. HIWRG W  HISR G W HSKR JT Z  3 WR  Q?
E
H  IW= X  JT U 1 M
I -QN V(N W" $  MK QE? E
H  GN WK WNZK M"  V(N
7> J ZNVIZH JGWK GN  %NZ QE\ J> R 3 WK I-  JT Z  3 WR GN M"  V(N
I- J^R' JT*^ GN ZN%W >IGT3 RKR VL
Z-K WL
VK  W"$ JTHNI3V
M" I-=H R
Z H^J GK R3%K QRS ^RL. G JTHN3 V
$ WK ILQNGN M"
I-MK J^ R ' JT * ^  VE
H  IW= X  JT U 1 M
I -QN V(N VE
H  GN WK
QI;JVK I-MK M"   I-E-K I-GN 7> J ZNVIZH JGWK GN  %NZ
IVJ> R 3 QIW%N3K JT * ^ M"   I-GN %NZ QHNE Z^ R V A 3SG R^ J K
RNZ A J^ R ' ST M ZAJRZ QH3R ST M Z QNIG M% I-  VJ> R 3
HIWRG W  HSKR JT * ^  GN ZN%W > I GT 3  RKR V ,
Z -K M"   ILG  I-= H
R
Z H^J GN JTHN3 HR
9. ^RL. V(N I-]% MK X]GRZ.8 G JTHN3 V
$ WK
I,QNGN M" 
I- HIWRGW HSKR JT*^  % IVJ>R3 R^J IW=X JTU1 M
H VE
H
IW= X  IWRNLZN% M
H   JT ( Z VE
H  IW= X  M
R  RX%N HKVK
I-= H  3SG WX%  %NE 
E 4 .  GKJ. GK RX%N HKVK IFR 
E 4 .
3SG. V
$ 
E4. J>=VR. GK 7>VJ=VK HKVK I-=H ZN%R
WR GK RX%N HKVK
IL IW= X  Q] I ZT V  *IRQN 
E 4 .  J> = V R. G  %NZ M%/A   H^ R Z# 
IUQN%K#   IWW H #   V L #   IML#   ] V
3 #
  ^ R IV#   QN%] G #   I6ZN#   I%3HNZ# 
LER] U K#   QIX] V #   JT  Z #   IGQNE# 
;" I RN#   
U  ] V NI-%# QR(NV 
U LKV#
IVJ>R3 HIWRGW % QNJ' J>=VR QIX]V %]^ IVE
H GK M
R RX%.
HR% GN *NR $IJQN V(N 3HVK JTGN% HKVK QIX]V % QH3R J>R3

22

I3T 3 1K RX%N

JRSTMZ  GK 3SG V


 7>VJ=VK HKVK V(N IHMN HK ZRK ZGG HR%N
QH3R J>R3 I-3%N% HR% ZN%R
WR 7>aV IUQN 7>a( QN%]G QNI-QN
V(N 
$  IUQN E] S   Z $  V= H  SNMR %MK$ QNI-QN VG QIX] V  GK
JTN(%N 7>aV QH3R J>R3 %]^ %K$G V
$ LUN7>' G E-K HIWRGW HSKR
JTZ3WR  % 7>K ZN%R
WR V
$ H>0 Q]IZTV LE E"H I-=H Q]YN S'NI-QN
V(N 7> Q]Y IW=X I-=H QNVZ. JTW3 HR IG=VK V(N Q]Y %]^ ZN%R
WR
G Q]IZTV LE IW=X 6=IYQN Q]Y GK U9U9NM1 %NE QH3R J>R3 GK
%K$GRN *]U M
-K 7>% Q]Y %]^ HT
; %NE GI\QN IL HNR% HRH Q]Y
G G
 *NU M
 U- 7> IW=X
$ L
VK I%R]L% 6R J>R3  I%=HIEQN L
 Q=U
X= E H  HNE# HMNI-QN I-GN WNVIWH %NZ H" E # M"   7>   WHV
IVJ> R 3 HIWR G W  %  QNHN3WN'K HKVK IH QNJ G
%
4 $  SNMR QN8
V(N QIX]V G GKJ IW=X RM
 QNIUQN JNH QH3R J>R3 V(N 6RJ>R3
H"E  G
%4
$ QIX]V G GKJ IW=X RIM' E=U S=IXQN GK %ENI-HK 7>%4. %]^
MK IG\N-K IH IHV IFR JT*^VN GK V9_ %N S' LNW IH7>$IH ZR=(
IS%. HNRL FE %MK$ M] > G N  IFR J^ R ' ;%K HIWRG W  %  RW RX%N
W" $  HKVK QNJ'K 3SG 3HVK %NE RNL 3 WRK RN31RK  3HVK
7>VJ]% HKVK IL V
$ RW STIMZ]Y %^] (NIJV HKVN I-%]^ JRN3HVK
JRN%] G %K WK HIM] G   M% J^ R ' ST M Z %  RW QNVZNW. %] ^  QNJ'  MK
Q] G R V
$  QNJ'K WX% 3HVK %NE QNJ'  ZN%W RKR > I GT 3  7> V J] %
HKVN JTVH M] QNVZN GN JTZNVZ. L"N RKR RIXQN ILGN VL 

E4.  ^RL. L"N ZN%W >IGT3 MK M" JT]V^ JTZ3WR G RKR G I-=H
R
Z H^ J  GN JT H N3 HR
9 . ^ R L. V
$  WK ILQNGN M"   SM> V  Z $  SNQG
6RJ>R3 L
VK I%R]L%  % 
IXQN IH QK$ IV]%
$ QIX]VAQH3R J>R3A6R
J>R3  I-=H MK GKJ IW=X RIM RM M. V M
R I-=HAI-=H GKJ IW=X RIM
RIM RM
M% Z"$ WK N;%N J^LN  HRH QE=U GKJ JTNJV HR^]UN 7>% Q"N
IWXNR HRH  I-= H  J" R  7> a V  \94 N  M
H    = V R  > = U  VJ HKVN

QN
VZ. HNE G LNE IW=X IHW)$ FKQ.#
QNV
IW33/A LG STMZ L
VK I%R]L%  VJ HR IRMN K V. QK$ *
QNVZNW. L
 Q=L L
VK I%R]L% G I-=HK   STIMZ]Y. IW=X RIM]G M%
I-GK N;%. 7> a V  QN3= H V M
 U-  V(N Q] V RQNVZN V
$  I-%] ^  XNM> '
E=U QNJ' =>\GN-K JT*^ IVJ>R3 V
$ SZ>=\ M
 U- IL HNR% QK$
JVKWRVN JG V
$ IUR U- J^R' JT*^ % WNRAWNR NW;N% HR% 7>aV
WK NYK QN(N 6R J>R3 V
$ %MK$ M1K I-MK JT*NW Q=L WK HNE GK
I3T31KIW=XIWGZN%M"ILW$%$LWN%S=XIFEZ1NR. QI*%VNW.V(NQI*%
VTKQ. GKQ.S%NW1KQGNW.V(NQNJ'R
LUNR7>G3E-KHRRM*^IZHN7>aV
QN=HVM
 L.G M%R
H'7>aV %MK$R>HGLHRH
-KQI*%VNL.QI*%VTK
I%=H1WRVK3IMRIW=XQNLNWV.G\
7>%4.%NGN%S=IXQNGK*K9HWEGR3%
HR%GE-KSM>]I\QNIW=XI-H=VRM
L.GKM")E"'NI-=H%NG'G
#R
LK

IUQN% U] U N

23

R
1K QI*%VN HZN RM M% %LWN% S=X E=>1 RM M% ZNVNAIJVN IH]%N WK
Z0N7>'JRS=X %MK$Z]%GHG %NHG HGK%NHGKE=>HA6>=JH L.G RIM]G
M%
J^R' STMZ HIWRGW HSKR JT*^  % 6R J>R3 V
$ J=>I6QN IH S
E

HK XNM]>G M
 7>% IHMN IH IJVN LK I-M (N% ZR E-K [=1 M" Z"%]^
QE= U  V
$  GKJ JT G N% HR% GK IHT J N HR
  M= H N HSKR IVHSKR  %
7>%]^  I-=HK  STIMZ]Y JTGN% HR
HR IG=V H>0 Z$ 7>JR]V L
VK I%R]L%
% 
IXQN IH I- IW=X H>=0 RX%N HR%K XNMKGK M" \
NEK STIMZ]Y JEN1
\NEK
IH H]Z G I-M IWXNR HRH IFR 7>%  =U
>  V=J HRH J^R' JTZNVZN
HIWRGW HSKR JT*^  V
$ RX%N GK Z=URK GK JTNR(%. HKVK IVJ>R3
% 7>%]^ IV]% U>' V(N J]L V=V JTG N% HR
HR IG=V IL IW= X  ST M Z L
V K
I%R]L%  % QNJ' STIMZ]Y. IW=X H>=0 RX%N HKVK IFR 
IXQN IH I-
IW=X LKW WK M
' XNMKG M% I-H=E GN IGE %MK$ E=UGN I-M IWXNR
HRH  X
$MP  >=U V=H _R VJ HKVN J^R% JTZNVZN HIWRGW G
J>=6' 7>aV G=IQN IH Z"%]^ H>0 QNVZNW. G IG7> ZRN I-=HE GN IG=E
%MK$ E= U  IRMN VG IVJ> R 3 HIWRQIU%K HSKR JT Z  3 WR  %  IHMN
IH ST M Z V R   VJ G  SGE  Z" $  V" % ] ^  M
R  ST I MZ] Y  G  HGN M. JR
QNJ'KQ. QNVZNW. %]^ IHK WK LJAVJ N;%N G _ER^J IW=X %MK$ G
HGN M. LHR H
-K QNVZN W"I-=6N %NE VR %NE LN'N XNM V. 7>M
LN HGN M"   > W N HIWR ZR= (  HSKR  G  WX% > ' H  L
V K I%R] L %
NY  H
E  QNI-QN QK$ * M]   QNVZNW. JIMEN V
$  MK 7>   7> a V
QN3=HV K QK$ 7>%]^ XNR
$ VR_ V
$ [R H \94 M
 U- L
VK I%R]L%
%  IHMN IH Z" $  IJVNLK V
$  QE= U  I-= H K ST I MZ] Y  JT N JV HKV  M% 7> a (
Q% H . JT H NR G  RZ'KH (N% S'N-  M% IH QNJ Z R   %NE X= E
$ U 
QK$ NR M]. % L
 Q=L  STIMZ]Y. IW=X JT3N% M. IHMN IH QK$
IVQNR M. L H R IJVN LK QNIUQN G  G '  VG 6RJ> R 3 J^ R ' ST M Z
ZMN% HIWR ZR=( HSKR JT*^  G H
E IUQN V(N NRK WNRVN HMK
VG HIWRQIU%K HSKR JT Z  3 WR  %  IHMN IH Z R   NMZ'  WKIHT V K
G '  WNE  %] ^  Z" $  QNIUQN G W .UN 6R J> R 3 V(N JRZ QH3R J> R 3
HSKR IZVLN  G
%4
$ QK$ * M] QNVZ.W. G JN QN- IV HIWR
G W  %  IHMN L
 M]   QNVZ. ST M Z G  %NE LN'N XNM] > G K M"  QNJ'N M= (
7>aJR HRH WKIHTVK GW QNJ' IJVN G NMZ' IH GK IM]ZV %N
M
- K IHK %  WKIHT V K %MK$ IG= V K SM> V  Z $  V= H  3%N1N 6NI-QN
IRMN VG IJ=6
$ I-=H M] QNVZN % NM HKVN V(N IHMN IH IJVN LK
Z"$ LN'N XNM]>GN M. IFR V. 7>GK G\NAG\K L
 Q=L HNE STMZ  G
 ST I MZ] Y . IW= X  FKQ. M%  QK$ * QNVZ.W. %  WKIHT V K G
IG=VK JTZ3WR HSKR LK % L
VK I%R]L% %]^ IHMN IH QNJ QNJ' (N%
7>aV LN7> IL%4. % VR %NE LN' GK WKIHTVK IG=VK M" Z"$ 7>%4. RW
M]   QNVZNW. %] ^  QNJG  JN * L  G W .UN L
V K I%R] L % QNJ'  
STIMZ]Y. IW=X XEN IUQN 7> Z$ V=H I-M I-=HK STIMZ]Y IVE
H IW=X

24

I3T 3 1K RX%N

MK %
7> V
$ SNQG J^R' STMZ % * V
$ JIME. WKIHTVK G' WNE M]
%] ^  E9HK GN R^ J  IG= V N JT ] V ^  I-VRK I-] G RK %MK$ RXK V(N RW
QNVZ.W. %] ^  IL%4 .  %  L
V K I%R] L % ST M Z  G  %NE LN'GK WKIHT V K
IG= V K K  7>   E9HK G  RKR IW= X  JT W  3  HR IG= V N V(N 7>  GN %NZ
QN31RN QNIG ZNI-QNJT I HT V K G W K G> R UN  IJQN V(N IVJ> R 3 %
IHMN IH J>=VRK Z"$ V"%]^ 3SG 3HVK JTGN% HR IG=VK M" IL]% LKW STMZ
HM  QNJ 7> V J] %  HR G ' N J^ R ' ST M Z HIWRG W  HSKR NIMS
QNJ' J=>VR IML GN G G>QNRN JTIHTVK %]^ 6RJ>R3 G H
E *L IG=VN
IML GN LK % L
VK I%R]L% %]^ G=IQN IH IJVN LK % I- *"' G
RKR IW=X 7>%4. RW QNVZNW. %^] JTW3 HR IG=VN M" IL%4. % VR %NE
LN'GK IMZVK IWQHV HKVK K V(N I-%]^ WX% 3HVK JTGN% HKVK
M" QNJ IL]% LKW X.M
U JTIHTVK QNJ' 3SG %NE 7>VJ]% HR GWUK
I-M HIMH  IML GN WNJ QNJ'  GKJ IW= X  QN IUQN
LWN% M
' G HNR' E9HK GN R]U R^J I%=?IRQN M
I-QN K STMZ
G Q]GR IW3AWN%N J"GN M
 U-K V(N JTIHTVK G %NE Q*=GR UVKIW;K
QNR]* HKVK VG G>RUN % IHMN HK L
VK I%R]L% ZR JN IJVN LK GK
JTGN% HKVK M
-K 3SG 3HVK M" QNJ IL]% LKW HM
U Z"$ 7>VJ]% HR
GW.UK QNJ Z"(^% JT]JRN 3>R^ %N HR
 QNJ WK 7>K IJVN G 3SG %NE
Q]Y V
$ 7>VJ]% M
- M
 V(N Z"$ WK 7> JRZ IJVN G WX% %NE MK SNQG
IW= X  7> V J] %  M
- K M. QNJ Z R   W= Y   *N-K M
  *" ' A*N-K GN I-M 
U
ZM.JNJ GN HNR% S'UN JT]V^ L
VK I%R]L% % JTIHTVKGWK GK I-=H WK
JT N (%. %MK$ > ' K V(N QNJ'K 3SG HVK %NE %N\^ % N %NE I-VRK
I-]GRK *U  JTIHTVK %]^ EUN IG=VK V(N SENVHNR HR% GK PN%K 7>
Z $  G> R UN %  QNJ'K I-= L V R= I \QN G  E-K H
- K M
R  XNRN %N G \
3^ \ 3Z R^ J  S'NI-QN V(N L
V K I%R] L % G  \> = E  4  Z> = \  G> Q NRN 7>  G  J 1
IW= X  JT W  3  HRH  V(N J^ R ' ST M Z HIWRG W  V
$  QNJ'K R= I \QN E-K
JT N (%. HKVK 7>  K Z $  HIWRG W  QNJ'  J> = V R 
U A] V N% QR(NV

ULKV GN R^J S'N H 7>a( JTU1 M
- V(N H]I%QN %]^ STMZ G 7>GR
IW=X
$ H=I<QN V(N IHMN IH L
VK I%R]L% Q=L V
$ VRN %NZ HNE M
WUN
V R   L%ZAIZT V ^  M] > G   RIM'U   I-E-K V R N %NZ 6RJ> R 3 M
W  U N V(N
I-= H  E= \  ZN%W 3RKR ;NRK JT N 'KQ. %] ^  JT V KIG% \NI-QN HR $ UN V(N
WN E= \  GK 7> V J] %  HIRQN HR $ UN QNJ G
% 4 .  %] ^   ST I MZ] Y . IMV
I%3HNI3V HKVN L.GN M" I-]%N HIM]G MK  STIMZ]Y IWZN% GK VR4.
X=E J- IML GN G GKJ G H
E
$ M]>G M
- VE
H V
$ 
E4.   ]\
H
 I-=H H
 EU*U  IH/ZK/ GN M]>GN M"  GK G^RK 7>aV LNH R>H U-
IW3 3  IWWR' A M> '  V= H  IV] %  3HVKQ. GN IWWR' QNI-QN M" 
+ J^ R ' ST M Z IL%] ^  M
R  7> J ZNVIZH %.WN %NE WK LNI'QN L.GN
M"   ILW $  IVJ> R 3 QHNEJ> R 3 3SGR^ J K RNZ JRZ QH3R
STMZJ>R3 QNIG I-M J^R' STMZ Q]\ STIMZ]Y. GN WNZK M"

IUQN% U] U N

25

26

I3T 3 1K RX%N

V(N WNVW IW=X QIW%N3K M"


 + JRST M Z IL%] ^  QH3R J> R 3 WK IHMN L.GN M"   I-M WNVW
IW= X  QIW%N3K %MK$ M"   I-M = V  ] \  ST I MZ] Y  GN WNZK M" 
 + ST M Z IL%] ^  L
V K I%R] L % HNE H" E  6R J> R 3 V(N ;RZRN-
QNIG %NW. %NE LNI'QN L.GN M"   L
 H W E I-= H K ST I MZ] Y . GN
WNZK
WNZK M"   M> '  Q= U   I-K ST M Z HNE  GK I3T 3 1K G  I-= H
STIMZ]Y GN JTKX" IG=VN LNWUN IL X IV]% M
R %NZ QNJ LK G
J94 %  IW= X  QN7> ' U  /A ST M ZN IW3'^  V(N I3W
STMZ V(N STMZN IW=X *GAI-=H STIMZ]Y IW=X S' RW7>JR (N%
7> a V  ST M Z 6R J> R 3  W" $  IV] %  U> J V (N%. GK RX%N HRH  ST M ZN
IW3'^ V(N I3W R^J IW=X RIM]GN M" V(N QNJ'K JV%K JTIHTVK G>RUN
G  IM
U  %NE IV] %  J> = V R. GK 7> V J= V K HRGN M"   7> % 4 .  G  %NZ WK
STMZN IW3'^ V(N I3W R=\GN M" L
 STMZ GN J>=VR STMZN M" 7>M I-=H
STIMZ]Y IW=X HWE IV]% E
H. IJT(WK E
H WRU E
H V(N JNVNE E
H
IW= X  I-= H  RLU> '  IW*NU GN Z] V T K  WNZK  M"   I-%] ^  IVT E
H K ST M ZN
IHMN M"  V(N ST M Z L
 ST M ZE
H  IW= X  ST M ZN R^ J  IW= X  RIM] G N M"  7>  %^ ]
ZM.ST M ZN V(N ST M ZE
H K-  GN ST M ZN IHMN I-K ST M Z HNE  %] ^
GNI3W ZM.I3W ZM.IW3'^  WK IHMN M" 
3TK IW3'^ J>RN' IW=X JTZN'/A XV>R( Q]3 QI;/ JT3P A
7> a V  3T K  ST M ZN LK %  IHMN/A IL QL] % ZN RWZ IW;NVN JT Z  3 WR
GN QNIG Z= ;  Q] V  WR^ J  > * NQ QV  NR QK$ %MK$ LN' JN7> $ G
E
H  
L
 ZRN R^J ;NR' HR ]NR GK RX%N HRGN M" I(VK G Z$ L

J>R3 R^J M" V(N L


 R>GR R^J %NE IW3W GN UTN HR L.GN M" Q%]V
R^ J  %NE ] J ^ R ' LUV %^ ]  ;NR' HRGN M"   E
H  

3TK STMZN LK 3TK IW3'^ LK V 3TK I3WLK GK 7>VJ=VK#
HNE ST M Z  %  JT I HT V K G> R UN  %] ^  IHMN IH M> '  Z R N H '  HK
IWUN9 U N Z%ZN%K HR.U. JT I HT V K %  IFR JT N (%N HKVK IH QNJ H> 0
3RZ HR
 JT(Z V. QNJ ZR W=Y *N-K M
 IH7>$IH 7>K J^R' JTZNVZN
HIWRGW  GK WX% 3HVK V
$ QNJGK STMZ GK  Q]Y V
$ 7>VJ=VK M
-K
V(N SNQG IW=X ZRK 7>VJ=VK 7>K JTZ3WR G WX% V
$ M
-K M" G^RN
Z"$ QNJG J1 V
$ SNMR I%HEK M. Z"$ QNJGK S1K M
-K QR(NV QNJ
Z R   IJVN M
-    I- JIW= V R %NV  IW= X  IWUN9 HR%N ZM.JNJ M
W  U N
ZR JN IJVN LK GK JTGN% HKVK M
-K 3SG 3HVK M" IL]% JTN'K HM
$U
Z"$ WX% V
$ 7>VJ]% HR GW^]UK L
VK I%R]L% % G>RUN GK I-=H WK IS%"
%MK$ >'K V(N IHMN Z"%]^ L
 ,N IZE'K K IZE U-K Z"%]^ VE
H V
$
I%3HNI3V HR IG=VN M>' Z"$ Z%ZN%K HR.UN I-M HIMH HNE J>R3
6RJ> R 3  %  JT I HT V K %NE LSRGVK 3NGK HKVK V(N IV] %  J> = V R.

IUQN% U] U N

27

RLU> '  > H VAST M ZN LK VU> '  > H VAIW3'^  LK VZU> '  > H VAI3W
3] H R LK  GK 7> V J= V K HKVK LWN% M
'  V= H  IV] %
$  J> = V R. %] ^  G> R UN G
G>QNRN QXV HRWN IG]GN M" IFR LWN% M
' 7>aV 3TK STMZN LK %]^ HZE
G F>=E 7>aV 3TK IW3'^ LK %]^ 33%NU LK GK L 7>aV V(N 3TK I3WLK %]^
H" E N3 JRWV 7> a V  X V  HRH  I-= H P  HR IG] G N M"   VG IJ= 6
$  JT I HT V K
G>RUN  G G>QNRN I-%4. IV]%. GN IWQNM HR IG=VN L.GN M" V(N I-=H
STIMZ]Y IW=X IV]% E
H. WRU E
H IJT(WK E
H V(N JNVNE E
H  IW=X
I-= H AI-= H  IW*NU IW= X  Z] V RK JT * ^  I%> H V HR IG] G N M"   ILW $  3T K
STMZN LK %]^ RL
U>' IW*NU GN V(N 3TK IW3'^ LK %]^ V
U>' IW*NU GN
V(N 3T K  I3WLK %^ ]  VZ
U > '  IW*NU GN V(N QNJ U> J V ZM.ST M ZN A
ZM.IW3'^  A ZM.I3W  R^ J  IW= X  Z> = \  Z] V RK JG %] ^  ] * NEGN M"   I-= H
ST I MZ] Y  IW= X  I-= H  ST M ZE
H  GK RX%N HKVK M"   7>    IW= X  IV] %  U> J V
(N% S'N-  M% I-= H  RL
U > '  JT ; N% (N% M"  IL= (   I-M ST M Z HNE
QNJ ZM.ST M ZN Z> = \ Z] V RK  R^ J  IW= X  RIM] G N M"  V(N QNJ'K JV%K %] ^
ZM.NIWVRK R^J IW=X R=\GN M" I-%4. G
%4. G ]
U %NE L
 J>=VR I-
(N% 7> a V  7> V J] %  M] > G N M"  7> M  QNJ MK RL
U > ' K S' L.GN M"   G^  RN
(N% V
U>' JT;N% S'NI-QN IUQN M" 7>a( 6R J>R3 QNJ ZM.IW3'^
R^ J  IW= X  RIM] G N M"  V(N QNJ'K JV%K G> R UN %] ^  ZM.EH3ZK R^ J  IW= X
R=\H L
 J>=VR 7>VJ]% HRGN M" 7>GN %NZ IW3'^ R=\GN M" I-M SNEH
V
U>'K M>]GN M" V(N VKRN I-K HNE % 7>a( MK I-=H VZ
U>' JT;N% \
VR S'NI-QN M" 7> IW=X 7>M QNJ GNI3W R^J S'NH RIM]GN M" V(N
QNJ'K JV%K G> R UN %] ^  ZM.JNRWVK R^ J  IW= X  R= \ GN M"   I-%4 .  G
M . G
JVKAJV%K IWWMNR %NE L
 J>=VR 7>VJ]% M]>GN M" 7>GN %NZ I3W R=\
IG]G M% V(N VZ
U>' >HV HR IG]G M% JTZN' E-K G\
 JIW=VR 3TK
I3W ZM.J>RN' IW;W3WR R>GR ]IMVN JT3P A IL IW=X STMZN
IW3'^ R>GR V(N ZM3WR V
$ M
R GNI3W M" V(N R>GR ]IMVN Q/ 
V(N   JT 3 1 %] +   V
$  V(N  7> a V  Q%> W NG HRVN 3T K
M%^ ] Z N% JT 3 NG J G NR UKVN JT "   U
R \J> R  V
$  JT H NI3V V(N JIW= V R 3T K
Z= G G W K ZM.J> R N' VKRN H] G  FN %] +  V
$   V= H  UKVN JT " a 
U
R \J> R  V
$  JT H NI3V ILGN Q%> W NG HRVN 3T K  M%^ ] Z N% JT 3 NG J G NR
IXZ% ENE U
WNZK  IFR I-%4. %]^ ;
\ IW=X R=\H QNJ' \N' G E-K
LKW. GK 7>VJ=VK 3TK STMZN LK GQNRN V(N I(VK I-=H G^R %NE Z
M
ZZVN IW= X  R= \ H  HNE LNE IW= X  R= \ 'N  3T K  IW3'^  LK V
$  V(N ] M NR
IH7>$IH HNE J>R3 %]^ 3TNJ HNR% I-=H E=\ ZN%W RKR ;NRK JTN'KQ.
G  3^ \ 3Z RKR IW= X
$  Z" E  H= < H  \N'N M] > G N M"   7>  G  E-K I-= H KW $
STIMZ]Y IW=X I-=H VJVI3EN M" L
 MZ3. URZ RIM]GK M" 7> 7>aV Z%>=\.
%] ^  URZ HRH  Z" E  IJ[ENH  \.GN M"   LKW ZRG  %MK$ JR H31
QIM'K- M]>GN M" IFR JTN'KQ. %]^ HRZ QN;NR 7>aV RKR IG]GN M"
3T K  I3WLK G> Q NRN HRWN7> $ GN M"   ILW $  IH  ZHN% G  IV] %  HZR  S'
M
' I-=H HZR IW=X Q3EKE IX=VR E=U M
' 7> HZR IW=X L.G MK

28

I3T 3 1K RX%N

Z% IW=X ZEK% IWXNR 7>VJ]% M


 L.G M% G^R HZR IW=X N;^Q.A]V.
*UV. G  IX= V R E= U   M
'  V. Z% IW= X  X] U   IWXNR JT * ^  GN IX] V % MK
SI'QN RIM]GN M" VKR HZR IW=X G3 *UV. V 3MKG. G IX=VR E=U
M
' V. Z% IW=X W" MK L
3KE IWXNR 7>VJ]% M
 L.G M% PKH I-
VR4. STMZ HNE  % QNJ'K ^0AS^0 %NE I-M IV]% U>' JT;N% (N%N
GK RX%N HKVK M
- K M" 

IV]%
$ U>' HK M% JTZN' IMV#
IV] %
$  U> '  RLU> '  ST M ZN LK VU> '  IW3'^  LK VZU> '  I3WLK
M% ST M Z HNE  V(N JT I HT V K G> R UN  V
$  7> V J] %  M
-   M% V(N IV] %
$
%N3WN% M%#
JT Z N'/A UKVN JT "   U
R \J> R  V
$  JT H NI3V 3D T K  I3W ZM.J> R N' ILG
]JNGH M% 3TK M%^]ZN% JT3NG JGNR FN %]+ A IW;W3WR ]IMVN
V(N JT3P  Q/  R>GR ]IMVN
MVN I- VR4. STMZNAIW3'^ V(N I3W IV]%
$
GWVNW. X U>' M% JT]V^ I3W STMZAHNE  U>'NVKV IHMN IUQN M"#
G^  RN JT Z N'/AUKVNJT "   U
R \J> R  V
$  JT H NI3V 3T K ZG G W K*NUWV
J>RN' ILG ]JNGH M% 3TK M%]^ZN% JT3NG JGNR IXZ% ENE U
WNZK
VKRN H] G  Q/  JT 3 P /A *UWN% IW3'^  %  G> R UN GK 7>  V> V K
HKVK IHMN IH Z" $  IW3'^  ST M ZN V(N 3] H R QNJGK IHT J N V
$  MK
IWGZN% M. NYN V. QNI*R*NW L%Z  V(N IVR
* NW IZT V ^  M] > G K
M" QK$ QZR QIW%N3K  %MK$ M.  QNJ MK I%=V M
 LUV L%%K
M
  JT I HT V K V(N %NV%K G W K M
  *UWN% 3] H R %  IHMN L  *UWN%
ST M ZN V(N *UWN% IW3'^  QNJG  V
$  7> V J] %  M
-   M% V. 7>  V
$  SNQG
7> V J] %  M
'  WNEN Z" $  VZ
U > ' K EKEN HR% WNEN 3] H R HK QNJGK ] V N%
%MK$ M
I-QN QR(NV Z"%]^ 7>VJ]% HR% WNEK QNJ MK M
 I- ]NR
GK I3T 3 1KAI(VKA] M NR IW= X  QNJG  MK U> '  RWGN M% I-MK IV] %
$
U>'. V
$ 7>VJ]% M
- QK$ STMZNAIW3'^ V 3]HR I%Z Q%>NR HNRL
HR% E-K V= V JR RIM] G   M.
7> J R
H V I-M IWWR% H W E Q%> W NIGV 3T K  G W K ZM.J> R ' IW= X  M" 
IL IW=X H>0 V=(. %]^ 6>JNI-QN IUQN M" I-E-K I-MK JTZN' G\
 3TK
ZGG W K *NUWV ZM.J> R N' *N3I1HZ ZNMNVZ \ Z RNL 3T K  IHT 3 %
GN JTHN3% Z]>S-K I- IW= X  ]  IHT V  IMV IM] G K Q%> W NG HKVN M" 
VKRN H] G  Q/  JT 3 P  E
H  /A
STMZ.AQIMZI-3WTMIFEVJT*NWNVTWIW]LNI%^VN%GNV^I%IVQNM
H Q%] >RNM 3V\ JTZ>=\NM X I%IVQN I%IVQN VWZW L%%K JTIHTVKM
J>RN'N 
J] L NSK Q%> W NG/A M  ZNVNC ST M ZN Z" $  V(N I3W V R   JT * NW V
$  MK
L%ZWN% M. I%=V %MK$ M. QR(NV QK$ QIW%N3K %MK M. IFR G^L
I-]GR QNIG GWVN IH VR4. I%=V M
 HG M% QNJ MK QIW%N3K M


IUQN% U] U N

29

JT I HT V K V(N %NV%K G W K M
 
JT 3 PA QI;QN-   E
H  /A
IG IGNGTZ%. % G]N ISH H(ZM] IWIMVM X VZ
U>'M HZEL3X
RL
U>']*WM >IWIMVM IHZ^ VWU>'
$ MIRM 
Q%> W NG/A *UWN% 3] H R S
E  / AM  ZNVNC L  QNJ NY  7> J = R  QNJ
IGQN > H V M
 V. Z" % ] ^  VZU> '  IH7> $  S'NI-QN HZE V
$  7> V J] %  ST M ZN
%^ ]  RL
U > '  IH E-K S'NI-QN V(N IW3'^  %^ ]  V
U > '  IH7> $  S'NI-QN
QR(NV LKW. G  L%ZAZR' R^ J K G> 3 HRZ IW= X  IH7> $  EUNI-QN
E
H/ARZ
/A
WJIV]J>RI3]GNVWUIV]%IMIWMWGZI3W 
Q%> W NG/A QNJ'  JVK J> R 3 QR(NV HNE *UWN% G  %NE GN
*
U AIWEN3 HRGK RIM] G K M
  QNJGK UVK H
- K %MK$ LN'GN
I%3HT 3 /A 7> J R
H V JT Z N'. V
$  JT Z NI'V M
I -QN IH RLU> ' AST M ZN
VU> ' AIW3'^   V(N VZU> ' AI3W M"  I-M IV] %
$  %N3WN% M% G> R UN GN
JVK ST M Z HNE  M"   I-M 7>   %NE *
U  IWEN HRGN M" 

STMZ HNE  GK QIWQHV RIM' GK JTIV=UQN#


       3^\3Z WG V
$ 33 I3T31K RX%NAAAAAA
IV] %
$  J> = V R. GK 7> V J= V K V
$  IJ= 6
$  ST M Z %  QNJ'K JV%K G> R UN
JTIHTVK  %]^ IHMN IH *IW=\ IW=X Z"$ JTIV=IUQN HRGN M. IH *IW=\ IW=X
Z"$ IH %]^ QNJ' WNVIWH R^J IW=X GR3% %MK$ GW.UN IL HNR%
V
$ Z"$ QIWQHV Z]I%QN L.W.UN G>RUN %]^ IHMN IH QNJ ZRN *G IH
%] ^  %N G ' N Z" $  U> J V RM.U. G> R UN %  J> = I 6QN IH HK QNJ QNJ'
J>=VR. %]^ WK GR3% %MK$ GW
U STMZ % IHMN Z"$ QNJ' J>=VR. %]^ V(N
M
R %]^ IH WK N;%. V
$ GR3% %MK$ GW.UN I-M ZRN Q1E I%Z
M" G>RUN % IHMN IH I-M QNJGN 7>V=Z I%Z %MK$ M" L
 QNJ QNJ'K
]VN% V
$ WK 6>J RM
$U VG HNE % IHMN G>RUN ZRK SW=K M" Z"%^]
I-=H E=\ ZN%W RKR ;NRK JTN'KQ. GN QNMNR HR% GN 3RNJ E=IUQN
M"   L  Z R   J> = V R. ST M ZN IW3'^   I3W  %] ^  JVN E= U  IUQN V. I-M
7>VJ=VK I(VK V(N ]MNR GN HNRL %MK$ HR%UI- E-K I-M ZRN
Q' 7>V=Z I%Z GN RMUN LG
$ I-M IV]%
$ H>0 W=Y M
 LN' V. I-%4.
%]^ QXV HR G'N ZR IW3 IW=X H>0 %N G=K$ %MK$ V. Z"$ V"%]^ WK G]Y
G W .UN G> R UN I- YR G  ZNR  = X N-K %MK$ G=  GK I- E-K UKVN
QI;/  E
H   IW= X  IHMN M"  IH I-M S= > ; KMK' L% Z> G NI- Z R 
Q'7>V=Z I%Z V
$ QNIJTIXV M% IH HGK WK IH G NMZ' JTU1 %MK$
M>]GN QNJ'K 
UZNI-QN %NE 6>IJQN RIM]GN M. I-E-K Z"%]^ QIWQHV
%] ^  Z%= > \  R^ J  IW= X  QNI-QN M
I -QN QR(NV IHT 3 % Z] % G  M%
QS>=;ZM  S>=;KMK' ZZ  ZR Q%>7>VZ  QR(NV [1KQN QWZ
QIW%N3K JRZ*NWZ IW33*NW%]^ QLN%]VR %NLN'GM
- ZNZQWHVZ
Z>0QIWQHV%]^ IWQHVZ Z%>=\R^JIW=X QNJ]%Z QNI-QN Z]%]V Z]%G

30

I3T 3 1K RX%N

M%QR(NVZ"$IHT3%%MK$M]^ UKVNQI;QN- E


H
UKVN QI;QN-  E
H   V(N  IW=X IHMN M" IH I-M Z R N
WNVW HNE R^J M" I-G GR3% QR(NV STMZ JTNJVK %N WG. IW=X
WRI'V IW;K V
$  %N LJ V
$  %N VJ V
$  V(N %N IHK IHIRQN V
$  M

HGK M" 
LG
$ IV]%
$ S=X LWN% M
 U- V. ZNVN *WN%K JTIHTVK Q31]UK  %
IHMN IH QNJ LNH NUR Z](% HR
 JIMEK WNR NUR Z](% HKVN V.
L
V K I%R] L % %  QNJ'  3> W . G> Q NRN XNR W G  7> V J] %  HKV   7> % 4 .  %] ^
U> J VSN'K G> Q NRN QNIUQN IG= V K IH NUR IW=X I%WN HR
 XNR
$ WG
I%HE 7>M STMZN % E- WV^ E"H IV]%
$ S=X ZNVN G JN QN- V. ZNVN
% IHMN IH XNR
$ WG. %]^ STMZN R=\ V J94
%
1/A WNVW IW=X J^R' STMZ % STMZ QR(NV HNE %]^ J]L WG
JTGN% HKV % JT]V^ STMZ % HWE XNR WG. %]^ JTU1 HKVN J]LW. W
G 6>JN IG=VN L
 J^R' JTZNVZN % QNJ JTU1 M
H HIWRIUT*KM QR(NV
HSKR SN'K  G> Q NRN EH
H VKQ. V  G
I MQ. G  ZNI;QZ %NE JT U 1
HKVN
G^  RK WNR NUR Z] ( % HKVN V. IV] %  H] I %Q. IZEKQ. ZNVN %
IV] % . %] ^  W] Y  IG= V N JT I HT V K G> R UN  %  QNJ'  MK M
R  IV] %  R^ J
NIWVRK EH3ZK V(N JNRWVK  ;NR% HKV  V(N Z> ] G R IW= X  6> J N
IG=VKQ. V(N NUR Z](% G Z$ SNMR QN U-KQ. 7>MK JTIHTVK IV]%
R^J M
-K V(N *UWN% STMZN %^] IW=VRK *UWN% IW3'^ %^] E=6ZK$ 3]HR
%^] JNRWVK JV%K R^J IW=X G IG=VKQ. IV]%. % *
U IWEN HKVN >R
V(N Q>R G
%
4$ J"GN M
-
LG VKRK WNR NUR Z] ( % HKVN V. X G 4 .  RV% ST M ZN %] ^  V(N
LG
Q] I ZT V  IW3'^  V(N G W V.W. %] ^   Z= ;  3RNS  Q> R . %] ^  V(N ,IMR
JT Z NR( I3W%  QNJ'  H] P  IW= X  PIMRNI-QN I-M V. SM> V  SNQG GK
U=E M"  LG STMZN WG J94% E=U V. JVN X=IEQN IH H
-K NR STIMZ]Y.
GK RX%N HR% WNEN H>=E GN ZNIEH J>R3 JT*^  M
R M" VG STMZN LK
%  IW3'^  LK %] ^  V(N 3] H R LK %] ^  G= I QN IH W G . IW= X  WR'% M"  IH
IRL%MNR H
-K M
R JT*^ M" JT]V^ WG HIM]G M% IH QK$ WK %MK$ LN'G
 I-G E-K ]HV M" IHK V=VWGR3K ]V V
$ J>=6
 VG STMZN ZNVN G
H
E IUQN V(N * IWRV.V HIM >'NI-QN ZNVN IHMN HRGK K IH
Z R   V
$  QIVIRHV M
R  H
- K %MK$ M"   Z" $  MK HRVN M. Z" $  MK RW
3HVKZN% M. JT ] V ^  ST M ZN %  IHMN IH W G  -K3WR IHRV M% I-M 0^ P
%MK$ M
 HG   G> R UN %  IHMN IH V R N IJVN V" % ] ^  GR3% %MK$ G W  U N
7>% JTIV=IUQN HKVK M
-K M" IFR STMZN % IHMN IH M>' QNJGK U=E
7> a V  QIW3WN3 M
 IUQN M"   Z" $  7>   J> R 3 JT * ^  GN JVN EUN H  MK
RM.UN G>RUN % IHMN IH L 7>%4. % V"%]^ GR3% %MK$ GWUN V. V]^ HK
HR $ UN ST M ZN %  IHMN IH Z" $  QNJ%] ^  3HE %MK$ IG\.W.UN G^ L   JN
L
VK I%R]L% % H3Z \N;K M" IH Z"$ QIWQHV RM.UN IHK %^] GR3%

IUQN% U] U N

31

%MK$ GW.UN QR(NV  STIMZ]Y IW=X Z"$ HG QNJ' WNVIWH HNE R^J
IW= X  QNHNR IW= X  %MK$ QNW.UN
UKVNQI;QN- %]+GNE
H%]+
QWHVZWHVZQNJ]%ZZ%VZZNZQS>=;M
JRZ *NWZ QLN%]VR ZZ QWZ Q%7>VZZ@@
Q%>WNG/A QS>=;ZM  S>=;KMK% E
H ZZ  ZR Q%>7>VZ  QN3T31
QWZ  Q1=E JRZ  JRZ *NWZ  *NW %]^ QLN%]VM  %N LN'G M
-
QWHVZ  QIGT3ZN% ZNZ  Z>0 HNE %^] IWQHVZ  QNHNR IW=X IHT3%
QWVNR QNJ]%Z JTNJVM
I-QN Z%]V Z]%G M%
UKVNQI;QN- %]+GNE
H%]+
%QMZJTHN3MRW
UZNNZQNWTVM
Z^9MQZ%QI*LN%NIVE
HMZNZQLZQWZ@
Q%>WNG/A QMZ  Z"$ 
UZNI-QN ZNWRZM  
UZNN %NE I6IJQN
M
I-QN TW *G JTHN3M JTV=\ % %MK$M>]GNQR(NVQIGT3QR(NV
QIWQHVRIM]GNM.I-E-K QLZ L%Z%E"' WNE QIWZ QIW%N3K
Q1E*NW%]^ QZ I-M Z^9M QIUQN%K E
HM E
HL%Z>GN-]NR ZNZ
Z"%]^ %  %MK$ QI*LN%NIV  LN'GN QR(NV Z"%^] QWVNR R^J IW=X QNI-QN
M
I-QNZ0GNM"IH7>$IHSTMZQNJ'K3SG3HVK%NEQNJ' %N%NR^J
S'NE"$GNM"I-MG>RUNGNJVKM"I-E-KI-Z]VRIW=XIHMNM"IHZ"$
3TKIHT3%QNIGGKVR4.G>RUNV
$L%Z%MK$E"$GN

)STMZN GN QNJ' IJVN STMZ GK JTNJVK E-K V%


VG G>RUN % STMZN LK %]^ IHMN IH QE? I%R]L% QNJGN IJVN M"
JT]V^ 7>M QNJ%]^ GR3% %MK$ GWUN STMZN % IHMN IH Z"$ GR3% HRH
MK QNW.UN ZNVN % J>=I6QN IH L V"%]^ GR3% %MK$ M
- V. HK HR$UN
STMZN % IHMN IH Z"$ JTIV=IUQN HRGN M. L IJVN G GR3% %N M
-
V. Z"$ QNJG NMZ' %MK$ QNW.UN I-M HIMH STMZN LK IWQNH>E M

IH 7>aVR IG3N W=E X=E IJQN IL=( M%4RN MK M%4RN K 7>a( STMZN %
XNR = > U  V= H  I;QN% EUNI-QN JR H> 0  JT N JV %MK M
I -QN HNE %
QNHN3SN'K HKVK IH G> R UN I3T 3 1K RX%N IH7> $  %MK$ HKVK *WN%K %
IHMN IH QNJ GN ,PN J=>VR STMZN IL=G HRH QNJGK VEN3 IW=X IUQN
M" STMZ HNE  % IHMN 7>%]^ WNJ S>EN E7> Z"$ 7>%]^ GR3% %MK$
GW.UN STMZN G IS%. LKW 7>VJ=VK GN HNRL * HNRL Q]*W M%
IFR G> R UN JT I HT V K  %  QNJ'K 3SG3HVK %NE UNI-VRK %NZ GK
E9HK 7> V J] %  HKVK V(N 7>  %] ^  ST M ZN %] ^  WNJ IEQN7> '  %] ^  IHMN
UNI-VTK STMZN LK G H
E U-K JR STMZN LK ZN;K EUN- M
- K 7>%4.
%] ^  H> 0  Q*N MK %MK$ K IH H
- K QNI-QN M"   VG QNIG H> Z NRK
JT I HT V K  %  UNI-VRK %] ^  I;QN% G> Q NRN G= I QN IH I-G  XR%
3JR3 HR VG UNI-VRK %  QILMN MK HKVN ST M ZN LK GN I;QN%

32

I3T 3 1K RX%N

*]U M
I-QN V. U>= %NE S
E IH H' JNJ' M" IL% ZRN I;QN% *]U
HKVN M"   Z" $  V" % ] ^  3RNJ G W .UN UNI-VRK %  IHMN IH Z R N G
3  %MK$
M"  JIME. Z R K U= E  > '
 IFR 3RNJ G ' N Z" % ] ^  ZNVN LK %  QNJ%] ^
WNJ IEQN7> '  E-K IHMN M"  IH7> $ IH QNJG  IS%. LKW 7> V J= V K %MK$
M
 HGK ST M ZN %  IHMN Z" $  IHW $  LNW. IJVN LK G  GR3% %MK
%MK$$
M
-    I- VR4 .  LNW.UN V. Z R N Z,NH M
W  U N L  QNJ ZNVN LK G
NMZ'  I-M HIM IG7>  IH ST M ZN %  IJVN L
V K I%R] L %  G  GR3%
HKV M% Z"$ QNJ'K Q=\. %NE GI\QN M" V. Z"$ QNJG %NE
X= E .UN VG UNI-VRK %  IHMN L  QNJ Z R   %NE ] *
U  " H   HR
U 
V. Z" $  0^ P K UWNMK *R.UK VG ST M ZN %  
I XQN IH IJVN G  GR3%
%MK
%MK$$  M
-    I- VR4 .  LNW.UN V. ZNVN JN L.G  Z" % ] ^  3RZ QNW U K
M
R  H
- K XNRN %MK$ IG\N-K IG= V N IFR UNI-VRK %NE RVK IHIRQN
] *
U  HKVK
VG UNI-VRK %  IHMN IH IH7> $  %N I-= H  UWNM M
R  IVQNR HKVN
LNW   ST M ZN %  IHMN IH SM> V  MK X] U N M"   IFR UNI-VRK %  3SG
3HVK %NE I-=H E9HK J
MJWVK %NZ GK  J"GN HKVK V(N 7>%]^ G
%4.
% IHMN IH QNJ UWNMK G'N IH STMZN LK % IJVN G GR3% HKV M%
VG J
MJWVK % IHMN IH Z"$ 0^PK UWNMK IH7>$ GW. M. L STMZN LK
ZR %NE RVK IHT Q N ] *
U  HR V. Z"$ UWNMK G HGK M. UNI-VRK
%  ST M ZN %] ^  Z0NI-QN 7> H NI-QN  IH M
R  H
- K RNVN %MK$ M"  VG
ST M ZN %  J
M JWVK %NE ] *
U  HKVN V  IV] %
$  IZEH  QNIG ZNI-QN
JTIHTVK  G JN QN- G
%4
$ GWKQ. % 7>JR
HV 3RV I-E-K R=\K K
IH7> $ IH L  ST M ZN ZNVN G  NMZ'  NYK 0^ P K UWNMK %] ^  G=   G W  U N V.
ZNVN N%]^ 3RNJ G GWUK I-E-K 7>%]^ WK G
3K S'N IEQN
 I-=( ZMNRNLURKSGNLKHIM]G M%IHAGNURKSMX^H;^R
$;^R#

ZNVN G>RUN  G>QNRN STMZN %]^ 3RNJ G'N#


VG ZNVN % STMZN V
$ J>=I6QN IH V"%]^ QNJ' IJVN G GR3% M
-
STMZN % IHMN M. Z"%^] IJVN G GR3% M
- M% G>RUN % IHMN 3NH3K
G= VG STMZN % IHMN IH I-%4. G
%4. G NMZ' 3N\3NVHNR M
I-QN
M" GWK % 7>%4. G
%4. E9HKQ. V
$ J>=I6QN IH QNJG NMZ' STMZ GN
3NH3NVHNR M
I -QN M"  VG G
% 4 .  %  IHMN IH M. QK$ QNJ'K Q= \ .
%NE GI\QN M" IFR *WN%K JTIHTVK  %]^ 3=H M
I-QN IH Z"%]^ STMZ %
IHMN K IH Z" $  IH  %] ^  GR3% %MK$ G W .UN JT ] V ^  I-M HIM] G   M% IH
GR3% M
-   M% IFR Q31] U K %  I;QN% EUNI-QN V(N HNE L
V K
I%R]L%  V
$ J>=I6QN HK HMN'K M" L
VK I%R]L% % IHMN IH I-M IV]%
$
0^ P  S
E  RM  M% IFR ZNVN %  IHMN IH QNJ 0^ P  S
E  RM  M

QNHN3WN'K M
-K M" IH I-%4. %]^ H
-K GR3% %MK$ M
- I-M U=E >'H
STMZN % IHMN IH ZNVN LK Z"$ M>] \NH IJVN GK VEN3 HR% IUQN K

IUQN% U] U N

33

JR IJVN STMZ  G GR3% M


- %MK$ Z"%]^ QNJG NMZ' QN7>$G 3RZ
QN RMK K I-E-K QK$ 0^P S
E IG=VN VG ZNVN G>RUN  % IHMN IH
M>' Z"$ QNJ%]^ 3RNJ IG]GK M.
ST M ZN %] ^  3RNJ
/A V R K J^ L N = U  IW= X  %MK$ M
W  U K Q= U   V R   W] 3 ,
3RNJ/A
M
'U 7>M SM>V J\]Y HR%U 0^PK U=E. S'NH =U %]^ P=U'U 7>J=R
V
$  V. HT Z  H.Y HRG  IG\'U  Q] G R
$  IWHNR HR%U   H(N J> R N'. %] ^
J94 H   > ' NI-QN HR%U   QNJ %] ^  IUQN% %MK$ M
W  U N IH GUT ] ( . IW=X
QEKQV HK M" IFR WK ZN% W=3 V(N ;% JTNJVK E-K U>R^ S'H QNJ'
XIEQ. %]^ E
HWG 3N3VR IWR=>; G]V H(N  >'NI-QN HR%U GWKAGWV
GK J^LN HRH V(N HRWNH G^IRQ. GK I%]GN HRH H31 7>PN7>'U
L
 7>%4. G Q%>QN-K M
'U 7>%4. %]^ JRZNR( %MK$ G='U GIH3'. E-K
LUV %] ^  U> ] Z RNM HRG  RIM'U   QNJ'  QNJ%] ^  * V
$  X] U N Z] % 'U 
G^IRQ. %]^ %KXN Z0'U LG ZNVN G Z>\ V
$ I-M >I'QN V. STMZN
Z^RI3V M
H ,ZK% 7>aV IY=U IJQN SM>V Z$ SNQG M
3 IW=X QNI-QN
UNI-VRK %]^ 3RNJ
/A VR H-K .Y JVK M
'U V^]> IZTVE
H IW=X U. S'UK
3RNJ/A
J
4JWVK %]^ 3RNJ
/AVRK LU4N U]GUK IW=X M
WUK VR F>=E. %]^ H
-K J^LN
3RNJ/AV
IW=X %MK$ EN-UN I- 0^PK UWNMK HNR% V"%]^ I-M %RH *
U'N JWUN
VRN %NZ HW9N HVHK M
WUN MIRQN'N IW=X H>$;K HIM]G M% I-M
U]GUK H>R9KQ.  WNEK LU4N 7>aV M]>GK M"
I- VR4 .  IV] % . %] ^  3RNJ G H   ZNVN *WN%K SM> V  J6VN-K I-
JTHNR JIMEN V. LKW IS%4. 
X Z% HNE I%R]L%  G JT*NW V
$ UEV
HNRL HR IG]GN M" JT]V^ LG QNVZN IVJ>R3 Q]3  G JT*NW V
$ 7>%]^
IUQN% M]>GN M" V. SNQG IW=X J6VN7>'N J"$GN M" ILVR4. ZNVNAIJVN
QNJ' S=X %]^ 6
1K ILMK UEVK G HNR% I09HG M% U>= IW=X  JT]V^
SNQG IW= X  J6VN7> $ G  M% I-MK IHT Q N Z% HNE I%R] L %  G  JT * NW
%NE RW LKW. IW=X IHTQNWN% M
 RMK M"  M. I-( I-=H U=E IW33
M" IH I%R]L% HNE STMZ  % WK QNJ'N HN%]^% S'N R=I\QN M" L H
-K
LKW IH G>RSE LKW %]^ VNWUN V. 7>D%^] 7>GN SGEN G'N JWUN
LG QNIG *WN%K JTIHTVK Q31]UK  % STMZN UNI-VRK V(N J
MJWVK
%] ^  3RNJ IG= V N V. QE\ I%R] L % ST M ZAHNE  %  IHMN IH M  *WN%K
JT I HT V KQ31] U K  I-M QNJ%  X] U N %MK$ HKVN M> '  Z" $  I%R] L %
QNJ%] ^  3RNJ IG] G N M. IH G> Q NJR > = U  IW= X  V R   J] L  JVK M
' U 
GR
JGK MK QNIG ZNI-QN GN QWVNR M
-K M"  LG I-M QNHN3SN'K
>'K V. QNIG ZNI-QN % IHMN IH M L
VK I%R]L% HNE  Z"$ VR W=
J-K M. V^] L
 XNM 
 HR E"

IW3'^
IW3'^ GN QNJ' IJVN STMZ GK JTNJVK G E-K JT(N%
V  ZNVN GN QN3KRWNG JN7> ' N#
I-V
$ SNQG IW3'^ %]^ JTIHTVK % IHMN IH J>=VR V^] WK QNJ' IJVN

34

I3T 3 1K RX%N

GN JVN EUN E" VG IW3'^ QNJ' IJVN LK HNE STMZ  GN JVN HRG
A JNVNE E
H IW=X XE U- IL=( 33%NU K 7>% IW3'^ %]^ QNJ'K
KZN IW= X  JT W  3  M> ] G   G \ H  HT
I ;V M
H   ,IMR *IRQN F> ] H NRN ZNIRQN
7>G LIMR G JT*NW %NE IW3'^ LK GN R]U .WEN M
IUQN ILW$ JT
J$1 M
 L.GN M" VG IW3'^ % XNIMQN IH I- %NU %]^ Z,N X\N7>'N
XNMKGN M"   VG L
V K I%R] L % HNE  %  G I \QN IH M> '  IW3'^  %] ^  3.V
HR%N XNMKGN M" VG QNHN3SN'K M
-K IH IW3'^ M>' V^] QNJ'K ZNVN
LK G H
E LN V =XA=X NRN IWWR% G= G'N V L
 H31 QNJ%^] 3
3%NU V
$  M
I -QN M"   I-GN JT V K3
;  G> Q NJR = > U  IW= X  E" ' N G> Q NJR
=>U IW=X QNJ IW3'^  V. IHT3% QWVNR ;NR' HR
U V(N HNEKG4 IW=X
HNEI-]GRK %NZH %NU 33%NU GN QWVNR M
WUN
7^XM
-KH %KXVNW"VNHRQ
-E SGEN Z
MK
$JNW"@
L
 LKWG-KJKRJ>%KHM>MZJ>%KQ
-EIGWNW$VNM]^ @
VG IW3'^ LK ZNVN LK G H
E QN- V(N =XA HIM IG=VN IH Z"%]^
IJVN G GR3% %MK$ M
- I-M U=E %NE ZNVN JTIHTVK  SM>V JT3]% M
-K
V(N IHMN IH J>=VR V^] VWNGK M" M>' Z"$ QNJ'K 3HVK %NE VR IJVN
%NE IZEWN7>$GK M. V(N VR Z% GN 3] 3   \VZ HRGK M.
HSKR G\ J>=VR V
IM IJVN *K1N7>$ VR Z% HN ;
\N IZ1N7>$
Z% WR^ J  HT V N HIM LN%
$  Z% V  G^ L N Q R  %N ZN%

WRU JNVNE G R  Z% H R N Z% Q(KR Z% QM"   Q% R N
I%R] H NR Z% MK H
 HIM-   Z% HK QN I%3 IG% RMK- 
G\ M^] JEI1 >% ZM L
VK LM. JR I0EIZE 0NER M
VK @
I- VR4. ZNVN Q31]UK JTIHTVK  % IW3'^ %]^ IHMN IH Z% MK LU
GN HRVN I-MK L
V K I%R] L % M"   I;QN% IW= X  L
 I-= H  M,NR L
V KQ.
%,R QN7$GKQ. M% I-MK 7>  GN R^ J  M"   L
 3] \  [] 1 N QNIG GKQ.
WN,N >I'QN I-M ZM.WRU IW=X I%R]L% GN MK W=L RMKQ. M% VG
ZNVN Q31]UK G>RUN  % IHMN IH M J>=VR V^] NR GW. GN RVNL M

V(N V R K MR HNZ%N V(N HNRL Z" $  J^ R   HR.UK V R K J^ L N RW = U


IW=X M
WUK QNJ% Z"%]^ =XA=X G=IQN M" HNE G I-=HK STIMZ]Y. G
JT N 'KQ. GK IW3 3  QNGV M"  IH QNJ'K IWQR( ZIMZN S'N7> $ GN M" 
ILW$ G>RUN LK 3TK IW3'^ LK %]^ HIM RMK M" IH VRK J^LN =U IW=X M
W
UK Z"$ V"%]^ VR IJVN G GR3% HRWN IG=V G>RUN % HWE JTHN3 IG\N
H IW3'^ %]^ SIMHN IG=VN 3TK IW3'^ LK *K JT*^ GK I-MK I(VK QNJ'
XIEQ. %]^ Z0N' E=U IH JTZNVZN GK HWE JTHN3 IG\N-K IG]GK M"
JT Z NVZN I%RNHNR M"   I-G  SNQG QNIG *WN%K R> G R ZM 3  LK  G
H
E U-K V(N IHMN IH ZM3 V^] WK HR E" QNJ' IJVN GK \
L VR G
%4
$
*N-KQ. %]^ V. QNJG IJVN G GR3% %MK$ M
- 7>%4. %^] L
 G'N K 7>M
JTGN% HR IG=VN M" M>' QNJ Z]U
 L
 Z]U'N M" VG ZM3 % IHMN IH M
L%%KCZ R   G
% 4
$  W= Y   *N-KQ. %] ^  IJVN G  GR3% %MK$ M
-   IFR V%
HR%N IWQR( M"   IHT J N HRH  Z" % ] ^  QILMN WR IG7>  IH Z" $  QZR

IUQN% U] U N

35

IZTV^]L  M
 L.WN VG ZNVN % IHMN IH I-M Z"$ %MK$ HR HGK M.
>HVK G= HGK M. IL %NE VRK 7>ZR * V
$ E]SK M
 LNWUK IW;K

U ZN;K M"  I-E-K ZM.G W  LK I,QNGNVR ZN;K IW= X  MK RIM] G 
M%  I-VR4 .  ZNVN Q31] U K JT I HT V K  %  IV] %   J> = V R. %] ^  IW*NU W] Y
IG= V  
*UWN% STMZNLK %]^ HNE E
H G E=\ XRNK G XE RKR  RX%
S'N7> '   GN QR(NV RL
U > '  JT * NIWV HRH  ] V N% 7> V J= V K G  E-K S
W= 3  HRH  LKW 7> V J] %  HRN7> '  GN IW*NU JT G N% HKVN
*UWN% IW3'^  LK %] ^  I-%4 .  LKW. G  JNE' J
3 ' HRZ Q%>  NR
HR%   V(N Z
M AZZVN 7> V J] %  HRH  I(VK S'N-K R= \ ' GN IW*NU
IG= V N
*UWN% I3W 3] H R ZM.G W  %] ^  ] M NR HR% GN IW*NU JT G N%
HKVN IH7> $ IH I-%4 .  G  IJVN I%R] L % %] ^  I-= H  E= \  ZN%W RKR ;NRK
JT N 'K JT V KIG% \N'  J" $ G  M%
I-=( Z% IW=X I-=H JT3% 7>VJ]% M>]GN M
WUN IH STMZN IW3']^ V(N
3]HR LK V
$ 7>VJVK I(VK V(N ]MNR IHW$ M]>GN M" I-M IV]%
$ QNJ'
A E
H  IW= X  RIM] G   M% ILW $  Q= L H= E  ] X NR JT ' NEK %] ^  XEN7> '  E-K
7> J UT I M %] ^  7> J = R  QZN% IW= X  6= I YQN L.GN M"  V(N 7> M  %KX  IJT ( WK
7>aV ]XNR JT'NEK %]^ XEN7>$G M% PKH I- VR4. I-M IV]%
$ GW IL=(
WK RIM]G M% I-%4. G RKR V
$ I%HE' WNE ^\3Z U>'. GKQ. VR]U.
IV]% E
H. IW=X QNJ' QNJMK MR JTN'K 7>aV JT*NW JN-K R=\GKQ. M%
7>JR
HV IWWR' I-=H STIMZ]Y IW=X STMZ HNE  GK RX%N GN M"
Q"   A Q"    6R J> R 3 HNE  G  I-= H K ST I MZ] Y  M%
JT]V^ 6R J>R3 HNE  QNJ QNJ' WNVIWH RKRH R^J IW=X IH
G NMZ' %MK$ QN7>$GN 7>%]^ JTNJV HR% E-K IV]%
$ GW. STMZN LK
IW3'^  LK V(N I3W LK  %] ^  W G . IW= X  WRI'V IW;K Q%>  NR HR9K
N;%N HRH WK STMZ HNE  G GR3% %MK$ M
-  SNQG IW=X IR3KQN
% WK WG. %]^ JI94QN 7> IW=X IE=I\QN M" IH QU%M V%^R QI#
JIW= V R L> R W G  Q+  Z] V R   JT Z  3 WR IMRKR M"  V(N JIW= V R
L> R W G  G  Q/ Z] V R  IW= X  IEI\QN M"  IH QU% M  V%> R  QI
IW3'W VWN 
Z V%>R QI# I- Z]VR IW=X G
 WNR WG UWNMK
G RM M% IH RWIWQNJH RWJNE% HRVN IVJ>R3 IMRKR M"
JIW=VR L>R WG QI;/  Z]VT  IW=X IHMN M" IH HIWR Z%K3K  IL
JT Z  3 WR GK RW JT N 'KQ. %] ^  XNM M"   7> M  HIWR QR(NV HSKR M" 
7>  GN RKR IS%. %N9K Q%NIWRZ  GN M"   3> H RZ  WKR, V
$  S'K
J]L V=V V
$ S'K *IVH QHNI-Z  HNI-QN RIMV
RIMV M" 7>M * GN ZNIEH
RW7>VZ
=  VE
H IW=X IWRNLZN% M" 7> JTZ3
 WR GN V,J>L
]  GN WRL
VK
W" $  JT H NI3V RKR M"  V(N L
 3SG R^ J  QR(NV QIW%N3K M"   7> M K
HIWRG W  HSKR JT Z  3 WR
WR  M"  L
 RW ST I MZ] Y . GK RX%N HR% WNEN
WG;NVN  RW ST I MZ] Y . GN RX%MNR W" $ *^ M  W" $  JT U 1 M
'  WNEN

36

I3T 3 1K RX%N

(N V( QR(NV  WNVW IW= X  3N3WV  QIW%N3K M"  UKVN


QI;/ E
H  IW=X WK JTZN' M"  *NWQR( M" IH J^R' STMZ GN
RKR GN %NZ HSKR HIWRGW  M" 7> JTZ3WR GN RKR %^R V=VW
V
$  SI'QN M"   JT Z NVZN GN RKR QIV 3^ \ 3Z M"  L
 7>   N;H %] ^
IG\N-K IG]GN M" ILGK IG* IGT31K \>=E4 X>=HK M" I- VR4. LKW GN
WK 3^\3Z RKR M" ILG 7>J=R I-M J]L V=VW GN \
E4 HWR  QR(NV
J]L V=VW GK HNI-QN X94K M]>GK M" L
 ZNVNAIJVN G ]
U %NE 3>HRZ
WKR, V
$  S'K M"   RKR IVQNU' G  IJ= 6
$  WK LKW GN 3^ \ 3Z RKR
%NE RIM]GN M" 7>M RKR 7>K N;H %]^ IG\GN M" ILGK IGW IGT31K
\>=E4 X=>HK M" I- VR4. JTZNVZN V(N LKW GK I(VK %]^ Z0
 WG. IW=X
8Z %NZ G IZR% GN JTZN' M" L
 HWE STMZ N;%. M" I- 7>G3
%NE 8Z %NZ G LNJ %]^ J^R' STMZ GN Z]% H IR3KQ. % WK M,NR. NE
MP
U  ZN;K ENH  HRH  JT * ^  JT N JVK GK H
I 3 HKVK JR JT * ^  G
GR3% %MK$ M
- I=;KQ. JTNJV M
 U-KQ. 7>%4. I=;KQ. R^JK I\E4'
%NE \E4H IR3K WK L%ZAZR% G X=HR IW=X MK RIM U- V(N QNJ'
Q%>*W %NE 3NVR IW=X JTZNVZN %]^ I%RNHNR IE=\ IG=VN STMZ HNE
% HZ \N-K M" IH Z"$ QNJ' WNVW R^J IW=X IHK %]^ GR3% %MK$ G
W.UN Z" % ] ^  QIWQHV Z] I %QN HR%U  QIWQHV GN *NWQR( M"  IH
H
-K QNHNR IW=X M" JT]V^ QIWQHKUV R^J %NE (^E R^J IW=X GR3%
%MK$ IG] G N ILW $  QNHN3 IW= X  S= G E 6NQ LN' 7> a V  ^ R L QIGT 3  M

L.GN M" 7>M IGT3ZN% %MK$ M" JT]V^ WNVW IW=X S=GE. G JNR IL7>$ GN
IV7>$ M" I- QW(N %]^ QIWQHV HIM]G M%  JTZN' G E-K UKVN
Q/ E
H  A Q/ E
H   V   G \

JIW= V R UKVN LK S
E ' WNEN ST M Z HNE  3T K  IHT 3 % LK G  RKR
IW=X JTVW=3 JTW3 HRH IHMN M" IH M QRL>% Z"$ WI;QN M
I-QN HNE
M. QV RW %]^ \N' G E-K QNI-QN M. UKVN QI;/ GN E
H %]+
  I-M Z R N WNVIWH R^ J  M"   I-%] ^  V R   V
$  I-ENWN %N V. H
- K
JIME. G \  IHQN V(N %N MK H
- K G \  HGN M"  QR(NV W G . IW= X
WRI'V =UAL=JAV=J V(N 8Z %NZ QNIG GK IW;K %NE ZR WNVIWH
R^ J  G  GR3% %MK$ M
 HG   UKVN QI;/ E
H  %] +   Z" $  IHT D 3 %
%MK$ M. I-M Z^ R \ E
H  IHT 3 % R^ J  IW= X  Z" % ] ^  QIWQHV %] ^  IWQHV
Z%=>\ R^J  Z]% RM M% IH7>$IH I-M ZR [1KQN I%Z V
$ QJTKIXV
M% IH Z" $  HG  WNVIWH I- HNE R^ J  IW= X  * G  NMZ'  %MK$
QN7> $ GN QNJ'K 
U  ZNI-QN %NE 6> I JQN RIM] G N M. UKVN Q/
E
H  %] + A  IWXNR HR
/ A QNJ'  6> J   RIM' WNE  IW;N% %] ^  W" $
Q3T  3 1 Q'7> V Z  IH7> $  HIM IRMN M" 
L IJVN QNJ'K ]VN% %]^ WK GR3% %MK$ IG]GN V. 7> IW=X H
-K
HZK M"  IL HNR% E> = I HQN M"  V(N > I W;NW. WK HR IRMN M"   HNE
ST M Z  %] ^  3RNJ G  HNR% I-= H  E= \  Z%= > \ K RKR ;NRK JT N 'KQ. GN
QNMNR HR%N J"$GN M" V  JTIV3V JTIVIG% L
 I,QNGN 7>VJ]% M>]G M%

IUQN% U] U N

37

38

I3T 3 1K RX%N

IUQN% U] U N

39

V(N 7>%4. %]^ IPHN' EUN7>' E-K V(N HRZ *


U GN G]Y G' E-K XRNK
E=\ L^%KQ. GK RX%N HKVK M
-K M" LHR * G NMZ' S"PH IH GK
S 1 K IH  GK JV%K IH  GN J= > V R ZNVNAIJVN %] ^  \NW  V. RW %] ^
ST M Z V
$  I[T ' N M
 LNW  V(N LG WK HG  J^ R ' JT Z NVZN HIWRQIU%
HSKR JT Z  3 WR  W" $  QN-  L. QNJ'N H
- K QNJ'N ] G  3 WNMH G^ V
* L ' V. NR  JT N 'K IV*UVK HRH  HNE G  LNE V
$  I%HE LN'
I-E-K I-M ;
\N GH R=\GN M" V(N JIW=VR UKVN Q/ E
H 
IW= X  QNJ'K N;%. %NE M
'  WNEK Z> H VK UVK  %] ^  WK Q%7> V ZNZ
QIV Q3T31 IHMN M" V(N QNJ' IW;N% I%Z  %]^ WK Q%>VZ  Q3T
31 IHMN M" 
MR H  ST I MZ] Y  IW= X  S'  ST M ZE
H  IW= X  I-= H  ZM.WRU S'NI-QN
M"   ZM.WRU IW= X  I-= H  (N% 7> a V  %HEK VE
H A%HEK QE\
E
HA%HEK QUZ E
H V(N %HEK Q%NZK E
H GK RX%N JTN'KQ. %]^ ;
\N
G '  E-K JT I HT V K G> R UNQNIG ZNI-QN  V
$  HRWN R= \ K M"   HSKR
NIMS GN I-= H  3SG M"  HR %" '
$  GKGNR ZIME Z $  IJQNRN M"  IW= X
SN'K M"  IH HNI-QN * G  IHQN I%RWNRN M * RX%N IJ] Y  Z] 0 NRN
M" ZNI-QN QIWUV LNE JNRN 
 HNRKUR *NRN M" QNIG ZNI-QN
IH%4K$ XV>RN-K 0^PK SNLK IJ]Y IG\N-K QIWUV RX%N RXK Q]Y ZNIM
WNHN JT I VIS] S  YNRN M" 
I-=H STIMZ]Y IW=X M

R E
H. GK WK RX%N M" ILW$ IH STMZN LK GN
E
H 3TK IW3'^ LK GN E
H 3TK I3W LK GN E
H IL=( S"PH IV]%
$ JT*^ %KX
G IV]% E
H WRU E
H QR(NV I-]GR GN E
HAIJT(WK E
H V(N JNVNE
E

H  7> a V  I-= H AI-= H  IW*NU G  ZNIEH S'H  JT * ^ V N HRG  M% V(N
QNJ' IJVN HNE G \N' G E-K JTN'KQ. GK 7>VJVK I(VK V(N ]MNR
GN HNRL*NU ] * NEG  M% IV] % . JT * ^ Q . GK L%Z V(N IZT V ^  M] > G K M" 
VG HNE I-%4. %]^ WK \.GN M" I- STIMZ]Y I-%]
I-%]^ Q]Y WK HIM]G M%
IH7> $ IH ST I MZ] Y  GK S%NW1 Q] Y NHNR M"   I-%] ^  IJ] Y  WK HIM] G   M%
IH7>$IH RKR IJ]Y  IW=X I-=H STIMZ]Y GK RX%N HZE. IW=X 1K/WK/ GK
VR4. G\K L.GK M"  IW=X I-=H ZN%R
WR V(N ;RZRNL I%Q.-;K3  GN
WK E
H  M"  V(N I-= H  U> J V (N% 7> a V  J^ R ' JT Z NVNZN M
R  R^ J  ;NR%
HRH RIM]GN M" ILW$ MRH G3 GN RNLG^V *W% M]>GN M" 7> LU4N H
-K
%MK$ LN HGN 7>a( 7>M QNVZ.W. RIM]GKQ. M% IL%4. GK VE

H GK
*UVK Q;^RK RIM]GK M" LG *UVK >=U QN7$>GN M" V. 7> Z$ I-%4.
J>]% QNVZ.W. %]^ IJT(WK 7>aV ZN%W RKR JTNJV M>]GN M" V(N I-M LEG
MK IV*UVK W=E E=U L.G M% V(N J^R' Z
H3 JTNJV HR L.G M%
7> (N% 7>aV RIM' WNE M] QNVNZ.W. GK I%=LK *UVK HZN-K \RX
%MK$ M] > G K JT Z NVZN G  *] Y NR V
$  RW > I W;NW. JT N JV M] > G KQ. M%
ST M Z HNE  G  7> J NH. GK *UVK HZN-K WRUA%RH IW= X  MK
ZNJV M
 L.GK M" IH7>$IH I- HNE E
H STMZ E
H  QV JRSTMZ E
H
IW= X  JT N 'KQ. %] ^  QNJ'N HKVN M
I -QN MK HRZ_E IZEGN M" 

40

I3T 3 1K RX%N

6R J>R3 STMZ  % QNJ'  STIMZ]Y. %]^ XNR ZM.STIMZ]Y. IW=X
IW*NILV HKVN M
I-QN M" I-=H ZM.STIMZ]Y IW=X J]L STIMZ]Y. GN Z^M
S'NI-QN M"  V(N XNR  JNI7> $  Q] Y NHNR U
E N-K JT K ;K  IW= X  R
I HQN
M
I -QN M"  V(N XNR
$  ZM.ST I MZ] Y . %] ^  WK IFR Q] Y NHNR U
E N-K JT K ;K
IW= X  R
I HQN M
I -QN M"   I-= H KW $  ST I MZ] Y  GK RX%N I-= H  ZM.ST I MZ] Y
IL]%. (N% E"H HKVK M" I-=HKW$ STIMZ]Y IW=X JTW3 M>]G MK IV]% RNV
S'N-  M% I-= H KW $  ST I MZ] Y  G  \= S   JN  %HEK VE
H  %HEK QE\
E
H %HEK QUZ E
H %HEK Q%NZK E
H GK RX%N JTN'KQ. %]^ ;
\ G
' IW= X  R= \ ' G  E-K QNIG ZNI-QN G> R UN  V
$  HRWN-K M"  V(N = L 
JN SNR4. * V
$ 3T31 STMZ N;H. *UV.  %]^ R=\GN M" IFR MR >=U
IW= X  7> % 4 .  %] ^  QNJ'N ] G  3  WNMH ] V  IVU> R ^  S'NH  IJT ( WK 7> a V  *
LGN M"   L
 3NVR IW;K RIMV N;%. V(N IUQN% G=  G  M% V(N
QNJWK *UVKMK' M
 L.G  M% V(N N;H. %] ^  WK HNEALNE IW= X  FN
L.G M% IFR 7>M U>R^ LK QV Q%>QN-K G
%4
$ MK %RH IW=X L.G M%
IFR NMZ'  I-= H  VNEN H> E _  EUN R= I \QN M"   7> M  RNVN HNE
ST M Z  G  I%= L  E
H  IW= X  L.GN M"   IL= (   I-M ST M Z HNE  QNJ'
WNVIWH ZN%W 3>IGT3 HNE R^J IW=X RIM]GN M" I- (N% 7>aV I-=H
J=(R GK 1>H9K VW G QNHNR GK  XJNVK JHN7>' GK E
M GK U
E ILMK
JE1 M]>GK M"  WV4 URZ RIM]GK M" IL 7>aV I-=H E=\ ZN%W RKR
;NRK JTN'KQ. G 3^\3Z RKR. %]^ *>]%4 H 7> IW=X
$ U]GUK H=<H \.GN
M" 7> Z$ RW JTN'K SM>V JK94N Q%>*W HRG M% V(N MNMNHNR Z=X
L.GK M" IFR H>0 Z$ IJ=6
 7>M SM
3 M
 L.G M% LKW ZRG %MK$
IFR ;RZRN-  G  E
H  IW= X  LNH  QNJ'  HRZQ;NR HRH  M
R  L%Z
JT N JV HRG  M% V(N L%ZAZR' GN X= H R SI'QN RIM] G N M"   7> J T
H V
NMZ' E=IUQN VNEN STMZ HNE  HWE QNJ' \N' WNE JTN'KQ. E-K
H> 0  Z $  E-K \
E 4 G N M"   J^ R ' JT Z NVZN G  IV%NZ V(N NR%NZ %NE
I-M VNEN QNJMK \> = E 4  L.GN M"   I-VR4 .  HNE GN LNE J^ R ' JT Z NVZN
HIWRG W  HSKRNIMS  %  QNJMK QNJ'  I%= L K *UV ;RZGN LK %] ^
Z0NI-QN

JRSTMZ G =V ]\ STIMZ]Y. GK (NJ%N#


HSKR JTZ3WR HIWRGW  LK % Q=U G=IQN IH JTSTMZ QH3R
J>R3  % QNJ' H]Z IW=X UEVK HKVK IH7>$IH 7>M ZN%R
WR IW=X $
IUQN V(N LG
$  JT Z  3 WR Z" $  QR(NV HSKR JT Z  3 WR %  7>   R
W R
IW=X Q]YN 6=IYQN V. QH3R J>R3 JRSTMZ  % 7>%]^ U=> %NE GI\QN
K I-%4. G
W$ QJRN;N HNR% WK 7>%^] =V ]\ STIMZ]Y. ZV VE
H
V
$ SNMR H=< IG=VN G^RN HNR% QH3R J>R3 JRSTMZ  QNJ' N(K
ST M Z 6R J> R 3  GK IWGN-K IW= X  IWQNH> E  M
H   JRZIJVN HIWRG W
HSKR JTZ3WR  LK %]^ *>=EH 7> %]^ NG HR% E=UN V(N 
IXQN IH

IUQN% U] U N

41

6RJ>R3 STMZ  V. SM>V QN%]G ZN' IRMN M


WUN Z"$ IJ=6 RIM IUQN
V(N H>0 M
R QNWZ.W. L
 JRSTMZ G =V ]\ STIMZ]Y IW=X L%ZAZR%
GN HRZG] Y  *
U  RMKQ. M% 7> % 4 .  M]   QNVZ.W. GK IWGN-K GK NG
IW=X \
 U-KQ. L
 STMZ HNE  G %NE I-=HK STIMZ]Y. IW=X FKQ. M%
V(N J^ R ' JT Z NVZN > \ GN-K HIWRG W  LK GK NG *> E NQ IG= V K JT Z 
3WR HIWRG W  G  WNRAWNR Z0N7> '  7> a V  WK QN(N [= 1  %MK$ M
- K
JRST M Z QH3R J> R 3  %  
I XQN IH Z" $  WK QE= U  (N% JT N JV HR.
V. X] U N RM   I-M 
X H  RNL JT D N JVK GK I-6N %NE NR%NZ GN LNJ
QNR]* IG=VN I-K VR4. M
R QNVZ.W. % L
 JTSTMZ G =V ]\ STIMZ]Y.
IW=X FKQ. M%  % 
IXQN IH L
 STMZ G %NE QNVZ.W. U-KQ. M%
7>M V. Z,AZ3VK Z%N7>'U QK$ IJ=6 RIM U- JRSTMZ G Z% IW=X
I-M ;NR%. S'K IH 6R J>R3 QE=U M
H SM>V 3>=\K M
WUN I-M IWXNR
HRH  Q] V RQNVZN V
$  I*] %  (N% JT N JVK GK PN% E-K JRST M Z
QH3R J> R 3  %  M= P 
U  %MK$ HKVN JT ] V ^  H W E QE= U  RNL JT N JVK
HR% E-K IML I;QN%
U  IW3 3  HH G  %NE HRGN IRMN QE= U
(N% JT N JV HR% G  E-K JNUE. GK VR4 .  QN= H V M
H   7>  %^ ]  XNM> '
E=UK J^R' JT*^ G J>=6' 7>aV JRSTMZ % QE=U (N% Z]IUQN V(N H>0
QNVZ.W. G  E-K *K NX%N HKVK VG HIWRG W  %  IHMN IH L

QNVZ.W. QNJG  %NE W" I -= 6 N %NE LN'N XNM  7> % 4 .  %^ ]  * L  IG] G N M.
J^R' JT*^ % J>I6QN IH H' M] QNVZN JRSTMZ G %NE LN'N XNM]>GN
M"   IMZVK IWQHV HR   SM> V  Z $  SNQG I-= H  M]   QNVZN %
WKIHTVK IG=VK IFR G\NAG\K 7>%4. RW QNVZ.W. %^] IMZVK IWQHV
HR IG= V K * V
$  JIME. IMZVK G '  WNE  M]   %] ^  I-VRK R^ J
S'NI-QN 7>  GN %NZ -K3WRK ZNI-QN JT I HT V K > R VK  R= I \QN V(N
M
R QNVZ.W. %]^ 7> -K3WRK ZNI-QN IW=X JTW3 HR H QIX]V G>QNRN
QH3R J>R3  JRSTMZ  G H
E *ILQN JVKWRVN JG V
$ IUR' GK
LN JN-K  H-K =>U. V=H G
%4
$ =V ]\ STIMZ]Y. IW=X RM JT]V^ JTSTMZ
% G>RIWWMNR %MK$ HKVN -K3WRK ZNI-QN GK W" I-=6N %NE Q]UKHNR
HKVN QV  QNJ'K 3SG 3HVK %NE %N\> % N %NE I-VRK I-] G T K  
% K
S'N-K -K3WRK G W K GK IMZVK %NE ] V N% 7> V J] %  HKVK I-E-K
JRSTMZ G E
H =V ]\ STIMZ]Y.  IW=X JTN'KQ. %]^ VJVI3EN GN H31
%MK$ M" V(N 7>a( J3^AJ]6K WK STMZ E
H G GW. V
$ WK X]U XIR=VR >HV
M% 7> Z R WK SM> V  E] S K M"  JT ] V ^  L%ZAZR% HRZQN;NR 7> a V  HRZG] Y
V(N IZM%V HRH  MK 7> G RJ^ R VK M> ] G K M"   WRU V(N %RH WK Q"  
MK S'  M% JRST M Z QH3R J> R 3  %] ^  = V  ] \  ST I MZ] Y  7>  G  I-= 6 N
R^ J K *UVK I;QN% QR(NV IML ZN;K IW;K %NE 7>  GK HZN-K G
JT V K_E IW= X  JT G N% HKV  V(N VE
H  V
$  I*] %  (N% 7> a V  U
E NHNR
JIR;K IW= X  S] G  HRH  = V  ] \  ST I MZ] Y . IMV QH3R ST M Z V(N
-K3WRK ZNI-QN %] ^  I%3HNI3V HR IG= V N
J^ R ' ST M Z IVJ> R 3  Q] \  ST I MZ] Y . L
 IVE
H  QNIG IW= X  M%

42

I3T 3 1K RX%N

V(N ST M Z G  I-= H K ST I MZ] Y . V(N JRST M Z G  = V  ] \  ST I MZ] Y . GN WK


ZNIEH JT * ^  M"  QR(NV JT Z  3 WR HIWRG W  H> = E  GN ZNIEH M" 
3TK STMZN LK 3TK IW3'^ LK V(N 3TK I3W LK QNIG %]^ XNRA *>LNW.
V(N  HE.W. M% V(N JT I HT V K G W K G> R UN  GKQ. Q= P  *> L NW. V(N
 HE.W. M% STMZ 6R J>R3  GK I-=H M,NR *>LNW. M% V(N I-=H
M,NR HE.W. M% V(N I-= H K ST I MZ] Y . GN JT * ^  M"   JRST M Z QH3R
J>R3  GK G= M,NR *>LNW. M% V(N G M,NR HE.W. M% V(N =V ]\
STIMZ]Y. GN JT*^ M" J^R' STMZ JRZ QH3R J>R3 QR(NV IVJ>R3
GKQ. Q]\ *>LNW. V(N Q]\ HE.W. V(N STMZ G I-=HK STIMZ]Y V(N
JRSTMZ G =V ]\ STIMZ]Y. IMV Q]\ STIMZ]Y. GN JT*^ M" MR JT*^
QNJ'KQ. * *>LNW. %^] Z1 H HWE G
 *>LNW. IW=X WK R=\ HG M%
V(N LG
$  XNM> '  * *> L NW. WK JT U 1 HR HG  M% J^ R ' JT Z NVZN
JTSTMZ G JTVH STIMZ]Y IW=X WK QE=U R^J S'NH U>JV RIM]GN M" I-]0
Z0
 ILW$ IH I-=H [>]Z' WNEN H"ZRN SNMR EUN IG]G M% V(N Q]GR
1K/WK/ 1"EKWK,%  R=\ IG]G M% 1K/WK/ 7>aV SNMR GN * H>0 %,R
QN7>$GN M" V(N G^RN 1K/WK/ SNMR R=\H Q]GR GN H"ZRN (N-K HRH
R=\ IG=VN LNW 7> IW=X IRF Q]GR S"P G IX=VR IG\N-K IG]GN M"
IL %NE * HRZXNRK NW;N% RIM] G   M%
I-VR4. J^R' JTZNVZN QNJ' VE
H IW=X S"PH RW %]^ I%]IVTV
HRG M"$ V(N JTVH STIMZ]Y IW=X WK IVU>R^ HIWRGW IWRNLZN% RIM]G
M% ILW $  ^ R L G^ R  M] > G   M
-   WK QNJ'N JT * NW M
R  E
H . 7> a V  S'N-K
R= \ GN M" 

JIW=VR Q=(RWWG IW=X I3T31K RX%N GN JTZN'


H.Y%]+/Q%>WNH%]+/Z]VR%]+/A
STMZLIUQN%] JT(ZZJTRVNGIWKZVM^RX
 W%QNWM
S>];N7>JZ.QIW3PNMV3X
I%ZV3XIWWM@@
STMZALAIUQN%ZAJT(ZZAJ>RVNVAIWIZVMA>R^XMAW%MAQNWMAMA
S>I;%NMA7>JZNAQAIW3PNM VMAXA 
I%ZA QVMA XA IW WM
Q%>WNG/A JT(ZZ  JTNXK% QT(NV %NV% STMZ  JTZNVZN % L  JTU1
M
H IUQN%Z  QNJ'K ^0AS^0 %NE J>RVNV  I3\R IW=X QR(NV IVE
H
QNIG%]^ >R^XM W"I-=6NV
$SM>VXNW%NEWJTHNI3V IWIZVM KZN
RIMVQR(NVIW3NEKZNWNEI*]%E
H.%]^7> W%M L>ENM%VN'QR(NV
H=J9GKVR4.S>'H QNWM >IRI\QVHKVN X V(N X 7>MJ^R%STMZMK
RWRX%NHRGNM" I-E-K7>Z^EZNIEH% Z^E(N%IVE
HGKRX%N
HKVKM" Q I-G E-K7>K 7>JZN >IGT3QR(NVIZEG L>EG VM
Q=H3RJ>R3QR(NVJRSTMZGE
HH>0(N-K X V(N QVM 6RJ>R>3
G Q(N-KE
HQNIG IWWM QNWN(N%I*]% IW3PNM (NIJVHKV
*NWQR(AJIW=VR WG. %]^ S
E' WNEN STMZ HNE  HIM IRMN M" IH

IUQN% U] U N

43

%NV% JTZ3WR % QNJMK Q%NZ Q%NZK  E


H V
$ VE
H IW=X JTU1
M
H   QNJ'K ^ 0 AS^ 0  %NE H= J 9  GK VR4 .  RX%N HRH  7> a JR G  VE
H
QNIG %] ^  KZN RIMV W" $  JT H NI3V Q,RAQZR QR(NV QIW%N3K
PIMRN- V(N %KX  G  JRST M Z G  = V  ] \  ST I MZ] Y  V(N ST M Z G  
STIMZ]Y V I-%4. IW=X 6
1K V
$ 6
1K RX%N WK 7>K JTZNVNZN % Q(N-K
HKVK M" 
H.Y%]/Q%>WNH%]/Z]VR%]//A
I-] IJVRNRN31RKXVWUT JT(ZNL%>3 *>W%3PNM
VZN-V] >R^X] MNRZM] ;RZZ3TK']V^ JT(ZN;NW@@
I-ZAIJVRNARN31RKA-V>AQUTAJT(ZNAL%^3A*>W%3PNMA VZNA-
VZA>R^XZAMWNRZMNZA;RZZA3TK']V^AJT(ZNA;NW
Q%>WNG/A I-Z I- IJVTN LUVIJVNJTZ3WR% -V^ I- QNUT
TW
VZ JT(ZN *V
$JIMEKZNI-QNJTN%]G%K RN31RK RNL3WRK3HVK
QT(NVJTN3HVKIL%]^ QHR3'3HVKWKHIM]G M%%]^ L%^3 7>VJ]%HRH
*>W%3PNM E
H(NJ%NHKVK VZ. 7>KJTZ3WR% R^XZ SM>VXNQ
G%NEW"I-=6N%NE -VZ I- JT(ZN JT(Z7>VJIVVGK3HVKQR(NV
JRN3HVKGG>QNRN MNRZMNZ I-=HG^RGIW
U%]^R
H'QR(NVQNHR3'
HVKG 3TK'N%]V^ U>R^VWQNHR3'%]^JTZNVZN%QG3IG=VNGNRM
7>HG
ZNJV%M
'WNE ;TZZ >*NQV
$ ;NW ;NR%HRHVN'QR(NVH=J9
GKVR4.S>'H R
H M
- M%
*NWQR(ALUVIJVN JT Z  3 WR %  QNJ'K 3SG3HVK %NE RN31RK
QR(NV * V
$  JIMEK ZNI-QN RNL 3 WRK 7> V J] %  HKVK V(N 7>  K
JRN3HVK G  G> Q NRN I-= H AG^  R  %] ^  QNHR3' 3HVK %NE R
H ' WNEK
HG  %N ZNJV M
'  WNE  U> '  V
$  7> J R
H V RW ST I MZ] Y . %] ^  (NIJV
HKVN
H.Y%]/Q%>WNH%]/Z]VR%]//A
JT 
 LU IWGWN%S];^IWTWNGWN%]ZLI%ZNIWWIHV
STMZSTMZ'7>LL*NRZ;N%KX"R^XX"/W;NQI*JT V(@@
JTAMALUAWGWN%=AS];^MAIW3WNAGWN%NZALI%ZNAIWWIHVA
STMZ'M ASTMZMA7>LL*NRAZI;QNVAI%X"MA7>XX"MAW;NAQI*MAJT VZ(
Q%>WNG/A JT RWJT(Z GWN%NZ GWVNW.WISTMZ]Y.GK LU 7>VJ=VK
GIUQN%%]^ WGWN%= ILIUQN^*UVGN M L
 S];^M WNVIWHN(K
QR(NVJ^R%JTZNVZNMKQNJ'I%aLWH%]^ LI%ZN QNJ'G>QNRNIRL%
HKV M
-" %]^ IWWIHV W" \>G MKPKHAPNHIWVNRJ^RWHG=IQNM" IH
STMZ'M J^R%JTZNVZN% ZI;QNV QNJ' Z=;V
$QR(NV3SG3HVKV
$
STMZM STMZA6RJ>R3QT(NVHNE%]^ 7>LL*NR 7>VJ]%HRH IW3WN NR
]NR%]^QR(NVRWE
H.%]^ 7>XX"M 7>J=RVE
HQNIG I%X"M %KXJTSTMZ
W STMZ G RW STIMZ]Y W;N  QNJ'K ;NR% HR% WNEK QI*M  QHR3'
3HVKV
$ JT VZ( G
%.4 %]^ Q=6KJTHNRI(VHKVN
*NWQR(AJ^ R ' JT Z NVNZN QNJ'  G> Q NRN RXK I3T 3 1K GN IUQN%

44

I3T 3 1K RX%N

V(N RW QNVZ. GK 7>VJ=VK GN IUQN% QNJ' I%=LK GN %]^ W"$ MK
MK G=GN M" IH J^R' JTZNVZN % QNJ' Z=; QR(NV QNJ' RKR V
$
QNJ'K 3SG 3HVK G G>QNRN STMZ 6R J>R3 HNE  GK 7>VJ=VK HKVK
V(N RW STIMZ]Y. %]^ 7>aJR VE
H QE\ E
H QUZ E
H Q%NZK E
H
QNIG V(N %KX JRSTMZ G =V ]\ STIMZ]Y V(N STMZ G  STIMZ]Y. %]^
QNJ'K ;NR' HR' WNEK QNHR3' 3HVK %NE IPMRNI-QN M
I-QN M"
ILW$ J^R% JTZNVZN HSKR JTZ3WR HIWRGW  % QNJ'K I%=LK WH
QR(NV 3\N TK ;RZGN LK QNGR'K-$ URKSGN LK QNIG %^] QNJ'
G>QNRN RXK I3T31K GN IUQN% \>G MK G=IQN 7>JR
HV WG Z]VR WK
I-MK ZR(% HR IRMN M"
H.Y%]/Q%>WNH%]/Z]VR%]//A
IMIGWMJTI(WNIRV(NZMKH3Z] R
GKQH*NV
ZMN%ZMKQH*NGIWLNV
 ;.GZJNRI(WZXRLM@@
IMAIGWMAAJT I (WNNAIRV(NAZMN%AZMKAH3 Z ZAR
G AQH*NV
AZMN%AZMKAQH*NGAIWLNVMA;NZAGZAJNRI(WZAXARLM
Q%>WNG/A   7> RW3HVKZN% JTZNVZN % IM  I%R]GM IGWM
7>J=RGXNR.IG*E
HILW$VE
HQE\E
HQUZE
HVQ%NZKQR(NV
QIHM E
H QR(NV IG* U>'. >HV E
H. %]^ IRV(N  V I(R QR(NV
QLRAQZRR^JV
$I(RHKV  7>%4.GZN% JTI(WN %KXGIJT(WKWNE
E
H.ILW$JRSTMZG=V3]\VSTMZHNEGI-=HKSTIMZ]Y ZMK IJT(WKV=VW
V
$ H3ZZ >R=I\QNG%NE QH*NV PIMRNI-N R
GK QNHNV=VWV
IJT(WKG
%
4$V
$7>J=R%KXGSTIMZ]YN%]^ILW$I-=H^\ZV=VM"QNHN3GNU>'
3SGM"J^R%JTZNVZN%7>J=RGE
H3SGR^JRXL
V,J>]LGS'N-M%V
%KXGJTSTMZ QH3RJ>R3 GJV3]\STIMZ]YVSTMZ6RJ>R3GI-=HK
STIMZ]Y.%]^IJT(WKV=VWV
$Q(N-KRIXQN ZMN% J^R%JTZNVZ.% JNI(TWZ
IJT(WK WNE IW  I*]%AI*]% ;NZ  E
H X  V GZ  QNWN (N% ZMK
IJT(WKV=VWV
$ RLM JTVHSTIMZ]YIW=X6
1A6
1E
H.GK LNVM RX%NHRH
QH*NV  I(R HKVN
*NWQR(/A7>J=R G XNR
$ E
H VE
H QE\E
H QUZE
H Q%NZKE
H
I-M V. QLR QZR QR(NV QIW%N3K RX M% V %KX GK STMZ V(N
JRSTMZ G E
H. GK Q(N-K RX%N HRH V(N M
R 6
1A E
H WK 7>
JT Z  3 WR %  RXH  I(R HKV  M%
H.Y%]/Q%>WNH%]/GNZ]VR%]//A
S^;]%NGT31L%^3
0*]UT STMJIVGTWVNVZTN1
QMTL6^H] L
IV3
 L%I31N([^Z]%V
 IWW]V^ IWJTN@@
AS^;]%NVAQN31RAL%^.AQI*AQUTZAISTMJIV/AGWVNA
VAZTN1AQVA3>HZ
T AL
IV3MALI%31AQ(A[^ZV
] /AIWASZ]VA^  IWIJTQNM
Q%>WNG/A M 7> S>;]%NV Z^EZNIEHV
$ QI*AQUTZ RWJT(Z
(N% 7>aV QN31T  Q31Q]UK ZNI-QNAG>RUN QR(NV JTIHTVK GWK L%^M
7>VJ]%M
-KIH7>$IH%KXGJTSTMZWSTMZGE
H.GNJT(Z(N%VE
HM"I-M

IUQN% U] U N

45

46

I3T 3 1K RX%N

VKRN ;NZ WK HMN7>$GN M" VZ  I- G>RUN G WK ZNIEH I-MK ZTN1
RNLNI;TNL ISTMJVK  *V
$ W=YN JVK W LUVU>R^ GWVN  JTZ3WR M" V
ILV
$ QM4  *GN IW
U M
I-QN Q(  I-G SNQG L
IV34  L
VK R^J
I%R]L%QR(NVHNEG 3HTZ WKRQR(NVSKL3HVKV
$ L%K31 G>RUN
G7>GRV
$7>VJ]%M
H ISJTNM *UVQNVZNW. IW QE=UV
$ [^Z]%VM Z%>=\
E
HVWRUE
HIW=XL
VKI%R]L%GQNG3%NEG>RUN%IHMN W]V^ I%WN
HR
QR(NV7>MI%WNHR%E=UK
*NWQR(AJ^R' JTZNVZN % 7>aJR G XNR
$ E
H. IW=X L
 %KX V
$ *
V
$ JIME. QR(NV VE
H IW=X QN31RN QR(NV Q31]UK JTIHTVK GWK
G> R UN  GK 7> V J= V K HKVK I-MK RNLNI;RNL LUVU> R ^   J^ R ' JT Z  3 WR
IVJ> R 3  M"  ILV
$  * GN IW
U  M
I -QN M"   IFR RW JT N 'K L
V K
I%R] L % HNE  G  WKR,  SKL V
$  G> R UN QN31T N  G  UR* G> Q NRN
7> V J] %  M
H   3WRU E
H  W IJT ( WK E
H  7> a V  I%WN HR% EaU 
 H.Y%]/Q%>WNH%]/GNZ]VR%]/
%^%] VGHNW
 IM%
VKZM
 GW=J^RW;NZ
-3LU" SM^I*MNHIZV(NJ^RW QR; IWI3V 3Z%%^@@
%^%ZAVVAQAHNW.AZMMAGWAJ^RWA;NZAIM%
IVAJ^RW
AIW3KV
A-3ALU"ASM^I*MANHZA-KV(NAQR;A%A%^
Q%>WNG/A %^%Z I%R]GM VV 7>MJ^R%JTZ3WRQR(NVV=VSTMZ
MK Q I- HNWM *UVQNVZ.L
J^R%GK*UVKIW;KW=VHRGNM"%]^
WNIJ ZMM  RW 3HVKZN% GW  JTZ3WR G J^R%  JIME G
;NZ  E
H IW=X QR(NV VE
H IW=X IM%
VK  *LGN M" J^RW  JIME WNE
IW3KV  IW33 XNM M
- -3  I- JTZ3WR %]^ WK LU"  I3T31K 7>VJ=VK G
IUQN%%]^ LN%H SM^*KM SM>VQN%]G NHZ G %NE QR; Q=;N %
>=VNM
I-QN -KV(N IW=;KW=;I-JTHNR %^ =XKQNVZ.%NEV^VKHRGNM"
*NWQR(A 7>MK J^R' JTZ3WR IVN;%N HR% WNE N;H %]^ 7>
JIME  WNE  (N% VE
H  IW= X  E"  L.GN M"   IL= (
$  IW69H  QN-  K
7>a( 7> WNVIWH >\ GN-K JT*^ %]^ JTNJV HRH \>3K %NE QNVZ IW*
R
M
H   ZVK %NE V> V K HRGN M"  IH M  JT Z  3 WR Q] \  L%Z. G  *> a E
A*1IHQ. %] ^  WNVIWH IPHN'N IZE IUQN I-GN JT Z N' IRUW G
Z] Y + > H V  Z] V R IW= X  WK M" 
QNGR'K- $  URKSGN LK %] ^  I-K VR4 .  J^ R ' JT Z NVZN HIWR G W
HSKR JTZ3WR  W"$ IV*UVK JTGN% HRH VE
H E"H U- K VG
QNJ'K Q] I ZT V SN'K IW= X  QNGR'K- $  URKSGN LK ZMNRNL %  Q= \ K$ G
\H  IHMN/A
URKSQLS%URZ$EU-MZH^]IVU>R^QN%I0EHIS]SQUN;UIV^V
XNGR VN%@
H.Y%]/Q%>WNH%]/Z]VR/A

5(WR'] IJVR] GWS];^ STMJIV] %ZNWXUX6NV
VW] IW3W3.LI%VN(NMHWKRGW
 %G*NVW;NWN%@@

IUQN% U] U N

47

MAQ(WR'ZAIJVRZAGWS];Z
^ ASTMJIVZA%ZNAQWAXAUX6NZ
AVWZAIW3W3NZALI%VNA(NAMAHWKRGWMA%AG*NVAW;NW%
Q%>WNG/A M L
 Q(WT'Z QX=EQR(NVQIW%N3K IJVTZ LUVIJVN
GWS];^Z *UV.GNWNVIWHN(KQR(NVQNVZ.GNQN;NR ISTMJIVZ
LUVU>R^ X  V(N %ZN  IS%ZR J>LNRK QR(NV IW;KWa; N;H %]^ QW
>R=I\QNG %NE UX6NV VE
HU- M
I-QN%]^ VE
HE" LN'WNEN IW3W
3NZ RWSTIMZ]Y.GK L%KVN RX%NHR%WNENLUG]SNQR(NVZNVNWNE
U>'N%NEWK>HV %G*NV HNEGKVR4.;
\N%G'WNE W;NWN% >*NQ
QR(NVU>'.WNEN (N IL7$> GNIV7$> QR(NVW"NMK M 7>M VWZ QNJ
HIWRGWHWKRGWM HIWRGWM"QR(NV*N3NI*]%I-%]^ HSKRJTZ3
 WRWK
HIM]G M%
*NWQR(A I- Z]VT IW=X I-M WK J=31 HR IG=VN IH 7> JTZ3WR
GN %NZ HIWRGW QR(NV HSKR JTZ3WR M" IL% RW RX%N HKVK M"
L
 JT Z  3 WR QXE QR(NV WNV QIW%N3K UKVN QI;/ E
H
A IW=X WK JTZN' M"  LUV U>R^ QNVZQ;NR L
 J^R' Z>HV M
H
VE
H  U-  M% 7> % 4 .  %] ^  VE
H  E"  LN' WNEN RW ST I MZ] Y  GN
RX%MNR HNE ST M Z  GK VR4 .  ;
\ N %N G '  WNEN IL7> $  GN IV7> $  7> M
W" $  HIWR G W  QR(NV HSKR JT * ^  M"   I-MK JT Z  3 WR RW ST I MZ] Y .
V(N JTN'KQ. %]^ QNJ'K 3SG3HVK %NE 7>VJ]% HR% GN HNR% LI%VN
ZNVN WK HMN7>$GN M" V(N IJ=VRZ  IJVN V(N S];^  *N-K WK WNVW
IW=X I-MK M" V(N GW  JTZ3WR WK I-MK M" I- E-K I- HIWR G
W HSKR JTZ3WR  7>V>VK HIRQN HRG M% VBZW ZNVN X IJVN VBZ
W VBZW S];^ X \N VBZW VBZW IWIGQN X GRIW'Z VBZW VBZW RW
ZZ G W  G W  I-  JT Z  3 WR GK ZIMZN GN JIW= V R IR= U W G  Z] Y E %] / 
> H V %] /  IW= X  IWIVRV WR'% M" 

JIW=VR IRUWG IW=X I3T31K RX%N GN JTZN'#


Z]YE  >HV  Z]VR /A
 MVTI3T3 J>R>3M MVTRNH3M MVTNJNV
*^IZZIW3WV
 WTVWNVIV3PG3NYMU^EZ@@
MVI3R3AJ> R ^ 3 MAMVRT N H3AMVT N JNVAA*^ I ZZA IW3WV
M
WRVWNAQVNIV3PVA G3]U^EZ
Q%>WNG/A J>R^3M IWRN1R^JHNE*UWN%QT(NV6RJ>R3 MVTI3T3
M,NRIR.WNEN MVTRNH3 M,NRQ=\.WNEN MVTNJNV M,NRJ"R.WNEN
  7>M HNE *^IZZ  IJT(WK WNE I-=HK STIMZ]Y. %]^ I3WVM  * VRF
$
G]U^EZ  G. 7^$UEN %NE QT(NV J^R% R^J %NE HNS^ HR M
- WRVWN
U
ENHNR[R IW=X[RH QVNIV3PV I-V
$W=;H QR(NVQNJ' HNEE
H
IW=X*V
$I%QNRNWKI-=HKW$STIMZ]YIW=XPIMIRQNM" QR(NVRIM]GNM"
*NWQR(AI- Z]VT IW=X IWRN1 HNEASTMZ  GN WR'% M" UKVN
QI;/A IW=X WK I- HNEASTMZ GN QILMN MK WR'% M" Q/ Z]VT

48

I3T 3 1K RX%N

%] /  IW= X  QRL> %  %  IHMN M"  IH M  IM]  RSNM^  QR(NV M,NR *^ , N
WNEN QNJ QNJ'  XV> R *> L  R^ J  IW= X  GR3% IG7> 
ILG M,NR. M=( J"R M,NR Q=\. H]% QNIG M% I-M IWRN1 R^J
HNE JT * ^  QNJ'  Q;K% NR  JT N 'KQ. %] ^  J^ R % HNS^  HRH  QR(NV 
ST I MZ] Y . %] ^  U
E QNHNR R^ J  IW= X  R
H H  QNJ I- V
$  7> a JR QE= U
I-= H KW $  ST I MZ] Y  IW= X  S" P N M" 
Z]YE  >HV  Z]VR /A
J>R^3-WG] RW] G*^V] XX*NWZ
7>VNZTVVW3N%
$ GQ%]%%NIVR
MIV@@
J>R^3A-WA-GZARWZAVA*^VZAVAXA*NWZA7>VA QIZTVVW
A-K3N%MAVAQ%]%%AQIVR
IMV
Q%>WNG/A -W I-JTHNRH>0MKVRV J>R>3 *UWN%M"7>MQH3R
J>R3QR(NVJRSTMZM" X V(N -KG I-M V L
 *^VZ 7>VJ]%M
I-QN
M" V L
 *NWZ *IW3IW=XM
WUN RWZ * V V%%NEQT(NV
ZIM%V G>QNRN Q]%%%  Q]% %NE QVT
IMV  IWHIV M]GN M" 7>M QHR
J>R3 7>V ]GM>HV Q]IZTVVW Z
H3GN -K3N%M WNZKM"QR(NV
*UWN%V.QH3RJ>R3WKH>0MKM" JTD]V^ J^R%Z
H3GNI-H%MK$M"
*NWQR(A I- Z]VT IW=X JRSTMZ QH3R J>R3  GN IWWR' M" L

H>0 *UWN% WNE U>'N IMV M" JT]V^ I-GK *UVK %NE WK J^R' Z
H3
%MK$ M]GN I-E-K I-%]^ ]GM >HV Z>HVKGNVN IHMN L.GN M" I-%]^
H> 0  JT * ^  G  U> ' . > H V I-E-K IHMN L.GN M"  IH I-M HNE GK VR4 .
VJVI3EN 7>aV *>]%H %]^ %MK$ \.GN JT]V^ I- JRSTMZ G E
H IW=X WK
JT N 'KQ. %] ^  IZM%V HRH  HRZQN;NR 7> a V  MK FE JT N JV M] > G N M"  V(N
Q]% %NE MK RW JTN'KQ. G RKR IWHIV M>]G M% L%Z V(N IZTV^
GN Z$ S3=H MK HNE 6RJ>R3  V
$ ILQNGN M" JT]V^ IFR WK 7>VJ=VK
IW%N3 V(N X R NK E= \  ,^ % KQN GK NV%. S'K RIM] G K M" 
Z]YE  >HV  Z]VR /A
-VNWN%ZIMZNV
 LN]XJ>R>3M
JNG
 IW3WN*^VNI%IVTJNGNZTV] IGIW@@
-VNWN%AQAZIMZNAQVMALNN%AXAJ>R>3MAJNGMA
QAIW3WNA*^VNI%A VIRA JNGA QAQIZTVZAIGIW
Q%>WNG/A Q I-QH3RJ>R3QR(NVJRSTMZGKV. -VNWN%
I-]%KMK ZIMZN JT*^VNM" X V(N J>R3M 7>MJRZQH3RSTMZQR(NV
J^R%STMZJTZ3WRV. QVM I-V
$WK LNN% WI;QNM" IW3WN ZV
*^VNI% 6RJ>R3VQH3RJ>R3VI-%4.GE
H.IW=XVVE
HVI-%4.E
H.
IW=XIL]%WKJTN'KM% Q I-J^R%JRZQH3RJ>R3GN JNGM I-=HJ"R
M" QR(NV I-=H Q]3 ZNVR M" Q  I- JTZ3WR G IVT  IV]% IGIW
IGWE
HILW$VE
HAQE\E
HAQUZE
H QIZTVZ QIW%N3K JNG G^RN
J"RM"QR(NVL
WKRWSTIMZ]Y.IW=X7>VJ]%M"7>MIVJ>R3J^R%JTZNVZ.
GNMKQ]3NQ]UM"

IUQN% U] U N

49

*NWQR(AI- 7>aJR G Z]VT  IW=X WRI'V QH3R J>R3 JRSTMZ


GK V. I-]%K MK ZIMZN M" V(N 7>M J^R' J>R3 HIWRGW V. I-V
$ WK
W=YN M" QR(NV RW3HVKZN% M" V(N RW STIMZ]Y 7>DK GN Q]3 ZNVR
7>aV PIMR M% I- Z]VT IW=X IV]% E
H. GN WR'% I- E-K M" IH7>$IH
X ( N Q%NZK Q%NZ  E
H  M
R  RX%N V
$  JIME. GN M"   I-MK IV] %
JT * ^ Q . 6R J> R 3AQH3R J> R 3 QV  I-%4 .  G
% 4 .  V
$  M
R  JRZ QH3R
J>R3  GN IWWR' TKZG*UWV UKVN Q/ ]/A IW=X M" I-K
I-K GN
JT Z N' QNGR'K- $  URKSGN LK HIM] G   M% IH/A
URKSLNHQT;R^ZJRHEJNRN-NJ^R%STMZMZNRN@
URKSQ%]VH
1STIMZ]YHN-HRIV%MK$*NRIVU>R^ J>R3HSKRM"$
H>aEH ITL%MNR@
I- GN JTZN' QNGR
'K- $ GNG^ NIMS LK HIM RM M% IH/A
QNGR'K-
IL%Z
H^] I%L%NZIGQN
I-IVU>R^ MZNRGNG^ G^RNH
-K%MK$
HSKR IRL%MNR@
     I- GN JTZN' QNGR
'K-$ %N%H NIMS LK IG]G M% IH/A
QNGR'K-
HQRLU>FVZJ3V
 GRH^%HRVNRM=HNHSKRHRKZV^]SQS
JRWRGKUNR@
3TK U>R^ UT]( NIMS JT3P %]+  ZM=EN  RNU IVE]U
H^% HRVNR GN Q
R ( M]>GN M" 
R W GN RX%MNR Q
QR
R
QTT(NV
(NV 3SG3HVK
%NE RX%N HR% WNEN 3SG WR^JK JT*^ M=HN HSKR GN Q
R ( M" IV
QR
HSKR HRKZ GN QR( M" IGQNE^ JRWRGKUNR GN QR( JTZNVZN M"
Z]YE  ^HV  Z]VR /A
IVTJNG^;WR 7>G"VJ>R^3M JNG
 MN*WVJ>%M
VV
 IW3W Y]WHTNZVN3%N%3%
 QI* @@
IVTAJNGA7>;RWMA7>G"VAJ> R ^ 3 MAJNGMAQAI-MAQ*WVAJ^%MAVVMA
IW3WYNAWHTNZVAMAQ3%N%3%AQI*
Q%>WNG/A J>R>3M  I-M JRZ QH3R STMZ QT(NV QIW%N3K JRZNVZN
7>;WRM 7>aJR IVT IV]%E
HILM VE
HAQE\E
HAQUZE
HR^J JNG
J"R QR(NV 7>J=R G IM= IW=X 7>G"V  JTU1 M]>GN M" QR(NV IWRNLZN% M"
Q I-JTZ3WRJ^R%STMZGN JNGM I-=HJ"RQR(NVI-=HIM=NLUV
R^J J>%R IFR I-M I-=( Q*WV JTU1M>]GNM" VVM I-E-K M 7>M
QIW%N3KJ^R%JTZNVZN Q3%N%3% \N'WNE HNE6RJ>R3V %N\N'WNE
JRSTMZQR(NVQH3RJ>R3GWK Q*K 7>aJR IW3WY]M RWVR IWHTNZV
IWNJVM" QR(NV7>GKJT*^VNRWSTIMZ]Y.WRWJT*^Q.7>aJRM"7>M
H>=EGNZNIEHM"IL% QNJ'K3HVK%]^ RWG 7>J=RF"ENI-QNM"
*NWQR(/A I-M RW I3T 3 1K RX%MNR JT * ^  QNJ'K RX%N V
$
7>aJR G IM= IV]% (N%. VE
H QE\E
H QUZE
H  IW=X IV]% R^J
IW=X W"$ JTU1 M]>GN M" QR(NV W"$ MK IWRNLZN% M" I-a( Q%NZK E
H
GN WR'% I-E-K %MK$ HKVN IH7>$IH Q%NZK E
H IW=X RX%N %MK$ M"
V(N QHIM Q%NZ  E
H 33 RX%N V
$ J^RW GN M" IFR IHMN M" IH

50

I3T 3 1K RX%N

7>K JTZNVZN G VE


H V
$ IW69 H %KX G STMZ V(N JRSTMZ G E
H
7>VJ]% M>]G M% V(N 7>M J^R' JTZNVZN \N' WNE STMZ QR(NV HNE V
$
IH7> $ IH ST M Z HNE %] ^  IWRN1 3RNJW= 3  I-= H  E= \  ZN%W RKR ;NRK
JTN'KQ. %]^ \.GN M"  V(N %N \N' WNE JRSTMZ QR(NV QH3R J>R3 V
$
JRSTMZ JTN'KQ. %]^ %MK$ \.GN JT]V^ L%ZAIZTV^ HRZG] Y  IL7> $  GN IV7> $
SI'QN RIM] G N M"  WK 7> a V  RWVR IWQNJH M"  QR(NV I- J^ R '
JT Z NVZN GK JT * ^ V N *G  7> a JR M"   HSKR JT Z  3 WR
WR MK H>E GN ZNIEH
M" IL% QNJ'K 3HVK %]^ RW G 7>aJR _"ENI-QN M" ILW$ ^RL QNJ'
JTHN3 RW G 7>aJR F"ENQ H JT*NIWV HRGN M" Q" J^R' JTZNVZN
%  QNJ'K 3HVK R^ J K R $ L 3ZVN  %NE RW ST I MZ] Y . %] ^  I%] V IRV
R=\' G E-K 6=IYQN M
I-QN M" ILW$ Z
SNI-E F
% GN 1NWR I-=H G3KQN
M>]G M
- QNJ'K 3HVK QR(NV Z
SNI-E _
% GK R$, 3ZVN  XNR
$ JN
F" E N-  RIM] G N M"   I-K JT H NR J^ R ' JT * ^  %  QNJ'K I%RHNR 3HVK
RWIWQNJH HKVK M"  IL %NE J^ R ' JT Z NVZN RW ST I MZ] Y . %] ^  I-= H
(N% 7> a V  S" P H  I%] V IRV R= \ GN M" 
I-K GN JT Z N' QNGR'K- $  URKSGN LK ZMNRNL G  RM  M%
Q] I ZT V WN'K RNU HIEQN'
VK% XT '  IX] V NZ'K NIMS 3 3  SG% JR 6N- 
ZNVN IJVN H> E  %N S] ; ^   %N IH%M $  L%%K LN- @
Z]YE  >HV  Z]VR /A
VZNIGWRNWWLNV IWRNL
 QI; J>R^3M
LNV
 QIVNIRXVJ3XNG*^ZKZ(
 J^RM@@
VZNVAIWRN1AQLNVAIWRNLMAQI;AJ>R^3MAALNVMA
Q=V[IRXVAJ6XNVA*^ZKZAQ(MAJ^RM
Q%>WNG/A VZNV 7>GIJ6
$7>JTZ3WRIVJ>R3GK3SG3HVK%NE
IWRN, IWRN1QR(NVSTMZIL%]^6RJ>R3VHNEWKHIM]GM% QLNV
7>VJ]%M
I-QNM" J6XNV I-G SNQG IWRNLM IWRN1J>R3QR(NVHNE
*UWN%V
$ QI; W=Y J>R3M JTZ3WR% *^ZKZ IJT(WKWNEE
HHNESTMZ
V(NJRSTMZGE
H%]^ QIVIRXV Q=6KVR4.RIXQN Q(M IFR J>RM
M
R6
1A6
1 E
H  7>J^R%JTZ3WR% MK LNVM 7>VJ]%HKVNQR(NV
(NIJV HKVN
*NWQR(/A 7> J R
H V Z] V T   IW= X  WRI'V IV] %
$  E
H . QUZE
H 
QE\ E
H  V(N VE
H  GK RX%N G  SNQG J^ R ' JT Z NVZN %  L
V K
I%R]L% STMZ  GK 7>VJ=VK HKVK QR(NV 7>K RW 3HVKZN% JTZNVZN
J^ R ' ST M Z HIWRG W  HSKR JT * ^  V
$  MK IWRN1 QR(NV ST M Z HNE
GK 7>VJ=VK M
-K I-MK JTZN' UKVN QI;/  Z]VT  IW=X M" IH QH3R
J>R3 QR(NV QIW%N3K JT*^ V
$ STMZ 7>VJ]% M
I-QN I-M JTZN' Q=(R
W G  H.Y  Q%> W NH  > H V  IW= X  M"  IH J^ R ' ST M Z V
$  ST M Z GK
7>VJ=VK M
-K 7> J^R' STMZ % *^IZZ  *^ZK QNIG 6
1AWaY RW E
H.
GK RX%N HKVK 7>M J^R' STMZ I- IWRN1 *UWN% QR(NV STMZ V
$

IUQN% U] U N

51

WK W= Y N M"  QR(NV I-GN *K ZNIEH M" 


Z] Y E  > H V  Z] V R /A
JVNN]JIR;IVRM JV IZ;M HTVNM
GWN IUZ] V]WN%N QS];%J>R3] J3^Z@@
JVAQAQN%AJIR;MAIVRJVAZK;MAHTVNMAG
WNAVAIUZAV]%WN%NMAQS;]%AJ>R^3ZAJ3^Z
Q%>WNG/A JV NV]\STIMZ]YV.JRSTMZG V(N IVRJV I-=HK
STIMZ]YHNESTMZG IZ;M HRZG]YG>=\R^JKQ=UV
$G>=\K IHTVN HR%WNE
JIR;M UE
HNR[RNR^JKZNIW=X QN% IS;ZN%M% V L
 J>R^3Z
J^R%JTZNVZ.GK IUZ IWI;WV;NRIZHHRZQT(NVJ^LNHRGNM" J3^Z
SEKG J3^ R^JKHNEG LNEIW=XHTZS];%IW=XS]%4 GWN *UVQNVZNW.%]^
V]WN%NM HNEGG>QNRNRXQR(NVF"EN-JNJHTZS];%LNE%NE QS];%%
S];%RIMVHRGNM" QR(NVS]GK6>YWN7>%WNENS]GK6
9M"
*NWQR(/ANV ] \  ST I MZ] Y  JRST M Z G  V(N I-= H K ST I MZ] Y  HNE
STMZ G IL]%4. IW=X U
ENHNR KZN IW=X S]G HRZ. GK Q=U IW=X LE RM
JT N 'KQ. %] ^  WNVIWH J^ L N IW;K G=  H  MK 7> J N%N HRN7> $ GN M"  IL
HNR% %NE SEK IG=V LN' WNE J3^ GK VR4. L%ZAIZTV^ G HNE STMZ
G  \N' G  E-K VJVI3EN G  H31 JK9V *UVQNVZNW. %^ ]  HNE G
HT Z S] ; % G  _" E N-  LNE %] ^  V
9 H  S] ; % RIMV HRGN M"  QR(NV S] ; %
6> Y WN7> %  WNEN S] G K 6
9  M"   I-K GN JT Z N' JIW= V R L> R W G  QI;/
Z]VT  IW=X M" IH HIW][NIRI HIWR HSKR JTZ3WR JNJ GN QIR 3=VR^
QI M"QR(NVJNJIW%N3HHSKRM"S]*NRKQK S]*NRK S];%NGN3=VR^
QR(NVS]GK6
9HSKRJTZ3WR QI M"
Z] Y E  > H V  Z] V R /A
IU%IUZL]VGWNVNI%;RZNI-JT(ZN]N%
V M%NH] ZIMZN%MX]VVRJ^RW N;NM]IVGWNM@@
IU%AUZAQAL] V AG W NMAVNI%A;RZNI'AJT ( ZNI%AQN%AV
A%NHZAZIMZN%MAX]VAVRAJ^RWAN;NMA]IV GWNM
Q%>WNG/AL
 GWNM I%RIWHNRGWWR^J*UVQNVZNW. Q=UZ Q;^RK
`EV;NRIZHJ^LNG (N%7>aV U% IV*UVK;NRIZHHRZG QN;NR
7>aV L]V J^LNHRGM% VNI% W ;RZI' ;NRIZH3HVK]J]% JT(ZNI%
Z>=\ QR(NV 7>VZ QN%  M%  V M  7>MK WNVW IW=X ZIMZN%M  ZMN%
*UVK3HVK>HVM
H NI;NM _E*UVL% %NHZ J^R%=>\GNI-HJTZ
3WR%]^ X]V *UVKI%IZVHNR%QR(NVV*UVKGKHZN-KV
$JTNJVM>]G
M%7>M7>a(XEL.GM% VR IL=( J^RW JIMEWNEKI3TD31KG GWNM
JNJRIMVGWWR^J*UVQNVZN-$ ]IV RIM]GKQ.M%
*NWQR(/AL
 I%RIWHNR IL%4 .  %  3RNS ZN V] S NH^   W %
IVQNU IG= V N M"  V(N M
R  S> R N-KQ. V
$  RIMV M"  G W  WR^ J  *UV
QNVZNW. 3NVT I W;K RIMV J^ L N %] ^  IVQNUH  3NVR Q%> H ^ E  N;%.
HRG M% 7>M *UVK GK HZN-K G ;%K M
H HNE G IR' V
$ Z>HV M
H

52

I3T 3 1K RX%N

QNJ'K V *UVK GK HZN-K HNR% 7>   RW > \ GN-K JT Z NVZN %] ^
JTNJV HRG M% QR(NV VE
H IW=X XE L.G M% IL=( RW JT(Z RXK
I3T 3 1K G  G W  WR^ J  QR(NV JNJ RIMV M]   QNVZ. RIM] G KQ. M%
ILW $  H> 0  QNVZNW. V. HNE ST M Z  G  LNE IW= X  FH  I-= (   QN
U-KQ. H>0 JTSTMZ G %NE =V]\ STIMZ]Y IW=X QN U-KQ. IFR WK
Q] \  QNVZNW. IL%4 .  GN IW3WN3 J^ R ' JT Z NVZN IW= X  Q1= E  IRMN L

QNJ' JVKWRVN JG V


$ %MK$ IURKQ. 7>M RIM U-KQ. I-E-K I-=(
7> M K WR'% JIW= V R W G . %  WK = X  G= I QN M"   I-MK JT Z N' UKVN
QI;QN-  G E
H  V
  IW=X WR'% M" IH L
 N;H J^R' JTZNVZN
GK VN;%N 3NVRIW;K Q%>NR HRGN M" 7>M *UV GK HZN-K G SE
%NE 7> J^R' JTZNVZN %]^ JTNJV M>]GN M" QR(NV 7> G H
E XEN L.GN
M"   I-V
$  I= ;  M> ] G N M"  IH IV] %  JT * ^  M% ST M ZAJT S T M ZAJ^ R ' ST M Z
I-%4 .  %] ^  +ST M ZA-K3A6R J> R 3 + JRST M ZAQH3R J> R 3 QH3R
STMZ + J^R' STMZ A JRZ QH3R STMZ A JTZ3WR A IVJ>R3 QNIG
JT N WNXK 3SG. %NE LNI'Q. L.GN M" 
I-MK JT Z N' IRUW G  Z] Y E  G  > H V  Z] V R  V
$   IW= X
J=31 M" IH J^R' JTZNVZN HIWRGW HSKR JTZ3WR  I33^ R^J ;NR'
HRH  JT U 1 M> ] G   M% V  QNJ'N I%RZE IUQN% QR(NV V= V WIUQN%
HIWUKRI*M  HSKRSN'K G G>QNRN QNJ' *UV. %]^ S
EAS
E H WR'%
HRG  M% 7> M  HIWRG W  HSKR JT Z  3 WR  ST M Z 6RJ> R 3  G  ;NZ
V(N JTSTMZ QH3R J>R3  G ;NZ V
$ I*]% L
 J^R' STMZ JRZ QH3R
J>R3  GN VKRN IR=V;NZ VE
H  M" 7> IW=X QNHNR IW=X IWRNLZN%
M% V(N VE
H  V
$  X ( N Q%NZK E
H  M"   7>   IW= X  WK I-MK HIWRG W
HSKR JT Z  3 WR  Q%NZK J> R 3 R^ J  IW= X  Z%= > \  > I GT 3  QNHNR IW= X
IWRNLZN% M" 

)JIW=VR 3TKZGGWK ZM.J>RN' IW=X I3T31K RX%N GN JTZN'#


STMZN IW3'^ V(N I3W G ZNVNAIJVN#
#
G>RUN QV STMZ G 
U V
$ STMZN IW3'^ QV I3W GN L%Z
JIW= V R 3T K ZGG W K ZM.J> R N' VKRN H] G  UKVNJT " a  U
R \J> R  V
$
JTHNI3V Q%>WNGHRVN 3TK M%^]ZN%JT3NG JGNR V(N IXZ% ENE U
WNZK
JT 3 P %] /  V
$
JT3P %]/ V
$  V=H IWWR' M" IH IH]% MK QXNRKQN *WN%K %]^
]J^R' Z%
R( J^R' HR% WNEK G=G M% 7>M JTIHTVK HMN7>$GK M" V(N
STMZ %NE Q*G ]S]; M" ILW$ JV%K %]^ QR;.U%K HIM]G M% QR(NV
G>RUN STMZ HNE  GK JV%K M" I-=H STIMZ]Y GK I3T31K RX%. G IW3
IW=X RNLN 3TK JRKHI3V G J>=6' 7>aV 3TK IWQN LK % G=IQN IH Z"$ 3TK
%NRG LK V
$ J=>)I6QN K IH M GWIR3C I- STIMZ]Y GK RX%. IHW$ M
-K
ZR I- JT3% G 7>V=R IW=X 3TK %NRG LK % IHMN IH Z"$ QNJ' IJVN
3TK STMZN LK %^] J>=I6QN IH M IJVN TK I- STIMZ]Y GK RX%N QNJ%

IUQN% U] U N

53

HKVK L. 3TK IW3'^ LK I-G RXNI-VN M% L. I3W LK % RIXQN M"
= X A= X  G=  ' GK IHT J N HR
  VG Z R   J^ L  IJVN 3T K  ST M ZN LK %
G=IQN IH S1N %NRG Z"$ QNJ' QNJ%]^ HZE G F>=E 7>aV S"PN JNI-QN
K Z"%]^ %MK$ JVN I- QUN; LE IW=X Z"$ IH=(
$ 7>VJ]% M
IUQN I-=H
M,NR NE V=H IJT(WK GK *NE HRGN IRMN IHV LE GN Q
RA3
R %MK$
JNI-QN IFR QNHN3SN'K M
-K IH VJ HR
 I-=H M,NR NE V=H VJ
HKVN IFR I3T31K HR% GK QNHN3SN'K M
-K I-]% %]^ Z;^ QV H"1*
%NZ G G
 RNH3 QN- 7>%4. G *"Q HNR% Z"$ HZE GN Y]YE F94H %KX
7> a VIRQN 7> > a (  *UWN% IW3'^  3 3 %NU GK 3"  N 7> a V  QX V  J-  %
7>%4. IW=X
$ I-=H QRV JTVWV JTW3 G>RUN  I%HEK 7>M QNHN3 IW=X
Q*^3' JIM' IG\N-K G' E=UK VG *UWN% IW3'^ M
3 IW=X QN- M>'
Z"$ V(N IW3'^ LK G
 K I-]% %^] *UWN% 3]HR WK QN U- GWK % N%]^
IWZN% IW= X  S" P NI-QN V(N ST M ZE
H  IW= X  E"  U-K 7> a (  I-= H  ST M Z.
I-=H IW3'^ V(N I-=H I3W M
R GI\QN IFR I-=H GWK G\K 7>%]^ G\H
IW3'^ LK % IWWHJ^RWH % I%Z% WR%' HKVN STMZAHNE % *UWN%
IW3'^ %]^ XV%N JTGN% HR IG=VK 7>%]^ QNJ' SXJ% GK NG QN-K VG
SXJ% GK HMN'K > ' N-K 
JT3P A 7>aV *UWN% IW3'^ LK % 3TK STMZN LK V(N 3TK I3W
LK %^] IHMN IH I-M IV]%. GK ZNVN M" I-MK LUV L%%K JTIHTVK GWK M"
Z"$ I- GWK %]^ VG GI\QN K LG Z"$ 6
1N SNEH K I-M Z"%^] JNE' IW=X
0>ENQ RMK K
VKRN H]G FN %]+  7>aV 3TK IW3'^ LK % 3TK G>RUN LK GK
7>V>VK HRG M
- IHMNAQNJ 3>=; R^JN M
 I-M NRN ]NR QNJG V
$
7>G*NIV M
 IRMN M" Z"$ IW3'^  STMZN QV 3]HR QK$ * QNJGK
IHT J N %NE MK IWGZN% M. NYN QNIWR*NW L%Z  QV  IVR
* NW
IZT V ^  M
I -QN HRGN M"  QR(NV QK$ IV] %
$  G W  %N3WN% M. H W E
QNJMK I%= V  QIW%N3K  M
  LUV L%%K M
  JT I HT V K G W K M

*UWN% 3] H R S
E   /A G W K L  ZM.*NU IW3'^  QNJ V
$  JT U 1
7>VJ]%  M
- M% V. 7>%4. V
$ SNQG 7>VJ]% M
' WNE STMZN WK QNJG
MK SNEH M
-    IFR Z" $  VZ
U > ' K EKE4 N  HR% WNEN 3] H R HK QNJGK
] V N% %MK$ M
I -QN QR(NV Z" % ] ^  WK 7> V J] %  HR% WNEK QNJMK M

IWXNR HR
/A 7>JR
HV WR'% V
$ I=; M
I-QN IH 3TK STMZN LK 3TK
IW3'^ LK 3TK I3WLK %N3WN% M% IZTV^] QLRAQZR  V 3RW3WR
%MK$ M% V(N G> R UN JT I HT V K  G  J> = V R M% V(N ST M Z HNEAGNI3W
I-%4 .  GN IJVN M" 
VKRN H]G FN %]  7>aV STMZN LK G J=>6' 7>aV IH M ZNVN)
C WG. IW=X L
 STMZ IHMN M" 7>M QNJMK M
 L. H
-K M
R JT*^ M" I-G
7>V=R IW=X G>RUN HIM RMK M" IH Z"$ V(N STMZ I-=H MK M. IFR I-K
H]G G JT3P %]+ 7>aV IHMN M" IH M>' ZRN HNRL I=; HR% G E-K
IWZN% 7>aV S"PH QNJ E
U LEGK J;NR
 LN8  H
-K HIP% HNRL M
'

54

I3T 3 1K RX%N

7>aV LG QNJ Z"%]^ NG HR


U V. Z"$ NMZ' QN LNW.UK GWVN8$ ZRN
G>RUN GN  V(N STMZ GN I;QN% QNJ %^] GN HRG RIM'N XNMKGN M"
NYN G
%4. GN IZR% HRG RM
U V. QNJG HNRL I=; M
' IW=X H
-K
WK 3] G  M  %MK$ M" 
7>JR
HV IWQNI\QN V
$ N_ I=; M" IH G>RUN JTIHTVK  V(N STMZ
HNE  MK IV] %
$  G W VNW. G  ZNVNAIJVN M% V(N ST M ZN IW3'^  V(N
I3WLK %N3WN% M% V J^R% 3HVK >=HV %MK$ M%
IV]%$
 GWVNW. 3TK STMZN LK 3TK IW3'^ LK 3TK I3WLK  GK 3NGK G>RUN
JTIHTVK GWK  % HKVK JT3P %]+A 7>aV VKRN H]G IW=X M"
UKVN QI;QN- %]  GN E
H %] /A
X-WNIVWHNM*NWNMRNLNMVNZNMX
ZVM-WI-IVVN%IWI;%V^QMZV3>VZI@
Q%>WNG/A X  V(N -W  WK   L
 NVIWHNR  V
U>' IW3'^ LK V
$
I(VK *NWNM *NWM%V  L
 RNLNM RL
U>'STMZNLKV
$7>VJ=VK X
V(N VNZNM VZ
U>'I3WV
$]MNRM% VN% 7>%4.*%]^V^] ZVM-W ZR
G>QNRN>I%
ILVI%Z%>NRMKM
'WNEM% I-IV QILMN IWI; LN' V^
JT]V^WNVWIW=X V3^ 7>%4.IW=X
$ QMZ Z"$QV V 7>M ZI ZRIW=X V
%MK$ M%

JIW=VR I3W ZM.J>RN' IW=X I3T31K RX%N GN JTZN'


HNE STMZ V G>RUN V
$ IW3'^  STMZ V I3W GK 7>VJVK

I-GN JT Z N' JIW= V R 3T K  I3W J> R N' UKVN JT " a  U


R \J> R  V
$
JT H NI3V Q%> W NG HT V N 3T D K  M%^ ] Z N% JT 3 NG J G NR I-G  QI;QN-  
R>GR ]IMVN JT3P %]+ 7>aV IHMN M" IH L
 Z^RVK RIMV JRSTMZ M"
7>  K GK Z^ R VK *UWN% GNI3W M"   I-%4 .  G  RKR IW= X
$  I-= H  3HVK
I%HEK 7> M  3HVK Q] I SHN JT I HT V K G> R UN  IVT G  W  L%%K 3T K  ST M ZN
LK 3T K  IW3'^  LK V(N 3T K  I3W LK %] ^  7> V J] %  HR% WNEK ZNVN
HIMEN-K ILGKQ. Q= P  *> L NW. M% 7> M  L
 GNI3W M% 7> % 4 .  %] ^
I3W 3]*^ QV ZM3WR WK HIM]G M% JT3P %]+ 7>aV  7>M QNJ'
NR  Q] U . 7> a V  *Z RZN-  RIM] G   M% 7>   HNE R^ J K ST M Z %  I-= H
I3WE
H  %NZH (N% GN I%RZN' HKVN IFR G
% 4 .  %  JVKAJV%K GN
IWWMNR HKVN ILV
$  I-= H  J> = V R 7> V J] %  M
I -QN 7>  GN %NZ IW3'^
R= I \QN JT 3 P %] +  
IFR R> G R ] I MVN QI;QN-  %] +  JT 3 P %] +  7> a V  ST M ZN LK %
IHMN IH Z R K 7> V J= V K WK *UWN% GNI3W ST M ZAHNE  V(N JT I HT V K
G> R UN  G  ] 
U  %NE QR(NV JVKAJV%K G  IWWMNR V
$  M
- K IFR
Z" % ] ^  S M
3  HR IG= V N
IFR R> G R ] I MVN QI;QN-  %] +   JT 3 P %] +  7> a V  IHMN M"  IH
I- JTHNR STMZ. IW3'^ V(N R>GR I-%4. IV]%
$ GWVNW. IW=X U>' M%

IUQN% U] U N

55

JT ] V ^  I3W HNEAST M Z  U> ' NVKV Z] %   U-  M%


I-= (   XNR I= ;  M
-   QR(NV GNI3W HNEAST M Z  V  JT I HT V K
G>RUN  V
$ MK 7>VJ]% M
- M% IV]%
$ *UWN%. 3TK STMZN LK 3TK IW3'^
LK V(N 3TK I3W LK  GK ZNVN LK 3TK G>RUN LK V(N IJVN LK 3TK L
VK
I%R]L% STMZ  M" I-M IV]%
$ JT*^ RLU>'ASTMZN LK VU>'AIW3'^ LK
VZU> ' AI3W LK M%

JIW=VR 3TKZG*UWV UKVN LK IW=X I3T31K RX%N GN JTZN'


I- GN JTZN' JIW=VR UKVN LK QI;QN-  E
H  V
$  V=H M"
ST M Z HNE  HIM IRMN M"   IH JT I HT V K G> R UN  V. Z R K JV%K M"   Z" $
STMZ HNE  I-GN JVK M. NY G
M. G ]
U V
$ RW JTN'KQ. IMV
IV] %
$  U> ' . RLU> ' AST M ZN LK VU> ' AIW3'^  LK VZU> ' AI3WLK  GK
7> V J= V K M
- K M"   Z" $  ST M Z  RW JT N 'KQ. GN IJVN M. V(N JT I HT V K
G>RUN  I-%4. GK ZNVN M" Z"$ I-G 7>GR IW=X SKL (NJ%N HRGN M.
IL V
$ RW JTN'KQ. GK 7>VJVK M>]GK M" JT I HT V K G> R UN  IV] %
$  U> ' .
RLU> '  ST M ZN VU> '  IW3'^   VZU> '  I3W  LKW. %^ ]  HT Z Q;NR 7> a V
RKR IW=X S]%4G M%
I-MK JTZN' QI;QN-  E
H  V
$  V(N  IW=X WK M"
UKVNQI;QN- %] GNE
H%]+/A
7>R;WZ^EZQ;M3N\ZQ3WV(ZJTNM>MQWZ
6%G.IJR'NI%MVZWGMWGIWV@
Q%>WNG/A 7>R;WZ^EZ 7>J=R%]^J^R%JTZNVZ.QNIGJ>R3JTZ3WRR^JK
L94 WNEN Q;MN\Z %KX %]^ 3N\NWNEN QWZ QIW%N3K Q3WV(Z
IWVNIRVIST?M"[
9ILMNZ,S^V  ILG 6%G.I 6
1A6
1IM=N
I1M'KQ. JT'NI% J=V JTNM>M HIM]GM% VZ 7>%]^]NRR^JKIST?%]^ M
L
 WG RWNU.IMVLN'GNM" M 7>M WGIWV J^R%IUQN%KQR(NV
VVWGR3K M"
UKVNQI;QN- GNE
H%]+
Q;MX7>R;WZJTTVNMV3N\NMU>'JTWTS>;M
IW3JTWNENMQ;MXZ^ENI%Q%>V
] VNI%HRZ%>S;
] KI%Z%>3E
H@

Q%>WNG/A V  7> IST?GKQ. Q;M  %KX X  V(N 7>R;WZ  7>J=R
U>'JTWTS>;NM  IV]%. U>'. STMZNARLU>' IW3'^AVU>' I3WAVZU>' R^JK
JT^VNM F"EKQ.M
-KQ. IW3JTWNENM IWHNRAHNZHT
;E
*Z
MQM]HNR
R^JKH
JE 3N\NM YNEKSTMZNIW3'^I3W HTZN%>S];KI% LKW.%]^HRZ.IW=X
S]%4GK QIJ WK Z^ENI% L94.Z>=\HNR%M% X V(N Z%>E
H Z%3E
HA
QT(NVIJT(WKE
HIW=X Q;M %KXA%RHXRNKE=\^%KQ.IW=X 7^R;WZ
7>J=RWRUE
HQNIGIW=X Q%>]VVNI% IWWI(VHKV M
- M%
UKVNQI;QN- E
H%]+/A
%R^JZQ-KMV(N7>JE*V%Q]VM%XQNIGM%

56

I3T 3 1K RX%N

XZJTIV3PNQ3WV(Z-%Z>IWR^YZ^EZQ]U3VT'IGT9%I6=VWN@
Q%>WNG/A Q  I- RX%N GN %  %MK$ QNIGM  3>R^QNV X  V(N
%  %N MK Q]VM  Q]V M" %  %MK$ V(N  W"N R^JZ  WR^J 7>JE*V
JNI-QNL.GNM" X V(N -KM IL=(IWXNRHNEIW=XQR(NVZRG>QNRNIG=VN
LN IRMN UKVN IUQN% IW=X J^R% LN'HNRK Z"%]^ WK %  %MK$ M" ZJTIV3PN
IH7$IHRWSTIMZ]Y.GKRX%.GKX]UKVR4.(N-KI(VKM"GNZ"%]^WKIUQN%
%MK$M" -%Z I- >IWR^9Z^EZ X]UK(N-KI(VKWNEN QWV(Z ZLS^V
R^J WNE ]NR R^JK IST? G IUQN% %^] Q]U 33VT'  J^R% IUQN% R^JK
IGT9
%  IGT9 3^\3Z WG QR(NV VVW IUQN% G G>QNRN LN'HNR I6=VWN
H=1H QR(NV I%R]L% GK *UVK %]^ 6I'H QR(NV I6' *]>U>R LN'H STMZ.
IW3'^I3WSTMZV(NJTSM
T ZV
$WKQ=U J^R%STMZGKVEN3HR%KXNMKGKM"
UKVNQI;QN- %] GNE
H%] /A
VVMJGZVVJIRZNIUTVWZIZ%UVNM%I%WRV]IV*^M
VZ-WXQNGZJ>RZJTJGVMJT=WTIVMJTTVNJ>RN'K@
Q%>WNG/ALG
$V=VWGR3K]VIZELNW VVM I-G SNQG VV 7>
JTZNVZ.G JGZ JG(N%QR(NVVE
H%]^ IJTZNRIUTVWZ *EK*.VK
\
L%N XNMK- IZ%  IL IW=X UVNM  U- M
- N;H *^M  IFR %
I%WTV]IV  Z>9H ]NR IW=X %MK$ QN7>$G X  V(N VM  IL JTZNVZ.AJTZ
QH3RSTMZ%NE J>RN'K QNIG JTWT=IVM RX%NAI3R31 JTTVN 7>VJ]%M
-K
M" VZ QIUQNV QN;Z QNIGZQR(NVZ"$HNEI%R]L% J>R^3Z J^R%
JTZNVZ.GK -W MK JTJG Z"$3R'IW=XM.V(N7>GKJ^LNHRGNM.
UKVNQI;QN- GNE
H%] /A
GWI-ZJ>R^E
HH3TMXQH3TM-WX
H3TTWNI'*^VNI%H^1=(MQH3TM7>XV@
Q%>WNG/A E
H I-]NRIW=X GW G
 JTHNRG H3TM %N3WN% X
QV QH3TM QIW%N3K J>R^3
M *UWN%M% -W I-KJTHNR I-
I-%4.
G
%.JT*^Q.GE
H.IW=X TWNI' ]J^R% *^VNI% JTN'KQ.GRKRV. H3TM
%N3WN% X  QV H^1(T  LKW QNVZ. QH3TM  QIW%N3K 7>XV  IHMN
L.GNM"
UKVNQI;QN- %] GNE
H%] /A
7>VZMJ>R3MV^Q]MJRZNVZ.I-IV7>GNMTVRM
ME
HVTZQNIW3IS*RIVQWM-K3WRM@
Q%>WNG/A 7>VZM  7>VZ J>R3M  JT* V^  V. Q%M  7>JR
HV G
%
$
JT*^Q. 6RJ>R3 V QH3RJ>R3  V
$ WK I*]% MK M" I-IV  I-M WNVW IW=X
JTZNVZN  JTZNVZ. 7>GNMTVM  IHMN IUQN M" M  L
 E
HVTZ  IV]%. E
H.
IW=X QIW3 JTW3HRH IS*TIV *GN;NR%J
3'HRGNM"V QWM
QIW%N3K -K3WRM JT*^Q.IW=X3T3PQR(NVZR=(JT*^ M"
*NWQR(/A UKVN IUQN% GNVN JT*^ % HWE I-]%. MK G=IQN M" IH
I-M ]NR 7>E1 E1H M
- IST? ZN% LN'
 7>aJR L94. Z^E  V. J^R'
JTZNVZN M" %KX I14'KQ. QNIG M
R IM= LN'
 I- ]NR R^JK IST?

IUQN% U] U N

57

G MRH *NU GN I*]%AI*]% WR'% L


 ]V LN'GN M" 7>M V=VWGR3K ]V
M" ILG IW3 IW=X UKVN QI;QN-  E
H %]+  IW=X IHMN M" UKVN
QI;QN-  E
H %] A IW=X HWE I-]%N MK G=IQN M" IH IV]% U>'
R^JK 3N\N M" I-=( IWXNRHNE IW=X QR(NV UKVN IW=X Z"$ QNJ%^] UKVN
IUQN%GNVN  J^R' LN'HNRK %MK$ G HGN IH7>$IH Z"%]^ I- ]NR GK
RX%N G QNIG V Q]V GN IUQN% %MK$ M" 7>G E-K UKVN QI;QN-
 E
H  %]   IW= X  IHMN M"  IH IHK V= V WGR3K ] V  V
$  7>   J^ R '
JT Z NVZN GN IUQN% LN'
 I- UKVN QI;QN-   E
H   IW= X  7> 
V=VWGR3K ]V GK JIMXN' G=K M" IH 7>M ]NR R^JK IST? G MRH *NU
GN J^R' IUQN% HRWN-UN 7>K V
$ J>=6
 UKVN QI;QN-  G E
H
 IW=X IHMN M" IH 7> V=VWGR3K ]V G IZE' V
$ SNQG 7> JRZJG
JT Z  3 WR GK \
L  HR%K XNMKGK M"  QR(NV 7>   V= V WGR3K ] V  G  G=  
Q%>  NR N;%N HR%K XNMKGK M"  ILG  J^ R ' Z
H 3 Q%NIG Z
H 3
JT N JV M> ] G N M"   UKVN QI;/ E
H  A IW= X  J31 HKVN M"  IH
IV]% JT*^ M% I-=H 6RJ>R3 STMZ  G^RN QH3R J>R3 JTSTMZ  VKRN
JRZ QH3R J>R3 J^R' STMZ  6R J>R3 V(N QH3R J>R3 WNVW
IW=X QIW%N3K %MK$ M% 7>M QIW%N3K JTZNVZN V. I-%4. G
%4. V
$ M
R
MK M" 7>MK IV]%. E
H. IW=X JTW3 HRH RW GN ;NR' J
3' HRGN M"
7>JR
HV 3TKZG*UWV UKVN QI;QN-  E
H  V
$  V(N  A
 IW=X I-M JTZNI'V M
I-QN M" IH 7>E1 E1H M
- ]NR R^JK IST? GK
Z^E QR(NV L94 V. JRZ QH3R STMZ QR(NV J^R' STMZ M" IL %NE
J^R' IST? GN JNE' J
3' M>]GN M" V(N IST? GN L
 IM=N IJT(WK V
$ SNMR
LZK% G  %NE IG\N-K IG] G N M"  7> M  V%N M> ] G N M"  7>  %^ ]  QH3R J> R 3
LN'
 7> V% V
$ 7>aJR X=E HR M
R Z
1K YNR I%HEGK M" 7> IW=X I-=H
YNR V. STMZ QR(NV 6RJ>R3 LN'
$ V(N 7>K YNR V
$ M
R IV]% N\.WN
I%HEGKQ. M% 7> % 4 .  %] ^  ST M ZN IW3'^  V(N I3W LN'
$  V(N 3N\NW. V
$
Q= U   J= V   R^ J  IW= X  ]  NIRH JT N 'K LN'
  7> J R
H V UKVN QI;QN-  
E
H  A IW= X  J31 M"  IH 6RJ> R 3 ST M Z  V(N QH3R J> R 3
JTSTMZ  V(N I-%4. G E
H. IW=X IL]% JTN'K M% 7>%4. G (^E 3RKR V.
%N3WN% M% V(N LKW QNVZN QIW%N3K M"  QR(NV 7> J R
H V G
W  $  JT * ^
V  I-%4 .  G  Q] V RUV RW JT N 'K %N3WN% M% *E  MK QH3R J> R 3
JRSTMZ  %]^ QIW%N3K IHMN M" JT]V^ WNVW IW=X QIW%N3K JTZNVZN V.
I-%4. G
%. V
$ QE=U M" 7>M IV]%. E
H. IW=X JTW3 HRH *GN JNE'A
J
3 ' HRGN M"   7> J R
H V IWWR' IW= X  IV] %  JT * ^ Q . GN I*] % AI*] %
IWWR' IG= V N M" 

JIW=VR SN-KSE V(N JIW=VR H>RN' 3RKF IW=X I3T31K


RX%N GN JTZN'

I- GN JTZN' JIW=VR SN-KSE V(N JIW=VR H>RN' 3RKF IW=X WK M"
H> R N' 3RKF IW= X  JIW= V R SN-KSE GN WK IUQN% M"   I-E-K

58

I3T 3 1K RX%N

I-%4. G
M. JIW=VR GUT](. % IZEAL>E H JTZNI'V HKVN M" IH H' V(N
H"  N M"  I3T 3 1K RX%MNR V(N 7>  GN WNVW %NZ HK M" 
JIW= V R SN-KSE 7> V J= V K UT ] (  FN %]   Q/ /A/ 7> a V
6W.IG%/AJTN'KQV Z%=>\/
M
RJTN'KQ.GKRX%NHRH+IFRJTZ3WR%IHMNZ"$Z%=>\.%]^QNJ'
WR^JQ%>NRQNJ'KZN%VNIW=XS'NI-QNL
RWJTN'KQ.VHNS^R=\UN
+VGJTZ3WR% Z%=>\%]^ QNJ' WR^JG Q%>NR7>VJ]%HKVNQNJ' MK
WR^JQ%>NRJTZ3WR% 7>%]^ 7>VJ]%HKVN%RQV %NRKHRH Z%>=\.GK
I3T31KHKVK
+JT*^%Z%=>\.G\N'E-KIL]%SK,WNE6
1J9VIL]%J9IW=XSK,
WNE _EM]>G M%7>M*
L%E-KJTGN%HKV ZN\N'N%MK$IHMN
=VW.IG%/AIW3NRNZGNIG%/
JTZ3WR%6IG%IW=XI3T31KGK7>VJ=VKHKVKV(N=VW$IG%QNRNZHKVN
JIW=VR SN-KSE % I=; HR IG=VN IH JTZNVZN ZN%W >IGT3 RKR
IW=X M" IL% 6 IG%. IW=X RW I3T31K GK RX%. HKVK V(N IW3RNZ
HKVN
JIW=VR H>RN' 3RKF ^RV F>RHN%K  QNI-V %]   
QNI-V/AFENV>IVQEAHNIFR%WLIMGM>ZISMKILMNG%HSKRN
HSKR% @@
*NWQR(/AI-GN*NWQR(M" IHMLRVZ>M]ZGLKGN\>GN JT*^ HIM
IRMNM" IHM J"U]SRCQNJHNFR. L
 I-=HJT*^ GK*UVKIVQNUH M
RGWK
GWVNW.V(NZ^RVKQNIGGKJ^LNHRGM% GNHIM'N%NZ]%'NIH7>$IH7>M
E
HHSKR%]^ J^R'JTZNVZN%MK$Z]%GQNJZR G>QNRNIG=V I-H>RN%G
IUQN%GQN;NR7>aVQ1=ERIM'NIHHSKRMKJ^R%JT*^M"V(NHSKRQ=E4N
G E-K]][R3HR%N E9%N%MK QR(NVQIY=URIM'N
QNI-V/A  /AW A VWHHE QEE A MI7>EEIL EN Z^V> W ISSM
ISMZIGMK W HFN ISMK ISL>%^IS IQSNIGMK \SKRN HSKRN @@
*NWQR( M" IH M,RV Z>M]ZG LK IL%]^ QNJ'N JT*^ Z]%G M% 7>M
Q=E4N JT*^  IHK M
R J^R' JT*^ G SNR ]HV HR IRMN M" IH M J"U]SR
7> HSKR JTZNVZN 7>aV IW3WN3 R=\ L
 V"%]^ I,]GN ZMNVZN G R^J IW=X
QNHNR IW= X  QNH  IZE  K 7> M  HG  ZR% WNEN %MK$ M"  QR(NV
WNVW  IW=X QIW%N3K M" VNRKF %NE 7>GK JNIH JIW=VR ZIMZN
GN U>'UN' HRGN LN 7>M HSKR Q=E4N HIWRGW  J^LN G 
U M" V(N
QNJ'  7> J NH. G  RW JNJ. GN IW%N3 HR% WNEN M" 
A
QNI-V/A
AQEELK\EHZNWNIVWEQRLWZNS"%M>ZNFKIVVIV
QNIZ% > Z ZVWN QEEQIR3 QRRMZN%>  FQE ISMK \SKR%
HSKR% @@
*NWQR( M"  IH M,RV Z> M ] Z G %] ^  H> R N' RKF S
E ' WNEN JT * ^
Q= E 4 N  HIM IRMN M"  IH 7> M  HSKR JT * ^  7> M K M"  IL%  LZK% V(N
QNZN% G IW=X L
 WK IWGZN% M" RW I3T31K GK RX%N 6 IG% IW=X

IUQN% U] U N

59

HKVK V(N =VW$ IG% 7>aJR QNJ' VE


H IW=X I][N3% 7>aV IWRNLZN%
M
 S" P  IUQN 7>  G  IW3  GK LN'HNRK IHK SN?SR  V= V WGR3K
]V V
$ J>=6

7>   J^ R ' JT Z NVZN GK JT N JVK IHW $  M
W  U K V(N WNVIWH IUQN%
V. IHK V= V WGR3K ] V  SN?SR  V
$  J= > 6
  Z" $  %MK$ LN'GN
7> J R
H V G
% 4
$  JIW= V R ;RZ. I-N-K V(N Z>  EZN%  G  JIW= V R
3NVR. %  WK IZEAL> E  H  JT Z NI'V HR IG= V N M"  IH RW I3T 3 1K
RX%MNR RW JNJIW%N3H RW 3HVKZN% QIW%N3K JT Z NVZN
ZN%W >IGT3 RKR IW=X QNH IW=X M" V VE
H IW=X RIM]GN M" 7>GN
%NZ HSKR M" 7>K %]^ Q=E4N M^ QHSR^ WK HIM]G M%
QNGR'K-$ ;RZGN LK % J^L HSKR JT*^ V
$ J>aI6QN IH M RW
3HVKZN%C Q= L  V= H  I-M V= V WIUQN% IHK %  %MK$ G= I QN W G . G
ZRZU IUQN%KQ. % WK %MK$ G=IQN I- V
$ I=; M" IH XNR
$ JIW=VR
W G . V(N XNR JIW= V R HV S . H> R N' 3RKF QNIG  0^ P   M% J^ R '
JTZNVZN % IHMN IH/A
HSKRWGHVS0^P %N*N-K0^P M" L
 Z0 %NMK$
*NWQR( M"  IH XNR
$  JIW= V R W G  IR= U W G AQ= ( RWW G AL> R W G A
NZ WG  V JIW=VR XNR
$ HVS H>RN' 3RKFALS^RA VRNV A I-L]E
UEV %MK$ M% JT ] V ^  L
 I-%] ^  Z0 %MK$ JN-  7> M  %NGN% M%

J^L HSKR JTZ3WR HIWRGW  LK GK Q]IZTVSN'K IW=X


I3T 3 1K RX%N
IW33/A MP IE\K Q]IZTV SN'K ]%  V
$ LG J^L%K HIWR
GW HSKR JTZ3WR  EKE4NZ-K RKR IW=X J]L NE. G M
-  ]% 
LG HIWRG W  HSKR JT Z  3 WR  ZUMR (N% V  IM RKR VE
H
U-  G  IW= X  EU*U  NE JIME. JRZ J^ L  HSKR JT Z  3 WR
HIWR G W  LK G> Q NRN QNJ'  I%= L K  W H GN *UV  QNGR'K- $
;RZGN NIMS LK %] ^  > ' N-K K V(N ;%K ;RZGN NIMS LK %
IE= J KS= ;  HKVK K JT ] V ^  7>   Z  $  G  JIW= V R IM] G ^ Q . V(N JIW= V R
Z>  EZN%. G  %NGN% U> R ^ Q . %KZAMHKZ.  %  IHMN IH I-M ;N'H
L>ENMN  HSKR 0^PN M" IH WK GUT]( IW=X 3TK STMZN LK 3TK IW3'^
LK V(N 3T K  I3W LK G  ZNVNAIJVN GN %NZ %MK$ M"   I-M IV] %
$  JT * ^
QIW%N3K M% I-%4 .  GN L%Z IZT V ^  %MK$ M> ] G N %N MK JIW= V R W G . V
JIW= V R H> R N% H> R KF QNIG IW= X  HSKR JT Z  3 WR GN JT Z N' M"  V(N
JT Z NVZN %^ ]  I%RNHNR IEI\QN M"   QK$ JT V KIG% J94 G   M. *
E K
QNVZNW. %  7> % 4 .  IWXH6'. XV> R  U> R ^ Q .  7> a V  IW3WN3 HR IEQN
=XZ=>X I-M HSKR ;N'H V. QI=I\QV M" V(N U>R^ LK I=I\QV M%
= X  HIM RM  M
' U   Q= L  7> M K = X N-K JT H N3 IW= X
$  QN RMK M"  V(N
QNJ'  RW JIW= V R ;RZ. G  JIW= V R GUT ] (  UWNM M% I-V
$  I= ;

60

I3T 3 1K RX%N

M"  IH J^ R ' JT Z  3 WR RW I3T 3 1K RX%MNR H= > E  HRVNR V(N RW= U
HIWRGW HSKR JTZ3WR  MK M" L
 HN3K S%NR3  IW=X HZE G F>=E
7> a V  JT U 1 M
-   V(N  NE V= H  WNVIWH V L
Z -K RKR G  7> a JR
ZN%W > I GT 3  RKR MEH  V L  GN S'NH  RM  V(N QNJ'  G> Q NRN RXK
I3T 3 1K GN PKHAPNH WNVIWH V= V W  IUQN% G H   IMRKR VE
H
XE  U-   IHT J N JT  Z K JNPH J= 9
4  I%Z% Q] I ZT V SN'K JT Z  3 WR HSKR
NIMS LK G> Q NRN 7> X NIRV/A
;RZGN  LU S
RN%N H
-K %N LN%  JG I%RWN%N@
IM HNR% Z"$ H(N JNRN LU  HMK- RNZ I%QNRN@
MK IUQN% LU LKW >%N7> * LKW
$HN *RZ I%N7>@
QS Z" $  V> Z   HM>  IXVN-K IVT G  W %HK 7> V J= V K *N-K@
H>0 3]\J HM
 U>MRN-K S ]3 V>ZMR IZ=1 LN-K@
*RZ U- LU WG J>RN%N QNIG RNZ HN *G %N LN%N@
RNZ RNZ S LUV S\N% QNIG RNZ H
-K ISREN LN%@
IUQN%K >% 
 IMRG EUN-K Z^R\ >% 
 UZ %N JN-K@
Z. Q31] U K IJVN I%R] L % W  LZ GNR> '  W] 3 % Q] L %@
JIME  HK$%4  I%R] L % RNI- JK6    ZNI-QN 7> J LN-K@
ZNI-QN R^J G\ QIV 
*N GW I%R]L% V% Z% E
*N@
HNZG W  ;RZRN-  VN-   G W K H
 V> R VMK ;R \N- @
J 1    G W K HRK J> H NRN NIMS Z R N HR
 7> S NRN@
1 R  > % K VS MZ VM. QN-   Q31] U K HN S] ;  6> 9 N- @
VE
H  Z  HK%4 .  G> R NXNRK HNE I%R] L % IG%4 .  I%HNRK@
ZNI-QN ZV GKQN *UN-K 
E4 3]\ H
 G^RK JR QN-K@
Q31]UK QR HNE QS G
-K Z]G HRZ  U- I*U
-K@
;RZRN- H
 IMHZV HK$%4. %? R\N  *UHR EK$%4.@
;RZRN- HK$%MN *
U IWENN ZNI-QN H
 RMK VS QNN@
VK% J>=VR Q31]UK LN- STMZN IW3'^ I3W %NZ ;RN-@
VK% G W  IWVNR XEN-   I-%Z   M  LU ;
\ N \N- @
J> R 3 UZ H"    H
I - JNW   HNE I%R] L % LU *RZN- @
VK% E
H  QNJ%  > V  GK$%4 .  > ] %  I%R] L % SNN EK$%4 . @
QE?I%R]L%>]%IPHN%NSTMZNIW3'^ I3W*G%NLN'N@
VK% GW 
 7>%H
 I;QNW$ I%R]L% HN W JNR %N JNW@
QE? I%R]L% S9N S1JNRN VK% E
H LKW HK$%4 QMNRN@
STMZN IW3'^ I3W %MK$ SXN- HE \N- J>]% ;^R 7>YN-@
IV%H  > V  M" $  IV%
$  G W N Q.;R LKW HRV M" $   W N@
QHNE J^R3 HNM^ %.IM XK$%4. HNE JN- SMK UM EK$%4.@
STMZ HNE HE LU LN% QNIG STMZ H
 %N JIMXN%@
VK%
$ GWN QR QVNRN VNH
 *L HE ]NRN@
VK%
$  U> ' HN M IWVNRN ;RZGN Z" $  HM
 J> H NRN@
U>' VK%
$ HK *UVK Z$  *^E JR
 ]NR@

IUQN% U] U N

61

H M "  H S K R  I% = L  % N Z  IS %   H"    7 > V R " $  JN R @


7> J R
H V Q] I ZT V  SN'K IW= X  JT Z  3 WR HSKR NIMS LK QNJ'  I%=LK
WH 3TK ;RZGN NIMS LK %]^ HIM RM M% IH ;RZGN I-M NRN
]NR V=VWIUQN% G JT*NW V
$ IWXIEV M" IH %]^ J^R' Z
H3 ZNRU
V(N J^ R ' I3T 3 1K RX%N GN IUQN% %MK$ M"   I-E-K Z" $  QNJ%^ ]  Z R 
G>QNRN RXK I3T31K GK H(N >'N7>$GN M. S>=;KZN% IWQNHVK V. V>R]V
MK Z0 LN'U JT]V^ L
 NR JTZN'. %]^ G\H WK %MK$ Z]%'U V. 7>M
%NGN% JTN'K HNE G JT*NW V
$ JT*NIWV M% 7>M *UVK 
U %MK$ M>'
Z" $  G=  GN M. IV] %
$  *UWN%. ST M ZN LK IW3'^  LK V(N I3WLK  GK
7>VJ=VK IHW$ M
-K 7>%4. GK ZNVN LK V. Q31]UK G>RUN  M" V(N IJVN
L
V K I%R] L % ST M Z HNE  M"   JIME  ST M Z GK 7> V JVK Q] Y   V
 M
- K
IFR G> R UN GK 7> a VJVK M
- K G> R UN G  R^ J  V
$  QNHT I 3V M
H   HNE
ST M Z  %  UEVK 6 9 A6N9  HKVK VG G> R UN JT I HT V K  %  I-G  J 1
IW=X 3R' E-K Z"$ 7>a( IUQN IL=( L
VK I%R]L% HNE K VG *WN%K
%]^ STMZ G 7>GR V
$ I%HNE H 7>G I-=HK STIMZ]Y ZV  3]\ H
 GK
G^RK V *L IG=VN L
VK I%R]L% ;RZRN-  % JTIHTVK GWK G>RUN  G
%NE *
UAWEN HKVN I-%4. G
M. G ]
U  %NE IV]%
$ U>'. 3TK STMZN
LK 3T K IW3'^ LK V(N 3TK I3WLK  GK 7>V JVK M
-K I-%4. IV]%
$ U>' .
RLU> '  ST M ZN LK VU> '  IW3'^  LK VZU> '  I3WLK  GK MK N;%N
HRH RW JTN'K HNE LNE IW=X _ M% LG V=H WNVIWH Z]VR %MK$
IZE U N J^ R ' Z
H 3 IHW $  M
W  U N
IW33/A IJQNR JNPH
 IWXNR HR
 IH 3TK STMZN LK 3TK IW3'^ LK
V(N 3TK I3WLK GK I(VK QIW%N3K G=K U-K K RW IM]G^ ZNL M>'
V=H IV]%
$ JTZNVZ. %]^ QLR QZR V L%ZAIZTV^ RIMV Z]%G RM LGIH
I-M IV]%
$ %N3WN% M% I-%4. G IJVN HNE R^JK STMZ V(N ZNVN G>RUN
JT I HT V K Q31] U K  M"  L"  N QNJ%  J^ R W JT Z N'. IW= X  JI94 Q N I-M
IUQN% QNJ' 3NVR. IW=X WK IWGZN% M" JT]V^ IM]G^ ZNL G HE>=UK
U> R ^ Q . IR3KQ. ] V . %] ^  IUQN% %MK$ L
 QI;QNJH JNPHT Z  IE
S  V
$ MK QJTKIXV %MK$ M" 7>M QI;QNJH PKH %MK$ IWGWN% %MK$
M" IWIGQNR(KQ. G *IW=\ GN G>3Z' M" I- JTHNR ILM9 U>R^Q. %]^
M> '  V= H  I-M %MK$ JVN IH 3T K  ST M ZN 3T K  IW3'^   V(N 3T K  I3WLK G
ZNVNAIJVN H '  M%V. 7> M  IR3K U> R ^   ] V  %] ^  IUQN% %MK$ M"   IL
HNR% V
$ NRN *UV ZNL %]^ 3NVR IWR>=; IUQN% E
H WG QR(NV
G] V  H(N  > ' N H  QIUQN% %NE JRKJ^ R '
' HR IG= V N 3NVRIW;K
IWR>=; *UVK N;%N HRN H JTZNVZN G WNVIWH EN* J^R' Z
H3  V
$
W]IXV R=I\QN * GN ZN%W L%Z %31 HR IG=VN IH7>$IH 3TK ZG*UWV
UKVN QI;QN-  E
H A IW=X WK I-MK JTZN' M" IH L
 3NVR
IW;K %]^ IVQNUH Z%ZN%K J^LN HRGN M" 7>%]^ H
-K EN* %MK$ M>]GN
J^ R ' JT Z NVZN HSKR LK %  ] %   V
$  MK RW 3NVR. > H V
IUQN% QNJ'K Q] I ZT V SN'K HIWRSN'K  IW= X  G=  'N QNR] *  HKVN K

62

I3T 3 1K RX%N

JT ] V ^  7>   QIUQN%K U> R ^ Q . %  I-M IUQN% *UV ZNL V= H  LN' %MK$


IG=VN L
 WRVZN% IW=X J=31 M
 IRMN M" I-V
$ I=; M" IH HIWR GW
HSKR JT*^  V=VWGR3K ]V R^J IW=X QNJ J^R' JTZNVZN MK QN- K

QNGR'K- $  URKSGN NIMS LK GK Q] I ZT V SN'K IW= X  I3T 3 1K


RX%N GN JTZN'
QNIG RZ"'K G UT]( FN %]+  V
  V=H
QNIG RZ" ' K QGEK NRN LN IG% M
V   ;> ] ; > ] H NRN@@
IV J>R3 HK%MN JTHN3N MZ M
V V?V HSKR \WNN@@
Z%Z
MK%KIRLKZNI-QNIVJ>R3I-HI\QNES'NI-QN@@
;RZRN-  IRL  GRSN%K X  P L> U VJ  W N P.%K@@
J> R 3 IJT ( WK LNH^ ]  GK$%4 K $ RNL HR
 G W N QN;K%K@@
STIMZ]YI-=HKRNLV>]ZGK$%4.Z%HKI-=6N*L>UEK$%4.@@
ZNI-QN Z^E R^J I-=H 6NLN Z
IM IE- IL]%M]^ ;RZRNLN@@
;RZHNZ%X]XEIX=V;NIRQNZ%ZNI-QNHNR^JISXNRN@@
X] X E X R K XJE IXRNUN N H  JR  RS LNUN@@
;RZRN- HKQN Z% HN *NUK IW3 WN%N ]U  LNUK@@
QNIGJ>R3QGEKQ%RNUK;RZRN-GKQNIGE$IVQNUK@@
J>R3 E
H $ IGQN <MN-K QUZ GKJ XIE QN- *NI-@@
IML GN IL GKJ RM]VN HNR' H$% H$% H>E J](N@@
;T Z RN-  S
E   GRSN%K > %
 IML GN ST M ZIUQN%K@@
XP >U MZ WN HK$%4K$ J>R3 JTI(WK MZ H]^ GK$%4K$@@
X] X E R^ J  *I-QN Z% S R N Z%Z
M K%K PIUQN * $ RN@@
IVJ>R3 H %N Z% *N- J>R3 E
H  MZ XE QN-@@
QUR GKJ >%V SY*NUK IML GN Z1
 Z% JNUK@@
S
E IMLGN IGE GN%K MZ V
 XNHR V MGN%K@@
IVJ>R3  QRL U>LNR]^ LS V>ZMNRN ISWN' 7>VNR]^@@
IML GN H
 HKQN IJQN%N VE
H  IEQN JT W N%N@@
IVJ>R3 NIMS RS]UK QIWUV QGEK QXE Q*]UK@@
;RZRN- V>ZMRN GRSN%K QUR GKJ XIE U- JTN'K@@
H% M>HZ HRK QRL QWNLN HM. JPNW
 7> ;RZRNLN@@
*-K QWNL QGEK I-=H NXN IW3 E
H LN VK%M]^ WNXN@@
IMLIWZN%XEQI;HN-KI6%Z$QURGKJXIEQN-K@@
MZV
 QRLHRKQ%>RNUKV>ZMIW3E
HLNW
 WY*NUK@@
;RZRN-  H  XE  IWZN%N ZN%R
W R QN-  JT N %N@@
ZN%R
W R RM% %N JN-   GR"  HSKRN (.%N EN- @ @
S] H %NE HK IW3ZK SN1K VM. HSKRN R
H K [N1K@@
I-% J.X
$ IZIE LUV S];N%N E=\ XRNK LKW ]VN%N@@
STMZNIW3'^ZM3WRZNI-QN;RZRN-HNRNLJPNI-QN@@

M  \
\ N J> R  0^ P K SNLK I*V S" H > ] P  GUNK NLK@@

IUQN% U] U N

63

HTIVZ LKW *^E.% *N-K I%L [R HK V


 \SR %N JN-K@@
WN EN\ 7>LJ$ I%V M]N -H EN\ IW%3 I%V Q]N@@
7>JVK \JVK NM JTE FRK MR3 3
H L$RN LZ LRK@@
J.X
 V=VW M"$ JTEQ Z.MK VWU>' RLU>' VZU>' 0.-K@@
QNP
$Q]UIZEKM"ZNI-QNIJ]YSTIMZ]YHE*RZNI-QN@@
N Z$ >RIV 3SG HK Y
RK IJ]Y STIMZ]Y EUK M" \
RK@@
3>WNN JNR Z% UM RN\
 \
EIM HJN1 QZKR XN\
@@
>%N7$^ M] 3SG >% GNN QUZ GKJ M" QU M" SNN@@
*WNUR LZ G] Y  LZN%N ;RZRN-  HN M"  VES.%N@@
JNX
$ 7>J=R JG HK %URK SN1 IWM]UZ S]HK YURK@@
MZRN ;RZRN- 
$ GNWN *WNUR Z$ LKW *RZNW.@@
MZV
$HM"$QUZHKSN'KLM.QIWUVQGEKQNJIS%N%K@@
S] G K 6
9  MZNRN %NZ]   QLR QZR M"  QI(R PNZ] @ @
L>U% L>U% MZ HMV QN-" LZ L
$RN  M] 6>1N-@@
L
 H
-K Z.% 3SG MZNRN *WNUR %MK$ *RZ$ ;NRN@@
NZ$>RIV3SGHNE\NV%Q]GRZ%HM
HK$%4KG\N@@
GN URKS QUZ HK SN'K \
LN M]N 3SG MGN%K@@
7> J R
H V Q] I ZT V SN'K GN *NWQR( M"  IH QNGR'K- $  URKSGN
NIMS LK HIM RM  M% IH I-= (   JIME. H W E Q] ;  R N K V(N J^ R '
JTZNVZN HSKR NIMS LK VE
H IW=X V\V I][N3'  7>aV
IWRNLZN% K QK$ 7> a (  XNHR K JT Z NVZN %  L
V K I%R] L % %] ^
7> V J] %  HKVN IFR 7> D  G  VJ G  JT V K_E IW= X  I-= H K ST I MZ] Y  JT G N%
HKV   IFR ZNI-QN JT I HT V K  GK 7> V J= V K HKVK > W N G> R UN G  R^ J
7 > a V   Z
I M V  M
H   L
V K  I % R ] L %  S T M Z  %   G > R U N  J T I H T V K  % N E
SENVNHNR HR% GK H
I 33 HKVK ST M Z %] ^  7>  GK ,N IZEK 7>  %] ^
VE
H  IW= X
$  H= <  IG= V N IUQN V(N 3RNJ E= I UQN IH I-= H  E= \  ZN%W
RKR ;NRK JT N 'KQ. GN JT V KIG% QNMNR HR U N WN E= \  7> V J] %
HR U N I-= (   RW JT N 'K L%ZAIZT V ^  GN H31 7> P NQ RM  M. L  H
- K
J^ R ' JT Z NVZN GN WNVIWH 3SG = X N%NZ LNJ Z] V T  NY  V
$  JT N JV
HR U N 7>  %] ^  HNE G  S] ; % V
$  6> = 1 WN G W .U   MZNRN S] G K6 9  %NZ
M"   QNGR
'K-$ URKSGN LK QNJ'  U> R ^  QV  JT * ^  HSKR JT Z NVZN G
QNGR'K-
QN;NR V  HIM RM  M% IH = X   Z] V R QR(NV IV%NZ V  NR3SG
GK JTNJVK HR E7> J^R' Z
H3 M
 LNWUN %MK$ V. %HEK %NZ GNVN
] V . V  ZM] V . GK IZ= P KQ.AIZ= P KQ. U= E . IW= X  FH  3NVR IW;K
RIMV N;%. HRH HNE LNE IW=X RIM LNW
U IFR H31 7> a V  H31
7>PN8U
@URKSGNLKZMNRNLLKGKSN'K@
IVUT](NIMSJT3P%]+G MN*NR
ZNI-QN QNIG I%R] L % *N-K QJ%  LN-  QNJ  \N-K
ST M ZN IW3'^  ZM 3 WR X E N 8Z 
M ]  HN M"  \ E N @

64

I3T 3 1K RX%N

IUQN% U] U N

65

I\R]>%Z;RZQI%QN-KIL%3HVKYNI-%ZIMEJPN-K@
EN\ URN I%=V 7>aP G^VK ZNI-QN QNIG V?V HK H>=VK@
WN EN\ [9K-  I%= V  *.Y   M]  N 7> V JVK JRE"  Y.Y 
  VK%
$  X E N S1JNRK IRL  J> R 3N IRLK %NRK@
\
\ NJ> R  Z $  LKW *> E N-   WJ%N SIM3V S" H > ] P  S%N- 

 MRM1 HN H^QN E
-K N UE S]I;N M" S H
-K@
HK9K H>]LR QR QWVNRN MRM1 Y
RK S]; H-K SNRN
QRS QEKE I-]GR M"$ *N-K MRM1 Y
RK S]; * QNI-@
3 3  ZM 3  U' 3 WR VNMK$ MRM1 Y
R K S] ;   * QNMK$
3> H RNIGH ST M ZNIGH G W N MRM1 Y
R K S] ;   S \ W N@
H
I1H HRVN IFRVN GI\QN MRM1 Y
RK HM]^ >% E\N
XV> R *> L K *UWN% HMNW" $  MRM1 Y
R K S] ;   S QNW" $ @
  M  \
\ NJ> R  HN H> Q N N Z  J9N 
 I%3X  Z^ W N@
L
VK I%R]L% HNESEK  G W3 M
H I-M IV]%
$ GWVN RLU>'ASTMZN
VU> ' AIW3'^   VZU> ' AI3W  QNJ'K ZIMZN IG\NH  LKW. %] ^  WRU
%RH V(N *WNUR IW= X  E= \  X R NK L^ % KQ. IW= X  *1HN7> $ G  RIM] G 
M% L
VK I%R]L% QNJ'K ZNI-QN %NU'K GK VR4. LKW. %]^ J"GN HRG
M% QV IFR ZNR IG]G M% IL VR4. %NU'K QNJ'K G>]Z %NE Q]IYQ.
G  XNR
$  VR_ H> ] Y EK S'N7> $ GK M"  IFR 7> % 4 .  Q] I YQ. 7> a V  QNJ'N F] %
ZNRGK M" IL %NE Q]YN _>=1 L.GN M" 7> IW=X
$ S=XN I%=HE L.GN M"
7>  %^ ]  %NU'K \N L.GK M"   _] %  ZNRG  Z $  H-K Q] Y   F> = 1  L.G  M%
IH7$IH %NU%K G HN_K Q]Y M>]G M% L
 Q]Y _>=1G M% 7>%4. IW=X
$ S=X
I%HEG M% LHR H
-K S=XN H>]YEK =J'K GK J^]6 GN [RN  V
$ SNMR
I%HE L.GN M"  V. 7> M  S= X N SX L.GN M"  %MK$ V. H] > Y EK IW= X  7> M
%NU'K  %MK$ 6=YGK IL]% S=X 7> H>]YEK G Q]GR M>]G M% 7>%4. *
%]^ 7>M \N L.GK M"
ZNI-QNHNEK%NIU%KQJ%LN-\NVH>]YEKZ$6
Y%MK$N
SNV
$
HK SNV@
I- VR4. I-M HNESEK GN LNE M" I%R]L% V=H GK *UVK J^R ]V
V
$  %NZ E" H   HR
U   V. WK I- I%R] L % GK H> ] Y EK I-= H K ST I MZ] Y .  V
$
SNMR %MK$ I%HE HG W"$ STMZN IW3'^ ZM3 QNIG ZNI-QN 3R.
WNEK WK I%R] L % GK H] > Y EK IW= X  MK M% I-M S X NR  QWVNR ;NRH
QN7>$G M% QV L%ZAIZTV^ GN X=HR H=1G RIM]G M% I-E-K IWXNR
HR
 
M] LNJ L
 IH ;R^W QV JTIMENG V 3>?GW IR3K % L=IJQN 7>M
WK JNR %MK$ M
-    IH7> $ IH T K  IW3'^  J> R N' G  JT ( Z Q] 3  QI;/ G
E
H   IW= X  JT 3 P  7> a V  IEI\QN M"  IH ;R> W  H W E I-= H  HEJ
QR(NV I-=H MLNR XV>R>=U V=H MK Z>HV M" I-E-K HNE E
H IW=X
MK RM  V(N 8Z %ZM *UWV  WN> G  W NQ  Z] V R LNJ HR% WNE  *UV
WK IHT3% V=H GK *UVK HR RM M% 7>M WK XRNK E=\ L^^%KQ. G X=HR
H= 1 ' V
$  %MK$ SX HG   I-M JRZ J^ L N'K- $  HSKR NIMS LK V

66

I3T 3 1K RX%N

QNGR'K-$ URKSGN NIMS LK ZMNRNL GK SN'K JTV=\ JTZN' IG]GK M"
Q%]VH
I1QWVNRM"$ZNI-QNHU
IW]GHRVNM
M
QWVRSM>R
J9 LUF]G@
IVJ>R3 HSKR NIMS LK GK *UVK %NE MK LKW Z>HV M
 HGN M"
LG V=H LKW VE
H IW=X WNJ %MK$ XEN LNWUN VG V=H HNE
E
H IW=X I- VR4. HTZ HRUN QV HK M
-K %NZ V GN% ;RZ GK HZN-K
WTU R^JK M
1E. IW=X \VZ HRH WNJ HRZ QN;NR %NE XRNK E=\
JTHNR G JTN'KQ. G RKR IW=X H31 *
U' WNE HNE E
H X=HR H=1GN
RMUN ZNI-QN G>RUN  V
$ 7>VJ]% M
H HR
9. U
IW]G STMZNAIW3'^AI3W
ZR X>=H M% *UWN% GN QWVNR S'H QN- K IFR HRZ S];% IW=X
S] % 4 H   HT Z . %] ^  *
U H  X R NK E= \  ,^ % KQ. IW= X  XE  U-   ILW $  *UWN%
IW3'^  LK %] ^  G W IR3K %NRG GN 3RNJ E= I UQN 7> M  3T K  RNZX] G R R^ J
IW=X Q
I;QN IW=X QN- IFR 3TK RNZ LK R^J IW=X SNEK GN W; HKVN
K 7> HTTZ GN G]Y *
U' G E-K 3TK IHT3% LK GN L%Z M
I-QN I_R
SNEK WNEK QNVZ. I3HNRK SI'QN V(N QNJ'N JT V K3
;  IEQN T K
IHT3% LK G J"R IW=X IW3"EN VKR ZNRH W; HKVN ZMNRNL URKSGN
LK QNJ'K SN'K IW= X  HIM] G   M%/
ST M ZN IW3'^  ZM 3 WR ZNI-QN Q R  ;RZRN-  HMK- 
I-% JNX
$ IZE JRJ]X S%NI-QN SN'K MZRK EMK-@
I-%JNX
$IZELKWQ1HN-L>U%AL>U%MZQN%6>YN-
S] G K 6 9  MZNRN %NZ]   QLR QZR M"  QI(R PNZ] @
JKR J"U]SR H>V>S QIEQN >R %R Z^%KL% IUQN%K
 V N H
 V
 RNM %N JNI-QN LZ H  S] ;   JT N 'K@
; R Z R N -   H K  ; ^ Z N A ; ^ N Z K   L Z  J R  L] U  X E N 7 ^ $ 
L
R N H
 V
 LN% % G] ^ U N S.; QGE [R IEQN7> $ @
HNE QHNE G
M^] H^ Z
^]  ZM.HNE IR Z]>Y^
Z" $  V
 V? V  M , ^ R K  M > H Z K   X
R  \
L  H] ^  < ^ ] < ^ @
Z^ E N ZNI-QN ZU Z $  S" P K M]  N X> ] % AX] > %  \N-K
L
I V WR^ J K *QN I%R] L % Z" $  MK HRVN *N-K@
 ] M   QP N K  G K J  Z ^ % K 3 W R   S ] ;   Z ^ E N  Y
R K 
- V Q. Z $  LZ HN VESN%N XEK-  J> R 3 IH3
R K@
Z ^ E N  HN  V
 ZN ( N  G N U ^ ]    I V H K  Z
M R  H R ] ^ U N 
J>R3 GKJ H^] M] XEN7>$ GRN % R
H' G^]UN@
M Z  V
 S ] G K  6  9  HM N W .   ;R Z R N -   M "  X H W " 
VE
H HK HE >%NW.  SN'K M ZRK Q\W"@
%   E = \  J = 1 %  7 > a J R  \  E ] ^   N M G R   H ] ^  R
H ^ 
GWNG H
I1 H1H S HN1^] M] JPN7^$ Z
\]^@
X
G 4  * > W %  U Z %  M "  Z  R N   L E  ( E  Z $  R S ] U K 
\NIEH \EH \EH Z$ \NIEH QIWUV QXE Q*]UK
QUR QEKE X= H R M"  Z R N ILV   MZ X= E  QN- 

IUQN% U] U N

67

J N X
$  JR  J T W N % N  Z  R N   S ] ;  6 > 1 N W %  ; N -  @
LM. Q
HNR I%R]L% %NMK$ STMZN IW3%]^ WG %NMK$ LNMK$
LM.HRVN%MK$LN%*UWN%NHNI-QNZNI-QNIJ]Y%JTN'N@
J.X V=VW IV]%
$ U>' %NMK$ L
RN HNE GKJ %MK$ LNMK$
QZR HR] ^  VE
H  JPN7^ $  V.V" $  S] G K 6
9  HMN7> $ @
HSKR JTZ3WR HIWRGW  GK ZIMZN G=G M
- QNGR'K-$ URKSGN
NIMS LK HIM RM  M% IH NY  JT * ^  HSKR HIWRG W  S] G K6
9  M%
S] G K6
9  GN *NWQR( M"  HNE GK HNRNUNR V
$  6> 1 WN7> '  WNEN HNE
STMZ G I-=HK STIMZ]Y. IW=X RW JTN'K JNJ. G HNR% HNE G S]GK M%
J^R' JTZNVZN HIWRGW  HSKR NIMS JNJ GN IW%N3 HR IG]G M%
JNJ. GN IW%N3 %N ST M Z %N JRST M Z %N MK ST M ZN IW3'^   I3WLK
HR HG M% HWE L"N HRZ M" 7>GN W"N MK FE G IG]G M%
I-E-K L>RWG G QI;/ G Z]VT  IW=X IEI\QN M" HIWR][NIRRI
HIWR G W  HSKR JT Z  3 WR  JNJ. GN 3VR^  M"   S] * NIRRI  S] ; %. GN
3VR^  QR(NV S] G K6
9  M" 
I-%4 .  J] L . ST M ZNAIW3'^ A I3WAZNI-QN QV  ;RZRN-  V
$  7> a JR
IVJ> R 3 JT Z NVZN HIWRG W  M"   L
 VE
H  GN ZNIEH M"   SNHK *
JRSTMZASTMZ V(N STMZN AIW3'^AI3WLK QNIG ZNI-QN %N3WN% JTZNVZN
M% ZM.JTEQ IW=X I-M * V(N I-%4. G E
H ZNJV M
 LN'U QNZ
LKW V
$ H-K M,NR U>'. ILQNGN E]SK I-%4. GK 7>ZR M" JT]V^ L
 Z.
I%R;NIRV M"  7> M  I-= H  IG% J^ R N ,R^ R  M
W  U N QNGR'K- $  URKSGN
LK ZMNRNL HIM] G   M%/A
I3WSTMZNHNRNLI-]GRIU%VKHM.XNRZ>HIVS"H>]PZ0VNEMN@
]\L>U%HKL^%K7>ZRS9;NRKQNLNL%%KH>RSN%>HNULJNIRQN@
VK 7>ZR S]>EG ZRUN Q]V R IVU>R EU % HN% % *"$1 ]V R@
XNM ]\ >=U GK E]SK 7>ZR WK IH7>$ % M
W 7>M I-=H IG% ?VZ
,R^ R  M
W  U K L H R IVJ> R 3 JT Z NVZN HIWRG W  HSKR NIMS G
%> Z NI-] G   J^ R ' ] V  U> R ^  L
 IV] %  %NZ GN Z] V R IL IW= X  8Z2V= V 2
IV ] H  I V= H  M%  IG] G N M"  7>  K J^ R ' ] V  G> Q NRN %NZ GN% HR% GN
QNG 3  M"   7>  V
$  7> J G 3  E"  H  HZN-K HR.U  V. QK$ VE
H  G
QI;HNRK M] M
 HG M. IV N;%N IS%. SM>V E]SK 7>ZR H
-K H]Z
%MK$ QNW U K IH7> $ IH I%R] L % E
H  IW= X  G> = \  MK G> = \  M%
HSKRLKW%NV
 (
94NMK*ENL" IV>ZR%M

EN\WR3HNLKW%NE\";R"%NH
-@
HSKR NIMS QNJ'K J^ R 'ST M Z GK  LN'HNRK W" $  MK G=  G
M% IH I- JT*Q. V
$ 7>aJR Q]\ *^LN GN JTZNVZN IVJ>R3 M" L
 IH
VE
H =X\]Y IV;NZ  IW=X RIM]GN M" V(N 7>G Q]VRUV RW E
H
STMZ HNE  G  STIMZ]Y V STMZN IW3'^ I3W 3HVK G E
H V(N
JRSTMZ G =V ]\ STIMZ]Y V M
R RW STIMZ]Y  QN7>$G M% V 7>a(
IV%NZANR%NZ G  LNJ G> Q NRN LNI-QN LNW U N L
 J^ R   U> R ^  V
$  JT N JV

68

I3T 3 1K RX%N

M>]GN M" =X\]Y VE


H  IW=X L
 QNVZN XEK L.GK M" 7>GN J>%R L%Z
%MK$ M] > G N IVJ> R 3 J^ R 'ST M Z  HSKR NIMS HIWRG W  MK M
R
E
H . IW= X  QNJ MK I*] % AI*] %  %.W. %NE IWRNLZN% M% ILW $  QE\
E
H IW=X QE\ J>R3 QUZ E
H IW=X QUZ J>R3 V(N QHIM E
H IW=X
Q%NZK J> R 3 R^ J  IW= X  IWRN,ZN% M% I-M V. 7> J ZNVIZH %NZ M%
JT]V^ WNVIWH %NZ 7> J^R' J>R3 GN HIWR GW *N3N I*]% M
H HSKR
NIMS  M" 

QNGR'K-$ %N%H NIMS LK GK SN'K IW=X I3T31K RX%N GN ]HV
3T K  U> R ^  %N%H NIMS LK GK Q] I ZT V SN'K ZM= E N  RNU ISENWE>
Q]3  3TK U>R^ UT]( NIMS LK FN 
QNJ X> HKQNHRL
I9Q]YLF
I9L
IYIW6
9@
;RVKQNHN3HK- S"'H7> (N7>RNIVIG%]V> HK- *7>A*N7^@
ILI% HK- HIR W\'MNRN 
IVTVKQN STMZNAIS%^AZMN GWK GW 7JN- WN 
J7>'JN'KQU%KIWRN7>VNMKI%R]L%> NX
 %N7>@
IV> ZNIM Z%>QN RIMQN IEW E-K JT'WIV %N%H> HNE> %N
\NI-@ 
7> J R
H V Q] I ZT V WN'K GN QR( M"  IH = X   JT Z NVZN IVJ> R 3  %
QNJ MK QNJ' M=(. %NE RW I3T31K GK RX%N HKVK M" 7>K % Q]YN
S'NI-QN IFR V
I 9QN V(N 7>   IW= X
$  L
V K I%R] L % I%HIEQN 7>  K
J^ R % JT Z NVZN %  RW JT N 'KQ. G  RIM' E-K ;RVK QNHN3 JW%
JN'K QNIG J]L V=VW RX QNJ' G>QNRN RXK I3T31K GN 7>M QNJMK
3NH3K M" G^RN H
-K MK LN'HNRK %MK$ G HGN IFR Q]Y G 1>=1'
%NE I%HE L
VK I%R]L% V
$ SNQG IV]%
$ 3TK STMZN LK 3TK IW3'^ LK V(N
3T K  I3W LK GK 7> a VJVK M
- K V(N M
R  G W KAG W VN J" G N M
-   V(N
Q'IU'V LKW. GK 7> a VJVK M
- K 7>  V
$  SNQG M
R  G W . G  LKW%
XIR=VR V(N M
R IR3KQ. G Q%>*W G 6 3NVR V(N QP4NR. J>RN' S'
U- J^R' JTZNVZN G =X %NZ IV%NZ  GK N;%N Z% V
$ HRH V(N
U>R^ ZIRQNGN IW=X RIM' WNE JR'WV  %]^ 3TK %N%H LK HIM RM M%
IH HNE %MK$ \.GN
RNU ZNR^  Q] 3  Q] I ZT D V WN'K ZM= E N  U> R ^  U] T (  NIMS FN %]

>]%M> STMZNIS%>ZM> 7>JN->]% WRV L>USN-@
I->JGISXNR
L%>J>RNIV>IZEKQ"*RZ>X>HNI-GN@ 
NZWG>IRU> L>LR> Q(RS'>STMZ$Z>I\ZNI-QNM" V"TU>'@
VNHKHKZIVHIM%H"H
 IV7> S
E IL7> S>ENI-GN@ 
7> J R
H V Q] I ZT D V SN'K GN NR] 3  M"  IH L
 ] V  J^ R ' I3T 3 1K RX%N
>'N GWUN V(N G=UN IH Q]Y G *NU M
H H' I%HIEQN IL% IFR

IUQN% U] U N

69

ST M ZE
H  GK > ] %  IW= X  QR(NV U> J V (N% 7> a V  ST M ZNAIW3'^ A I3W LK
GK 7>VJVK HKVK V(N 7>M JTZNVZN H' M" IL% STMZ HNE  G Z]^M V
$
XNR
$  W G  JIW= V R IRUW G  L> R W G  NZW G  Q= ( RWW G  %] ^  7> X NR'
HRWNI-QN 7> M  J^ R ' JT Z NVZN ILW $  XNM  7>    VR4 .  MK MR JT N 'K %] ^
S> E N7> $ GN M"   I- NR  IUQN% %] ^  J^ R ' G=  ' WNEN ] V  IZE LNW  V.
7>G H
E LN7> QV L
 * 3]H. GN J^R' I%WNR% HRGN M" 7>MK J^R'
] V  QR(NV V= V WGR3K M" 
3TK U>R^ U]T( NIMS FN  Q]IZTV SN'K 3TK U>R^ %N%H NIMS LK
GK RNU RNZHEK ZM= E N  G= \ 'K 8$HNR
88Q]HNRSTMZN7>VJIV88Q]HNR> HKQNILI%IXV88Q]HNR"EL>U*-
 88Q]HNR SG I%TZN- 88Q]HNR SIG 7>;R 88Q]HNR U>RZ>I\ VR
8%ZQ\R>'M> SKXNR>8%ZQ\R> IVT*W'NR>
7>JR
HV Q]IZTVSN'K IW=X 3TK U>R^ %N%H NIMS LK HIM RM M% IH
8Q] H NR QR(NV L
V K I%R] L % HNE  V
$  ST M ZN LK GK 7> V J= V K M
- K
H-K >=U ZVK ZNR H 8$HNR STMZ  % WG. GK 7>VJ=VK HKVK STMZN
LK %]^ JTNJV M
- IV]% E
H GK *UVK V. HWE 8Z Z]VT MK WNVW LNJ
HR% GN M"   I- 8Z 3SG %] ^  J^ R   ] V  V
$  7> J G 3  E" H   QR(NV U> R ^
;NR% HRH  LNJ HR% %NE 7> G NR M> ] G N M" 
IW3 3 /A 3T K  U> R ^  %N%H NIMS LK %  IV] %
$  Z] V R. 8Z2V= V 2IV
GN (N%A(N% 7>aV RM=Z-K IWWR' IG=VN M" 7%]^ HWE J^R' ]V
V=VWGT3K ]V  MK Z0 HGN M" V(N IV]% Z]VR. G LNJ %]^ 7>JG3K
%] ^  Z0NI-QN L.GN M" 
FN 7>VZIVU>R^ J>R\I%RNESIGRV MIRRIZVWNE
IRI;S>;KII;IUQN%>U>R^VJN-KQ"J^R*NUIZENI-GN@ 
IVU>R^ V JN- WKXNRN>%ZNI;X [RSNRN
%N%HI%RZE%NG^3SG;^I%X>RNZ"$%NIZZNI-GN  @@@
7>JT
HV Q]IZTVSN'K GN *NWQR( M" IH WNVIWH IUQN% G' WNE
IVU> R ^  V. I%RNE  MK M% 7> M  H W E %NZ LNJ MK L= J G  M% M
R
M= P 
U  N;%N %MK$ G=  G  L  QNJ%^ ]  ;] %  G E V JG S> = ; K L. *UVK
3HVK WK XNMKGK M" V. 7>M *UVK ZNRU GN IUQN% J^R' ]V MK J^RN
JTGN% HRUN Q"N J^R' ]V W=Y *NU. V
$ MK IZEGN M" 7>MK J^R' ]V
IWWT '  G=   U N IH 7> a JR ] > %  QNHN3  IW= X  QNJ'N WNVIWH [R
VE
H  JT Z  3 WR %  RX R= I \QN M" 
7> IW=X I-=H WNVW NR %NZ GK ;>]% QNWN,  M
 RMK M" 7>
QN%] G  IW= X  QIW%N3K JT Z  3 WR G  NR 3SG %NE ZNI-QN L.GN M"
QR(NV 7> WNVIWH >=\GN-K (N% IW=X WN M
 HGN M" M
R %NZ.
V(N Q;^R U>R^Q. V
$ %MK$ M
 HGN
Q.I3H Q]IZTVSN'K ZMEN JIMEN 3TK U>R^ UT]( NIMS JT3P A

 IW%URKZIMQNI'S"7> HEJIVQNUKSNG] 
I]UKSGGN;>I%
M" QIM%NIJ^R" %NG] 

70

I3T 3 1K RX%N

MIRHKRIVRMRNIMZNRKU>R^Z>\J](QVKV 
UEKL
IVMZNRK]IZQN%N%NWR'Q%H]
HM%N%H>I'*R(RKL
UKJNRSTMZIEW-H] 
7> J T
H V Q] I ZT V WN'K GN *NWQR( M"  IH 3T K  U> R ^  %N%H G W  NIMS
LK HIM RM M% IH M *R(RK 
UK LK QNJGK N;%N *UWN% I3W V=H
M" 7> V
$ QNJ%^] I3W %URK E
H  IW=X (N% IZIEQN M" QV RKR
IW= X  L
 I] U K 3SG QNIG M
 IRMN M"  7> M  I-%4 .  HZE. GN M"  V(N
1"EKIWL% GK VR4. MRH GW G E
H G RKR IW=X >' IRMN M"
QK V. I-=H JTZNVZN JTSTMZ QR(NV * V
$ JNR L
 J^R% JTZNVZN
M"  M
R  IH  QV  I-= H  JT Z NVZN IW= X  E  I-= H  Z% %NE EU% %NE
EUN7> $ G  M.
QK$ 7> a JRK IG\NWN *Z EUN7> ' N M= (  IW= X  Y] Y N R= \ 'N  %MK$
HRG Z"$ V. RW JTN'KQ. %]^ I-=H J^R' JTZNVZN IVJ>R3  GK ]VN%
Z0GN M. * 7> GK 3HVK V
$ XENI-ZN' M% NYK Z>GRN V. =XN
%NZ LNJ U> R ^  V
$  JT N JV HRH   HR%N M"  V(N Z> Q N_ HR%N NYN SN'N
W 3 *^ 3 N  M"   Z" $  V. J^ R ' JT Z NVZN GN 7> J NH M. V(N J^ R ' IVU> R ^
GN *UVK ZNRU I- V
$  I*] %  M" 
Q]IZTVSN'K RNU QNN ZMEN  3TK U>R^ UT]( NIMS JT3P 
@QNNZMEN@IL%K%NZ>IWNIRQNG^L*RIZ*^EN-KZ^E>6
I9YNEKEUIHQN
JNWIM6N-K@@NIMS>ZRN-H> M"QWR>%MK$*N-KIHRJNV>\> JNI-QNNXJR(N-K@@
U>RHKWN
HRIL>QNIJHRN-%N%HIR>G6>1K-GRUMJIVJN-@@@

7>JR
HV SN'K GN QR( M" IH 3TK U>R^ %N%H GW LK NIMS LK HIM
RM M% IH L
 J^R' JTZNVZN GN WNVIWH %NZ *>=EH M
R *UWN%. G
%NZN GN LNJ IW=X *TZ RM M% 7>M V. Q"N HR RM M% IH Z^E J^R'
JTZNVZN  %]^ 6=YH YNEKQ. IV]% U>' R^J RLU>'ASTMZN VU>'AIW3'^
VZU>'AI3WLK  GK I]XN-K J^LN  HR RM M% 7> N;%N %NE H
-K
>=\ %MK$ M
 HGN QR(NV JGN LG >=H LN-UN V. 6NI-QN IW=X %MK$
S" P  HG   *NWQR( M"  IH 3NVR IW;K RIMV N;%N HR% %NE
IWQR( JT  V% M"   H
- K EN* %MK$ I-GN JT Z N' JIW= V R UKVN
QI;/ E
H  A IW= X  WK M"   7> J^R' JTZNVZN %]^ JTNJV HR%
E-K Z%Z>\K Z%ZN%K  N;%N IVQNUH J^R' U>R^GW %]^ ZRJ' HR% V
$
V(N =X %NZ G LNJ V
$ MK Z
H3 ]*W M" %MK$ V. IZTV^ V
$ SNQG %RH
IW= X  LNW U N
3T K  U> R ^  U] T (  NIMS FN %]  A
@ISENWE> ZMEN@@Z"$ ZI% XN7> ['N NIX IWUNK RNZ Z
MK JTZ IJR JT*^
QIW%N3KRNZ@QIWUV
MIR%N(%N(MIV"*NW"
(KQ"IHTJNE>GNGQNE>GNVNLKQN
Q]GIRV^]LKQ"Z"$QN;R^VRNV^\Z>ZRNZ"VN'>VHKQNVR8NIX^XNGN%N%H
U>RSIG0UR>I%SR7>$@@@

7>JR
HV Q]IZTVSN'K IW=X 3TK U>R^ %N%H NIMS LK HIM RM M% IH
QIW%N3K J^ R ' JT Z NVZN %N(. GN WK %N( M"  QR(NV G W . GN WK G W

IUQN% U] U N

71

M" RW JT*^Q. 3TK STMZN LK 3TK IW3'^ LK 3TK I3W LK V(N STMZ V
JRSTMZ 7>aV WK %N( M" QR(NV WNZK M"  Z"$ V. =X %NZ %]^ IGE IW=X
ZN X>=HN M. M JTZNVZNC RW JTN'K GN LKW% QN;NR QNJMK M
 Z"$
QNJG QN3IRV M. QNJ ZR ZNIEH M

 QNJ% MK U>R^ R^J IW=X QNH


IV*UVK GN I%R'NI-H IUQN% G H   RW 0U9  \VZ HKV  QR(NV
RW 3] H N GN ZN;N% HR IG= V N
3TK U>R^ UT]( NIMS JT3P %]+  RNU IVE]U ZMEN 
HQRLU>FVZJ3V
GRH^%HRVNR
M=HNHSKRHRKZV^SQSJRWRIGUNR
%N%HS>U
GL%V>RNVRXNHR.JN\NH

7> J T
H V Q] I ZT V SN'K IW= X  J= 3 1 HR IG= V N M"  IH M  M= H N HSKR
QNJ IVHSKR H^ %  HRVNR  3SG 3HVK V
$  RX%N HR% WNE  3SG
WR^ J K JT * ^  QR(NV RW I3T 3 1K G  RX%MNR M
  QNJ MK S Q " S
I%RIWHNR JRWRIGUNR  RW G  JNE'HRVN IGQNE^  JT * ^  M
  Z" $
QNJLK G GN. GN WK GN M.
3TK U>R^ UT]( NIMS JT3P %]+  RNU IRK ZMEN 
VRNI-=H> %NZ> VNR ]NR>Z"$-MNQN-M
 QN;NR
%N%H %KX HM" SKXNR ;N'H R^J RMN HRVNR@
7> J R
H V Q] I ZT V SN'K %  JT Z N' HKVN M"  IH L
 HN3K IW= X  ;N'H
L>ENMN  M" I-MK HRVNR  H>E GN IRL%MNR M" QI
V QN;K% M
H TK
QIV
%N%H NIMS LK HIM RM M% IH Z"$ =X HIM IRMN M. IH
IH I-M ;N'H
QR(NV HSKR L>ENMN MK J^R' STMZ IVJ>R3  M"
IW33A 7>JR
HV JTZN'. G ]HIVH IUQN% V
$ JTZNI'V M
I-QN IH
I3T31KRX%N IHW$ M
-KM>' J^R' JTZNVZN GK JTNJVK HR%K XNMKGK M" 
I-M J^R' ]V V
$ %NZ E" H MK ]*W M"

M
R ]V. G>QNRN G=K U-K I3T31K RX%N GK G]V H(N
M
R ]V. G>QNRN G=K I3T31K RX%N GN IUQN% G=IQN M" 7>M IH
VR4. GN M" IHTJN %KX J9
4/A I3T31K RX%N G IW3 IW=X RN;N WNZK
J]( G ]V. G V ;]%A;]% IVU>R^ J]( G ]V. G IWXNR/A
JIW= V R J>  VH LKW% XIR= V R JRZ ] V  SNSN LZE I] [  LK
ZMNRNL JT 3 P %] +  A IW= X  I3T 3 1K GK RX%N# NW% IHT J NE
JSEKH 3 % IG= E K
JIME.IVJ>R3I%RNHNRKIFRI-LMNR QNHNR IW=XQNI-QNVN7>aJRGIV]%
I%RZEZ]YE VE
HQE\E
HQUZE
H S'IUQNV(NJTHN3V(NZ]YE.GN%NG ;>%K
#
S'IUQN#

JIW= V R J>  VH NRWX% %R  JT H N3H/ARN;N WNZK IV] U


*N IGQNESNU QNURN I3T 3 1K GK RX%N JT 3 P 
JIMEN;>];^HNRK7>IW=XJ>R3>]%ZN;IW=XKLG
$H>0RX%N%MK$M
-K

72

I3T 3 1K RX%N

K_RLGZLM
-KVG3SGJTU1M
I-QNQV7>V
$*RX%NM
-KJIMENVE
H

QVIFRIVJ>R3HKHENV
$IV]%E
HQV*IWVNRM
I-QN

I-M IUQN% V. QILMN M" ILW$ I-=H Z$ H


-K S=XN %HRK E=U' G
E-K I-]1TIW7^ G E-K IUQN QI;HNRK % J>=I6QN IH QNJ% ZM.*NRV
J=I94QN M" E9H % 7>aVR IG=VN IH 7>$UEKQ. 7>aV RI1QN M
I-QN M"
QI;HNRK %  JT 3 % HKVN IH J] L . J.YW. G  %NZ G= 
  E9H  %  7> a VR
IG=VN IH I-=H *KZ K I-=H 7>GN W=YN *N-K K I-=H 7>V
$ 6
1N I-=H
M
R K V I-=H GN %NZ %NZ Z"$ *>=E IUQN 7>JR
HV I3T31K RX%N GN
IUQN% V. QILMN M" 
IVJ>R3 V VE
H GK ZIMZN G=' WNE V J]L %NZ Q$HNR A L
VKI%R]L%
A RR]HNR A 
M] A IV%NZ  G' WNE V IV]% %NZ QHNE Z^RV A IVJ>R3 A
3SG WR^JK RNZ  G' WNE ]V. G>QNRN RXK J>VH. G H>0 I%3HR3 /A

] V ZV JT H N3 *NU  JT 3 P  7> a V  IEI\QN M"  IH = X \] Y  L.


IV%NZ X ( N E
H  M"  I-= (   IV%NZ  %] ^  (N% IHMN M"   IFR I-
JIW=VR J>VH G JT3P %]+  7>aV IEI\QN M" IH -H RNZ G3R( HN
S 1 N G^  RN %NZ Z%  VKRN RNZ ST M Z  X
( N RNZ IV%NZ  I-M
WNVW RNZ M" IFR JIW=VR J>VH ]VZV JTHN3 JIMEN *NU JT3P %]+
 V IEI\QN M" IH 7>M VE
H M"  7>K %]^ IV%NZ IHMN L.GN M"
JIW=VR J>VH NR WX% %R N%K WNRIVH  JT3P %]+  7>aV IEI\QN
M" IH M>' Z0'N XNMKGN M" IH RN;N WNZK JG * V
$ 7>aXN Z>HNZ M"
IH IL%]^ ]V. % VE
H V =X\]Y QV NR3SG V IV3SG V IV%NZ
V IVJ>R3 HIM H ISQN% HKVN M"#JIW=VR J>VH NR WX% %R
QNURN V
$  JT H NI3V JT 3 P %] +  7> a V  WK 7> J R
H V I-  VR4 .  WR'% M" 
JIW=VR J>VH =X\]Y GK 9H  JT3P %]+  ]V. GN G3 =X\]Y L.
VE
H M" 7>K %]^ IV%NZAV3SGANR3SG IHMN LNGN M"#
IW33/A 7>JR
HV IWQNI\QN QILMK E=UK ILW$ IH % LKW% IW=X
%N V. 3IMR G I \QN % HNR G I \QN QV  % J" a 1R
E  G I \QN M"   %N
YRNI-WR GN IUQN% M
W   IH YRNI-WR IH%] ^  HIM] G   M% QV  7> M
IWQHVK M
R  N(KQ. %] ^  HM  IH Z" $  3IMR L.GN M. HNR IW=X S"PH
QN%]G ZN%GN M. IFR N(KQ. % J>aI6QN IH HNR IHM
 ILMK M>]GK M"
J"1R
E HM
 ILMN M>]GN M" V YRNI-WR IHM
 ILMN M>]GN M" 3IMR IHM
 ILMN
M>]GN M" 7> U>R^ LK % 7>V=R IG=VN IH 3IMR HM
 XNM HNR I-=H MK U=E
M" 3IMR WK HNR MK M" J"a1R
E WK HNR %]^ MK HIM]G M% YRNI-WR WK
HNR %]^ MK HIM]G M% 9H WK HNR %]^ MK HIM]G M%
QN7> IWXNR HRK-/A IVJ>R3 V. J^R' JTZNVZN M" IV%NZ 7>M
G
 Z]VR GN %NZ M" IL IW=X 7Z2V=V ]HIVH M" I-G SNQG NR%NZ
N;H %]^ J^R' U>R^ G>QNRN IG=VN L.GN M" I-M IV%NZ V(N NR%NZ
G
%4
$ IZR% HR% G %NZ M% IVE
H V. 7>M LU4N M" IL=( IVJ>R3
RIM] G N M"   J> ] %  QNVZNW. QNJ I%R'"  HR% IH IV HK M"  QV  QIV
HK M" 

I I

IUQN% U] U N

73

H'V(NH"NM" H>EGNZNIEH
IL%4 . AIL%4 .  J] > % QNVZNW. %  JT Z NVZN %] ^  JT N JV HKVN M"  7> % 4 .  %
GIQN M" IH H>E GN ZNIEH I-=H M" 7>M ZN%W >IGT3 V,
Z-K RKR
>HV M" ILG I-=H R
Z H^J GN JTHN3 HR
9 ^RL V(N HR
9 X]GRZN
GK R3%K V
$ WK ILQNGN M" 7>% MK %N%N R^J QNJ' S'N- M% JTZ
3WR GN WNVIWH %NZ QNJ'KAQNJ'K *N3NWN IW= X  HIWRG W  W G .
IW= X  ]  IHT V  *N3N IW= X  V(N M= H N HSKR 3T K  U> R ^  UT ] (  NIMS LK G
JT3P %]+  IW=X \VRK *N3N IW=X  V(N V HSKR 3TK ;RZGN LK
GK SN'K IW= X  7> % 4 .  GK \ V RK *N3N IW= X  V(N S] G K6
9  HSKR NIMS
] V  URKSGN LK G  GUT ] (  IW= X  7> % 4 .  GK \ V T K  *N3N IW= X  HSKRN
HSKR% V  \SKRN L. \SKR% 3T K  H> R N% 3RKF ^ R V F> R HN%K %] + 
QNI-V %] +     IW= X  \ V RK QRSK *N3N IW= X  I-K
J^ R ' JT Z NVZN G  7> J ZNVIZH %NZ Q%NZK J> R 3 QUZ J> R 3 QE\
J> R 3 IVJ> R 3 QHNE Z^ R V 3SG WR^ J K RNZ J^ R ' ST M Z JRZ
QH3R STMZ QNIG M" ILW$ G3 G JT;N%Z]VRK GN WNVIWH RKR GN
%NZ H>0 M
R M" 7>JZNVZH %NZ JT;N% Z]VRK LK JTNI-Z IZI%1R LK
QE=U M>]GN M" ILW$ *NRV G3 GN JT;N%Z]VRK LK QNJ' H
E UTIM Z]VRNE
R=\ E"$GN M" LG 7>M 7> IW*NU G GVNWL.. 7>aV MVN\R HRGN M V.
7>a( UTIMZ]VR K GK *^IZHN HRGN M" QNJ'N JG WK UTIMZ]VRK IE\GN M"
MVN\R 7>MK M>G
]  M% I- JTHNR -K3WR GK =VN %]^ Z0'N XNMKGN M"
IL%4 .  ] V . V  IR3KQ. %] ^  JT Z NVZN GK JT N JVK %MK$ M
- K 7> % 4 .  %
QNJ'N QN\RK Q%>*W G=IQN IH JTZNVZN GN HWE JTHN3 MK GI\QN
LN HGN M" JT*^ IG\N-K %MK$ IG]GN IH7>$IH 7>GN H
-K QNHNR %MK$
M" V(N RKR IW=X ;>% >'%N QNIG JT*^ *UVK GK 7>JE=*;K M"
QN7>  IWXNR HRK- / A ILW $  H
- K Q] % 4 N  M
R  Q] %  4  IWQHVK %] ^  QNJ
Q=\. WNEN I=; HRK S"PN M
W V(N HIM]GN M
W IH RNV %]^ X]GRZN GK
R
3%K SM>V >MNW'K M]>GK M" Z% *NW%K M>]GK M" Z"$ G\GN M. M
R Q]%4
XE % J>=I6QN IH U>R^ LK X]GRZN IHM
 ILMN M]>GN M" XV>R Q]%4 % 7>V=R
IG=VN IH X]GRZN V. I%RNHNR M" 7>M IG\N-K (
94N MK G HGN H
-K
HM ^RL I%RNHNR M" 7>M IG\N-K %MK$ IG]GN RIW 3W" JTHNI3V M" I-
E-K 7>GN HWE JTHN3 IG\N-K IG]GN M" U>R^ LK G G= Q%>NR I33
<N-K []1 WR V(N <N-K []1 3NZ QNHN3 IW=X G\GN M" JT]V^ 7>%]^
H>0 IG\N-K %MK$ IG]GN QNJMK IWXNR IW1.GRN HRG M% IH U>R^ LK
V. MK HIM RM M% NYK N;%N <N-K []1 WR 3NZ V. J^RK %MK$
M
 M>]GK I-E-K ^RL V(N X]GRZN GN JTHN3 IG\N-K %MK$ G IRMN
XV> R  U> R ^  LK GK IWQNI\QN 7> a V  QN;NIRV M
H   7>   XENH Q] % 4   GK
IUQN%MK%  IWQNI\QN G  JT X NRH HR
9 . Q] % 4   IUQN%MK%  M
 X> = H 
M% IFR 7> % 4 .  %] ^  Q= \ . WNEN V= V WGR3K ] V  G=    IH ^ R L QNHNR
IW=X M" V(N 7>V
$ MK JTHN3 I%HE IRMN M" I- VR4. MK X]GRZN V
$

74

H' V(N H"N M" H>E GN ZNIEH

WK JTHN3 I%HE IRMN M" %VRMK'


$C X]GRZN G IS%. RNV %]^ JTHN3 IHW
$ M
 HGN M"ILW$ H
-K HM IH I17^S ENI-1 G\K IFR H
-K J=>6 IH
I17^S H"K M]>GK M" ILGK QNJ% R3%K G\K M"7>aVR IZE IH I17^S
V. I%RNHNR M
' G HNR% IG\N-K %MK$ IG]GK HWE JTHN3 GI\QN LN
HGN M"   IWXNR HR
/ A I17^ S  IS%. JT H N3 IHW 
L H
-K HM IH MKRN \>G JTHNI3V M>]GN M" IFR I-M WK HM IH
MKR GN HWE JTHN3 GI\QN LN HGN M"IH7>$IH MKRN V. I%RNHNR M"
7> M  IG\N-K %MK$ G  HGNV. 7> M  IWQHVK MKR  V
$  JT K IXV %MK$ M" 
_
H 1 , M RK SI'QN M"   L
 JT Z NVZN %] ^  I%RNHNR HIM] G   M% V(N H W E
JTHN3 G\'N V(N ;>]% >'%N MK JT*^ JTNJVK Z]%G M% 7>M J^R' R^J IW=X
JT * ^  V(N *UVK V
$  LN'^  %MK$ M% LG
$  7> % 4 .  %] ^  JT N (%N HKVK IH H> 0
%MK$ GI\QN M" QNJ% QNJ' XIEQ. %]^ *RIZV HRH G
3K M
 RM M

%N V. QNJG U>R^GW %^] V=VWIUQN% R^JK %VR M% V(N %N MK QNJ%^]
I-E-K G>%KQ. %]^ *RIZV %N HR
 I- U=E 7>aV TW IUQN%R^JK %
VR. G Q]I%4Q. % Y]Y X=>H E- IH QK$ V. 0^PV^] I-=H =XN Q=L 7>MK
I(VK ] V  RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL LK G  %NE M" 
I- IWWNG GN I%R'  IHW $  M
W   IH IH ] V  G  IWXNR MK M%
IHG UEV M% Z]% E7> ILW$ IHK QJRN; G IW3 IW=X J]L WHKE
QNJ'NAQNJ'N IWXNR JT U 1 HR RM  M% I-= H  HM  IH I- QJRN;
7> a V  ] I W;N% GK ;NRN  E= U  U K G^  RN HM  IH VKRN HM
 X ( N HM   V(N J] L WN WHKE  %] ^  MK G=   
I-M J] L   PKH %MK$ M
 HG   H W E I-= H  MK PKH M
 HGN M"  L
7>GK IWQNI\QN QNJ' G3 G JIW=VR ]IW;N% G %NE IZEGK M" L
7>GK IWQNI\QN WK ]IW;N% G IWJRKV M" V. J]L WHKE UEV M%
I-GN F"EN G3 GN JIW=VR ]IW;N% HRUN L
 * %]^ Z]%'
U M" I-
JTHNR I*]%AI*]% IWXNR ;NRNW. IW=X V(N N;%NW. IW=X IHM9K 3NVR
Q%> H ^ E  M"  L. IHM9K 3NVR IWR= > ;  M"   I-GN F"  EN JIW= V R GUT ] (
MK HR'U L
 *G E-K Z]%'
U M
' XNMKG M% I-MK JTZN' JIW=VR
3T K ZG*UWV UKVN QI;/ E
H  A IW= X 
IL%4. Q=\. WNIEQ. J^R' ]V.  % ^RL J^R'JTZNVZN  %]^ GI\QN
7>%4N IW=X
$ H>0 G %NZ M% /A
  QNGR'K- $  ;RZGN NIMS LK   QNGR'K- $  GNG^  NIMS
LK   QNGR'K- $  ZE^ H GN NIMS LK   QNGR'K- $  URKSGN
NIMS LK   QNGR'K- $  3T K  U> R ^  %N%H NIMS LK   QNGR'K- $
[KN GN NIMS LK QNIG
  QNGR'K- $  ;RZGN NIMS LK
 S.;WU94  Z= ;  JT G  3  WNE 
LK
IL%4 .  %] ^  J^ R ' JT Z NVZN IL] G N ZMNVZN G  R^ J  IW= X  Z(> R N IW= X  IZE 
VE
H IG\NI-QN 7>a( VE
H IW=X G
 R^J IG\NH IL]GN WNE R^J IW=X
JTZNVZN WNE I][N% 7>aV IWRNLZN% M
 U- V(N QNGR'K-$ ;RZGN
NIMS LK %] ^  IHMN IH Z"  HN3K S%NR  IW= X  %KR^ A %KZN G  [R

IUQN% U] U N

75

QNI-QN M
I-QN M. QNGR'K-$ 3TK RNZN%]G LK ZR U>R^ LK M% I-M
HIMH 3TK ;RZGN LK GK QNVZN %]^ WNJ RKR IW=X *L IG=VN 3TK
;RZGN LK GN RKR G
 IG% SM
3 IRMN VKR IG% M
3 QNI-QN V.
HN3K IW=X \
L HR% 7>aV JNI-QN IH I-MK H.3K IW=X QNI-QN ;N'H
MK J^ R ' JT Z NVZN IVJ> R 3  M"   QNGR'K- $  ;RZGN LK %  JIW= V R
HSKR NUR HSKR N\K HSKR SKLH %NZH GUT ] (  GK Q= \ K$ G \ K
V(N J^ R ' JT Z NVZN G  JIW= V R Z> = \  HZE V
$  I%HE  Q] I ZT V  WX% R^ J K
IWWR' %NE RX%N HKVK Q] I ZT V  SN'K IW= X  JT Z N'/A
QNLZ
M GR3%IG7> LKHSKR@1H@
VE
H    XE HR QN-   HN1% LZ HK L] L KR@@
(NRGR3%ZMNRJNJH1VM"$I%RZEM
WLKRKR@@
Q]IZTV *
L% ZMNR IVU>R^ LKZ"$ 3SG G^; HK \KR@@
I M ] G ^  H   V> Z  G  W  HM N -    Z>  E Z N %  H   J K R @  @
G
%
4$ GK% HN 0U9N I69 IUQN 1
M %N JN- RKR @@
;RZGN HK QRL U
.-K S9N E][N-K8 JRE VKR @@
  QNGR'K- $  GNG^  NIMS LK Q] I ZT V SN'K IW= X  JT Z N'  HSKR
JTZ3WR G NH3KA/ QNGR'K-$ GNG^ NIMS LK LG =V NE G S=X K
VG J^R' JTZNVZN IL]GN ZMNVZN G R^J X IZE V VE
H E" U- IV]%
IG% V= H  GNG^ L K S M
3  RM   IFR M
3  IW= X  QNH  SM> V  Q] I ZT V SN'K
7> X NR% HKVK/
IL%Z
H^]I%L%NZGKQN
-IVU>R^MZNRGNG^G^RNH
-K%MK$HSKRIRL%MNR@
GNG^ %NZ HSKR HK L H
-K EW 81 7>%H
 HSM]^ ENU %MK$HNE SLR HK X
1@
GNG^ %NZHSKRHN>%HRH.J HNE%NZ*R

 L
 %RXEM
W %NS]HNSNE@
L
L
3R%HSKRHVRU-Q%]VQJNRGNG^U>'HKVNHMHMV%NQNWJNR@
HSKR HRVN QNJ M" G^LN %NIM$ H
- GNG^ J^R% LUV H
 *UVK IGT9NWV 
-@
PHNJ^R%M
- LSSH
-KVL RKRGNG^ HNEU], %MK$LJ L
 %NZHSKR@
QNGZKHKQN^[1VSZ[RQN->ZR%HKQNHSKRHNGNG^IEQNSXN-@
Z1IGQNQJRN;*QN- IZE 6%Z.MGNG^ ]UE" XEHSKRXR%HK6.M@
WHGWI%LXR'HNGNG^QNJ%NLN%*R]UKVHSKR%HK%MNQNJZN%@
GNG^Q]VRUVGNI6%AI6%>IZR%I;QN%WNR^%NZHSKRJRJEAJEZRNJTDN%@
>%A>% N\K HSKR HK HNE %WNW ZN( ;]%A;]% M
 IV]% E
H Z$ GNG^ L
9 MN(@
HMRK%NZHSKRHNIW3ZHNEULRNLGNG^ *L%JTVNJV*NU >%VQNWNL@
JE-H%NZHSKRHNGNG^Z%IXVEN-MVKHQ3WNRH
3WN%HNE%MK$\N-@
>ZRV %NZ HSKR HN H1 HNE HK JKR GNG^ IG% IG% 7^$X JRZN%]G >\ KR@
GNG^ %NZHSKRHKL
 H
-KEW Q
1IV%H
 HSM^ %NEU-KHNESLRHKX
1@
Q
R]VSH^JM"$HV 0RKVN%KRGNG^ QUZQJNRM"$GRKQNIVHSKR@
QSMKVRKSIZ1L%ZZR%HKJKRW.7>W.>IZREGNG^%NZHSKR@
H
-KRU>'Z$RK0RMNH
-KI%RU>'PIMRN-GNG^UVKHSKRHKZ
VHMK%LN-@
IL%Z
H
I%L%NZG-KGU>R^
-KMZNRGNG^G^RNH'M"HSKRITL%MNR@

  QNGR'K- $  ZE^ H GN NIMS LK HIWRG W  LK G  3NHKA

76

H' V(N H"N M" H>E GN ZNIEH

 NE GK 7> Z R IW= X  3T K  ZE^ H GN NIMS LK %] ^  J^ R ' JT Z NVZN
IZE V G
 IG% V=H 3TK ZE^H GN LK QXV RM IFR I%Z%SN'K S
EK/
LJ
 R Z%IVU>R^ %NZHSKR@1H@
-HZ U>R^ S]KSLN-KHNEI-]GRKH VKR
>RA%RZ^%K(HU-R>HIUQNGRKQN%KR@
H.3KVLU>R^ ZUMRQN-G
%4
$GK%H JKR
H
-KUNY H
-KQU%LRNW<^]YN%NJNI-QNRKR
XNRGNU IVU>R^ I%QNRNQLR
 QZRRKR@
GNZE^HE^HHMVM"\
L
 \ZHSKR@
  QNGR'K- $  URKSGN NIMS LK 6> 9 N%K I,E4 N A0= 0 R
R MIRQN'N
WNE Q]IZTVSN'K IW=X JTZN'  JT*^ HSKR HIWRGW  G  NH3KA
QNGR'K- $  URKSGN NIMS LK GN QNIWR*NW ] %  IW= X
M
I -QN V(N NIMS HSKR LK G  GR3% G NE GK 7> Z R ] %  
IW=X %EN %NZH \V IW=X M
- V(N VE
H WN ]%  IW=X M
I-QN
QNGR'K- $  URKSGN NIMS LK %] ^  WK JT Z NVZN HSKR NIMS LK
3IMRKR I,] G N R^ J  IW= X  IZE   QNGR'K- $  URKSGN LK NIMS QNJ'
%EN %NZH \V. IW=X M
R N(K UWNIEQ. %NE U.W. XRNQ RM K L

\V HSEN%N IJ]Y GK KZN G %NE M" UWNIEQ. % I,]GN ZMNVZN G
R^ J  IW= X  JT U 1 HSKR JT Z  3 WR LK %] ^  S % VK HKVK IH QNJ *
L % %MK$
\.G V. G>=; UTIM' HR
 IH7>$IH JTZNVZN % IHMN K IH Z"$ QNJ' IJ]Y
VE
H V
$ \N'N \NH QNI-QN M. VG JTZ3WR HSKR LK % IHMN IH
Z"$ H>QNRK U. GN G>=; JK$GN M. SNEH URKSGN LK % I-=H H>QNRK
U. %] ^  JT Z  3 WR G  H
E  IEQNH  IHMN IH SNSN LK I-M IS%. IWQNMK
H>]WNRK  U. G>=; IHW$ G HGK M" VG HIWRGW HSKR JTZ3WR  %
H>QNRK U. QR(NV W=6K GK HZR 7>aV M=( R=I\QN QNJ' QNJ H>QNRK
U. Q;%N ;%>  G ('. IW=X
$ G>=; I%=HE' E=UN JNVR *R% V R>=H
IUQN 7> M  G> = ;  JT Z  3 WR HSKR LK %  JKVN V  JT 3 NG R^ J  IW= X  H> 0
QNJ'  S= X   URKSGN LK %] ^  IJENI-QN V  VE
H  G  GR3% HRWN- 
VE
H IW=X QNJ' G
 R^J IG\NH IFR I,]GN WNE R^J IW=X H>E ZNIEH
R^J IW=X I][N3% 7>aV IWRNLZN% M
 U- V IHMN IH Z"$ MK  NE
V=H HN3K IW=X ;N'H L>ENMN  R^J IW=X RIMH QNI-QN M. Z"$ JIME.
WK M,RV Z> M ] Z G LK %^ ]  IZIEQN K JIW= V R H> R N' 3RKF IW= X  L

HSKRN HSKR% \SKRN \SKR% Q= E 4 N M^  QHSR QNIG 3SG M% 7> M


ZRN MK S
; HRN7>$G M% V Z"$ MK 3TK U>R^ %N%H LK %]^ S-K %GK 7>aV
I,] G N ZMNVZN G  R^ J  IW= X  IZIEQN K Z>
Z>  EZN%. IW= X  I,] G N ZMNVZN
M>]G M% 7>M HNEN X
UN 8WR H
1 ILMN  U
IYQ. V
$ %KX V=H V IR
7>aV X
1 WNEN HNEN 1
J JIM'G M%
M%  V Z"$ MK SE\ 3IMR IW=X %R3
3TK QSRNMKZ >EVN% Q;Z LK V 3TK GNG^ LK %]^ IZIEQN K V XNR
$
JIW= V R W G . IW= X  L
 HIWRQIU% HIWRG W  HIWR] [ NIRM  QNIG %NZ
M% 7> M  Z R N MK S
;  M%

IUQN% U] U N

77

HSKRSGMZNRN*GM"Z"IZE^]SG
$%NMK$L%SGZ"$IZE^]W
SGLN%V%NMK$@

      Z"$ MK WG. V


$ JIME. VE
H IW==X IWRNLZN% K
IJ]Y 6>9N%K I,E4N 0=0R MIRQN'N  IW=X Q=L WK 7> L]UE IW=X IL=(
J^ R ' JT Z NVZN ] V  URKSGN LK %] ^  ZN%W RKR IW= X  3N\3NV HNR
M
I -QN K I-= H  NGUNR IW;ZN% M"  QNGR'K- $  URKSGN LK GK
QNVZN QNJ' JTZNVZN HSKR S]GK6
9 G %NE XE LN' V
$ SNQG 7>%4.
%]^ IZTV LN'H IXVN 7>aV R=\H LEN7>' GK IVQNRK HR% E=U 7>> Z
$ QNGR'K- $  URKSGN NIMS LK GK QNVZN J^ R ' JT Z  3 WR %  RKR
IW=X JTW3 HR IG=VN G NE G SNEH URKSGN IL]GN M
 U- 7>V
$
SNQG J^R' JTZNVZN GN Q=\K$ GI\QN IWWR' QNJ'K Q]IZTVSN'K IW=X
GUT ] ( # %NZ V
$  UT ] (  GK RX%N HKVK 7>  K Q] I ZT V SN'K IW= X  JT Z N'/
QLS%URZ$E"IUQNMZH]>IVU>R^QN%I0EHIS]SQUN;UVK>VXNGRVN%@
Q%]VH
I1STIMZ]YHN-HRIV%MK$*NRIVU>R^J>R3HSKRM"$H>EHITL%MNR@
U"SKI\QNEIW3NEIVU>R^QXEIGU]ST(KRM"$*UVKMVHNI-QN;RQN-QIWUV
IVHSKRM"$@MRGZ?
LM%
LMN,RIVTW"'KH VKRM"$GNURKSVSKSIVU>R^
S]GK6
9HSKRM"$@MZ>EVN%K%N%HVNRGNG^ H^] 7>JG3GKQNLNVL>ENMN*G%MK$
JNI-QNHN3KZNIMHSKRM>QNSJGWKH Z^EM"$HEI=;M"$VKRGNURKS
IVJ>R3*L
QIWUVHENHSKR@I,]GNL
UKLUVU>R^ZNIEHZ>R3GJKRGM>GK%NHN
0U9NZ]IYQNJNI-QN%MK$RKR@URKSILH]^HMVHSKRL>ENMNSUIVJ^R'
QUZQUNMN@

7>JR
HV SN'K IW=X QNGR'K-$ URKSGN LK ZMNRNL LK % J=31
HR IG=VN IH HN3K WNE ;N'H L>ENMN  % Z"%] ^ WK %NZ GH JNR HKVN
I-MK HN3K WNEN ;N'H MK IVJ> R 3  J^ R ' ST M Z M" 
JT Z  3 WR HSKR MK VE
H  IW= X  IL] G N ZMNVZN R^ J  IW= X  QNH  Z" % ] ^
QLS %UR QG*> = V  %UR VE
H  IW= X  E" H   U-   IL= (   QN%] G  MK
QN%]G M"H
-K IX]VN %MK$ L%ZAIZTV^ M
R JTN'KQ. G RKR IW=X H31
QNIG GN 3
H  %MK$ M" 
I-K H.3K IW=X ;N'H R^J IW=X QN- IVJ>R3 % I*]%AI*]% Z$ IW=X
JT U 1 M
 H  QNGR
'K- $  T K  QST N MKZ > E VN% Q;Z NIMS LK V(N
QNGR'K-
QNGR
'K-$ GNG^ NIMS LK V QNGR
'K-$ %N%H NIMS LK %]^ WK IV%NZ
QNGR'K-
QNGR'K-
GH JNR HKVN 7>MK HIWRGW ILG I-=H R
Z H^J IW=X HT
9. ^RL. IL]%N
JTHN3 M" V ZN%W >IGT3 M" QIV VLZ

-K QNJ' WNVIWH RKR G 7>aJR


MEH VLJ>], GN X
EN *=GRN WVR. QR(NV VLJ]>, GN RKR  JNH N%]^
IZTV^E
H ZN%>3 E
H  IW=X IZEGN M" IH7>$IH 7> JTZ3WR G WNVIWH
WR^J G JTHN3 %]^ XRZ IGT31K IM' %MK$ HR HGK
QNGR'K- $  URKSGN NIMS LK %  QNJ'K Q] I ZT V SN'K IW= X  IHMN
M" IH RW HEN VU>R^ NIMS HK MRK QN- MIRQN' %]^# *NWQR(
M" IH J^R' JTZNVZN HIWR MRK HIWRGW  IL \VR IW=X QN- 7>GN
%NZ MIRQN'N QR(NV JT Z NVZN G  QN7> '  WNEN JIW= V R (= E  ILG
HNR% QNAJN G \VR. %]^ MIRQN%N MRN'N  HIM' E=U ]%

78

H' V(N H"N M" H>E GN ZNIEH

%] ^  J] L NS JT . V G  IW*NL% M
'  7> a V  I- \ V R GN %NZ MIRQN'N
MRN'N  IJQN EU*U  NE J^ R W HMK SN'K  IW= X  I= ;
M
-K IH Z$ QN7>' 7>aV I-M \VR MRN'N JT.V %NZ V
$ IWI\QNV M
W
UN L
 Q=L JTV=\ JTZN' M"
I-E-K U>>R^ UT]( NIMS FN  IW=X QNJ'K Q]IZTVSN'K ZMEN
 IW=X 3TK U>R^ %N%H LK % IHMN M" IH /A
M = H N  H S K R  HR K Z  V ^   S  Q " S  J R W R I G U N R
%N%H S> U
- G L%>  V> R N V R   XNHR. JN\NH
I- GN JTZN' U>R^ UT]+ N+G RNU IRK ZMEN  J]+%]+  7>aV
3SG %] +  
3SGAI-H>QN%G>-K>QN%K%NE*EH *$HMKGNISQNE
H>9 6>RN Z>PN Z>RGNR ;N'H R^J RMN HRVNR@@
Z" JIVHKJ]IG%HR%KHKHNR7>MISU9" R^JRMNISHRNE@
VRN-H%NZVNR ]NRZ"$I-M
 QNI-M
 QN;NR
Z>\I%]GNQN\NIG%RNVJR[RL
MK%KXZ%NIV@
HNZHT
;V%W X]YNE;N'HR^JRMNHRVNR@@
FNMK^RVZE^HKW7>MPUWN9NP=UKG@
\RN IQN'N SM>VN *NR ;N'H R^J RMN HRVNR@@
Z"$HKVN%LNVNMRNZ\
R7>MIHQNZ>MGNG>31X
R
%N%H %KX HM ISXNR ;N'H R^J RMN HRVNR @@
 U> R ^  UT ] (  NIMS RNU QNNWRK ZMEN  GN H> 0  Q] 3 A
NIMSZRNI-=H
 M"I-=H
 M" *N-KI-=H
 M"
QNJ R^JHR SM> *.VK%N%HSJ>9N-WHM@ FN
L
 IV%HKQN
 X> (KQNQ]IZTV%NZIVU>R^ GKQN@ FN
U>R^ J^R V UIVZIVJN-K FN
S^YVLU> GI\QNV7> YIR*NU
IVU>R^ RN\  SY*NU%N%HU>R^ HKXR'
$ENU@ FN
Z"$U>R^ J>=I6QNQJ'NNXNISXNRKRNZ FN
7> J R
H V Q] I ZT V SN'K IW= X  3T K  U> R ^  %N%H NIMS LK W" $  WKHNR
HR RM M% IH NIMS JT*^  I-=H MK M" V(N 7>%4. GN TK %N%H LK GN
H
-K Z%>=\ R^J IW=X WHV U>R^ *K K ILG IW3 IW=X IHMN M" IH J^R
U>R^ V
$ V=VWIUQN% JTNJV M
I-QN V(N ZR U>R^ LK Z"%^] Q]IZTV %NZ
QZR %NZ QR(NV J^ R ' Z
H 3 HR% WNEN 7> J G 3  %NZ Z] V R IG= V N
7> M K Z R N U> R ^  %N%N R^ J  ;NR% HR E" $ GN M"  QR(NV 7> M K IVJ> R 3 M"
7>MK IL]GN R^J S'N E"$GN M" 7>MK ;N'H R^J IW=X WK HN3K %UR IW=X
IWRNLZN% M
H   QNZ IWQHVK QR(NV *UV GK *^ I ZHN HRGN M" 
3NVR IWR> = ;  J^ L N HRH  NR  LUV%] ^  L%ZAIZT V ^  V  HRZFE GK Q= U
IW=X LEG G\H LKW% IWQR( M
' G YR V
$ *=LH Z"$ U>R^ LK G XR'.
IW= X  3R' E-K
 SIEMNRKU>R^ QNJ' IG7>MN9KGWNR

IUQN% U] U N

79

IL%ZN%V GWV HK- HRV%ENUKWNR


QNJK%" QNJNIL7> QNJK% RIX7> %N7>
G>-KH>GRIVNLK-HIRQN'> IYP8XN7>
GNVNHRVNQNIJV^]V>IGWIMHRIMJN7>
V^] LN'
-K*" G E"IMIL]GHWN7> HIRQN'> IYP
 XN7> J]+
*NWQR( M" IH J^R' JTZNVZN I,]GN GN R^J S'NH S-K %GK 7>aV
QN-  QR(NV I,] G N HMN-  V  QNJMK G
 G> % KQ. 7> a JR VE
H  QNIG
V(N %KX STMZ V JRSTMZ G E
H  %]^ RXH 7>aJR VE
H IW=X QNH
QN' 7>aV S"PH XNQ %NE QNJ' G>QNRN RXK G>%KQ. %]^ G\ RM M

V(N QNJMK W"  ] * ^  QT ( NV ZNVN G  UR* V


$  L%Z %MK$ E" $ G   W" $
JTU1 M>]G M
 I-MK JTZN' L>RWG Q/ Z]YE %]+ IW=X M" IH HSKR
Z%K3K W" Z *] ^ M  JIR*^   WIW;NVN *NWQR( M"  IH HSKR JT Z NVZN
RW=U M" Z%K3K GN QR( RW=U M>]GN M"  V(N QNJ' QNJ JTU1 M>]GN
M"   7> M  JIR*^  %NV% QR(NV RW JT ( Z WNEN JT * ^  M"   7> M  RW
ST I MZ] Y . GN WIW;NVN M"  I*] % AI*] %  RW E
H . GN RX%MNR M" 
-M^ LK7> SM>V L%Z*RIZQNV.IVU>R^ 3SG>'NI-QN@ J]+
*NWQR( M" IH 3TK U>R^ %N%H NIMS LK HIM RM M% IH ZRN I-M
LKW SM>V Z$ V
$ L%ZAIZTV^ G X=HR IW=X *RZGN IRMN M" M>' J^R'
IVU>R^ % WNVIWH %NZ JTGN% HKVN
3TK U>R^ %N%H LK G J^RWAL%Z V>=U IW=X RNLN Q]SRK3 VTVN
=>U IW=X RNLN L%H M
- K V IFR %N%H LK M
- V M
R 
%KQN G
L%Z. GK V. IU'VK MK %MK$ M" 

JT*^ HSKRNIMSLK% WNZKRNZN%]GLK%]^ V=VWIUQN%Z0NI-QN


J] I YV WNZK RNZN%] G  LK I-= H  IWGWN% J> R 3 % W G . V  UKVN
LK G U^94 IUQNVN Z]% L.G K

J]L NE GK 7>ZR IW=X RNZN%]G LK %]^ U>R^ ;NR' HR%N
IL Z $  HSKR JT Z  3 WR HIWRG W  QNJ'  EKE4 N Z-K RKR IW= X
J] L  NE G  M
 U-  VG U> R ^  ZIRQNGN S'N-K R= \ ' E-K EKE4 N  HKVK
<N-K NE GK 7>ZR G S=X GN R^J ;NR' HRH WRAWR Q];R IW=X
J] X U] U N [N1 GKQ. J 9 KQ. G  7> a V  E 1  U-  IL= (   WNZK RNZN%] G  LK
JTVKIG% I-3%N% QR( LNI-QN HRG % 3TK RNZN%]G LK XNR. WG.
G  IUQNVN V  JIW= V R UKVN LK G  IWGWN% Z] %   L.G  % WNZK
RNZN%]G LK GK 7>ZR  NE GK M
 X>=HK K HN3K IW=X L
 J\]Y J^LN
G^  R  J] Y V. %  XEN R= \ K K 7> M  S] G  HRWN IG= V K K RNZN%] G  LK
3NVR. Q%>NR N;%N G=G K V J^RK HN3K IW=X QNJ'  GRSNR
EUNI-QN HRG  K RNZN%] G  LK JIW= V R UKVN LK V  JIW= V R W G . G

80

H' V(N H"N M" H>E GN ZNIEH

QN;NR G  IW;KW= ;  N;%N G=  G  % 8Z %NZ GN LNJ 7> J G 3  IG] G 
%
7> IG% WK LG I-3%N% HR% G E-K 7>M J]XU]UN [N1 7>aV U-
V. J9KQ. 7>aV HSKR NIMS E1 M
- % WR STMZ ZM^RV G M%4
R IW=X WNZK RNZN%]G LK %]^ HSKR NIMS IG\N-K %MK$ IG=V HSKR
NIMS G IR IW=X RNZN%]G LK G J"R GK \9NZ E=U U-K HSKR GW
% ILW$ SNEH R
$G M% 7> VR4. R
'N 3>R^ HR IG=VN RNZN%]G LK VLK
%NE 0>H V GI\QN IH IHV SNEH G X
1 V. %MK$ E=U U-K V IJQNR
%NE 7>PNI-QN 7> Z$ RNZN%]G LK G UE GK H]PK ZNEN  I%=HEH
JTZ3WR HIWRGW G UE IW=X J" U-K RNZN%]G LK % IHMN IH S1N
RNZARNZ S
E
 RNZ G %NZ %NE G>=\ G^R M
 L.G M% J>=VR RNZARNZ
S
E
  HSKR NIMS G  IR 7> a V  M= (  R= I \QN I33^  G  R^ J  IW= X  HSKR
NIMS X=>J M
 U- IFR RNZN%]G LK I-3%N% HR% E=U U- V 
IXQN
IH S= X   %] ^  QN3RZ IW= X  E"  X= E .UN ILGN M
W  U N 7>  G  H
E  I*LWN
GW.UN RNZN%] G  LK %  I-3%N% HRH  G I \QN IH S= X N 7> a (  %MK$ M" 
HSKR NIMS 7> a (
$  Q] V RI;QN% M
-   V  QNJ'K 0
$ J9K IW= X  QN U- 
RNZN%] G  LK % 
IXQN IH S=XN K XEN IUQN M
-U N M>' 7>%]^ IH=(
E= * .

 HSKR JT*^ G>QNRN WNZK RNZN%]G LK G QN3RZ


IW=X G
 R^J ;NR' HR%N

I-=H IG% WNZK RNZN%]G LK GN H


-K I33 IHV IV]U HR IRMN
K HSKR NIMS 7>a( XE U- 7>M IR3K LK 3TK IW3'^ J>RN' GK H(N
>'N IRMN K 7>M HIM IRMN K IH *UWN% IW3'^ LK NRK I3T31K G
RX%MNR M% I-MK *G JNE'HRVN M% I-MK RNZ V IHT3% R^J IW=X
QWVNR QN7>' WNEK JRZ3HVK M% I-M QL%Z M% 3TK IW3'^ LK G
H
- K ZNVNAIJVN %MK$ M% HIWRK3WR %  I-M NRK XT X N > ' K
IV]U V
$ SNQG HSKR JTZ3WR % IHMN IH IR3K LK HK Z"$ I-=H JT3%
J> = 6  HGN M.IR3K LK %  IHMN IH M. S 1 NC J= > 6
  7> (   " $ H9N GK
]I\QN IW=X *UVL% K HIWRGW % IHMN IH QNJ IW3'^ J>RN' V
$
IV]U >'N RM K IH 3TK IW3'^ LK MK JRZ3HVK M% I-%4. V
$ MK
ST M ZN V  I3W LK GK 7> V J= V K M
- K M"   IR3K LK %  IHMN IH Z" $  L

> ' N7> G N M. IW3'^  J> R N' IW= X  QILMN MK IEI\QN M
I -QN M"   HSKR
NIMS %  IHMN IH IR3K LK
LK Z" $  V. QNJ V
$  3] H N I%WNR% GK JT N (%N
HKVK M"  QNJ G> \ K %N M
W
  I-= H  IG% Z" $  I3WJ> R N' 3> I 'QN K 7> 
IW=X 7>M ZM.J>R3 >'N IRMN K IH *UWN% I3W V
$ IW3'^ V STMZN GK
7> V J= V K M
- K M"  JT Z N' JIW= V R I3WJ> R N' R^ G R] I MVN QI;/ V  
IW=X UKVN JT"a U
R\J>R V
$ JTHNI3V  GWK *NUWV G VKR H]G IW=X
IEI\QN M" IH GWK I-M IV]% STMZN IW3'^ V(N I3W GK Z. M" I-M
IV] %
$  V. %N3WN% M%QIW%N3K %MK$ M% IR3K LK I%R7> a VR M
 U-

IUQN% U] U N

81

 U> =    IW= X  QNH  S


E   V] ^  H
'  M"   IHGN J> = V R M"  HSKR NIMS V
$
JIME. MK G^  R  *UVL% HIM' E= U   IH I-M V. %KR^  L> E NM  GN J> = V R
M" WNZK RNZN%]G LK GN I33 HIM' E=UN IH V]^ UE IW=X H]PK IHW
$ JN R=\K M" W"3%^ N;^ V>EK G I-=H Z'K- GK ZNEN UE IW=X JN7>$G
M% 7>V
$ I-M JTZNI'V M>]GN K IH I- W"3'^ JT]JRN V
$ 7>JG3 IEQN
M
I-QN M"  VRN U>R^GW H' M" HSKR NIMS % IHMN IH ZR U>R^ LK
7>MK M% L
 IH QNJG U>R^ LK M% 7>M IR3K SM>V HT
I;V M
 IUQN V
S
I EQN IH M  %NGN%C V] ^  Q6^ V . L> E NM  GN S 1 N QV  Z R   U> R ^ G  W  %] ^
QNJ'N U>R^ G=GN M"$ ZR U>R^GW GN JVN M" H' M% 3TK 3TK 
J] I YV RNZN%] G  LK QXNIRQN V^ ]  L> E NM  GN SNEH 7> M  V. V R   WRU
Q3^V. G GR3% WK %MK$ HRG V V]^ HIM IRMN M" IH Z"$ 7>%4. V
$ %NZ
IEQN M" G\ EW
 *N-K *UVL%
$ I-M 0^PN HJ1K M" M>' U>R^ GW G
H
E LNW.UN V 7>%4. %]^ VRK NRK HMN'K G=.UN V]^ 6
1K LNVK GN S=XN
NY  U> R ^ G  W  GK S I -= , VK HR IRMN M"   HIWRQUI% S
E   IH PKH M"
U>R^GW LK %]^ G=
 7> IR3K % LNH 3TK RNZN%]G LK %]^ G=IQN IH U>R^
GW I-=H L>ENMN LNIV GN E9HN M" 7>% V. NYK %=H H=1 IG=VK 7>M
HIM]GN M" IH WNZK RNZN%]G LK ZR U>R^ GW LK M% M *UWN%C NYN
V. SNMR I%HE'N WK G>*=R M
 IUQN WNZK RNZN%]G LK S
E IH H=E4
WR 7>%]^ S>ENQH IEQN7> HE4 G\'N QNJG NMZ' 7>%]^ IH]%N G]Y
G W .UN

WNZK RNZN%]G LK G Z% GK U=E G='K

QUE IG% WRAWR HSKR NIMS %]^ G= %NGN% IWQHVKQ. %


F9H  3T K  RNZN%] G  LK G  NMZ'  7> J I(V HR IG= V N RNZN%] G  LK %
I-M IG\N7> '  E-K IH Z" $  HG  6
1 K LNVK WNIEQ. G  GR3% WK %MK$
HRGN I-M 0^ P  S
E  IRMN K IH I-%  Z R   V
$  GKH3N E-K M"   Q= U 
JRGN EUN IEQN RNZN%]G LK % JRG G IJ=6
$ J>=I6QN IH V^] H
' M" V
V R K HK LNIV M"   V R N IHM9N J] (  M"   QR(NV IH JT Z NVZN GK J^ L N
HRGN M" $ /A
RNZN%]GQI;HNR>I%L>EMNQ]HLUGK3GNURKSISE]S%NVNIM%WNWV3K3@@
RNZN%]GH^]U>R^HM"V%"$%MK$IZENVGNURKSGR3%*-J"9EUKL>]ENV@@
J](XEVP
HREUKRNZ%NZHIMGK%GNURKSHR%MK$K\E-KJTSK%@@
QNYNJ9GNEN-HIRRNZN%]GS^0]VGNURKSH>E]U6ISQ;RYNHH>G]V@@
H%LNIVH>EJ](M"H'V>ZMNRN%NZGNURKSQN;K%UIVS
EVM"SIEL.W@@

7> a VR HSKR LK GN/A

LNIVMZNRKLUVU>R^JTZWRJGJ](GNURKSIE\IVJR"%NZI%R]L%H]V@@

RNZN%] G  LK S
E  / A

RSNEH>%G>RS>;
= K[1ZPV%QNHNRGNURKSGRGEUNM
S
E RL%MNR@@
V>ZZ
Z%HJNEWNL>EMH[RSNGNURKSQIUQN%UIV-VNIGT9IW3WN3@@
ZN%SYN-K6NIYHIRS
ESNEHS"$%GNURKSQ;ZZ>=\K-VNV>Z[1_"$%@@

82

H' V(N H"N M" H>E GN ZNIEH

VRHVE>"$S
EV"RNZN%]G>RIUQN%GNURKSH>LNIVM"QN\R%KXI%GN%@@

JTZ3WR HSKR LK HIWRGW  % IJQNR %NE 7>aVR IG=VNA

ZMHSG%\>ENHR>I%WNZKJTSK%GNURKSZ%KZR"Z"$QNILLQN;K%@@
Z"$QIWUVUIV"JR"XNIRSG"$G^RGNURKSG3$IG3NHEI];*RJ^R@@
HEI];*RJ^RM^]\NIEHMZRN%NZGNURKSQLNIVM]^V"$L]^HM.SIEL.W@@
LNIVJNIVZR%MK$%MK$SVK%MK$UNZGNURKSQI%%UIV%MK$MZNR%NZ@@
%NGIS]GZR%MK$%MK$U>GN%MK$UNVGNURKS3SGLN%MK$IHKHNN(@@
S]UKIS6R^%MK$QNIGQ]VSM>L.IMGNURKSHEW]^SNMR*KVRZ.IM@@
-WNZKI3T31NZ"$I3T31KMZNR"VKRGNURKSQ;RS^]QIWUVVHSKR@@
JMZK;RI'QNHN3Z"$Z"$IWQNJHSPRGNURKS%G^RNMZZV>E%MK$QR@@
MZGN%HGNM"$HRVNJ>R3HRKZGNURKSQW;^VMZMZSTMZXNRKKZ@@
>I%RNZN%]GRNZMZZ"$SNW%%RI]MGNURKSHEKHEKMZMK$IHT3%Q*]U@@
MZMKI-]GRH>SR
 M"$STMZNIW3'^ZM3GNURKS;RZ;W=LN;RI'RNVE33@@
>I%WNZKIV*N\M]^ 0^P%MZR"IR]XGNURKSMZR^JIS%QRHEJTJX
] @@
U
VNEN7^$WRU"$IFIRJ"$P]^JNVNEGNURKS<^]<VIFR]^MKRZNI'HENE@@
I-GRKQNH]HRSM>VENEHMK$HMK$PNWURKSGNZNI'HX>U$" MZZ>RLKWN%.W@@
ZRLKWNZNI'HX>U"$H]HRJ=(RYNIRGNURKSY
RKQUZ7>VR
3SGQN;NR@@

L ZRK LNIV J>=6 RM M


 V. Z"$ LUVU>R^ M. WG. IW=X IEI\QN M"
IH LUVU>R^ NRK I3T31K %]^ IUQN% JTGN% HR% WNE HSKR JT*^ %  Z
RN J]( HK M" IH JTZ3WR GN Z"$ ZNRUGR3% HRGN M.  I- G
7>aVR IW=X HSKR LK % IHMN ZRN JTZ3WR J]( M" -K3 -K3WR JTZ
3WR ST M Z JRST M Z J^ R 'ST M Z V(N 6R J> R 3 QH3R J> R 3 JRZ
QH3R J> R 3  Z" $  7>   RW7> a X 3HVK > J T K Z JNWR  JT Z  3 WR GN
ZNRU GR3% HR% QNI-QN M. L
 Q%]V H
I1 STIMZ]Y G RXNI-VN V
;NR'AJ
3 ' HR% WNE  M% W G . IW= X  IL%] ^  HIWRG W  HIWRQIU%
QNIG %NW. %NE ] S
I ;V HKVN M" 
-K3 V 6RJ>R3 V. STMZ %]^ IHMN L.GN M" L
 HWE I-=HKW$ STIMZ]Y.
GN WNZK M" JRSTMZ V QH3R J>R3 %]^ -K3WR IHMN L.GN M" L
 V
]\ STIMZ]Y. GN WNZK M" V JRZQH3R J>R3 %]^ J^R' STMZ QV JTZ
3WR IHMN L.GN M"  L
 Q] \  ST I MZ] Y . GN WNZK M"  QR(NV H> E  GN
ZNIEH M" V I- E-K HSKR LK % WNZK RNZN%]GLK %]^ IHMN IH ZRN
J] (  JT Z  3 WR GK JT N JVK WNEN M" 
UKVN QI;/ E
H  %] +  IW= X  IEI\QN M"  IH WNIVW IW= X
QIW%N3K JTZ3WR V. H
-K M
R MK M" V 7>MK IV]%. E
H. JTW3 HRH *
GN ;NR'AJ
3' HRGN M" V 7>MK QIW%N3K JTZNVZN JTZ3WR I- %NZ
%NE LNI'QN L.GN M" 7>M JTZ3WR Z"$ MK M. I-M U=E >'H WNZK
RNZN%]G LK SM>V U>= M
 U- V IHMN IH R I%H]ZC V^] 6
1K LNIV GN V
6
1N Z^]M W=YK U=E V]^ QNJ' QNJ *UWN% S' S"PN S>RKQ. UNE4. WK
IG=VKQ. HSKR NIMS S
E IH U>R^GWC QNJ ZR U>R^ LK M
 QNJ Z"%]^
UNE4KQ. G RM M
 V. WK QN%]G QN IRMN M" EIH% Z"$ L
 QNJ%]^ HIM

IUQN% U] U N

83

IRMN M. Z"$ MK J^R'STMZ M. I- IW=X H


-K 3]HN %MK$ M" I-M U=E
>' H RNZN%]G LK % IHMN IH PIMRLN VRK V. E]SK HMN'K S'UK V^]
I- VR4 .  %MK Z] %  U N Z" $  JIME. QNJ'K J^ L N HR E" $ GN M. RNZN%] G
LK % IHMN IH I-%]^ ISPN8 Z"$ JIME. QNJ'K H>0 IHTQN RIM]GK M" 7>M
HR E"$GN M. IFR SNQG IW=X I- %NE I%J1.UN WNZK RNZN%]G LK
HK IHT Q N HRG  %*UWN% IW3'^  LK GK I-= H  HNEJI%H Z^ R VK
S'N7>D $G K NMZ' Z^RVK IG\N-K G' E=U J"$GK K ILW$ HRZH.Y
HRG  M. *UWN% GK Z^ R VK G  JIME. JN-  M
-   NR  H= J 9  7> V NR H 
7>%. %]^ LE %NE I-3%N% HRWN H IFR NF H=J9 *UWN% PNH>R %^]
JIM'NH  UE IW= X  ZNEN JNH   IVEH EUNH  Z> H 1 R= \  IG] G   M%
RNZN%]G LK HEJ%N HR RM % HEJ%N HRH *UWN% GK HNEJI%H
Z^RVK S'N-K 3R;N %NE ILW$ %]U J"R LNH QNJMK U]UN LE IEQN-
M
' QILMK QNJ'K *NW%N S'NH PNH>R LK GK Z^RVK G H=J9 7>VNR
IFR I-3%N% HRWNI-QN V  %W $  WVR IJM'N IG= V    IVEH EUN
IG=VN Z>H1 R=\ IG=VN V ZNEN H]PK  JN7>'K *>=E U- M>' L H]PK %N
JN7> '  V. J^ L N Q;^ R K QV  L I-=H WNR Z>H1 R=\ IG=VN V. Z>H1 J>%R
7>%^] 7>VNIRQN %MK$ LN HGN
HGN L  7>    IG% Z> H 1 7> V NR GW
 V. J^ L N
\]IYV Z]%K L.GK M" WNZK RNZN%]G LK QNJ' QNJ%]^ H
 RM M% IH
I-] % N LKW% M
 IUQN Z R N HGK WK Q"  K QILMK UEVK IL] G UK IWX
%MK$ S'K K JT*^ Q=L HK UEVK S' U-K Z>0 JNJK V
L Z>H1 7>VNR.
V. J^LN \]IYV 7>D% 
IXQN IH Z>H1 G 7>aJR %NE H]PK ZNEN  JNH
G \ GN M. HEJ%N %NE HR RM  M% H
- K NMZ'  Z^ R VK %MK$ M"  V
JRGN E=IUQN M" HSKR NIMS G^RK VR_ S"P M%  Z>H1 IW=X ZNEN
F U-K Q= U   %MK$ LN RMK K VG RNZN%] G  LK %  
I XQN M> '  HK
HR. M *UWN%C Q=L V. ZRN NRN MK IG% IWQR( IUQN Q=L GK
ZRK *UVK HZN-K IWQR( U-K IH7>$IH IL%]^ JTZNVZN GK HH M]>GK
M" 7>GN I-=H I%=V I%Z WK RIM LNW V. 7>%]^ GRG SM>V M]>GN M"
ILW $  I-] % N% GK L S  H= 1  LNW  V  I_R SM> V  J6VNWN HRGN M"   I-
VR4 .  MK JT * ^  G  = X   *UV. %^ ]  Q"  K EU% M> ] G K M"  I-] %   IW= X  HSKR
NIMS % IHMN IH WNZK LK ZNEN GK [^]YK \
E4
 V UE IW=X JN IG7>
IFR U] <  EUN G ' N Z> H 1 7> V NR%N %MK$ JW U N M> '  RNZN%] G  LK
IHM9N Z> H 1 7> V NRGN K IHM9K U] <  \
E 4 G N K H> 1 KQN G  NMZ'
E=UN JRGN WK WNZK RNZN%]G LK % QNJ' M=( %NE >=1 IG=VN V NR
STMNZ' ZNL G NMZ' 7> HSKR JTZ3WR %]^ K% %NE EUN IEQN
RNZN%]G LK % IHMN IH M *UWN%C QNJGN V. I-]%N H
ZE RKR M" ILW
$ IH R]^ M
W V ZRN J=(R L"N RKR M" I-=H JN V. JT*^ \9 QV I-=H
JN LNVK V ;RZ GK GKWNR M" JT*^ XNM' WNEK J>]% QNVZN ;RZ GK
S%NW1K GKWNR %]^ V
9%N 3T31 Z]%G M% W"N MK WNZK RNZN%]G LK
% HKVN NMZ' J^R' JTZNVZN %]^ JN H %N LNVK G\K QV %N MK ;RZ
G I \QN %N 6^ Q NA6NV H W E QNVZ HIEQN' G I \QN I-%] ^  ST N MZ'

84

H' V(N H"N M" H>E GN ZNIEH

HIM] G   M%
S
EV RNZN%]G LK MZ [R S9N >HNE URKSGN J^LN HR"$ Z>H>1 FMK LIG ZNE@@
WNHR
$]*NEHIR>I%WNZK>RIUQN%URKSGNIRZ>H>1;IRZNENQ1HKLN%@@
WNZK[>]YK\
EHRIFIRZNENUEYNRURKSGNI-*L%H]^LN%VM" HRVNR@@
IY7>YK J9GN G^IR HIR EKQN H]P EUN- URKSGN U>LRK SM>VSG%"$ SG% IZEN-@@

IFR WNZK RNZN%] G  LK %  IHMN M  HSKR JT * ^ C  QNJ%  0^ P  IH7> $


S
IEQN HSKR NIMS S
E H"N 0^P WNZK LK WNZK RNZN%]G LK %
IHMN IH QNJ HIM RM K IH QNJ% ZR V
$ %NZ E" R=I\QN M" QNJ
% ZR V
$ 7>JG3 HG
$ IEQN HSKR NIMS S
E I-=H Z$ QNJ I-3%N%
HR% E-K J] X U] U N [N1 7> a V  U-  K Z" $  7> a (  E I 1QN M
I -QN K
QNJG J"R. GK \9NZ ZR IR IW=X E=UK K V. QNJ% IHMN K IH S
1N RNZ %NZ S
E
 RNZN%]G LK S
EAM. M>' H>0 NG QNI-QN JT]V^ 7>M
V. SM>V 6
1N S=XN K IH7>$IH 7> Z$ J]L NE GK 7>ZR G S=X SM>V
W=Y M
 LNI-QN HRG % V J]L NE G S=X G RKR IW=X V <N-K NE
G S=X G RKR IW=X G>=U'N Q]VR M
 L.GN K  HSKR NIMS HIM' E=U
IH WNZK LK G\
 Z"$ Q"N K WNZK RNZN%]G LK G NMZ' WK \94
M% V I-=H <N-K NEN S=X GN G^RN R^J S'NH IHK WH GK I-=H
Z]LK IW6K K 7>G 7>aJR IWRNLZN% M
 U- M>' RNZN%]G LK % 6 SNR
I-=H JN GI\QN V 6 SNR G^R JN GI\QN IFR Q=\. ZEZE H G
I\QN IH IHV ZRKQ. Q=\. ;
\N V. %MK$ \N RMKQ. I-VR4. G\ MK
RM K IH I-]% IW=X HSKR NIMS GN 6
1 WNEN R^J 7>aIPQN V HSKR
NIMS G W=Y J]L NE WNE WR^J IW=X ZNQ IUQN J]L NE WNE
WR^ J  IW= X  HSKR JT Z  3 WR RIM U- 
Z%HK J^LN V>Z E\K Z>H>1 ZNE JRS URKSGN UIV H
 E\" H% WR' IHQN *
3@@
MV
$V>ZI3H3NG-KZNI%E-KZ%Z
RURKSGNH
ZEJ>R3MZRNSG%HP
R@@

VG RNZN%]G LK S


E IH ZRN WIMZ IZ=1 IUQN M JTZ3WRC QNJ%]^
IHW$ JIMXN' HG M. QNJ IH LNVK V IH *A*^3N IW=X \94 M

QK$ %NGN% JT N 'K QNJG  %NE WNGAIWWNG HRH  G
3 K M
 U-   Z> Q N_
HR%N J^ R ' JT Z  3 WR HIWRG W  Z" $  QNJGN Q'LN% S= X N M.

WNZK RNZN%]G LK %]^ VE


H GR3%#

>I%S=XNZ"$WRUHKH"6.Y$RKIVURKSGNU>GRKEUKL%ZLNVM"SKV@@
XNIRZ>IHVS"H>]PZ"$IL%HKZ
R"XNMURKSGN[RQUZHKH"$JN7>$(NM@@
MZR^JLM.;RI'M"RV%L9S
M3
*URKSGNS"H>]PH]^V%Z%MZNRNE
*@@
3]\X=HRUGNJGZM"$Z
M%ZG%Z>RNIRURKSGNZ>REKSL>RUE
HGRSNIR@@
G>;$HK%GKQ.SU"$VISR?>*N%URKSGNZ]GEZ>IHV>RUNJ>RQ(N%@@
RV%L9N7>Z%>3M"$U'U];RWSGWURKSGN7>;NZHKH"$6
9>]W@@
IRU>LNZQ(RW']UNW"$XNR$WGURKSGN[RQUZHKH"$LN%
$*G@@
XNRZ>IHVIXVW%EUKH""$S]X^]VNIMURKSGNU>JVNRUIVMZH
;
Z0N-@@
>RUE
HS""H>]PM"N"$JR$%QRURKSGN613NVRXNIRSGHKGR@@

IUQN% U] U N

85

XNRSGUNW"$IV"$>R%RZ>I%IZENJURKSGN;R>WJ
RILIZI1U-VK%]^ VNJ@@
JTIMENGU-IVE
HH^] >RUNJ>RKZ>EURKSGNMIR*IHVHKZ"$S]XVM^] ;^E@@
IS]TGNW%U-IVE
HH^]>RUNJ>RKZ>EURKSGN7>Z>IHVH^]H"$LN7>$*^E@@
%NRGSTMZ.IVR1"$UNW"$33U'3URKSGNS"H]>P"$QRJR"H
G3@@
M]QPNKILLJ"$Q
RVVK
$WURKSGNLN"$JRQRH%M"GW@@
>I%WNZKI%LZ^EUIVHIMZ0N7>V
IMURKSGN*UWN%H^] R=I\QNLUVZ
IM@@
VKI%E
HHLKW*IW3WN*TZN-URKSGNMZH
$LJ$IVH^];NZIG\N-@@
L
 G\"UN;NZH]^
 LN%VM" Z>0URKSGNV
$HM]^>I%UNI-VRKU^0@@
IHT3%IW3'^*UWN%H^]LM<N-$M$LKWURKSGNIVTE
HZ"$HNEHRZIRKW@@
>I%WNZKV
"$HM]^QUZGKJHK"EURKSGNJ^PJRJ>VHENGS"E@@
J
MZK;RI'QNHN3(]*XEKX]GR^RURKSGNRLISRLHKHM.RMUK;^R@@
VNRN'IVTE
HSXEKI-]GRH>SRURKSGNSLNVM"$>RUJNVNE>ZR@@
XNIRZ>IHVS"HP
]> S1F%NM>QNH-KSNRURKSGNQEJR^JZ[IHQNLN%"$]NR@@
HM
WNZKIHVRM
U XGN*>W%ISM]YURKSGNSKLHHMNXEVJTN'Q
RIJ]Y@@
>%WNZK-H3HVKM"QR;]UK8H.RURKSGNSK,HVM.Q%]VE
HI][NR@@
L"HNV"NRM"JRE
F%NJTN'URKSGN7>3HVKH]^SNRSNRH>RS.%@@
H
I1I-]GRSTMZ.LM.H
I1IHT3%H"EN3URKSGNI3WH
I1M"$HR
H
%HKQN@@
H
I1IW3'^LMNSVM"$7>3HVKH;NZURKSGNU>ESMVM"$QE_SVI%MHNZ@@
I3W3HVKLN"M>- Q%]VH
I1QWVNRURKSGN7>QEFH^] E\
M
- HRVNR@@
QEFMZNRNR^JM"GZGMK%MKG]VURKSGNU>E"$JR"XE%NM"IS%J](@@
IS%NJ](7>H]VH;NZXE%M"Z
RURKSGNUIV%NIHK]\>RUJRY
R@@
]\>RUJRMZS"$>I%WNZKM"%URKSGNMZQEFM"$
MU>E_
H1_"$%@@
L
V"IHMN
Z"$IEMQNIS%G\ %MK$;KLURKSGNWNZK$HM$HM.QEFW
SKL@@
Q%]VH
I1STIMZ]YF'Q%]VH
I17>GUNRURKSGNWNZKHMHMNQEFGKGNR@@
MGSMGHMK$%NHMK$%NHMK$(RJKP
RURKSGNI%LSTMZHKH';NZWMJ
R@@
XEWNZKRJRXE"$U]UVKR>%IUQN%URKSGNS"HP
]> S1H
I1A[1I;QN%@@
VM.H
I1S"H]>PM"$%HRWR]UKV>URKSGNWNZK$>%"$LNVQ%]VL>USKV@@
JTN'IJ]YJ>RZ"$;U-RNZN%]GH
I1URKSGNR>RUZ"$RM
SGHKQ
1@@
VM.WM.IX=VX=IHTV*NGI\FLEGRSNRURKSGNI,GNHKQNMZJN-GKGNR@@
V>ZWNZKZ"$SNES>I;*TZHTZIH-%N3URKSGNI%,STMZV>ZMZRIGT9IW3WN@@
>%
] AS%
]> "$ VZJR"7>R$"   MZR VKRURKSGNRS]UZ"$QIWUVJ^R3HSKR@@
H
I1AH
I1ILGHR"$H
I1H
I1JT'NZURKSGNQ%MGQ;RMZJR"$V>Z;NZ@@
>I%WNZK-HUEU>0IVEVNRKJE,
IRURKSGNRUU%Z"$^RLQ%]VHR
IR@@
MRQZN%Q%]VJ>RIRZI0ZIRZI0ZM
I-URKSGN7>%URHNZTZ%NLN%$H
I-@@
>I%WNZKH" E\
$HIMZ0N7>$V
IMURKSGNIS%JR7>Y$" V%Z%3K3%NM
-@
 @
RW%J>RK-HX=HRM"VM.;%LSN-URKSGNLKVL%ZNH^]EVZN-@@
QN%JGZEUN-HRI*T]U%NGH
\"$IXURKSGNQXW%HRGWG=VH
-IX@@
HNEK7^%H>EK%R]ULNHG
F>%;NRURKSGNH>R]*IRVNHR7>GUNR@@
IX3ZENEU>ENER]UVKI%IUTM%*J"$XURKSGNWM%NU%KH^]M%%NGWRX@@
H>*
] HRXHSHR$7>%HRV7>GUNRURKSGN7>%NU%KH^LKVH
-KI\ENR@@

86

H' V(N H"N M" H>E GN ZNIEH

H>]**RRXHHRIFR1>1VM"J%URKSGNUU%Z]YE%MK$M
VM"R
%@@
QNU[N1KS]GM"I-ENAIJ]U>ENG
URKSGN3>3Z%\>EVNIZENWNM
@@
IL7>$HNIV7>$MKSPRM
VLQN3'S
UURKSGNJESKXJGTW3"ES*
U@@
H
I1H
I1S"H>]PM"$H
I1H
I1I3W33URKSGN7>;NZZ"$STMZNH
I1%R3@@
QWNGN%QZN%J>RXIEWNZKVM.XNEURKSGNJRE
Q%]VSMIR%0]J HNE@@
QZRXKRVM.JMIRM"$QZRM]>\;NZURKSGN*
L%QLRXEWNZKI%L;NZ@@
S
EV RNZN%]GLK >% HSKR HRVNR URKSGN S R^JZ"$V>ZMK$ S
E% MNR @@
V>ZNIMSV>Z]VM
V>ZVU>R^ V>ZM]URKSGNV>ZR^JIS%Q
R%G^LNQ]@@
Z"$*UVNZ>HVN*NIHQNHRZH>G
] %N3URKSGNQIWUVIZEZ1KZ%HKSN@@
G
M]^ PR M" -H V]^  *N -H  G
 URKSGN MZ VNR'"$ 7>VR M"$ Z[ L
@@
U
31K RNZN%]G "$ HN3K %UR Z]0NR URKSGN IL]G JKRH MZ JN- GKGNR@@
S
E RNZN%]G LK >%$  HSKR >*.% URKSGN Z>HVN * 7>;R IJ]Y QR> JTN'@@

HSKR NIMS HIWRG W  %  WNZK RNZN%] G  LK V


$  J> = I 6QN IH
WNZK LK QNJ IHM9K J^ L N HRG  M
  WNZK RNZ%] G  LK %  IHMN IH
Z" $  W G . V  UKVN LK G  Q%>  NR N;%N HRGN M. HSKR NIMS %
J>=I6QN IH WG. V UKVN LK G Q;NR 7>aV N;%. HRH IH E
H IW=X
LN7> U    WNZK RNZN%] G  LK %  IHMN WRU IW= X  LNW.UN HSKR
NIMS % J>=I6QN IH WRU IW=X HK HR
$U GNVN RNZN%]G LK % IHMN
IH 7> a (  SM> V  IJQNR  *UWN% IW3'^  LK M% 7> % 4 .  G  GR3% HIRQN
HR.UN V  7> a (  G> = ;  GKQ. %GKQ. M% 7> a (  H
- K IX] V N %MK$ M"   H
- K
I_HR %MK$ M" Z"$ 7>a( QN%]G %NE RM.UN HSKR JTZ3R % J>=I6QN IH
WNZK LK IH] %   IG% RM
U   WRU IW= X  IWGWN% J> R 3 % 7> % 4 .  %] ^
IUQN% K G
 MK IZ]1 IW=X Z0 U- 
WNZK LK S
E ZRK IL]%K *UVK GK HZN-K M
WUK VG V=H RM.UN
HSKR NIMS %  J> = I 6QN IH IFR IH= (   LNW
U   RNZN%] G  LK %  IHMN IH
%N LN' HTZ QN;NR 7>aV IH=( V(N IH ^%K IW=X L%Z M
WUN HSKR
NIMS % IHMN IH I-M N;%N V. WNZK LK QNJ' Q]\. WNR HKVK
M" I-%NE LKW Z>HV %MK$ M
 HGN QNJ 3TK IW3'^ LK GK N;%N
HRH  WRU E
H  IW= X  LN'N XNM> ] G   M
  L
 N;H ST M Z N;%N HRH
STMZE
H IW=X L.G M% 7>M WK L%ZAZR% G X=HR IW=X MK RIM]G M%
IH7>$IH I-=H IG% ZM.WRU L
 STMZE
H IW=X SI'QN M" 7>MWK %31 M

LNWUN UKVN LK G  QI;/ GN  W. E


H G=GN M" WNZK RNZN%]G
LK V. IWGWN% J> R 3 K 7> % 4 .  %] ^  7> M  E
H  7> U EKQ. 7> a V  NG K
WNZK RNZN%]G LK % IHMN IH QNJ PKH HIM]G M
 QILMN MK IEI\QN
M" HSKR NIMS % IHMN IH G=
 LK IFR IH=( RM
$U %N QNJG 3TK
IHT3% Z>RNRK RIM'U I-M STMZ E
H IW3'^ E
H QNIG G RW LKW
V 3TK IW3'^ LK QNIG IV]%
$ GWVN WK %31 M
 LN'U IFR QNJ IH=(
RM
$U U>R^GW IFR RNZN%]G LK IWXNR HR% E-K ZLS^R M
 U- JTZ
3WR HSKR NIMS LK % J>=I6QN WNZK LK UKVNLK GN IUQN% IH%
S
IEQN WNZK RNZN%]G LK % 7>aVR IG=VN IH 3TK IHT3% LK % JTZ

IUQN% U] U N

87

3WR HSKR NIMS LK % IHMN IH WNZK LK ]?IJV ZM.*NRV G G^L
\]Y JT3P  J>RN' WNEN V(N  %W$ WNEN  IW=X IEI\QN M" IH
3TK IHTD3% LK V. HIM RM M% IH QRL>% Z"%]^ M>' 7>M UKVN GN IUQN%
NG %MK$ M" Z"$ G>WNRN 7>MK IUQN% %MK$ >'N HGN JTZ3WR HSKR
NIMS LK % NR JTZN' G=
UKVN QI;QN-   E
H   IW= X  UKVN IUQN%GNVN ST M Z  HIM
IRMN M"  IHA
8Z-KVK-HQH3RZSTMZIWMNR%ZNZQ%>ZR%
MJTNIVVL%GMZMIVJRZNZUIVZ@@
I-GN3SGQR(M"IHUKVNS
E'WNENSTMZQR(NVHNEHIMIRMNM"
IH ZNZSTMZ ZRNSTMZGN -KVK I-M 8Z-HQH3TZ 8ZI-=HQ=\RM"
IWMNR% 7>XNR%HRH Q%>ZT% >ZR%HR%GN M L
N;H VL%G
MZ  RKR IVQNU' VH QR(NV Q]IVZ >W. VH JTNIV  >ZR% N;%N
HRGNM" M 7>MN;HMKZRWNEK JTZNZUIVZ JRZUVK%^] IV JTNJV
M>]GNM"
*NWQR( M" IH 3TK IHTD3%LK G RKR IW=X JTVWV JTW3 HRH STMZ
QR(NV M,NR *^LN WNEN L
VK I%R]L% HNE HIM IRMN M" IH ZR STMZ
GK N;%N HWE I-=H 8Z %NZ G IZTV^ V=H L=J' WNE N;H %]^ ZR V
$
IZE' WNEN EN* JTNJV M>]GN M" M
R H
-K Z]VR ZRK *UVK GN %MK$ M"
UKVN QI;/ E
H   V
$   V(N  IW= X  UKVN IUQN%GNVN %
QNJ' IW3 N;%N HR% E-K G=IQN M" IH L
 ZRK N;%N 8Z %NZ G
IZR% Q]IVZ WN V=H HRGN M" 7>M Z"%]^ MK JTNJV M>]GN M" I-E-K
V^] >=; WK HR V(N ZRN 8Z %NZ GN IZR% WK HR IH7>$IH >=; M=EN
7>XK 3WR %NE 3
R  HRH HKVN L.GN M" I- E-K IHMN M" IH 8Z
%NZ GN 7> X NR% 7> a X  3WR IW= X  3
R  HRGN M
I -QN IZR% WK HR
V(N > = ;  WK HR
IFR UKVN QI;/ E
H  IW=X IHMN M" IH I-M IW;N% M" IH L

IL JT*^ GN Q]V V=H IZR% HRGN M


I-QN RKR IVQNU L.GN M" 7>M
7>K %]^ JTNJV M>]GN M" UKVN IUQN%GNVN JT*^ UKVN QI;QN-  E
H
G  V
$  V=H IV]%
$ E
H. IW=X STMZ V(N M
R JTZNVZN JTZ IGW J>R3
JT Z  3 WR QR(NV J^ R ' ST M Z  G  IW3  IW= X  HIM IRMN M"  IH L  H
- K
7>  GK N;%N HRGN M
I -QN RKR IVQNU L.GN M"  V. 7>  K J^ R '
JT Z NVZN JT Z  3 WR  %] ^  MK JT N JV HRGN M"   7>  K V
$  J^ R ' Z
H 3 V(N
VE
H JTNJVK V(N JRZ3.VK JTNJV M>]GK M" I-E-K 7> JTZ3WR GK
3R' IW=X LNH UKVN QI;/  E
H A V(N QI;/ E
H 
Z" $  UKVN IUQN%GNVN ST M Z  WK I-K GK 3R' IW= X  M.
RNZN%] G  LK %  RW JT Z N'. %] ^  Q= \ . %NE G \ H  G] G N IW= X  7> D $ UEK
GSN-K V(N =X %]^ IWHNR HKVN IHMN IH S=XN U=E V. 3NVR. GK
MK G= IRMN M" L
 IH =X M" N%]^ MK IH % QILMN IUQN% %MK$
IG= V N QK$ HK HRK-   HSKR NIMS LK %  G= I QN IH JIW= V R UKVN

88

H' V(N H"N M" H>E GN ZNIEH

LK IW=X MK IEI\QN M"  QI;/ GN   V(N  E
H V(N QI;/%]+
G E
H %]+ J94H G\

JIW=VR UKVN LK V(N JIW=VR WG. %]^ S
E' WNEN STMZ HNE  HIM
IRMN M" IH 7> JTZNVZN GK 3R' IW=X LNM QRL>% VRN IFR ZR% %MK$
M
WUN 7>G E-K QI;/%]+  GN E
H   7>%4. ]V. %]^ \
L
 L
 7>
JTZNVZN G JRZ V=VW %]^ LN%' WNE M
' 7>%4. %]^ G]YW=V JT'NZ HR

IS%ZR V I%3HJ1 *NW %NE 7>%4. GN IVHNR HR
 LG 7>M VVWGR3K
]V JT]% M
 LN' V. IFR 7>%4. V
$ GKH3N %NZ  Z]U
 IFR VRN J>%R
L%ZAZR' %MK$ M
W  U N JIW= V R UKVN QI;QN-   Z] V R V
$   IW= X
IHMN M" IH I-M 7>E1N E=1IHQN M
I-QN ]NR R^JK IST? 7>JR %]^ Z^E
V. QNIG J>R3 QR(NV %NV% JTZNVZN M" %KX %]^ IV]%
$ U>' RLU>'
STMZN VU>' IW3'^ VZU>' I3W  R^JK 3N\NW. M% I- J^R' ]NR
IST? QR(NV J^R' I3T31K RX%N %]^ Z"$ STMZAHNE  %MK$ LN'GN I-=(
IWXNRHNE IW= X  QR(NV UKVN G  IUQN% IW= X  QNJ%] ^  Z" $  J^ R ' IUQN%
%MK$ G  HGN 7>  G  E-K IHK V= V WGR3K ] V  GK \
L  HR UKVN
QI;/  Z]VR   IFR 7>M QNJ%]^ RW I3T31K GK RX%N GN IUQN%
V(N RW JT*^Q. GK I(VK MK G=UN 7>G SNQG 7> JRZJ=G JTZ
3WR GK \
L  HR%K XNMK-  IL IW= X  U-  N;H GN L%ZAZR% %MK$
M>]GN QT(NV J^R' Z
H3 M
 L.GN M" IL JTZ3WR % ]NR R^JK IST?
QR(NV RW STIMZ]Y. GK RX%N HKVK M" Z"$ STMZAHNE  WK 7> JTZ
3WR GK 3R' IW= X  M. I-E-K 7>   JT Z  3 WR GK J^ L N HR
  WNZK
RNZN%]G LK S
E IEI\QN V. Q"N MK M" S=XN ISEH>E QILMN MK M"
JT ] V ^  I-M VE
H  %N V. IHK %  > I 'QN M"  IL HNR' M> '  Z R N Z%
IW3WN3 %MK$ HR IRMN M" IH I-M =X M
WUN HSKR NIMS % J>=I6QN
IH QNJ IHW $  N;%. HRG  M
  WNZK RNZN%] G  LK S
E   IH Z" $  NR
RKR %]^ N; IEQN M" 
U QI*QN G %NE Q]GR HZE. IW=X
$ E][H
IVTH>1K  IVTW"'K  V=H JM>]X L.GN M. HSKR NIMS S
E IH QNJ I-=H
WNR IVTW"'K V=H JM>]X
 LG RNZN%]G LK % ZN;K E-K IH7>IH 7>%4. GN
JTIVIG% GN QI*QN K  IVTW"'K 7>aV LN H IV]% RNV M
 L.G M%
MRH STIMZ]Y IW=X S' STMZE
H IW=X JTW3 HR% G IV]% RNV M
 L.G
M% I-  VR4 .  WKM ST I MZ] Y . G  JNR I-= H K W $  ST I MZ] Y  IW= X  WK I-MK
IWW(N M" I-=H NMZ' STMZE
H G S' IV]% U>JV (N%. %]^ L.GN M"
IL=( IH L
VK I%R]L% IV]% R^J S'NH RIM]GN M" NMZ' GN STMZR];R
QNJG I- %NZ %NE %MK$ \>E4UN I-M STMZR];R WK IV%NZ %NE \>=E4
UN HSKR NIMS % >Q. G G>QNRN QNJ'N IV%NZ 7>XNR% HKVN
NMZ' GN RNVN \>=E4 IUQN HSKR NIMS % IHMN IH M>' Z"$ QNJ%]^
HNE *UWN% IG\N7> $ GN M. IL%] ^  QNJ I%RNHNR HIM] G   M
  L
 UKVN
IW=X HIM]GN M" IH Z"$ * %]^ \.WNUN QRL>%C Z"$ HG IH %]^ GR3%
%MK$ IG] G N Z" $  HG  IH  NMZ'  JT U 1 %MK$ M] > G N HSKR NIMS %
IHMN IH M>' QNJ G Z=H3 7> HNE %^] IG\N7>$GN M. JIME. V. I-=H

IUQN% U] U N

89

ST I MZ] Y  IW= X  S'  ST M ZE


H  G  U> J V (N%. %] ^  IG\NI-QN IH ST M ZN
IW3'^ QV I3W R^J ;NR' HKV M
- % IFR STMZE
H %]^ JNR HR%
G RNV V
$ I%HE H I-=HKW$ STIMZ]Y IW=X E" U- STMZE
H V
$ Q=U LN'
WNE RNV %]^ WK L
 L1N H>]YEK R
WR G 7>aJR M" QNJ'K %,R. IW=X
R= \ GN M"  IH H
- K I%HE %N LNW   I-= H KW $  ST I MZ] Y  GN L
 Q] I VZ E
H
QN7> $ GN M"  7> M  HNE ST M Z 6R J> R 3  GN QNJ'N (N% M"   7> a (  7> M
7>    I*Q] H R R^ J  IW= X  S" P N M"   L
 IH I-GN QEK R^ J  M"   HSKR
NIMS % IHMN IH G\
 I-M S"PN QNJGN I%RNHNR *UWN% IL%]^ QNJ
I%RNHNR HIM]G M
 IH7>$IH 
UKQ. % WG. G QN;NR 7>aV 8Z %NZ
GK N;%N HKVK JT Z NVZN V. IZIEQN %MK$ I= ; KQ. QN U-KQ.
WRU XE U- ZM.WRU U- IFR J3^ S' U- I-E-K 7>%]^ NR
I%RNHNR Z]%G M% IH 7>M IG\N-K %MK$ IG]GN V WG. IW=X IEI\QN M"
IH *UWN% QNHNR IW=X M"  LG Q=U HNE G H
E JM]>X V. NIMS %
QNJ'N NR%NZ G  %NE IV%NZ GN 7> X NR% HKVN 7>    Z $  HNE GN
IR %KX 0>H IUQN HNE G IR G 7>aJR 7>M G>QNR M" ILV
$ VE
H
%]^ LNI-QN L.GN M" V JRSTMZ G E
H IW=X JTW3 M>]GN M" 7>G SNQG
I-=H *]WR U>FN 3>R^ M>]GK M" I-=H *]WT U>FN HNE G E
H IW=X WK M"
HNE G IR 7>aV J"R R=\H HSKR NIMS LK G M] I%RIWHNRK N;H
7>aJR L.G M% I-M HNE 7> GK J9K GN H]Z HRGN M" JRSTMZ G
E
H %]^ JNR HRH HSKR NIMS 3TK RNZN%]G LK GK QNVZN %]^ VE
H E"
U- 7>a( WK I-=H *]WR U>FN M"  VE
H LN H 3TK RNZN%]G LK % G
I\QN IH HSKR NIMS HIWRG W  QNJ'  WNVW R^ J  IW= X  S" P   K
7>a( HSKR NIMS LK GN I-]%N VL M" IH I-=H R
Z H^J IW=X ILW$ HR
9.
^RL QV HR9. X]GRZN GK IZEKA L>EK R
3%K JT]V^ URZK %N M
W  V
$
WK ILQNGN M"   HSKR NIMS 7> a (  LN H  QNJ'  MK G^  R  WR^ J  G
7>aJR XWR HR% E=U 3TK RNZN%]G LK % 
IXQN IH *UWN% V. I-M
M" L
 I3][N3' 7>aV IWRNLZN% M" V I-M V. HSKR NIMS GN H
-K 
WH U'  M
W  U N JT ] V ^  E
H  * V
$  I%QNRN M"   JT Z NVZN GN SM> V  V ,
KQILMN 
X  MK RM  % I-] %   IW= X  JT Z NVZN GN 7> M  V ,
Z -K R^ J
I3][N3' V
$ 7>aIPQN V J]L NEN G S=X G R^J IW=X JTZ3WR HSKR LK
V?V 7>aV IWRNLZN% M
 U-JTZ3WR GN L
 WNVW VL
Z-K R^J %,R
QN IRMN K 7>M SNEH R^J HSKR NIMS 7>aV XWR HR% E=UN7>V
$
SNQG HSKR NIMS GN G^LN VL
Z-K R^J SNEH WNE R^J HSKR NIMS
IW=X ZNQ IUQN QV I-H=E J]L NE G S=X G R^J IW=X HSKR JTZ3WR
V?V 7>aV IWRNLZN% K XWR W"$ X=E IRMN K I-]% %]^ RNZN%]G LK
GK QNVZN %]^ WNIJ RKR IW=X *L IG=VN7>GK ZN;K 1>=1K NMZ'
GI\QN HSKR NIMS Q=U J]L NE G S=X G RKR IW=X S"P M%IFR
WNZK RNZN%] G LK %  IHMN IH/A
VM.WM.IXVXIHTV*NGI\FLEGRSNRURKSGNILGNIHQNMZJN-GKGNR@@
V>ZWNZKZ"$SNES=>;K*TZAHTZIH-%N3URKSGNI%LSTMZV>ZMZRIGT9IW3WN3@@

90

H' V(N H"N M" H>E GN ZNIEH

>]%AS]>%"$V>ZJR"7>R"$MZRVKRURKSGNRS]UZ"$QIWUVJ>R3HSKR@@
H
I1H
I1ILGNHR"$H
I1H
I1JT'NZURKSGNQ%MGQ;RMZJR"$V>Z;NZ@@
S
EVRNZN%]GLK>%HSKRHRVNRURKSGNSR^JZ"$V>ZMKS
E%MNR@@
V>ZNIMSV>Z]VM
V>ZIVU>R^ V>ZM]URKSGNV>ZR^JIS%QR%NG^LNQ]@@
Z"$*UVNZ>HVN*NIHQNHRZH>G
] %N3URKSGNQIWUVIZEZ1KZ%HKSN@@
G
M]^ PRM" -HV]^*N-H G
-URKSGNMZHNR'"$7>VR M"$Z[L
@@
S
EV RNZN%]G LK >% HSKR HRVNRURKSGN S R^J Z$V]^ MK S
E%MNR@

 RNZN%] G  LK %  IHMN IH M  JT Z  3 WRC M  HSKR JT Z NVZNC M  HSKR


HRVNR RWI3T 3 1K G  RX%MNR C QNJMK RWIWQNJH J^ R ' JT Z 
3WR M

G
M^P
9M"-HV^]*N-HG
URKSGNMZHNR'QN-M
ZUL
@
M HSKR JTZ3WRC QNJ G
%
$ LU4N VE
H IW=X V ZR NMZ' QNJ
MK M
 V I-=H V
$ G
 R^J S'NH NY V>3 LKW. G E-K QNJ I-=( QN- M

Z"$*HVNZ>HVN*NHTZH>]G*-%N3URKSGNQIWUVIZEIZ1U-KZ%HKS.@

RNZN%]G LK  NE G ZM.J>R3 V J]L NE G S=X HSKR JTZ3WR
%]^ HIM RM M% IH Z"$ QNJGN GN Z>HV M
 IUQN V ZR Z% GK *RZ'.
A*1H' ZNJV M
 U-K Z"%]^ JTZNVZN G WNVIWH WR^J IW=X GR3%
M
 U- M J^R' JTZNVZN HSKR NIMS HIWRGW C XNR
$ JIW=VR WG.
V  JIW= V T  UKVN LK QNJMK GN U> ' UN' HR RM  M% QNJ HIWRG W
HSKR JT Z  3 WR  LK %  WK IHMN M"  IH/A
SGMZNRN*GM"Z"$SG
$Z%NMK$ILSGZ"IZE]>SGLN%V%.MK
*NWQR( M"  IH XNR
$  JIW= V R W G . IW= X  IUQN% J^ R ' JT Z NVZN GN
MK M"JT]V^ J^LN GK IW;K HWE STMZ L
VKI%R]L%  V=H GK MK M" JTZ
3WR HSKR HIWRGW  GK J^LN IW;K G IUQN% V V=VWIUQN% G E-K
JIW= V R W G . V  JIW= V R UKVN LK IW= X  IHMN M"  IH 7>  %] ^  V. H
- K
V=VWGR3K ]V MK G= HGN M" L
 W"$ MK JTZ3WR M>]GN M" L. H
-K
7>GN *ILQN M
I-QN WNVIWH JTVKI%;K M>]GN M" 7>V
$ 7>JG3 JTNJV
HRH  J^ R ' Z
H 3 QV  JRZ3.VK JT N JV M> ] G K M" 

IUQN% U] U N

91

JIW=VR3NVRWKHIWRGW HSKRJTZ3
 WR G 3NH3K
I- JT H NR HIWRG W  HSKR JT Z  3 WR  %  Z>  EZN%. %] ^  S> R N %MK$
IHMN M" %N MK JIW=VR H>RN' 3RKF %]^ UEV IHMN M" HWE 7>%4. HNLK
V Z>ENW. %]^ EVNI9QN M" L
 RW ZNL %]^ H>RN' 3RKF G WNVIWH
IUQN% G  IWJT K V Z%ZN%K N;%N HRWN RM  M%
ILW $  JIW= V R W G . %] ^  S
E ' WNEN ST M Z HIM IRMN M"  IH J^ R '
JT Z NVZN HIWRG W  G  IW3  IW= X  H
- K L%Z E" H   QWVNR R^ J  QN7> ' N
Z] % G  M% H
- K HGK L%Z %N E" '  WNEN I%RNHNR Z] % G  M% 7>  GK
LN'HNRK V. ;KRN'NZ  V= V WIGT 3 1N ] V  MK G=   ' U   Z" $  ST M Z  %MK$
LN'GN L> R W G  QI;/ Z] V R   I-GN JT Z N' JIW= V R UKVN
QI;/ E
H  V(N QI;/ E
H  V
$  IW=X WK M" LG V=H 7>M
V=VWGR3K ]V %MK$ IZEUN VG V=H LKW GN HIEQN' Q]*W M" 7>M ]V
M>' QN IUQN M" I-M V=VWGR3K ]V RNZJNE LK %]^ JIMXN'


JIW=VR H>RN% 3RKF IW=X JTDZN'

I-  VR4 .  JIW= V R H> R N% 3RKF G  QI;/ ^ R V F> R HN%K ] +  
QNI-V  A IW= X  IHMN M"  IH WNVW IW=X I-SNI-G HSKRN
J^ L N G  
U  HSKR Q= E 4 N  M"   I-M HSKR 7> M K J^ R ' JT Z NVZN M"  IL%
6 IG% IW=X I3T31K RXK V(N =VW$ IG% V=?V 7>aV LN IWRNLN 7>GK
?SR IHK SN?SR V
$  J> = 6
 G \

JIW= V R H> R N' 3RKF %] ^  S
E ' WNEN Q= E 4 N  W" $  IHK M
R  HSKR
%NZH JT * ^  GK VR_ ] H  V  HR IRMN M"  V(N
V(N HIM IRMN M"  IH J^ R '
JTZNVZN HSKR G IW3 IW=X Z"$ WK %MK$ LN'GN 7>G IW3 IW=X IH
V= V WGR3K ] V  SN?SR  V
$  J> = 6

HIWRGW % I-MK IHMN K IH Z"$ W"$ J^R' JTZNVZN Q=E4N HSKR
 QHISR^  M. QNJ'  W=  ( IUQN% GN ] G  3 WNMH R^ J  IW= X  Z" $
QNJMK QNI-QN M. Z"%]^ JIMXN'
 JT]V^ Q" MK QXNRKQ. % JIME. WK
JTZ3WR G WNVIWH IUQN% %]^ L%VN V=H %MK$ LN' IG]G IHMN HRG
% IH HSKR V. QI=I\QH M"I-M ]IHTV V. LN'GN MK %MK$ QK$
I=I\QV M. I-M U=E. 7>aV JIME. V. *UVL% U>]ZRNM M
 U- %JT]V^
M> '  RW ZNL I= I \QH M"   I-%4 .  ZNRU I*T 3 1 QXNRKQN GK GNE
%MK$ UE RMK %NMK UE U K
IE=EQ=EN/ALAAIGZ>
N/A
M]ZIG%IFEQLNIGQ=E4NM>ZZIE=EQ=ENHIWR
HSKR Z>M]IZGI_EH>S^>IRFLNI-E ILHR

92

JIW= V R 3NVR WK HIWRG W  HSKR JT Z  3 WR  G  3NH3K


+ ML^R QHG E=EENM^ QE"IM W =EZ GN I-R3NG M" IH H
-K
S]GN QILMN %MK$ IH ENI-=ENAMAI-=EENMM  HM QV 7>G E-K QNZN%N
G GRWNL %N \>=E4 LN' I-=( V=H IH I-M HIEZN I=;N QR3 V=H JM>]XGN
M" JR S3RV IH HSKRN U>%4NM. V
$ SXN7>$GN RM
_A IH] % K W= Y K _LKEV M"  QV  HS> I EQV GK I-] V MN M"  IH I-M
HEKZN SRNM RNV QR3 ZEN V=H JM>]XGN M" QV I-M M>' ZNE^Z M

IUQN M" IH L HSKRN U>%NM. G %NE WK IHMN LNW V. %F V
$ 7> WHV
WK \NEK %MK$
Z> = E N QEK HNRKRMN FRZ.7> G   M% IH HSNI-R V
$  SX' GK 3RV
HS^E HKVK LEGK QV QNZN% G * GRWNL \>=E4' G -VNSNR V
$ M"
WR%. SNS QV  HS^ E  V
$  HSNI-R HSKR  G  %NE WK \NK %MK$
SNL 7>EZN % I- MGK GN I-M ZVES ISQN% _RZNI-QN  M" IH
Q" 3H3 G WNV ZR% V
$ SNQG 7>GK R^M G I-LNL IW=X QZN%
G  NR  GRWNL  \> = E 4  LN'U 
I-= H  MGK IW= X  QNI-QN M"   G
 HIEZ  QILM  M% IH 7> % 4 .  IW= X
$
I-=H E-K QR3 G %KX H
-K Z>%VMN %MK$ G^RN QNZN% QV ,ZK%
%]^ QNJ' %^R L. QNJ' QLR V
$  *R GA
- H  EN-KENAM I-= E I-= E NM  M"   G^  RN Q= E 4 N M^  QHSR  HSKR
M" 

JIW=VR WG. IW=X JTZN'

HIWRG W  QNJ'  IUQN% GN G^ V  S'H  W" $  MK QN7> $ GN M"  V(N
QNJ'N WNVW IUQN% WNVIWH V=VWIUQN%  W"$ MK HRWN7>$GN M"

IUQN% U] U N

93

QNJ HIWRGW HSKR JTZ3WR  LK % QNJ'K Q]IZTVSN'K IW=X IHMN M"/A
3SG/AQIWUVXEQN-H
-KZRN*GZTZ%MK$JNI-QN 1H %NZRNL%Z%NUR*
SRNSNEHM
IG\ENI-QNHN3K%URLEHZEJRYRNWM.L>ENM%JNI-QN@ZNVAIJVN
ZRH>0%NMK$%NZR[RGNK JV%K L>EMNHN>VQN%HMNI-QNLUVHRZRK
MNK@J.XV=VWHN;9%MK$ZRNLN%>IUQN%QJNRNVWR^JK WNVIWH %NZ
NIMS J^R'JT* ^ HN
-K%NZMZNRN@Q;RGKJ 7>JR
= VE
HZ$ UU%U>FNZ$VM.I%LWV^
NRNL
VWR^JKQE\I%R]L% STMZ *K;RVNI;QN%MZNRN@MNYXNZEM^%NZR
H
-KLN%IV%NZ7>JNKVNR%VR%Q*JGGNVNZ"$M^]HSKRQIW%N3K@

7> J R
H V 3SG IW= X  HSKR JT Z  3 WR HIM RM  M% IH %N V. Z R K
H
- K JV%K M"   %N MK Z R N J] L  V= V W M= Y AXNZ EM^  QR(NV %N9KQ.
G  L
9 AL> U N9 WNEK HNI-QN  GN RKR M"   Z" $  W" * ^ ]  M. V(N
V(N HN3K G
IEMRVNRN %NZH VNENS G LE IW=X HZE G F>=E 7>aV W"$ JTU1 M
H
SNEH R^J S'NI-QN K 7>( Z"%]^ %KR^ %NZ GN L>ENMN X>=HH E" IUQN
K L
 WNVIWH %NZ JTZ3WR GN QR(NV ZRN M" WG. IW=X HIWRGW
U>R^ U]T( NIMS IW=X M=HN HSKR V(N
V(N H>RN' 3RKF IW=X Q=E4N HSKR%
7> M K %NZ Z R N M"   Z" $  7> a JR IR= V ;NZ IW= X  RIM] G N M. V(N QNJGN
*UWN% L
VK I%R]L% STMZ  WK ZRK MK J^LN HRGN M" I-K GN JTZN'
= I VQNR( JT H N3 = V W $  ] Z 7> E N JT + A GK%N%UR J] L NS V
$
JT H NI3V  IW= X  *K M"   W" $  IGQN%] G  LK %  L> R W G  QI;/  Z] V T  
V(N IR=U WG Z]YE  >HV  Z]VR  GN Q%>WNG HKVN M" IL IW=X
WG. %]^ S
E' WNEN STMZ HIM IRMN M"  IR=UWG Z]+  >+  Z]+
V(N  L>RWG QI;/ Z]+ IW=X  AM Z%>=\
 L
 I3T31K V
$ J^RW RW
GK 7>VJVK HRVN V(N
V(N RW GN WNZK K M" V(N
V(N Q=U WK RMUN 7>MK
I3T31K %]^ S'NH ;NR' HR IRMN M" 7> >=\ WR^J JTZNVZN GK *UVK
ILW$ QK$ STMZN V M
R GW WK 7>K GK N;%N  HRG M% W" QNJ
E
H  WK HR

JT Z N' + JIW= V R L> R W G  QI;QN-   Z] V R  A
IZ;G
 Q;Z%>3
 G>R
' G
W
 GWN]LILNVWGM
QNXSMIVRIZVTZMI3XIHVNW.VW] G^VMHIWRIJTXVNM@@
IZ;GMAQ;AZ%> 3 MAG> R
'  A G W MAG W N%ALAQIALNVAW" G MA
QNAXAWMAIZVRZMMAIXIHVWN%AVWZAG^VMAHIWRAQIAJTGVNM
Q%>WNG/A Q; Q=LQT(NVWRVZN%IW=X G>R
' RKRR^JZMEIW=X
G>RNXNRJ^RWH Z%>3M 0^PKJ^LNIW=XEK%Z]%'3KEIWQHVKQ.%]^ IZ;GM
EUN-KM
-KQ=UQR(NV3NVRIW;KRIMVWRVZN%J^LNL
MN%KHNRHM>]GK
M"QIU%LENH*ZHRIG]GKM"QILMN;HGNLKW%3NVRIWR>=;N;%N

94

JIW= V R 3NVR WK HIWRG W  HSKR JT Z  3 WR  G  3NH3K

HRIG]GKM"7>G (N%7>aV GWN% GWVNW.G GWM GWVN LNVWGM


J^R% JTZNVZ. VJ>R3 GK WNVIWH L  J^LN QI  M" QN  IGQNE^
IZVTZM  LKW GN QEK N(K J^R% JTZNVZ. G IXIHVWN%  W( IUQN%
QR(NV(NR(*UVK%]^ G^VM ]G3WNMHR^JIW=X WM E" H QN7>'WNEN
X V(N JTXVNM S
;HRN7>'WNEN VWZ QNJ HIWR HSKR QI M"
*NWQR(/AIL Z$ *UV ZNL %^] 3N3VRIW;K IVQNUH Z%Z]I%QN
QNXR' J^ L N  HRNI-QN LN IRMN M> ] G N M"   7>   Z $  HIWRG W  HSKR
JT Z  3 WR  V= V WIUQN% %^ ]  JT U 1 HRGN M" 
JT Z N' + JIW= V R NZW G  ] I \QN  IW= X
]+ %]+ NZWG Q+%]+ G \]Y %]+ GN E
H %]+A
J^R. I*]G^^WN HIWRIZVLN QLNV
I-]G
T IWWHRZ'
 ;RVNWLTKJ>R>31^VM@@
J> R NZAI*] G ^ M A^ W NAHIWRAQIZVAQ L NAQLNVAI-] G RMAIW3WA
HRZ'MA;RVNASLTKAJ>R^31^VM
3SGQR(/A ^WN  J^R' ZR( HIWR  HIWRGW QR(NV HSKR JTZ
3WR QIZVQLN  IW3NE 3HVK >HV QR(NV RW 3HVKZN% QLNV V
,J>]L GN RKR ZNI-QNW-K S'NH ;TVN  JTH1 M
H QR(NV QWVNR ;NRH
WLTK QNJ'V3SGWIV%NZR^JK3N3VRV
$ J>RNZ HNEASTMZGJNJ
R^JK S];% R^JK HKE %]^ I*]G^M  V
9% WNEN 1>H9A1>H9 HR% WNEN I-]GTM
RW>=\GNI-HJTZ3WR IW3W RWLUVG RWJTN'KQ.%]^ HTZ'M
Z%N WNXN HRZ'N QT(NV J^R' I%3PN G %NE M
R Z% %NE ;NRIZH HTZ.
G>QNRNV*UVK%NE J>R^31^VM V^VK7>JN%NHR%G 
UM"
ILW$S=XNV(NIST;RWHNRLHR%IW=XZR(%MK$M>]GLWN%IWQHVK
RWHNRLHR% E-KZVNR=\GNM"QILM MKJTSTMZSTMZQV IVTE
HK-
STMZ.AIW3'^AI3WV(NM
RGWKAGWVN%]^ S=X QV IST;Z0
 I-E-KHSKR
JRZ3WR%]^ ^WNGK7>JZ.WGIW=XIG=VKM"
*NWQR(/AL
 HIWRG W  HSKR JT Z  3 WR  V= V WIUQN% ]  NR IW= X
QN7> $ GN M"   7> M  RW3HVKZN% M"  V(N HNE ST M Z  G  HRZR^ J K IHE
%^] V
9% WNEN M" 7>M RW >=\GNVN M" RW G J^LN HR% 
U M"
]I\QN%]+NZWG7>VNRIXHQI;QN-%]+\]Y%]+E
H%]+
*GRN WVRN Z]NQWN%
 ZMN% HIWIR%WX%NI% 3]%
QN WXW X]W
M J^ZN%
 IWXH3'
 LNUTIWRGWWKV@@
*GRNAWVRNAZ] % NAWQ%RAZMN%AHIWRAI%WX%NI%A3]  %A
QNWXNWAXZW
MAJ^ZN%MAIWXH3'MALNUTIWMAGWAWKV
Q%>WNG/A IWXH3'M XV>RIWQHVKQ.% QNWXW QNJ' IWXNR.

IUQN% U] U N

95

G>QNRN J^R% STMZ GK J^LN %]^ %N G=H M


R 7>JN%. GN ZNRU GR3% HRH
Q]IZTVG (N%7>aV J^NZN%M M
R7>JN%NILW$*^VAJTVJ^LNIJ=VT J^LN
IV]%
$ U>>'. RLU>'ASTMZ. VU>'AIW3'^ VZU>'AI3WLK  QV STMZ HNE V=H
GKJ^LN R^JK[NWV
$I%HEZWNG%]^ X]ZW
M QNGRG%NEQNXZ%HRNRM
UEV IUQN% %]^ *GRN  JRZ >=\GNI-H ZMN%HIWR  J^R% JTZNVZN HSKR
WVRN MRKRN;NR%W*^3NIW=XQR(NVWVRGNQR(M"W3*^3N
]V*N3NIW=XI-%]^XENWKHIM]GM%XEGNQR(M"RKRLIH]V
GNGM.VM
 L.GNM" V.IHMNL.GNM" IH7>MXEN6=YU- Z]%N QNJ'
VE
H WNE RKR G >IGT3 M
R RKR V,J>]L GN ;NRH WQ%M  QNZ
IWQHVKGKVR4.LKW%LKQHH>0IG%]NRIW=XRIMH I%WX%NI% QNJ'K
3SGNWEKQNIGG ZNI;QZ%NEVIUQN% 3]% WR%'HRH GW J^R%
JTZNVZ.G WKV I6JM
- RU>'AI%RU>'IUQN%%]^ LNU4IWM LNIUTVHRGM%
*NWQR( /A3N3VRIW;K IWR>=; N;%N R^JK ZWNG QT(NV [NVH N;%N
7>aV Q;NIRV*UVZNL%^] HIWRGW HSKRJTZ3WR VVWIUQN%G Z0'
E-KI-=(]NRIW=XJTU1M>]GNM"7>Z$QNJ'VL
Z-KRKR7>aVM
RRKR
R^JKWVR MEHVLGN JIM'HQN7>$GNM" IH7>$IHJTZ3WRGWNVIWH
VL
Z-K RKR %^] XRZ IGT31K %NE %MK$ GI\QN LN HGN  H>0 IG% QNZ
IWQHVKILMNLKW%LKQH EKE4NHRGNM" V(NJTZ3WR%^] QNJ' %^] JN7>'
WNE IUQN%%^] 7>LNURHRGNM"
IRUWG Z]YE  >HV  Z]VR 
I33^ ]  LIUQN%]  MRV]  ZRL] I V 3> Z *] I V WIM% ZR^ V
 U' % 
HIWIUT * K HNW % N HIWR ] V 
Z M JIWVT Z QV I V R * %@
I33^ZLIUQN%ZMRVZZRL]IV3>Z*]IVWIM%ZR^VMU'%
HIWIUT*KHNW%NHIWR]V
ZMJIWVRZQVIVR*%@
Q%>WNG/AJ^R% JTZNVZ. MR I33^Z  IWE=\' Z%>=\ G S=X G R^J IW=X
LIUQN%Z LN%AS>0H JTU1M>]GNM" V QNJ' VVWIUQN%%]^ VZ 7>Z$
ZRL]IV I%RZEVNG%NE 3>Z*]IV 7XNR%HRGNM" WIM% JT*^JTNJVKGK
E=UKIWRMNQU%KWNE ZR^VM *UV U'% Z^MGE-K HNW%N HIWVNW.
G>QNRN HWKVW %NE JIWVTZ QVIV  Q=IVQNI;H SN'K I%RZEVN G %NE
HIWRIUT*K  HIWR SN'K QR(NV HSKR SN'K G>QNRN R*%  7>aX WR %NE
]S
;%HRH S
EGNM" HIWR]V
ZM 7>MQZRJ>R3QR(NVVJ>R3MK
]VQR(NVIR3KR^JIW=X\>GHIWRGWMKM>]GNM"JT]V^ 7>JTZNVZ.%]^ %
JIMXN'HHIWHIM'E=UL.GM%J]TV^7>MJ^R%JRZNVZ.MKM]>GNM"7>GN
WNVIWH %NZ HIWRGW M"
*NWQR(/A IRUWG Z]YE %]+ >HV %]+  Z]VR  IW=X IHMN M"

96

JIW= V R 3NVR WK HIWRG W  HSKR JT Z  3 WR  G  3NH3K

IH QN7> J^R' JTZNVZN G WNVIWH


WNVIWH %NZ %]^ LN'
 I- Z]VT  IW=X 7>
JTZNVZN GN %NZ V(N
V(N 7>GN J^RN JTZN' IG=VN M" WG S
E' WNEN STMZ
HIM IRMN M" IH J^R' JTZNVZN S=X G R^J IW=X JTU1 M
H HIWRGW QNJ'
WNVIWH
WNVIWH IUQN% %]^ QNJ'K HSKR SN'K G %NE I%RZE IUQN% QNJ'
M] QNVZ.WN QR(NV J>]% QNVZ.WN Q%>QN-KQ. %]^ HIWVNW. E
H
HVKQ.
G  G> Q NRN ] S
; % HRH  QR(NV 7> X NR' HRH  WR'% HRGN M"   I-
V=VWIUQN% G Q*NW %NE 7> Z$ JTU1 JTZNVZN %]^ %N JIMXN' H HWE
IR3K V ]V L. HWK Z]% E"$G M% 7>M JTZNVZN QNJMK HIM]G M% IH Z"$
J^R' STMZ M. JR E
H WG G QN;NR %NE JTZNVZN %]^ I%RNHNR Z]% M
-
JT
L% %MK$ JIMXN' G ILW$ URKSGN LK ZMNRNL % HN3K IW=X JTU1
JTZNVZN %]^ JIMXN' H 7>%4. GK ZIMZN HMK V(N
V(N 7> JTZ3WR GQNRN
QNJ'K ZIMZN G=K K 7>GN (NWV WR'% QNJ'K SN'K IW=X HKVN
URKSLNIVMZNRKLUVU>R^JTZ3WRM"J](GNURKSIE\J9%NZI%R]L%H]V@
URKSMZMKQE\Q=EN4 M"$H>VS
> U
QRJKRURKSGN\NIEH;%KMZRN%NZHSKR@
URKS-WNZKI3T31NZ"$I3T31KMZRVKRGNURKSQ;RS^QIWUVVHSKR@

I-] % N J= 3 1 HR% 7> a V  WK 7>  %^ ]  HWK L. ] V  *UV L. L> E NMN
HIM]G M% JT]V^ 7>M J^R' JTZNVZN MK M>]GN M" 7>GN WNVIWH
WNVIWH %NZ
HIWRGW M" 7>M QNJ IVJ>R3 HSKR MK IR3K L. ]V R^J IW=X M>G
] N M"
JT]V^ V=VW IUQN%MK% IR3KQ. V(N
V(N ]V U> R ^ Q . G  QIUQN% I;.V G
QN;NR V  QN;NIRV JT L N 7>   Z $  ZIMZN% R^ J  IW= X  JT U 1 JT Z NVZN %] ^
%MK$ JIMXN'G  IH7$> I H 7> % 4 .  QIUQN%K IR3KQ. ] V . V(N U> R ^ Q . %
JT Z NVZN %] ^  I%RNHNR G= I QN M
I -QN M] > G N M" 
IRUWGZ]YE>HVZ]VRA
IRI3Z%N IRI3HT V W3T N M MVT N 'K(4  JGWKM HWK%NZ
IVT V ]  ;NZZIM34  I3N] V 
Z
 IWRNLZN%^  RNLIV 1^ J @@
IRI3Z%N  IRI3HTV W3TNM MVRN'K(M JGWKM HWK%NZ
IVTVZ;NZZIM3MI3N]V
ZMIWRNLZN%^ RNLIV1^J@
Q%>WNG/AWG S
E% WNEN STMZ HIM IRMN M" IH   L
 J^R% JTZNVZ.
IWE=\' S=X G R^J IW=X QNH HWK%NZ  JTI=; HWKQ. GK JGWKM  7>JN;K
JTNJVHRHQR(NVI-=H]VL.IR3KGK*^IZHNHRGNM"7> IRI3HTV ]V
R^JIW=XJTU1M
-JT*^G>QNRNRXK MVRN'K(M M,NR.SN'K IRI3Z%N ]V
>*NQWNEIWQHVKQ.QR(NV*UV.GE-K W3TNM WRUV>=EQN%]GGNI-H
M>]GKM" 
Z 7>MQZRJ>R3QR(NVIVJ>R3 IVTVN VKR ;NZ Z>HVK
E
HQR(NVVE
HGK ZIM3M >IGT9IJT(WK%]^ I3N (NIJVHRH Q%>
IJ=6
$ ]V ZN%W>IGT3]VR^JIW=XM>]GNM
I-QN 1^J 7>aXI1=ER^JKI][N3%

IUQN% U] U N

97

7>aV IWRNLZN%>RNLIV 7>L=WE(^EQNHNRIW=XQR(NVZN%W>IGT3VL


Z-K
RKRIW=XIWRNLZN%M"
*NWQR(/AZ]VR  IW=X IHMN M" IH HIWRGW I33^ R^J ;NR' HR
E"$GN M" EKE4N HRGN M
I-QN W=YN M>]GN M" HIWVNW. G>QNRN V=VWIUQN%
WR'% HR% G  HNR' HWK GK JGWK JT N JV HRGN M"  QR(NV 7>  %] ^
IR3K ]V V(N
V(N HWK HIM' E=U L.G M% QE IW=X 7>M J^R' JTZNVZN
HIWR MK M"   7>  G  G> Q NRN RXK Q] I ZT V SN'K HSKRSN'K HIWRSN'K
HMK L.GK M"   L
 *UV. G  E-K WRU V> E  > \ GN-K M> ] G K M"   7> M K
JT Z NVZN VKR  Z> H VK ;NZ QR(NV VE
H  GK (NJ%N HRH  V L
Z -K
ZN%W > I GT 3  RKR IW= X  QNHNR IW= X  IWRNLZN% M" 
I- Z]VT IW=X VKRN ;NZ VE
H %]^ IHMN M" ILW$ I-=H STMZ GN
E
H  L
 I-= H K ST I MZ] Y  GN \ V R M"   G^  RN JRST M Z GN E
H  L
 = V  ] \
ST I MZ] Y  GN \ V R M"   VKRN JRZQH3R ST M Z QR(NV J^ R ' ST M Z GN
VE
H  M"  IH7$> I H J^ R ' JT Z NVZN %  VE
H  IW= X  IVJ> R 3 R^ J  IW= X
IWRNLZN% M
H %KX G E
H. GK RX%N HKVK M"  I- E-K %KX U'%N
HKVK U-K
IRUWGZ]YE>HVZ]VR/A
XZ^V%M3H^%MIW*RVWNU
IS]G^MGRJQN>;NI%IS*TV
QJNZT^I*MXZN%MZ>GTZV>RKZ;NZZIM3MIWWIHV@
Q%>WNG/A X  V(N Z^R6V  JIW=VR U
IS]GM>  HNZ;%]^ R^JK RW
Z%
HNZ%NW. J^R% HR% WNEN J^R% HIWRGW IW*TVWN  RW GN JNE' HR%
WNENM" 3%M _"GR]U>HV 3H^%M 3>*
= E=6'>HV XZ^V RW3HVKZN%
M" GTJM ILW$G>=;V
$GMK$S%N7>'GKIW;KM>]GKM"I-VR4.3NVRQ%>H^E
N;%.%NEGMK$R^JKJ^R%Z>HVKGNVN QN>;NI% VVWIUQN%R^JKHNELNE
IW%N3H;%>3>HVNR]UJN'KJT*^M" XZN%M QEK IW*TV *GNJNE'
J
3'HRGNM" QJNZ^RI*M IUMRLE>HV Z>GTZ NURGKVR4.IUMRN
U]*KR QR(NV IW3NE V>RKZ  X( ;NZ  E
H QR(NV Q%NZK E
H IW=X
ZIM3M 7>LW=E>IGT9IJT(WK7>aV IWWIHV QE=U(N%7>aVI*]%WKRIM]GN
M" I-MLN%HNRKHIWRGW\>GMKI*]%AHRH IWVNR%NEIG]GNM"
*NWQR(/AZ] V T   IW= X  IHMN M"  IH J^ R ' JT Z NVZN HIWRG W
HSKR JT Z  3 WR  VKR  Z> H VK ;NZ QR(NV VE
H  IW= X  RIM] G N M" 
I- Z]VR  IW=X IHMN M" IH * V

$ IX=1 R]U WNEN J^R' JTZNVZN L

HNZ; % ] ^  GK VR4 .  * Z%


H NZ%NW. J^ R ' HR' WNEN M"   7> M K WNVW
IW= X  *GN JNE' HRVN M"   7> M K HIWRG W  L
 IZT V E
H  IW= X  I33^  R^ J
;NRH QN7>$GN M" ILW$ G=>; V
$ GMK$ S'N7>' GK IW;K M>]GK M" I-VR4.

98

JIW= V R 3NVR WK HIWRG W  HSKR JT Z  3 WR  G  3NH3K

J^ R ' Z
H 3 JT N JV HR% GK 3NVR IW;K Q%>  NR N;%. G=  H  J^ R '
Z
H3 R^JK GMK$ JTGN% HR' WNEN M" V=VWIUQN% R^JK 3NVR QR(NV
;%>3 >HV M
' %NE NR]UJN'K M" V(N
V(N ILW$ Z]>GR NR LE GN T
V
M" 7> VR4. J^R' JTZNVZN V
$ RW GK 7>VJ=VK M
-K M" UKVN QI;/ 
E
H  IW=X IHMN M" IH ]NR R^JK IST? %]^ V=VWIUQN% R^JK 3NVR
%NE H= 1 H  QR(NV V= V WIUQN% G> Q NRN 3] 3   ZNJV HRH  7>   V
$
SNQG 7>   JRZ JG JT Z  3 WR GK \
L  HR%K XNMKGK M"  IL= (   LN' V
$
SNQG N;H Z>9H ]NR IW=X WNJ %MK$ QN7>$G QR(NV J^R' M
 L.G
M% IL JT Z  3 WR V
$  NR  ]  NR R^ J K IST ?  GK JT I WRVK IWVNR %] ^
JTNJV M
-K M" 7>M J^R' JT*^ X
( ;NZ QR(NV Q%NZK E
H IW=X RIM]GN
M"   ILW $  JIME. VE
H  G^  RN QE\ E
H  VKRN QUZ E
H  X
( N
Q%NZK E
H M" I-E-K I- Z]VT  IW=X J=31 HKVN M" IH HIWRG
W HSKR JTZ3WR  MK Q%NZK J>R3 X
( ;NZ QR(NV Q%NZK E
H IW=X
WK M
R  V L  WNEN R^ J  ;NR' HRH  RIM] G   M%
IRUWGZ]YE>HVZ]VRA
ZRM%3>*RV]WZZTLN%MQVM%TVWN% ;%N%NZ
IWT3W^(NJIRH
3ZQR3%HI%HTGVX]ZW
MI-RNIWW3
Q%>WNG/AJ^R%JTZNVZ.HIWRGWL
X(;NZQR(NVQ%NZKE
HIW=XV
VKR;NZQR(NVVE
HIW=XRIM]GNM"7>MKJTZNVZN %ZRM Z%>=\ILMN
M"JT]V^%N3RIMVQR(NVQZR ZTLN%M I%RZEZ>=\Z]YE>HVQNHNRIW=X
QVR SM>V 3>*TV]WZ IW3NEWVRKR;NR%HRGNM
I-QN7>aJRG
E
H.IW=XIW;=ZN%M" V 7>(
$V
$ TVWN UVKHRH QR(NVX=EH ILGNIH
%]^JVN%MK$XEGN7>MKZR^JJTZNVZN I-RN IJT(WK7a>V IWW3 M
RW3*>N
QR(NVI*]%R^J X]ZW
M ;NR%HRHQN7$GNM"VE
HVIJT(WKE
H7>aJR
EKENHRGNM" ^(N SM>VW=YZ^M%]^QEIW=X % %NV%J^LNGK IWT3
W WR\NHRH %;%N%NZ 7>%4.%]^RNZ%NZGKHZN-KGI%R;%.%]^ HI%HTGV
Z]GWR%NEQR(NVW.A7>W.%NEZ%MKZ%IW=X7>XNR%HRHJ^LN
HRWN7$GNM"IL%NEQ]\Q%>QN-KQNGNJ^RN][ JIRH
3Z J^RWWNE>=\
NURR^JQ]IZTV?LN%QR(NVVE
H%]^ QT3% J^LNHRHJTNJVHRGNM"
*NWQR(/A J^R' JTZNVZN HIWRGW HSKR JTZ3WR  7>aJR VKR
;NZ QR(NV VE
H  IW= X  RIM] G N M"  V(N
V(N 7> M K JT Z  3 WR M
R  Z%> = \  R^ J
;NR' HRH  X (   ;NZ QR(NV Q%NZK E
H  IW= X  RIM] G N M"   7> M K
JT Z NVZN 7>    VR4 .  MK Z%> = \  WNEN ZR^ J  ] > G R Z> = \ Z] Y E 3W V  > H V
RKR > H V QNHNR IW= X  IJT ( WK E
H  7> a V  WK QN7> $ GN M"  V(N
V(N QNJ'K
QEK J^ L N IW;K GN IUQN% HRWNH  SM> V  NR  Z^ M  %] ^  V*UVK GN

IUQN% U] U N

99

;'K S'N IG] G N M"   Q] \ . Q%>  N-KQ. GN J^ R N Z^ M  V*UVK GK
HZN-K V
$  J^ R W WNE  = > \ Z-K E
H  J^ R ' Z> H VK G  ?LN%  %] ^  QR(NV
VE
H  %] ^  N;%. HRH  JT N JV HRGN M" 
]VRNZJNEGNG>QNRN*NWQR(
Q(RWWGH.Y%]+Q%>WNH%]+Z]VT %]+ ]


 (TW'ZIJVRZGWS];^ZSTMJIVZ%ZNWXUX6NV
WZ IW3W3NZ LI%VN (NM HIWRGW
 % G*NV W;NWN%@@
MAQ(TWN'ZAIJVRZAGWS];Z
^ ASTMJIVZA%ZNAQWAXAUX6NZA
VWZAIW3W3NZALI%VNA(NAMAHIWRGWMA%AG*NVAW;NWN%
Q%>WNG/A M L
 Q(WT'Z QX=EQR(NVQIW%N3K IJVTZ LUVIJVN
GWS];^Z *UV.GNWNVIWHN(KQR(NVQNVZ.GNQN;NR ISTMJIVZ
LUVU>R^ X  V %ZN  IS%ZR J^LNRK QR(NV IW;KWV N;H %]^ QW
>R=I\QNG %NE UX6NV L
 VE
HLNX>aH M%7>%4.%]^ VE
HE" LN'WNEN
IW3W3NZ WRSTIMZ]Y.GK L%KVN RX%N %G*NV HNEGKVR4.;
\N%
G'WNE W;NWN% >*NQQR(NVU>'.WNEN (N IL7$>GNIV7$>QR(NVW"N
MK M  7>M VWZ  QNJ HIWRGWM HIWRAGWM  HSKR JTZ3
 WR QR(NV
HIWRGW M"
*NWQR(/AIL JT Z  3 WR G  IW3  IW= X  IHMN L.GN M" A VWZ W  ZNVN
IW= X  IJVN VWZ W  VWZ W  S] ; ^  X \N VWZ W  VWZ W  IWIGQN IW= X
GRIW'Z VWZW RWZ ZZ GW@7>M L
 QIW%N3K * GN ZNVNAIJVN V
*N-K V  \N V  LUVU> R ^  R^ J  IW= X  * %] ^  V*UVK JT G N% HR% WNEN
VE
H E"H LN' WNEN HNE G W.U ;
\N %N G' WNEN STIMZ]Y. GK RX%N
HR% WNEN HIWRG W  HSKR JT Z  3 WR  M" 

100

HSKR NIMS XNR


$  > = U . IW= X  QN7> $ G  M%

HSKR NIMS XNR >=U. IW=X QN7>$G M%


IVU> R ^  J> R 3 HSKR M" $  XNR
$  > = U  JT W N%
0^P U>RWN ZR U- M
 U- *^V ZN%@

V>U IW=X HIWRGW HSKR NIMS  GN IV>IHTV %NZ %NE JTU1 M
'N
V= V WIUQN% G  Q*NW HRH  3R;NE^  3] H N IWQHV HRG  M% IH
L>ENM R^J IW=X HSKR LK V. IW/ ]/  ]%  IW=X HN3K IW=X
QN-  M% W G . IW= X  HIWRG W  I-MK HN3K WNEN L> E NMN ;N'H  IHW
$ J^ R ' JT Z NVZN M
 HGN M" 
I- IW3 IW=X GN ]V RNZJNE GN  GK JTN(%N M" IH I-MK J^R'
JTZNVZN HIWRGW HSKR JTZ3WR  WG. G IUQN% %^] WK J^RW VE
H
IW= X  IW;ZN% % QV  QNJ'N WNVIWH IUQN% V= V WIUQN%  G '  G
E-K XNR
$  > = U . IW= X  QNJ WK JT U 1 M
-   M% V= > U  IW= X  IV> I HT V
%NZ %NE VTVN>=U IW=X Z>I%]GR %NZ %NE G>WNJR >=U IW=X HR>'NZ
%NZ %NE QV  HE> = U  IW= X  QNJ'  WNVIWH %NZ HIWRG W  HSKR
JT*^  %NZ %NE JTU1 M
- M% QV I-G QIVIRHV M
R R^J ;NR' HRH
HGK *K JT U 1 M
H   QNJ'K EKE4 N  HRH  Q] V RI;QN% M
 L.G  M% 7> 
Z$ EKE4N HR% QN- JTZ3WR %]^ JT*^ XNM>' WNE 3R;NE^ %MK$ JIMXN'
%MK$ H   IH7> $ IH RW ZM.IR3K V  ] V  HIMEN7> '  WNIEQ. %  JT * ^  %] ^
I%RNHNR G= I QN M"   WNVW IW= X  JT Z NVZN QNHNR IW= X  M"   Z%> = \  G
> I GT 3  RKR > H V M"   JT ] V ^  JT Z  3 WR GN RKR %N9KQ. G  
U  %NE
SI'QN J] L  V= V W GN %MK$ M"   I-= H  %^ R  V= V W %NE SI'QN M"   J^ R '
JTZNVZN LG XNM ILa( XNM 7>a( JTU1 M
 L.G M% V 7>M HGK Z. V
$
L%Z %MK$ E" $ G  IH7> $ IH 7> M  RW G  7> V JVK HRVN M%
J^ R ' JT * ^  HSKR LK HIWRG W  V> U  IW= X  V> I HT V  %NZ %NE
W" $  JT U 1 M
-   % 7>   Z $  UR> 9  LK 3T K  ST M ZN LK QNIG %] ^
IVIUQN% Z0NI-QN K 3T K  Z%^ ]  ZM.IR3K LK %] ^  WK V= V WIUQN%
Z0N7>'N XNIMQN K JT]V^ 3TK Z%^] LK % JTZ3WR G IUQN% %]^ =X %N
LN'H TK STMZN LK V
$ >' WG IUQN% 7>aV Q;NIRV M
 IH V QNJ'
G>QNRN H=< WG. G I%3HT3 7>aV MK QR^9 RM I-G  7> E 1 JT Z  3 WR
IV>IHTV LK GN 7>JMN HR% E=U IH QNJ V. RW IWJRKV IUQN%
HIM RM  M
  I-  E-K JT Z  3 WR IV> I HT V  LK GN 8R_ %NZ WNZG W
I%HNE IEQN WNZ GN QR( M>]GN M" 7>E1N ILW$ \=S M=( %]^ 7>E1N M=(
HIM]G M% ILW$ =L M=( %]^ I=;N M=( WK HIM]G M% 
I- JT H NR V= > U  IW= X  JT Z  3 WR HIWRG W  LK L
 IV> I HT V  %NZ
%NE QN-  % 7>   Z $  G  IR3KQ. V(N N;H. %] ^  WNVIWH IUQN%
Z0NI-QN HRG % JT]V^ IR3KQ. % IWHNR %MK$ HKVN IV >HIRV
LK G (N% 7>aV JTZ3WR %]^ WNZGW HIM' E=U
I- E-K >LRWG QI;QN-  Z]VR  IW=X IWWR' M" IH >LR
WG G WNVIWH IUQN% %]^ WNZGW IR3K % MK LNI'QN V(N M
R. %]^

IUQN% U] U N

101

Z0NI-QN JIW= V R W G . G  IUQN% %] ^  Z0' G  E-K IHT J N IWXNR


HR
A ILW $  > L RW G  M"   I-M I-= H  JIW= V R J>  VH M"   I-G  IW3  IW= X
HKV  ]  IHT V  *N3N IW= X  IWWR' HKVN M
W   IL= (   L> M  L. L> Z  3SG
QNIG IE\ M
' V. WK JIW=VR J>VH L>RWG GN MK S
; ZI0QN L.GN
M" I-K JTHNR J^R' JTZNVZN GN WNVIWH %NZ HIWRGW M" I-%]^
I*] % AI*] %  *N3N IW= X  HSKR NIMS HSKR JT Z  3 WR HIM' E= U    H-K
3R;NE^  3] H N IWQNHV HRG  M% IH HIWR %] ^  HSKR IHW $  I= ;  HR
IG= V N IWQNHR' IGT 3 1KH
'  %NE HIWM GN QR( RW= U  MK M"   GN
GK JTN(%N M" IH JTVH 3SG GN H
-K %N H
-K QR( V. S'GN MK M"
RMK U=E IWQNHR' GK *N3N JT(Z S'K IH7>$IH WG SN'K JT*^ G>QNRN
HMK M"   V(N IWQNHR' SNQG IW= X  IR3KQ. G> Q NRN S'N-K M"   I-M
VR> 1 K > H V WK M
 HGK M"   W G  G  Q%> W NG *N3NA*N3  IW= X
IWQNHR' IWQNJV M"  QR(NV Q] U V V(N IWR
;  *NW M"   IH7> $ IH W
G SN'K Z] V R. G> Q NRN JG. IW= X  M"   ILW $  JEWE 3IMR G  QNAJN
G IWQHVK JEWE %]^ JRWR S
EG M% L H
-K HM JEWE %]^ JRWR
IHW$ JRWR I=; HR IG=VN I-MK HIWR %]^ HSKR IHW$ I=; HR IG=VN
HIM' ZNVR M" ILW$ (NI%H *N3N IW=X JEWE %]^ JRWR HIM]G M%
I-K JT H NR HIWR %] ^  HSKR S
E G  M% JT * ^  7> M K M" 
ZMNIR3K IGQN%] G  LK % = I VQNQNR( JT H N3 Z> 7 > E N  FN
 V  IGQN%] G  Z= P  GK%N%UR J] L NS V
$  JT H NI3V IW= X  G W > H NZN#
GN QR( GWR GK HNZ%N HRH HKVN M" GW> %]^ J^RN R# IE\H GWR
HKVN M" HIWR %]^ HIWR IFR *N3N I*]% HSKR IE\' L. S
E' IW=X H
-K
QNJ=VK L. IWQNHR% GK VR>=1K %MK$ M" J^R' JTZNVZN HIWRGW M%
I-M JTZN' >LRWG QI;/ Z]VT  V(N
V(N NZWG ]I\QN  IW=X WK
M" L
 I%Z% M"/A
]VRNZJNEGNG>QNRN*N3NA*N3 /A
L>RWGGQI;QN-%]+GE
H%]+ ]

IZ;
 Q;Z%>3
 G^R
' G
W GWNLILNVWGM
QN X SM IZVRZMI3XIHVW.V]W] G^V HIWRI JTXVNM@@
IZ;
M AQ;AZ%>  MAG^ R
'  A G W MALAQIALNVAW" G MAQNAXA
WMAIZVRZMMAIXIHVWN%AVWZAG^VMAHIWRAQIAJTGVNM
Q%>WNG/A Q; Q=LQR(NVWRVZN%IW=X G>R
' RKRR^JZMEIW=X
G>RNXNRJ^RWH Z%>3M 0^PKJ^LNIW=XEK%Z]%'3KEIWQHVKQ.%]^ IZ;
M
EUN-KM
-KQ=UQR(NV3NVRIW;KRIMVWRVZN%J^LNL
MN%KHNRHM>]GK
M"7>G(N%7>aV GWN% GWVNW.G GWM GWVN LNVWGM J^R%JTZNVZ.
IVJ>R3GKWNVIWH L J^LN QI M" QN IGQNE^ IZVTZM LKWGN
WNVWIW=XN(KJ^R%JTZNVZ.MKQNJ' IXIHVWN% W(IUQN%QR(NV
(NR(*UVK%]^ G^VM ]G3WNMHR^JIW=X WM E"H QN7>'WNEN X V(N
JTXVNM  S
; HRN7>' WNEN VWZ  QNJ HIWRI  HIWRGW QR(NV HSKR
JTZ3WR M"
*NWQR(/AIL Z $  J^ R ' JT Z NVZN JT U 1 M> ] G N M"  7>   Z $  RW

102

HSKR NIMS XNR


$  > = U . IW= X  QN7> $ G  M%

IR3K V(N ] V  L% 3NVR IW;K IVQNUH  Z%Z] I %QN QNXR' QR(NV
J^LN G>QNRN RW *UV ZNL %]^ ZNRU GR3% HR RM M>]G M% VG
QNJ'  V= V WIUQN% QR(NV W( IUQN% GN ] G  3 WNMH S'H  QNJ
MK HIWR G W  QR(NV HSKR JT * ^  MK QN7> $ GN M" 
]I\QN%]+NZWG7>VNRIXHQI;QN-%]+\]Y%]+E
H%]+
]V RNZJNE LK G>QNRN Q%>WNG /A

*GRNWVRNZ]%NQWN%
 ZMN%HIWRI%WX%NI%3]%
QN WXW X]W
M J^ZN%
 IWXH3' LNUTIWRGWWKV@@
*GRNAWVRNAZ] % NAWN%MAZMN%AHIWRAI%WX%NI%A3]  %A
QNWXNWAXZW
MAJ^ZN%NAIWXH3'MALNUTIWMAGWAWKV
Q%>WNG/A IWXH3'M XV>RIWQHVKQ.% QNWXW QNJ'IWXNR.
G>QNRNIHMNM>]GNM" L
 JTWX%HRG M%I-%4.GNQ%>3R'HR
7>%4.XV>R
IWQHVKQ.% J^R%STMZGKJ^LN%]^ %NG=H QN'7>JN%.GNZNRUGR3%
HRH Q]IZTV G (N% V J^NZN%M  QN'7>JN%N R^JK ZWNG ILW$ *^VAJTV
J^LNIJ=VR J^LNIV]%
$ U>>'. RLU>'ASTMZ. VU>'AIW3'^ VZU>'AI3WLK
QV STMZAHNE V=H GK J^LN  %^] X]ZW
M  QNGR G %NE QNXZ% HRN RM
QR(NV3NVRIWR>=;UEVIUQN%%]^ZNJVHM'GE-K *GTN JRZ>=\GNI-H
ZMN%HIWR  ZMN% HIWR QR(NV J^R% JTZNVZ. HSKR WVRN  MRKR
N;NR%W*^3NIW=XQR(NVWVRGNQR(M"W*^3N]V*N3NIW=XI-
%]^X
ENWKHIM]GM%X
EGNQR(M"RKRLIH]VGNGM.VM
L.GN
M"V.IHMNL.GNM"IH7>MX
EN6=YU-# Z]%N QNJ'VE
HWNERKR
G >IGT3M
RRKRV,J>]LGN;NRH W%M QNZIWQHVKGKVR4.LKW%
LKQ G H>0 IG% ]NR IW=X QVK(K GK VR4. WH I%WX%NI%  QNJ'K
3SGNWEKHSKRSN'KQNIGG ZNI;QZ%NEVIUQN% 3]% WR%'HRH
GW  J^R% JTZNVZ. G WKV  I6J M
- RU>'AI%RU>' IUQN% R^JK ;]% %]^
LNUTIWM  LNIUTV HRG M%
*NWQR(/AILW$ >LRWG QI;/  Z]VR  IW=X IHMN M" IH QU%
M V%> M  QI JT Z  3 WR IMRKR M"   IW3'W  VWN 
Z  V%> M  QI
7> QZR JT*^ GN JNE% J
3' HR% G E-K M
R RKR M" L
 QIV(K R^J
IW=X H>0 IG% ]NR IW=X QN7>$GN M" V=VWIUQN% V
$ QIUQN% %K$GRN
IW=X 
- M
- JT*^ JTZKQ. %]^ LUN7>$GN M" 7>MK JTZN' I- Z]VR IW=X M"
IH H>0 Z$ G E-K J^R' JTZNVZN HIWRGW QR(NV HSKR JT*^ QNJ'N
R^ J  SGE H  QNZ IWQHVK ILMN R^ J  S'NH  IJT ( WK Z] Y E 7> a V  JT U 1
M> ] G N M"  V(N HIWRI%RWX%NI% ] 3 ' QR(NV HIWRSN'K S
E GN M" 
ILG ZNI;QZ %NE V=VWIUQN% %]^ LUN7>$GN M" V(N 7> Z$ ZM.IR3K
HIMEN7>' WNE XV>R JTN'K IZI(QNIUQN% G QN;NR 7>aV 3NVR IW;K
Q%>  NR IVN;%. R^ J K Q] I ZT V  G  (N% 7> a V  3NVRIW;K RIMV J^ L N
R^JK ZWNG %]^ 3R;N G %NE QNXZ% QR(NV J^LN HRN RM M>]G M%
7>   Z $  J^ R ' JT Z NVZN QNJ JT U 1 M
H   V= V WIUQN% G> Q NRN 3NVR
IW;K Q%>  NR N;%. %] ^  IUQN% JT G N% HRGN M" 
JIW=VR IRUWG G Z]VT. IW=X WK JIMXN' G=K M" IH LG 7>M J^R'

IUQN% U] U N

103

JTZNVZN H>0 Z$ E-K ]NR IW=X EKE4N HR% E-K QN7>$GN M" V. I33^
GN R^ J  ;NR' HRGN M"   7>   J^ R ' JT Z NVZN GK JT W IR3 QN;] % . ;
%W  H>QNRK U. G>QNRN M>]GK M" IFR EKE4NWV W=YN M]>GN M" V(N QNJ'
JN7> '  V(N VE
H  LN' QR(NV J^ R ' Z
H 3 ZNRU GN V= V WIUQN%
HIWRIUT * KM  HSKR SN'K G> Q NRN HIWV.W. G> Q NRN S
E GN M"   IL
HNR% V
$  JT I = ;  HWK HIMEN7> $ GN M"   JT ] V ^  7> M  \> G  HIWRG W  J^ R '
JTZNVZN MK M>]GN M" L
 VKR Z>HVK ;NZ VE
H IW=X RIM]GN M"
IRUW G  Z] Y E  > H V  Z] V R  V(N > H V  Z] V RA/A
Q*KI-]ZQ;]%N7>V3TK']IV;%WMI33^Z
ZIZ]GNT JNVW@@
Q%>WNG/A 7>V IW33HR I-Z I- I33^Z SNEHR^JIW=XJTU1

ZZ J^R'JTZNVZ.JT*^GK I-]GTN >=\>IW;NW.G>QNRNQR(NV\N'AJK'
G>QNRNL
RKRIWT;K%]^JTNJVM>]GNM"7>%]^ JNVW IWT;KGE-K Q*K J^R%
VR4. Q;]%N;%WM L
U..YG>QNRNHGWKJT3N%%HKVKU-KM
QR(NV
H>QNRKU.G>QNRN 3TK']IV JTWIR3HKVKL.GKM"
*NWQR(/AJ^ R ' JT Z NVZN QZRJ> R 3 LG EKE4 N  HRGN M
I -QN
SNEH R^ J  ;NR' HRH  W" $  JT U 1 M> ] G N M"  7>   Z $  H> Q NRK U. QNJ'
QNJ G>=; IG]GK M" IL V
$ 7> JT*^ GK JTWIR3 M>]GK M"
IRUWG Z]YE  >HV  Z]VR 
I33^ZLIUQN%ZMRVZZRL]IV3>Z*]IVWIM%ZR^VMU'%
HIWRIUT*K HNW%N HIWR ]V 
ZM JIWVRZ QVIV R*%@
Q%>WNG/AJ^R%JTZNVZ. MRI33^Z Z%>=\GS=XGR^JIW=X LIUQN%Z
LN%AS>0H JTU1M>]GNM" V(NQNJ' VVWIUQN%%]^ VZ 7>Z$ ZRL]IV
I%RZEVN G %NE 3>Z*]IV  7>XNR% HRGN M" WIM%  JT*^ JTNJVK GK E=UK
IWRMNQU%KWNE ZR^VM WNL^GKVR4.*UV U'% Z^MGE-K HNW%N
HIWVNW.G>QNRNHWKVW%NE JIWVTZQVIV Q=IVQNI;HSN'KI%RZEVNG
%NE HIWRIUT*K  HIWR SN'K QR(NV HSKR SN'K G>QNRN R*%  7>aX WR
%NE]S
;%HRHS
EGNM" HIWR]V
ZM 7>MQZRJ>R3QR(NVIVJ>R3
MK]VQR(NVIR3KR^JIW=X\>GHIWRGWM>]GNM"JT]V^ 7>JTZNVZ.%]^ %
JIMXN'H HIWHIM'E=UL.G M%
*NWQR(/A WG S
E' WNEN STMZ HIM IRMN M" IH IWE=\' Z%>=\ G
S= X   G  R^ J  IW= X  JT U 1 M
H   J^ R ' JT Z NVZN HIWRG W  QNJ'  WNVIWH
IUQN% %] ^  QNJ'K HIWIUT * KM QR(NV HSKR SN'K G> Q NRN I%RZE
IUQN% QNJ'  M]  QNVZNW. QR(NV J> ] % QNVZ. Q%> Q N-KQ. %] ^  HWK
R^J IW=X HIWV.W. E
H
HVKQ. G G>QNRN ]S
;% HRH QR(NV 7>XNR'
HRH  WR'% HRGN M"   7> M  QNJ IVJ> R 3 HSKR MK M> ] G N M" 
IRUWG Z]YE  >HV  Z]VR 
IRI3Z%N  IRI3HTV W3TNM MVRN'K(M JGWKM HWK%NZ
IVTVZ;NZZIM3MI33N]V
ZMIWRNLZN%^ RNLIV1>J@
Q%>WNG/AWG S
E% WNEN STMZ HIM IRMN M" IH   L
 J^R% JTZNVZ.
IWE=\' S=X G R^J IW=X QNH HWK%NZ]  JTI=; HWKQ. GK JGWKM  7>JN;K
JTNJVHRHQR(NVI-=H]VL.IR3KGK*^IZHNHRGNM"7> IRI3HTV ]V

104

HSKR NIMS XNR


$  > = U . IW= X  QN7> $ G  M%

R^JIW=XJTU1M
-JT*^G>QNRNRXK MVTN'K(M M,NR.SN'K IRI3Z%N ]V
>*NQWNEIWQHVKQ.QR(NV*UV.GE-K W3TNM WRUV>=EQN%]GGNI-H
M>]GKM" ]V
ZM IR3K]VR^JV
$JTU17>MQZRJ>R3QR(NVIVJ>R3
MKM>]GNM"7>MJ^R%JT*^ IVTVN VKR ;NZ Z>HVKE
HQR(NVVE
HGK
ZIM3M >IGT9IJT(WK%]^ I3N (NIJVHRH Q%> IJ=6
$ZN%W>IGT3]V
R^JIW=X 1>J U>]SLIW=X7>aX I1=E R^JKI][N3%7>aV IWRNLZN%> RNLIV
7>L=WE(^EQNHNRIW=XQR(NVZN%W>IGT3RKRIW=XIWRNLZN%M"
*NWQR(/AZ]VT  IW=X IHMN M" IH HIWRGW I33^ R^J ;NR' HR
E"$GN M" EKE4N HRGN M
I-QN W=YN M>]GN M" HIWVNW. G>QNRN V=VWIUQN%
WR'% HR% G  HNR' HWK GK JGWK$ JT N JV HRGN M"  QR(NV 7>  %] ^
HWK HIM' E=U L.G M% WNVW IW=X 7>M J^R' JTZNVZN HIWR HSKR
JT * ^  MK M"   7>  G  G> Q NRN RXK Q] I ZT V SN'K HSKR SN'K HIWIUT * KM
QR(NV HIWRWN'K  HMK L.GK M"   L
 *UV. G  E-K WRU G  V> E
> = \ GN-K M> ] G K M"   7> M K JT Z NVZN VKR  Z> H VK ;NZ QR(NV VE
H  GK
(NJ%N HRH  I-= H  U> ] S ] G  QR(NV U> ] S L IW= X  I3] [ N3' 7> a V  V L
Z -K
ZN%W > I GT 3  RKR IW= X  QHNR IW= X  IWRNLZN% M" 
I- Z]VT IW=X VKRN ;NZ VE
H %]^ IHMN M" ILW$ I-=H STMZ GN
E
H L
 I-=HK STIMZ]Y GN MK \VR M" G^RN JTSTMZ GN E
H L
 =V ]\
STIMZ]Y GN \VR M" VKRN JRZ QH3R STMZ QR(NV J^R' STMZ GN
IR=V;NZ QR(NV VE
H M"

VTVN>U IW=X HIWRGW HSKR NIMS  GN Z>I%]GR


%NZ %NE JTU1 M
'N)
%E V(N %KE %]^ 3R' IW=X E"'N
VTVN=>U IW=X W"$*^ W"$ JTU1 M
' WNEN  HIWRGW HSKR JTZ
3WR  R^ J Q] V R HRH  Z> I %] G R IR3K %NZ %NE QN-  M
-   % Q%E
QR(NV %E V(N Q%KE QR(NV %KE G
%4
$ *UV QNJ IW=X ZK G
J>=VR % ZNVNAIJVN GN GM.V M
 X=>HN K %E V(N %KE G
%4
$ RKRH
V  ZN%IH R
U  V
$  SM> V  JK9V % RW ] V . V  IR3KQN %^ ]  H31
I%WNR' GK JT N (%N HR X> = H   % RW ] V . %  G= I QN K IH I-M
QNJGN JTNR=S; GN JNJ HRZ GN G]Y M" I-M QNJ%]^ *
U'N MK JWUN
I-GN H
-K ZN;N% %MK$ M" G
%4
$ IZ=VR LKW% V
$ I%RN3 M
H IZTV^ GN
I-]VLNR HR RM K
I-=H IG% G
%4. %^] Z>I%]GR %NZ %NE JTU1 J^R' JTZNVZN GN IV]U
>'% GN QWR JTNJV M
I-QN IV]U G 7>JR]V ILW$ MK G
%4. % JTZ
3WR HIWRGW HSKR NIMS  8R_ Z>I%]GR IR3K LK G XR' 6^M V(N
JT Z  3 WR Z> I %] G R LK %  IR 7> a V  M= (  R= I \QN V. G
% 4 .  GN QN; R
U
6^MZ]VR M
IUQN QR(NV G
%4
$ %E V(N %KE W( M
 U- I- QG*>V
XZVHNR %]^ G\H JT*^ G XR'. IW=X IURH H-K []1 R
$G RM V(N IHMN
Q=L N%]^ JT*^ IZE IUQN ILGK VEN3 K V(N 7>%4. V
$ JT*NIWV M
H

IUQN% U] U N

105

7>%4. V
$ %NZ GKH3N  E" IEQN V(N Z>I%]GR NIMS LK G %NE MK WN
IW= X  RIM' E= U    JIME  ] V . GN ZNUZ JN'K GK IWW(N G \ H  %GK
G IH%NR V M>]GN K %E V %KE G
%4
$ SM>V JT*^ JTDZK V(N *
EK QNVZN
K JT Z NVZN IW= X  7> % 4 .  GK SM> V  3R;N K  W N SM> V  HIRQN HRG
K ZNUZ. IW=X R
UK V IST; V IWHE.U *UVL% QN7>$G V. 7>%4. G
H=J9 V(N SRV% N_ HRG % 7>%4. G E
1 V(N IUEN Z.L IG]G
K JT]V^ M" *
E GKZNU G % H=J9 ;
' E=U L.G V. V]U IW=X L

JT*^ GK H(N >'K M>]GK 7>GK XRXN HR% E=U L.G 7>M G

%
4$ JT*^ GK
XRXN IW= X  ZV M
 L.G  V  WV^ Q . GIRQN G  LE IW= X  Y= > S  L.GKQ.
7>%4. %]^ JVN %MK$ XEGN IH GKQ. XNR WV^ E"H L.G V. G
 WV^Q.
WNJ IEQNH IG]G % *UVL% HIM]G IH *N-K WN V. SM>V HRG
M
 JT]V^ NYN V. SM>V H]Z IWUN9 IG]G M
 I-M \
-KQ. M
-KQ. WV^Q.
QK$ IH= (
$  E" H   QN-K-   QNJ NYK  W N MK HR%K 6= Y  IG7>   QK$
QNJ'K WN \>G HR EW.U IFR %E V(N %KE R
' E=U L.G % IH
NYK WN %N 6K%
$ M>' GK WNR %MK$ \
W.U JT]V^ IFR 7>MK H]Z HRG
 IFR JT*^ GK XRXN IW=X E=U L.G V(N WV^Q. GIRQN LE IW=X Y>=S
L.GKQN *UVL%. %  IR3K Z> I %] G R LK %^ ]  JT N (%N HKVK IH IHT J N %E
V(N %KE %]^ Z0N8 I-M %N V. Z]%G M% QV Z%4. HRG M. V. R
'
E=U L.G M% NYKQ. V. Q=;KQ. WV^Q. WNJ %MK$ IEQN7>$G I-M
%GK IH%NR V]U >'K *UWN% GK XRXN IW=X ZV M
 L.G M% V(N
WV^ Q . Y> = S  L.GKQ. M% Z> I %] G R NIMS %  I-= H AG
 WNR V. 7> % 4 .  %^ ]
Z0NI-QN 7>M R
' E=U L.G % IH NIMS NYK I-M WN %N 6K%
$
IVU>R^ Z>I%]GR NIMS % IHMN IH S1N %E V(N %KE \^S WN HR
 Q=L
V
$ SNQG QNJG M=(
$ H
-K WK XK, XNM J=(R L. E
MN MK IH7>$ %N M
W
LE IW=X %MK$ Y>=SUK Z>I%]GR NIMS % I-M QN3KRWNG 7>%4. %]^ IG=VN
QNJ% RZNI-' V. >'K MK M" I-=H Z$ GK U=E M" IH KVN LK %]^
RNW' X>=HH E" IUQN *UWN% RNZ %]^ JVN WK %MK$ IH KVN %]^ H' X>=H
H E" IUQN3TK RNZX]GR LK I-=;R 7>a;R \
L HRG M% M%^]ZN% LK %
\
L HRH G=IQN IH KVN ZNVN E]HNJVK RNW' RN
\3
3  GK H"G IW=X
RN\3
\33 
M" JVN E=U' V
$ SNQG *UWN% RNZ % RNW' H
E 3.VK G^V *L V(N JTN(%N
HKVK IH KVN LK %]^ WNJ HR GW JT]V^ RNW' %MK$ Z]I%QN >=; GK
IVQNRK M
-K IFR Z>3IHE QN-K IH Z>]GR V
$ "%N IHW$ JNR HRK-
*UWN% 3TK RNZX]GR % IV]% IG% V=H U
IYQ. V=H JN'K IW=X \94
M
H M=( L
9H Z>]GR %]^ JTN(%N HKVK IH RNVN G IG7> JT]V^ Z]>GR
1 V
$ Z %MK$ M
I-QN LG Z>]GR %MK$ Z]I%QN V. 3TK RNZ % 7>%]^
QU%K SN' %NE LEN7> ' N XNIMQN *" Q *KV Z] > G R I-= H  ST M NZ' GN
R^J S'NH NMZ' QNI-QN V(N IHMN IH *UWN% * GK QNJ'KQ.A
ZIRQNGN M% Z"%]^ LEN7> ZV ZR Q]GR %N LN' IH]% LKWAL]V^ S
M% L QNJ Z"%]^ LEN WK IG7>U V. WK QNJ Z"%]^ JNR %MK$ HR HG
IH7> $ IH I-= (   SM> V  UIMRN \= Y N S' LN- U NIL%] ^  QNJ HGK WK JNR
%MK$ HR HG 

106

HSKR NIMS XNR


$  > = U . IW= X  QN7> $ G  M%

Z]>GR % IHMN *UWN% QILMN HR


 IH =J WK ZR LN- QV ENPK
WK %N 1>=1 ZRK ZIRQNGN WK RIM LNWUK QNJGN J>E WK S' LNW
VG *UWN% RNZ %  J> = I 6QN IH 7> M  HK IW;K M"  ST M NZ' R^ J  IW= X  \94 
Z] > G R %  IHMN IH QNJGK " % N IW= X  %E V(N %KE %NZ G  G
 " I %H
M% 7>%4. H
E 7>%4. G U>R^ LK V
$ JTNJV I-=H QILMK 3HVK M" IL %NE
7>%4. G M=( V
$ J=(R WK LE IW=X VR L.G M% MR WV^ XNM WV^ E
M
GK MK M
W V"R L.GK M" 3TTK RNZX]GR LK % %E V(N %KE %]^ S>ENI-QN
V(N 7>%4. V
$ J>=I6QN IH QNJG H
E H
-K QILMK 3HVK M"%E V %KE
% IHMN IH M. LK NY M=( V
$ J=(R WK LE IW=X %MK$ Y>S'U 3TK RNZ
%  IHMN IH JT K \' HRWN8
7> % 4 .  %NGN%. %EA%KE  %  
I XQN IH Q= L  *G  NMZ'  QNJGK
SM> V  ZIMZN M
W  U K 7>   IG% 7> % 4 .  %  QNJ'  U> R ^ G  W  *UWN% Z> I %] G R
HSKR NIMS  LK %]^ I-M 
XH NG %N HKVN IH L QK$ 7>%4. %]^ NG
HR.U V. 3TK RNZ IHV I-M %N 
X' IH I-%4. H
E 3HVK %MK$ M" I-M
V. IH M
R V
$ Z]UG M% 7>%4. % J=(R X>=HH JN'K IW=X JNI-QN V.
J= ( R JN'K IW= X  Y> = S  IUQN %E QV  %KE %  SM> V  H
I 33 HKVK JT ] V ^
7>%4. V
$ J=(R %MK$ VR VG *UWN% RNZ % Z]>GR G W=E GI\QN ZN%

HIM'N XNM RM M


' IH QNJ V. 0^P S
E RM M
 I-%4. IW=X V. H
-K
3HVK %MK$ M" Z]>GR % IHMN IH %E QV %KE Q=L QNJ QNJ' U>R^
GW %]^ NG %MK HKVN %NGN%
$ QNJ' U>R^GW %]^ NG HR
 7>M G
%4
$
Z0 U-  IH Q= L  QK$ UEVK HR IG= V K 7> % 4 .  %  IVU> R ^  Z> I %] G R
NIMS %]^ NG HKVN IVU>R^ Z>I%]GR HSKR NIMS  7>a( JM]>X U-
*UWN% RNZX]GR LK % IHMN IH M IR3KWRC ZRN G>R*NU M" IH QNJG
WH. G M=(
$ J=(R %MK$ V"R RM M% Z>I%]GR NIMS % IHMN IH M>'
I-%4 .  G  M= (
$  V" R 'U  WK %MK$ IH7> I H I-%4 .  %] ^  QI*ZN% M
I UQN M" 
IVU> R ^  GK SN'K JT Z N' HRGK M"  IH/A
URKSL" ZNVNUR*H
RN\ LV%S%N-
PEUV
6K'M
WVRKQ"*UVKLN-
7> IG% G IJ=6
$ %E V(N %KE GK 7>M 3HVK ZNJV M
 U-K 3TK
RNZX]GR LK % JTZ3WR Z>I%]GR NIMS LK %]^ IHMN IH M IR3KWRC Z
R 7>aV SM>V QNJ=VK QN-K M
-K M" IGQN HR
 IH JTHNR "%N JRE
JNR M
 LNW LG QNJ QNJ' WH. %]^ 3HVK G HG M
 V. JT*^ H>0
R,N HR
 Z>I%]GR LK %  IHMN IH I-M L
 NMZ'  WNEN JMN9 M"   Z" $
7>  G  XNR
$  JN  I-= H  R \ N I\= X  IG= V K M"   I-G  IW= X AIW= X  G  J= ( R
X> = H  EW
  7> M  %MK$ Y> = S 'U   3T K  RNZ %  JT K \' G  E-K I-= H  J= ( R
Z] U NI-QN 7>  %] ^  JN'K IW= X  R= I \QN V. 7> M  V" R ' E= I UQN %E V(N
%KE HNRKUR I
3 EJHNR  WK K M%^ ] Z N% LK JT V KIG% *UWN% %] ^
I3
NG HIRQN HRG  K 7>  %  QNJ'K G" I %H IHT Q N WK %NE R= \ K V(N
RNZ RNZ WK IE\GN IRMN V  JMN9 G  JMN9 X> = H H  WK E"  QN7> $ GN
K %E %KE 7>%]^ L
9AV
9 H J>E IW=X EUN IG]G K I-VR4. J=>E
SI'QN K ;RZGN LK HIM] G   M% IH/A

IUQN% U] U N

107

RM %E %KE LV% HR MNR VS IVU>R^  HRK J>HNR
LN V R\N IE\K QJNR I];^ JR I3EN IVRN% WNE
;]%A;]% IVU>R^ IV HSKR *UV HK JKR IZ1N% WNE
H
-K HIM]GN K IH M%]>ZN% LK % J=(R 7>aV RNZ %NZ IE\ IG=VN
K I-E-K J= = ( R V" R  U-   H
- K HIM] G N K IH %EA%KE %  J> E
S'NI-QN K H
-K HIM]GN K IH 3TK RNZ % J>E S'NI-QN K JT]V^
I-M H(N I- VR4. M" IL VR4. QNJ%]^ 7>aJR G=K U-K M"
IV HSKR GK N\KA_N  V
  V=H
A/JKW IJ6N% H
 Q]U/A
HSKRAVK%GWH
*H
-KI;QNWX( GWHNZRZ%NJNW
X(N6NYJ]XZH
I;QNWHMHSKR
MZJRQNW@@
HSKRA8$HNRI%3X*NMHRVNZVLN%
NXN3SGHSKRHNJRGZNMKJIMXN%@@
HSKRARNZIHT3%QWVNRM"I-%HN%NMK$]NR
IL%NIMS]NRIHQN
IH%M>%NL]%IZQN%NR@@
HSKRAXNR*>LNH*L%Z$*^IEJRS]V
HISRN>IZR
VN>H
LNH*>LNQ%]V@@
HSKRAZ]>GRJN1E]HNU-KVNH
*RVNR
VNIMQUVZ>I%JKU
I-%Z$H
HRVNR@@
HSKRAU
WR;%IURK;NIR7>IHT3%LKGT
'NIURKM%]>Z]V
33%NU*I3T31KMNRKI-%Z$H
*UW]V@@
HSKRAHN1S];%IWJIVZ"$HIP%IHQN]UTNZ
IX]%M
$R%RJTN'KQ.UR>9S9
HKRNZ@@
HSKRAHMHSKRIXVXVM^3SGHR
I%R>WNR
3TKRNZIMHRVNHIMVM"$*^EJR
]NR@@
HSKRAIL%RNZIHT3%WI%]RL%IHQ

V
HRVNI%QNR
Q];NIUQN%%NS>0-KHMHSKRIWXNR@@

G>QNJR>=U IW=X HIWRGW HSKR NIMS  GN HR>'NZ-K %NZ


%NE JTU1 M
'N

  JT Z  3 WR HSKR HIWRG W  G> W NJR> U  IW= X  HR> ' NZ-K %NZ %NE
JTU1 M
- K 7> Z$ I-=H SNEZKH LNVK IW=X 7>VJ]% *UV >GR3%
>JX Q%>3^IXV LNVK GN  7>%4. GN I33 M
I-QN K I- >GR3% LK
% J.YW. GN =U FE HKVK K L
 %N V. 3TK IHTD3% LK G *
L% HR%
%NE FE M
-K K %N MK VVK HR
9 GWVNW. QPNK MLNR IR3KQ.
SNR. HR
9 STNMZ' % %N( XRNK I=; QNIG G *
L% \N' %NE FE
M
-K K *UV >GR3% WNEZKH J^R' U>R^ LK V
$ WNVIWH IV]% Z]VT
JT N JV HRH  V N;%N U> R ^  ZIRNGN IW= X  RIM] G   M
-   HR IRMN K

G>WNJR >U IW=X I-]GRZVK %]^ 3R' IW=X E"'N


G>WNJR>U IW=X X]GRIWL" %NZ GN I-=H RNLN K 7>GK JV%K

108

HSKR NIMS XNR


$  > = U . IW= X  QN7> $ G  M%

I-] G RZVK SM> V  MK ;NRIZH JT I WRVK GK Q R V K ] V AZMNVZ. GN


SM>V QNGR HRGK K 7>% I-=H U>R^GW WK S'NI-QN K 7>G U>R^
GW % G=IQN IH S1K N;^Q.A]V. GK WN HR%K XNMKGK M" ]V. %]^
*
L% 6HN7>' %NE SM>V EN* M>]GN M" I-HNG3K GN WRV Z]VR GN LNJ
QNIG N;%NW. L
 U>R^GW LK % G=K K 7>M *UWV *UVK SM>V IGT9VN
%NE E=UK M
-K K U>R^GW % G=IQN K IH ]V. %]^ *
L% I\EN-$UK V.
V]^ Q=U WK RN'K S'UK QV V"%^] WRU JTNJVK M
WUK RN'K % 
IXQN
IH JT V KIG% I-= H  ] V  %] ^  *
L % LR^ R  I\ENI-QN HR.UK 7>  %  I-M
JTIV=IUQN Z% IW=X PN' E-K IH Z"$ \N'N SNQNG IW=X \NI-QN HR.UK
JIME ]V %]^ I\ENI-QN HR.UK I- %NE Z"%]^ NG S'K RMUK IHV
ZR V
$ *=>E %N M
 LNW RN'K JTVKIG% I-=H ]V %]^ *
L% I\EN7>$GK IFR
SNQG IW= X  QNJ *
L % HRGK H-K NE. V= H  I-M HT Z  X= E GN IRMN
I-=H Z$ MIRG>QNR IW=X H>]* G ZE GN ]
U M
I-QN IL]% WK
IVTU>' ZNI-QN G 7>JNH ]V K * U]UN I-3%N% HR% E-K JR*K
E" '  G  E-K  JT  (N% HR U-   I- HNR% H-K IG%. RN'K %] ^  *
L %
HRN7>' E-K H
-K ]V %MK$ IZIEQN RN'K I-]GRZVK % QNJ *
L% WK
%MK$ \NI-QN X( IG% QNJ'K S.GK %]^ IHMN IH S.GK G\ E" H
-K ]V
IZE LNW V. %MK$ V. Q=L VRK RN'K LKWV %MK$ RMUK Q=L ZR JTN'
I%= H E LN'U  JT ] V ^  Z" $  \N'N %MK$ \NW.UK 7> M  GK%IGQNE HSKR JT Z 
3WR QNJ' JIME. WNE *UV %]^ 3R' IW=X E"' E-K HK %N LN' HK
HNR' S'N IG] G N M"   S.GK %  7> a JR Q1NRK 7> a V  X= 9 4 H   G I \QN IH
NMZ' V
$ I-=H ]V QN IRMN M" F"G H=J9 K G>WNJR>U IW=X JTZ
3WR HSKR HR>'NZ %NZ %NE QN- K S.GK %KX QN-K V(N RN'K
%^] IHMN I-=H IWQHVK L
 N;^ WRUN %,R QN7>$GN M" RN'K % IHMN
IH LEGK %NE S>EN IEQN S.GK ZIME V
$ SNMR U-K QV JTN(%N HKVK
IH M ZMNVZN LKC QNJ%]^ NYK RN'K % NG HKVN M" HR>'NZ NIMS
%  IHMN IH RN'K %  Z" % ] ^  IH7> $  NG HKVN M"   Z R N V(N RN'K GN HK
] S ] ;  % H RN'K %  NRK U= E  G=  K HR> ' NZ   HSKR  NIMS %  IHMN
IH L RN'K %]^ QNW3HVN M" V. I-=( QN LNW Z"$ I-=( \94N M. V]^ S.GK
V(N 7>M RN'K L Z"$ 7>a( LNW. V(N L 7>M HIM GW IH V"%]^ IH%
S>ENI-QN K L. 7>GN RNLN MK H>0 HIM GW QR S1K ]V. GN Q%NGR
SM>V JNJ GN-K M>]GN M" S.GK IFR WNJ U-K V(N RN'K %]^ NRK U=E
G=K VG RN'K % IHMN IH S.GK ZRN M=( F9 V X=E L.G MK RN'K
%  G] Y W= V  JT ' NZ HRH  V  JT N (%N HKVK IH M  JRWRIGUNRC XNM] > G K V.
I-M M. IH QNJ%]^ QNJ' Z
< 7>aV ISPN E" LNW. HR>'NZ NIMS %
IHMN S1K)C Z"$ I-MK G\'N XM>]GN M. IH VR IW=X H
-K 3R;N WK M" L.
W"    MK *> = \ K ZR RMK M" $  RN'K %  QNJ'  M= ( . %NE \N'N S'NI-QN
HR>'NZ R^J IW=X QN- HIWRGW LK % IHMN IH Z"$ \N'N %MK$ \.GN
ZRN RKR \N'N \N' GN %MK$ M" V. RN'K % IHMN Z"$ WK \N'N %MK$
\.WNUK HR>'NZ NIMS % IHMN IH S1K E" QN \N'N \.G M.IH7>$IH
ZR=( 7>K %]^ HIM]G M. L
 L
 XNM 
 HR HR>'NZ NIMS % \N'N

IUQN% U] U N

109

\N IEQN HR> ' NZ   R^ J  IW= X  JT U 1 HSKR QU%K HSKR JT Z  3 WR  %


RN'K V
$ J>=I6QN IH L
 V^] N;%. HR RMK M" I-M V"%]^ IH% G=K M"
RN'K %  IHMN IH Z R   U> R ^ G  W  %  QNG 3  IG= V N M"   HSKR NIMS %
J> = I 6QN HK QNG 3  IG= V N M"  V R   U> R ^  %   I-] G RZVK %  IHMN IH
ST M ZNAIW3'^ A ZM 3  GK J^ L NI-HNG3K G  WRV VKR( *RZ' G W K
J^ L N 3RN; H= < 'N Z] G R IW= X  LN'N ] V . GK  W N HR%K HR> ' NZ 
HSKR  NIMS % IHMN IH L
 N;%. VR U>R^GW % IG=VK M" V"%]^ L%Z
V IZTV^ V(N WRUA%RH V XRNK E=\ L^%KQ. G H31 V
$ Z>HV %MK$
HR HGK RN'K % IHMN IH ZMNRNL LK IL]% WK ]V M"$ QNJ'KAQNJ'K
JT * ^ V N QNJMK S'N7> '  QN7> $ G  M% Z R   U> R ^ G  W  SNR  H> 0  %N HM
  Z" $
XNM  Z> H V M
W . LN %N M
W .
M>' HR>'NZ-K HSKR  NIMS 
XG M% IH I- *
E LKW %]^ IHW
$ Z0NW. I-%4. % L
 J^6 F9 E-K M" 7>%^] 6=Y %MK$ HG ZR HG
M% HR> ' NZ-K NIMS %  IHMN IH S 1 K W"    V R K I-= 6 N M"   Z" $  I%] G N
%MK$ HR IRMN HK Z"$ QNJG U>R^GW %]^ UNEK IG=VK M" L. S>RN IHMN
M" Z"$ V. *UVK ZNRU G= IRMN M. IH I-M *UVK 3NVR IWR>=; M"
V"%]^ JNR %MK$ M
' GWUK V %N MK H
-K VRN QN7>' WNEN HRZG]Y H=1
UN V >' E" Q=L V
$ VKR IG% VRK IZTV^ M
 LNWUK %N VRN U>R^ V"%]^
SXNQ HUN V %N MK VRK %HEK N;%N SXN HGK M" LG ZR% GK
WNRK QN7>$GK M" V. IFR LKW %]^ YR E=UGN M" W" V. %MK$ Z]%G  RN'K
% 
IXQN IH ]V 0^P %MK$ S
EG IHV QILMN %N M
W Z"$ JR
$ ZR
L.WN I- YR %NE HR>'NZ-K NIMS V
$ J>=I6QN HK NIMS ZRK LN%
SX HGK M" HSKR NIMS HR>'NZ-K  % IHMN SX HGK M" L V^]
Z R   V
$  7> J G 3  EW $ UK Z R K I33 S' $ UK IJ6EKQ. J^ L NW. IVQNU U K$
VG VRK LN% SXUK I-]GRZVK % IHMN IH Z"$ >I'QN IH U>R^GW %MK$
SGE'  XNMKG   JNJ E= U GN M"   HSKR NIMS HR> ' NZ-K  %  IHMN IH
S1K I-M WK VRN *RZ M" I-=H W"G YNH1R  GK GWN-K %N E=U V.
HK G^R V
$ %MK$ E"$G I-=H J]LWK$ HEN GN QI;QNJH M>]GN M" I-=H
7> > X  HEN GN QI;QNJH M] > G N M"   S 1 K QUEK HEN IW= X  LN'N M
W 
UN HK NRK 7>ZR J]LWK$ HEN IW=X MK J9
4U I-%]^ 6=Y'N JWUN
V]^ Q=U GK J94N-K HR Z"$ J94N7>' QNI-QN M. W" V. %MK$ Z]%GK JT]V^
IZT V ^  IG\' E= U K IH ] V  HIM IRMN M"  V. IHV  U= E  %N IWU9 LNW 
QILMN IWXNR HRH I-]GRZVK % IHMN IH L"N QNJ HM
U Z"$ W" MK
HR^ ] U K HR> ' NZ-K HSKR  NIMS %  7> J G 3  IG= V N IHMN IH VKR
IG% ZR R^J IW=X HNE QNWUN V^] 7> %NE S
EK ZV L
 Z"$ %NZ IG=VN
M"  G
 IZ] 1  I-GN LNJ HR%N G
 IZ] 1  SNQG 7>  %] ^  G \ 'N M"   7>  G
SNQG IVHNR HR%N M" W" V. U>R^GW QN7>' V. QIV 3K[R XR'.
IW=X IUR LN'N XNMKGN M" I-M ZRN HWE I- WNR E-K QNG3 M"
RN'K %  IHMN PKH M"  LK
M> '  RN'K %] ^  IX] V N S'K M
- K K 3R;N %NE LNJ HR RMK K
HSKR NIMS  HR>'NZ-K GN R^J S'NH U>R^GW R^J IW=X HNE QNI-QN

110

HSKR NIMS XNR


$  > = U . IW= X  QN7> $ G  M%

QNWN, EUN-K I-] G RZVK I-] G RZVK M> '  7>  %] ^  V. JIME. V
$  MK YR
K %NZ IZR% HKVN HNE W=E %MK$ GI\QN G
 IZ]1 G SNQG LG
GI\QN V. HNE GN WR^J SGE IUQN HNE GN IL7>$ GN IV7>$ XMRN
IG\N-K G '  E= U N HR> ' NZ-K NIMS GN WR^ J  %MK$ IRMN LG HNE
%  G I \QN IH V R N V. WR^ J  SGE IUQN 7> M  LN' IUQN IH I-G
H
E H
-K 3HVK >HV Z]VR M" I-M HIMH XEN IUQN IH V"%]^ IFR G
\^]UN M>' V. SX U-K M" RN'K SM>V \>3 M
-K F>EK %MK$ ZN-K HG
QNJ'KQ. S.GKQ. %]^ HM IH ZRK IZTV^ K ZR U>R^GW % R=I\QN HR
IG=VK RNL H
E U-K V(N IHMN IH Q=L ZRK IZTV^ M
'K K ZR U>R^G
W % Z"%]^ SXN IEQN Z"%]^ E"' E-K HNE QNI-QN K RNL % IHMN IH
V^] Q" MK YRNZ HRGK RIM]GK M"$ HNE QN7>$GN QV V"%]^ 6=Y L.GNI-M
]V W" WIMHN IG]G M% RNLN GK U=E %]^ RN'K IHW$ Z]% \>3KA\>3K
IW=X RN'K QNJ' HZR IW=X LNH E1 U-K H>0 GR G SNQG =J S'H
HNE IFR QNI-QN V(N RN'K %] ^  Y=   IEQN IL7> $  MK = J  %  RN'K %] ^
Y=IQN V. RN'K %]^ JVN X=E IUQN RN'K ,
R %NE IXEN-K Z"%]^ =J
% Y= IEQN %HR *=L G\G MK G\G I-=H Z
RK JN'K I%=HE' GN
6
1 N I6GT  IW= X
$  7> M  = J  I%HE IUQN QNJ'  U> R ^ G  W  %] ^  J> H NR HR
RN'K SM
3 M
 U-K HR>'NZ-K HSKR  NIMS 7>a( JTU1 M
 U- E
H.
%] ^  IG\N7> '  E-K Z] V R S
I EQN 7> M  V. IS%. Z] V T  V
$  WK LKWV HR
HG M% IHK L]VTAZ]VT GK H
-K ,R^RV %MK$  I-]GTZVK %]^ LKWV HR
IG= V N RN'K %  SM> V  3> = H R Z%NI-QN IH M  S] G K 6 9  L  Q= L  QNJGK
3R' IW=X %N M>]GK V. ZRK IZTV^ M
 L.GK HSKR JTZ3WR % IHMN IH
I- HNE %]^ Z"$ VR [R IW=X [>3' WK %MK$ IG]GN VR 7>aV I-M MZEN
WK %MK$ HRGN JT]V^ V"%]^ IW3WN3 WK %MK$ M]>GN V]^ I-M 
XGK IH Z
R 7>aV H
-K Z>KSV %MK$ QN7>'K K U>R^ LK % Z"%]^ SIMHN H %NZ
IG= V N M"   I-E-K V" % ] ^  (
9 4 N  ILMN 01HN IG= V N M"   %MK$ V. S 1 K V" % ] ^
IW3WN3 %MK$ M
' N K
;RZGNM.['NQ];RNIS%JRXLKWLZHNXRN@
HSKR NIMS HR>'NZ-K  % IHMN IH M>' LG Z"$ XNM^]U N VG V
RK IZT V ^  M
W  U K URKSGN LK HIM] G   M% IH/A
URKSHNEYR" HRVNRL" L" L" LUGK3
LRNLRK0N9VKJURLYNR 3K3@
I-M HNE HSKR *UWN% HSKR JTZ3WR  V
$ YRGN M" QV I-M ZV
HSKR NIMS G L>V
=  0N9GK M" QT(NV %HR G V>E M" IFR 7> ;^9 %]^ QNJ'
IR V EUNH HIM]GK M" IH QNJG *UV G 7> H
E Z"$ %MK$ LN7^$UK
URKSHNEL
 JK JK%NLRNM" JI%MNR
 G
 QEZ],^RM"$ZR NIMSH GRSNR@
I-M HNE L
 I-= (
 G   ST M IZ] Y  GN *UWN% ST M Z  M"  V(N L

STMZN IW3'^ ZM3 GN IJVN M" I-M V. ZR HSKR NIMS GN QN1N
JKGN M" QR(NV J=HN %HR M" QV LRN ZV  ZR HSKR JTZ3WR GN
JN'K *RGK M" QR(NV I-=H IW
33 %HRN'K M" I-M G
 QE Z,G^R Z
IW3

IUQN% U] U N

111

R HSKR JTZ3WR G GRSNR IW=X M" H>0 IG%. G SNQNG NIMS IFR
QN- RN'K I-]GRZVK %]^ IV%NZ JTGN% HKVN
IFR H> 0  Z $  G  SNQG HR> ' NZ-K NIMS %  RN'K I-] G RZVK GK
QIV 3R;N G \ H  NR%NZ IG= V N 3SG GK 7> J E= * ;K HRWN-K HSKR
JTZ3WR RN'K I-]GRZVK %^] Z$A 7>aV GR3% G' L.G RIM]G % V.
I-] G RZVK JT N (%. HIRQN HRGK K IH Z R   JVK RNLN %] ^  Z0N7>
ZNIEH I-M WK Z]% LNW QNJG XR%. IW=X QN LNW V. ZRN LKW%
FE M
 LNW X]GRIWL" %]^ HSKR NIMS % JTN(%N HKVK IH X]GRIWL"
QNJ WK %NZ E" E7> I-M G
 IG% GN RNL QV PNP M" IFR XRNK E=\
,^ % KQ. IW= X  JT N 'K XEN LN- U N X] G RIWL"  %  IHMN IH Z" $  V. %NZ
EW.UN %MK$ QV QNJGK I33 %]^ Z%4N HR^]UN %MK$ XNM NR \,N% %]^
MK GN% HR
  XNM  IH  JT H NR GN IV] U  HRWN8 Z" $  Z%4 N  %MK$
HR.UN HSKR NIMS HR> ' NZ-K  %  J> = I 6QN QNJ %NZ IH7> $  %MK$
EW
UX]GRIWL" RNLN % IHMN IH Z"$ V. W=YA RNILQ. GKQ. JNR1KQ.
V
JNR1KQ. V
LN'N J"$GN M" HR>'NZ-K HSKR NIMS  % IHMN IH JNR1KQ. IW=X LN'
IW=X %NZ HK R>HNW1 HRUN *N IW=X LN8 7>a( HNL^ \N8 G=>; JK E8
3TSV L^  JK E8 3RNS ZV JT
U HR
 3
RNS JK'N ZM.JNJ M" JT]V^
3RNS
RNLN %MK$ Z] I %QN
RN'K GK JT N (%N 7> a V  HR> ' NZ-K HSKR  NIMS %  RNL  %] ^  IFR
Z0NI-QN IH %NZ G  IS%. I-M LKW% Q"    MK IWQR( M
 LNW U N
QNJ %NZ E" E8 RNLN % IFR IHMN IH U>R^ LK Z"%]^ %NZ G E-K ZV
HIM'N QNJGK I33 %] ^  Z" $  Z%4 .  %MK$ HR.UN XNM  IH] % N GN% HR 
IH]%N IV]U HRWN- NIMS % IHMN IH S1K I- G
 IG% G >=\ %]^
G\H I-GK S>=;K I*T31 M
 U-K M" V^] JT*^ G XR'. IW=X E=UK RIM
QNJ'N QNVZ HIEQN' HRWN I-=( H
-K IH GN JVK %MK$ H
-K IH
GK JV%K %MK$ J^RW L%Z G ]HNR %NE G
 IG% GN ]S]; M" QNJ'N
HTZ S'N S1K LG I-]GRZVK  NE GK S=><K M
 U-K M" IH=(  NE
GK 7> Z R IW= X  ZR LN'N K LG RKR WK IM= E ' E= U NVG HR> ' NZ-K
NIMS S
E M>' S
E I-]GRZVK HK XNM>]GK M" X=E'N XNM]>GK M" VE
H
I-] G RZVK %  IHMN IH JT Z  3 WR Z" $  IVQNR M. ISEH> E  IVQNR M.
GNVN HR>'NZ-K NIMS % IHMN IH VRK H
-K J
V L. J
VK IW=X ZZVN
V. %MK$ M"   RN'K %  IHMN IH ISEH> E  %MK$ JT Z  3 WR QNJ'  IUQN%
MK QILMN I%T Z E G  IG= V N I- U] G   E
H  GK HK I-= 6 N HR. HSKR
HR> ' NZ-K  JT Z  3 WR LK %  IHMN IH XE S 1 K RN'K JT N ' IVQNU
U-K JT Z  3 WR HSKR HR> ' NZ-K  S] G K6 9  RN'K I-] G RZVK GK QNVZN
%]^ 7>aJR E" U- I- STIMZ]Y IW=X I-=H ZN%R
WR M" 7> ZN%R
WR
7> a V  LNH  I- QNVZN %] ^  I-3%N% HRWN7> ' N M> ] G N M"   I- JT N 'K %] ^
HSKR JTZ3WR J^R U>R^ WR^J IW=X JTU1 M
H H>0 Z$ V=H ZN%R
WR
7>aV R=\G M% JTZ3WR HSKR S]GK69 LK % I-]GRZVK V
$ J>=I6QN I-
]NR IW=X VRK H>0 I-=6N M
W V. G>SNRN L%Z E"'N JWUN LHR Z%
IW= X  I-= 6 N RIM U-K V. VE
H  %MK$ LN HGK I-] G RZVK %  IHMN

112

HSKR NIMS XNR


$  > = U . IW= X  QN7> $ G  M%

NIMS QNJ V. Q] V RNZK M


  H
- K I-= 6 N %MK$ M"   QNJG  XR'. GK
I-=6N M" EIH% I-=H Z% IW=X 3]HN S'K M
-K M" IH ZRN L
 JVK K
7>% Z"%]^ IH WK ;NRIZH HRZ G E-K HG Z%4N %MK$ HKVN %MK$ V.
Q= L H= E 4  G  JVK QNJ'KQ. JV%KQ. %] ^  Z%4 N  HR IG] G    L H R 7> M  Z" % ] ^
Z%4 N  HR IG] G N V. Z" $  QNJG  XR%. IW= X  %MK$ E= U  JN7> $ GK Z R N
HIEQN' %MK$ M> ] G N 7>  GN I- 3> * HRZ IW= X  IM
U  GN H> 0  EN*
S'GN M"  V. HGK 7>  V  WK IGN HR%N GNVN JT Z  3 WR HSKR LK %
GI\QN IH I-M %NGN% I-G IJ=6 IFR E1H U-K NIMS S
E PKH M"
S1K M>' V]^ G
 XNR NE I-=( RIM
M> '  G
 NE G  SNQG RNLN WK ZR% E= U N IH7> $ IH %NZ %MK$ E"
%MK$ R= I \QN K Z G  G^ V  QN-   RNLN X $ H IWX X= H R \NH  IUR
IUQN Z G  G^ V . %  7>  GK UT G % %] ^  GSNI-QN RNL  GN 1= 1 K QV
IJ3NS I%HE IUQN HR>'NZ-K HSKR  NIMS % RN'K %]^ IHMN IH G
\ VR RNLN GK HK MNEV M
 RMK M" 7>a( ZN%R
WR V
$ JTZ3WR HSKR
LK % IG\NI-QN I-M * HVH G\H RN'K % IHMN IH G\ E7> GNVN
L 7>GK *UVK IW=X IM
U GN H
-K FE S'GN M" V. IGN HR E7>
RN'K %^ ]  I_R WK (
9 KAILMK ZZVN S'K K NIMS HSKR HR> ' NZ-K
% 
IXQN IH I-M IFR HNEG LNE IW=X FUK I-M 
XH ZN%R
WR
V
$  7> a (  U-  IL= (   RNLN X] G RIWL"  QNJ'  ZIME IW= X  S M
3  IJQN K
ZG^V 7>G JTN' H=< RM % HSKR NIMS G QN7>$G MK ZG^V Q"
QNHN3 IW=X 7>Y U- L" Z>RG V
$ IU=; 7>aY L.G M% X]GRIWL" M
3
IW=X QN IUQN NMZ' HR>'NZ-K NIMS \94 % HWE X]GRIWL" %]^
IG\N-K G  RM  % IH  M
R  %] ^  IG\N-K %MK$ G  RM  % X] G RIWL"
XR%. IW=X IURH I\ZN NX%. HR% E=IUQN Z"%]^ Z>QN_ HR IG7> GNVN
ZRK LN% SXN7> IH7>$IH M>' 7>% GI\QN IH VRK LN% LN' WNEK M"
LG I- LKW GK Q=\ \>=E4GK M" IH I-M U=E V. IWU9 U-K  Z"%]^ ZNQF
HR IG7> GNVN ZRK LN% SXN EW
 ZNIEH HSKR NIMS % IHMN IH
RNLN Q=L WK 7>MK U=E M" 7> IG% WK I-MK U=E K %NZ E"'N M
WUN
RNLN %  IHMN IH Z" $  %NZ E"  EW.UN LK M> '   E"  EW.UN %NZ HSKR
NIMS % 7>JG3 IG=VN V(N IHMN IH M>' Z"$ V"%]^ G
 NE GK 7>ZR G
W.UN L I- IW=X I-=H NM WK \NEK XEN IUQN V. IFR HRZG]Y RIM
LNW U N
HSKRLKW%V
(
9N*ENL"V>ZR%M
EN\WR3HNLKW%NE\;R%NH
@

3>* HTZ IW=X IM


U IG=VN M
I-QN IJ6EN HTZ QV %NE MK 3R;N
%NE G
 NE G IZR% %NE QV IV]%
$ %NZ JTGN% HRH HSKR NIMS
X]GTIWL" %]^ WK JNR HR E" U- S
E
 HSKR JTZ3WR  HIWRGW HK L"
L"  S] G K 6 9 #
JTZ3WR HSKR NIMS LK =X 3R;NE^ GK 7>ZR W;N IG]GN M" V(N
7>G JIRWNR GK WK RH3N HRGN M" 7>JR
HV IWWR% V
$ I=; M
I-QN
I-M JTZN' SM>V JIME. G M% WRVZN% IW=X N;NR' IWQHVK IW3WN3
%MK$ HRGN WRVZN% IW=X J^L HSKR JTZ3WR GK 3HVK %NE IVU>R^

IUQN% U] U N

113

RNZJNE LK G G>QNRN M


- H31. I%WNR% V(N 7>ZR W;N7>' G <R RW
JTZN' J94% I-K J>VH IW=X *=1IHQN %]^ ZNRU IW3# %NZH E\ IW=X

 HSKR NIMS HIWRGW  GN HE>U IW=X JTU1 M


'N
IWHT Z K ] Z V  ] %    L P  ZN GK J^ R I'ZN W R  A W R 
ST M ZZM^ R V IW= X  7> M  J^ R ' JT Z  3 WR HSKR HIWRG W  LK W" $  QNJ'
Z^E (N% VE
H V
$ QN- HN3K IW=X EIMRVNRN VENS G Q]GR HZE
G  F> = E  7> a V  I-= H  SNEH GN R^ J  ;NR' HKVN JIME. Z" $  QNJ%] ^
%KR^A%KZN SNR IW=X G='N XNM.UN IH 7>M H' % G>QNJR >=U IW=X
%KR^A%KZN >JX >GT3% G ZNVN IJVN % I-%4. % HSKR NIMS GK
U=E %^] 7> Z$ WKHNR %MK$ HKVN K Q]V IW=X >GR3% % HR>'NZ-K
R^J IW=X QN- HSKR NIMS %]^ JTN(%N HKVK K IH JT*^ QNJ% Z"%]^ 7>JG
3 G IG=VN V. * H>0 G IG=VN QNJV
$ Q=L V=H H>0 Z]U' GK H
-K MK
,R^ R V %MK$ J-K IH7> $ IH QNJ%  RW Z%
H NZ%N J^ R ' HR IG= V KQ.
V(N L
 QE *UVK ;] %  M"  7>   %NE WK JT K J^ R ' HR IG= V N I-= H
JTNR(%N M"" GN GK L PKH Z0
 V. WKHNR HR E"'N ZR ZNVN IJVN
L IHK WK L%Z IW=X HGK Z%>=\ RKR JTNJV HR% V. 7>%4. %]^ ]*NE'N
JT * ^   I-M SM> V  J] > % QNVZN M% E I H% Q= L  I-%4 . GK S> = ; K IWJRKV M

U-K M" I-M JTZNVZN GK SN'K %]^ Z]% %MK$ RM HSKR NIMS % IHMN
IX]VN %N HR V]^ QNJ' ZNVNAIJVN G X=HR IW=X I-=( 7>E0 LNW$UN
QN7> '  G  Z. I-%4 .  %^ ]  WK ] * NE^ ] U N HNE LNE V
$  JNR HR.U. V] ^
I%3IX]V M
H VE
H LN >GR3% LK VE
H XE U-
> G R3% G  ZNVNAIJVN G  HE= > U  IW= X  %KR^ A %KZN G  L%Z V
$
JIME. WK STNMZ' [R IW=X I-%4. G L%Z M
- 7> Z$ WK I%R]VN%
MK RM IFR VKRN Z%=>\ L%Z HN3K IW=X M
I-QN 7> Z$ WK 7>M
STNMZ' QV STNMZ'K URK 3]HR QV RWVK %NZ %NE  % ]VN%
IFR WK %MK$ K
%KR^ V(N %KZN G
%
4 URK 3]HR QV RWVK %NZ G STMZ' LNVK
V
$ % I-M *UWN% I3W G 7>JN3H % *UWN% I3W GK ZIMZN I3W
J> R N' V
$  I%RWNR( *NW %NE *UVQNVZNW. %^ ]  > ' NI-QN HRG  %
IHK V
$ J"N %MK$ E"$G % I-]% %H QNVZN % IH L H
-K 7>%4. %^]
QNJ' QNJ G=HI3'N G L.GN K 7> IW=X
$ *
L% 
U R=\ E"$G % QV
L
 SX L.GN K 7>GN *]YNRN HR IG]G %
M
R WNR(K STNMZ' URK 3]HR V(N RWVK V
$ %_RV HRG K
IH7> $ IH U R K 3] H R I%RWNR( H(N HIRQN HRG  % J"    G  ENEX
IW=X *UV. %]^ U]>ZRNM %MK$ HRG % IL HNR' 7>M JT3]3N G JNVR
S' M
- % 7>a;R Z>EZN%. %]^ IUQN% M
 IUQN K IH I-%4. G %NE
H
- K ST N MZ' IM] G ^  %MK$ M"   7> % 4 .  %  I-GN EN* 7> P NI-QN V(N
SEJ^RWH 7>%4. %]^ Z>EZN% S'N IG=VN Z>EZN%. % QNJ'N JN'K 7>%4.
G  NR  [R IW= X  I69H IG= V N V  7> % 4 .  G  Z] ^ M  IW= X  WK JN IG= V N NR

114

HSKR NIMS XNR


$  > = U . IW= X  QN7> $ G  M%

H=JI9Q. 7>aV WK I69H IG=VN 7> %NE IM]G^ STNMZ'. % IHMN IH M>'
I-M Z>EZN% S' U- Q=LG SNQG I-%4. GN NY %NE H
-K *N-KAXNRN
%MK$ RM U N

%KR^A%KZN %^] L>ENM GK 7>JN;K V(N JTZ3WR JTNJVK#


SXNR URK 3]HR V(N RWVK SW=3 M
 U- Z>EZN%. % J>R3
GN %NZ %KR^ V(N I-VRK GN %NZ %KZN R=I\QN JIMEN 7>%4. H
E J^LN
QN7>$GK K 7> %NE 7>%4. GK R
LKAR
1K XE RMK K QV L
 R>JI-QNAJ"N
SX LNGN K 7>  GN G> R  7> J 
U  %MK$ HRG  % 7>   SX  ;] %  %NE
;RZA*]YNRN HR IG]G % J^LN QN7>'K WK S]G M
 U-K K 7>%4. %

IXQN M>' HK H]Z HRK- 7>%4. % I-=H H=J9N S>%' GK \=YK EUN E-K
QV L>ENM GN H]Z HR%N 3>R^ HR IG=VN H=J9N S>'H H I%RWNM HR%
E=U H=J9 GK S>'N-K %NE [R ?RX G IJ=6
$ L
 J"N SX L.GN K 7>%^]
GN *]YNIRQ. IW=X EUN IG]G % IM]G^ STNMZ'. % %KR^A%KZN GN U]UN
IW=X I-%N% HR%N S]G HR IG=VN K HIM]G K IH M>' QNJ Z>EZN%
M
 U- M

U]UN GIRQN GN JN'K EIMR. %NE 7>6EH HN3K G I-=H EIMRVNRN
%NZH SM> V  W= Y   R
W R %] ^  *RH  R= \ GN K SM> V  I%RZE LE *IRQN
RIM]GN K 7> IW=X HZE G F>=E 7>aU M
- % ]%  IWHRZK
] Z V   L P ZN3 3> G K J^ R %ZN3K %] ^  ST M ZZM^ R V ^ ^ R L7> G "  V
$
EU*U Y <  [] 1 N JIME.  IW= X  QNJ'  VE
H  IR= V ;NZ  V
$  IMRKR
QNH JTZ3WR HSKR HIWRGW  SNEH GN R^J S'NH EIMRVNRN VENS
IW= X  HZE G  F= > E  7> a V  IWRNLZN% M
-    7>  K EIMRVNRN VENS IW= X
%KR^A%KZN WRA WR STMZZM^RV IW=X I-3%N% HR% G E-K JTVKIG%
LNI-QN HRG % STMZZM^RV R^J HIM]G M% ^RL7>G" M
' %NE Y<
[]1N J^RW  I-=H SM>V VLJ>]L GN XZHKEN U
EN S=X G R^J IW=X JTZ
3WR HSKR NIMS LK QNJ'  V L
Z -K  RKR > H V QN-  % G^ R K G
HNR' JTHN3 J]>L MK %LR QN7>$GN M"  7>>aJR V
$ VE
H V
$  QNI-QN
QV HZE G F>=E 7>aV IZ
1 IUQN IL %NE NRN EIMRVNRN VENS
IZ1
LUZU ALUZU M
 IUQN K QV  IFR I-= H  H
%   IW= X  LNH  QIGT 3  M

IUQN I- IGT3 %]^ WNZK RNZN%]G LK G I-=H I33 IR3K Q31N%]G
LK Q=\. %NE G\ RM % Q31N%]G LK I-3%N% HR% E-K MR R
L
I-H.V (N% 7>    EIMRVNRN VENS 7> a V  JT V KIG% LNI-QN HRG  %
7>a( S"PH U>R^ GW % L
 Z]VR IG=V % 7>GN LNJ HRG % QV JTIHTVK
GN QN%]G ZN'G % WNZK Q31N%]G LK % LG GI\QN IH I-]%N V
, JT H N3 IL %NE Q= \ . WK X> ] I ;QN U-KQ. IR3K LK %  
I XQN IH
I-M H
-K ZRK *UVK GK 7>JE=*;K M" L. ZRN ;
\N M" I-M 
XH HNR'
J>=6' G E-K QNJ' U>R^GW G JN U-
QNGR'K-$ RNZN%]G LK V
$ Q31N%]G LK % J>=I6QN IH M U>R^GWC
Z" $  Q= L  QILMK R 3 %K G \ K L
 Z" $  IL] G UK IW= X  HG  %MK$ G \ K NRN

IUQN% U] U N

115

IWTV.V G=IQN IH QNHN3 IW=X


$ I-=H JTHN3 Z^M QN IRMN K Z"$ G
I\QN V. Z R KQ. Q= \ . 7>   R 3 %K %] ^  IM' %N HR HKQ. I-E-K
S]G M
 U-KQ. S]G Q=\. %NE I-=H I33^ GN R^J IG\N-K IG=VN ILW
$ ^RL %]^ G\' V
$ SNQG ^RL GN I-=H U
ENAILMN IG\N-K IG]GN M" Q"
MK SNEH IG\N-K G' E=UN  HK I-M H
-K *UVK GK H
-K 7>JE=*GK M"
L. Z R N IGT 3 1KG
3  KWNZK RNZN%] G  LK %  IHMN J> = V R QILM  E= 6 '
VG M> ] G   M% LG 7> a JR G  E
H . V
$  H
- K QWVNRU' QN7> $ G  M% 7> M
IH G I-=( JTU1 M
'U IHK Z. G L%Z E"'U V IFR EKE4N HR'U
 IH7> $ IH I-%4 .  IR3KQN %] ^  IRF I-] % N MK IUQN% M"  IH Z. V
$  MK
L%Z M>]GN M"  IL]%N IR3K %]^ IUQN% K QNJ' I33 GN 3]HN ZN;N%
HR IG= V N
%KR^ QV %KZN JTVKIG% GK VR4. 7> IG% WK I-3%N% HR% LN RM
% RNV  IW= X  %KZN %  JT * ^  %] ^  JT N (%N HKVK IH M  *UWN% I3W
IH7> $ IH 7> M  S 3 = H  Z>  EZN% S' U-  % E I H% 7> M  QNJ'K N;%.
IMRG V
$ %MK$ *>=E JN RM % L
 I-]% NE. V
$ HR RM %  HK QNJG
[R IW=X NY E-K S=X GK HZK J" U-K M" N%]^ WK I-=H ENE G IG7>
NYN LKW% WK FE M
 LNWUN QILMN HIM H F>=1AF=>1 H R
' E=UK
7>G JVK %KR^ % IHMN IH %KZN JT*^ GK I-=6N IW=X JT]% RIM' IW=X MK
IM=V M>]GN M"  L I- VR4. R
$GK RM$UK V. VRN RKR HZ,
R M
 LNW
UN Q= \ . V
$  IG\'N S] G  M
 LNW U N NY  *NU. IW= X  ] V N% %MK$ M" 
QILMN HIM] G  A HIM] G   EIMRVNRN VENS 7> a V  JM> ] X  U-   (
9 4 N A(
9 4 N  M%
R4N K %KZN I-3%N% HRH SNMR QN-K QNJ' H=J9 SGE %KR^ LG
I-3%N% HR% G E-K VNENS IW=X JTW3 HRH U
V ZNRAZNR H %MN7>'
E=UN %KZN LG I-3%N% HRG Z$ JIMI%QN M
I-QN H=J9N ;
' G E-K
G> S NRN VNENS G  IH%NR V  U-K VG V= H  M% 4 R N M1 IUQN K ^ R L
X94' WNEN K %KZN % VNENS IW=X GI\QN IH NMZ' HZE G F>=E
7>aV H
-K WV^ IM=E RMK M" HSKR NIMS % S=X G R^J IW=X I-=H J"R
GN I-=H Q]U^PN Z>=\ IW=X G R=I\QN K QV J"R IM=EN RM % JIMEN
V. %KZN % 
IXQN IH NI-G H
-K =J %N M
W ZR JVK G W=E QN IRMN
M
W IFR I;QN% %NE GI\QN V. Z0G GR %N E=UK IH I-M V. H
-K
S=XN M" S=XN QV HZE G F=>E G 7>aV I-HGZ QNJ' JVK %^] QNWNL
EUN-K IH G\'N LK S=XN Y=>SUN S=XN Y=>SUN %KR^ S
IEQN IH V^] S=IXQ.
G X=HR IW=X JNUE M
 U-K M" JN'K IW=X WK V"%^] S=XN %,R QN7>' E=UN
%KZN % IHMN M. 7>M NMZ' HZE G F>=E 7>aV G\
 7>GK L
RGNR
QNWN, V
$ JT*NIWV M
H IL VR_ M=( %NE ]HV HR RMK K %KR^ %
7>a;R GI\QN I-=H HZE G F=>E 7>aV %WLNV I33^ EI1QN M
I-QN K
%KR^  7>   S= X   %] ^  F> = E  Z V  X> = H  IEQN-  QV  %KZN %] ^  G  IG= V N QNJ
I-3%N% HR% E= U N %KR^  I-3%N% HRH  SNMR QNI-QN %KZN S= X   G
R^J IW=X QN- JTZ3WR %]^ SM>V IJQNR HR RMK K QV I3W JT*^ GK
JT  ]  N V(N 7>  V= V K HR RMK K IH M  JT * ^  QNJ%  Z R K NE. GK
Z%
H NZ%. J^ R ' HR IG= V K IH7> $ IH 7> M  I3W GK J^ L NR% K  HIM

116

HSKR NIMS XNR


$  > = U . IW= X  QN7> $ G  M%

RMK K M I3W JT*^ Q=L MK IMRG V


$ J>HNR HKVK K Q=L MK >' E-K
7> HSKR JTZ3WR %^] ILGN %NZ E"' %NE NY IMRG IW=X I-=H
IW33 MEXE ILMK M]>GK M" 7>G JTZ IW=X R
ZAR
Z \94N M
 L.GN M"
QNVZN *RH  QN7> $ GK M"  QV  IL ZNVNA*" '  %  K%  %NE EUNH
J> = V RW= V  IJQNR HKVN L
 QN%] G  7>   ZN-K %] ^  M
I -QN M
W  U N 7> M
QNWRI'V M"   IL VR4 .  IWQHVK U> 9  \NMH  M
R  %^ ]  7>  G  QN%] G  %^ ]
%MK$ G=   HGN \N' WNEN MK LN' HGN M"   ILW $  Z. IJQNR HRGK
M" I- VR4. I33^ R^J ;NRK JTZ3WR G HGK Z>=\ %]^ X]>Z HGK K% %NE
EUN RMK K QV I_R WNRAWNR 7>G Z>=\ %^] G\ RMK K I-]% IW=X
%KR^  I-3%N% HRH  SNMR QN IUQN IH7> $ IH Z%= > \  ZNL W= E
ILQNGN G \ GN M"  7>  %  IWXNR EUNI-QN IH %N V. Z> >  EZN%. %NE
NYN IW3 3  IJQNR SI'QN M"  V  IM] G ^  ST N MZ' NY  %NE GW" 3  HRG
M% JIME. I-K QWR GN EN* Z>  EZN%. %  7> a PNI-QN IH N%] ^
Z>EZN% S'N IG=VN NYN H
-K N(K %MK$ M" L QK$ I- S=X %]^ E"H
LNW.U V. E
H J>=6'U IH I- S=X G ZNVN IJVN H' M% QNJ IHK
GN S= X N 7> a PNQ H  IEQN-  M
  I-GK Z. R
 RMK M
W  U K QK$ HK
LWNS G W .U   IHW $  G=  .U   HZE G  F= > E  7> a V  G=  .U  V. H
- K Z] %  U N
%MK$ I-M * IWXNR HRH %KR^ % IHMN IH %KZN I- S=X %^] I-=( MK
6=Y G %KZN % IHMN IH LK Z"$ I- S=X %^] %MK$ 6=Y HGK ZR JTN'
LN HG M% Z"$ V9_ H ZR LN7^$UK %N LN' ZR 7>aV I- SNEH %
HK ,NG^ HR IG=VN Z"$ I-%]^ %MK$ 6=Y HGK %KR^ % %KZN %^] NRK U=E
Z0N-K IH NY %NE Q"N S' HGN M" %KZN % IHMN IH I- S=X
G E-K Z"$ G3 I%HNEN WK E" HGK M. JT]V^ I-%]^ %MK$ 6=Y.UK %KR^
% 7> GK %NGN%K %]^ G\H 
IXQN IH I-M V. JNUE M
 U-K ZNL %]^
%MK$ G\ RMK M" %KR^ % %KZN %]^ IHMN IH Z"$ Q=L V=H VRK HG U=E
GK 7>E]['N %MK$ HKVK K IH7>$IH QNJ' S=X %MK$ % L
 V]^ HIM]GK
RMK Z"$ WKHNR HRGN IRMN JT]V^ Q=L Z"$ VRK I-M U=E %MK$ Z]%.UN
L. V. V] ^  I- SNEH %] ^  I-= (   MK R= \  G   %MK$ V. V" % ^ ]  M> '   G
 (= J 9
EUN7>$GN M. 7> ZMNJ>R3 % JIMEK WNR QNJ'K JV%K GK VR_ M=(
HKVN K 7>K Z$ I33^ R^J IW=X HSKR JTZ3WR HIWRGW  % IHMN
IH %KR^ Z"%]^ [R E" X=E
 V"%]^ H
-K IWJVN %MK$ QN-UK I33^ R^J IW=X
JT Z  3 WR G  WX% > ' H  %KR^  [SRN IUQN IHV  I-M S= X N V. H
- K
FIR3VN M
W Q(WN H
-K I=; J>R3 M
W QV VR 7>aV H
-K IW=JVN %N
QN LNW X>=J HRH X=E IJQN
LG S=X %]^ E" H [R QN- V. NR I-M J>=6'N *>=E U- IH I-M IH=(
$
IEQN-  M
 HN3K G  I-VRK QV  J> R 3 E9H  %] ^  G \ ' E-K QN-  QV
HIM' E=U IH I-M V. H
-K GWVN %,R QN7>$GN M" I-]%N ]>GR RKR
Q"  N V L
Z -K S= X N JIME. HG  QK$ %MK$ G I \QN H
- K HM  I-M V.
ST M ZNAIW3'^ A ZM 3  IW= X
$  H
- K JT * ^  M"   ST M ZNAIW3'^ A ZM 3  HIM] G   M%
IH I-M V. H
-K 7>aJR G E
H. V
$ QN-K M
-K 3HVK M" I- VR4. *
QNJ'KA I1= J 'K HIM RM  %

IUQN% U] U N

117

URKS XRNK S];% H1HK%K HEJ HSKR *W% XV>RG3 E


H S 1^1 L]Z L],KR@@
URKSQ%]VH
I1STIMZ]YZ$S]GK69HMN-
V
-HHSKRM"$L%%KLI%QN%NZN-@@
URKS3SGWR^JNIMS;%K3SGI];SZ.IMSNMR*KVRRIZRMNLM.VM.SP.IM@@
URKSLE(EIJT(WKUU%Z$SNMR*KVR-HJ^R'STMZHSKRM"$QIWUVJ>R3QE\@@
URKSWHM
-HIR7>VRI-IJT(WKHZ.IMLKW7>;NR%LUVU>R^SNRSNRSIEL.IM@@
URKSHN3KJ^RKHVIHQN7>VR Q;RQ;NRZ
Z%H]^ Z>LRNM>WNL]UEZ$GKGNR@@
URKSH
I1IHR%3I3*N%>I;QN%Q;RISZN%JRVJ^R'STMZH]^ 3KVEIJ]YR^JTN'@@
URKSU
GIEQNZ>\X>]ISHIRMZR^J0EH]VLURZURHNI-QNHRGZHJGZQ%]V@@
URKSHN3K7>Z1KU>E*NZ
Z%HN[R[RH
-KHMSTMZNIW3'^M"H
-KHMI-]GTH>SR@@
URKSH
-KHM6E-K3WR%MK$H
-KIH]%T HMEN-"H
-KHMU'-K3HNIL7>$IL7>$ZNVIRN-"@@
URKSH
-KHMWR^';RZRN-M"H
-KH
-KHMV-K3
EMHEN>*.%UIVH
-KHMLUGK3@@
URKS *UVK Z>IHV E 7>VR Z1% VK%
$ VNJ Z
Z% H YRN IEQN HM HSKRN SNJ@@
URKSG^;%JKW%Q]%*\"%MK$JE%0>E]VQ;RQZN%I;QN%Z$HZEHENF>E]V@@
URKSHN3KZ$QXRLI*QNU-KLUVHK%K$G-G>EM7>VRIL7>$H]I%QNWRSK$G@@
URKS\EHZ>EHG\%IUQNRNLNJTLNRKVL]S^GKJILM.%Z7>VR 3SGQVKV@@
URKSG>%KHM" 
MGWM"GWHMVM"$-K3-K3HM JRSTMZM"J^R'SKW SK@@

JTZ3WR HSKR LK MK Q%NIG JRZU>R^ M% 7>MK MK R^J.VR HRH ]V IR3K
*3 IW=X Z$AZ$ 7>aV W"$*^  W"$ JTU1 M>]G M% HNE G G^V. ]V.  G>QNRN
IWUN9 V=VWIUQN% %^] W=( HRG M% HSKR NIMS % MK STMZ IW3'^ I3W
QNIG GWVNW. IR3K Z>%K V ]V. %]^ Z$A 7>aV QNJ' VE
H V
$ QN H %NZ
7>JG3 IG=VN QNGR'K-$ URKSGN LK ZMNRNL % QNJ'K SN'K IW=X IEI\QN M"
L
 HSKRLK % W"$ G=IQN M"/A
QNIG Q]V MZNRN %MK$ Z=;N IZENWN Z^E STMZ IUQN% >%N-KN ;R IJ]YN Q(^E@
3WV *^IZHN MZ U-LMN IW3]*R%N( MRKQZ MKRN %NZ G Q31 HZE GE W.IV@
MZ S"RNUK STMZ JG ]I%QNK ZM.GW 
M] Z]VR IGQN 3]HR H^ HRV MZNRK W@
MZ>EVN%K%N%HVNRGNG^H]^7>JG3IGQNLNIVL>ENMN*G%NJNI-QNHN3KZ.IMHSKRM>QN@
V>UZ$IV>HIRVHIM1RNVTVN%NZZ>I%]GRZRN
GWNJRZ$HR>'NZHMENNHE>UZ$HSKR%NZ;RNN@
XNR
$>U
$Z$MZJ>HNR"$H^HHM"$MZMER
MKRZNI%HZ
VKSR$LUX>UVN<ER@

7>JR
HV SN'K V
$ I=; M" IH HSKR JTZ3WR MK QIW%N3K JTZNVZN M" I-M
QLR
AQZR M" I-MK JTZNVZN XNR. >=U. IW=X W"$ QNIV(K R^J IW=X H>0 Z$ G
E-K I- ]NR IW=X QNH QNJ'N IV*UVK GN ZNRU IG]G M%

118

J^ R % ] V  GK JIMXN'

J^R% ]V GK JIMXN'#


JIW=VR GUT](. V
$ J^R' ]V GK JIMXN'
W G . UKVN LK QNIG JIW= V R GUT ] ( . IW= X  JT Z N' IZEGN M"  IH
LGALG ;RZ GK MN%K M> ] G K M"  V(N Q;RZ GK WIR;K M> ] G K M"  V(N
WTVZN% G %HEK ]V ZM]V QV U>R^Q. G>QNRN *UVK ZNRU G WR^J
%]^ IWUN9 IG=VN IUQN M>]GN M" IFR JTZ3WR QNJ QNH L. QNJ' JRZ
IUQN%K ] V  %] ^  * L H  = X   IUQN% G  G> Q NRN ;RZ GK J> % R (NJ%N
HRGN M"   7> M  *UVK ZNRU %] ^  3NVR. G  Q%>  NR Z0N7> $ GN M" 
7>GK JIMXN' M>]GK M" IH WRVZN% G ;RZ U>R^ 7>G IWR
; IW=X \94
M
H   RNLN V  JT L N %] ^  U] > Z RNM HRH  7>  G  7> a JR Q= I VQNXNR HRWN7> $ G
M% HSKR NIMS LK QNJ'K SN'K IW= X  HIM] G   M% IH/A
L
 ZZ]VV7>JG3IGT9NW" SVNW WNH ]U*KRN9S9NW"
NS]VZM]V%HKHR'K;RZGNZ"$V
  WR'K@
HSKR NIMS QNJ'  IJQNR  I33 ;RZGN %] ^  SN'K IW= X  I-M
Z0N RM M% IH L
 ZRN ]V IV *UVK ZNRU %]^ G=UN 7>G %NE *
] V  QV  ZM] V  0U9N HR'U   I-M 7>  GK JIMXN' M
W  U K
G^RK JIMXN' 7>M ]V * ;RZ UT](. GN J^R' LN'HNR M>]GN M"
JT Z N' IVU> R ^  URKSGN LK GK SN'K IW= X /A
IVU>R^HE=6'HM^]Z;^RS"%IW%
GXNRWG613NVRHMQP4NR.S
;@

IVU> R ^  URKSGN LK ZMNRNL QNJ'K SN'K IW= X  J^ R ' ] V  GK


JIMXN' G=   RM  M% IH 7> M  XNR
$  W G . 6  3NVR. QP4 N R. J> R N'.
QNIG * UT](. GN J^R' LN'HNR M
WUN QR(NV 7>GN NR H=<H G=
UN L> R W G  QI;QN-   Z] V R  IW= X  IEI\QN M"  IH W G . G
Q;^R WNH. QR(NV ]HIVH 3SG. W I-=H X(N-K 3E
H. %]^ J^RN HRH
IWVNR %NE G=UN V IV]% Z$ GK J^LN G=UN WR J^R' JTZNVZN
GK J^ L N G> I JMR %] ^  IW3W G  G W VNW. GN IVHNR V  ] I ;QN QNRVK
QE=U V
$ G=UN 7>M LUV GN 7>JHNRH ]V M>]GN M"
L> R W G  QI;QN-   Z] V R 
];K6G/AQR;GIRVX"M7>H(N%NZR^JZJG"MQNJ%
IVI%IWGM
JT'W"M 3N3VRN'NZ R^JZ JN 
ZM QNJV@@
Q%>WNG/AL
 ]V QR;G IRVX"M  WG. G QR; WNH. QR(NV ]HIVH
3SG.%]^ J^R%HRH I%IWGM QJ^RVKHRGNM" JG"M E
HG X( *NU.%]^
QR(NVQ]I3HWNH.%]^ 7>H(N%Z V
VR.G R^JZ R^JIW=X QNJ%
IV JTNJV
HRGN M" QR(NV Q]I3H IWWR% J^R' R^J %NE Z0GN M" V Z0N7$GN M"
3N3VRN'NZ ILW$3N3VR.%]^ XEN7>'NLN%'WNEN7>%4.%]^ R^JZ J^R%R^J
IW=XJT
UHRGNM"Q"J^R%]V JT'W"M Q$HNR
$QR(NVQZAVVAVZ]VR.
%]^ J^R%R^JIW=XZ0WZ0NH JN G>=;AJN'K6N'GNM" QR(NVJN'K
RIMVG>=;L"NVVWIUQN%JTGN%HRGNM"ILV
$ 
ZM QZRJ>R3QR(NV
QIW%N3KJTZNVZ.%]^ QNJV JTNJVHRGNM"7>MJ^R%]VWG%]^ LN'%

IUQN% U] U N

119

WNENIHMNIUQNM"
*NWQR(/AV=VWGR3K ]V 7>M M]>GN M" L
 WG. G ]HIVH 3SG. %^]
J^ R ' IWVNR %NE WR'% HRGN M"  ILV
$  J^ R ' JT Z NVZN GK JT N JVK
M>]GK M" 7>M WG G LN%' WNEN IHMN L.GN M"
L>RWGQI;QN- Z]VR
3];K6G/AQI3W*NZJTNVMW%ZI-]GT'-G]TZZN;I%GR%Z
W"3WG"WZ RWVN IVTVKZ QNJVZ W%Z@@
Q%>WNG/A7>MJ^R%]VIV]%Z$GKN;%NG=GNM" QI3W*NZ ^RL
G7>G"AQVV
$S'I-HIG%GQN;NRV
$ I-]GT' JT(Z3T3PVN%NERWG
W.G ZNIEHJ^R%JTZNVZ.GK JTNVMW%Z J^LNV.JTNVHNEHR%G E-K
HIM]GNM"L
 -$%GTZ J^R%JTZNVZ.GE-KM>]GKM"G^RK Z;IG]%Z IG%
G Z=; IW=X HR% %]^ HIM]GN M L
 W"3WG"WZ  NR GWVNW. G IVHNR %NE
]S]I;V RWVN Q]IZTVSN'KG>QNRNN;%NHR%%]^HIM]GNM"QV VTVKZ
VKRK W%Z J^LN3NZ%]^ QNJVZ JTNJVHRGNM"QR(NVL
IV]%
$Z$GK
N;%.I*]%AHR%%]^ HIM]GNM" 7>MLUVGN7>JHNRH]VM"
*NWQR(/AIL J^ R ' ] V  G  IW3  IW= X  Z] V R IW= X  IHMN M"  7> M
IG% IW=X IV]% WNR JTNVM IG% G Z=;AV(N 3NZ %^]  N;%N HR% %]^
HIM]GN M" WR V. J^R' JTZNVZN GK J^LN Z=;M %]^ RW GWVNW. %^]
IVHNR G E-K QV 3NZ %]^ ]I;QN QNRVK QNIG %]^ Q]IZTVSN'K G %NE
HR% %] ^  HIM] G N M"  7> M  RW ]  NR G  7> J HNR HR% WNEN M> ] G N M" 
L> R W G  QI;QN-   Z] V R 
];K6G/AWTV%GKH3NZQNJ%
IVGKH3NQNJ%
IVGIH3'NZ
GIH3'N3T;GNZQNJ%
IV3T;GNVZQNJV@@
Q%>WNG/A WTV% G>WR%
GNWRVR=\'%NEQR(NV*]U3RNSZN
QVV]SNH^QNIGGW%%NE]ZR=\'WNENN;H GKH3NZ J^R']VV
$
GKH3N%]^ QNJ%
IV JTNJVM>]GNM" QR(NV7>MJ^R%]VGNI33S'GNM"
GKH3N J^R%]VGKIH3VI33%NE GIH3'NZ GN%%]^ QNJ%
IV JTNJV
M>]GNM"QR(NV]V7>V
$GN%E"$GNM"L
7>V
$%NZE"E"$GNM"I-JTHNR
IW;KW=V GIH3'N  U>R^GW G>QNRN G= Q%>NR L
 GN%AGIH3'N %NE ;RZ
HRGNM"7>V
$ 3T;GNZ 3R;N%]^ QNJ%
IV JTNJVM>]GNM" 3T;GN 3R;N%NE
*UVKHR%%NE VZ GNRIM'WNE >=\WJTZNVZ.QR(NVQIW%N3K
JTZNVZ.%]^ QNJV JTNJVM>]GNM"
*NWQR(/AJ^ R ' ] V  7>  K IWQHVK %] ^  I33 S'N7> $ GN M"  L

GNXNRK RM UEV JGNR(. GK WRV


 QV %3KEK WV^Q. GN W% %N
HR% GN QWN3% IG]GN M" J^R' ]V 7>K V
$ GN% %]^ UTIM' HRGN M"
L
 7>GN I33 S' L.GN M" IFR U>R^GW V
$ %NZ JTNJV HRH IFR GN%
IG] G N M"  7>   %NE 3R;N W= ; GK M"   3R;N %NE IV*UVK HR% %NE
QIW%N3K JTZNVZN GK JTNJVK M>]GK M" QR(NV J^R' Z
H3 M]>GN M" J^R'
] V  I*I\QN QV  X] G . Z] U GN %MK$ IFR U N
HRKSU>R^ IS%ZNENFRV U>R^ IS%GV GN%

120

J^ R % ] V  GK JIMXN'

U>R^ IS%G
%
$I%3FEM" J^6
 WGJ>RN'@
 VKRK JIMXN' IV] %  JT H NR G  Z] V R. %NZ  %] ^  IV] %  WNR IW= X
7>JG3 HRUN ILGN WR'% HSKR NUR UT]( JT3P %]+ S
; NUR
IW=X IZEGN M" W UKVN LK G QI;+ %]+  E
H  W NZWG ]I\QN
%]+  IW=X IZEGN M"
HSKR NUR IW= X  QZR Z^ E  S
;  NUR JT 3 P  A
VSHSKRQHMW EK%MNIUQN%*GHEHMGK%MN@
;RZGNZ"$HM
 ISXNRKILIMV I%SM" S]NRK@
JT(ZIMI3M
- L
 QN-KVNHM"$JN%GM> V>Z*N-K@@
LSG\M> V>ZIGT9VNIUQN%NVNHM"$HM> 3SGJTWN%N@@
3SGZ.IMLSI%3XQNW"VNHM"$IUQN%QUN;>%NW"@@
G> S NRN IFR Z0NI0QN M"  A
SNEH Z LNHR M" IUQN%N VN
$ HMM> WX% JTWN%N@@
LNH
 ^\3ZIUQN%M" *N-KVNH
 ZR%GM> E\N-K@@
IUQN%UZLNH
 J>I%M
-KNR3SGLNH
 HM
-K@@
LN H
 M
- IGW IUQN% JTW3N VNH
 HM V=VW IUQN% 7>JG3N@@
7> J R
H V SN'K V
$  J= 3 1 M"  IH HI9MNR U> R ^  J^ R ' ] V  IV] %
I(VK IW=X NR%NZ V=H JTGN% HRGN M" V X(K I(VK IW=X NR3SG
JT G N% HR%N M> ] G N M"   IH7> $ IH HSKR NUR IW= X  JT Z N' SNG IW= X  G
I\QN K JT ] V ^  7> J G 3  IW;K JIME. MK J^ L  GNGN U> R ^ G  W  V  JT Z  3 WR
HSKR NIMS LK % NY J^L U>R^ GW %]^ JTGN% HR IG=VK K L
 N%]^
3>R^ V
$ MK IV]% WNR IW=X %NZGN% GK GKH3N HRG QN RM M%
NY U>R^GW RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL JT(ZWNR IW=X 3TK U'3 LK 3TK
STMZN IWVRK LK 3TK E=6ZK$ IW3'^ LK 3TK 3]HR JNRWVK LK W ZNVN
3R.WNEK GN %NZ LNJ IG]G M% IL%4. GN WN NY ZN%W RKR IW=X
S' X=HR. IW=X M]>GN M" Z^EN;NR X=HR IW=X U'3 LK GN WN >QNG
X= H R IW= X  ST M ZNANIWVRK LK GN WN %N*K X= H R IW= X  E= 6 ZK$AIW3'^
LK GN WN IMRG  X= H R IW= X  3] H RAJNRWVK GN WN H] P  X= H R IW= X
3 R .WNEK ZNVN WN3 M"  QV  I-%4 .  * G W KAG W VN8$ G  QNIGAQ%NIG
%NZ Z] V R M> ] G   M% IL%4 .  GN WRVZN% G  U> R ^ Q . %] ^  IUQN% %MK$ M" 
I-%4. Z]VR. G LNJ %NE I-M J]L
$ X=HR \>=E4 L.G M% I-%4. X=HR. G
\>=E4' G SNQG ZN%W *UVK G ENI-H S'GN M" IVU>R^ URKSGN LK
QNJ'K SN'K IW= X  JT Z N' IG] G   M% IH/A
J.X%NZU>0UNI-VRKQNVZV=VWLUN7>8ZIHIEQZMIRQZ3TKQZ
M]
I;QN7>@

*NWQR(/AJ]L %NZ L
 U>0 UNI-VRK M" I-GN LNJ HRH QNVZN
%]^ LNIUTV HR
 G^RK WNR IW=X G
 Q=\R GN LNJ IG]G M% IL IW=X
I-=H 8Z QV G^RN V=V L
 U>JV M" 7>JG3K %]^ G=IQN L.GN M"  IL
%^] >Q. %NE LNJ HKVN LNGN M" VKLK WNR IW=X NR%NZ IG]G M% L

IH J^R' R^J %NE U>JV M"

IUQN% U] U N

IV]% WNR IW=X %NZ LNJ GN JTZN'/A

121

QI;QN-  GN E


H %] 
8Z VV V I-VK I%RG 3 M ST M Z'MIVT I WI;MZT V M
STMZ'M V% WGNM X UNM X IWIMVNM J^RN@@
Q%> W NG/A 8Z  ST M Z GN VV  ] H  I VH Z] V R JRST M Z GN V
J^R% STMZ GN I-VK  I-VR4. I-M IVIWI;M  IV]% JTHNR G STMZ'M
J^R% JTZNVZ. G %NZ >ZR% I%TG3M  3]HV IZTVM  IHMN M" X  V
J^RN  I3T31K G QNIGHNE IW=X STMZ'NM  IWGWN%
$ % G=IQN IH V
%  7> J^R% JTZNVZ. WGNM WG X  QV UNM  =U QNIG IWIMVNM
RX 
] I \QN %] +   NZW G  7> V NIXHR QI;/ \] Y  %] +  E
H  %] + 
] V  RNZJNE GN G> Q NRN *N3NA*N3
Z%KI3I*MJWV J^WTMHIWR%TI*TVMJIRH
3.QI3GV
IRV%NZL%]%Z;^ H3RRI%]%GTWN]^ \NWR;%@@
Z%KI3I*MAJWVAJ^WTMAHIWRA%RI*MAVMAJIRAH
3N%AQI3GV
AIVRAVA%NZAL%%AZ;^AH3R%MA%AI-]GRAWN^ZA\NAWR;%
3SGQR(/A J^WRM %NV%QR(NVQIW%N3K HIWR%RI*M HSKR
JTZ3WR ZN%WR^J ;NR% HRH QR(NV U>R^ R^J IW=X JTU1 M
H Z%KI3I*M
IMRG V
$ XNM>' WNE 3R;N %NE *UVK HR% WNE *UVQNVZ. %]^ IVR  VK%
%NZ Z]VRQR(NV%NZ7>JG3GH JWV JIW=VRHRH L%% L%ZW
H3R%M IZTV^ V
$ % RIMVHRGNM" V V 7>G WN^Z JTN'QR(NV
LKW%A>W..%]^ L
 ]HNRWIU'VKG JN- M>]G M%%]^ H
3N% QNJ% *]YNR
%NE ]I\QN  IZ=VRVN G QN;NR 7>aV JIR  J^R% R^J IW=X WR;%
W;N7>$GNM" VM ILHNR%%NE I-]GTG JTZ3WRG Z;^ WNVIWH
QN%]G%]^ QI3GV QNJ' QN3KRWNGJTNG%NEJTNJVHRWN7>$GNM"
*NWQR(/AI- Z]VR IW=X J=31 HKVN M" IH J^R'JTZNVZN HIWR
QR(NV HSKR Z%>=\K RKR IW=X U>R^ R^J IW=X JTU1 M
H JT*^ JTZKQ. %]^
IV]% %NZ GN LNJ GH =XK *UVK JTNJV HRN7>$GN M" V 7> IZ=VR *UV
%]^ JIW=VR HRH QNJ' QN3KRWNG %NE J^R' JTZNVZN GK JTNJVK HRH
J^R' >=\ JTNJV HRN7>$GN M" N;H GK 7>ZR W;N7>$GN M" I-MK JTZN'
UKVN QI;/ E
H  IW=X M" IH 8ZAV;VAV -KVK I%TG3M STMZ'M
IVRIW; ZTVM *NWQR( M" IH
IH J^R' JTZNVZN %]^ JTNJV HR% GN 8Z 
V=V   V   I-M Z]VR LNJ IZR% HR% GN I%RG3 M" I- %NZ
%] ^  V= V WGR3K ] V  V
$  JT N JV HR
  V= V WGR3K ] V  G  IW3  IW= X  UKVN
QI;+  E
H %]+  IW=X IHMN M" V UKVN QI;+ %]+  E
H %]+  W
 IW=X V=VWGR3K ]V GK JIMXN' G=K V IHMN M" IH V=VWGR3K ]V
V
$ V=VWIUQN% LN'H 7>G IJ=6
$ 7> JRZJG JTZ3WR GK \
L HR%K
XNMKGK M" IL=( LN' G IJ=6$
 N;H Z>9H ]NR IW=X %MK$ QN7>$G QR(NV
J^R' Z>HV M
 L.G M% 7>K J^R' JTZNVZN V
$ ]NR GK RX%N M
-K M"

122

J^ R % ] V  GK JIMXN'

IW3 3 /A7> J R
H V IWWR' V
$  3J= 3 1 M
I -QN IH JIW= V R XNR
$  W G
WK UWNM M% IH J^ R ' JT Z NVZN MK J^ L N G  
U  M"   7>  GN WNVIWH
%NZ HIWRGW HSKR JTZ3WR  M" V IV]% Z]VR G %NZ GN LNJ HR%
%NE MK J^R' Z
H3 M>]GN M"
;RZGN LK %] ^  V. JT Z  3 WR HSKR NIMS LK %  NR 3SG G '  V
$
Z%4. HR IG=VN K V IHMN K IH L NR 3SG IHK HNE G G^V G M=(
J" IUQN V. IWXEK JK94K WNE M] JNR %MK$ M
 JN7>'U ILW$ HE>=U
G QNR]* IW=X JT(Z JK94K WNE *UV QI=I\QV % V(N HE>=U G Q]V
IW=X Q]IVZ JK94K WNE *UV QIHTV['K M
 LN'U V(N M>' WRVZN% ]%
 V
$ *NRV >V]VR M
' G IJ=6
$ IWXEK JK94K QNR]* M
-K M" ]%
IW= X  IVU> R ^  RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL %^ ]  * I LQN M"   M> '  RW
*UVL% I= I \QV M% 3NVR QNJ'  H
E  IW;ZN% M% M> '  I-M
IVZNRU IV N;%. J^R ]NR IW=X F"EUN V(N %HEK U>R^ V(N ]V
ZM] V  E= > H G  IFR'U 
I- E-K HSKRNUR LKW ;RZ S
;  S
;  NUR JT 3 P 7> a V / A
;RZGNV
IMEN\G>MN-KNR3SGHMK$SNMR%MK$LN-K
NR3SGSNMRL
 JIRM"$ISXEKJK94KM]%MK$VIRM"$
J>  VH ;%K ;RZGN LKW% GR3% - W Z W] 3  JT K X" #  G  JT 3 P
 V IEI\QN M" IH  WK$ JK94K %]^ U=GK %MK$ IZEK IL ZM]V LK GN
%NZ ;KRL %NZ NIMS# HWR;N IW= X  RIM] G N K 7>  G  SNQG W.
ZM]V 7>UT %NZ NIMS % GNZN\9N IW=X U=GK GK (NJ%N HKVK V(N
V(N W"$
MK ZM]V S' S"PN I- V
$ JIME. GNZN\9N IW=X U=GK %MK$ K I-V
$
J= 3 1 M"  IH J^ R   IW3W IW= X  IVU> R ^  RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL G  I-ENWN
WNVIWH *UVK ZNRU %MK$ M" ]V RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL QNJ' JTWX%.
IW=X WNRA HIM]G M% IH RW JT*^ JTZ
 K 3T;NE^Q. %]^ JTN(%. M" IH Z"%]^ JT*^
GN *ILQN M
I-QN GN LN'H QNJ'N HIEQN' HRWN7>
I-M]NRZ0GN%NMK$HIM]GN3NZG>JMR %]^
URKSGNI-MWHVLNVM"R
W
U I-JIMR %]^@
W $  J] (  URKSGN J] (   W. J] (  IEI\QN M"  HSKR NUR
HSKR XIR= V R S
;  JT 3 P  7> a V  G  IW3  IW= X  HSKR NUR HSKR
SN'K JT 3 P %] + A V  SN'K IE\K M"  IH/A
]ZWVVRN" JXM=VRM
-KVNIG%JTZJTH1$LU
-K
N\KMZNRKE LKWZ0NWQ]\L%ZP
R%MK$JNW
SNR4W$J](JTU1M" SN'K3SGMZNR HKI%R' PN'K
QI(R[RHNZRZ%NJNW"$ SNR4.J](MZMKH
 I;QNW"
SNRW$J](MZMKXEQNW"$SJ](ZI1-HMKJ](XENW$
;RZGNZ
RKEN\G>MN-KNR3SGSNMR%MK$LN-K
NR3SGSNMRL
 JRMKISXEKJK94KM]%MK$VRMK$
VVKQRSIUQN%MZ*N\NNR3SGU>JVMZRN\N
Z^EIUQN%VSV=H6>JN-KLSEUGWNG3J](IZ1LN-K

IUQN% U] U N

123

I-=( HSKR NIMS LK QNJ' I33 ;RZGN LK %]^ Z0N7>$G M% IH
] W V  IW= X  Z R   IUQN% GN JT X NR M
W  U N L
  W. J] (  M
W  U N
SNR4W$ J]( IW=X ZRK SN'K JTU1 M
WUK JT]V^ MK *UVK ZNRU %MK$ M
W
UN IFR  W$ J]( IW=X Z"$ MK XEH QNWUN QV * J]( IZ
1NH IR_
IZ1NH
I-= H  J] (  XEN- $ U  JR ;RZGN V" % ] ^  E= \   U ] ;  M"  IH I-M NR 3SG
IH H>JNVR %]^ ZV G G'N %MK$ V. IWXEK JK94K G M] JNR %MK$ M

H'UI-E-K LG V=H SNR4. J]( IZ


1NH I-=H J]( %MK$ X=EUN VG V=H
IZ1NH
Z" $  I-M Z^ E  IUQN% 6> J NH  R= \ ^ ] U N
]V URKSGN LK ZMNRNL GK SN'K G %NZ GN ZM=VW/A

% N Z  Q* " J G  7 > $ X N   ] V
  % N Z  Q* " J G  7 > $ X N 
R N Z  G > M N - K  N X  H M V  M ] ^    V U > R ^     J> 6 N 
HM" HSKR J^R3 SIRQNZ URKSGN -H %HN %NZ@
%NZ I%R]L% %KHN ]V
$  %NZ I%R]L% %KHN@
VKR( WRV (
(R ENU  L=J VJ ]Z FKHN
UL V>RH JNEHK QR(N %NZ IS%N S G.% IWQR(N
HSKR %NZ UM 
 ]V >LN%N %NZ IS%N LU 7>R0N%N
VNIM %N LN%  ]NRN %NZ IS%N S LZ H XNRN@

]V %N%H NIMS LK GK SN'K IW=X %NZ GN ZM=VW/A

%N%H %NZ X94 G K HEN V R   *N'  RS= V  GN *EN


%N%H G> I \QN S ]  NR > I \QN 
-   %NZ QN;NR@
LNJVNJIUQN%SI;QN%313NVRIZRVIWQN\N%
L
UQI*QNHRZ;RZSIHTQNUEIVQNUW'Z=;IFIRQN
Q%H JTHNR IH- SM>V V%N GN% J>]% M
Z SM> RV%N
3K3 H1N-  M
Z "  HR RNIV WRV % Z  HR  SM>  *.IV@
%MKV>EQRNZ%NZIWXNR%N%HU>RZ>\
= %NZLIJ-I-=HSNR@

     JRZ J^LN 
U HSKR NIMS HIWRGW  LK GK Q]IZTVSN'K

]V
 3SG-K 3SG S\N%N@1H@3SG _. FN S H
-K 3SG %MK$
JIMXN%N@JT(ZIM] STMZW] I-=6NV J.X
 3SG7>XNRN@
M]I%R]L%R]RHNR
3HVKQ
RQ
H.RN@J.X
V=VWJTIHTVKVK%
$U>'7>JLNI-QNE
HGKJXNR
$\N%
XRNKE=\S%NI-QN@3SG-KHNEHE]GRHIM-3SG-K*RZ*>ENI-QN@J.X
3SGHKQN3NZ$RWZ^EU]WNI-QN@3SG-KSTMZJTHN3Z1H S"P Z>]G
G>WNRN3SG-KI%RU>'3SG-KRU>'3SG-KWGJ>HNRN@3>;STMZHNI-QN
H*KVRS"PHR(N%NIUQN%K
UKJ]IYVQ
RI=;3SGZ$7>R0N%N@J.X-K
3SGJ.XM" Z>GRNHNI-QNSKXIPHN%NL
 ILM]HQNRN;%HRVN
 IVIM
HRVS\N%N@3SGI%R]L%X.XRKZ>GRNM"%"%%HZNMK$VNH
LN%U
R\
UK
ZM.VLV=JZ.MK@3SGQ
H.R*>XRKZ>GRNIVTH>1KM"(N%NIWQNGWVNIM
JIMXN%NX.G^RIVIMLN%N@
M] 3SGQU
XRKZ>GRN*WRU>_N(N%.
3>HGW Z>%K VNIM JIMXN'N >' Q'MG H
 HN%N@3SG R]RHNR \XRK Z>GRN
GW$GWNRIPHN%NSTMZ.IW3'^ZM3QNIGE
R]RHNRJIMXN%N@3HVK3SG
I;QN%7>%Z>%KZ>GRNS QNHN3%MKI0EIZEI0EIZEL
VIG\NW LN%

124

J^ R % ] V  GK JIMXN'

L%HIWGMK@J.XSGJ.XM$"Z>GRN
I%3XHRLN%NQNUJ>R3J>RN%
I%/QH3RIV%HK?SR%NLN%N@% %N(XRNKI=;E
 J.X3SGZ$Q1H
Z>GRNN;RM[1*KVRIFRQ
$;Z\>E1H@J.X3SGJ.XM"Z>GRNE
HGKJ
ZLNENHM"$HSKRQH3RH QNU I%/QH3RHN7I>LQNEN@
L"N IH I- 3SG ]V
 3SG-K 3SG S\N%N IW=X IEI\QN M" IH
NR  ] V  L% 3SG %NZ  GK ZIMZN > ' N7> $ G  M% J^ R ' ST M Z HSKR
NIMS LK %  G= I QN M"  IH 3SG IVJ> R 3 GN WK M"  L
 IVJ> R 3 GN
JTVKH M" V L
VK I%R]L% HNE  GN JTVKH WK 3SG MK M" ILW$ 3SG
L
VK I%R]L% I-M X.XRK Z>GRN %]^ JTNJV HRWN7>$GN M" I-%]^ U
R\ 
UK
% SM>V I,QNGN VJ HRH JTNJV HKVN L
 IH QNZ N;NR'  IWQHVK
G S GK U=E %MK$ M" QV I_R U
R\%N( HNE V=H MK N;%N HRH I=;
S' U- Z>HV %MK$ M
 JN- LG HSKR NIMS % IV%NZ QV NR
%NZ IG=VN VG HNE V
$ 6>=1HNRN U
R\ %N( LK GN M
I-QN I-E-K L
VK
I%R] L % %NZ GN LNJ HR' WNE  HNE LNE V
$  SX %MK$ HG  QR(NV
VE
H  %MK$ LN HG   3SG Q $ HNR 8Z  GN LNJ HR% %NE *] > X RK
Z>GRN GK I(VK IW=X N;H QN L.GN M" L
 IH WG IWQN % N;%N
HKVK QV HNE LNE IW=X MK IRMN 
M] %NZ G LNJ %NE QU
XRK Z>GRN
GK I(VK M
 L.GK M" V HNE G E
H IW=X S'K *]WR U>FN IW=X JM>]X L.G
M% ILGK N;%N >\GW IR3K % HKVK QV IR_ 3TK IW3'^ LK G
E
H  IW= X  S'  WRU V= H  JM] > I XQN 3SG R] R HNR ?" X RK Z> G RN GW $
G> Q NRN > 3 Z'N  V= H  JM] > X  L.G  M% ST M Z. IW3'^  ZM 3  IV] % . %
RR]HNR %]^ MK V Z]% H HNE G LNE IW=X 7>E0 RM 3HVK 3TKQZ
3SG I-M 7>%Z>%K Z>GRN %]^ JTNJV HRWN IG]GN M" IL%]^ RNLN L%H %
JTNJV HKVN JR Z>HVK %MK$ M
-K H-K ]V. % J]L %NZ GK 3HVK GK
LU4N IV%NZ L
9 IG=VN M" L
 IH IV%NZ H
-K LNJ %MK$ M" I-M V.
=X %NZ GK VR_ I-3NRN HRGN M" ILW$ VE
H %]^ =X\]Y WK HIM]G M%
Q" MK IV%NZ QV =XN %NZ M" IRF IV%NZAIV%NZ LNJ HR%
GN %MK$ M" I-%4. J]L 3SG. GK N;%N HR% WNE %$ %N( QV XRNK
I= ;  WK I-%4 .  V= H  KIZV RM  QV  RKR IW= X  [1 IW= X  MK QNWN,
>'H QN%]G E"$G RM QEK VE
H (N% V. RKR IJ]Y  V
$ Q]Y
STIMZ]Y V
$ JNR M" I-E-K IFR ZNVN G UR* IW=X QN- 7>E1 E=1H
 QR(NV L%ZAIZT V ^  GN H31 ZNJV %MK$ M
I -QN L
 *K 7> J E= S ;K
[1  RKR IWX M
WUK 7>M V. HNE STMZ  V=H MK M" IH7>IH J^R'
JTZNVNZN GN I%=L (N% VE
H  V 7>K G RKR GN JTHN3 V. JRSTMZ
QNIG V
$ WK I,QNGN V SM>V Q=U G^R  M" 7>G E-K V. J^R' ]V MK
J^RK N;%N G=UN L
 J]LN %NZ. 3SG.  V
$ QE=U M"
]V
IVU>R^Z
M*NW"L
%%%QE\E\NW"@
<
EVI<U%NS
EVISR"V7>JG3IGT9NW"@
Q.\%NZ^]GHN%%NR^]G"$%NQ%MG7>R0NW"
JTN'J]>LIHTQNW
$I%QNRNMLZN;KSVNW"@

IUQN% U] U N

125

[1 RNZNI-' G RXNI-VN QNGR'K-$ V>EKGN NIMS LK MN(R


WNE  W" $  HIM] G   M% IH/A [1 RNZNI-' JT ( Z *NU JT 3 P %] +   
J . X
 % N Z  HN E  H  L N %   V S  G N % K  Z %   ] H N  QN %  
> R IV I%RV E"  E
H  I;N7^ $  QNIG%NZ E  HNE IURN7^ $ 
IV%NZ E  LKW 7> S NRK Q XE LN7^ $  J^ R 3 GRSNRK@
HSKR H
I1 %NZ ]NR Z$ I-% Z>IHV %N M

NR %NZ Z>IHV HN GNVN WNH
 LN% %N H
-K@

U>R^ %N%H GW LK GK SN'K IW=X IV]% %NZ GN JTZN'/A

J^RN IVU>R^ 
- HMNW" G
- Q=\R HN *G SVNW"
I - = H  6 > 9 N W "  I - = H  E\ N W "   V
 J T N ' K  I % L  [ R  L N W " @
L   J] I Y V  V ^ ]  J I 9 4 Q N   IS % N  G 7 >  Q \ R  G 7 >  % N Z N 
J R ' W V  % N % H  I- = H  E] [ N -    L  H R  = X   Z N W N 
W G  HV S  IZIRV S .V I-% JI9 Z> I HV % M
- K@
I - = H  Q H 3 R  L
 U > R Z > = \  L N J "   I V   H K  I % R Z E  M
- K @

Q%>WNG/ U>R^ %N%H GW LK ZMNRNL QNJ'K SN'K G>QNRN Z0N7>'N
XNM] G   M% IH J^ R N IVU> R ^  7> M K M"  L
 G
 Q= \ R G  LNJ G  SNR  IW= X
LN'GN M" IL IW=X HNE QV ZNI-QN G S];% V
$ 6>1WN7>$GN M" QV
G^RN JTZNVZN %]^ IG\N7>$GN M" QV VKRN L
 I-=H Q=\R M" 7>M JTZNVZ.
%NE IZEN7> $ GN M" 
]V URKSGN LK ZMNRNL HK Q]IZTVSN'K IW=X W. G %NZ GN JTZN' M"/A
URKS WN. JNR * G  MZNRN L
 \
L   
 7> V R  JNRN
 W N  .  JN R N  Q N I G  I% 3 N % K   L
 \
L   
 M  -   G R S N % K 
 W N  N  M K  Z   N R  J G   JG  Z    W N  N  N R 
G Z  G  M K  HN  \
L  HR
  QN W N U Z %  I % W N R @
URKS W. > R IV H  Z= ;  M"   I%QNRN HG  %MK$ M
-  
 I V U > R ^   N H 3 K  * ^ V  H] ^   R N \
  > R I V   Z
-  @
URKS  XNR JGNR( 7> R  Z $  L
W     > R IV I%RIV Z% JW% Z
W  
> R IV I%RIV Z% JW% JGNR( %NZ  HR
 I-H= V R NR
G W N G   Q] G R   Z
-   E    IG E  Q] G R  G K G N R 
H S K R   H M V N  M ^  H I M  L N V  M ^ ]   HM ] ^  S L N  H   <
E 
 W .   L
 \ N E K  L N V  M " $   V K %  E
H  HN  Z
E 
H S K R   ZN E N   W .   7 >  W .   H K   _ R  $ U   I % L  G N  
XRNK *RZ %MK$ H1$ HRZ HK F.@

U> R ^  %N%H G W  LK GK SN'K IW= X  JT Z N'/


N'/A

XM7$>HN]UXM7$>HNZKVLNZXNIRM1NWI%V
Z%JW%H
RN\S]GEMIVTH>1KIVTW"'K];
Q\]YZ]YEZ$>]%ZN%NZ%JW%=X\]YI1HN%N@

J^R' IVU>R^ 7>MK M" L


 IV]% SNR %NZ GW QV W. GK IHTQN G
%NE IZR% GN VRKHN G=     VGK LKW GN Z
H 3 ] * W M"   ILW $
JT Z NVZ. = X  M"   PKH 7>    VR4 .  JT Z NVZ. GN N\3NVHNR QV  Z
H 3

126

J^ R % ] V  GK JIMXN'

JTNJV HR% GN VRKHN WK QNIG Q%NIG QV =X M" L
 HG %MK$ SGEGN
M"   URKSGN LK ZMNRNL QNJ'K SN'K IW= X  HIM] G   M%/A
* U V K  S K L N  J E 1   % M K $   > U  L. M K  Q  ] \ 

-K
IR
RNI\7>
XRNK
%MK$
3]H@
[KN QN- -H
 G3  7>VR -H
 [N1
 Z 0
$  H N  ZN R U  -  H  M "   Z ^ R \  S N R M  S N 1 @
H S K R  * U V K  S K L  J E 1   % M K $   QN %  J 9   S M >  0
E 
L "  H] X %  I S 3 1 N  JR "   [ 1 "  % N  V N H N  Z
E @

SM> V  NR  ZM.J> R 3 = X   %NZ SNR  %MK$ LN'G   7> M  Z%Z> = \ K %NZ
IG]G M% IL%NE %N V. >=\ M>]GN M" QV %N MK Z>HVK M
 HGK M" H
-K
HIM]GN M" VJ MW% =U QNIG HR
 QV H>0 ZM.J>R3 Q=\ H]% QV
Z]^M S]G HRH Q]GR I;QN% EUN7>' GK U=E HIM]G M% L
 IH 7>%4. GK
Z%Z> = \ K N;%N GN JT V KH M"   LGIH HSKR NIMS ] V  URKSGN LK
ZMNRNL U>R^ %N%H GW LK QNIG JRZ ]V. % NRK IHTQNW. %]^ Z%4N
HRH  I-= H  %NZ LNJ HR% E-K MK IHMN M" 
I-= H  %"  VT  G Z %NZH *IW= \  WHVN K ILGKQ. RW *IW= \
SN'KQ. =X M
 RMKQ. M% L
 EU*U   NE JIME. IE\K QV S
EK
U-KQ. K 7>% IHMN M" IH ]%  IW=X I-=H IM]G^ ]V JTU1 M
W
UN QR(NV ]NR IW=X 7>GK XRXN M
WUK 7>DM ]V %N V. Z>EZN%
M
W  U N %N 7> M  I-N-K M
W  U N IR_ IM] G ^  MK M
W  U N 7>  G  G> Q NRN
G=IQN IUQN *UVK ZNRU RW V
$ I*]% V V=(. 7>aV QN;NIRV M
WUN
7>%]^ IUQN% IW=X H
-K JTNIL=V %MK$ HGN ]%  IW=X 7> ]V GK
7>ZR  W  NE G IW=X M
WUK ]V RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL GN L%Z
 V]SR ]%  IW=X M
I-QN L>EN-K ]%  IW=X ]V GK 7>ZR
PKH  NE GK S'GK M" L
 *IW=\WN'K Q%>NR MK M"  7> IM]G^ ]V
G> Q NRN G=    IUQN% %] ^  J^ R N ]  NR IWHNR HR U N 7>   IM] G ^  ] V  GK
QI;QH3VN IW=X RW ]NR IW=X *NRV WR3 GN NR ]NR IW=X 3N3%
M
WUN QV 7> ]V GK QNIUQN %NE RW HNRL M
'U 7>  GK ZIMZN
QNZN%. V
$  7> a JR M
W  U K %"  VT  G Z G> Q NRN G= I QN ] H  V IVH ] V
RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL M% L
 ]%  IW=X IWI\QNV M
- M% *E MK
Q%LN%N % S>RN-K HRH JTI=; HKVN M" JT]V^ ]V IW=X H
-K G
3 %MK$ M"
7> J R
H V V= (  L
 G=    M% I-M * V= V WGR3K ] V  RNZJNE LK
ZMNRNL IW= X  M%

IUQN% U] U N

127

]V %^] VN7>' GK 3LN


QNGR'K- $  URKSGN NIMS LK GN L%Z JNW% IJ] Y  6> 9 N%K
I,E4 N A0= 0 R IW= X  3T K  SERNZ ;%\9 L= 1  G  [R M
I -QN QNJLK WK
HN3K IW=X  NE RIMH ]%  IW=X VE
H XE U- J^R' STMZ
HSKR JT Z  3 WR HIWRG W  VE
H  IR= V ;NZ  V
$  ] %   IW= X
IMRKR QNH IZE % QV QNJLK G LKW %]^ VE
H E" H U- %
IJ=6
$ JIRWNR L%. % URKSGN LK %^] IZTV LN'H IXVN 7>aV R=\ IG=VN
K 7>K Z$ HIWRGW % QNJLK GN LKW WNIJ RKR IW=X JTIW31
HR IG= V N 7>  G  IJ= 6
$  QNGR'K- $  URKSGN LK WK JRZ J^ L 'K- $
HIWRGW HSKR JTZ3WR  GK Q=\K$ G\K ZIMZN L%A %]^ >'N7>' E=U
 L
 WK G>=\K JTN'K QNJLK V
$ 7>JG3 JTNJV HRGN 7>M >=\K M
 L.GN
QNJLK GK W= ; GK ZIMZN QV  V= V WIUQN% G  NMZ'  M
R  U> R ^ Q .
QXNRKQ.  G Q;^R IUQN% GK J
E \>>=E4' %NE QNAJN G NR Q;^R
IUQN% >HV U>R^ QXNRKQ.  QNJLK V
$ QIVQI;=H -KR?N HR% E=U
 QNAJN G  Z= > \ A X
; RKQ. %] ^  7> E 1K J= 1 K J94 N  IG= V K IL V
$
QNAJN G IJ]Y. G QNZ IWQHVK JT*^ HSKR G IJQNR S=X QNGR'K-
$ URKSGN LK %^ ]  I[T ' N HR% E= U  
IG=EK G WN,KGJ>R IJ]Y IW=X QNJGN I-=H I33 K 7> %NE WK
J^ R N IJ] Y  -KR?N HRGN K 7>  GK JT N (%N 7> a V  QNJLK H> 0  IG%
WN,KGJ>R IW=X PIMR 7>K Z$ I1=YK GE % QNAJN G I-ENH IW=X
SN,R GK _E %31 HR IG=VK JT]V^ QNJLK G WH GK _E %]^ H
-K
MN%K %MK$ JM> ] X N-K NR  IJ] Y WNK ] V  URKSGN LK GK ZIMZN V
$
SM> V  JT * NIWV M
-   QV  IUQN% %] ^  IWHNR HRH  QNJ'N QNVZ
HIEQN' HRWNI-QN
QNJLK G QNG3 %NE QNJG *UV % 7> SN,R %]^ J^R IJ]Y IW=X W]Y
IG=VN V URKSGN LK G SNRA Z%4. HR% 7>aV WK H>0 SN,RN S"EU=YK
IW=X R=\ IG=VN V IHMN IH JTVH J^R'ZN3K IW=X QNJ *]YNRN HRG M

H>0 GN% QNJG GN GN WK M
 LNWUN *UV. GK 3R;N %]^ R=\G M
-
QNJLK % WKIHTVK JTGN% HR IG=VK QNGR'K-$ URKSGN LK G XNR
E9H QV G
 H]I%Q. ]VN% R^J IW=X K V(N EU*U  -H9 ,ZK%
G WNZK %  7>K S"EU=YK IW=X S"PH QNJ IJ]Y 6>9N%K %]^ X=E J-
 RNV  IW= X  IJ] Y  HN' $ GN G  H
E  S" E U= Y K JM> ] X G  MK JIME. V
$  MK
> I %
I LV 6I9Q] V R WNR(K U> R ^ Q . QXNRKQ.  %  ] V  URKSGN LK
%]^ [R IEQN NRN SN,RN E=>1 IEQN V 7>K IJ]Y G X;RK 6NL^RNZ
I6=HNRN %]^ ^X%N HR IG=VK IH 7>M IM]G^ ;RZ GN ;T
MK JH9 IEQN M"
X ; RK 6NL^ R NZ G  QNG 3  %N% X J N9 IW= X  S] % 4  IG= V N IUQN X ; RK
6NL^ R NZ LK %] ^  RHNR GK VR_
$  H> 0  HN%] ^ % K QI;HNR JT N JV % 6
ZMK% GK LN J]L 
 R>J- ,>RZN%N V ZMNG
3K %]^ HNP IW=X S]G HR%N

128

]V %^] VN7>' GK 3LN

QNIG 3ZIEV K


7> % 4 .  ;RZ G  QIUQN%K P H  G NR. U> R ^ Q .AQXNRKQ.  G> Q NRN J^ R W
V
$  MK 7> E 1K J= 1 K J94   M
-   X ; RK 6NL^ R NZ I6= H NRN LK %  7>   JRZ
QNGR'K-$ URKSGN LK ZMNRNL %]^ HNP IW=X S]G HR IG=VN HNP IW=X
S] G  HR%N I-= H  JT H NR GK HIP% HNRNUNR GK ,N K G
% 4
$  J" R . G
U
IYQ. V
$ 7>aJR G
 HNP G Z
1 Y]Y S]%4 H G
%4
$ M=(. %]^ IJ=6 S]%4 IG=VN
L.GN K IL HNR% IWQHVK S"P %MK$ HGN K V(N JK9N SM>V M>]GK
K J"R 3>L L.G %  S"EU=YK WNEN ?NEK U=YK E" H IJ]Y WNLKGJ>R
WNIJ XEN IUQN L
 IJ] Y  H' $ GN V
$  EU*U IH+ZK+ G^ R K 7> a V  M" 
^X%N JTNJV M>]G MK WLKGJ>R IJ]Y G H>0 Z>=\ IWQHVK V>R]V HN'$GN
JM]>X U- QV X;RK 6NL^RNZ LK %^] JTN(%N HKVK QV SM>V Z0NI-QN
IH 7>M QNZ IWQHVK %MK$ M" 7>M JRZ 3HVK ]J]% M% QNJ 7>%4.
V
$ ZN_K Z]U E7> X;RK 6NL^RNZ LK SM>V MK %H QNVZN QV SM>V
MK IGQNE^  QV  %RZ IGE GN IWQHVK K JT ] V ^  7> % 4 .  WNR(K QV
JT*^VN G *>=\ U>R^Q. QXNRKQ.  % 7> J>]%QNVZ. 3TK 6NL^RNZ I6=HNRN
LK %]^ 0^PK HMN'K >'NH JT*^ G IJQNR S=X QNGR'K-$ URKSGN LK G
JTVK QIVQI;=H UEN%K J"GN HR IG=VK K IL HNR' X;RK 6NL^RNZ
LK % IS%. HNR' LN' MK ,N 3>R^ HR IG=VK K WNLKGJ>R G *UV.
GK JTN(%. Z]%H QNGR'K-$ URKSGNLK %]^ 6=Y IG=VN IUQN QNGR'K-
$ URKSGN LK ZMNRNL LK % H>0 %MK$ IHMN QV QNJ' IJ]Y 6>9N%K
QN U-   H> 0  IG%. 7> J R] V  X
; RK 6NL^ R NZ LK W R   1= 1 K I_R% _T " 3
M
'  L
M9 VNENS  7>aV U- QV 7>%4. G M=( [
9WNR. % H=1 IG=V
7> Z$ 7>G NMZ' QIGT3 M
 U- I- IGT3 %]^ VNENS 7>aV \94 H-K
IWQHVKQ. %  WK G I \QN SM> V  7> J XNR HRWNI-QN JT ] V ^  M= ( . IW= X
$
GRG QV RHV GN WIM'N S]G %MK$ M
I-QN H-K IG%. V=H S>R VRKH
%NE IXEN7> $ G  RM   IFR I-= H  IWQHVK %  IHMN QNGR'K- $  URKSGN
LK H
E LNH ZN_K Z]U E7> 7>M IGQNE^ M% JIRWNRL% 7> X;RK %]^
[
9   7> a V  ISPNH  6> 9 N%K E"  U-   3T K  6NL^ R NZ %  L.G  MK QNGR'K- $
URKSGN LK G XR%. IW=X IUR IUQN Z>QN_K Z]UK ]V URKSGN
LK %  QN3KRWNG IG= V N QV  %NZ 7> J G 3  IG= V N QV  QNLKW% *UVK
HR% %]^ IHMN X;RK 6NL^RNZ LK % IHMN GNVN Z"%]^ QNJG IW3 IW=X
QIVQI;= H  *RIZV HR R= I \QN K
Z" % ] ^  JVN %MK$ K IH QNJ J^ R % JT Z NVZN QN-  M
  QNGR'K- $
URKSGN LK %  IHMN IH Z" $  J^ R ' JT Z NVZN HSKR NIMS HIWRG W
L>ENM GN *ILQN M
I-QN GN M. 7>%4. GK 3HVK %NE QNJ PKH M
-
M
  Z" $  QNJ%] ^  H
- K 3RNJ %MK$ IG= V N K QNJGN HRZ MK QNJ%] ^
IZIEQN M"   L H R I-= (   %MK$ QN7> $ G  V. QNJG  JIRWNR 7> a V  M
R  WK
JNJ GN JT*NW K M>' 7>M %MK$ RMUN IH7>$IH QNJ% 7>JG3 JTNJV
HR IEQN M"   X ; RK 6NL^ R NZ LK %  QNJ'  NR  JIRWNR %] ^  7> J G 3
GWNI-QN Q= L  WK 7>  K J] > % QNVNZN 6NL^ R NZ G  W] 3 L QNGR'K- $

IUQN% U] U N

129

URKSGN LK GK JT]JRNUV J^LN HRG M% EU*U "$H9 JIRWNR M%
IL%4. %]^ 6NL^WN9N HIM]G M% IH7>IH/AV>
H/A Z% 7> GRUM HN ZME %N G\N
;RZRN-HIVEAHNE\NRNZHMZRN;H
G>\%NGKL
H
-N;G>\N-
Z$" G>\K ZRN QNJN *K G>\K M
-IMR'NH3J 7GR J1  IWGNIRQN Z"$ MK
ZNIRQNH]3L
ZRN;H
VNWWNHN\
G^W]3@N;VNW%H
I1JNJM"
Q%IU%M=IVQNQJRN;]G>RWNNHKHEJHNEJTEQM
 U- NGW@
7>JR
HV SN'K IW=X IVU>R^ URKSGN LK NIMS JTZN' G RM M%
IH JTZ3WR HIM]G M% IH ZR ]V %]^ G>=\K ZV HR%N L
 ZR ]V %]^ G>=\K
HRGN M" Z0
 Z"%]^ G>=\K HRGN M" LG ZR *UV JTIMENG %]^ G>=\K HKVN
VG Z"$ IMR'NH3J GN J1 _NI9QN QV Z"$ MK H]3 %]^ ZNIRQN QV L

Z R   N; %] ^  G> = \ K HR U N Z" $  7>  GN W] 3  IZ


1N G W .UNI-E-K ] V  %] ^
IZ1N
VN7> '  G  HR
9 . JNJ E= U G  M% ILW $  Q%IU'V Q%] V  M= I VQN HR
IG= V KQ. M
'  I-M Q%LN% E
H  JT Z NVZ. G  ] I W;N% %] ^  %MK$ LN'G 
I-E-K I*QN%H *=>E HRG M% QV IFR G]Y G *NUK S'G M% N;^
VN7> '  %^ ]  I%Z% G] Y  IZEGN M" 
L I-=H Z%=>\ G^R Z%=>\ GK IZTV^ HR IG]GN M" V. 7>G QUEN L%Z
M=IVQN HR% %NE J^RN M
 L.GN M" JR ]V %]^ VN7>' GN SM>V W=YN
G] Y  M"  L
 Q%] V  L%Z. IW= X  WK J^ R N %MK$ M] > G N IVU> R ^  QNJ'K SN'K
IW= X  HIM] G   M% IH/A
QT;Z>=\KUT*WNZ$MRGZSNR]SNRL^%K*^VIJ3NXHKLSEUI3T31K]MNR
Q"K UEVK HR% WNE %]^ JTZ3WR I*]% JTN'KQ. GKQ. ,^%KQ. IW=X
SNR]WNR Z. G UR* IW=X JN7>$G M% QR(NV 7>M L%Z E"$G MK SNR]SNR
IZTV^ %]^ JTNJV M
 L.GN M" QV LG V=H I3T31K JTE %MK$ M
 L.GK VG
V=H *^VAIJ3NX GK ^%K QV Z. G UR* IW=X ZM. H31 R=\GN M" L

SM> V  MK G> = \ GN-K M] > G K M"  QV  VG V= H  ZN_K %MK$ IZEGK LG V= H
VNI-QN M
I -QN ] V  MK Z> Q N_ %N HR G W  
I-=H WNR G>RWNN IR3K % QI*ZN% W=3 Q]SRK3 IR3K %]^ ZNR% G
E-K QNJ'K 3HVK %NE I-=H >GR3% X=HR 6=Y IG=VN >GR3% X=HR
Q]SRK3 IR3K G XR% 6^MH WNJ G>RWNN %]^ ZNR% E-K G>RWNN GK
VR_ X=E IJQN G>RWNN IR3K % 
X IEQN IH V]^ SM>V W=YK UEVK HR
IG=VK M" EIH% I,QNGN Z. %N RIM]G G\ G>RWNN >GR3% X=HR G
Q=UA *=L IEQN *=LGNA 3TK STMZ. LK G H
E JM]>IXQN QV S
IEQN
IH *UW%C IHTJN Z"%]^ I- >GR3% X=HR V
$ SXN8 I-V STMZ. LK
S
E IR3K LK I-M ZR S GK U=E %MK$ M" QNJ' IR V
$ SEN 1NE'
E-K QNJ *UWN% 3] H R H
E  LN8 7> M K QNJ%] ^  SXN HG  M% I-M
>'G MK G>RWNN IR3K *UWN% 3]HR G H
E IUQN QV S
IEQN IH M
*UWN%C IHTJN HRH QNJ Z"%]^ I- >GR3% X=HR V
$ SXN8 I- 7>aV
*UWN% I3W %  ST M ZN GK VR4 .  1NEG  M
-   IHMN IH QNJ 3T K  IW3'^
*UWN% G JN LN8 7>MK QNJ%]^ SXN HG M% I-M >'G MK 7>M
*UWN% IW3'^ LK G JN LN H G>RWNN IR3K % IHMN IH M *UWN%C

130

]V %^] VN7>' GK 3LN

QNJ MK Z"%]^ I- 3>GT3% X=HR V


$ SXNQ HG M
 WR%N I-M Z"%]^ H=1H
ZNR G W  U N I-V  *UWN% IW3'^  LK %  IHMN IH M  IR3K LKC I-
3>GR3% X=HR QNJ%]^ IH7>$ ZNR%N XNM]>GN M"G>RWNN IR3K % 7>JR
HV
NRK HMN'K G=K VG IW3'^ LK % IHMN IH M G>RWNN IR3KC L QNJ
7>  K Q] S RK3 G  XR' F9H  ZN_K Z] U
 V. I-M > G R3% X= H R QNJGK
LN% S? HGN M"  %MK$ V. Z" $  HK H
- K WK G W  QNJ%] ^  %MK$ SXNQ
HGN I-GN G^RN H
-K 7>JNQ %MK$ M" ZRGN HK %MK$ HRGN VG
G>RWNN IR3K WNJ LNH Q]SRK3 G XR' F9H R
' E=UN QV IGE V
$
ZN_K Z] U K VG Q] S RK3 IR3K %  7> M  > G R3% X= H R QNJ'  M= (  IW= X
F= 9 H  G> R WNN IR3K %] ^  IG= V N QV  IHMN IH ] V N IR3KQ. G  %NE S
QGSK HG  %MK$ HR%K XNMKGK 7>  GN JT ' NZ SM> V  S> R N M] > G N M" 
3TKIHT3%U>R^ H%KM>-KQ
RSXUNH%#
LG 3TK IHT3% LK G U>R^ G>RWNN L" IR3KQ. GK I-M MNEV M" V.
IFR QNZ QNGZK IHW $  SX HGN M" 

I I

IUQN% U] U N

131

*1IHQN %]^ ZNRU IW3


*UV ZNL JT*^ GK QEK *UVK V
$ H
M. G^R M"#
VE
H  QN3RZ HR $ (N ILE4 N AR
M VH MIRQN'N IW= X  HIWRG W
HSKR JTZ3WR  G JTU1 IGW G 7>JE=H3 IW=X X=E RM J]L IGWK-
 V
$  L^%  V=H  IV]U ZNR
M IW=X *UV S]V I][ "'K
%  QNJ'K HMN'K > ' N-K L
 IHT J N I%Z% J94
/ AA

JT*^ IJQN *UV S]V I][ "'K %]^ ZNRU IZE'N#


Z" $  S] V  I] [  " ' K IJ] Y  U.;RN ILE4 N AR
M VH MIRQN'N GN RIM'
WNEN M. QV  J> R N'N JVN Z+%] +  Q"  +  J.YW %UR %LGKH ZGR
Y Q RK Z> % NJNR IG= E KA IW= X  RIM] G N K NY  JIRWNR 7> a V  Z] %

IH G> = \ . GN JMN9 1> = I 1QN M


I -Q. K IFR WK JT Z NVZ. %] ^  JN7> '  GK
XNMV QV G>=\. GK I%WRVK G E-K ]V. QV ZM]VN G H
E QN7$>G L.G
RIM] G   K JT ] V ^  IHV  WK G> = \ . GN I%WNR% %MK$ M
I -QN QNI\RHNR
I-= H  Z] %  A JT Z ] %   ] V  3T K  QNNRNZ SNJ^  %^ ]  IZE   7>   Z $  SNJ^  LK GK
]UV IG=EK IW=X EU*U I-=H MLNR K ILG HNR' SM>V %LGKH V
$
IZE' GN Z H N IZIEQN QK$ QNJ'  G> = \  QV  JT Z NVZ. JN7> '  GK
LIUQNN 7>%4. G NMZ' R=\K 7>%4. % N%]^  Z]VR 8Z U>R^  MIR
8Z 8Z - $  %ZM 8Z %ZM I3WN 8Z %Z
 *UWV  WN> G  W NQ
MRKQZ RNZN- %ZM QV UNI-VRK Z]VR QNIG  G= IL%4. IW=X
 I-=H
6.1' G E-K IHMN IUQN QV I-=H 
MZ# Z]VR L
 >W. G>QNRN 
#
Q] G R QV  M$# SNMR H= < H  LNJG  E-K IHMN IUQN - H NG3K QV
J^ R %KZN GN WRV 
Z WNR GN WRV QV  Q31ZK GN WRV HR% %] ^
IHMN ILQNGN V
$ ILQNGN IVRS]; JTN'NNZ QV I=;QN% IW=X S"PH
I;QN% EUN7> ' N QV  Q%> 3 PN% HR%N G= I QN QK$ Z] V R IEQN QV
QNJ' G>=\ 7>%4. NMZ' R
- QV G=IQN IH NY VNI-QN LK  NE
JIME. ZR U- K 7>M JTV S' M
- M% 7>% NY G
 *N-KQ. %]^ ZNR
IG= V N Q= P AG=   Z= 0 . ZNR IG= V KQ. J] L A6  U.WN ZNR IG= V KQ. J3^ Q N
GN H
- K WK S= X N I,] G N %MK$ RIM] G N [R G  NR  Z" $ SR ISZNR RIM] G 
M% G>>=\ G HNR' SMNE M% QV H]Z HNR H
-K X=E' %MK$ IG]GN M>'
HIM IRMN M"  IH QNJG  IJVN LK %] ^  E" H   LNW.UN QK$ SNJ^  LK %] ^
JTN(%N HKVK IH N%]^ SXN7> JR 6 ZMK% SNQG 7>M JTV NY IJVN
LK %]^ WK E" IUQN SNJ^ LK % IHMN L
 M
I-QN 7>M V. M
'N MK K J3^
QV ;% GK MN%K QV RKIRH ISZNRK V. JNJ GN *
U M" L
 IH IEI\QN
M
I -QN M> ] G N M"   7> M  V. *
U 'N MK J" $ GN M"   QNJ *UVK HR
  QK$
JT Z NVZN JT N JVK E-K E= U   RM   SNJ^  LK G  Z0N7> '  V
$  SNQG QK$
JTZNVZN JTNJVK E-K J^RK 3R;N %NE E=U U- Z"$ S]V GN  * V
$

132

*1IHQN %] ^  ZNRU IW3

JIMEN 3T K  QNNRNZ SNJ^  QN3RZ IG= E K IW= X   IG% GN Q%> 3 PN%
ZM]V %IR]GR STMZXNRK GK ENM %NE HKVN I- V
$ SNQG  IG%
G  6  Q%> 3 PN% QN3NRNZ SNJ^  QN3RZ J] X  9  RVENZ Z= ;  JT G  3  IW= X
ZM] V  HNHN LK GK G \ R \  IW= X  HKV   7>  G  SNQG G

 Q%> 3 PN%
QN3NRNZ QN3T Z  NSRZVK QIMZGNSNG U> L RNV G  Z %  Z] I GR IW= X
HKV   I-= (   QN3NRNZ SNJ^  LK %NE X] U K VR4 .  U= E  HR% GN Z H N
IZIEQN VG Z"$ SNJ^ LK %]^ J>=I6QN IH SNJ^ LK IL JTZNVZN %]^ JN7>'
G E-K Z"$ QV NRN *UV ZNL E=IUQN M
I-QN M" 7>M JTZNVZ. H
'
M" H"N M" QV IH=( RIM]GN M" G=' GK IHTJN HR

I-M >'H SNJ^ LK % IHMN IH QNJ E=U RM
 * JVN X=E LNWUN QV
G=IQN IH UKVN LK G I-=H QI;QN- GN JNP MR R
L HR%N M" QV HG
ZR GR3%. GK I-=6N M
W V. I-=H IHTQN G=GN M. IH IV]% IG% V=H HZR
IW=X S]G M
 LN7> HZR IW=X S]G M
' V
$ JIME. \N'N JK'N 6=Y IG7> V.
IH SN(R^Z E"1RK% V
$ RIMV M
 LN7> 7>G IV]% IG% V=H H>0 \N'N JK'N
%MK$ M" %N MK SNMR I%HE'N M" HZR IW=X MK RM
 VTN1H HR
 [R
LNH Z"$ I-M IV]% SNR HKVN JR SNJ^ LK G GR3% %MK$ M
- Q%>3PN%
G Z$ LKW% ZV %NE E9H ISZNRK GN NMZ'N HR%N IJQN JR IFR
WK JTZNVZN JN7>' E-K E=IUQN IRMN
V] S R  IW= X  ] V  RNZJNE GN LK ZMNRNL GN IV] U
HNPZ]YK R
MVH IW=X >I'QN IL%4. % V=VWIUQN% G QN;NR 7>aV UKVN
LK %] ^  Z0NI-QN 7>  G  SNQG UKVN LK GN JNP HR% W E   Z% IW= X
QN7>' E=UN IH UKVN IW=X *UWN% HK HIM RM M% QV SNJ^ LK HK G=
RM M% HKV =XZ>X QK$ *UWN% G IWR>=; N;%N V. %MK$ HR RM
 ]V RNZJNE LK G G>QNRN G= UKVN G Q%>WNG %]^ Z0
 V. Q]VR
QNVZN R
'  E= U  L.GK M"  QV  SNJ^  LK %NE IZE H  I-M RW 3] H .W.
J>=6'KQ. XNMKQ. Z"$ SNJ^ LK G H
E UKVN LK E"H IUQN QV UKVN LK
IG\N H  NRK U= E  J> = 6 K JT ] V ^  SNJ^ L K %  IHK 3] H N GN ZN;N% %MK$
HKVN Z" $  SNJ^ L K %] ^  IHMN IH SNJ^ L K L H R QNJ%] ^  JT Z NVZ. SNR  %MK$
JVN V. I-M *UV ZNL %]^ QNJ' H
E IH7>$ 7>E0N RM M
 I-M U=E >'
H Z"%]^ [^R H GI\QN QV S
E V^] HK LN' *UVK G IW3 IW=X Z"$ 7>P
H  R

$ GN M
I -QN QNJ'  [R QN IUQN
JTZNVZ. GK JTNJVK %N M
' QV 7>E0 M
- LKW% %]^ G\G M
- QV
MP R^JK *UVK QV WRVN %]^ HRH RKR SM>V HZL
R M
 IUQN K V(N
ZV %9 IG\' E=U J-K K IFR M
R ]VN RN;NWNZK J]( ;]% ;]%
IVU> R ^   3T K  VJNE LK ZMNRNL 3T K  SNE
U  3 WR LK ZMNRNL IG*
L
V K ST M ZH> Z NRK I%R] H NRK IZ3% L"  U> R ^ G  W  Z(^ R N WNE  QNIG  G
JN *1IHQN JR L
 IUQN% ]V RNZJNE LK JN M" 7>M IH M
R ]V
LN J]( G JN %MK$ M" Z"$ J6VN7>' E=UN IH I- Z$ 3NI-G ;RVK
V H
-K WK ]V QILMN %MK$ M" IL%]^ JTZNVZ. GK JTNJVK M
-K M" QV
L
 G= H IH JTZNVZN IHM
 ILMN M" H
' M" QV IH=( RIM]GN M" I-M
IWXNR HRH  Z" $  SM> V  R
$ GN IRMN ] V . V
$  IW3WN3 7> a P IUQN Z%

IUQN% U] U N

133

IW= X  QN7> '  E= U N IH LG 3T K  QNNRNZ LK L"    JT I = ;  ] V  MK 3N3VR
IW;K IVQNUH  Z%ZN%K J^ L N HRWN RM  M% V. IH ] V V  IW3WN3
HKVN LNW ]V RNZJNE LK IUQN% V. * V
$ W;KQN G= RM M% JR
I-%4 .  JN ILQNGN ] U V %MK$ M"   I-M J^ R ' ] V  IH VR4 .  M
 HG
M% I-M 3]HN Z% IW=X QN-K H>0 IG%. SNQG ]V RNZJNE LK GN
I-=H I33 NY IJ]Y GN IZIEQN ZRK HMN'K >'H 7>% Z"%]^ JTZNVZ.
WR^J ]V RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL G IV]U IW=X G>SNRN E" QNI-QN Z"$
I-=H []1 GN IV]U >I'QN QV IV]U >'% V
$ SNQG R
$GN M
I-QN
ZMNRNL LK %]^ IZIEQN ZMNRNL LK % Z"%]^ K% %NE EN H IHMN IL
]V G H
E QNJ L.G M
 7>M 3N3VR IW;K IVQNU H Z%ZN%K J^LN HR
QV HRWN RM M% ILW$ 7>M * H>0 LN'G M
' HK Z"%]^ XNMKGN M" QV
ZRKQN Z=IQN GN M=E ]V RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL % QNJ' XR%N IW=X
ISPNH  I- VR4 .  HKVN
V=VWGR3K ]V RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL % G=IQN IH JIW=VR UKVN LK
QI;QN-   Z] V R  IW= X  IJ= V R J^ L N QR(NV 3RN; H= < '  Z%4 N  HKV
M% M
R GWK GWVNW. GK J^LN HR% WNE %]^ Z]GS>=;K WNE IEI\QN M"
UKVN QI;QN-   Z] V R  V
$   QV   V
$   V= H  JR 3T K
QNNRNZ LK 3RN;
3RN; ZIMZN# %NZH J>VH IW=X 3RN; H=<' GK 3T31
IW;K G=  G  M% ] V  3T K  QNNRNZ LK G  NSRZVK QIMZGNSNG
QN3RZ V
$  JT H NI3V JIVT H N IR3K JT  NG Q] H A ZNRX  IW= X
IEI\QN M" IH *^V J^L' WNE V IJ=VR J^L' WNE QV M
R GWK GWV.WN
GK J^ L N HR% WNE  HK S%'U   J94
 J= I VT H N G  QUE  Q] H  IW= X ++++++
QUE Q]H GK JNIVTHN IR3K JTNG Q]H  QJT"E  FN  IW=X
IEI\QN M" IH *^V J^L' WNE *^V E
H %]^ JTNJV M
'U QV IJ=VR J^L'
WNE  IJ= V R E
H  %] ^  JT N JV M
' U  QV  3T K  IHT 3 % G  J> L NRK *UWN% 3T K
IHT3% LK G S"H>]P E
H %]^ JTNJV M
'U
IWXNR
/ A T K  QN3NRNZ LK G> Q NRN JT H NI3V 3RN;
3RN; ZIMZ.# %NZH
J>VH IW=X IJ=VR J^L' GK Q=6K IW;K WK IE\K M"
IHTJN 
X
/A H
-K IWQHVK I-M WK HIM IRMN M" IH \^M IW=X IUR'
WNE GK ZV M
 LNWUK IFR QNJ MK \^M IW=X IUR' E-K >0NQ WK G
IRMN M" QV HIM IRMN M" IH \^M IW=X IUR' GK X]UK IW;K Z"$ G=GN
M. IH G
%
$ J"R X>=H H I-HGZ 6E.U EUN IG7> I-M \^M IW=X IUR H
ZR' GK W;KQN IW;K M"   L
 QILMN %MK$ HRGN 7> M  G
3 K M" 
IH 7> M  IWQHVK % H  M"   I-M *^ Z KHN 3T K  QN3NRNZ LK ] V  HIM
RM M% IH I-=H JN V. HIM RM M% IH IJ=VR QV *^V J^L' WNE
*^VE
H QV IJ=VR E
H %]^ JTNJV M
'U IL=( 7>M *>=\ IJQN RIM]G M%
IFR 7>%4. %]^ 3RN; G>QNRN IVTJV HKVN L.GN M"  I-=H M
R IWXNR 
U
IW3 M" IH LG ZNVNAIJVN IL]GN K V. 7>M JTVKIG% [=1 V
$ [=1 G
 SNR
*
L % HRG  K M> '  Z V  V
$  SNQG 7> M  3T K  UKVN LK G  IWR> = ;  N;%N
HRH G>\GN-K *^V QV IJ=VR L>^%K %]^ JTNJV HR X>=H M% M>' I-=H IG%
G RN; %NE 7>M IHW$ IVTJV M
 HG M%  IG% 7>M HK \N'U

134

*1IHQN %] ^  ZNRU IW3

 ILG  E-K ] V  QV  U> R ^  L% G


3 K M"  L
 *
E KA*NEK QNVZ.W. %] ^
U> Z RNM HR RM  M% 3N3VR IUQN% V
$  7> E 1 ] V  MK I- LKW %] ^
3N3VR IW;K RIMV N;%. HRWN H  G> > = \ K 
% KQ. IW= X  JN HGN M" 
3T K  QN3NRNZ LK 3T K  I3W LK GK 7> J N%N GN Z] V R 8Z %ZM
I3WN  QV 3TK IW3'^ LK GN Z]VR 8Z %Z
 *UWV WN>GWNQ  G=G
M% I-V
$  I-ENWN MRK 8Z 8Z U> R ^  QNIG %NZN IW= X
$  H
- K I-= H
Z]VR QNJ'K I-=6N Q%>NR X>' E"' %^] HIM]G M% QV 
MZ %]^ G
 IM=
HRH >WN G>QNRN IRZ% HR%N QNIG Z]VR IG]G M% L
 IH 3N3VR
IW= X  JT Z N' %MK$ M" 
IWXNR HR
A H
-K R
UK ILG J1 IW=X GRG M
W IHK W"G G H
E
I-ENL G E-K JTN(%N HR W"G 7>G Q=U 6 U
EKQ. R=\ G QV HM
VRK ZRLK M" L
 ZRLK GWN-K \N E HK 7>M W"G M
 HGN M"
JIW= V R UKVN LK QI;QN-   Z] V R  IW= X  IHMN M"  IH/A
8ZI-VK-HQH3RZSTMZIWNMR%ZNZQ%>ZR%
MJTNIVVL%GMZMNIVJRZNZUIVZ@@
I-GN3SGQR(/AUKVNS
E'WNENQR(NVHNEIHM
ILMNM" ZNZSTMZ
Z"%]^STMZGNV. I-VK I-M Q
ZQH3RZ 8ZQ
ZI-HQH3RM" IWNMR%
7>XNR% HRH Q%>ZR%  IZR% HR% GN M  L
 N;H VL% GMZ
RKRIVQNU% V=HQR(NVQ]IVZW.V=H JTNIV IZR%N;%NHRGN
M" M 7>MN;HMKZR WNEK JRZNZUIVZ JRZUIV%]^ NIV JTNJVM]G
> NM"
*NWQR( M"  IH 3T K  IHT 3 % LK G  RKR IW= X  JT  V W3 JT W  3  HRH
ST M Z QR(NV M,NR *^ L N WNEN L
V K I%R] L % HNE HIM IRMN M" I H Z R 
STMZ GK N;%N IRF I-=H 8Z %NZ GN LNJ ZV V=H HR% WNEN N;H
%]^ HWE ZR V
$ IZE' WNE EN* JTNJV M
'U M
R H
-K Z]VT ZRK *UVK
GN %MK$ M"  QV  QNJ'K UVK %] ^  WK UKVN QI;QN-   Z] V R  IW= X
Q%>VZNZ QR(NV SM>V [1KQN IHMN M" I-GN JTZN' UKVN QI;QN-
 Z]VR  QV  IW=X IHMN M" IH L
 IV]% WG. IR=UWG L>RWG
QV NZWG  IW=X WRI'V IW;K G>QNRN ZRK N;%N HRGN M" QV M
R
GWVNW. GK J^LN HRGN M" 7>%4. GK L%ZAIZTV^ QV WRUA%RH SI'Q.
RIM]GN M" QV IJ=VR J^L' WNE 3RN; HR% WNE  IJ=VR S' H IJ=VR.
%] ^  JT N JV M> ] G   M% *^ V  J^ L ' WNE  V R 4 W K$ = V R4 W K$ WR3K Q(KQ.
X> = H H  U] U N QNIG IW= X  IHT Q N HRWNH  JT W NM HRWN7> ' N IJ] Y  *R%N
QNIG *^V J^LN M"  *^V S'H *^VE
H XE LN'U IFR IJT(WK 7>aV WK
*1HG  RIM'U   I-M J^ L N QIW;K J^ R WH QIUQN% J^ R WH Z%AZN%K
J^LN M" I-E-K IWQR( M" JTZN' UKVN QI;QN-  Z]VR A
IW3 3 / I-= (   X
(   Q= ( RWW G  GN IWWR' I-E-K %MK$ M"  IH 7>   IW= X
J^ L N IW;K [= 1  QV  I3T 3 1K RX%N ILQNGN M"  I-E-K UKVN QI;QN-
 Z]VR  IW=X IHMN M" IH 7> JTZNVZ. GK 3R' IW=X LN IL %NE
VRK J^R' Z>HVK M
WUK QV JRZ 3.VK QR(NV 3N3WV LU4N QR(NV
VE
H %]^ JTNJV M
WUN QV UKVN QI;QN-  Z]VR  IW=X IHMN M" IH

IUQN% U] U N

135

V= V WGR3K ] V  IZE' 7> a V  7>  G  G=    Q%>  NR 3NVR IW;K Q%>  NR


N;%N HR%K XNMKGK M"   IFR 7>   JRZJG JT Z  3 WR GK \
L  HR%K
XNMKGK M"  IL= (   LN' V
$  SNQG N;H GN HG  L%ZAIZT V ^  %MK$ M> ] G N
QR(NV Q%NIG Z
H 3 JT D N JV M
 L.GN M"   UKVN S
E ' WNEN HNE
QR(NV 6R J>R3ASTMZ HIM IRMN M" IH  Z"$ WK 7>K QNIG J>R3 JTZ
3WR GK 3R' IW= X  M.
]V RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL LK % G=IQN IH M
R NR ]V HIM]G M%
IH JNJ GN *
U  JIME. V
$  IEI\QN M
'  HRH  *
U 'N J" $ GN M"   *UVK
HRG  RIM'N XNMKGN M"   QN7> '  WNEN QUEN LKW% > \ K M
W  U N
IHTJN IWXNR HR
/A IH G J"R IW=X H]YN E=IUQN M
W IL HNR'
7>%]^ SM>V GRG M
 IRMN M" 7> H]Y G H31 G I%WNR% E-K 7>M IH
H
E JTN(%N HR V. 7>V=R IZE IH H]YN V. E=IUQN RIM' G
 L>=VN JN
E7>   Q= U   *IW= \  IW= X  H] Y N %MK$ E= U  U N HK 7> M  IWQHVK MK ENM
G IRMN M" IH7>$IH H]YN E=U J"R IW=X L>=VN JIMI%QN %MK$ LN HGN
JIMEN H]YN I%HE IFR I-M YR %NE L>=VN JW IH Q=U H]YN %N E=U LNW
 PKH I- VR4. J^R' JTZNVZ. % J^R' ]V GK 3R' IW=X QN7>' %NE
JNJ R^ J K H] Y N ZNJV M
 L.GN M"   IFR N;H J^ R ' JT * ^  GK 3NVR
IW;K Q%>NR N;%N R^JK L>=VN I- YR %NE JNWUN IH IFR H
-K JNJ
R^ J K H] Y N H31 %N G W  
NR ]V. % JIW=VR UKVN LK G QI;QN- G QR( GN Q%R( HKVN
M" UKVN QI;QN-  Z]VR A IW=X Q%>VZNZ GN QR( QIV 7>aVZ
HKVN M" QV QI;QN-  Z]VR  IW=X WRL GN QR( QN7>'N HKVN
M"   LGIH Q%> V Z GN QR( QIV[1KQN M> ] G N M"  QV  WRL GN QR(
LN'N M> ] G N M"   V= V WIUQN% GK [N1 %NE QR(NV IUQN% MK% U> R ^ Q .
G  HNR' WK RW *UV ZNL 3NVR IW;K RIMV N;%. HRH  Z%> = \
LKW% IWQR( HR IRMN M" JIW=VR UKVN QI;QN-  Z]VT A 
NR  JIW= V R ;RZ. GK JIW= V RAQNVZ.WN V= V WIUQN% V
$  LN'^  %MK$
M% IL HNR' %HEK U> R ^ Q . ] V . ZM] V . QV  IR3KQ. GN GNQ
E= I UQN M
I -QN M"   IL Z $  JIW= V R *UV ZNL QI;QNVIZH
V= V WIUQN% V
$  JT K IXV M
 LNW U N 7>   Z $  %HEK U> R ^ Q . ] V . QV
QXNRKQ. %] ^  E> H ' E-K LU4 N  %MK$ IZE U K
7>JR
HV =XN-K %]^ Q=\K$ G\H Z"$ QV M
R JIRWNR G Z"$SR ]V
RNZJNE ZMNRNL LK G  XR%. IW= X  E= U   M. J^ R   JIRWNR IW= X  H
- K
SKZNRK %MK$ RMK QV L
 *^V HG JIRWNR G IHK Z"$SR %]^ ZNR IG]G
K IHK J3^ %]^ ZNR IG]G K H]ZA;]G %]^ X=E' %MK$ IG]G K 7>M [R
V
$ MK %MK$ IJ]Y V
$ WK *=L U- QV G^R IR3VGNR. G [R XE U-
M% L
 M>' WK 3TK QN3NRNZ LK G J^LNRK M% 7>a( LN H *^V HIM]G
M% IH S]V G [R V. JTZNVZ. GN I%WN M
 IUQN M" 7>%4. %]^ JTZNVZ.
WR^ J  J^ R % ] V  IZE U-  M% QK$ 7>  G  [R %MK$ LN HG   ] V
RNZJNE LK G  7> J G 3  V
$  SNQG QK$ J^ R K VR4 .  V] G R>  V QV  > = \ K

136

*1IHQN %] ^  ZNRU IW3

LKW% LK RM M. NY JIRWNR QV IR3VGNR. G EU*U G
  Z"SR.
% ]V RNZJNELK V
$ 7>JG3 JTNJV HR IEQN M" L
 JIME. 3TK QN3NRNZ
LK G I33 K ]V RNZJNELK G G>QNRN G= V=VIWIUQN% %]^ Z0H
EU*U G M,NR 3T K  QNNRNZ LK G  I33 WK IVU> R ^  RNZJNE LK
ZMNRNL GK 3R' IW=X QN X>=H M% 7>M WK ZR W.U J3XNVNJ HR RM
M% ZRK *UV ZNL %]^ JTN(%. M" IH IL%]^ JTZNVZ. JN7>' GK V9J
M" VEN3 M" IHTJN JTZNVZ. WR^J ]V RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL G XR'.
IW=X QNH QNJ' LKW% %]^ >=\K S%N7>' QV JTZNVZ. %]^ JTNJV HR'
*UV S] V  GN

QG*> V  HIR3ZN#

J^ L N'K- $  U> R ^ G  W  LK %] ^  G] Y WV JT ' NZ


Z"$ QNJ' JIRWNR GK \>3K QNGTJ^RWH ^IXV HR%N XNM>]GN M. IH
L%WRK  G  3> D R ^  IW= X  QNJG  JT W X%IV] U  VNLJ> R  IJ] Y  G M EK
IW=X 3TK Z>RNRK *UV G I%WN 7>aV X=E IRMN K V. IHK M
R *UVK
GK S1K % ZRK JV%K 3TKZVK ISZEN GWK 6NWEN  %]^ IHMN IH XNXK
LK UW.< G IJ]Y IW=X L
 IV]U X=E IRMN M" L QNJ 7> ZMNRNL LK
V
$  %NZ JT N JV HR E7>  V. QNJGN Q;NR' R
U  RK94  GK M= Y K IW= X
I-=H I-]X GN FNEN  PKH M
 HGN M" V. ZRK JV%K % 7> E9HK %]^
IHMN IH QNE I-] I YQN Z" Y KHE I-]  1KIX7^ 1  QNF IRRX " $ 1R QNF
NI-] IG=EK IW=X ILGN <N-K NE I-ENL X=EH Q_E M
 X=>HN M
W V.
7> I-=H %NZ L. 3SG IW=X IHM9K 3HVK M" L
 ZRN Q;N R

U PKH
M
 LNWUNHNFK GR V=H G
%4. GK SIM XEGK RMK Q]V IW=X ;KR X=EH
7> IV]U IW=X LN' GN I%R'" IEQN IUQN JRZ J^L ]V RNZJNE
LK G JTWX% Q]IZTVSN'K >'H Q=;^RK 6>=1K M
-K *UVK GN VNR J>%R
S]GK69 % L>9 IUQN V <N-K NE G I-ENL V
$ _NI-GN %N JNH HWE
%NZ G IZR% %NE J]L IG%. G Q]GR MK QN; R
U PKH M
 IUQN
I-V
$ J^RW YNH1R. % 7>%^] S"P' V \94N M
' GK ?V Z%NMK HKVK
K L
 Q=L WK 1RK1Z"1 IEJ 7>aV IEI\QN M" 7>M I-=H I-]X G FNE
G Q"HR WK IW=X ZL^G M" * V
$ W=YK Z=IQN ZRK JV%K GK I-M
K IH 7>M S"PH JN?N%N %MK$ HKVN L.GN K V M=(;
' Z$ G=AJ]GR.
IZ]1 R
'N J"$GN K IH7>$IH I,QNGN 0>H' 7>aV I,QNGN GRG M]>GN K
M> '  7> M  JRZ J^ L N IVU> R ^  RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL LK G  QN3KRWNG
%NE  IH=E
 G W,% %]^ QNJ X=>H E"$GK M" V J^R' V]GR>V M" ZRK
NR JNPH. %]^ JTN(%. M" IH JTZ3WR V>E ]V RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL L

HIWRG W  HSKR JT Z  3 WR  LK G  J^ R ' IHT J N JNVR M% V


$  LEGKA
Z> _ V %NZ JT N JV HRH  IM JIRWNR HIEQN' HRWN-  V  J^ R ' Z
H 3
V(N VE
H  3N3WVZ (N%Z  JT N JV HR

QNJGN  W H *UV %= ( ^ R NZ
IJ] Y  6NWEN IG= E K
G^ R *N3 

IUQN% U] U N

137

Q'M
%K HKVK JTZ3WR %#
Z" $  *UV > I R] G R GN IJ] Y  U.;RN VIMKE .JEN ILE4 N  R
M VH
GN I%WNK M. ZRK 7>ZR  NE M" QV SXJ% V
$ MK JTZNVZN GK
\
L IW=X E=IUQN M
I-QN K QV Z%Z>=\K J^LN Z]IGR. IW=X LN'N WRV
QNIG HR%N 3RN; H= < 'N QNIG  WK HRGN K JT ] V ^  RKIRH H31
QV  ZN%IH Q3.VK EUNVNR S'K M
- K K IFR WK JT Z NVZ. IW= X
IW3WN3 QV  JT Z NVZ. JN7> '  GK V9F SRHRNR K I-MK V9F Z" % ] ^
]%  IW=X ]V QN3NRNZ SNJ^ G H
E E" U-K Z"$ 7>%4. V
$ %NZ 7>JG
3 IEQN QV L"N *UVK ZNRU 3.*^ ,K G=IQN Y1H N;%. HKVK JT]V^
%N V. H
-K RKIRH H31 G^R M
I-QN QV %N MK H
-K M
R QI;QNVIZH
7>JES=;K M
-K SEIH H31 W=;GN MK XEN IUQN Z"$ QN3NRZ SNJ^ G
G= Q%>NR N;%. HRGN K ILW$  UTNZ G>=; WR JK$GN K QV
 UTNZ G>=; 3NZ %]^ JK$GN K QV ZR Z]VR IW=X IL]% Q=\R K 7>%
E=\ Z]VR LNJ HR%N QV ZN;K EUN7>'N  IG% GK I-M IHTQN K
L
 IH I-M Q%>3PN% M>]GN K Q"A Z"$  HKV
I-=H WNR Z"$ SNJ^LK GN IV]U >I'QN IH =V IG% V=H I%RQNMNR
RIMH  Z] V R LNJ HR% ZN;K EUN7> '  QV  JT N 'NNZ HR% %NE
-K3WR GK JTNJVK M
WUK IFR Z"$ I-%4. WX%. %^] =X Z]%H QILMN MK
HKVN JT]V^ JTZNVZ. GK JTNJVK GK SLN- *>=\N RIM' G HNR' IZTV^ G
%,GKH JM> > ] X  IUQN QV  JT N 'NNZ HR% %NE IGZNUK ] V > E % IWU9
IUQN QV  JNUE WRUN M
 IUQN
7> Z$ ZR 7>V IVU>R^ J^R' ]V RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL GK IHTJN
IGT 3 1K J-K QV  Z" % ] ^  V] S R  IW= X  U> R ^ G  W  ] V  RNZJNE LK
ZMNRNL V
$  %NZ 7> J G 3  JT N JV M
I -QN 7> J G 3  IZEG  MK Z" % ] ^  QILMN
E= I UQN IH IHK %  GKW  IW= X  [K JN IG= V N M
W   QV  Z R N LKW% 3.V
RIM' E= U N
J^ R ' ] V  JNJ HRZ %] ^  WK ?VZ HR HGN M"  I-GN JT Z N' Z R 
LKW% IW= X  VG [= I 1V M
I -QN LG Z" $  Z-K  IW= X  Q R NU] S NG
ZM.RN31R IW=X ]V RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL G IV]U G E-K 1"$1 GK 
WN HRG M
-  F>=1 7>aJR V
$ %KX J=(RKEK ,ZK% 7>aV IUR IUQN
I-=( HNE %]^ H>0 M
R MK Z]L^R K QV ZRK RK94 GK M=YK 1>=1 U-K QV
ZR RKR G %KX G IM= %]^ Q;R]U ZNR IUQN 7>K Z$ Z"$ QNJ' U>R^
GW LK ]V RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL %]^ NG HKVN ZR U>R^GW GK GN %NE
7> Z$ G
%4
$ J"R PKH H]Z HR% E=U
URKSHNEYRHRVNRL"L"LUGK3LRNLRK0N9VKJURLYNR3K3@
7>V
$ SNQG Z"%]^ QR]UNSNG G I%=LK MJVNE J1WR;% MNIJ1E
IW= X  E"  LNI-QN IUQN 7> a (  YN+ YK+ LK+ J1WR;% %  Z R   RKR LK
L.X HKVK V(N Z R K M= Y K GN Q" H RN HKVN IRJ
R 1 V
$  JVN E= I UQN
IH RK94 GK M=YK 1>=1K M
-K K IRJ
R1 G\H YNH1R SM>V M"RN% M
H

138

*1IHQN %] ^  ZNRU IW3

HIM' E=UN IH QNJGK RK94 GK M=YK 1>=1 U-K M" V(N 7>GN I-=H 1>H9N
1>=1H QE=U M
 IUQN M" YNH1R SNRASNR ZR J"R. %]^ M=( EUNH G
\GN IRMN QV  IHMN IH QNJG  7> a V  JT Z NVZN GK IW3 3  IHT J N M"  IH
QNJG  J" R  PKH H] Z  HR RM  M% IH7> $ IH 7>   IRJ
R 1 G  Q%>  NR
Q;R]U M
'N LR^RK K 7>a( 7> MJVNE IW=X Z"$ IV]% IG% V=H GN\E
IRMN 7>   V
$  SNQG Z" $  6> = 1 K E"  H  WNJ QNJ'  [R MIRQN'N QN
IUQN I-= (   R
M VH IW= X  Z" $  QNJ'N I-ENL M= Y KQ. G  JT I = ;  YNH1R
X=<N V
$ HRWNI-QN YN+ X=<N ZRK IRJ
R1 G\H M"RN% RIM IUQN V(N
IHMN IH QNJ XE IFR IHW $  RM  M
  QNJ %] ^  V. IRJ
R 1 G  Q%>  NR
Q];R]U M
'N XNMKGN M" YN+ X=<N % IFR V
$ R]UK% Q"HR HRWNI-QN
V(N IHMN I-GN I-ENL ]*W %MK$ M" QV QJT3% G %NE MK I- %]^
IL I(VK IW=X M" 7> I(VK IW=X R
IHQN LN HGN M" V. HK M=YK
M
R %N 1>=1 H 7>% M=YKQ. %]^ VNHV G' E-K I-]L"H3% 3>R^ HKV
V(N IV]% ZMK% IW=X J^R I-]L"H3% E=U U- IFR 7> % IHMN IH QJT
3% LR^ R  HRWN7> ' N JW U N %MK$ V. SNHK GK SXK M
- K M= Y  WK 1> = 1
HGK M" V IHMN HK QJT3% GN ?RX G
 E=\ R>J- QNWUN IFR 7>
Z$ YNH1R % G=IQN IH IRJ
R1 G Q%>NR QNJ IV]% ZMK% G Q]GR
ZR LN'N K Q=L QNJ JTZNVZ. GK IHTJN %NE MK IL]GN M
 QJT3% GN
?RX G
 E= \  G '  V
$  Z" $  QZR( K I-E-K Z" $  G^  R  YNH1R H
E
I-ENL E-K IUQN 7>M WK ZRK IRJ
R1 G\H M"RN% M
 IUQN QV IHMN
IH QJT3% IW=X GR M
 U-K V. M=YK 1=>1 HGK M" 7>% WK G=IQN IH
IRJ
R1 G Q%>NR Q;R]U M
'N XNMKGN M" QNJ X=E IFR IHW$ RM M

QNI?RHNR MNRH Z"$ QNJ' U>R^GW ]V RNZJNE LK G XR'. IW=X
JTN(%. HKVK VG ZR J^LN'K-$ U>R^GW % ZR V IGQN HKVK V IR
7> a V  M= (  R= \ H  IHMN IH S 1 N V>  K$ ISEH> E  PKH M
 LN7> U    L H R Q= L
HSKR JT Z  3 WR NIMS LK GK 3R' IW= X  %MK$ M] > G   V. *> U V H  ZR%N
K QNJGK 7>ZR %MK$ K QNJ I-=H WNR IFR YNH1R %]^ IG\N E7>
Z"$ U>R^ LK GK QNIUQN G Q%>NR QUE MK IG% YNH1R %]^ IG\NI-QN
IL% ZRN Q"HR HKVN V Q"HR G\H YNH1R M"RN% RIM IUQN IH
L
 M=YK 1>=1H QE=U M
 U-K K 7>M QNJ' QNJ 7>aJR %]^ 7>aPH IHW$ L>9
U-K YNH1R LK % G=IQN H I- M=YK GK QILMK I(VK K IH ILW
$ H
-K U=YK SM>V ILQNGN <EN' WNEK X94N-K X94 RMK M
W 7>G I-]L'
IW=X ?RNSK M
 LNW 7>M WNJ MK QN HGK M" L. JIME UQR IW=X
JNH J=(R QNIG JMK- G IJ=6 EUNH 7>a( MK R
HK LN HGK M" Q=U
%MK$ X94 HGK QNJGK M=YK I-VR4. 7>aJR %^] X94H L>9 U-K M" L

YNH1RK I-IVMN G SNMR GK U=E M" I-%NE Z"%]^ WK ZIM^ M]>GN M"
IH H
-K 3HVK Q]*W %]^ ]*W HR HGK M" I-M V. QJT3% %NE WK
%MK$ M
 HGN K QJT  3 % HRG  Z $  WK 7> M  IH  JGNR( %NE LU4 N
*RK LN HGK K I_R WK LHR QNJ H
-K WL% X>=H' GN H]Z HRG
V. M= Y K I\H' HNR' QNJ Z] L   7> a V  *> U VH  ZRG   YNH1R G  Z0

IUQN% U] U N

139

IW=X %MK$ QN IRMN K Z"$ IHMN IH J^R' STMZ HSKR NIMS G WR^J
IW=X ZR J^LN U>R^ GW ]V RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL % ZR JNJ HTZ H=1H
ZRK ZV %]^ 1NEH QNJ' H
1 IW=X
$ Z"%]^ %WK$ IL]GUK IG=VK M" JTZ3WR
HSKR NIMS GK SN'K M"  IH/A
L
 ZRK*UVKIJ6
9KM>-KV
 MZRN%NZ%NEW H
-K
M> '  Z" $  ISEH> E  V] G R>  V M. V(N IVU> R ^  G  XR'. IW= X  QNVZ
HIEQN' E-K I%RWNR(  W N HR IRMN M.  IH+ UT N Z WL% Z" $
QNJ' QNJ MK X=>HH XEN L.GN M. NY U>R^GW GN QEK 7>G3 V.
*UVK HRWN H  LKW %] ^  IWHNR. V
$  Z> H V HRWN H  QNJ'  JRZ ;NZ
VE
H E"H LN'N M" I-=( G 6
1AZ
1 >=\ V. U>R^ LK QNJ' ?LN% V
$
G HG M% V. IH LKW *UVK ZNRU IW=X E=IUQN RM Q]V IW=X Z
RK NR  ZNL %] ^  JT N (%. M"  IH NY  U> R ^ G  W  G  XR'. IW= X  QNH  = X K
*UVK HR
 V(N ]  NIRH > = \ . G  %NEA%NE QNVZAHIEQN' GN ZNRU
WK JT N JV HR
  V NIMSCC
IW33/AIR=UWG Z]YE  >HV  Z]VT  IW=X J^R' JTZNVZ.
% IHMN M" IH M 3NVR Q%>H^E N;%N HR% WNE N;H V]^ ]J^R' *NW
%NE Z R K 3R' UT I M' HR QR(NV ]    RIMV M
H   Z R K *UVK HR Z" $
VR QN; R
U WK ZNJV HR GW.UN L VRK 7>ZR WK SNHK %MK$
M" V. Z"$ VRK 7>ZR G >W. %^] WK W;NH 
 NE HR GW.UN 7>JR
HV
H(N JT * ^  GK ZR= ( VN %] ^  JT Z NI'V HRGK M" 
*UV > I R] G R GN
 Z
+  %] +  

JT*^ % >'K URKS. GK#


Z" $  HT Z WKR J> = V R 3T K  [NKRNZ J> = V R 3T K  6
1 ^ R NZ IJ] Y  *RN'
ILE4NAR
MVH GN (N-K I%WNK M. * V
$ JIME. Z"$ V J^R JIRWNR
% ]%  IW=X I%R]HNRK SNSN MRGW I][ LK ZMNRNL LK GN %NZ
IEQN 7> Z$ Z"$ *"'. %^] X^9KQ. X94N7>' GN H]Z HRGN K QNRI(H
I(VK W;KQN K M
E KAM
E K I(VK IWU9GK XEK U-K I_R H> 0
IG%. SNQG Z R K JV%K G  RKR IW= X  VR4 . A GKQ. ISZNRKQ. E= U
U-KQ. 7>%]^ SWNKR GK ISZNRK QV IJ=V GK ("EK IW=X J=(RK K
YNH1R % QJT3% GN \RXN  MLNR R>/G=IQN Z>0 GN G [R IW=X
7> Z$  M,NR GN' WK %MK$ K QV Z"%]^ WK GZ GK ISZNRK K
ZRK JV%K V Z"$ QNJ' G>=\. %]^ NG HRH G>=\K Z% %NE XRXN HRG
M
- I-=H QN1
 IW=X S"P H S= Q=Y LN RM K IH J"N V. M" %MK$ M>'
QJT3% IHW$ M
WUNQK$ V. ZR MK LNW.U 7>K QN1
 IW=X I-=H *"'
S"PK M
-K K 7>% ZRK NRK U=E >'K V IHMN IH QNJ HR$(N XE
LN7>   7> a (  I-= H  ZMNRNL LK M% L
 ISZNRKQ. GK Z> _ V GWN-K IG] G 
M% Z R K JV%K *UV ZVK Z W N G W K AA %] ^  VE
H  QN3RZ
HR$(N IW=X U-K QV S]GK 69 IVU>R^ RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL %]^ QNJ'K

140

*1IHQN %] ^  ZNRU IW3

NRK ISZNRK QV [R GK MNEV G=K IVU>R^ GW % SM>V IJQNR %NE
NRK U=E >'K QV IHMN IH S1K I-=( H
-K GWN-K %MK$ IZEGK HWE
QNVZ HIEQN' GN ZNRU Z0NI-QN L.GN M"  QV  *UVK HR% GK
IW;K JIW= V R W G . QV  JIW= V R UKVN LK G  QN;NR V  3NVRQ%> H ^ E
N;%. G=  K L.GK M"   J^ R ' JT Z NVZ. HSKR NIMS LK GK IHT J N %NE
IR_ Z]VR G LNJ HR% G %NE MK NR H31 G^R M
 L.G M% V Z^E
EN* V. L%ZAZR% V
$ J^R' R^J %NE LKW GN 6=>1HNRN HRWN7>' GN M"
ZNL >;NR V M
R >=\ V. R^][ IW=X QR(NV I%3>EH W"$ MK QN L.G
M% RNZ%NZ GK GWN-K G H   Z R   NR  JIRWNR GN 7> ; NR HKVN M> '
QK$ JT  Z  J^ R WH IL] G UK LKQ RM  M. * ISZNRKQ. H W E %NZ
IZR% %NE V  U> R ^ G  W  G  QN3KRWNG ZNVR ZNJV M
 U-KQ. QK$
S]GK6
9 %]^ QRGN HRG M. IH GNVN L"N >=\K LKW% N%]^ IG=VN M" W"N
MK *%] ^  S?3

*UV HRZWKR GN J> = V R 3T K  [NKRNZ
IJ] Y  *RN' V+ ZMZ I,E4 N  R
M VH

*UWN% M
W V. Q"N
Z"$ *UV ZM.SKR I][ J>=VR 3TK HMR I][ IJ]Y <RN'N I,E4NA0=0R
MIRQN'N  GN I%WNK M. JIME. Z" $  I3W GN H= 1 9 *UV K Z R 
U>RG QV EKWR Q]GR JKH J" U-K K QV Z"%]^ ZRN *RN *UV ZIM]GR
I] [  Z" Y KHE IW= X  I-ENL HRWN7> '  E-K E"  IUQN 7>  V
$  JIME. WK
HN_K J"  N E= U  IUQN K JT ] V ^  H
- K QNRNZ %MK$ M
I -QN Z" Y KHE G
Q]GR QE1RNN7>$Y G SNQG IV]% QJT3% S
E IG=V Z"$ [SRN IUQN
Z" $  QJT  3 % HRWN7> '  V
$  I-%HNR HR IG= V N \N'N WK %MK$ \NI-QN
L.GN K MNEV SM>V %NL>H M
 U-K K ZRN W=YN *RN ZIM]GR IHMN
HRGN K IH QNJ ] V  RNZJNE LK V
$  7> J G 3  JT N JV HR E7>   7> M
JTZNVZ. G QWVNR QN- M
- M% HSKR JTZ3WR J^R' STMZ M% Z"$
HIM]GN K IH I3WLK *UWN% G NMZ' VR HSKR L>ENMN ;N'H  GK
HK QHNV M" HSKR V. I-=H HWK K 7>M *UWN% %MK$ M
 HGN Z
R W=Y *RN ZIM]GR I][ J>=VR 3TK HMR I][ GN JIRWNR WK ISEH>E
7> a LI9QN M
I -QN K ] V  RNZJNE LK GK 3R' IW= X  LN' HRH  7> M
J^ R ' > = \ K M% 7> % 4 .  %  NRKQ. JIME  WNEKQ. J^ L N IVQNU R= \ KQ.
M% 7> M  IFR WK SM> V  > = \ K M% Z" $  WK Z] % GN K JT ] V ^  IFR WK Z" $
QNJ' *UWN% I3W LK V
$ 7>aJR IH %]^ %MK$ Z]%GN K ZRN W=YN *RN
ZIM] G R HIM] G N K IH ZM.SKR I-MK *> = E  *%^ ]  E= U K M"   J^ R 'ST M Z
HIWRGW HSKR JTZ3WR  MK M% I-%4. GK 3HVK G NMZ' STMZ.
IW3'^  QV  I3W ST M Z QV  JT S T M Z V. SM> V  I%7^ %  3HVK > H V M%
ILW$ G3 G JT;N% Z]VRK QV RN31RJVK G NMZ' JT.V G Z]VRK GK
3HVK M] > G K M"   I-] % N Q] V R HSKR JT Z  3 WR LK RN31RJVK QV
JT;N%Z]VRK Z]%
 QV I3WLK I-=H IW*NU Z]VRK LN'
 GK 3HVK IW=X

IUQN% U] U N

141

M" M>' QNJ W"$ MK IWXNR HR


 IH IH=( P.P. HIWRGW HSKR JTZ
3WR  IH= (   IZQ.AIZQ.# *UWN% I3WLK  QR(NV ?NU9 GK V> E %.
IW= X  S= H RN ] V  RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL %  RW GUT ] ( . GN UIMRN
QI;Q"% HKVN M" QV *UVK 3HVK V
$ * Q%>*W %NE WK JNI-QN M"
VG QNJ'K L+-K GK %HRK 6=YH *UVK G Z"GN% IW=X H>=G M% Q=L
NR ]V. QV ZM]V. QV QXNRKQ. %]^ IJ=6N9H R=I\QN M" RW J](.
G ZMNIR3K IGQN%]G ILM %]^ WK 7>%4. G E\. %NE FE4 HR IG=VN M"
ZNXNR J= V R. IW= X  WK \> E 4 Z A\= > E 4 N  RW %^ ]  EEHNIRQN M"   H
- K %MK$
S
EGN QNRKQN ZNL G H>0 %NGN%. % IWR
; HKVN K Z^]M GK \N'K
J-K IH7> $ IH ZMNRNL RNZJNE LK JT Z N'. IMV U= E  HRG  M% M
R
IR_ I%RN;NR G]V H(NW. G QN;NR V MK ZNRU GR3% HR RM M%
= X  G  NMZ'  0^ P  %MK$ I1H HGN
W=Y *N-K ZIM]GR GKQ. 7>JR
HV U=E. >'H Z% IW=X QN7>$GN K
IH E9 JW. JR W=YN M
' G HNR' H>0 S
EGN %MK$ K L H
-K M
R
HIM IG] G N IH IH= (   IH= (   P.P. HIWRG W  HSKR JT Z  3 WR  IH= ( 
IZQ.AIZQ.# *UWN% I3WLK  V. Z" $  ZM.SKR  ,R^ R  E9N-K HR
E"$GN JT]V^ M>' JVN E=UGN M" IH =XZ>X HSKR LK MK J^R' JTZ3WR M"
ZRGN HK %MK$ HRGN7> IG% Z"$ QNJ' *N-K ZIM]GR %]^ IHMN IH Z
RK LN% SXNQ E" ZR *N-K ZIM]GR % IHMN IH HR$(N QN3RZ X=E
V R K LN% 7> a (  S= X  U K Z" % ] ^  QJT  3 % I(- 1 R E"  LN' E-K 1RNEK IW= X
IE1N IG=VN V QJT3% WNE H=J9 WK JIM'N IG=V Z"$ 7>P=H XE IJQN
V H=J9 7>VNR H QNJ' H==J9 JIM'H QNJ' *N-K ZIM]GR %]^ IHMN IH
Z" $  %NZ EWNU. QK$ U= Y K HRH  Z" Y KHE R
M VH V
$  I= ;   S] G K6
9
IVU> R ^  RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL GK 3R' IW= X  QN-   %NZ 7> J G 3  IEQN
7>K Z$ Z"$ QN3RZ IW=X ?N'N \NI-QN Z"$ FR Z"YKHE IUQN V L.X
HRWN-K YNH1R M" R N% M
 IUQN Z" % ] ^  H
- K VHEK_ %MK$ M
- K Z" $
V]GR>V M
 IUQN ZRN QN3RZ IW=X H
-K \RXN %MK$ M
I-QN %NZ V
Z] V R GK J>  VH Z> _ V JT N JV M
- K Z R N NRN JIRWNR M
R  G W KAG
WVNW. GK J^ L NAJNP HIRQN HRGN JT ] V ^  7> J G 3  E" '  V
$  SNQG *
IVQNU IG= V N JIME. V
$  ILQNGN = > \ K QV  W( M
 U-   S] G K6
9
J^R' JTZNVZ. IVU>R^ RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL GN IG% RNV U>'UN' HRG
M.
]V RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL GN Z=>\ 7>G3 V. %NZ 7>JG3 G H *UVK
HRWNH HNE G LNE V
$ Z>HV HRWN7>'N M" ZNL >;NR QV M
R >\
V. R^ ] U   IW= X  QR(NV W" $  MK M
 L.G  M% V NIMS#
*UV ZMNSKR

E>=1 J>=I1Q. %]^ MNRN


Z" $  *UV LKNRNZ RNL^  J> = V R 3T K  U' 3 K RNZ IJ] Y A<RN'N GN
I%WNK M. Z"%]^ V ZRK JV%K %]^ QN; R
U K H
-K 8JRNAJRNI-QN

142

*1IHQN %] ^  ZNRU IW3

HIM]GN K YNH1R % 1K+SK+ G=K QK$ YNH1R V


$ WK HN_K I-ENL
HRWNI-QN V  G W KAG W VNW. GK SM> V  J^ L N HKVK V  ^ + JK+ MIRQN'N
RNL(N% IW= X  SNENLK QNIG WK I-ENL G  E-K U-   HN_K J"  N E= U
IUQN G= SNR. NE V=H I- VR4. MK *1HG RM QK$ [=1
A[=1 G

E=\ R>J- EUN IG=V M


'U JR H
-K QNRNZ %MK$ M
I-QN QK$ SM>>V
V]U M
 U- Z"$ SM>V URKS M
 IUQN  :J- HZN7>$GN QV  :J-
\T X N M
 L.GN H-K WNR QNVZAM= I VQN HR% GK 
X K MW% WK
HRWN-   MW% HRG  Z $  J] I YV YR IUQN QV  J] I YV %  G= I QN IH
I-G  Q] G R SM> V  W= Y N IL] %  M"   J] I YV %  IHMN IH Z" $  IFR V
$  MW%
HRNU. QV  IFR G=  .UN *UV ZIM] G R J> = V R 3T K  H M R I] [  L
 Z R 
IJ] Y  G  M%  %  ] V  RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL LK V
$  %NZ 7> J G 3  IEQN
M
I-QN K Z"%]^ H-K WNR HIM]GN K IH LKNRNZ HKV WK []>Z E" QV
P=U. G H
E E>=1 E" ]V RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL IS%. H31 I%WNR% %MK$
M
 HGN *UV ZIM]GR HIM]GN K IH Z"$ *K RW *1H H QV E>=1H
] V  RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL LK G  QN3KRWNG %NE V  7> % 4 .  G  IG= V   %NZ
HNR' 7> L 9H  SIQN M. Z" $  *UV ZIM] G R %] ^  HIM] G N K IH HR $ (N
WNEN QN3RZ V. M> '   SI'QN M"   Z" $  V. S9 A S9  Z] I GR IW= X  LN X> = H N
M. Z"$ V]U QN7>' G HNR' *UV ZIM]GR %]^ IZIEQN QK$ QUE IG%
IVU>R^ RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL LK V
$ Z>_V %NZ 7>JG3 IEQN QV 7>JG
3 E"' V
$ SNQG QK$ ISEH>E PKH M
 U- N%]^ %NZ 7>JG3 E- M
-
] %   IW= X  EU*U G
 NE M
 U-  M% M> '  NYN J^ R N JIRWNR
V]GR>V M" QK$ RNV IG% J^R' JTZNVZ. S]GK6
9 IVU>R^ RNZJNE LK
ZMNRNL GN U> ' UN' HRG  M.
]V RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL GN Z>=\ 7>G3 V. %NZA7>JG3 G H *UVK
HRWNH HNE G LNE V
$ Z>HV HRWN7>'N M" ZNL >;NR QV M
R >=\
V. R^ ] U   IW= X  QR(NV QNJ MK M
 L.G  M% V NIMS#
*UV LKNRNZ

]V M
W V. Q"N#

Z" $  33K JT * N IJT ]  KJE RNLHK WIR3P ZN;IZH IWI;QNE


IYUN%N I,E4NALK$G IW=X H]Z HR RMK M. Z"$ QNJ' [R E9N-KA0U9
 ZN%IH V%NW G HNR' EU*U  NE V
$ JT3N% K JVK ZNRGN
WK K NRK V%\NM E" E"$GN K V IL]%N 7>V
$ JT3N% HKVN L.GN K
7>M HRGN K  IH=E ,ZK% GN ZNIEH M]>G M
- WK N%^] H=>V GK VR4.
R
1 K IG] G N K Z" $  7>  G  V  QNJ'  * IR3V G NR. V
$  ZGG Z] U K Z" $
ZNL IW=X RIM' WNE J]XNI-VK QNGZKQ. V
$ WK ZGG Z]UK ZRN IH
%  WK N( %MK$ IG= V N I-M IWXNR HRH  IH ] V  IWU9  H] Z . %] ^  WK
]WNR HG M% Z"$ QN%]GJ>R SK%N  Z=;JTG3 WNE %]^ U>R^ S'NI-QN
E I H% [R IW= X  7> M K HE 3  E9HKQ. JT Z NVZ. GK IHT J N %NE QNJ'
GZ V J94N-KQ. M>' 3NGK %MK$ M
 RMK K SNJ % IR3VN E=*' S]G
HR IG= V N M> '  I-  7> E 0' G  HNR' Z" $  SNEN LK U-K SU9

IUQN% U] U N

143

RNL(N%  ;EK ;NR IMZNXE JTG3 U-K JKR _HKR U>R^G>QNR GN


MNRN IEQN [R IW=X LG I-H=EK M>]GK V. R
$GK M]>GK K IH ;RVK V
JTZNVZ. M" MK %MK$ L>EZ V %N I-%NFK IM' HRGKA ZRK MNEV
JNUE. WRUK M
 U-K K
IFR I-=H IG% I-M G>=\K QNVZN 7> JTZNVZN G GRSNR V=H JM>]XK
L
 G>=\ I%WNR' HRGN M" ZR J9 IW=X JNP M
I-QN ZRK J9' Z"%]^
JTNG G' E-K ZR [R S>EN7>' QN-K LN' V
$ SNQG SNVXKV M
-K
JNP G SNR IW=X G=IQN IH I-M JNP JTZNVZN GK =XK SN'K M" IL
%NE G>=\ H=1G M% JT]V^ I-M JNP IRF ]V RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL LK
GK QNIUQN Q%>NR HRW7>' V
$ MK EN* M]>GN M" M
R IH G JNP %NE
H
-K EN* %MK$ M>]GN ILW$ RNLN JRKH3V %]^ H(N >%N7>' G Z$ IHK
WK IR3K %  JNP H(N  HR' GK IM] Z V %MK$ HKVK IH7> $ IH 7> M
QI;HNRK %MK$ K QV =VW$ IG% %VKLN QN7>'N K I-E-K WRU
V
$ IR3K >\GW QN- 7>%4. % RNLN JRKH3V %]^ %NZ GH I33 S'NH
 = V  IG% V= H  H(N JNP  HKVK VG RNLN JRKH3V %] ^  H> 0  RNMV
IZEK WRVZN% IW= X  H
- K WK WNVIWH IUQN% QV  V N;%. V
$
LN'^ %MK$ M" I-E-K H
-K WK JNP HR IG]GN M" IL%NE N;H %]^
H
- K WK EN* %MK$ M] > G N 7> M  *" '  IL %NE Z R K XRXN M
- K ] V
RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL G  IWXNR > I 'QN HRGK K Q%J94  M> ] G   M
-   WK
3NVR. GN U^9N IUQN% ]V RNZJNE LK V
$ >I'Q. M
I-QN >'NI-QN
Z" $  IJT  KJE M] > G   M
- K WK M" R N% K QILMN E= I UQN IH JT Z NVZ. Z R N
M=( F9' LN RM M% *"' % G=IQN IH NY U>R^ LK G>=\. GN I%WNR%
HRG M% Z"$ 7>%]^ IHMN IH Z"%]^ QNJ' U>R^ LK G GR3% HRWN HG
M
 ZNIEH GK IGQN V
$ Z"$ QUE IG% U>R^ RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL LK %]^
N;NR' ILMK H>RK V S"PN GI\QN Z"$ %MK$ LN'GK K IH ]V HK M]>G
M% 7>%4. GK ZIMZN HK M>]GK M" L
 IL]%N 7>aXN M>]GN M" 7>M 7>)]%N MK
N;NR' IGGN M" NYN (N% V. ;RVK V
$ WK (=E M" QK JTZNVZ.
GK ZIMZN %]^ *EN HK Z0.U ZR U>R^ LK % ZRK IWQN(N >'K QV
IHMN QNJ %NZ 7> J G 3  E"  E7>   * PKH M
 LNW U N QUE  IG% Z" % ] ^
7>JG3 IG=VN I-=H ZMK% G Q]GRA E9HK E-K IR3VN QNI-QN QV
7>GK 3NGK M
-K Z"%]^ QILMN E=UN IH ILW$ H
-K Q'M
'K ILMK M
 RMK
M" 7>M JVK L
 IR3VN WK %MK$ HRGN K 7>MK 3NGK HR IRMN M" IFR
H>0 Z$ SNQG ZRK W=YK E9HK G J1 IW=X REK M
 U-K S=XN QL
K %MK$ IFR IX]VN S'K Z"$ QNJ' E9H %]^ IHMN IH V^] GI\QN LG
QNJ. I_EZ. G\G M. V. I-=;R JTZNVZ. %]^ JTN(%. HKVK L.GK M" QV
7>;R IH IWQHVK GN QJR3% X=E IRMN M>]GN M" V. 7>M PKH M
 L.GN
M" 7>M ZRK U=E V
$ IMZV M
 IUQN QV VNLJ>R IG=EK  IVU>R^ G
IV] U  IW= X   W N 7> a V  XEK U-K 7> a (  V
$  Z" $  QNJ'K E9HK G  H
E
MJVNE U-K QJR 3 % PKH M
I -QN L
 3] H N H" $ R GK K 7> M  WK
PKH M
- K IFR E9HK UR*WVK M
- K I-] %   %] ^  LZN-K G  %NE I-= H

144

*1IHQN %] ^  ZNRU IW3

1R" H 1R Z
1 R N-KHE GK G> R [1%N GN ZNXNR IZE IUQN Z" % ] ^  V.
ZR U>R^GW V
$ I-ENWN H>0 %MK$ >0GN ZNIEH GK IL]%K ZIMZ. UNW.
7>M (
94K M" Y< ZMK% G Q]GR PKH M
 H LZN-K [R QN U- G>%KQ.
HK Z0  Z R K JT N (%. JT Z NVZ. > ' GN M" 
IL IG% V
$ Z"$ I-M %NZ 7>JG3 IEQN Z"$ 7>%4. %HEK ]V. GKQ.
F
1
 QNJ' IWM9 IW=X JN H WNM HR IG=VK 7> IG% V
$ ZRK LKW%
GK U= Y K J19K 7> a V  X94 K   ] V SR  %] ^  Z" $  QNJ'K LNUGKQ.
Q= \ . %NE A WL  %] ^  I-= H  I*QN%H QNIHT V K %^ ]  G I \QN I-] % K
I*QN%H 3HE GN QNGZK K IH L %NZ %N IEQN M>]GN V. ZRN IGE F1
L.GN JR Z"%]^ 7> Z$ YR %MK$ E=IUQN JR I-M QIMN M
 IUQN
IH I-M ZG^V M" QUE IG% Z"$ QNJ' U>R^GW LK %]^ G=IQN IL%4.
%  I-M J= 3 1 HKVN IH Z R   7>   IG% W. J^ R   M
 U-  K M> '  Z" $
QNJ' JTZNVZ. WR^J U>R^ LK GK IGQN %NE MK LK RMK M. 7>%4. GK
IHTJN %NE ZRK 6
1K E9HK GK 3NGK I-=H I-]L%KQR E9H %NE IJ6E
NE M
-K G
 IV]% SNR ZRK %HRK LN' GK WK QN3]HN M
-K JR IFR
WK Z R   JT Z NVZ. %  Z" % ^ ]  ] * NIEQN Z" % ] ^  G
 VR= H KQ. IG= V KQ. ] V
RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL HIM]G M% IH RNLN WK JT*^ GN MK S=XN M]>GN M"
7> IW=X WK JT*^ GK 3HVK MK H]Z HRGK M" JTZ3WR MK QNJ' N;H
E-K RNLN IW= X  JT  R 'N HRH  NR  F R  SGE HRWN IG] G N M"   HRGN
M
I-QN RNLN IG\N-K IG]GN M" JR HRWN7>$GN JTZNVZ. MK M" H
-K Z
R U>R^ RNZJNE LK GN QNRN E"H G\
 E"' WNIEQ. G I- VR4. H]Y
I%HE'U   ILW $  Z R   I%HE  M% JT Z NVZ. = X Z> X  S  MNR  %] ^  MNRN
IG]GN M" QNVZ. GK J>HNR >'G M% ZR %NE I-M H>0 NE. IW=X L

WK M
I-QN IR_ JTZNVZ. MK HR HGN M" ZR U>R^GW GK ZIMZ. GN
WR'% HR% E-K Z R   JN 3SG %MK$ M"   I-M QNJMK HSKR NIMS
LK GN QWVNR M% L
 JT Z NVZ. GN GKGNR XNM] > G N M"   7> M  HR
$ (N
QN7> ' N %N *> E    Z R   WRU  6
1   LKW %] ^  IHW $  7> * NIRQNZ" $  QNJLK GK
SM> V  G ' GNR M. IHM9  3SG. %NE QNJGK ZIMZN U.WN I-MK 3SG.
%]^ JNPH QNJ' IGE IW=X JN E7> V EN* 7>PN8
SM> V  V> 6  JT N 'K
*UVZVK 33K

QNJ' *UV %]^ ;RZRNL G GRSNR V


$ 6=YWN7>'N

Z"$ *UV 7>ZJTHN3 >J>=VR 3TK ZNVNGK% %L=FU94 IG=EK GN I%WNK
M. Z"%]^ JRZ J^L ]V RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL LK V
$ %NZ E- M
- Y<
NE M
 IUQN M"   Z R K %L= F U94  IW= X  MEWN-K GK G> H N% M"    Z-K
 %]^ RNV G / WL Z"%]^ G>HN% 7>aV J1 IW=X SM>V GRG M
I-QN
GRG G HNR' ZRK MNEV SM>V \RNS M
 U-K K Z"$ U>R^ LK GN %NZ
E" $ GN M
I -QN [R JM> ] I XQN [R JM> ] X G  MK Z" $  U> R ^  LK GK VWKR
NMZ' G]YWV JT'NZ HKVN Z"$ G]YWV JT'NZ HRH \94N M
I-QN V. Z"%]^
J 1  GN GRG ZIM^   %MK$ M
I -QN F R  Z" $  XNRJN-K V  E 1  IUQN

IUQN% U] U N

145

XNRJN-K 7>aV J"$G MK Z"$ SM


3 M
 IUQN ZR XNR JN Z G G^V X=HR
EUN7>' E=U QV Z"%]^ YRN7>' E=U Z"$ YRG ZNR SM
3 M
 IUQN VG
ZG^V. % ZR 7>aV I-=H _G XNGR JN-K QV Z"%]^ ZRNL G GRSNR
E" U- ZRNL G GRSNR Z"$ GI\QN IH ENI-% E=UK M
-K M" LG Z
RN %]SR QNI-QN V. ZRNL % IHMN IH I-%]^ VNENS IW=X >=1 IG7>
LG Z"$ VNENS W=E GI\QN V. 7> VNENS IW=X ZURZ=6 MK ZURZ=6 K
Z"$ ZRUZ=6. %]^ G\H YR IUQN VG Z"$ QNJ' JRZ J^L U>R^GW ]V
RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL LK %] ^  NG HKVN 7>   Z $  ;RZRNL G  G^ V  Z" % ] ^
VNENS IW=X >=1' E-K IVQNR M
 U- Z"$ U>R^ GW %]^ J>HNIRQN IH M
U>R^ GW Z"%]^ SXN7># VG Z"$ GI\QN IH U>R^ LK HSKR NIMS G R^J
IW=X QN- QV Z"%^] VNENS IW=X IUR' V
$ JIME. MK SNMR H=< IEQN
ZRNL % HSKR NIMS G XR'. IW=X IURH G]YWV JT'NZ HKVN IFR
U>R^ LK QNJ' R^J IW=X QN U- QV Z"%]^ HIM' E=U IH V]^ IH E-K YR
IRMN M"$ M>' Z"$ VR %NE M. VG ZRN YR G^R M
 IUQN ;RZRNL %
U>R^ LK %NE SIM HKVK IH QNJ I-%]^ SNRA IH7>$ SXN7>$G M
 I-M
V. ZRN *
L% M" QNJ I-%]^ JIME. WK G
 SNR ZRGA SXNI-QN M"
JIMEK SNR V. H^1R V LKJ GK QNMZ'ANMZ' 1=HR M
-K JR Z"%]^
0RK1 WK %MK$ E=UK V G^RK SNR Z
1R N-KHE IE=J M
' G SNQG
1R= H  G  %KX  LN IUIRQN U> R ^  G W  LK %  7>   Z $  1R= H  G  %KX
SXNI-QN#
 VG U>R^GW % ;RZRNL %]^ IHMNAI-% ZRK IJ6E L%Z GK *UVK
HKVK M
-K M" I-E-K Z"$ I-%]^ SXNI-QN IFR ;RZRNL % IHMN IH
M>' I-%]^ IH7>$ SXNI-QN LG
$ IH Z"$ I-GN %NZ V>9WN IG=VN M" IFR
U> R ^  LK %  IHMN IH I-GN %NZ QNJ%  V> 9 WNI-QN M"   I-%  QNJ'K
ZR,K %NE %MK$ V
I 9QN I-E-K Z" $  SXNI-QN I-M Z R K *UVK
HRGN M" VG HNE % IHMN IH Z"$ G\GN M. IH QNJ I-%]^ HG V==H
SXN7> U    IFR U> R ^  LK %  IHMN IH Z" $  JEAJE I-G  %NE M. QNJ
I-GN H> 0  %MK$ IWUN9 HGN
IFR U>R^GW % ;RZRNL %]^ IHMN IH M>' L QNJ I-%]^ IH JTHNR
GN H31 IG=VN V. ILW$ V]^ E
H. %]^ VN7>$GN M"$ 7> V
$ S>RN MNE VRN
HR.UN
7>G SNQG IVU>R^ GW LK Z"%]^ ;RZRNL G GRSNR V
$ %KX E" H
QN- QV Z"%]^ IHMN IH V]^ LEGK V
$ LEGK QNJ' [R WNIEQ. %]^ G=G
IH Z"$ ISEH>E PKH M. QV Z"%]^ [R E" X=E
 G
 YNH1R V. Z%4N HR X>=H
% IH NY S GK U=E %MK$ ZR [R WNE Z"%]^ MJVNE E" H LN RM
K Z"$ [R WNIEQ. %]^ IHMN IH Z"%]^ LEGK V
$ LEGK [R E" X=E
 Z"$
ISEH>E PKH M. L
 ZR %NE K 7>M I-=HGZ M"RN% M
 U- IH I-M V.
ZR IUQN K I-%]^ M
3  IHW$ QNI-QN I-M I-VR4. GK U=E IH7>$
HIM IRMN M" IFR ZR [R WNE RNV V
$ MK [R W=E LN' E=U V. Z"%]^
U>R^GW LK HZE G F>=E 7>aV S"P IG\N-K IG=V HGK V. U>R^ LK G R^J IW=X

146

*1IHQN %] ^  ZNRU IW3

HGK HSKR NIMS G R^J IW=X IG\N-K IG=V QV ZRK VR_ M=( IMEN7$>G
IG\N-K IG=V Z"$ IFR L
RAL
R %NE R
' E=IUQN IH ZR U>R^ LK U-
ZR U>R^ LK U- ZR [RWNE IFR [SRN U- IH I-M QILMN IH7>$ HR
IRMN M" IFR Z"YKHE W=E LN' E=U VG U>R^ LK % QNWNL EUN-K IH
*UV V]^ I-M HK HR IRMN M"$ Z"$ V. V"%]^ IHMN M" IH [R LN LEGK V
$
LEGK IFR Z"$ QNJ' [R WNIEQ. %^] IHMN IH Z"$ ISEH>E PKH M. Z"%]^
ZR U>R^GW IG\N-K IG==V K VG ZR [R WNE Z"%]^ [R E"H U- V
[RWNE I-=HGZ M"RN% RIM U- IH I-M V. ZR IUQN K I-M I,]GN
IHW $  M
I -QNZ" $  QNJ'  [RWNIEQ. %] ^  QNJ'  %NE SKVK NRK [1%N
G=K IH ZRK %NE QILMN M
I-QN V ZR IVU>R^ LK Z"%]^ [R 6=YH XE
U- 
*UV 7> Z JT H N3 GN
RZ-15,B Block UEK %]+ 
 ZH^ G NSNG HE
% K
 %L=_U94 %WK IG=EK
Z
+  %] +  

J^R' JTZNVZ. N;H %]^ I*QN%H R


U V
$ Z>HV
HRH 7>ZR W;N IG]GN M"
*UV YNH1R 7>Z JTHN3 M=>YN C.M.O.  GN JTZN'
JTZN' IR=UWG Z]YE  >HV  Z]VT   QV  IL IW=X JTZ
3WR HIM]GN M" IH L IHK %]^ JTV=\ L. U>JV R
U VJIGH M
W 7>%]^ WK
PKH HRGN M. V LHR H
-K R
UK IWQHVK GK JTN' 3HVK 6K' M
 X>=HK
M
W    ILGK 7> Z R SNHK %N M
W    V R   JT N 'N GK R= I \QN HR. QV  V R K
7>ZR  NE JTGN% HR GW. RW >=\ JTGN% HR. Z]VR  IW=X IHMN
M" IH M J>%R LKW% JTNJV JTN'KC V]^ RW *NW %NE ZRK 3R' UTIM'
HR LHR JNJ HTZG]Y G HNR' VRKQ. Q=\. WK ?VZ M
'KQ. M
' V.
Z"$ V"%]^ J>%R QNLKW% Q=\. JTGN% HR GW. V"%]^ R
U Z>HV HRH RW
Q] U  JT G N% HR. QV  V" % ] ^  JT N JV M
W . QR(NV IZE.
LZLRNLN YR$IZ1 HRZH E\
QGEKQGEHSKRM"$H>EH IVU>R^ -H@
7> J R
H V J] H VKQ. Z R   LKW% IW= X  J^ R ' R^ J  IW= X  IV [I1V
M
- KQ.
Z" $  *UV YNH1R 8ZJT H N3 M= > Y N (C.M.O.-M.B.B.S., M.S. (Eye
specalist), 18 A, RH>ER R
Y R
MVH IW=X RIM]GN M. ZRN Z
SNI-E %]+
 M"   Z R N L%Z  QJT " E   %] ^  IJ] Y  IHE
- K ILE4 N
R
M VH IW= X  M
I -QN Z R K J] L WK$ V
$  SNR4 W K$ HEN GK J94 N -K D.A.V.
H^E HNEL Q]IZTVR IW=X M
-K Q]IZTVR IW=X ZR W=Y *N-K Librarian
G JG V D.A.V HNEL IW=X H]Z HRG K 7>a( G LN%HNR E
H 7>%4. %]^

IUQN% U] U N

147

ZN1R LK QV Z"%]^ IJQNR %NE 6


1 ZN1R LK HIM]G K LG Z"$ 6
WK$ HEN IW=X J94GN K V. Z"%]^ I-=H ZMNVZN % L
 IH G>RUN%N Z]IGR
Q]IZTVR IW=X WH K % ZRK M=( GKQ. R\.W. G\ H G=IQN IH
QNJ YNH1R S'
U QV QNJGK 7>ZR  NE M
WUK I-M HIM]G M
-
*"Q M
I-QN IH I-M =XN-K I- S=X %]^ G=H UEV HR IG=VN JR Z"$
S= X   W.U ZMNVZ. GKQ. U= E . %] ^  Q%> I 'QN HR IG= V N Z" $  W= Y N M
H 
YNH1R SI'QN V Z"$ M.B.B.S QV M.S. (Eye Specalist) WK P.G.I.M.S.
R
M VH V
$  HKVK
PKH  NE LG J^R M
' K VN  QJT"E  GK RNV SNR4.
WL G HRKS 7> IG% Z"$ NR JIRWNR %NE R
MVH MK K V. ZR G
%
4$
M= ( . IW= X  GRG QV  K%  IW= X  *NRKJ% 3> R ^  M
I -QN I-ENL G  E-K
P.G.I.M.S IW=X XE U- I- V
$ JIME. Z"%]^ %N V. SE=Y JT"3R RIM]GN
K V. %N MK 3^ U R GK ISZNRK K Z" $  %NZ E" '  V
$  JIME.  NE
EUNVNR ;^ ] Z RJN' WK LR^ R  HKVN M" 
7> a (  IY7^ 1 K 7> a V  V" % NV YNH1R. %] ^  Z" $  QNJ'  SNR  G= I QN IH
H.C.M.S.I. (Group A) 3T'K IW=X Z"$ S.M.O G JG 7>aV V"%NV M^] 7> Z
$ S.M.O WRVZN% IW=X C.M.O 
 JTKX G'G SNQG SNQG YNH1R V>R]V
7>IXV %RK?' V
$ SNQG ZRN I-ENL 3>DR^ HR IG=VN QV Intensive Care
Unit IW=X I3F1 HR% V=H Z"%^] NRKQ. UVKIW;KQ. JVN K JR I.C.U
IW=X I3F1 HR% G H>0 Z$ SNQG Z"%]^ H>>0 %MK$ JVN ZR %NE Q=U HK
M
I-QN EU*U Y< G
 []1 G SNQG Z"%]^ Q"N ZIM^ M
I-QN IH Z"%]^
XNR
$ JN HNEG G^V [RH \94 M% V Z"%]^ HIM RM M% IH VRN Z$
J^RN M
 IUQN M" QK$ V"%]^ E"' E-K QN- M. Z"$ 7>%4. %]^ H>0 WK %MK$
HIM IHQN K VG J^R' JTZ3WR HSKR NIMS ZR IVU>R^ V=VWGR3K
]V RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL G R^J IW=X ZR S"aY G H
E JTU1 M
- V. 7>M
HNE G G^V IL%4. GN IXMRN YRNW%N QV RKR YKEAY
E K ZMNRNL
LK %]^ G\G MK QNIGT3 M
 U-
ZR IVU>R^ GW % Z"%]^ QN3KRWNG IG=VN IHMN IH HSKR JTZ3WR
% QNJGK 7>ZR QNJ' H
1 V
$ QNJ'K 3HVK %NE  W;N IG=VK M" V. IH
QNJ QNJ'K *UVK J^RK HR H
 QV VE
H LN H
 Z"$ R
 H IHMN
IH ZNIEH QNJMK JTZ3WR M
 QNJ I- X
E IW=X QNJ' QNJ%]^ 6>JN
R= I \QN M"   JT Z  3 WR *UVK WK QNJ MK HRWN7> '  WNE  M
  Z" $  *UVK
HR% WNEN H
' M>]GN M. I-]%N HIMH ZRKQ. Q=\. \=>E4KQ. V. ZRKQ.
Q=\. IW=X M]0^Q. V
$ IWN H>0 WK %MK$ K IV]% IG%. SNQG LG I.C.U
V
$ Z"%]^ WNRY IW=X IEQNI-QN LN IRMN K V. Z"$ 7>aPH J"GE X=E' E=UN
V. YNH1R %  *= L H  Z" % ] ^  JH9 IEQN QV  IHMN IH HK HR RM  M

QNJ%  J" G E ISEH> E  %MK$ X= E 'N QNJ%] ^  MNR1 Q1" H  M
I -QN M" 
J"3E WNRY IW=X I3F1 HR% G SNQG YNH1R % Z"%]^ G=IQN IH
QK$ M" R N% M. IH  VNRK? GK RNV QNJGK E.C.G./B.P QNIG
IRJ
R 1 G=   RMK K IH QNJ SX' WNE  %MK$ M
  JR W R   QNJGK

148

*1IHQN %] ^  ZNRU IW3

E.C.G QNIG IFR ;NR' 3>R^ M


 U-K

Z" $  AA %] ^  V= V WGR3K ] V  RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL V


$  %NZ
IEQN K I-V
$  JIME. Z" $  ST M Z H> Z NRK L" % K RN;NWNZK GN I33
IRMN QV  D.A.V. School College GN IWIGQNR(K M
'  G  HNR' Z" $
QNRKQN ZNL GK QIZ= 1  6NJ Z R   7> a V  K UNI-VRK Z] V R GN LNJ
H-K E=\ WNRK HKVN M
WUN [R IW=X EU*U "$H9 F
1
Q. NR GWKA
GWVNW. GKQ. K %NZGN% G SNQG * GWKAGWV. GKQ. F
1
Q. LE
JTWNM HR IG=VKQ. QV RW JTHNR GK QN'A7>JN%. S]G HR IG=VK QV
IVU>R^ RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL LK G QNG3 Q%>NR J^R' JTZNVZ. HSKR
JT Z  3 WR HSKR NIMS  GK *UVK 3> R ^  HR IG= V K IH7> $ IH IVU> R ^  %
IHMN M"  IH/A
-HN;S;SN;SLN-ZNEKK$X"Z^EH
FEAF^EQ[N-@
I-=H HSKR JTZ3WR GK *UVK IW=X Q1>=1 IW3WN3 M
' 7>aV 7>M WK
IRF V=VWGR3K ]V V
$ %NZ E"' V
$ SNQG EN* I-M M
I-QN IH ]V
RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL % QNJ' H
1 V
$ ZRK 7>ZR W;N IG=VK I-M U=E
Z" $  QV  JIRWNR G  Z" $ SR. %  P.G.I.M.S IW= X  NR  YNH1R. QV  G^  R
1NF G Z"$SR. %]^ G=K JR 7>%4. G Z0 I-=H WK %N QN-K IH7>$IH
I-M U=E Z0 IW=X 7>K G QNWUK ILGN X"%E JTZ3WR Q% HRUN
%MK$ V. ] * W %MK$ IH H
- K I- IUQN% %] ^  Z0 H 
Z" $  AA %] ^  V= V WGR3K ] V  RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL V
$  %NZ
IEQN V. Z"%]^ JVN %MK$ K IH I-MK J^R' STMZ HSKR NIMS LK IL7>$
G  IV7> $  QWVNR QN-  M% JR LG Z R   %NE 7> J R
H V [1%N [I1V
M
-K V. Z"%]^ I-M IW3WN3 M
 IUQN IH
ZNN[1 %NIVES;IW;%NIE\ L
 E\
NXNIVU>R^ Z1HR7>aJRZNR$Z\
HSKR JT Z  3 WR IMRKR ] V  RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL G  R^ J  IW= X
QN- M
- M% L
 =X IVU>R^ M% V IW;%N *NU  G JNJ HTZR^JK E\
%] ^  IZ
1NH  QNJ'K 3HVK %NE %W $  E \  IE\ IG] G N M%
IZ1NH

*UVZVK 3>3KEN GWK GK Q=\ PKH HR%N


I-K JTHNR ZRK ;RZJV%K 3TKZVK 3>3KEN M>=YN %]^ AA %]^
= L K Q= \  V
$  G
A G
 WV^ Q . %,R QN7> ' KQ. 3> R ^  M
 U-KQ. %
P.G.I.M.S. R
M VH IW= X  * 1"  1 M.R.I.QV  M.R.I.Angio graphy QNIG
HRWN7>' QV NR W=Y YNH1R. %]^ IG\NI-QN V I-ENL WK HKVN EIH%
H
- K EN* %MK$ M
I -QN JT N -KW 1  YNH1R -K3WR I] [  QNIG %] ^  WK
IG\NI-QN JT]V^ H
-K EN* %MK$ M
I-QN I-M * H>0 QK$ IVU>R^ G
W GK QNIUQN E"' V
$ SNQG HKVN K EIH% LG GWN-KQ. V
$ H
-K EN*
%MK$ M
I -QN V. QK$ IVU> R ^  G W  %] ^  JT N (%. HKVK IH JT Z  3 WR QNJ
7>ZR W;N HG M
 V. QNJG E-K IH I-M Q\N M" IHTJN QNJ QNJ'
S=X 7>aV IHTJN HR IG7> IVU>R^ GW % IHTJN HKVK QV IR V M=(

IUQN% U] U N

149

R=\G MK Q=\ ISEH>E I=;K M


 U-K QV G
AG
 WV^Q. %,R QN7>'KQ.
S]G M
 U-KQ.
U-KQ. ILW$ JIME. K 7> VR4. PKH M
 U-K M>' I-%4. %]^ J^R'
JTZNVZ. JNJHRZ. %]^ %31 HR% WNEN *UWN% %N HMK- V. HK HMK-
IHTJN JNPH QNJ J94H IWXNR HR E"' _"EN HR E"' QV LEGK QNJ
WK QNJ'K ZN' S9N-K V 3NVR V
$ 7>E1 N;%. %]^ IVQNUH VE
H
QN3RZ HR $ (N IW= X  QNH  JRZ J^ L  IVU> R ^  RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL V
$
%NZ 7> J G 3  E" H   QNJ'N V  QNJ'  JIRWNR GN HIEQN' HRWN7> 
IV NIMS
JRNR(K
*UV YN+ 8ZJT H N3 M= > Y N

IV]% VNJ %]^ J^R' JTZNVZ. MK ZNJV HR HGN M"
*UV RNLH>ZNR <NHN (Ex. Headmaster M.A.B.ED) GN JTZN'
Z"$ RNLH>ZNR <NHN IR1NI-R M"aYZN1R IG=EK (M.A.B.ED.) IJ]Y ]>YN%N
I , E 4 N A R
M V H   W R V Z N %  J V N A QNLNG %UR R
M VH Z
S N+
%]+A  IW=X RIM]GN M. ]%  IW=X ZRK JV%K QV G
%4
$
E9IHQ. %]^ SM>V I*QN%H
I*QN%H SKZNRK K I- SKZNRK %NE I-] %   V] U  M

U- K IH G


%4
$ E9H HIM' E=U IH %HRK %MK$ M
 HGK IH7>$IH I-
SKZNRK %NE UEN R> H GN K QV  NM QN7> ' N S] G  M
 L.GN K LG
$
YNH1R E" H QN7>$G K QV %3 GN 1KHN IG]G JR RNV %]^ YK7^1K 7>aV
M]>G VG IH=( E" H L.G SM>V MK JT3N%K M
 L.GK K Q_R WK Z"%]^
S>EN E"$G K Z"$ 7>%4. %]^ G=GN V. 7>M HIM]G IH I-ENL HRWN7> LG
[R IW= X  M> ] G   V. YNH1R %] ^  RNV G  G
A G
 WNR WK QN7> ' N J" $ GN K
IH7>$IH HG IH [R G Z"$SR QV HG IHK %]^ LHR IH %]^ 3=H M
W
VN YSE _N1H V YNH1R =XGWN GK G>HN% M" =XGWN NIMS V
$ J>6
=  E7>
IH ZN1R LK G [R GN HK MNE M
I-QN HRGN K
IL%  WK IL= (   G= I QN Z" $  7> a (  MK IUQNA7> V = R  JT G  3  IW= X  HRN%N
3NZEK G  H
E  7> V = R  JT G  3  IW= X  \ \ 9N RNL(N% IW= X  SNENLK H-K
SNR \N1^3NZ LK QV H-K LU4N L]VRAZ]VR WNIEQ. G H
E MIRQN'N
IW=X V. Z"$ H
-K LU4N %MK$ 6=YK JT]V^ H
-K _RH %MK$ IJQN HREN G
H
E \9N H]X%K S
MVNWNEN U
MN%N G H
E %UR ZXN%N IH]GRJ>R
I\9WNEK QNIG SM>V LU4N U- EU*U IV]% E=\ R>J- E=U H
-K H]Z %N
QN-    Z" $  (= H  IUQN QV  Z R N JIRWNR SRSNG M
 IUQN Z R K JV%K
% Z"%]^ IHMN IH ZRN LKW% ?VZ M
' WNEN M" QV *UV >*N3 J>=VR
ZIM]GR J>IE WNEN IL% ]V RNZJNE GK ZIMZN >'N7>$GN M" Z"%]^ 7>
]V V
$ %NZ GWN IG7> JIME. Z"$ IH U=E 7>aV IW3WN3 %MK$ HRGN
K QV U>R^ S'N7>'N UEV Z0GN K IHMN HRGN K IH VRN U>R^ V.
Z" $  MK M. Z" $  Q" Z +- + SK+Q" a Y Z R   V
$  ILQNGN H
'  U> R ^  M
W  U N JT ] V ^
JTI(VKQ. % Z"%]^ SW=3 HR IG=VN QV Z"$ I-M WK Z]% IEQN QV QNJ'K
JV%K %]^ %NZ E" E8 QNJGN LKW% SNHK %MK$ M" IH7>$IH 7> Z$

150

*1IHQN %] ^  ZNRU IW3

Z R K JV%K GN WL%  IH+ UTNZ RIM IUQN K JIME.  IH+ UTNZ
WL% K 7>P' S"P' V
$ WK RIM U-K K X=E'N IFR%N V. SM>V G^R GK
U=E K
Z"$ IHMN IH ZR V. E-K %NZ WK E" H G\ E" QNJ' Z% GK I-M
WK HRH G\ E" M>' Z"$ V"%]^ %MK$ R
H.UN %NZ E" EN PKH M" IH7>$IH
]V RNZJNE LK V
$ %NZ E"' E-K HIM' G^R VKR ZMK% 3>*N3 ZRN
*VKLN QN7>$GN K HIM]GN K VN-K LK %NZ E" E7> %MK$ V. ZR LN7>U
 Z"$ HIM]GN K IH H
-K YNH1R 6=IYQN %MK$ QK$ SNENLK QNIG NR
V.VIRHN H
E  IR ZNR IEQN V. QNJGN ] V  HK HR EW U N
JT ] V ^  V] U  QN H   IHV  U= E  %MK$ S'K VG %NZ E" '  * L  IG= V N
IH7> $ IH Z" $  WK QNJ'  JIRWNR %] ^  QN3RZ E"  LN' G  IWR> = ;  K 
L%WRK  IW= X  %NZ IEQN QV  UIMRK %,R UKVN Z $  %NZH
J>VH %NE E" H QN-K I-=H ZMK% IW=X ILW$ GKW IW=X VE JN IG=VN
M
W I- VR4. R
3%K M
 U-K MR ZMK% IV]% IH=E
 WL% W=;' E=UN
LG W=Y E9H %]^ SU"R %NZ E- M
- I- Z. G %NZ E"' HNR' X]UK
%K$G QN7> '  E= U K VG 7>  %  QNJ'K JV%K %] ^  %NZ GWNI-QN IFR Z" $
UIMRK %,R UKVN Z $  J>  VH J94 K  VG Z" $  WK UIMRN-K IW= X  IUQN
QV  JNI-QN IH QILMN IUQN% IHV  %MK$ JI94 Q N QV  %N MK > I 'QN
K QV Z"$ WK QJT"E  IW=X %NZ IEQN Q=L ZR [R G W=Y QV
S=X V=H % %NZ IEQN M"
LG 7> M  SKZNRK M> ] G K K VG NRN [R H] S  7> a PGN K E9N-K
0U9N % H RK IW= X  IWWNG YNH1R GN QN7> ' N LN'N L. Z" Y KHE IW= X
Q"ZRL"$K IW=X E" H JM]>XG K Q=L NYN [R WRU G ZN% M" QV
VE
H  LN' GK I-= 6 N M" 
I-= H  ZMK%  JIME. > J %  IW= X  JT Z  3 WR HSKR NIMS LK U> 9 U.W
" H 1R  IW= X  JEN1 S> = H  HR U-   LG YRNQ I%= H IEQN V. 7> M K
JEN1 %]SR IZIEQN L
 >J% IW=X HSKR JTZ3WR % G=IQN K WR
ZNXNR J= V R JI94 Q N V. 7> M K JEN1 %] S R QE 1  K
NY Q"K ISZNRK K IH H
-K WK I-]%N G>=\K %MK$ M
WUN L
 QK$
K M>' ]V RNZJNE GN LK ZMNRNL V
$ 7>JG3 JTNJV HR% G SNQG
SM>V (
9 IG%. IW=X QK$ NR SM>V >=\K M.
ZR [R IW=X I,]% JTU1 M
I-QN 7>% IHMN IH Z"$ QNJG QN3RZ
IW=X L.GN M. * H>0 G\H QN7>$GN M. JR Z"$ 3K3 IW=X %MK$ L.GN
IL=( ]V LK S"PH IV]U HRG M% IH7>$IH Z"%]^ * U=E. GN JVN M"
LHR Z"$ 7>a( LNW.UN V. ZR J1N-K M
WUK I-E-K Z"$ WNJ SNMR QN
L.GN M. QV  QNJ H-K V.VIR] H . G  H
E  HK XNM  SNEN LK U-   Z" $
Q]GR %MK$ IUQN SNMR RIM L.GN K Z"%]^ H
-K S]%' WNEN %MK$ M"
ZR N(K YRJ
H K YR H *=L U- K Z"$ %MK$ LNW.UN Z"%]^ J94H 6=Y
R=I\QN M" Z"$ VR [R QV VRK E9HK G [R GK I-=1 %NE I-=1 SLN'K
M"   Z" $  I- JT H NR J94 H   6= I YQN IUQN M. IH I-= H  G  SNQG I-= H

IUQN% U] U N

151

NIRQ. G  IW%N3 GN %] S R QNW U N XNM  IHV  WK *= L  E7> 


H>0 IG%. G SNQG 7>M JTV IFR [R IW=X JTU1 M
I-QN QV L
RA
%NE S
E ' E= U N IH V R N U> R ^  RNZJNE IH= (   M"  V R N ZNIEH HIWRG W
HSKR JT Z  3 WR   LG WK JT U 1 M] > G N K V. QNGZK W.U U= E SNV
HRGN K VG MK ZRK JV%K NY [R IW=X J^LN WNEK LU4N 7>aV XEK
U-K QV G]YWV JT'NZ HKVN VG MK IL]% JTV  GK IJ1N-K 3>DR^ M
 U-K
QV  HIM' E= U N IH IJ1N-K HRG  M
 M> '   Z" $  I-M H] ; . IURN G W .UN
7>G X]UK ZNR J-K V. HIM' E=UN IH I-M H]; %MK$ E
M GN LNE M"
RK- M% I-M ZNIEH RNZJNE LK IH=(
$ QN U- I-M V. SRWNEN IW=X
IV]U HR% U- M
- K 7> IG% RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL SRWNEN I,E4N
IMNR IW=X IV]U HR% U- M
- K  Z"$ V. I- E-K QNI-QN K IH
ZNIEH I-= (   M"  MK %MK$
IL]% % IHMN Z"$ QNI-QN K QNJ GK I-=1 %NE I-=1 WLN7>' JT]V^
ZRK I-=1 %NE I-=1 S=L U-K Z"%]^ %RH IW=X JN7>'U Z"$ XEN LNW.UN
Z"%]^ 6>9WN IG7> HR$(N QN3RZ IW=X ]V RNZJNE LK S"P M% I-%4. %]^
QNGZK %N Z0
 J^ R ' JT Z NVZ. QN-  M
-   M% I-%4 .  %] ^  %N 6= Y  G ' N
%MK$ V. \VN M
 LNW U K I-= (   MK \ 9 N HX%K WNEN J] I YV WK I-ENL
HRGN K
LG Z" $  \ 9 N HX%K IW= X  IUQN V. J] I YV %  G= I QN IH QNJGN
JIRWNR I-=H G SNQG I-=H HRH ?VZ M
 LNWUN Z"$ %MK$ Z]%K JR
3NMJ>R IW=X MK *N-K GK E9HKQ. GK 3NGK HRK M
-K K QV 7>M J]IYV
MK 3NMJ>R GN K IFR J]IYV LK % NY X;RK LK %]^ G=IQN IH R
MVH
WNE  X ; RK RNZH> Z NR G  SM> V  ?VR%NH ISZNRK M"  QV  NRN JIRWNR
%31 M
 LNWUN
N 7>%4. %]^ S>EN H IEQN7> VG X;RK NIMS % QNJ'
GNZNG %]^ ZR H
E *ILQN NY GNZNG ILE I][ % G=IQN QV %NE
E"  H  IUQN S> E N%N V. QNN% K JR IFR I-ENL SM> V  Z> I 3HE M

IUQN 7>G HNS^ IW=X %MK$ QNI-QN Z]UE QV 3%KWNR %]^ RNV G Z
$ J]LAJ]L XHKQ. QN7>$GKQ. K 7>%.4  %]^ 7>VNRGN QV %NE G VNENS IW=X
JN IG]GN I-M JTU

RNZ XNR NE V=H XEGN IRMN JR SNQG IW=X M=( \94
HR IG=V
Z" $  S
M VNWNEN ,K$G  I-= H  IQN'  G  H
E  IUQN 7>  %  IHMN IH
VRK ISZNRK Z"$ H=1 GW.UN QNJGK SKZNRK GN Z"%]^ JVN M" 7>M N%]^
H-K WNR SNEN LK WK E" U- %N 7> IQN' G HNS^ QNI-QN %N 7>G
Z]IGR IW=X IH7>$IH Z]UE QV 3%KWNR %]^ XHKQ. QN7>' %NE 7>M WK
I-]%. V]U M
 IUQN IH 7>% WK M=( \9 HR IG==V IH7>$IH XHKQ. LG
WK QN7>$GKQ. K V. 7>%]^ ]G3 QN L.GN K IH RNV  V
$  WL V=H
Q= U  LEN H   JN'K GN E
1 N E"  H  QV  
1 K E" H   LNUG  RIM'N I-M
JT
U RNZ ] %   V
$   V= H  X= E GN IRMN S
M VNWNE  G  H
E  LG
X$HK QN-K V. 7>%]^ I-=H JRXK IZEK K S
MVNWNE IQN' %]^ IHMN IH
IW= X
$  M= 1  L. V" % ] ^  J] L NM M,NR R> J -  G  GW.U   %MK$ V. V R K WK \" R

152

*1IHQN %] ^  ZNRU IW3

%MK$ 7> % YR G HNR' Z"%]^ I-%HNR HR IG=VN Z"$ IG% IW=X IG=EK
%HRK HR% L.GN QV RNV %]^ QN H JIMRN IG]GN HG RNV %]^ YNH1R
%] ^  S> E N H  IEQN7> $ GN Z R K G> R G3N M
 U-KZ" $  7> a JR G  H] Z  V
$  QV
NRN JIRWNR ISZNRK V
$  SM> V  V] U  K IHK %] ^  HIM] G   K V. 7> M
Z,NH HRGN K IH % WK N( %MK$ IG=VN SM>V J" E=U*U  E=\
?RX M
 IUQN
ZRK JV%K X]G HR %]^ (N-KRN-KY M
 U-K K L%WRK  IW=X
YNH1R 8+JK+ U> J VN %  (N-KRN-KY G  E-K IVZNRJ> R  IG= E K MJVNE
IW=X GN\E HR% E-K ZNRH HR IG=VN JT]V^ 7>a( %N LNH Z"$ Z"YKHE
IW= X  YNH1R X> = U  I-GN J"  IE31 K 7>   V
$  I-ENL HRWNI-QN
7>  %  IHMN NRK 7> Z R GWN-K \N'K JW U K JR M> '   IW= X  %NZ
E"' V
$ SNQG GWN-K ISEH>E \VZ M
 U-K Z"$ YNH1R X>=U %]^ WK X"aH
HRWNI-QN 7>M M"RN% M
 U- IH I-M IHW$ M
I-QN NRK U=E G=K
M> '  Z R   E9H  QV  Z R K JV%K GK NRKQ. ISZNRKQ. S] G K6
9  %
PKH HR IG=VKQ. M% W=Y E9H GN %NZ >IR]GR H>ZNR 6
1 GN E9H
GN %NZ Z%
L  H> Z NR M"   G
% 4
$  MIRQN'N J> I E IW= X  % H RK HRG  M%
LG 7>M G
%
4$ MK 7> I,]%A*^V V
$ JT*NIWV K QV [NE % WK 7>%4. 7>aV
H-K WNR Q1" H  HKVN JT ] V ^  %NZ 7> J G 3  IEQN M
I -QN K I-E-K
7> % 4 .  %] ^  JT Z NVZ. HSKR NIMS %  SXN IEQN
V=VWGR3K LUVU>R^ ]V RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL NY E-K MK QWVNIRV
M
- M% IH7>$IH IL JIRWNR G G
 E9H %HRK QV G
%4. IW=X MK JTV
V. 7>   [R GN HK M
W  U N IL Q R V G  G
%
4 $  E9H  G  %NE QILMN
I\EWN9 M
W QV QNJ IW=X WK IL]% M
W V. HK IL]GUK M" L
 E
H HR$(N
QN3RZ G SNR IW=X IUQN% %MK$ HRG 7>M E
H V. Q];R IW=X M%
IH7>$IH J94% G E-K IGZNU IG=VN M" J9
4 QV 
X
 HK =XN-K M"
NYN JIRWNR SRSNG M
 IUQN K ZR S=X QV ZRK JV%K LG
PKH M
 U-K VG MK Z"$ QNJ' IVU>R^ RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL LK G XR'.
IW=X ZRJ' HR IG=VN ZRN H>0 %MK$ M" I-M V%AZ%A;]% NRN U>R^
LK G  XR'. %] ^  ZRIJV HRGN M.
ZRK E9HK QV GNZNG % WK %NZ IEQN Q=L ZRK S1K GN [R
WRU M
 IUQN M" ZRN GNZNG 3RNS JK$GN K 7>% 3RNS WK 6=Y
IG=VK ZRK E9HK GK JTZ
3% JEN1 ZHN% QNIG H>0 IG%. IW=X JTNJV
M
 IUQN QV * GK ZL M
 RMK M"
]%  IW=X S]GK6
9 U>R^ RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL % NY JNJ HRZ
R^JK >=H [NM G <R %]^ IV%NZ R^JK Q=U %NE LEN H ?VZ HR IG=VN
%N H
- K U] Y  %N H
- K Y
R K %N RN\ %N VNWK, QNIG H> 0  %MK$ S
IRF S]GK 6
9 G Z]VR %NZ 7>JG3  G %NE MK 6>1HNRN JN H VE
H
E" H   LN'N M"   I-M NRKQ. ISZNRKQ. V. R^ ] U   IW= X  HIWRG W  GK IHT J N
%NE ?VZ M
 L.GKQ. M% LHR QILMN %N M
W V. *UVK V
$ IW3WN3
7> a P L.GN M"   M> '  QK$ SM> V  = > \ K M. XNM  H
- K H> 0  WK HR   NY
[R V H>0 %MK$ M
 HGN IH7>$IH QK$ S]GK 6
9 HSKR NIMS G M]

IUQN% U] U N

153

M. 7>%4. G XR'. IW=X M. Z"$ WK %MK$ Z]%GN K I-%4. U=E. %]^ JN\]Y
HIM]GN K JR LG I-=H G SNQG I-=H %]^ YNH1R G H
E E"H L.GN K
V. J" WK E=U V]U WK M
I-QN V=G Q=\. \>=E4KQ. HK QE LNE IW=X
_IQN M
I-QN M. I- E-K QNJ' I- WIMZ %]^ *=>EN G'N IH *^VA
JTV H>0 %MK$ M" Z"$ HIM]GN M. IH SHWN %MK$ I-M U=E. QE IW=X
M"   IH7> $ IH ZR
9  IW= X  Z" $  QNJ'  [R %] ^  SRSNG HR IG= V N M> ] G N
I-E-K Z" $  NR  JNPH. %] ^  JT N (%. HRGN M. IH QNJ WK QNJ'  NR
G>=\. V
$ 6>=1HNRN JN7>' QV V*UVK E-K VE
H QN3RZ HR$(N IW=X
JRZ J^ L  ] V  RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL LK V
$  Z> F V %NZ 7> J G 3  JT N JV
HRH  Z%> = \  LKW% %] ^  _E S'N7> 
JT N R(K
M" a YZN1R RNL H> Z NR Q" Z +- + SK+Q" Y
7> J R
H V H> 0  *UVQNVZNW. GKQ. QNVZ H(NW. QNJ%  J94 K Q.
QILM A  *UV M,NR. E= \ . M% L
 QNJ'K QNVZ H(N J>  VH IW= X
IE\WN7> ' N XNM> ] G   M% I-E-K I-= (   (N% [= 1  M
'  G  HNR' H> 0  MK
*UV. GK QNVZ H(N G=   H  M. L  NR  *UV. GKQ. QNVZ H(N
QK$ IE\' S" P  LN-K-  V. 3NI-G " $ H9N J>  VH. 6= J  LN'UKQ.
I-E-K Z0GNR IWQHVK %^ ]  I-3NRN MK HNFK M> ] G N M" 
*UVK IW=X *G/A *UVK *UVK IW=X SM>V *G M>]GN M" QNJ XNM
IHK GW GWK GK *UVK HR
 7>GN FE LR^R IZEUN L
 IH %N3WN%
M
WUN JR Z>HVK %MK$ M
 JNWUK QV JNJ HRZ ?VZ %MK$ M
'U IL%4.
%]^ *
U' E-K SNRA L%Z E"'N JWUN Z>HVK GN IRF J^R' ]V GK
3R' IW=X LN H QR(NV 7>%4. V
$ %NZ 7>JG3 E" H JTZNVZN GK *UVK
HR% V
$  MK M
W  U K QR(NV %MK$
 ]NRZ0GN%NMK$HIM]GN3NZG>IJMR %]^
URKSGN WHVLNVM"R
W
U I-JIMR %]^@

154

HSKR NIMS LK GK HNE %NE WNRVN

HSKR NIMS LK GK HNE %NE WNRVN


LG JTZ3WR % RW STIMZ]Y. GK RX%N HKVK QV QNJ' E
H IW=X
IW3RNZ HR% E=U 7>G SNQG QK$ * HNE G STIMZ]Y IW=X RIMH
QNJ'N HKVN M
I-QN HRZG]Y *
U' E=U QV SM>V G=>\K RIM' E=U >=\
QV .VK GK \
L IW=X *1H' E=U QV N%]^ QNJ' I%=L [R VE
H GK
NG VN7> '  E= U K QV  7> a (  LN' E-K *UVK QNR] *  HKVK IHK %
XNR
$ WG. %]^ H]P3( HKVN V. H
-K 7>UR V=J HR% E=UN QV MW% =U
I;QN% ZN;K QNIG IHT Q NW. QNR] *  HKVKQ. E I H% QNJ'  I%= L  [R
VE
H  %MK$ LN H  IH7> $ IH 7> J R
H V IHT Q NW. HR% %NE QUE  L%Z.
IW= X  Q= 6   ZIR= ;  LKW% %] ^  JT N JV M
H   ILW $  RNLNAZMNRNLN W= Y N
WJNRK QI;HNRK G W AZM.G W  WRUA ZM.WRU QNIG  WNJ E= \
X R NK *
U ' E= U    SM> V  JT  3 N% RIM' E= U   QV  JRZIJVN JT Z  3 WR %] ^
JTN(%. HR% E=U IH M IGQNE^C N%]^ I%=L [R GN RNVN IG\N8 QK$
IMRG V
$ QNJGK *UVK HRG M% QNJ N%]^ GR3% IH7>$ %MK$ G RM M

I-M IWRV.V HSKR NIMS % ;RZGN LK %]^ G=G M
- IHMN IH
;RZGN I-%4. LKW. GK J>HNR >'H Z"$ QNJ' VE
H V
$ IMLGN GN
R^J S'NH HNE E
H IW=X QNI-QN VG I-=HKW$ STIMZ]Y IW=X IL=( HNE
GN I%=L [R M" 7>a( VJVI3EN 7>aV LKW. %]^ *>]%H 3^\Z RKR V
$ U];
H= I <QN LN IRMN K Z R   JM> ] X ' G  SNQG LKW. GK LE% ZNVZ M

U-K 7>%4. % Z"%]^ G\ H IHMN IH M J>R3C QNJ H
' M
 QNJG GR3%.
%NE MK N%] ^  SM> V  > = \  QV  3.VK GN QIMN M
 IRMN M"   IFR Z" $
G=IQN IH Z"$ JRSTMZ JTZ3WR HSKR M. QNJ * LKW ZR E
H V
$
QNH  HNE ST M Z G  E
H  IW= X  _ U-  M
  I-M HNE R
, N%. I-= H  E= \
ZN%W G  ^ \ 3Z RKR IW= X
$  U] G  H= < H  \.GN M"  QV  SNQNG IW= X
QE=UA JTHNR GKQ. 
%KQ. IW=X G]Y *
U' E-K 6=Y IG]GN M" VG 7>M
LKW QNVZ.WN HIM' E=UKQ. IH M IGQNE^ JTZ3WRC N%]^ I- HNEGK
LE IW=X
$ 6>9N7> Z"$ G=IQN IH I-M STIMZ]Y HNE % IV]% WNR *UVK
HRH ZR V
$ JTNJV HKV M
- M% L
 QNJ I-=( * WV^Q. GN JT
U HR
RM M
 I-M * HNE GKQ. M% QV QNJ * QNJ'K I-=6N %NE [>]Z'
QN-  M
  I-E-K M> '  QNJG  7> a JR HNE ST M Z GN SM> V  I,QNGN IR'
M
 X=>HN M" QV 7>M IR' ZR =X %NZ G LNJ IS%4. %MK$ 7>VR HGN
LG V=H QNJ IR' Z>HV %MK$ M
 HG VG V=H QNJ HNE STMZ GK
,E4 V
$ SNMR %MK$ LN HG I-G E-K QNJ%]^ ZR V
$ %NZ 7>JG3 E"
H *UVK HR%K M

WUK VG Z"$ QNJ%]^ 6=YWN H E" LNW.UN QK$ I-M
WNRVN HR MK RM K IH 7>a( HNE STMZ JTU1 M
 IUQN QV 7>% SM>V
HT
I;V M
 H ZR 7>aV MZEN S
IEQN Z"$ QNJ'K 3SG 3HVK %NE 7>%]^
Z^ R I3V HR IG= V N IFR H> 0  Z $  SNQG 7> M  M
3  IW= X  QNI-QN Z R 
XR%. IW=X IUR H ZN_K Z]U' E=UN QV S
IEQN IH QNJ ZR V
$ W=Y M

ZR 7>aV H>0 IGQN HR
 QV I-M G=
 HK QNJ ZR E
H IW=X IH7>$ QN-

IUQN% U] U N

155

M
  VG Z" $  HNE J> R 3 %] ^  G= I QN IH H> 0  LKW QNVZ.WN *UVK HRH
QNJ'  I%= L  [R VE
H  IW= X  WNJ LN'N XNM> ] G KQ. M% 7> % 4 .  %] ^
IV*UVK ZNRU %MK$ IZE IRMN M"   I-E-K 7> M  *UVK HR' G
SNQG WK I- E
H IW=X RIM L.GKQ. M% Z"$ 7>%4. %]^ IV*UVK ZNRU
G=' G E-K QV VRN *G G' E-K QNI-QN M. IH V^] HNE M"$ I-=H E=\
LKW. GN QNMNR HRGN M"$ QV WN E=\ LKW. %]^ 7>VJ]% HRGN M" QV
*UWN% S'H S"PN M"$ Z"$ 7>%4. %]^ G=.UN IH QNJ ILGK *UVK HRG
M
 7> M  *UWN% %MK$ HNE M"   I-] % N > ' G  MK HNE S
I EQN L H R *
LKW WNJ XE LN'U V. ZR *
L% GN HK M
WUNZ"$ *>=\N ZR LNW.UN
QNJ%]^ ZRK JTN(%. M" IH IV]% >=U. IW=X LKW [=1 E" H LN'N QV *
%]^ ZRN *G %N G'N HK Z"$ HNE M. * %]^ \.GN M. LG HE>U QNW
V. XNM IH]% LKW. %^] E" LN'N I-M WX% HNE % ZR V
$ JTNJV HR
IEQN HSKR NIMS %  ;RZGN LK %] ^  Q= U   G=  G  M
-   IHMN IH
IV>U VTVN>U G>WNJR>U IW=X WK Z"$ QNI-QN K QV SM>V LKW.
%]^ VE
H E" H IUQN EIH% I-GN *G %MK$ IG=VN M>' Z"$ HE>U IW=X
QNI-QN M. QV HNE %NE ZRK WNRVNENJ M
-K M" HNE STMZ % Z"%]^
IHMN IH M>' QNJ IL]%. XNM L
R EUN E"'N QNJGK U=E H
-K %MK$ >'
UN JIME. V. Z"$ LKW %]^ *UVK G ENI-H MK %MK$ 6=IYQN M" 7>%4.
IW= X  SK9K IUIR1 3RNS ZN QNIG S> R   H] Z  GK QNGV JNH  7> % 4 .
GK IWRVK %^] IWUN9 IG=VN M" H-KAJTHNR GK JN\]Y J^LN IW=X LKWQNVZ.
%]^ EUN IG=VN M" G^RK U=E I-M M
WUK LG QNJ QNJ'N IUQN% G H
VE
H XE LN7>U VG Z"$ HNE  QNJ' G^V *LH QNJG J]( %NE IZEG
AL>EG SNR4. J]( XENH LKW. %]^ *TIZV HR GW.UN ZIMZN VE
H GK
G=  'U   QNJGN IUQN% H(= ' U  JR %NZALNJ Z R N HR%U   ILG
JIR'NZ WR^J ZRN MK *
L% S%'U I-M U=E >'H HSKR NIMS %
IHMN IH QNJ QNJ'K H
I 3 HR%N Z" $  IVZNRU G=  H  MK WNJ
LNW.UN QV L
 ZRN IUQN% >' EWUN 7>M VR SIMHNW IW=X HGK %MK$
QNW U N
IVU>R^ HSKR NIMS % IHMN IH M I%R]L%C LHR Z"$ XNMW. V.
VR NR \E4 %]^ I6'*R IW=X ZNJV HR HGN M. JT]V^ Q"N HR% %NE
Z R N WX% *] U  M> ] G N M"   I-M 
X H  Z" $  QNJ'  IJQNR  M]  . %] ^  (NR(
IUQN% G H 3SG GN SE JTGN% HRH VE
H E" LW.UN QV IHMN IHA
>%
 ;RZRNI-QNMZ]\
 M]NJGJRNI-QN
IL%EK%MNMZRNJTWN%N
 M]NMZIH- QZN%N@
JIW= V R HSKR NUR IW= X  LKW. %] ^  *> = E A*> = E -KQ. IW= X  JN7> '  G
E-K V(N QNJ'K *>=\ %]^ IZ
1N7>' G E-K VR4.A G VRKH GN WR'%
IZ1N7>
GWNGJ](HR^] Z"$NLN%NZV>ZMNRNE HR^] QWN,N
GWNGZ]NRJPM
%NZV>ZMNR J](XE"M
@
JT(ZG^VZZJTU1 LN-KJK6 Q]3V>ZMRNQN-K@
MKIW;KLKW%H
 *RZN7>$J>R3%NZLKW%Z0N7^$@

156

HSKR NIMS LK GK HNE %NE WNRVN

GWNGJ](%NZL
 E"M
 MZR Z>=\QN%Z" M"@
HMNV>ZMNRNLKW%MK$ZN%MZNRKQ
RM
SNGS\N%"@
Z"$IGT9F]GNRXKS%N-KLNZ$LKWRM 7R0N-K@
GWEGWJN3N%J^LN-KVKR(WRVLJAVJZ%EN-K@
=UM
ZQR^ %ZQXNRNQ
RQ%HF]GZ$YNRN@
L
 IUQN%KLN7> ]NRNLKW%NZN% HMNV>ZMNRN@
 IVU>R^ WX%
IUQN%KHM >%
 QI%QN-KHN1
 F]GLKWE" LN-K@
LIVHF]GV>ZRX IWXNRKV3SGV" S" IS]YNRK@
L
%LKWMZ3SGIGT9NWF]GV>ZMNRNHEZ>HNW@
X
HNHRJTWN%NJN-KJ>R3%NZIVIMG7> IX]%MN-K@
VNHI%H1HNE%MK$QNW]I;G\KVNHM]IR%NW"@
7> J R
H V IWWR' V
$  I= ;  M] > G N M"  IH L
 Q% H  J] (  X= E   M
-   M%
IL%4 .  G  H
E  HSKR NIMS G> Q NRN G= I QN M
I -QN IV*UVK ZNRU
%MK$ M"   I-M * HNE JT  I RV M% Q] V  S> = ; KZN% %] ^  XNMKGN M"  IH

X AIWXNR HR *UVK ZNRU QJ'N8 IH7> $ IH Z%> = \  L%Z Q%Z
E  M" 
I-M SNRA %MK$ IZEGN HSKR NIMS HIM] G   M% IH/A
HSKRZN%>3L%ZG>RE*M"IZE %NSNR]SNR
VR>WR J=VN1^1IURSM>R%NEUVNYNIR@


IUQN% U] U N

157

IW3W IWLVN ]V#


]V RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL GK QI;QH3VN IW=X IM]G>VN% IW3W
;RZU>R^ G R^J IW=X JTIV3IPV M
WUN
] V  RNZJNE LK G  IW3  IW= X  %NVT  G Z #  GK *IW= \ WN'K
F" T $ X FR.  G 3  G  %NVT  G Z %NZH JT I = ;  *IW= \ WHVN %  ] %
I-++   IW= X  I-= H  MLNR E
H . IW= X  *IW= \  GK ] H  I VH = X K
*IW=\WN'KQ. IE\KQ. M% A E
H. G G VH S'N- M% IL%4.
IW=X M>' V=H * I=; M
 X>=HKQ. M% IM]G>VN% IW=X =X M
 X=>HKQ.
*IW= \ SN'KQ. IW= X
$ /A
+ *NRV GK JIMEK ZIMEN JT ; N%Z] V RK SM> V  JT * NW3NEK W H> 3 E
M
-UK I-M ]HV W+ 3TKZVK I-]GRN U.;K GK VR_ M"  V(N 7>%4. GK
ZV 7>%4. G %LGKHK R=I?QH G>QNRN M
'N IEI\QN K L
 =X M
-K
+ 7>   V
$  SNQG 7> % 4 .  GN J> = V R 7> a VRNQI;HNRK M
W  U N QV  7> M
SM>V [=1 Z$ V=H RNL HRUN V(N QXN%H IZTV^ %]^ JTNJV M
WUN L
 =X
I= ;  M
- K J^ R W G  JT ; N%Z] V RK 3T K  WRUK RNLKW U.;K G  IW3
IW= X 
+ ] V  RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL G  IW3  IW= X  *IW= \ WN'K %NVT  G Z
G> Q NRN L
 IWVNR J^ R WH IE\K M" 
7  QNJ'K *IW=\WN'K G 3VH J]L G Q]V IW=X V(N 3VH 6 G
QNR]* IW=X %NVTGZ LK % IEI\QN M" IH Q=L QR(NV I-++ ]%
 V
$ PKH  NE SNQG QR(NV ]%  IW=X I-=H IM]G^ ]V
3NIR%  JT U 1 M
W  U N QR(NV RW LUV IW= X  7>  GK XRXN M
W  U K
7> Z$ 7> IM]G^ ;NRIZH ]V 3NIR%  GK 7>ZR A NE G IW=X
M
W  U K JT Z  3 WR %  %NVT  G Z %] ^  ] V  RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL G  Q; 9
7> Z R WNE  RKR GN 3N\3NVHNR HRWNH  XEIX= V R GK *.VK NRKQ.
[1%NW. %] ^  IG\NI-QN QV  Z0NI-QN 3T K  %NVT  G Z LK %  WK$
GK %^ ]  JT ( Z 3VH IHMN M"  I- JT H NR J] L WN 3VH  WK$ GK
M
I-QN %NVTGZ LK % IHMN M" IH 7>M ;NRIZH IM]G^ %VN QR(NV
]V CHYRANA3NIR%  J]LW$ 3VH G Q]V G NE IW=X QR(NV ]%
-K++   IW= X  [RA[R V] U  HR%N IVQNU H  QR(NV X \ 1.
%^] E][H SNMR QN-UN QV QNJ' Q%>QN-KQ. %^] 3NVRIW;K Q%>NR
*UVKZNRU G=   U N 7>   ZMN% ] V  G  G=    ZNRU V
$  Q%> Q N-KQ. %] ^
QG*> V  QNI;QNVIZH QV  * I VH EN* M
W  U N 7>   V= V WIGT 3 1N IM] G ^
] V  G  G> Q NRN G=    3NVRJT Z NI'V V= V WIUQN% %] ^  Z0H  XNM> '  WNE
3R;NE^ I-]% QX]I*V M
'U ILW$ H
-K U^9K %K$G V
$ LNIUQN M
W 7>
V=VWIGT31N IM]G^ ]V G>QNRN ]%  IW=X XEN-K QNI;QVIZH HT.VK
I-+K  V=H X=EUK VG V=H SM> ]I\QN IW=X JTZNVZ. XNM>' WNE

158

IW3W IWL V N ] V

*UV V=VWIUQN% %]^ Z0H Q%>QN-K S'H >=\K M


 X>=H M
'U 7> V
$
IJ=6
$ 7> (N% GK X\1 V
$ *K SNMR E][UN 7>V
$ SNQG  V
$
WR' > = U  QR] *  M
W  U N
%
1/ IJQNR JNPHL% IHTJN J94% I%Z% *IW=\WN'K L
 FT. G3 G
WNK 3TK %NVTGZ GK K ILG IW3 IW=X ZGRN G I-=H L
IV33NVRK
H +  Q" a + IHT 3 'NZ^ R VK %  IHMN M"  IH T K  %NVT  G Z ,K G> Q NRN ] %
 IW=X IE\KQ. *IW=\SN'KQ. GN (NR( Q%>WNG ]%  IW=X
ZM.RN31R IW=X I-=H L
IV3 3NVRK HRUN 7>M L
IV3 3NVRK %NVT
GZ GK *IW= \ WN'K IW= X  Q] I HV ] H  I VH *N3N GN J= 3 1KHR% HRH
7>   IW= X  IE\V *IW= \ V [1%NW. GN QR( G H   QNJ'N *IW= \  U] T (
JT H NI3V HR U N #7>   L
I V33NVRK G> Q NRN (NR( Q%> W NIGV HKVK
U-K J>  VH IW= X  Q%> W NGHT V N G  3SG. IW= X  J94

+ JT 3 P  7> a V /AAPIMR
 WR' > = U  RNZRNL  QN IRMN
M"   I-= H  Q; 9  7> Z R GN 8GNR 8> G NR  QL
9  ZMN= V N QI;HNRK
*NRV MK %MK$ NRK IJT ( WK 7> a V  WR' > = U  IEQN- U N QV  QNJ'
%NV% ;RZ GN J> % R7> ( N% HRH  (NR( *UVK ZNRU G=  H  RW 3T 
31 IM] G ^  RN31R S'NW U N 7>  V
$  SNQG ST M ZG 3  JNIHVN% S] U EN
3T K E] H N % J NE IV= S V IVS V  QFUNI%VN% ZENI-QN QNIG G 3 .
IW=X 7>MK NRW*Z GN ;NRIZH %VN M
WUN =VN;NRK X]YNE XH9KQ.
7>aV 7>GK =VN M
WUK 7>M %VN NR%  GN G>%KQ. %]^ Q;NJ ZNE^Z
M
'N M" S G\G RM

+ JT3P  7>aV IFR IEI\QN M" /APIMR
 RNZRNL WR' >=U
QN IRMN M" L^% I-++  V
$ I-++  V=H X=E' WNEK 7>VHT.VK
IW= X  WR' > = U  GN 7> ( N% M
W  U N IM] G >  VN% IW= X  7> G "  M
'  WNEN
VNR'MNR NR% G> % KQ. IW= X  > = \  ZIR= ; K QV  3.VK JT G N% HR U N
%NVTGZ LK % I%R3]GM IHMN M" IH JTU1 M
' WNEN 3NR% CHYRAN
QL IUQNV %MK$ M" EIH% 7>M IHT3X% QV Z>EZN% MRIU, %MK$ M"
7>M IM]G^ MK M
WUN QV Z"$ %NVTGZ 7>GN M>' 6NVK P
H H URW HR
HGN M. IH7>$IH 7> IGW >V]VR ^RL 3NR% GN 7>G" M>]G MK NR
JIME. WNE IWGWN% HIMEN7>' WNE ZMN% %VNW. %]^ ZLS^R M
H 7>G
NMZ' I%ZR S'%N JWUN 7>M IM]G>VN%K ZMN% V=VWIGT31N ]V *
%] ^  Q*^ V J^ R W RNL JT G N% HR U N 7> M  ZN% HNI-GN ZN% I%Z
S'N-UN I-VRKAJ>R>3 IW=X QZKRAURKS IW=X LNVK QV ;RZ IW=X
H
- K * G A*NW %MK$ R= \  U N IH  7> a V  QI%Q. %MK$ M
'  G W  U N 7> 
V= V WGR3K ] V  GN * L%VN IW3 3  ] Z N% HR U K ZNVNAIJVN V.
QNGR'K- $  M> ] G   MK M% JT ] V ^  JIW= V RVN G  QN;NR 7> a V  7>   3NR%
V= V WGR3K ] V  GN ZNVNAIJVN V
$  WK QE= U  3R;N GN (N% M
W  U N
%NVTGZ QNJ LM^GK W]3 GN K QV FT. G3 GN %NUIRH K 7>%
IHT3X% ;RZ WKHNR HKVN M
I-QN K IFR WK %NVTGZ % I%R]G
M IHMN M"  IH JT U 1 M
'  WNEN 3NR% IR_ IM] G ^  MK M
W  U N

IUQN% U] U N

159

+ JT3P 7>aV /A* %]^ ZN% HNI-GN I%Z Q%>3N3% JNE'
HRWN H  = X   J] ( V  EUN- U N Z" $  %NVT  G Z  I-= H  U= E  I%RIWWNG
I= ;  HRGN M. 7> M  NR' ;NRIZH % V N  %W. IUQN% QNIW3HNR
HR U N 7> M  = X N ZNRUGR3% HR% WNEN VNR'MNR - 3 KQN \] Y  IW= X
IL G 3  GN %NZ ZM.NUR IM] G  ZM.NUR  M"   7>    %NZ WNE
IM] G ^  VN%  G 3  IW= X  L%Z EW U N 7> M  %N IHT  X% %N Z>  EZN% %N
IL^  M
WUN 7>M I%R3]GM IM]G ^ M
W U N M
R *^V J^RIWH ;NRIZH %V NW.
V
$ I,QNGN S>=;KZN% M
WUN QV QIL]IHQN M
WUN %NVTGZ *IW=?WN'K
G 3VH  E
H  IW=X ZM=VWJ^R' ]HV ]G3 G= IRMN M"  7>%^]
NR JTZ HR'U 7>GN S
E SNEN RMUN 7>GN YR WK M
WUN H
-K
WK QJIHTV HR%N WK %MK$ 
XUN 7>GN %NZ QV HKRVK VT"\]Y IW=X
U>]LUK QR(NV QZN%. V
$ JNR 7>GK ZIMZN GN S
ESNEN M
WUN M>'
V=H QIUQN% GK %K$G IW=X U^9 
- M
- ZNL %^] V=VWIUQN% GK R3%K
%NE LUN- U N RWZN%W ZNL M9S9NH  LNU U N 7>  G  V= V WIUQN%
G QN;NR 7>aV *UVK N;%N HRUN RWZNL V
$ IV N;%N HRNW
UN IL HNR' RW N;H. %] ^  QNJ'  QNIGAQ%NIG (N% IVE
H
IW= X  QNJ'  J^ R WL. G  H
E  E"  LNH  7> a (  (N-K (N% JT N JV HRN- U N
WNIR3 S'N-UN  I- HR^R *^ZK HNE E
H  V
$ Z>HV HRN-UN I-M
3SG S
E  7> a P U N
+ JT3P  /A I-M IM]H HR^RX]GR ZM.HNE  H' M" IH=(
M" I-M U=E 3NR% V=VWGR3K ]V  MK G=UN 7> HR^RX]GR V
$ 7>M
CHYRENA3NR%  3NR% MK Z> H V HRWN- U N 3NR% V= V WGR3K
] V  G  HNRIHRG IW= X  I- *^ V E GK JIW= V R *^ Z K 7> a V  IM] G >  VN%
IW=X  WR' >=U GK 3>R^QNV M
WUK IFR I-M J^R ]NR IW=X F"EUN
7>   IW3W % V N QV  7>  G  GU> ' N GK 7>  G  SNQG WK ZIMZN UN-K
LNW U K 7>  G  Z% GK 3NEK'VN I%ZRVN 7> > G NRVN GN I-] % N R E AJ E
S
E SNEN M
WUN IH I- V
$ JIME. %Z^G HKV M
- 3VH  E
H  GK
QNI?RK J] I HVK IW= X  HKVN M
I -QN 7> E  \  IH QNJ'N 3SG \> G  MK S
E
7>P=GN M" QV 3NR% GK MK L>SN% S
E RMK M" IH 3NR% QNJ' SNR
IW=X S= IV]% MK 3SG S
EGN M"# I-=H IWL IUQNVN# I-G %NE M
R
IW3' %N IXJHN8 Z"%]^ Z]L^R %MK$ M
WUN I-M JT3P WNEN  7>E
\ SN'K 3VH  E
H   IW= X  M"  IM] G ^  3NR% QNJ'  IUQN% %NE
G" I GJZN% 7> V ] U  7> a XN WR^ J  GN IW;N% V= V WIUQN%  IFR V
$  IS%.
3RV 7> L NUR HRWN- U N Cyren will be chief of the world, loved
 QV ZN%WK ]IHTVK I%R;
H ]WNRUN I-
feared and unchallanged 
IW=X H
-K 3]GM %MK$ M>' IH %]^ JVN %MK$ M" JR LG
$ QNJ' Z$
IW=X %RI][ QXN%H JTU1 M
I-QN K I- VR4. MK 7>M IW3W ZMN%
%VN Great Chyren)QNJ'
QNJ' VRH3>=; QX^H QI;QNVIZH IUQN% QV
*UVK V, %NE IWI\QNV M
WUN Z"$ %NVTGZ  QX]I*V M. Z"$ %N
7>G G3 IL=(
$ 7>M QWVNIRV M
WUN QR(NV IVE
H G3  %]^ QV %N

160

IW3W IWL V N ] V

7>%]^ LN'GN M. Z"$ 7>%]^ NMZ' G\ WK IRMN M. 7>GK ZIMZN GN
3SG S>=; IW=X H
-K IZNE %MK$ HR HGN S 7> %]^(Great Chyren)
ZMN% ;NRIZH % V N  HIM] G N M. QNJ'  ;RZ S] ; ^ Q . GK Z= G G HNEK%
Z=IQN V
$ G%K% MNEV V
$ SX"% M>]GN M
I-QN >V]VR IUQN% ^RL
GN 7> G "  HRGN M
I -QN QNJ'  *UVK V L  %NE LU GN VNR'MNR W $
3VH WK$ GK G Q]IVZ NE IW=X  G Q]V IW=X I-+K+ Q;9
7>ZR GN IW3W GN ZMN% %VN ILW$ V,WK I][ ZN%W Great Chyren
7> G KWU% MNEV IW= X  X \ 1 E] [ GN M
I -QN Z R   %NVT  G Z G  Z% GN
*G E" IRMN M" QV Z"$ 7>GN WNUV HRGN M
I-QN M"RN% M
 IRMN M.
7>GN WK M
 IRMN M. IH7>$IH 7> GN G>%KQ. %]^ IUQN% %N M
' %NE
Z R N 3NR% V= V WGR3K ] V  7> J  H 3N GN JNVR S' IRMN M" 
Z R K %NVT  G Z GK  IX= V * G H *IW= \ WN'K GK QV  7>   W" I 3WH
I] [  ZN%W GK 7> J  H 3N %N HR% 7>  G  JT U 1 M
'  7> a V  V(N 7>  G  V
LWK V=VW IUQN% R^JK ^RL 7>G" M
' %NE QNGT3WNGK 3T31 IWQNHVKQ.
GN J> % R7> ( N% V(N WR' > = U  GN 7> G "  JT * NIWV 3VH  IW= X  Q= L
I-+K+  V
$  NE SNQG QR(NV  IW=X 2 
G  SNQG QR(NV  IW= X  3> R ^ Q NV M
W  U K I- IHT V NR( 3> R ^ Q NV
%] ^  Z" $  %NVT  G Z  IGT 3 1N M
 IRMN M.
+ JT3P     /A %NVTGZ 3VH  E
H  IW=X IFR
JTZNI'V HR IRMN M"  IV]%. JNIQ. V
$ Z]>GR %NE I[R GKJ IM]G>3VN%
G 3  IW= X  7>   ZMN% ] V  GN L%Z M
W  U N 7>   Z $  V= V W IUQN% G
Q*NW HNR' Q*NW QIUQN% Q] ;  R N M
W  U N %" I VHVN VN JV% M
H 
MNMNHNR Z=XK M
WUK 7>M 3NR% ;NRIZH %VN  U^RWR QR(NV U>R^
LK %] ^  WR 3T  3 1  Z] % H  QNJ'K N;%N HR U N V(N HRWN- U N 7> M
;NRIZH % V N V= V WGR3K ] V  QNJ'  ;RZ SE QR(NV *UVK GK
3HVK %NE V(N V= V WIUQN% G> Q NRN RW RN31R. %^ ]  %VZVH HR
UN - 3 KQN IW= X  7>  %^ ]  R
H 'N QR(NV 7>  G  JT X NR IW= X  SN;N HR%N
JNUE J' M
-  U N 3= V H  E
H  
%
1/A %NVTGZ GK *IW=\WN'K FT. G3 GK *N3N IW=X IE\K U-K
K SNQG IW=X I-=H JNE ST]1% %NZH Q]URL % I- %NVTGZ GK
*IW= \ WN'K
WN'K " $ X^ R K UT ] ( # %] ^  FT .  IW= X  H> 0  NE RIMH  ZI0QN F R
I-]UIE3 *N3N IW=X IEI\QN 7>% U>R^WR 3SG %]^ STIMJVK  U>R^WNR
QV (RY LN'H IE\ IG=VN IH 7>M QNJ'K J^LN G QN;NR STIMJVKWNR
%] ^  S'N- U N WNVW IW= X  U> R ^ W R 3SG M"  ILGN QR( M"  IH RW
U>R^Q. IW=X L
 I-=H V=VWIUQNVN 3T31 M" V(N U>R^ %]^ Z>=\ Z]%H N;%N
HR%N M>]GN M" WG *N3N IW=X STIMJVK GN *NWQR( RW7>aX WNZK
QR(NV JT Z  3 WR G^  RN QR( ST I MJVK GN LUVU> R ^  WK M] > G N M" 
LUVU> R ^  V(N JT Z  3 WR WK ST I MJVK GN S
;  M" 
7> M  Q; 9  7> Z R IW= X  V= V WIUQN% GN GNVN V(N IU M
H   VT " \ ] Y
IW= X  HKRVKZN% M
-  U N Z" % ] ^  %NVT  G Z  7>  GN %W. 7> J NQ N;%N

IUQN% U] U N

161

Z]VR Q"N ,NIEZ ZNE^Z M


 IRMN M" ILW$ =J %]^ W3 HR% WNEN UNR9^
Z] V R %NE ZM.IW3" E   = J  %] ^  W3 IW= X  HR E" $ GN M"   7> M  %W. 7> J NQ
%W. HNI-GN S%N7> '  WNEN V= V W V N G> % KQ. G  NMZ'  7> L NUR M
W  U N
7>K %]^ Z"$ %NVTGZ  M"RN% M
H UT1 3NR%# G= IRMN M. 7> G
IUQN% G  IGW V L  G  JT * NW %NE 7>   GKJHEJ *NRVWR3  IW= X
QHRIZH V^FN% \ESEK Z=XUK QR(NV QIUQN%K ]V. G>QNRN IWGR
M
HKVN LNWUN 7>%^] 3.V HR% GN 7>JNQ WK 7>K %^] ZE^Z M
WUN ILW
$ ,NEZ =J'K %^] W=3 HKVN L.GN M" 7>M 3R G ZN% 3HVK3NEK W V
LJ]>L IWQHVKVW GN M
WUN I-M Z"$ %NVTGZ J=31 3SG IW=X G=
IRMN M. IH 7>M H]>YE%K 3HVK ;NR% HKV M
- M" Q=U J=31 3SG
I-M M" IH IL Z$ 7>M 3NR% IL ZM.NUR IW=X GKJHEJ M" 7>K
G3 G %NZ V ZM.NUR GN WK %NZ M" IM]GZM.NUR  IW33VN I-M
M
W  U K IH 7>   G 3  GK *> L ] U  3RJ'K 3HVK H> ] Y E%K 3HVK  GN J^ R '
JTKIXV (True Master) M
WUN 7>M Chyren ZMN% ;NRIZH %VN  7>GNRZV
WNEN IHT J NE^ A IGQNE^   G" I GJZN% %NV% NZRNL QI;HNRK QNIG
J> R 3 IVJ> R 3  GN Q%> Q N-K M
W  U N
N 7>GK =VN RW*Z M
WUK 7>GK
ZIMZN 7>JNQ U>R^ 3R;N U>R^ *UVK QR(NV U>R^ IS%. H
-K N;%N FE
%MK$ M>]GK I- I;.V %]^ IGT9 HRUN V=VWIUQN% GN IV]U HRH JT(Z
QIUQN% %K$GTN IW=X 
- QNJ' ;RZ S];^Q. IM]G^Q.  %]^ LNUIRV HRH
Q] ; IW3WN3 QN;NR V  N;%N HR RM  3R;NE^ Q . %^ ]  3NVRIW;K RIMV
N;%. GN S>RHN FN9H U^94 UIMR IUQN% V=VWIUQN%  GN JTHN3 HRUN
QNJ'  %NV% ;RZ GN JNE' HRWNH  ZIR= ;  3.VK GN QI;HNRK
S'N- U N VG IJ= 6
$  7>  GN V=VWIUQN% ]J^R' IW3W IW=X _"EUN 7>
ZMN% V= V WGR3K ] V  G  IUQN% GK H
- K SRNSRK %MK$ HR H U N
QR(NV 7>GN H
-K WK N%K %MK$ M
WUN 7>G U^9 IUQN% V=VWIUQN%
G  NMZ'  ^ R L GN V L  WK [= 1  JW U N I-E-K Z" $  %NVT  G Z
W"3IWH I][ ZM.ZN%W I-]%N ZMN% M
WUN IH Z"$ 7>GK ZIMZN %]^ 3SG.
IW=X %MK$ S]%4 HGN Z"$ %NVTGZ  7> ZMN% 3NR% %]^ G\ IRMN
M.
7>JR
HV IWWR' GN *NWQR( M" IH 7> IW3W %VN %]^  NE
GK 7>ZR IW=X V=VWIUQN% 3NVR. V
$ JTZNI'V M
WUN QR(NV 7>M 
NE GK 7>ZR IW=X ]%  V=H RW ;RZN G 3NVR. %]^ J94H 7>%4N
GN IUQNVN V= V WIUQN%K  M
W  U N V(N 7>  G  SNQG 7>   V= V WIUQN%
GN IUQN LN%' 
U JTZ3WR GN IUQN% M
R. %]^ JTGN% HR' WNEN
M
W  U N V(N 7>  GN QNI;QVZH L%Z QZNW= I QN %] ^  M
W  U N 7>   Z $
7>GK 7>ZR VR>' QR(NV    NE GK %MK$ M
WUK 7>M JR9
M
WUN V(N LG 7>M JTI=; M
WUK VG 7>GK 7>ZR  NE V
$  NE
G  IWXHNR M
W  U K#
+ JT 3 P    /A%NVT  G Z HIM] G N M"  IH I%R] G  M  IW3W
IW=X 3T31 V=VWIUQNVN UT1 3NR%  G IW3 IW=X ZRK *IW=\WN'K G

162

IW3W IWL V N ] V

3SG. 3SG %] ^  IHK % V NW. 7> a V  L


9  H  VRHAIWVRH HR G \
U   V.
H
-K \RN %MK$ 7>VRUN Z"$ %NVTTGZ  6NVK P
HH 3SG. 3SG HIM
IRMN M. IH Z R N 3NR% GN HRV= V W QV  7>  GN U^ 9 AUIMRN IUQN%
V=VWIUQN%  MK RW GK \=E4 7>VNRUN S  NE QN7>' IG7>
I- IW;N% GN I-= H A 3SG \RNA ZR(% 3NR% MK G W  U N
+ JT 3 P  /A %NVT  G Z %  QNJ'K *IW= \ WN'K IW= X  IHMN M"  IH
WK$ GK G 3>R^ IW=X G>%KQN G I\=VL 7>aV 3NR% GN 7>G" M
WUN
L
 WK SGENW M
W  U N 7> M  Z R K %NVT  G Z GK  I-= 6 N %NE %MK$ SEIH
7> 3NR% GK QNIUQN %NE I%VK GK I-=6N %NE NRN SGENQ M
W
UN MK M
W  U N 7>   IW= X
$  %WN SGENQ ZVES IM] G >  VN% RW 3 3 1
RN31R M
W  U N H-K GKQ. V
$  %N G I \QN QILMN IM] G ^ Q . GN > = \
NZRNL IGT 3 1K U
X R M
W  U N 7>   G 3  IW= X  J" G N M
I -QN ;NRIZH ] V
MK V= V WIGT 3 1N V(N L= U  GN VNR'MNR L= U IUQNVN M
W  U N - 3 KQN
\]Y. IW=X RNZNI-' ZM.*NRV QNIG GN IUQN% L
 IM]G^Q. IW=X JTXIEV
M" 7>V
$ WK QE=U Q=U GN IUQN% 7> V=VWGR3K ]V GN M
WUN 7>M
IVJ> R 3 GN Q%> Q N-K M
W  U N 7> M  I-= H  QG> I WVK ] V  M
W  U N
+ JT 3 P  /A SM> V  NR  ] V  % V N QN7> ' U  QV  LN'U   RW
JT Z NVZN G  GT
M K V(N QI*ZN%K M
' U   Z" % ] ^  %NVT  G Z %^ ]  Q.VIRH
N\3NVHNR 7>   3NR% GN M
I -QN M" 
IM] G >  VN% GN IM] G ^  ] V  QNUNZK Q] ; HNRK *UVKIUQN% G  Q*NW
%NE Q] ;   JT E HNRK WNR( W=   *N-KA*N-K %] ^  ZNR IRMN M"  S
1NASNJ V
$  IWZ> = \  M"   IM] G ^ A IM] G ^  GN 3VR^   Z>  EZN%AZ>  EZN% GN
G>3Z' SI'QN M"  ;]^;HNRK ZNI-QN GK G9 IW=X SSR ZNL  LUV
%] ^  %W. JT H N3 G '  WNEN 3RW3T  3 1 L= U L V N ;NRIZH IW3W % V N GK
QNJ'K 7>GNK G IWN H
-K QI*EN3N %MK$ M
-UK QR(NV ZN%W G 7>;NR
G E-K IX]VN G QIVTHV H>0 WK WNR( %MK$ M
-UN %N QI*ZN% M
-UN
I-M Z R K *IW= \ WN'K GK U
R W GK U= E  M
-  U K IH WNVW IW= X  7> M
V= V WGR3K ] V  ]  NR IW= X  QW= 3  JT I = ;  M
-  U N 7>  G  G> Q NRN G= I QN
IUQN% GKQ. V= H  6NI-QN RM U N 7> M  ] V  QN;> I %H IWIUQNI%H.
GKQ. Q= \ . XHNX $ ; HR U N Q"    QNI;QVIZH XZVHNR HR U N IH
IWIUQNI%H WK QN3XR, IW= X  J"  LN'U   7>  GN RW IUQN% 3NVR
JTZNI'V M
-UN Z"$ %NVTGZ  HIM]GN M. IH S>=;KWNGK IWQHVK 7>GK
7>JH3N %N HR% 7>%]^ 6
1N IUQN%GKJ %N Z0' 7> V=VWVN ZM.ZN%W
3NR% %]^  I][N%( HRH QN% 7>aV ISPNH  7>%]^ QRNI;QN GW
Z] % H  J^ L N HR
  7>   QNIG J> R 3 IVJ> R 3  GN Q%> Q N-K G> % KQ. GN
VNR'MNR M
W  U N

%NVTGZG 3ZR(%IW=XM
R*IW=\WHVNW.GK*IW=\SN'KQ.#
+ I-]UE"$Y G L
V3K HKR^# % ]%  IW=X IE\K J>VH IW=X

IUQN% U] U N

163

*IW= \ SN'K HKVK M"   SKMWK$ GK QR(NV ] %   -K+ G  7> V RN;G
IW= X  ] %   G  IJ= 6
$  7> V J] %  ] V  MK IW3W IW= X  I-= H  %WK$
= I *QVN# IEQN- U N L
 ] J ^ R ' IW3W IW= X  F" E  LNW U K *NRV GN 7> M
I-= H  IWQHVK NR  ]  NR IW= X  IUQN%HT . VK IEQN G W  U N
+ *IW=\WHVN 3TK WLKEI1%#
1%# G Q%>NR  WK$ GK G 7>VRN;RG
IW=X IW3W IW=X QNJK JTZ GN Q*NW ZN%WVN GN MN ZNI-QN ]UTIM
GK G9 E>=1 W RNL %VNW. GN Q]I%QNK M
 LN'N QNIGA SM>V NR
7>VJNV G\' %^] IZE'U JT]V^ *NRV V
$ 7>VJ]% M
-K 3.VK *RNVRVW *NW
7> a V  Q;NIRV %WK$ = I *QVN ]  NR IW= X AG 3  JT . V QV  LNIV GKQ.
KZNW. V
9H IW3W*R IW=X QZ% W X"% 7>VJ]% HRUK
+ QZRKHN GK ZIMEN *IW=\WHVN LK% IYH3%# G Q%>NR WK$
GK G Q]V V
$ JIME IW3W IW=X I-=H [
R MNMNHNR V(N ZN%WVN GN
]MNR M
-UN W"XNIRH >=; G SNQG QI;QNVIZHVN 7>aV Q;NIRV I-=H
%WK$ =I*QVN ]*WVM *NRV G UTNZK' JIRWNR G IWQHVK G %VRVW
IW=X L]ZUK QV ]NR V
$ >=; %^] GNAGN G E-K IWGN HR GWUK
+ QZIRHN G 3TK Q]YR3%# G Q%>NR WK$ GK G Q]V V
$ JIME
L.  WK$ GK G JT(Z G3H IW=X IW3W IW=X Q=I*QVN GN %]UN V.YW
M
-UN I- IW=X *NRV GN I-=H GMNV GN I-=H ;NRIZH IWQHVK I-=H
ZN%W I-= H  *N3N QV  0] Y N GK R^ J R \ N GN IW;N% S'NH  ]  NR %^ ]
GNXNR 7>GNRVN ZN%WK- WN W IJQNR GN SH GUN I-M ZKMN
]%  V=H IW3W IW=X Q=U QN7>' WNE MLNR. NE. G E-K ;RZ W
>=\A.VK *R GWUN
+ I-]UE"$Y G *IW=\IGT31N 3TK URNRY HTN-K# G Q%>NR  WK$
GK G Q]V V
$ JIME L.  WK$ GK G JT(Z G3H IW=X I*Q]HR >=; G
HNR' H-K G 3 . GN QIV= V W MK IZ
1 LNW U N JT ] V ^  *NRV GN I-= H
IZ1
ZM.J>R3 ]J^R' IW3W %^] ZN%WVN G I-=H ^VR IW=X S]%4 GWUN W IM]N
F>=1AG>RNXNR HJ1 QNIG ]NR V
$ GN G E-K IZ
1N GWUN
IZ1N
+ QZIRHN G *IW=\WHVN 3TK XNRE HENRH# G Q%>NR  WK$
GK G Q]V V
$ JIME I-=H G3 IWIUQN% GK 7>%VK IW=X * G3. %^] J6N9
GWUN JT]V^ *NRV GK JTIV3PN IW33HR I-G ;RZ QV GR3% V
$ M
-UK
IL %^] J^RN IW3W QJ'NQ EWUN I-M ;NRIZH HT.VK WK$ GK G JT(Z
G3H IW=X ]J^R' IW3W %^] JT*NIWV HRUK M
R ZN%W %^] QI;QNVIZHVN
V IWW=3 HR GWUK
# G Q%>NR ]%  -K+ V
$
+ M]URK GK ZIMEN L
V3K S
IRHN
RHN#
JIMEAJIME 7>UR JTI(VKQ. M=IVQN QV E>=1ZNR G IW=X MK ZN%WK-
GU> ' . GN IWHN I-= H  *NRVK-  FIR3V  G  G> Q NRN *
I VHWNG %NE
FE ][R3 G FER^J M
-UN L
 IXR(N-K RMUN I- QI;QNVIZH
IWQHVK G W=YK ]I\QN IW=X 6
1A6
1 E
H MK Q%>QN-K S'H *IVHWNG
%^ ]  QI;QNVIZHVN IW= X  SGE G ' U 
+ FR. G YN+ L^EWR% G Q%>NR ]%  G SNQG 
R
JK

164

IW3W IWL V N ] V

G3 *NRV GK ;NRIZH =I*QVN GK VRF VLK %NE 0>H'U ]% 
V=H IW3W GK QSNGK  HR
9 G QNAJN M
-UK *NRV V
$ 7>aPK
IUQN% GK ;NRIZH HT . VK %N3IVHVN GN %N3 HRH  Q.;K V> F N% GK
VR4 .  ] J ^ R % IW3W %^ ]  <= H  EW U K 7>   *NRVK-  ZMN% QI;QNVIZH
IWQHVK G Q%>QN-K G\GAG\G I-=H ](N G R^J IW=X
QNVZ3HVK
QNVZ3HVK
QNVZ3HVK

V
$  ] J ^ R ' IW3W 7> a V  JT * NW LZN E" ' U 
%VTGZ# G Q%>NR IW3W *R IW=X 3"I%H HT.VKQ. G
+ FR. %VT
SNQG (
9 ILM MK Q=6 E
H ]NR %^] Q=6N S'N-$U IL]%4. GN ZMN%
;RZI%3P IW3WIWI\QNV %VN  WK$ GK G Q]V QV  WK$ GK GK
3>R^QNV IW=X IH J^RW G3 V
$ L%Z E"H *NRVIWRV W L]VN G>QNRN
NR IW3W %^] -HVN G ^VR IW=X S]%4 GWUN %VTGZ 3VH  E
H
 IW=X JTZNI'V HR IRMN M"  IV]%
$ VRF. V
$ NUR %NE I[R GKJ IW=X
7> ZMN% ]V GN L%Z M
-UN 7> Z$ V=VWIUQN% G Q*NW HRH
QIUQN% Q];RN M
-UN %"IVHVN GN JV% M
 IH MNMNHNR ZIXQN M
-
UN 7>M 3NI-R% ;NRIZH %VN  U>R^WR QR(NV U>R^ LK %^] WR 3T31
Z]%H QNJ'K N;%N HRUN V(N HRWN-UN 7>M ;NRIZH %VN V=VWGR3K
] V  QNJ'  ;RZ SE QR(NV *UVK GK 3HVK V
$  V(N V= V WIUQN%
G> Q NRN RW RN31R. %^ ]  %VZVH HR U N - 3 KQN IW= X  7>  %^ ]  R
H 'N
QR(NV 7> G JTXNR IW=X SN;N HR%N JNUEJ% M
-UN 3VH  E
H
  " $ X> R KA H] % NA
+ I-LRNI-E G JT
+ MRNR G Q%>NR *NRV G3 GN I-=H IG*
ZM.J> R 3 ZN%WVNWNGK IWXNR. HRH  ] %   -K+ V
$  JIME A JIME
QI;QNVIZH HT.VK GKQ. L94. Z,S^V HR E-UN W NR IW3W %^] 7>%4. G
IWXNR > ' % %^ ]  SN; M
' N JW U N *NRV G  QI;= H VR RNL. IW= X
RN31RJVK 3N3% M
-UN JR SNQG IW=X %VRIVW ;RZI%3P WKR E
H.
V M
-UN L
 I-=H ;NRIZH ]UP% G QN3IRV M
'U
+ %NRW G 3TK QN%]GNXNRK- GK *IW=SN'K G Q%>NR ]%  G
SNQG I-=H 3HVK3NEK ;NRIZH ](N *NRV IW=X JTHN3 IW=X QNWUK
ILG WNZK$ I-=H UTIM( IWQHVK GK QNXNR ]IMVN GN JNE' ]J^R'
IW3W HRUN ;KRA;KR *NRV 7>G
IUH ;NRIZH QV QNRI(H IGT31K
V
$ IW3W GN %VV
T W HRUN QV 7>GN IWIUQN% QI;QNVIZH V=VWIUQN%
MK J^R IW3W %^] ZN% M
-UN
7>JR
HV *IW=\WN'KQ. G Q%>NR MK Q=L IW3W IW=X [1%NW. [1
RMKQ. M% >U JIRWRV% JTIHTVK GN Q1=E I;.V M" W"IGH GR3%
G Q%>NR XNR >=U.A V>=U VTVN>=U G>QNJR QV HE>=U GK IWW(N
M"   LG IJT ( WK 7> a V  JNJKQ. GN I-= H  6VR NZRNL M
 L.GN M"  VG
*UWN% IJT(WK 7>aV ZN%W R^J IW=X JTU1 M>]GN M"
I-K JT H NR > = U  JT K WRV% GK *IW= \ SN'K -KN-KQ. GK JIW= V R
;NRIZH J>VH SN-KSE *K 3J=31 3SG. IW=X HIM]GK M" JIW=VRQNVZN
I3^ % "$1 L
MN% G / QV / V
$  IW=X I-=H MNI-H *L' GK

IUQN% U] U N

165

*IW=\SN'K HKVK M" SN-KSE GK  WK$ GK G Q]V V
$ JIMEAJIME
7>VJ]% %MK$ M
I-QN V. SN-KSE GKQ. *IW=\SN'KQ. W"$ QIV JTZNI'V
M
 LN-UK JT]V^ Q"N Q]*W M" IH7>$IH 7> ZMN% QNVZN I3^ % 7>
MNI-H %^] *L' G E-K MK QNJ' JTN'. GK QNM^VK IG=VK K I-M V=(
"$1 L
MN% G / V
$ J1 JTZNI'V M>]GN M" V. *K Z"$ QNJ%^] =X
HIM]GN M. IH ZRN LN'N QNJG E-K Q=6N M" IH7>$IH LHR Z"$ % LNW. V.
MNI-H QNJG JN %N QN-UN JT]V^ LHR Z"$ LN7^$UN V. 7>%^] QNJG
JN *L GW.UN QV QNJ' HM G Q%>NR 7> JIW=VRQNVZN % QNJ'
LKW% %^] W"I-=6N %NE SEK X94N IG=VN
ZN%WVN G I- J^R' IWHN GN H]Z Q%NIG HNE V
$ *NRV MK HRGN
QNI-QN M" I-K J>]%*^ZK V QWVNR. GN QWVR' Q%NIG HNE V
$ M>]GN
QN IRMN M"
EIH% H"K IWY]S%N M" IH IWW(N M" IH IR3KAZ>%KQ. ZM.J>R3. W
QWVNR. G LKW% HNE IW=X 7> Z$ G 3N3% IWW(N W L%VN % 7>%4.
GK IG* U=E. W QNGR3. 7>aV I;QN% %MK$ IG=VN QV 7>%.4  G Q]VRI;QN%
M
' 7>aV G>U' 7>VNM %NE 7>%.4  GK J^LN 3>R^ HR J^L' E=U U- I-M *K
I-=H IWY]S%. IH QK$ LKW]V QV Z$ RIM]G 7>%4. GK %MK$ Z]%G QJKV^
7>%4. GN IWR
; W QJZN% MK HRG RM M. H>0 WNR(K V=VW L%VN %^]
*TIZV HRH JRZ ]V %^] SG%NZ HRH SN;H S'G M% I-M 7>IHV MR
>=U IW=X XIRVNR( M>]GK QN-K M" QV Q=L *K M
 RMK M"
L
 ZM.J>R3 M,NR. H31. %^] IM' HR QNJ'K VJ=IQN W IV V
QIY=U RIM]GN M" 7>%4. GK U=E QIV %MK$ M
 HGK IV 7>aV QIY=U
RIM]G M
- -KN ZKM % QNJ' RKR IW=X IH=E. GK I*Q]HR JK9N %^]
0=IEQN >HRNV % ,IMR GN IJQNEN JKVN 3TK RNZ V(N 3TK IHT3% LK %^]
*K NV%NW. GN I3HNR M
'N IJQN
-KN ZKM % IHMN K IH /A
IJT(WK QV QNHN3 1E HG M%
/A
^RL GN Q1=E I;.V M" 7>G"AQV 7>M *K I%RV M
 HGN M" EIH%
ZRKQ. U=E. HGK 0^PKQ. %MK$ M
 HGKQ.#
3=,'
$C LHR Q=L G HR
9. ZN%W 7> JRZV=VW G IUQNVN ]V %^]
<^]YH WKHNR HR 7>%4. G G= J(NQ%>NR QNJ'K LKW% 3"EK %^] >;NR
E" ' U  V. J^ R   IW3W IW= X  G*NW%. QNJK *N-KAXNRN IGQN V(N
G*UVK GN WNVNWR' M
 LN- U N WRVZN% GN ZN%W S> = ; KLKWK M"
I-E-K 7> ]V G IWXNR. %^] QW3 WKHNR HRUN V(N ;]% M
-UN
7>M ]V M" LUV U>R^ V=VWGR3K ]V RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL IHTJN J94% ]V
RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL GK ]\IJV LKW%K L
 RW *IW=\SN'KQ. 7>aV \RK
7> a VR RMK M" 

]V RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL GN ]\IJV LKW% JTKX"


] V  RNZJNE LK GN L%Z  V] S R  %] ^  IJ] Y  ;%N%N ILE4 N

166

IW3W IWL V N ] V


%KJ=V MIRQN'N IW=X I-=H IHN% JIRWNR IW=X M
I-QN J94N-K J^RK
HRH  MIRQN'N JT . V IW= X  I] X N-K IW*NU IW= X  L^ % KQR I-] L K%KQR GK
J
 1 7> a V   NE V= H  H] Z  HKVN ] %   IW= X  JRZ ] V  RNZG
WN%]G LK V
$ %NZ GN% JTNJV HKVN QV V%AZ% EUN H WNZK RNZNG
WN%] G  LK G> Q NRN G=  K U-K *UVK ZNRU %NE N;%N HKVK QV
JT Z NVZN GN 3N\3NVHNR HKVN
] V  RNZJNE LK %] ^  %NZ GKH3N  FRWRK  %] ^  F= U ' ZMK%
GK QZNW= I QN %^ ]  RNVRK IW= X  JT N JV M
- K 7>   Z $  ] V  RNZJNE LK
ZMNRNL GK 7>ZR  NE GK K 7>JG3 IGW GKH3N IGW  %^] ]V
ZV IW= X  7> J G 3 K *UV GN QNI;QVIZH L%ZIG% Z] I %QN L.GN M" 
7> J R
H V IWWR' 3T K  %NVT  G Z GK 7>   *IW= \ WN'K %NE J^R' ZE
\.GN M"  L
 JT 3 P ] +  A V  IE\K M"   IL Z $  7>   V= V WIGT 3 1N
3NR% GN QI;QNVIZH L%Z M
WUNN 7>   IG% Q] ;  R K QZNW= I QN M
- 
UK 7> Z$ 7> IW3W %VN GK 7>ZR    NE %MK$ M
WUK
7>M VR>' %MK$ M
WUN QR(NV 7>M JT
9 M
WUN QV 7>M  QV  NE
GK 7>ZR IW=X GK 7>ZR IW=X ]NR IW=X JTI=; M
WUN 7>M ]% 
M
W  U N
] %   IW= X  WNZK RNZG W N%] G  LK ZMNRNL %  QNJ%^ ]  IV] U
HR% GK QNIUQN IG=VK V(N ]%  IW=X %NZGN% HR% GK QNIUQN
JT G N% HKVK *UVK ZNRU IW= X  EK' M
'  G  HNR' L + -K GK J
 1 V
$
IVQNUJ=VR G IG=VN L
 MIRQN'N RHNR G>QNRN AA %]^ J=VR
HT Z Q] H  A IV(K AA G  VIMV IWHNR M"   ] %
 V
$   V= H  ] V  RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL %  [RA[R IJ] Y AIJ] Y 
%URA%UR IW= X  LNH  IV] U  HKVN SM> V  ] I \QN IW= X  Q%> Q N-K M

U- %NEA%NE IUQN%MK% ]V. GN IWR


; WK W=;GN IUQN ]% 
IW= X  IJ] Y  HR $ (N I,E4 N  R
M VH MIRQN'N  IW= X  VE
H  QN3RZ HR $ (N
GK (NJ%N HKVK V(N I-= H  L^ %   V
$   L^ %   V= H  JT Z  3 WR
HSKR LK G JTU1 IGW 7>aV =V IGW3K- IW3NE IV]U GN QN
L%
HRH  QN3RZ GK 3> R ^ Q NV HKVK V(N ZMK%  G  MR H  J^ R I'ZN %] ^  IV] %
IG% GN IV] U  3> R ^  HKVN G^ R AG^ R  V
$  3R;NE^  IV] U  > % ' QN7> '
E=U V(N V=VWIUQN% %]^ Z0H SM>A]I\QN IW=X Q%>QN-K S'% E=U
H>0 IG%. IW=X ]V RNZJNE ZMNRNL LK G Q%>QN-KQ. GK ]I\QN E=\.
IW= X  JM> ] X  U-K IL4 % . IUQN%MK' ] V . V  IR3KQ. G  Q%> Q N-K ] V
RNZJNE LK G  H
E  QN7> '  E= U   V(N Q%> Q N-K S'% E= U   IFR 7> % 4 .
QIUQN%K QXNRKQ. V(N ]V. %^] JT3% HR% E=U IH QNJ RW IUQN%
QNJ'  GUT ] ( N V
$  IWJRKV G=   RM  M

L> R W G  QI;QN-   Z] V R  IW= X  IEI\QN M"  IH J^ R ' JT Z NVZN
QNJ'  *UV G  RW QJRN; JNJ  %N3 Z> Q N_  HR IG] G N M" 
QNJGK J>VH L
 IH QK$ \RKGK M" 7> IW=X IEI\QN M" IH JTZNVZN
QNJ' *UV G JNJ %N3 %MK$ HRGN QNJGK J>VH =IVQNR( JTHN3

IUQN% U] U N

167

Z>EN  IW=X IEI\QN M" IH ^RL 7>aV IJT(WK GK VR. Z%>=\ V(N M
R
JT N 'K WN HRG  M% I-  JT H NR IJT ( WK GK VR4 .  RW JGNR( M%
SN` S`KX   %GK 0R%  QNIG HK I-M ] * W M"   JIW= V R L> R W G
QI;QN-  Z]VR  IW=X IEI\QN M" IH JTZNVZN IMRKR M" QU%
V%>R QI IW3'W" VWZ 
Z V%>R QI@ I- Z]VR IW=X G
 SNR
UWNMK IG=VK M" IH JTZ3WR IMRKR M" 7> QZR J>R3 JTZNVZN GN
RW G JNE' HR% E-K RKR M" QR(NV JTZNVZN LG QNJ' *UV.
%]^ V=VWIUQN% Z0N7>' G E-K H>0 Z$ QIV(K R^J IW=X I- ]NR
IW=X QN7>$GN M" V. QNJ' WNVIWH VL
Z-K RKR 7>aV MEH VL J]>L
GN RKR JNH QN7>$GN M" I-E-K 7>JR
HV Z]VR IW=X G
 SNR JTZN'
IG=VN M" I-VR4. G VRH V
$ I%R7>VR M
H QNJ' QIUQN% GN JRGN
FN M
'  G  *" Q  HRH  7> % 4 .  QIUQN%K ] V . ZM] V . V  QXNRKQ. %
IVE
H  QN3RZ HR $ (N G  QNJN G  IJ] Y . IW= X  ] V  RNZJNE LK
ZMNRNL LK %] ^  SG%NZ HR% G  E-K G> R JT X NR HR%N QNR] *  HR IG= V N
V(N AA %] ^  ] V  RNZJNE %] ^  LN% V
$  ZNR% V(N QN3RZ %] ^
%31 HR% G  E-K QNJ V(N QNJ'  Q%> Q N-KQ. V
$  IVE
H  QN3RZ
7>aV MZEN HRWNI-QN J>IE % R
H' GK H
I33 HKVK IL HNR% H>0
E
H L?ZK M
 U- RHNR % IVE
H QN3RZ %]^ QNJ' Q;K% E" IEQN
V(N ]V RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL V H>0 Q%>QN-KQ. 7>aV 0^PN H S'N H
LE4 IW=X JN IG=VN I- JTHNR ]%  IW=X ]V RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL
IWI\QNV M
- *E MK Q%LN'N % 0^P QR
J EUNH ]V %]^ JTI=; HKVN
JT]V^ ]V I%RG
3 M" IJQNR JNPH
 %NVTGZ  GK *IW=\WN'K %]^ J94H

X
U IH ]V RNZJNE LK %^] I-]%N SG%NZ HR IG=VN M" IHW$ 3]*W M
W
UN IH IW3W %^ ]  IUQN% JT X NR HR U N 7> % 4 .  %] ^  JT N (%N M"  IH JT Z NVZN
JE IW= X  JT  I(VK SGE HGN M" 
HSKRNMS SM
VM"S]G  H>6^ %.MK
RN-KJRSVHRJRSVIFRRN-K@
JTZ3WR HSKR LK QNJ' S=IXQ. G 7>;NR G E-K LEGK MK ZNL
%] ^  V= V WIUQN% G> Q NRN WNVIWHVN V
$  JT K IXV HRWN7> ' U   IFR J^ R N
IW3W ] V  RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL G  IUQN% GN E
M N Z] %  U N
] V  RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL ] %   V
$  Q?SNR. V  1K+WK+ X" $ %E.
G ZNI;QZ %NE IV IUQN% GN JTXNR HR M
R ;RZ U>R^Q. %^] HIM RM
M% IH QNJGN IUQN% 3NVR IWR> = ;  QR(NV QNJ *UV ZNL %] ^
3NVR RIMV J^LN HRWN RM M
 QV G
3K S' RM M
 L Z"$ UEV HIM
IRMN M. V. I- GN LWNS IG7> Q=L V=H IH WK ]V % LWNS G' GK
IM] Z V %MK$ HKVK
] V  RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL %] ^  I-+] +  ] %   IW= X  QHV^ S R
ZMK%  G  JIME  ST I MJVKWNR %] ^  QXN%H JT  R 'N M
- K IH RW ;RZ.
G  GUT ] ( . GN UIMRN-K %NE QI;Q" %  HR# I- QN;NR 7> a V  * V
$
JIME. JIW= V R 3T K ZG *UWGUKVN LK GN QI;Q" %  HKVN V(N J>  VH

168

IW3W IWL V N ] V

UMRK %,R UKVN Z$# GK RX%N HKVK V(N 7>K QN;NR 7>aV * V
$
JIME. RNL(N% JT.V G L
;J>R 3IMR IW=X ZNRX  IW=X IV]U
3>R^ HKVN I-E-K %NVTGZ LK % IHMN M" IH IW3W ;NRIZH IM]G^ ]V
3NR%  J] L NM NE GK 7> Z R IW= X  QR(NV  U   IUQNVN M
H 
JT X NR HR U N ] V  RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL GN L%Z JIW= V R IM] G ^  ;RZ
IW=X ]% -K+]+   IW=X  IV]SR %]^ IJ]Y ;%N%N ILE4N 
%KJ=V
JT . V MIRQN'N *NRV  IW= X  I-= H  IHN% JIRWNR IW= X  M
I -QN I-
JTHNR ]%  IW=X ]V RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL GK 7>ZR  NE S'GK
M" 
 %NVTGZ G Q%>NR \RK M" I-E-K 7>M IW3W ;NRIZH %VN
]V RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL MK M% IL%4. GK QI;QH3VN IW=X *NRVWR3
J^ R   IW3W 7> a V  RNL HR U N J^ R   IW3W IW= X  I-= H  MK IUQN% *UVK
ZNRU  X= E  U N I-= H  MK HN%] ^ %  M
W  U N H
- K G> \ K %MK$ RM U N IW3W
IW=X J^R' 3.VK M
WUK  L
 IWR
; HR'U Q]V IW=X 7>M WK J3XNVNJ
HR'U  V(N V= V WIUQN% %] ^  WKHNR HR% E-K S S =   M
' U  QV  RW
ZN%W ZNL ZN%W ;RZ GN JNE' HRUN QV J^R' Z
H3 JTNJV HRH
VE
H  LN'U 
IL V=VWIUQN% G IW3 IW=X %NVTGZ LK % QNJ'K *IW=\WN'K
IW= X  7> E  \  HKVN M"  IH 7>   IW3W IWL V N ] V  G  G> Q NRN G=    3NVR
JT Z NI'V V= V WIUQN% G  NMZ'  J^ R W G  RW ] V  I%3J= H 3 QFE
M
 LN'U V(N * %]^ 0>=H'N M
H 0>H'N JWUN 7>K G IW3 IW=X JTZ
3WR HSKR S] G K 6
9  LK %  QNJ'K Q] I ZT V WN'K IW= X  JIW= V R HSKR
NUR# UT]( IW=X L
 ]V ;RZGN LK G>QNRN E=U*U  NE J^RW
IE=JKS=; HKVN IUQN M"  IHMN M" IH I-=H Z$ QN-UN LG J^R IW3W
IW= X  Z R N MK IUQN% X= E  U N J^ R N IW3W 3.VK J^ R WH *UVK HR U N
QNJ IW=X IW33 JTZ M
WUN IV>U L"N Z. WR' >U  M
WUN
JT Z  3 WR HSKR S] G K6
9  G> Q NRN G=    U-  IUQN% %] ^  ] V  RNZJNE LK
ZMNRNL % ZI0QN M" I- IUQN% G IW3 IW=X HSKR NIMS LK %
QNJ'K SN'K IW= X  IHMN M"  IH /A
HSKRQRIUQN%SIUQN%9KHSKRIUQN%
 IUQN%
L" U
ENV
SHNHRVNXE Z"GN%@
*NWQR( M" IH I-M V=VWIUQN% I-]%N JTS=E M" IH I-G NMZ'
M
R ]V. QV IR3KQ. GN IUQN% I1H %MK$ JNWUN ILW$ V
J ]VR GN
U
EN IL=( WK IURGN M" 7>a( RW IHIEQ. V=H %^] <NMH NF Z"GN% S'N
IG] G N M" 
 I-MK JT Z N' ] V  URKSGN LK 6> 9 N%K I,E4 N  0= L R MIRQN'N
WNE  % IG=VN M" IH IVU>R^ V=VWGR3K ]V JTZ3WR HSKR S]GK 6
9
GN * I LQN M
I -QN  IG= E K Z] Y E IW= X  QN- U N
URKSIVU>R^ IG=EKZ]YEQN-K^VK;R%K^ZLUN-K
JT Z NVZN GK *UVK IS%. H] L ^   M
 U-  IWQHVKQ. %] ^  LUN- U N
IJ] Y  ;%N%N I,E4 N  
% KJ= V  JIME  IG= E K IW= X  J" $ GN K I-E-K ] V

IUQN% U] U N

169

URKSGN LK ZMNRNL % IHMN M" IH IVU>R^ WNVIWH IUQN% LN%'
WNEN ]V QR(NV V=VWIGT31N ]V  IG==EK Z]YE IW=X QN-UN IFR IHMN
M"  IHA
NIMSHSKRV?V\WNNIG=EKZ]YEEKL WNN
*NWQR( M"  IH JT Z  3 WR HSKR S] G K 6
9  G  V?V GRSNR  GN
\WN % H R  QR(NV JT Z  3 WR GN %> ] Z .I-GN JT V KI%;K  IG= E K Z] Y E
IW=X WN HRUN QR(NV 7>a( 7>VJ]% M
WUN
N JT ( Z QNJ'  IM] G ^  S] ; ^ Q .
%]^ V=VWIUQN% V
$ JTKIXV HRWN-UN S>=;KZN% IM]G^ I- VR4.
LNU'U  ILW $  H
- K M9S9N H  LNUGN M
W   QR(NV 7>   ] V  G  G> Q NRN
G=    U-  V= V WIUQN% %] ^  Z0H  QIWE] S  7>  GK 3R' UT I M' HR%U
 IFR J^ R N IW3W 7>   V= V WGR3K IM] G ^  ] V  G  IUQN% %] ^  WKHNR
HR U N I-M *IW= \ SN'K %NVTGZ LK % *K HKVK M" %NVTGZ LK
% I-M WK IEI\QN M" IH Z"%]^ G=>\ I- U=E GN M" IH 7> V
$ LN'^ %N M
'
G  HNR' Z R N 3NR% V= V WIGT 3 1N ] V  7> J  H 3N GN JNVR S' U N M
S> = ; KZN% ZN%WC 7>  GK 7> J  H 3N %N HR
  7> M  V. I] [ N'3( HRH
QN3' 7>aV ISPNH  QRN; GW I-31GW  R^J IW=X ZN' HR' 
U M"
7>M IM]G^ ;NRIZH ]V 3NR% QNIG J>R3 J^R' JTZNVZN  GN Q%>QN-K
LUV GN VNR'MNR M" 
%NVTGZ LK *IW=\ WHVN % J>VH FN A 7>aV IV]% 3SG.
GN 7> E  \  HKVN M"   IHMN M"  IH 7> M  IW3W IWL V N V= V WIGT 3 1N ] V
HR^ R X] G R QR(NV HNE GK G> \ GN-K *^ Z K V
$  6> Y N H  QNJ'  QNIG
Q%NIG J^ R WL. G  %NE WNIR S'N- U N V(N Z> H VK IGEN- U N I-= ( 
7> J G 3  Z] V R G  W= E  WK ] H  V  M"  IH 7> M  3NR% H W E IV] %  3SG
7>ZAV=VAIV  MK Z]VR LNJ GWUN I-%4. IV]% 3SG. G %NE Z>HVK
GN H
-K M
R 3SG %MK$ IXJHNWUN I-MK JTZN' JIW=VR IR=UWG Z]YE
 > H V  Z] V R  IW= X  NZW G  E
H  ] I \QN  QV  3T K ZG
*UWV UKVN QI;QN-  E
H  IW=X M" IH J^R' ]V V=VWGR3K
]V  IV]% Z]VR 7>ZAV=VAIV IL]%4. IW=X V=V V(N IV ]HIVH M"  G
H J^R' JTZNVZN QNIG J>R3  GK *UVK HRWNH LKW HK HNE LNE V
$
Z>HV HRWN7>$GN M" IFR 7>M N;H GK *UVK HZN-K H SE %NE 7>a(
XEN L.GN M" IL=( QNIG I3T31K G Q=6 JTN'K RIM]G M% I-=(
$ I-M LKW
QNJ'  J^ R WL. %] ^  6= Y H  HR^ R X] G R HNE JT * ^  G  %NE QN H  I-
G>\GN-K E
H IW=X F H H31 7>aV H31 7>PN IRMN M" %NVTGZ LK
% I-M WK J=31 HKVN M" IH Z=; HNE QR(NV IWXEK JK94K IM]G^ ;RZ
GN QNGR3 LKW% LK7> ' U   3NR% V= V WIGT 3 1N ] V  QNJ'  IUQN%
%NE G"IGJZN% 7>V]U 7^aXN WR^J QR(NV 3RW3T31 3NVR Q%>H^E
*UVK IW;N% IFR V
$  IS%N 3RV 7> L NUR HRWN- U N QV  ZN%WK
]  IHT V K QR(NV ZN%W ;RZ G  E= 6 ' I%R
; H I%3HJ1 *NW %NE
] W NR U N Z= ; IEQN HNENV IM] G ^  ;RZNX  QV  IM] G ^ I XQN QNGR3WV
0NE E AI-M ZRNPK *N3N IW= X  FN  7> a V  IEI\QN M"  IH 8JR
H V

170

IW3W IWL V N ] V

*NWQR( M" IH IWXEK JK94K GN 7>GNR 3NR% HRUN I-M 7>E\ 
GK IM] G K IE\'N RIM IUQN K I-E-K I-= (   IE\ IG= V N M"  V(N
J=31KHR' WK IG=VN M" I-MK JTZN' J^R' JTZNVZN HSKR LK % IHMN
M"  IH
;RZGNV
M EN\G>MN-KNRIUQN%WNR3SGHMK$SNMR%NLN-K
NR%NZSNMRL
 JRMKIWXEKJK94KM]%MK$VRMK@
NRIUQN%VSV=H6>JN-KLSV=HGWNGJ](%NIZ=1LN-K
ILW$ -K+]+ ]%   IW=X *NRV Q]URL. V
$ Z>HV M
I-QN K
7>   V
$  JIME. IM] G >  VN% IW= X  I= I \QN %MK$ K ] %   IW= X  ] V
RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL %]^ JTZ3WR LK % IJT(WK 7>aV *ILQN ]% 
V
$  JIME. HE> U  GK JIMEK JK94 K  LN'
$  V(N  V
$  IWXEK JK94 K
QNR]* M
-K I-M I-=H MLNR NE V=H IV *UVK HRUK I- GRN%
L
 J^R' I%3X" G %NE *UVK HRUN 7>M IVE
H XEN LNWUN L
 VE
H
%MK$ LN H V(N HGK *UVK HKVK HG 6=Y IG=VK JT]V^ U>R^ ;T
MK %MK$
M

I - 7> M  IFR MLNR. Z%> = \  L%Z I- HE> U  IW= X  JT N JV HR%U
IH7> $ IH I-M 7> % 4 .  GK 3NVRIW;K Q%>  NR N;%N GN JIR'NZ M
W  U N
I- JTHNR H-K MLNR. NE. V=H HE>U GN Z. WRVNZN% V
$ WK X]UN
X= E  U N IFR Q] V  GK JK94 K  *UVK RIMV 7> V J] %  M
W  U K IH7> $ IH 3> *
HZN-K L
 *UVK > U  IW= X  HKVK 7> M  SNRA L%Z JT N JV HRH  \RX
ZNJV  HR IG= V K M
W  U K I- JT H NR HE> U  G  Q] V  GK JK94 K
QIHT V ['K M
W  U K 7> M  *UVK %MK$ HR H U K I-E-K IHMN M"  IH
M>' HE>U GK IWXEK JK94K XE RMK M"  V
$  ]%  V
$ 7>M
3NR% * G  NMZ'  JT U 1 M
 X= > H N M"   7> M  M"  ] V  RNZJNE LK
ZMNRNL#
7> J R
H V IUQN% L
 IWXEK JK94 K  V  JT ( Z V(N Q] I VZ JK94 K  WNEN
]V RNZNJNE LK ZMNRNL QNJ' JTWX%. IW=X NE. V
$ G=G QN RM M%
L
 M>' %NVTGZ LK GK *IW=\WN'K % WK J=31 HR IG=VN I- E-K
]V URKSGN LK ZMNRNL % IHMN M" IH A HSKR JTZ3WR GK *UVK
J^R' ]V V
$ 7>JG3 E" H HR
 %MK$ V. I-M QWR I_R %MK$ QNWUN
URKSZ0NM" V
 IR;RJ.WSM>R%MK$R -NGNW@
*NWQR( M"  IH L H R QNJ V= V WIUQN% %] ^  Z0 U-  M
 V. IR
7> a V  J" R  R= \ H  QR(NV QIV3K[RVN %NE V= V WGR3K ] V  RNZJNE LK
ZMNRNL V
$  7> J G 3  E"  H  QNJ'N HIEQN' HRWN7>   I-M 3> *  QWR
IFR JTNJV %MK$ M
WUN ILW$ I-M IWXEK JK94K Z=; HNE  WNEN Z.
QV QNJGN ZN%W RKR V(N V=VWIGT31N ]V JTU1 M" LHR M>' WK
*UVK ZNRU 7>aV %MK$ E=U
U V. 7>G IW3 IW=X IHMN M" IH/A
M]NRZ0GN%NMK$HIM]GN3NZG>JMR %]^
URKSGNMWHVLNVM"R
W
U I-JIMR %]^>@
*NWQR( M"  IH ] V  URKSGN LK ZMNRNL HIM RM  M% IH I-M
*
EN ]NR 3NVRIW;K RIMV N;%N HR IRMN M" L
 SM>V G>\GN-K M"

IUQN% U] U N

171

I- %]^ >\GN-K Z0 RM M% ILW$ L^% ZMK% G>JIMR IG% G SNR4.
WL  IW=X ;>=J IW=X \9NA LE IRMN M" 7>K %]^ 6. G= IRMN M" ILW
$ H
-K 3RNSK IWQHVK 3RNS JK H 9H 7>aV IJQN M" QV 7>%]^ H
-K
HM IH QNJ G>JIMR GK ;>>=J IW=X IH7>$ LE RM M
 6. IW=X XE
 7>M
3RNS G %3 IW=X HIM]GN M" IH %MK$ 3NZ M" H
' HIM]GN M" IH G>JIMR
M" "   I-K JT H NR L
 N;H 3NVRIW;K IVQNUH  Z%ZN%K J^ L N HR RM
M% 7>M QNJ'N LKW% %31 HR RM M% 7>%]^ IVQNU'N %MK$ XNM>]G
SEIH 7> %]^ RW3T31 Z]%H HNE G E
H IW=X G>=\. GK Q=U IW=X LE
RM M% ]V URKSGN LK ZMNRNL HIM RM M% IH I-]% JTZN' IZE'
G SNQG WK IVN;%N J^R' ]V G G= Q%>NR %MK$ HR
U V. I-M
Q%Z
E Z%>=\K RKR V(N IWXEK JK94K GN *UVK >U M=( IW=X
$ I%HE
LNW U N IFR I- Z $  %] ^  NG HRH  R
W
U    SM> V  J3V8U   IFR H> 0
%MK$ S' U N JT Z  3 WR HSKR LK S] G K 6 9  LK %  IHMN M"  IH/A
QN6 IG%JN6" U-IVU>R^  IHQN%NMV
QSJ6VNWNIHQNHRLSIX9KQNX>=UU-K?V@
RW ZN%W ZNL %] ^  JT N (%N HRG  M. IH J^ R ' ] V  RNZNJNE LK
ZMNRNL %]^ JIMXN'
 V(N QNJ' V QNJ' JIRWNR GN HIEQN' HRWN7>
QNJ'  IR3V G NR. V(N G
 V. %] ^  WK IEQN7>  V(N J^ R ' Z
H 3 JN7> 
WR' > = U  QNR] *  M
 X= > H N M"   E= \ . J> ] %  QNVZNW. ] V  RNZJNE LK
V=VWGR3K ]V %]^ JIMXN' H IV *UVK HR RM M% 7>M QIV >=\K
M
 U-  M% RW IWHNR 6= Y H  I%RZE LKW% LKQ RM  M%
IHTJN Q=U J94
 ZM.RN31R G L
VIV3 3NVRK GN ZRNPK *N3N IW=X
%VT  G Z GKQ. *IW= \ SN'KQ. GN Q%> W NG

I I

172

JTZN' G E-K G\


 F
1
 HNJK

IUQN% U] U N

173

174

JTZN' G E-K G\


 F
1
 HNJK

IUQN% U] U N

175

176

JTZN' G E-K G\


 F
1
 HNJK

IUQN% U] U N

177

178

JTZN' G E-K G\


 F
1
 HNJK

IUQN% U] U N

179

180

JTZN' G E-K G\


 F
1
 HNJK

IUQN% U] U N

181

182

JTZN' G E-K G\


 F
1
 HNJK

IUQN% U] U N

183

184

JTZN' G E-K G\


 F
1
 HNJK

IUQN% U] U N

185

186

JTZN' G E-K G\


 F
1
 HNJK

IUQN% U] U N

187

188

) (NR( IUQN% JT H N3 IW3

(NR( IUQN% JTHN3 IW3


JTZ3WR G IW3 IW=X 3NVR HK G=G M%
JT*^AWNZKA-K3ARNZA\>GNAQ=E4NAR=SAZNIEHANIMSAGWA
*UWN%AUY I-M * 3HVK S
;H 3SG M% L
 I*]%AI*]% *N3NW. IW=X
7> X NR' HKV  V(N IE\  L.G  M%

M%
JT*^# GK ZIMZN V
$ JTVH JTN'K JT*NIWV M" IH H
-K 3HVK M" L

JRZ >=\GNI-H V(N H31 I%WNRH M" 7>M H


' M" H"N M" IH=( M"
IHW$ IZEGN M"I-M JT3%WNXH IX]%4 QL V=H J^R' R^J %NE %MK$ M1
JNI-QN I-M 3]HN I- J>VH %NE J^R' R^J %NE ZNJV M
 LNWUK
L
 3HVK Q]%4 %]^ Q=\. JTGN% HR U^]U %]^ QNWN, SIMR %]^ H]%.
%NE RW% HRN GW S.0 %]^ J>=VR GW I%R;% %]^ ;]%WN% S'N GW R
UK
%]^ W( HR ILG LHR GR3% M
 LN' V. QIVQN%]G M
W L
 RW
ST I MZ] Y . GN RX%MNR J^ R ' 3.VKGNI-H LUV U> R ^  V(N RWU M" 
ILGK QNIUQN IS%. J=VN WK %MK$ IM=E HGN QR(NV RW3HVKZN%
ILG  NMZ'  H> 0  WK Q] * W %MK$ M"   Q"    U> '  IL IW= X  M% 7> M
WNVW IW= X  JT * ^  WNZK -K3 RNZ *UWN% \> G N Q= E 4 N  RMKZ
ZNIEH R=S U Y  HMN7> $ GN M" 
I-=( I-=H U=E IW33 IWXNR'K-$ M" IH IHK WK 3HVK GN IUQN%
IHK 3NVR V
$ MK M]>GN M" 7>K 3NVR G QN;NR 7>aV U>R^L% QNJ'
Q%> Q N-KQ. %] ^  ZNRUGR3% HRG  M% 7> M  3NVR ;NRIZH J>  VH.
M% XNR
$  W G  IR= U W G  NZW G  L> R W G  Q= ( RWW G  3T K ZG *NUWV
UKVN 3T K ZG *NUWV > ; NNUR QP4 N R. J> R N' ZM.*NRV SN-KSE
H>RN' QNIG JTZNI'V JIW=VR 3NVR M% XNR
$ WG ?>G J^R' JTZNVZN
G  QNG 3  %NE L
V K I%R] L % HNE  %  Z] > G R G  Q] G R QNJ'  > Q N.
G>QNRN U>JV 6>JN IG=VN V(N JT(Z SNR NUR Z](% G Z$ I-M XNR
$
WG 3TK STMZN LK %]^ JTNJV M
- L
 STMZN LK 6R J>R3 G LP J>=VR
% J94 V(N L"N Z0 IHQN 7> QN;NR 7>aV ]NR IW=X IUQN% GN
JTXNR QNJ' W]3L. IR3KQ.  G G>QNRN HRWNI-QN J^R' JTZNVZN %
J]LW. WZ# ^\3Z  WG WK STMZ HNE  %]^ IG=VN K L
 I- L
VK
I%R] L % %  QNJ'  H
E  U> J V R= I \QN V(N 7>  %] ^  ZNJV HR IG= V N
H> 0  Z $  7> J R] V  QR(NV I-= H  HEJ I-= H  MLNR XV> R > = U  G
SNQG IV]% E
H IJT(WK E
H WRU E
H JNVNE E
H  G RW JTN'K
JTE"Q IW%N3  M
 L.G M% IFR L
VK I%R]L% HNE  G I%RG3 %NE
ST M ZN QNJ'K RNVT K  ZNJV M
'  7> a V  ST M ZN GK RNVRK I-= H  MLNR
XV>=R>U GK M]>GK M" V(N I-]%N MK IG%  LG IG% QNR]* M]>GN M" RL
U>'
V
$  JT * NIWV HRH  JT N 'KQ. GK 7> V J= V K IV] %
$  E
H . IW= X  3> R ^  HRGN M" 
VG IV>U GK 3>R^QNV IW=X 7>MK XNR
$ WG HNE STMZ  ?>G STMZN
%] ^  IFR JT G N% HRGN M"  V(N IFR JT I HT I VH 7> ( = E AJ> ( = E  G  HNR% XNR
$

IUQN% U] U N

189

JIW= V R W G . GN IUQN% ZNJV M


 L.GN M"   7>   G  IJ= 6
$  IFR Z $
Q%>NR M
R IR3KQ. IW=X JTW3 HRH G>SNRN IE\N7>$GN M" IFR WK Z
$ Q%>NR JTNIHTVH 7>(=EAJ>(=E G SNQG WNR(K E
H. G G>QNRN WG.
IW=X SGENQ HRH WNVW IUQN% ]NR V
$ E>JV HR IG=VN L.GN M"
7> M K HNE ST M ZAL
V K I%R] L %  ZM.*NRV > = ;  G  Z $  3T K  IHT 3 % IW= X
JT W  3  HRH  XNR
$  W G . GN ] \  I JV IWWR' 3T K ZG*NUWV UKVN G  R^ J
IW=X IG=VN V(N IHMN IH QRL>% I-MK IUQN% JIME. Z"$ ^RL %]^ IHMN
K 7>% QNJ' J>=VR W"W3WV QR(NV Z%^ %^] V(N W"W3WV QR(NV
Z%^ % QNJ' J>=VR I-3WNH^ %]^ IHMN K JT]V^ IW=XHNR IW=X I-M 7>VZ
IUQN% ZNJV M
 IUQN K
I- HNE ST M ZAL
V K I%R] L %  %  3T K  W G IWQN IR3K G  RKR
IW=X JTW3 HRH XNR
$ WG ZM.*NRV QP4NR. J>RN' 3TKZG*NUWVUKVN
3TK >;NNUR %]^ G>SNRN V
$ IE=JKS=; ]IHTV *N3N IW=X  HRWNI-QN L

Q= L  * %^ ]  7> J E= S ; M% I-M RW 3NVR 3T  3 P M% M> '  I-%4 .
3NVR. %]^ HE>UK IR3KQ. % *N3NA*N3 QR(NV IM]GK Q%>WNG HRH
QNJ' IWXNR IZEN7>' GK H

I33 HKVK M" L


 J=31 UEV IG\N-K IG]G
M% QV  IWQNI\QN %NE Z E  %MK$ \.G  M% I-M RW 3NVR
ZM.IR3K IWQNLK G> Q NRN E= U *U  J] L  M,NR IV] %    NE
J^RW G>SNRN IE\ U- K 7> Z$ IM]G^ ;RZ I-N-K ;RZ Z>EZN%
;RZ V  I= \  ;RZ QNIG H> 0  WK %MK$ % I-= H  W G . G  Z] % ' WNE
QNRKQN MK M
I -QN HRG  % HRZ QN;NR 7> a V  LNVK M] > G K K V(N
H W E XNR WR' H3= V RKAW" 3 AST M NZ' V(N 3^ G R  MK %
I-V
$  I-M VN JT Z NI'V M
 L.GN M"  IH I-M RW 3NVR IHK
;RZ L. IWQHVK IW3 3  E-K %MK$ M% I-M H W E ZN%W G  ZNVR
HIEQN' MV^ M% G^RN I-M JTZNI'V M>]GN M" IH NY J^RWL I-=H MK
% IL]%4. G ]HNR QNJ IW=X IZE L>E M%
RW JT(Z JIW=VR 3NVR UKVN LK 7>aV IWXNR HRG M.

JIW=VR UKVN LK GN IUQN% IH% IHMN


JIW= V R UKVN LK G  IUQN% %] ^  7>   Z $  S
I EQN IUQN K LG
ZM.*NRV GN > = ;  M
'  LN IRMN K QRL> %  %  > = ;  HR% V
$  I-%HNR
HR IG=VN K >=; IH7>$ M
 IRMN K I- >=; %]^ ;RZ>=; GK ]IUQN
WK %MK$ IG=VK LN HGK IH7>$IH G
 JIRWNR. GN ]J=VK IWVR' GN IW3
K HRW. V(N J.YWN GN ]J=VK GN S1WNRN %MK$ M
 IRMN K HRW.
%  J.YWN %]^ Q=;N RNL WK G' V
$ Z%4. HR IG=VN K G
M. J=\. GN IW=X
SXN8 HR% G E-K JT*^ 3TK IHT3% LK IV]% SNR 3.VK G^V S'H U-
JT]V^ G
%4
$ MK J=\ QNJ'KAQNJ'K IL=G 7>aV Q1=E % 3TK IHT3% LK %
>=; V
$ M
' WNEK MN%K %NE WK JTKIXV HRN7>$G M
- IHMN IH %N LN'
IH] % KQ. *" ' . IW;WN M
' UKQ. %N LN'  IH] %   S= X   Q%N( M
' U 

190

) (NR( IUQN% JT H N3 IW3

ZM.JNJ V
$  I-ENWN H> 0  WK %MK$ IZE U N > = ;  IW= X  %N LN'  H '  ZR 
H' SX VKRK SNR LG 3TK IHT3% LK Z0VN HRWN7>' U- V. G
%4.
J= \ . %  QNJ' A QNJ'K J= \  WNE  RNILQ. GK " % N IMV ^ X K J= V R
IG\NI-QN V(N IHMN IH I-]% RNL NY J=\ IW=X M% V(N I-]% NY J=\
IW=X LG 3TK IHT3% LK % GI\QN IH G
%4
$ MK J=\ 1 V
$ Z %MK$ M

RM M% >=; G E-K IVQNR M


 X>=H M% VG 3TK IHT3% LK % 
IXQN
IH I-=H GNQ M
R M" 7>M WK Q=L EUN IG]GN M. 3TK IHT3% LK % 
IXQN
IH IHV J.YW ZR 3]S];K M
' G HNR' QNJ'K IL=G I-E-K %MK$ 6=Y
RM M
' IH 3TK IHT3% NY %NE M% IL=V NYK MK M
WUK IH7>IH 3TK
IHT3% LK GK *"' >*=GRN LK GN IWQNM 3TK QRL>% %NE M
I-QN K 
3TK IHT3% LK % IHMN IH I-=H VR_ ZRK RW "%N M
WUK QV G^R
VR_ Z"$ M
W.UN QV I-G %NEA%NE Z"$ WX%W=; WK M. IH Z"$ MI(QNR
%MK$ 7> P NW.UN I- [
3 'N %NE J.YW. G  J" R . %KX  GK ,ZK% I\H
U-K 7>%4. %]^ E=IUQN IH M>' NYK JTNL I%3IXV M" I-M IWXNR HR
J] L
 J.YW I-M HIMH  *N V
$  SNMR U-  IH QK$ H> 0  IWXNR HR
E-K- H>0 Z$ 7>JR]V 3TK IHT3% LK %]^ *N V
$ SNMR QN7>' GK JTN(%.
HKVK 3TK IHT3% LK G SNMR QN7>' V J.YW. % IHMN IH M *UWN%C
N%]^ J]L IJ]Y IGEWN IG7> QK$ >=; %MK$ XNM>]G M. NYK I-=,V WK
RIM LNWUK V(N QNJ XNM>]G M
 IH >=; %N M
W I-M WK 1E LNWUN
J.YW. G I- F"E V
$ 3TK IHTD3% LK SM>V JT3]% M
- V(N 
IXQN
IH S>RN Z$ 1E IUQN *N IW=X HWE HRW V(N 7>%4. G ZT(H 3
3 % 3TK IHTD 3% LK % IHMN IH G>R
;% >=; 1E IUQN M" ZRK WK
I-M MNRIGH I-=6N K QNJ J.YWN %]^ J]L IJ]Y G IG7> 7>M HIM RM
M% IH QK$ >=; %MK$ XNM>]G G>R
;% % IHMN IH J.YWN E-K ^-K
GK %
H V>=E WK ,ZK% %MK$ M" L 7>%4. %]^ XNMKGK M" V. >=; G E-K
H^RH3VR G Z"GN% IW=X QN LN' I- U=E V
$ 3TK IHT3%LK %RN, M
H
IHMN IH V]^ I-]%N% %MK$ 3"VN% M" IH=( Q=;N RNL QV IH=( J]L IJ]Y
ZRK U=E Z]% E" J]L IJ]Y GG 3TK IHT3% V
$ %NRNL M
H G>R
;% % *N
IW= X  7> J I(V 
I ;Q. %] ^  QNIUQN IG= V K IH 3T K  IHT 3 % %] ^  JH9
 V(N
HNRNUNR IW= X  YNE IG7>   QNIUQN IZEG  MK 
I ;Q. %  IHT 3 % LK %] ^
XNR
$ VR_ V
$ [R IEQN 3TK IHT3% LK % QNJ'N IWRN1 R^J IG\NI-QN
IL HNR' RW 
;N V(N HRW YR H H>RKQ. G %KX [> U- V(N
RKR G VL JTHN3 %NE Q=\. S]G M
 U-KQ. 3TK IHT3% LK 7>a(
$ I%=HE
U- 
QN7>  IWXNR HR $ /A7> J R
H V IWRN1 R^ J  IG\N7> '  GN JT Z N' ] \  I JV
ZM.*NRV UKVN JT"a U
R\J>R V
$ JTHNI3V IW=X JTV=\ M" HR^H3VR G
Z" G N% IW= X  JIW= V R UKVN LK GN IUQN% > ' N7> $ G  Z $  QI;QN-  
E
H  IW=X JIW=VR UKVN S
E' WNEN JT*^ HIM IRMN M" IH QRL>%
Z" $  WI;QN M
I -QN HNE M. M> '  * E
H . %] ^  \N' E-K JT U 1 M
I -QN
M.#LRN 
X
 IH 3TK IHT3% LK V. JIME. V
$ MK 3TK QRL>% LK G %NE

IUQN% U] U N

191

K LHR JIW=VR UKVN LK G IUQN% %]^ 3TK IHT3% LK S
E RM M>]G V.
I-M %MK$ HIM]G IH M>' JTWRV M
I-QN M. 3TK IHT3% LK HNE %MK$ K
7>%4. G GR3% ZNVR MK Z%>=\ J3^ U. QNIG  JT3]% M
H 3TK IHT3% LK
H
E QN H IJQNR JN7>$G K IL%4. G GR3% IS%. U
JKQ. GN \N'N
JK'N 6>1 L.GN K I-E-K HNE H
-K M
R 3HVK M" 7>M 3TK IHT3% LK
G  RKR IW= X  JT  V W=   JT W  3  HRH  JIW= V R 3T K ZG*WUV UKVN LK G
IUQN% R^J IW=X XNR
$ JIW=VR WG. GN NR S
E IUQN 7> GKQ. I-=H
MLNR *> L NW. M% 3T K  IHT 3 % LK 3T K  IW3'^  LK G  QWVNR K IL] % 4 N
GKQ. XNR *>LNW. M"$ IFR QI;QN-  E
H  W  IW=X QRL>%
HIM IRMN M" IH *UWN%C QNJ V. IR3KQ. GWV.W. V(N I=;. %]^ WK
\N RM M
 L
 QNJGN MK U>'UN' JIW=VR WG. G Z]VR. G>QNRN 7>XNR'
HR RM M% V(N QNJ' LKW% GK R=I\QN G E-K Z]UE HNZ%N HR RM
M% H> 0  QNJGKQ. LN94 N  IW= X  E1H RM  M% H> 0  QNJG  Z> = \  IW= X
ZNQ RM M% M M]R SNM> QR(NV MLNR *>LN WNE *UWN%C QNJ
QNJ'  7>  K XV> R *> L  R^ J  IW= X  QN7>   Z" $  QNJG  IWHRNE R^ J  %] ^  G \ H
;KR, %MK$ HR JN IRMN M.
QI;QN-   E
H   IW= X  JIW= V R UKVN LK %] ^  S
E ' WNEN JT * ^
HNE HIM IRMN M"  IH M  QRL> %  I-M Z R N WNVIWH HNE R^ J  M" 
IL%] ^  V R   QIVIRHV JIME. IHK %  %MK$ G I \QN M"  #
7> J R
H V IWWR' V
$  I-= H  V= (  V. I-M I= ;  M"  IH H R W. GK *N
IW=X IWRN1 R^J 3TK IHT3% LK % IG\NI-QN K V(N I-=( >=; G Z"GN%
IW=X IWRN1 R^J HNE 3TK IHT3% LK G RKR IW=X JTVW= JTW3 HRH
QNJ'N IWRN1 R^ J  HNE  %  IG\NI-QN K %MK$ V. I-M %MK$ HIM] G N
IH I-M IWRN1 R^ J  V R   QIVT H V JIME. IH  %  %MK$ G I \QN M" 
IH7>$IH 3TK IHT3% LK QNJ'N IWRN1 R^J HRW. GK *N IW=X JIME. MK
IG\N X>=H K
G^RK U=E I-M I=; M
-K M" IH JIW=VR UKVN LK %]^ S
E' WNEN HNE
STMZAL
VK I%R]L%  M" %N IH 3TK IHT3% LK IH7>$IH 3TK IHT3% LK %
JIME. HG %MK$ IHMN IH Z"$ HNE M. V(N SNQG IW=X HGK %MK$ IHMN
IH Z"$ HNE M. 3TK IHT3% LK HNE %MK$ M
 HG 7>%4. G GR3% ZNVR
%] ^  MK G^ R A I-ENH  G  I-VRK V(N J> R 3 V9IFQN HRG  K
%
1 /A IWRN1 R^ J  HK M> ] G N M" 
IWRN1 R^J/ QNJ IG% G Z$ L. X.G%K RNV IW=X LG QNJG RKR
GK 6. 6
1K E=U*U RKR IL]%K E]SK M
W L. H>0 W=YK M
W 7> 6. G
K% WNE (N% 7>aV G
 IZ]1 V=H I-=H 1=H G\
 XNM Q=\. V
$ JN'K WK
IH7> $  %N IUR   IFR NMZ'  QNHN3 GK VR_ G \
  QNJ%] ^  QNJGN MK
IWRN1 R^J IG\N-K GWUN L
 _G R]U GN QNZN% %]^ 6]^ IRMN M
WUN
I-K JT H NR JT V  H  ZN%W QNJ'N IWRN1 R^ J  R= \ GN M"   JT ] V ^  IL%4 .  GK
*UVK 3HVK ILQNGN M
WUK 7>%4. GN 7>%N MK VL QI;=H M>]GN L.GN M"
I-K JT H NR 3T K  IHT 3 % LK WK J^ R W GK *UVK 3HVK %NE I= ; K

192

) (NR( IUQN% JT H N3 IW3

>HV % 7>%4. % WK QNJ'K I=;K 3HVK %NE QNJ'N IWRN1 R^J JTU1
HR IG= V N L
 HNE G  V ,
Z -K RKR IWRN1  V
$  [= 1  V L Z-K K
VKRK U=E I-=M I=; M
I-QN IH JIW=VR UKVN LK S
E' WNEN JT*^ HNE
M]RSNM> QR(NV MLNR *>LN >HV M" V(N 3TK IHT3% LK V. 3TK IW3'^
LK G QWVNR % L
 XNR *>LN >HV M% 3TK IW3'^ LK 
E4. HEN >HV
M% V(N 3TK L
VK I%R]L% HNE *UWN% I-=H MLNR HEN >HV M" L"
I-=H S=ES  WN1 GN M>]GN M" I-=H S=ES  WN1 GN M]>GN M" I-=H
S=ES  WN1 GN M>]GN M" R3%K NR S=ES. GK M]>GK M" JT]V^ SM>V
Q]VR M>]GN M" PKH I-K JTHNR G
%4
$ JT*^Q. GK 3HVK V(N IWRN1 R^J
GN V L  I*] % AI*] %  K
I- V=VWIUQN% G JTNJV M
' V
$ JIME. L
 UKVN LK G IUQN% %]^
Z0N7>' WNE ZMNVZN LK K 7>%4. V
$ I-M GN RNZJNE GN  JT3%
HIRQN HRGN K IH JIME. V. *UWN% 3T K  IHT 3 % LK IV] %  SNR 3.VK
G^ V  S' H  U-  K V(N IHMN K IH > = ;  HR%N ZM.JNJ M"   LG 3T K
QRL> %  LK %  QNJ > = ;  HR% V
$  Z%4 N  HRG  M
-   IHMN K IH G W HK
%]G% Z"$ >=; %MK$ HR%N XNM>]GN NMZ' \94 *L%. V %NIVQ. V(N
"I%H. GN M
' WNEN IW%N3 G\H Z"$ Q1=E F"EN HR IEQN M" IH Z"%]^
IV] %  E
H  GN RNL WK JT N JV M
W   V. WK Z" $  > = ;  %MK$ HRNU. Z" $  V.
XNM>]GN M. IH Z"%]^ I%M=( %]^ G>R
;% QNIG VKR %NE ZNR G' V. IH
ZRK IZTV^ %NE >=; IW=X M
' WNEN IW%N3 S=X LNW M 3TK IHT3% C Z"$
> = ;  %N HRH  *K\ GN *
L % \NH  U> L NRN HR%N PKH Z0GN M. M
IHT3%C *L%. %]^ ZNRH V. JNJ %^] JTNJV M
W.U ZRK S>=;K H]Z HR%N
S]G HR U-K M" QNJ NY U>R^ M
 Z"$ QNJGN I33 M. QNJ NY L

IM=V IW=X M
W 7>MK ENM IG7> JT]V^ Z"$ %MK$ Z]%GN M. IH QNJGK H
-K
ENM Z"%]^ >=; G E-K RN,K HR JN-UK QR(NV Z"$ >=; %MK$ HRNU.
JTZN' JIW=VR UKVN LK QI;QN-  E
H  V
$  V(N QI;QN-
 E
H  A
IFR 3TK IHT3% LK IW=X JTW3 HNE SNRA HIM IRMN M" IH QRL>%
HNI-R ZV S' >=; HR L. V. >=; IW=X ZRH WRU %]^ JTNJV HR
L. > = ;  IL= V  H  IJT ( WK G  RNL %^ ]  *
U  $ UN QNIGAQNIG HIM H  Q"  N
I*Q] H R IW%N3 HRWN IG= V N L
 Q= L  V= H  G  ] V .AZMNVZNW. V(N
I*QH E
H . G  XIR= V R IW= X  E= * ' 7> a V  WK %MK$ IZEGN VG 7> M
%NGN% U> R ^  LK %KZAMHKZ  IHMN HRG  K IH QRL> %  H3= V RK ;RZ
%]^ IVQNU IRMN K I-V
$ H3=VRKVW %]^ MN%K V(N ^RWKRVN GN GN
E-K IW%N3 M
 L.GN QRL> %  %] ^  H3= V RK ;RZ JNE' HRWN7> '  E-K
I-M ZM.*NRV GN >=; 3TK IHT3% LK % HRWNI-QN K JIME. V. Z"$
I- %NGN%. WNEK HMN'K 7>aV X>=J M
 L.GN K IH7>$IH Z"%]^ W"$ IUQN%
%MK$ K
J>%R IWXNR HR
/A*UWN% 3TK IHT3% LK QNJ H3=VRK K H] GK
M=IVQN G SNQG 3TK Q=UR% LK % Z(>RN GK W.UAY
R QNJ' G
MV 3TK

IUQN% U] U N

193

IHT3% LK %]^ ]*NE IG=VK K I-=H IG% %NRG LK % 3TK IHT3% %]^ G=IQN
IH I%H1 MK I-= H  U> F N IW= X  I-= H  I= ; K > H V RNH33 RNLN Z> X H] G

I -QN M
I -QN M"   7> M  6  ZMK%   $ GN M"  V(N 6  ZMK%  LNUGN M" 
LNU' 7>aV 6 ZMK% 7>M >=; HRGN M" V(N 6 ZMK% ' G Z$ LHR
H
-K 7>GK %K$G \RNS HR GW V. Z>XH]G GKQ. Q=\. V
$ QU%K SN'
> = 1 G  M% V(N NMZ'  WNEN V> R ] V  IZT V ^  %] ^  JT N JV M
 L.GN M"   QNJ
NW;N% RIM'N I-M HIM H  T K  %NRG LK XE  U- 
H> 0  Z $  G  7> J R] V  3T K  IHT 3 % LK %] ^  6
1 K 7> Z R IW= X  Z(> R N G
I] [ N% 7> a V  S" P N G \  I-= H  HNEW% %NZH RNLN %  QNJ'K QP4 N R.
HR
9 "%N E" H Z(>RN 7>aV QNHRZ' HR IG=VN 3TK IHT3% LK % G
I\QN IH G>3Z' GK "%N SM>A]I\QN IW=X M" V(N %N LN' IH]% "I%H
IZTV^ %]^ JTNJV M
'U IH7>$ %N HNEW% GN W; Z>XH]G V
$ HRWN GW.
I-M IWXNR HRH  *UWN% 3T K  IHT 3 % LK %  HNEW% %] ^  > = ;  E-K
EEHNIRQN V(N >=; 6=YH H3=VRK ;RZ %]^ *>=E H IW%N3 1NE' LR^RK
LN'H  *=L E- QV 7> U>FN IW=X JTW3 HKVN IL IW=X Z>XH]G 
I-QN
M
I-QN K Z>XH]G G RKR 7>aV QNJ'N JKV.ZSR JKEK XNGR  JN
H 3TK IHT3% LK U>FN IW=X UIMR LN H 6>=J U- IJ=6A HNEW% WK
7>K U>FN IW=X JTW3 HR IUQN Z>XH]G %]^ 3TK IHT3% Z0H Z>XH]G GN
J"R F9H []>ZN IG=VN V(N IHMN IH HNI-R V"%]^ 6=>J M
- %]^ (
94. 6=YNU.
JK9N G HNR' Z>XH]G GK %K$GRN *]U M
-K %VR. V
$ QU%K SN' I%HE
V(N HNEW% GK IZTV^ M
 U-K HNEW% G "I%H V(N Z]VRK QNJ'
RNLN G 3W %]^ E"H WNIJ XE J- IH7>$IH >=; IW=X RNLN GK IZTV^ "%N
GK MNR Z]%K L.GK K L.G M
- HIM U- IH QK$ %W. RNLN I%>HV
HRH  LEGK MK QNW.U  V(N 3T K  IHT 3 % V" % ] ^  %MK$ 6= Y .U 
3T K  IHT 3 % LK %  QNJ'  Z> = \  QI*Q] % VN XKF I-] L K%KQR  3T K
IW3WHRZN LK %]^ S>ENH IHMN IH H
-K QILMN (N% \
L
 ILG IV]%
VRF Z> ] G R V(N I-= H  JN  RNVN G> Q NR  M
W    7> a (  LEGK I-= H
GWNRHN I-= H  G> Q NR WNEK  %URK S'N G W
  QK$ LEGK MK 7> a (
JT  (N% HR.U   I-M Z^ R \ E
H  I-= (   X" %  %NE LK' %MK$ G ' U   3T K
IHT3% LK I-]%K %H QNVZN V(N >=; G IWR=>; K IH QNJ' H3=VRK-
M
'  %] ^  WK GNQ 7> a V  R= \ H  > = ;  %^ ]  1NIEQN HK IFR 7> M K IHT 3 % LK
QNJ' IJQNR N(K V(N ]S];K %]^ >=; HR' GK S>RK ENM G HG M%
V(N QNJ >=; %N HR% GN WX% HR% WNE G^R %]^ >=; GK JTR'N G
HG  M% QR(NV HG  %MK$ *UWN% 3T K  IHT 3 % R^ J  IW= X  W" $  3T K
IW3'^  LK MK QWVNR ;NR H  QN-  K
I-=H Z 3TK I*TU^ IR3K % QNRNZ %NE S"P *UWN% 3DTK IW3'^ LK
3TK IHT3% LK  G K% IW=X E=V ZNR IG=VK 3TK IW3'^ LK % 3TK I*TU^
IR3K LK GN J"R IMEN7>$G M
- IHMN IH M IR3KWRC QNJG H
ZE J"R
7>aV IHV =1 V. %MK$ E=UK IH7>$IH ZRN K%N V. HP
R J=(R L"N M"
LHR 3TK IW3'^ LK 3TK IHT3% LK  >=; IJT M>]G V. >GR3% X=HR %NE

194

) (NR( IUQN% JT H N3 IW3

3TDK I*TU^ LK G I-]% 1>H9 HR HG K IH IU'VK %N M>]GK#
WNVIWHVN I-M M" IH HNE *UWN% L
 I-=HK STIMZ]Y GN JT*^ M"
7>% JTIV=IUQN HKVK M" IH Z"$ QNJ' RKR IW=X IWQHV ZN%W >IGT3
QNJ' WNVIWH  R^J IW=X *G NMZ' %MK$ QN7^$UN 7>K % ^\3Z
RKR S'NH JTV GK VR4. 3TK IHT3% LK G RKR IW=X JTW3 HRH JIW=VR
UKVN LK GN IUQN% V. MK WG. GN NR  IHMN JT]V^ >=; HRWN7>'
G  E-K Q1HE SNLK IW= X  WK HR %MK$ 6= Y K HNE ST M Z  H
'  M" 
I-M LN%' G  E-K J94
 I3T 3 1K RX%N I-  J>  VH IUQN% U] U N# G
JT 3 P A V= H 
LG V=H ZM.*NRV GN >=; ?VZ %MK$ M
I-QN VG V=H L
VK I%R]L%
HNEAST M ZA6R J> R 3  3T K  IHT 3 % LK G  RKR IW= X  JT W  3  IRMN V(N
>I;3PR LK V
$ 0^P S>EWNI-QN IH HIM GW
 Q3W(NZN ZR IUQN *KZ
G J
V V(N [1
VH=6 G J=>VR SSR^ *N% GN 3K3 H1WNI-QN V(N QNJ
R= (  G  JMK-  %] ^  MI(QNR R^ J  IW= X  7> P NI-QN I-M RW HNE GN MK
HKVNAHRNI-QN LNE K JT*^ 3TK IHT3% LK GN %MK$ ZM.*NRV GN >=;
?VZ M>]G MK HNE *UWN% 3TK IHT3% LK G RKR V
$ I%HE IUQN 3TK
IHT% LK % >I;3PR LK %]^ I-]GRJT( IG=EK  GK RNLU=GK 7>aV ISPNH
QNJ GWNIRHN LN' %]^ IHMN VG QRL>% QNIG % JTN(%N HKVK IH M
3T K  IHT 3 % LKC QNJ NY  J^ L  U> R ^ G  W  M
  N%] ^  I-= H  IV] U  > ' NH
LN'N V.IH QK$ QNJG  GWX%. V  X= E H  QNJ'N QNVZAHIEQN'
HR HK- 
I-M JTN(%N WKHNR HRH 3TK IHT3% LK % IZVK Z. V(N (N%
I%>>HV HR IG=VK I%3IXV IZVK %]^ 3TK QRL>% % *UWN% 3TK IHT3%
LK %]^ IHMN IH JT*^ Q=L 7>MK JIW=VR UKVN GN IUQN% IL7>$ GN IV7>$
>'N8 IH7>$IH Z"$ S>=;K G G
3 HNR% *>=E IUQN M. VG 3TK IHT3% LK
% IHMN IH M QRL>% V]^ I%3X" MK S9N 3R;NMK' M" VRK S=>;K X]UK
%MK$ M" Q" JIW=VR IUQN% %]^ V]^ IH7>$ *>=E IUQNIFR QNJ IHMN IH
7>   J^ R   UKVN G  IUQN% %] ^  Z" $  %MK$ HIM HGN QR(NV Z" % ] ^  IUQN%
%MK$ M" IHMN IH Z"$ 7> Z$ Z"$ 
U>HV M
H S
IEQN K IWXNR'K-
$ IW3N M" IH LHR *UWN% 3TK IHT3% LK >=; G Z$ 
U >HV M
- M>]G
V. 3.VK Z $  
U > H V M
' N HIP% %MK$ K LGIH 3T K  IWQN LK %
7> M K JIW= V R UKVN LK GN IUQN% H-K NE. SNQG IL7> $  GN IV7> $
IE= J KS= ;  HR IG= V N K 7>   Z $  7> M  ST M Z HNEAL
V K I%R] L %  3T K
IWQN LK G  RKR IW= X  JT W  3  HR IUQN V(N JIW= V R 3T K ZG*UWV
UKVN LK %]^ IE=JKS=; HRWN IG=VN L
 M>' QNJG HR HZE. IW=X M"
JTZN' G E-K ]\IJV ZM.*NRV JT3P %]  V(N J>RN' G JT3P
%]  7> a V  G \
/ A
%3]IHQNV]IZN*^V(NWHV^Z36VM@JRZIMSTMZHI(VZ

U^HV% V]IZN ZM.*NRV QN3RW A
*UWN% S
EA 7>M *AGNA* 7>K R^J IW=X I_R G>MRN G'N M>' ZR

IUQN% U] U N

195

W=GKU=E%MK$M"7>Z$Z"$
U>HVM
HJTVZNVZV=VWGNWR'%HKVNK#
]\IJVZM.*NRVGIWVK- *NUG
JT3P%]+V
$MN*NRM
3TKIHT3%GNQRL>%V
$UKVNGNIW3 J>=6'NI=;ZIMIR3KW"3]ZJN%
QVHN3JGN]WNG# AJ.Y^%]G%QRL>%3TKIHT3%G%NERIMHSM>VJT]%
K7>%4.%I-=HWNR7>RZ'K-*NGW=EIGT31KJNH*UWN%%^]I-MWX%
IHMNAAGWHK%]G%C LG >=; GN QWR 7>JI(V K 7> Z$ Z"%^] QNJG
ZM.V]ZGNIUQN%QV I-3WRK- WR^JGNGR3%M
I-QNKIH]V^ H3WC
QNJ%%MW=3JIME.Z"%]^IUQN%GN7>JG3IG=VNK7>M*I-Z$S>=;K
G G
3%NE*>=EIUQNM"7>%4.IWI3Q.%^] >'%G E-KSNR]SNRZR Z%IW=X
7>VH]PNM>]GKM"I-=;RQNJLEGKMKG>WNRHNLN'WNEM%QVMLEGK7>M
*IW3 Z"%^] >'NIG7>
W"3ZJN%LKHIM]GM%AAQRL>%GQILMNHIM'7>aVWHV.W.IW=X
$3T31
ZM.V,=3WK*UWN%3TKIHT3%% 7>%4.%^] UE EUNH I-JTHNR7>aVRIG=VN
3TKIHT3%S
EAAQRL>%C7>Z$Z"$V"%^] QIVQ]VU
J%K- IW3 GNRW%
HRNI-QNKQNJ'WR^J*^V;RZ%NV%JT3
VZV=VWGNJTKX"IG=VNKQV
3>HEAIHT3%UVKGNI%R^J'HRGM
- I%=VE
H.GNWKWR'%HKVNKIH]V^
V^]L
QNJ'K%NZ0KGHNR%7>7>JG3%^]NG%MK$R=I\QNI-MLN'HZ"%^]
SM>VG>=\M
I-QNM"7>%4.U=E.GNM>'J^RNAJ^RNZR'M
'N]*W%MK$LN'
HGN J.Y^%]G%C I%3X" MK V^] SM>V 3R;NMK' M
 VRK S>=;K Q=6K %MK$ LN'
J"$GKM>'ZRE-K7>7JG3%^]IL7>$AGNAIV7>$G>MRNG'NHIP%M"IH7>$IH
7>Z$
U>HVM
HZ"$JTZNVZV=VWGNWR'%HKVNK QI;=HLN'HNRKG
E-K J94
AA]\IJV ZM.*NRV G^IWVKQ" *NU#
IWXNRHR
/A7>JR
HVZM.*NRVGE\.W3TKIW3'^J>RN'GE\.W3TK
ZG*UWV UKVN LK G E\. G JTZN'N V
$ I=; M
I-QN IH 3TK IHT3% LK %
3TKZG*UWVUKVNLKGNIUQN%%MK$S
IEQNI-MV.HNER^JKSTMZ L
VK
I%R]L% QR(NVZMNIW3'^LK%JTVW=33TTKIHT3%LKGRKRIW=XJTIW31M
H
S
IEQNK#
M
R  JT Z N'/A+ 3T K  IW3'^  J> R N' UKVN JT "   U
R \J> R  V
$  JT H NI3V
XV> R ( Q] 3  QI;QN-  G^  RN E
H   IW= X  FN  7> a V  IW3'^  LK
ZM.IW3'^ QR(NV HNE R^JK STMZ % GW V(N RNH33. G >=; G Z
$ G W V.WN GK JT N (%N IWHNR HRH  IHMN IH Z" $  RNLIR3K 33NG G
J>=VR J>R]L G RKR G Q] ZNVR QR(NV H>0 Z$ G E-K JTW3 HRH
RNH33. GN %N3 HR G W .UN
+ 3T K  IW3'^  J> R N' UKVN JT "   U
R \J> R  V
$  JT H NI3V  XV> R ( Q] 3
QI;QN- VKRN E
H  IW=X FN  IW=X 3TK IW3'^ LK % U];RW.
V %NU. G >=; IW=X %NU. GN J=\ E"$G M
- IHMN M" IH Z"$ ZM.IW3'^
QR(NV HNE R^ J K ST M Z  ZN%;NVN G  J> = V R J> R ^ H > V  IW= X  JT I W31 M
H 
7> % 4 .  ] J ^ R ' G> 3 1 U] ; RW. GN %N3 HR G W .UN#
M
R  JT Z N'/A H> 0  Z $  SNQG 3T K  > I ;3PR LK %] ^  I*QN%H > J %

196

) (NR( IUQN% JT H N3 IW3

QN7>' E=U 3TK IHT3% LK V


$ HNR' V(N
V(N ZN;N% J=>I6QN V. G=IQN IH
QNJ% >=; IW=X L
 JNJ HKV M% 7>M %R ]MNR GN G
3 QNJ%]^ G>=\GN-K
M
 IRMN M" I-G E-K =U HR
 3TK IHT3% LK G Z>=\ HZE V
$ I-M
WX% >'H QRL>% %^] SM>V G>=\ M
I-QN V(N
V(N Z% MK Z% IWXNR HR%
E=UN IH *UWN% 3TK IHT3% LK JIW=VR UKVN S
EG Z$ V. HIM RM %
IH QRL> %  V" % ] ^  H
- K JNJ %MK$ E= U  U N V] ^  > = ;  HR E"  JIW= V R UKVN
QI;QN-   E
H  A  L H R > = ;  IW= X  ZNIRQN WK IUQN V.
WRU IW=X >=\ *
U$UN %MK$ V. >=; IL=V H IJT(WK G RNL GN QN%]G
EW $ UN QRL> %  %  IWXNR HKVN IH L
 ZN;N% G> = \  I%WNR' GN 3T K
IHT3% LK % G=IQN M" I- IW=X HR
9. R>J- ?RX M
'N M" IL %NE
W=Y *RN >I;3PR GN G>=\ GN I%WNR' M
WUN LHR Z"$ 3TK IHT3% LK %NE
WNGAIWWNG HRNU. IH QNJ JIW=VR UKVN LK GN IUQN% IG]G Z$ V.
HIM RM K IH V"%]^ JNJ %MK$ E=UUN M>' 7>G IWJRKV HIM RM M

I- %NE ZRN W=YN *RN I-M %N 
X E- IH HR
9. R>J- G \RX %]^ G
\H QRL>% S\EN IUQN M" V(N
V(N ZR H31 I%WNR' V
$ JT]% %MK$ M"
I-E-K Z %  RIM'N 7> I XV LN'H  MR3 IWHT V K G  IG= V K IH ILW $
HM
U W"N MK M-UN 3TK IHT3% LK % 7> =U GK IZVK I%R;NIRV HR
IG=VK 7>M =U WK >GR3% BJX G *
L% \N' %NE _E M
-K
H> 0  Z $  SNQG IR3K G> R WNN LK G  3RNJW= 3  RW NGW H> E
IW%N3 M
IUQN 3TK IHT3% *UWN% G J"R G VEW IW=X I-=H I3HNRK L

VTVN>=U IW=X >URKW GN *N-K SNEK GK MK QNVZN K  % IW3N?V VKR
ZNR IG=VN VG J]L. J.YW. G [1%N (=E 7>aV JM>]X LN' G 7>JR]V
3TK IHT3% LK % IHMN IH QNJ ZR I33 M
 Z"$ QNJGN ;NRIZH U>R^ WK
M. I-E-K Z R K Q] I VZ QNIUQN > '
  I-= H  V. I-M M"  IH QRL> % 
GWNIRHN GKQ. RW I-VRKQ. %] ^  I-] G RJT  ( IG= E K  E"  LN'N
IH7>$IH I-=( H
-K %R %MK$ SIXQN M" V(N
V(N G^RN QNJ RW J.YW RNL
IVQNUH  IMZNIEQN IW= X  N;%N HRH  RKR %] ^  UENQ G ' N IH7> $ IH
QNJ% ZM.*NRV G >=; GRN' L
 M=IVQNW. HKVKQ. K QNJG 3K3 V
7>M JNJ SM>V I*Q]HR M% 7> Z$ QRL>% QNJ' QNJ %]^ %MK$ R
H
IHQN V(N
V(N IHMN JT*^ W" V. QNJ Q"K I(VK IW=X M% IH Z"%^] Q"K
U=E %MK$ HR%K XNMKGK JT]V^ JT*^ LHR Q=L ZRK 3]HN GN ZN;N% %MK$
M
I-QN V. Z"$ X"% %NE ZR WK %MK$ JN7^$UN J^RN LKW' R
$GN RMNU.
3T K  IHT 3 % LK %  IHMN QRL> %  J> = 6  E"  L
 H> 0  J> = 6 'N M"   Z R K Q] I VZ
[9KQ. M% 3TK QRL>% % Q=\. IW=X Q=(R^ *RH IHMN IH JT*^ S>RN %N
Z] % 'N LG QNJ%  JIW= V R UKVN LK GN IUQN% IHMN K 7>   Z $  Z" $
>=; HR% V
$ Z%4N HR IRMN K QNJ% IHMN K IH QRL% VR G
%4.
M=(. IW=X E=Y^ M% LHR >=; IW=X ZNIRQN IUQN V. WRU %]^ JTNJV
M
W  $ UN QV  L H R IWL"  K M
I -QN V. IJT ( WK GN RNL *
U  $ UN V(N
V(N V" % ] ^
H
-K JNJ %MK$ E=UUN QK$ QNJ MK GK G\AR\ V QNIUQN Q%>NR
>=; HKVN JTZN' JIW=VR UKVN QI;QN-  E
H A  M *UWN%C

IUQN% U] U N

197

NY V. I-=H M=( IW=X WK E=Y^ %MK$ IRMN %N V. >=; IW=X ZRH WRU
GK JTNJVK M
-K V(N
V(N M>' RNL IVQNU' GN QNG3 QNJ G RM M
 %N MK
IJT ( WK G  RNL GN QN%] G  *
U  JN-   Q"  N 6E > H V IWWMNR HRH
QNJGN HK WNR( KQRL>% G Z>=? V
$ I-M WX% >'H >I;3PR LK
% IHMN IH QRL>% Q"K I(VK IW=X LG IH *UWN% Q]IVZ NM IU'
RM  M% QNJGN I331NXNR RIMV IWWMNR 3
* N %MK$ IG] G N 3T K  IHT 3 %
LK % IHMN IH QRL>% Z"$ Q=L Q]IVZ I(VK IW=X M. V>]^ ZR QIVQ]V
IJQNR  M
  Q= L  WNVIWHVN G=  GN M. IH H
- K \E%NI-H L"  K 3HVK
M" L
 QNJ. %]^ ]VR GK VR4. %XN7>$GK RMK Z"%]^ H>0 JVN %MK$ IH Z"$
UKVN IW=X HK S
IEQN K JT]V^ M>' Z"$ L
 HIM IRMN M. 7>M QNJG IM=V
IW= X  M"   3T K  IHT 3 % LK I-M WX% Q= ( R^  > H V % V T .  %NE HIMH  JT N '
IVQNU U- 7>JR
HV IWWR' V
$ I=; M
I-QN IH JIW=VR UKVN LK GN
IUQN% 3TK IHT3% LK % %MK$ IHMN I-M V. STMZ L
VK I%R]L%AHNE
% S
IEQN M" L
 I-=HK STIMZ]Y GN WNZK M" HNE STMZ  H
' M"I-M
LN%' G E-K IHTJN J94
 J>VH IW=X FN  V
$  V=H
3T K  IHT 3 % IMV RW NGW. GN Q] I VZ ]  HNR HR QRL> %  %] ^
6= Y H  XNR
$  *N-K I-] G RJT  ( IG= E K  XE  U-   IJ= 6   QRL> %  GWNIRHN
GKQ. I-VRKQ. %]^ E"H QN IRMN K RNV IW=X L]UEK E
H. % RW
U
JKQ. %]^ E=>1 IEQN V(N
V(N H>0 H> %]^ *LNH E" U- V(N
V(N QRL>% %]^ F9H
H> = I 1QN QRL> %  G  M= (  7> M K U.YKW ;%> 3  K IL %NE ZM.*NRV G
> = ;  IW= X  Q'IU'V M= I VQNW. HR IG= V KQ. K 7> M  WK %MK$ X= I EQN
VG QRL>% % IHMN IH 3TK IHT3% WNVW IW=X 0^PN V(N
V(N HJ1K K LG
>=; IW=X JNJ HRWN7>'N K VG V. 3HVK JTGN% HR IG=VK I-=H VKR
%NE "$H9 
I;Q. %]^ ZNR IURN7>$GN K QV Q=L 7>MK 3HVK 6K' E-K
\9NA IJ=1 IRMN M. I- IW3 IW=X J^R' STMZ HSKR NIMS HIWR
G W  LK GN HIM'N M"  IH 3T K  IHT 3 %LK HJ1K QV  0^ P   %MK$ K 7> M
NRN L> E Z HNE L
V K I%R] L %  HR IRMN M"   LG V= H  I-M QNVZN
HSKR JT Z  3 WR IVJ> R 3  GK 3R' IW= X  J^ R   ] V  V= V WGR3K  G
ZNI;QZ %NE %MK$ QN LNWUK VG V=H HNE I- VR4. H31 7>aV H31
IG] G N RM U N J^ R ' LN'HNRK V= V WIUQN% %NE M> ] G K M"   I-E-K HNE
H
' M" I-M LN%' E-K IHTJN J94
 I- J>VH G JT3P  V
$  V=H
IW3 3  IWXNR/A7> J R
H V JT Z N'. V
$  I= ;  M
I -QN IH 3T K ZG*UWV
UKVN GN IUQN% 3T K  IHT 3 % %  %MK$ S
I EQN I-M V. 3T K  IHT 3 % LK G
RKR IW= X  JT  V W= V  JT W  3  M
H   ST M Z HNE QR(NV L
V K I%R] L %  %
S
I EQN K

3TKZG *UWV UKVN NR


  JTZ3WR GK \
L IW=X QNVZN >=U. V
$ E=UK M" L" IJQN %]^ JN'K
GK XNM M>]GK M" LKW QNVZN JTZNVZN V
$ IW=69' V
$ IJ=6
$ ZM.H31 0=E
RMK M" L
 >=\ J^R' STMZ IVJ>R3  G VE
H IR=V;NZ  IW=X K

198

) (NR( IUQN% JT H N3 IW3

7>M >=\ I-=( HNE STMZ  JT*^ G E


H IW=X %MK$ M" XNM H
-K HR
9JVK
XNM H
-K IJT(WKJVK RW IJT(WK GN RNLN  M" XNM >RJVK WRU
GN RNLN I-]GR  M" XNM 3TK STMZN 3TK IW3'^ V(N
V(N I3W IVTE
HJVK M%
IH7> $ IH L%Z V(N
V(N IZT V ^  HKV  HRZ GN *
U  LR^ R  MK JT N JV M] > G N M"
JT Z N' UKVN Q/ E
H   QI;QN-   E
H    I-E-K JIW= V R
3T K ZG*UWV UKVN G  IUQN%GNVN JT * ^  HNE *UWN%  %  QI;QN-  
E
H  V
$  V(N
V(N QI;QN-  E
H  IW=X IHMN M" IH QRL>% RW
*NW %NE 7>   JT Z  3 WR GK 3R' IW= X  LN 7>  GK IHT J N %NE MK V] ^
JRZ3.VK %]^ V(N
V(N VE
H 3N3WVZ (N%Z  %]^ JTNJV M
W$UN 7> JTZ
3WR G  V= V WIUQN% V  *UVKZNRU %^ ]  Z" $  UKVN IUQN% GNVN  %MK$
LN'GN 7>   V= V W IUQN% %] ^  V= V WGRK ] V . G  H
E  LN H  7> % 4 .  %] ^
G]YWV JT'NZ HR V(N
V(N IS%ZR *NW %NE JT3% HRH VG 7>M V=VWIGT31N
]V QNJ %]^ JTZ3WR GN V=VWIUQN% G='U IFR 7>%4. G G= *UVK
ZNRU 7> a V  RW *NW %NE E= U  LN JT Z N' UKVN QI;QN-   E
H
  V=VWGR3K ]V GK JIMXN' UKVN QI;QN-  E
H  IW=X G=G
M
- IHMN M" IH I-M ]NR 7>aE1 E=1H M
- IST? GK VR4. M" ILGK
7>J=R %]^ Z^E V(N
V(N %KX %^] 3N\N M" L
 I- ]NR R^JK IST? G IW3 IW=X
LN'GN M" 7>M V=VWGR3K ]V M" UKVN QI;QN-  E
H  V
$  IW=X
IHMN M"  IH 7>   ]  NR R^ J K IST ?  GKQ. IV] %
$  U> '  RLU> ' AST M ZN
VU> ' AIW3'^   VZU> ' AI3W  R^ J K 3N\N M% L
 WRU E
H  JNVNE
E
H  V(N
V(N IJT ( WK E
H  IV] % . E
H . IW= X  7> J = R  V(N
V(N %KX  F" E KQ. M
- KQ.
M% 7> ]NR R^JK 7>aE1 E=1H M
- IST? G IW3 IW=X QR(NV I3T31K
RX%N G SNR IW=X Z"$ I- UKVN LK G IUQN% IW=X %MK$ G= JN7^$UN
I-= (   IWXNR HNE IW= X  UKVN IUQN%  L
 IUQN% QNJ%] ^  G=   IRMN M.
I-M J^R' IUQN% %MK$ M" 7>G E-K UKVN QI;QN-  E
H  IW=X
]HV HKVN M" IL IW=X IHMN M" IH J^R' IUQN% V=VWIUQN%  G E-K
V= V WGR3K ] V  G  H
E  LN 7> M K G=  'U   Z" % ] ^  J^ R ' IUQN% %MK$ M" 
UKVN QI;QN-  E
H  IW=X IHMN M" IH V=VWGRK ]V GK JTNJVK
V
$  IJ= 6
$  7>   JRZJG JT Z  3 WR ILG  IW3  IW= X  UKVN QI;QN-  
E
H  IW=X IHMN M"  GK \
L HR%K XNMKGK M" IL=( LN' IJ=6
$ N;H
J> % R WNJ Z> 9 H  %MK$ QN7> $ G  QR(NV J^ R ' Z
H 3 JT N JV HRGN M" 
IL J^ R ' JT Z NVZN V
$  7> E 1  ]  NR R^ J K IST ?  GK JT I WRVK IWVNR %] ^
JTNJV M
-K M" *NWQR( M" IH IL JTZ3WR % RW STIMZ]Y. GK RX%N
HKVK M"  V(N
V(N Z" $  UKVN IUQN% GNVN ST M Z  WK 7>  K QNIG J> R 3 JT Z 
3WR QR(NV J^ R ' JT Z NVZN GK 3R' M. 7>  GK N;%N HR% V
$
Q%NIG Z
H 3 J^ R ' Z
H 3  JT N JV M> ] G N M" 
  V= V WGRK ] V  7> M K M"  L
 7> J = R  %] ^  Z^ E  V(N
V(N %KX  G  IV] %
$  U> '
RLU> ' AST M ZN LK VU> ' AIW3'^  LK VZU> ' AI3WLK  R^ J K 3N\N V(N
V'N V Z
1K YNR GK J^RK LN'HNRK JTGN% HRGN M" IHTJN G\
 7>E=1N
E= 1 IHQN M
I -QN ]  NR R^ J K IST ?  GN IX= V R 
   QNJ'  G> Q NRN RXK I3T 3 1K GN J^ R ' IUQN% V= V WIUQN%  QNJMK

IUQN% U] U N

199

200

) (NR( IUQN% JT H N3 IW3

J^R' JTZNVZN HIWRGW HSKR JTZ3WR  % V=VWGR3K ]V GK *^ZKHN
HRH  HIWIUR*KM  HSKR SN'K G> Q NRN G= I QN M"  JT Z N' IR= U W G
Z]YE  >HV  Z]VR  V
$  V=H V(N
V(N IR=UWG Z]YE  >HV 
Z]VR  V
$  V(N
V(N Q=(RW WG H.Y  Q%>WNH  Z]VR  V
$  IW=X
HSKRQH3RJ>R3-HJ9M"L
VKI%R]L%WNHKYNR
VK%
$GWN3N\NM"JNVR^J]NR@
JIW=VR UKVN LK IW=X WK IV]% JTT*^Q. + 6R J>R3 QR(NV STMZ
+ QH3R J> R 3 QR(NV JT S MZ V(N
V(N + JRZ QH3R J> R 3 QR(NV
J^ R ' ST M Z  G  IW3  IW= X  WR'% M"   JT Z N' UKVN QI;QN-   E
H
A QI;QN-  E
H  GN 7>V=R E
H  IW=X M" 7>>M JRZ QH3R
STMZ M" V(N
V(N IV]% JT*^Q. GN I-=H M
R JTZN' UKVN QI;QN-  E
H 
IW=X UKVN IUQN%GNVN HNE STMZ  % QNJ' IW3 IW=X IHMN M" IH Z"$
QIWQHV M. I-M JT(Z QIWQHV JT*^ M
I-QN IFR UKVN QI;QN-
 E
H   IW= X  IHMN M"  IH I-M ]  NR IG% G  Z $  QIWQHV
JRSTMZ  V
$ 7>VJ]% M
I-QN M" IFR RNVRK G Z$ 7>K IW=X EK% M

L.GN M"   I-M G^  RN QIWQHV M


I -QN QI;QN-   E
H   IW= X
IHMN M" IH 7> QIWQHV V
$ WK G^RN L
 QIWQHV J^R' STMZ  M"
7> M  JRZ IGW J> R 3 RW JT N 'KQ. G  %31 M
'  7> a V  WK %31 %MK$
M]>GN I-M JTZN' UKVN QI;QN-  E
H  IW=X WK M" IH %N3 RIMV
7>   JT Z NVZN %] ^  LN' ILGN %N3 HR' IW= X  H
- K WK ZR( %MK$ M" 
QNJ'  IW3  IW= X  UKVN IUQN%GNVN ST M Z  JT * ^  QI;QN-   Z] V R 
V(N
V(N QI;QN-   E
H   IW= X  IHMN M"  IH Z" $  V. L%ZAIZT V ^  IW= X
QR(NV %N3WN% M.
7> J R
H V ]  NR R^ J K GR?V GK Z^ E  L94  V. JRZ QH3R J> R 3
QR(NV J^R' STMZ HIWRGW M" I-K %]^ VKRN QIWQHV JT*^ IHMN
M"   IST ?  GK Z^ E  V
$  MK RW J 9  %] ^  QNMNR JT N JV M> ] G N M"   I-E-K
UKVN QI;QN-   E
H  IW= X  IHMN M"  IH WNVW IW= X  JT Z NVZN V.
6R J>R3 QR(NV STMZ V(N
V(N QH3R J>R3 QR(NV JRSTMZ V
$ WK M
R
MK M" L
 IV]% E
H. IW=X JTW3 HRH * GN ;NR'AJ
3' HRGN M" 7>MK
WNVW IW= X  QIW%N3K M" 
+ 6R GN QR( M" %N3WN% IH7>$IH STMZ QR(NV UKVN IUQN%GNVN
% QNJ IHMN M" IH QRL>% V]^ V(N
V(N Z"$ V. L%ZAIZTV ^ IW=X M. JTZ N'
UKVN QI;QN-   E
H   QI;QN-   E
H   IW= X 
+ QH3R GN QR( M"  QIW%N3K I-= (   JRST M Z %] ^  WK (N-K
QR(NV QIW%N3K IHMN M"   JT ] V ^  I-M WK WNVW IW= X  QIW%N3K %MK$
M" I-M IXR (N-K M" ILW$ I-=H IZ=1K GN IJQNEN L
 _G R]U GN XNM
JK' G  H] Z  QN7> $ GN M"   7> M  V. IURG  MK 1> = 1  L.GN M"   I-M I(VK
ST M Z HNE QR(NV 6R J> R 3  GK LN'
  G^  RN IJQNEN I-JNV
1KE  GN M] > G N M"   I-M IZ= 1 K G  IJQNE  GK V> E %N %NE
$  ILQNGN
(N-K  QIW%N3K  E=UGN M" JT]V^ I-%]^ WK L]U E=UGN M" V(N
V(N %31 M

L.GN M" *E MK ILQNGN Z$ E=UGN M" I-E-K I-M WK WNVW IW=X

IUQN% U] U N

201

QIW%N3K %MK$ M" VKRN IJQNEN 


% GN M" 
%N ;NV^ WNVW IW=X
QIW%N3K M"  ILGN %N3 %MK$ M> ] G N
ILW $  JRST M Z QH3R J> R 3  7> M  QIW%N3K WK IHMN M"  V(N
WNVW IW=X QIW%N3K V. I-%4. G
%4. V
$ M
R M" I-E-K QH3R J>R3
%]^ QIW%N3K WK %MK$ IHMN M" HNR'/A =V RLU>' STMZN GK IZTV^ V
$
IJ=6
$ I-=H VU>' IW3'^ GK IZTV^ M]>GK M" =V VU>' IW3'^ GK IZTV^ V
$
IJ= 6
$  I-= H  VZU> '  I3W GK IZT V ^  M
 L.GK M"   LG VZU> '  I3W GK 
MLNR SNR IZTV^ M
 L.GK M" VG I-=H 6R J>R3 STMZ  GK IZTV^ M>]GK M"
I-M JRSTMZ QH3R J>R3  GN I-=H >=U M>]GN M" Q" I-=H MLNR >=U
GN JRSTMZ GN I-=H IG% V(N
V(N I-]%K MK RNVRK M>]GK M"  IG% RNV
GN I-= H  ZMK%N ZMK%  GN I-= H  NE QV   NE GK JRST M Z
QH3R J>R3  GK 7>ZR M>]GK M" VG I-M JRSTMZ V(N
V(N RW STIMZ]Y
L
 VE
H G %KX G M% %31 M
 L.G M% H>0 Z$ SNQG RW %KX
G STIMZ]Y. STMZ V(N
V(N JRSTMZ G E
H.  GK RX%N J^R' STMZ QR(NV
JRZ QH3RJ> R 3 HRGN M"   I- JT H NR I-M V= V WIUQN% Z0'N M" 
JT ] V ^  JRZ QH3R J> R 3 QR(NV J^ R ' ST M Z IVJ> R 3  V(N
V(N 7>  GN
VE
H IR=V;NZ  IMV 7>J=R G QE\ E
H QUZ E
H V(N
V(N Q%NZK E
H
HG  %31 %MK$ M> ] G  
I-E-K UKVN QI;QN-  E
H  IW=X IHMN M" IH WNVW IW=X
7> V = Z  JT * ^  QR(NV JT 3
V Z V. ST M Z 6R J> R 3  V(N
V(N JT S T M Z QH3R
J>R3  V
$ M
R MK M" L
 J^R' STMZ JRZ QH3R J>R3  M" 7>MK WNVW
IW=X QIW%N3K M" 7>MK * GN JNE'AJ
3' HR% WNEN ]NR R^JK IST?
GK Z^E R^JK J^R' JTZNVZN M" IST? GN L
 *NU ,ZK% G V>R]V SNMR
%,R QN7> $ GN M"  7> M  V'N HMN7> $ GN M"   7>  %] ^  QH3R J> R 3 JRST M Z
LN'
 V' %]^ MK QNMNR Z^E L94  V
$ JTNJV M>]GN M" IFR V' V
$ Q=U
IST? GKQ. H-K YNR M>]GKQ. M% 7>%4. IW=X
$ I-=H YNR STMZ 6RJ>R3
M" I-%]^ WK QNMNR Z^E QR(NV JRZ QH3R J>R3 V
$ MK JTNJV M>]GN
M"   7>   YNR 6RJ> R 3 ST M Z  GK Z] %
 IV] %  U> '  RLU> ' AST M ZN
VU>'AIW3'^ VZU>'AI3W  R^JK 3N\NW. M% I-%4. %]^ WK QNMNR Z^E
JRZ QH3R J> R 3 QR(NV J^ R 'ST M Z  V
$  MK JT N JV M> ] G N M"   I-%4 .
IV]% 3N\NW. G J=V R^J IW=X M
R JTN'K QN3IRV M% 7>%4. %]^ WK WNVW
IW=X QNMNR Z^E JRZ QH3R J>R3 QR(NV J^R' STMZ  V
$ MK JTNJV
M>]GN M" I- E-K RW GN J^L J^R' JTZNVZ. MK I=; M
I-QN I-M
WK %MK$ IHMN LN HGN IH J= I VQ. V= H  QNMNR JM> ] X N7> '  V= H  V'N
YNR V(N
V(N 3N\NW. GN H
- K 
U GN% %MK$ M"   I- E-K RW MK
QNGR'K-$ M% JT]V^ J^L'K-$ V. HWE Z^E L94  MK M]>GK M" QNGR
V(N
V(N J^LN IW=X Q]VR M>]GN M" ILW$ JVKWTVN I-VRK IVHNR V. *
GN HRGK M" ILW$ ,P GN W=Y *N-K Z GWR GN 6
1 *N-K Z JT]V^
J^LN QNJ' JVK GK MK HRGK M" QR(NV L
 *NW QNJ' JVK IW=X M>]GN
M"  QILMN M
R  J> R 3 IW= X  JVKWRVN I-VRK GN %MK$ M
 HGN
G^RN 7>GMNR'A I-=H Z$ MIRQN'N JT.V IW=X M94 QN- K 7>

202

) (NR( IUQN% JT H N3 IW3

Z $  6    HR
9  R> J -  GN %> H N% M
I -QN K 7>  GK J^ R VK MIRQN'N
RHNR %MK$ HR HGK K IH7>$IH MIRQN'N RHNR GN J^R NE GN
SL1 MK %$  HR
9 R>J- K G3 G JT;N%Z]VRK LK % 7>M %>HN% GK
J^RVK HKVK K 7> 6  HR
9 R>J- GN IWVR' MIRQN'N RHNR G
QI;HNRKQ. V(N
V(N HRZXNRKQ. %  HKVN K RNMV JT N JV HRVN L

Q%LN' M% 7>M 7> IWVR' HRVN %]^ MK RNMV HRVN Z]% E"$G M%
7>%4. V
$ MK *IW=\ IW=X WK M
R RNMV GK QN HRG M% 7>K GK J^LN
IR3WV QNIG G ' N HRG  RIM] G   M% JT ] V ^  L
 I= I \QV M% 7> M  LN'G
M% IH IH HRZXNRK GN IH]%N 
UGN% M" 7>M QNGR V. HRG M%
JT]V^ J^LN IR3WV QNIG G'N  %MK$ HRG %N MK M
R HNRL GK I=;K
GK QN R= \ G  M%
M94 RN3K IWVR' G SNQG 7>K \VR G JT.V G Z]VRK LK QN-
7>%4. % IHMN IH Z"$ QNJG \VR IW=X G= E=\ R>J- IG=VN 7>K IJ]Y
GK ^ X K IW= X
$  %NZ J94 H   > ' N-  + RNZQWVNR %] ^  G=   MLNR R> J -
+++QNIG IG=VN IFR JT.V G Z=>\ Z]VRK WK 7>K IJ]Y IW=X QN- 7>%4.
% WK ^XK J94K V(N
V(N IHMN IH Z"$ QNJG IJ]Y %]^ G= E=\ R>J- IG=V M%
+RNZQWVNR %]^ G= MLNR R>/++QNIG IG=V IFR 7>K IJ]Y IW=X G3 G
JT;N% Z]VRK LK QN- 7>%4. % WK ^XK J94K V IHMN IH Z"$ QNJG IJ]Y
%]^ G= E=\ R>J- IG=V M% +RNZQWVNR %]^ G= MLNR R>/++QNIG IG=V
 RNZQWVNR % IHMN I-M * 0^P S
E RM M% Z"%^] V. :/ J1WNRK
%  IG= V   M% 7> M  Q%LN% RNZQWVNR QIUQN%VN G  HNR' IJ] Y  G
J1WNRK GK MK J^LN HRH QNJ' RW HNRL. GK I=;K XNM]>GN M"  L

II?QH M% 7>M LN' E"$G M% IH JT;N%Z]VRK LK RNMV %MK$ IG]G V.
Z>=\Z]VRK LK Z]VRK LK V(N
V(N J1WNRK LK H>0 WK %MK$ G HG LHR
Z> = \ Z] V RK LK WK QNJ'  RNMV ?LN%  IW= X
$  RN3K IWVR' V.  A 
R> + ++Z> 3 IHE %NE G  HG  L
 %N ZNVR M] > G    I- JT H NR Z0GNR
IWQHVK LN' E"$GN M" IH IHGK IH]%K QHNV 3ZVN  M" 7>K QN;NR
7> a V  7> % 4 .  7> a V  QN(N RIM] G K M"   Q%NGR'K- $  H
- K %MK$ M] > G N JT ] V ^
J^ L N G  E-K 
X  Z0H  X> ' GN M"   PKH I-  VR4 .  UKVN QI;QN-  
E
H  IW=X IHMN M" IH QRL>% SM>V W=Y ,EN3 GK ILGN LE G
NE WK WR?N %N M
W V. WK ZNJV %MK$ M>]GN  JTNJVK G SNQG 6
1
,EN3 ILGN LE I-=H NE G Q]GR MK ZNJV M
 L.GN M
W  IW=X
L"K QN(N RIM L.GK M" I- JTHNR J^R' JTZNVZN G IZE' WNE EN*
G IUQN% V
$ JTKIXV M
' G IJ=6
$ VRK QN(N M
R JT*^Q. IW=X W"K MK
RIM LNWUK 7>M 6
1N ,EN3 S>RN %MK$ E=UUN JT]V^ 7>GK ZR=(VN
GN JVN M" IH I-M V. H]Z XEN7>^ M"
UKVN QI;QN-  E
H  V
$  IW=X IHMN M" IH IV]% U>'. V
$
L
 H> 0  WK M
 IRMN M"  ILW $  RLU> ' AST M ZN V
$  LKW. GK 7> V J= V K
VU>'AIW3'^ V
$ I(VK V(N
V(N VZU>'AI3W V
$ ]MNR  I-GN Z>=\ HNR'
Z"$ STMZ HNE MK M. L
 N;H IV]%
$ U>'. RLU>'ASTMZN VU>'AIW3'^

IUQN% U] U N

203

V(N
V(N VZU>'AI3W  GK J^LN HRG M% 7>M RNH33 >*NQ %]^ ;NR' HKV
M
- Z%>=\. IW=X
$ %KX G>31HRZK HR% WNEN Z^R\ Z>0 STMZ GK *UVK
WK %MK$ HRGN IFR QNJ'K *UVK %] ^  WK QIV [1KQN Q%> V ZNZ
IHMN M" UKVN QI;QN-  E
H  IW=X I-E-K UKVN QI;QN- 
E
H  V(N
V(N QI;QN-  E
H  IW=X IHMN M" IH J^R' JTZNVZN GK
*UVK HR% %NE MK J^R' EN* Z
H3 JTNJV M]>GN M" L
 3NVR IW;K
Q%>  NR *UVK HRGN M"  V(N
V(N M
R  JT * ^ Q . GK I-31 R^ J  IW= X  N;%N
3NVR IW;K G  IWR> = ;  M
'  7> a V  IWQR( M"  JT Z N' UKVN QI;QN-  
E
H  A IW= X
ILW$ Q]S GN JGN %RRK V
$ IEQNH 7>G Z^E %]^ ,ZK% IW=X U=YN
?
GH GSN-$U IFR Z^E GK I]XN-K J^LN  HR.U V. JGN W=YN M
WUN
V(N
V(N J9 S' LNWUN IFR 3N\NW. %]^ _E E=U'U LHR H
-K 3N\NW.
%]^ ,ZK% IW=X G=SH Z^E 7>aJR %]^ HRH JG I]XN-K HRUN V. JGN >=H
LNW U N IHT J N G \
 I= ; N SKI,QN M
I -QN V(N
V(N 7> E = 1 N E= I UQN M
I -QN
J G N I- J>  VH IW= X  J ,  A V
*NWQR( M"  IH N;H %] ^  J^ R ' JT Z NVZN Z^ E  GK N;%N J^ L N
I-31 R^J IW=X HR% %NE 7>GN FE IV]%. STMZN IW3'^ I3W 3N\NW.
MK JT G N% HR'U   IH7> $ IH I-M *UWN% HKV  HRZ GN FE IL7> $  GN
IV7> $  MK IG] G   M%
LHR QNJ IHK H]J%K IW=X %HRK JTNJV HR%K M" V. J^LN H]J%K
F" H 1RK  G  ZNIEH GK HR%K M] > G K M"   7>  %] ^  JT N (%N J= V R G> Q NRN
NX%N HRH %HRK JTNJV HR%K M>]GK M" IFR WK %HRK J^LN  ZNIEH
GK MK HRGN M" L" L
 HNRL 7> %HR %^] G=IQN L.GN M" 7>M QNJ'
WN HNE IW=X MK HRGN M" I-M J^LN %HRK  ZNIEH GK M
-K %HRK
J^ L N  GN HKVN Z M %VN%N 7>   ZNIEH G  M
R  % H R HRZXNRK L.
QI;HNRK  IG] G N M"   ILW $  I3F1 Q_R IG%. G  QN;NR 7> a V  Z
M%VN%N HKV  HRZ GN FE  S'NH  ?LN%XK H" 3 KQR  G  H
E  * L GN
M" 7>a(
$ 7> %HR WH  GK WN J^LN  GN _E JTNJV M>]GN M" I3F1
Q_R QV  H" 3 KQR IRF HKVN HRZ MK IG] G   M% 7>   IW= X  H
- K
JIRWRV% %MK$ HR HG %N MK I-=H R>J- W=; G HG M% QV %N
MK I-=H R>J-KQN [=1 G HG M% LHR 7>M H]J%K G ZNIEH GN %HR
J> L NRK  % H  %KVK %NE % H RK J^ L N  ZNIEH GK HRGN M"  V. ZNIEH
7>GK WN GK ;]%RN3K IW=X WIR;K HR IG]GN M" V(N
V(N QE=U V
$ I-%NZ
R^ J  IW= X  ;] % RN3K QI;= H  G  IG] G N M"   L H R H
- K ZNIEH GK % H RK
J^ L N  IVQNUH  M
R  QI;HNRK GK % H RK J^ L N  HR% E= U  LNW  V.
7>  %] ^  ZNIEH V
$  IZE' WNEN EN* S] G  M
 L.GN M"   IL HNR' 7> M
%NGN% I%R;] %  M
 L.GN M"   QI;HNRK 7>  %] ^  7> % N Z M %VN%N %MK$ G
HG   F" H 1RK ZNIEH GK V> E %N IW= X  SM> V  [= 1  > W K;NW. IZE' G
HNR' 7>M M
R QI;HNRKQ. GN WH QR(NV I-=H ZNIEH %]^ IVQNUH
QNZ 7> J N%N HR% WNEN IWQHVK ZM.G> = \ K M
 L.GN M"   IHT J N I-

204

) (NR( IUQN% JT H N3 IW3

JT H NR V= V WIUQN% G  QN;NR V  JIW= V R 3T K ZG*UWV UKVN LK G


IUQN% %] ^  Z0

J^R' STMZ H>E ZNIEH GK J^LN 6=YH M
R GWVNW. GK J^LN HR%
%NE N;H %] ^  J^ R ' EN* JT N JV %MK$ M] > G N V(N
V(N N;H N;%. HRG A 
WK ZM.H31 7> P N7> $ GN RIM] G N M" 
I-E-K JIW=VR UKVN QI;QN-  E
H  V
$  V(N
V(N  V
$ 
V= H  IV] % . U> ' . QR(NV IV] % . G W VNW. RLU> ' AST M ZN VU> ' AIW3'^ 
VZU> ' AI3W  GK J^ L N HR% WNE  %] ^  RNH33 > * NQ %] ^  ;NR' HKV  M
- 
 Z%> = \ N IW= X
$  %KX G> 3 1HRZ HR% WNE  Z^ R \ IHMN M"  IH 7> M  Z R K
6R J>R3 QR(NV F"H1RK ZNIEH G I3F1 Q_R GK  J^LN %HRK
%MK$ HRG *NWQR( M" IH L
 IV]%
$ GWV.WN V(N
V(N M
R GWV.WN GK J^LN
HRG  M% H" 3 KQR GK % H RK HRG  M%  7> % 4 .  %] ^  Z^ R \ V(N
V(N RNH33
>*NQ WNE RNH33 IHMN M" ILW$ IL IWQHVK GK QNZG% G N;%
[=1 M
' 7>M H>0 MRNAFRK LR^R HRGN M" HG X
RK LN IZENW1 QNIG
6EHJ1 GN ZNRU QJ'N7>$GN M" IL HNR% ZNL IW=X MQ M
 L.GN
M"  V(N
V(N GIR= G R M
 L.GN M"   I-JT H NR IV] %
$  G W V.W. 3T K  ST M ZN LK
IW3'^ LK V(N
V(N I3W LK  V(N
V(N M
R GWV.W. GK J^LN V
$ J^R' EN* JTNJV
%MK$ M> ] G N IL HNR' N;H 0^ P  HJ1 V(N
V(N M
R  IWHNR WK HRGN
RIM] G N M"   IFR JNJ HRZ GN G] Y  WK *
U 'N J" $ GN M"   I-E-K ST M Z
QR(NV 6R J> R 3 I3F1 Q_R  HIM IRMN M"  IH I-M %NGN% Z R K
J^ L N % H RK  WK %MK$ HRG    Z" $  I-%4 .  ST M ZN IW3'^  V(N
V(N ZM 3  V
$
ILQNGN IZM%VN%N HKV  HRZ GN ;] %  G  HGN M. L
 7> J R
H V
JT*^QN V
$ ILQNGN M]>GN M" IFR UKVN QI;QN-  E
H  IW=X IHMN
M" IH ZRK J^LN %HRK  WK J^R' EN*GNI-H %MK$ M" I-E-K QNJ'K
J^ L N %] ^  WK UKVN IUQN%GNVN ST M Z 6R J> R 3  JT * ^  %  Q%> V ZNZ
QIV [1KQN QR(NV QIV I%Z% VR GK IHMN M"   I-E-K UKVN
QI;QN-  E
H  V(N
V(N QI;QN-  E
H  IW=X IHMN M"" IH 7>
JTZ3WR GK 3R' IW=X LN ILGK IHTJN %NE V]^ JRZ3.VK V(N
V(N VE
H
3N3WV (N%  %]^ JTNJV M
W$UN7>a( LN' G SNQG N;H GN J>%R L%Z
%MK$ M]>GN QR(NV Q%NIG Z
H3 J^R' Z
H3  JTNJV M
 L.GN M" V(N
V(N UKVN
IUQN%GNVN JT*^ 6R J>R3 STMZ  HIM IRMN M" IH Z"$ WK 7>K QNIG J>R3
JTZ3WR GK 3R' IWX M. UKVN QI;QN-  E
H  V
$   V(N
 V
$  %]^ Z0' G E-K IHTJN I%Z% IWWR% I;QN% J^RWH J94


IV]%
$ U>' HK M% JTZN' IMV
IV] %
$  U> '  RLU> '  ST M ZN LK VU> '  IW3'^  LK VZU> '  I3WLK
M% I-M ST M Z HNE  V(N
V(N JT I HVK G> R UN  V
$  7> V J] %  M
-   M% V(N
IV] %
$  %N3WN% M%#
JTZN' /A UKVN JT" U
R\J>R V
$ JTHNI3V 3TK I3W ZM.J>RN' ILG
] J NGH M% 3T K  M%^ ] Z N% JT 3 NG J G NR JT 3 P  QI;QN-   R> G R

IUQN% U] U N

205

] I MVN I- JT H NR ST M Z.AIW3'^  V(N


V(N I3W IV] %  $  G W IVQ. IW= X  U> '
M% JT ] V ^  IW ST M ZAHNE  U> ' NVKV IHMN IUQN M"  #
G^  RN JT Z N'/AUKVNJT " a  U
R \J> R  V
$  JT H NI3V T K ZG G W K *UWV
J>RN' ILG ]JNGH M% TK M%^]ZN% JT3NG JGNR IXZ% ENE U
>QNZK
VKRN H] G  QI;QN-   JT 3 P  /A *UWN% IW3'^  %  G> R UN GK
7>VVK HKVK / IHMN IH Z"$ IW3'^  STMZN V(N
V(N 3]HR LK QNJGK IHTJN
%NE MK IWGZN% M. NYN V. QNIWR*NW L%Z  IVR
*NW IZTV^  M>]GK
M"   QK$ I%= V  QIW%N3K  %MK$ M. V> Z  I%= V  M
  LUVL%'K M

JT I HVK V(N
V(N %NV%K G W K M
  *UWN% 3] H R %  IHMN / L H R *UWN%
ST M ZN V(N
V(N *UWN% IW3'^  QNJG  V
$  MK 7> V J] %  M
-   M% V. 7> % 4 .  V
$
SNQG 7>VJ]% M
' WNEN Z"$ VZ
U>'K EKE4N HR% WNEN 3]HR HK QNJGK
]VN% %MK$ M
I-QN QR(NV Z"%^] WK 7>VJ]% HR% WNEK QNJMK M
 I-
]  NR GK I3T 3 1KAI(VKA] M NR IW= X  QNJG  U> '  GNARWGN M%
I-%4 .  IV] % . U> ' . V
$  7> V J] %  QK$ ST M ZNAIW3'^  V(N
V(N 3] H R I%Z.
Q%>  NR HNRL IW= X  V= V JR RIM] G   M.
7>JR
HV I-M IWWR' HWE IM]GK IW=X Q%>WNIGV TK GWK ZM.J>RN'
V
$ M" IL IWX H>0 V=(. %^] E>HNI-QN IUQN M" I-E-K I-M JTZN'
G \
 T K  Z= G G W K*NUWV ZM.J> R N' *N3I1HZ ZMNVZ \ Z RNL T K
IHT 3 % GN JT H N3% Z> ] S -K I- IWX ]  IHT V  NIMV IM] G K Q%> W NG
HKVN M"   VKRN H] G  QI;QN-   _N  E
H  /A
STMZ.AQMZZM3WRMIFEVJT*NWNTWW]LI%>VN%GNV^I%VNM
H Q% ^RNMXI%VNI%VNVWZWL%%KJTIHRVKMJ>RN'N  
J] L NSK Q%> W NG/A IW3'^  LK %  IHMN  M  ZNVNC ST M ZN Z" $  V(N
I3W QNJG  MK JT * NW %NE L%ZWN% M. I%= V  %MK$ M. QR(NV QK$
QIW%N3K %MK$ M. I_R M
R I-]GR QNIG G^R GWVN IH JTHNR I%=V
M
 HG  M. QNJ MK QIW%N3K M
 NY  * GK L%'K M
 QR(NV
7>VJ]% HR% WNEK ZNVN M
 JTNIHRVK GWK V(N
V(N %NV%K GWK M
 
JT3P A QI;QN-  E
H /A
/A IG GNGTZ%N % G. ISH
H(ZZM] IWIMVMXVZ
U>'MHZEL3XRL
U>']*WM>IWIMVMIHZ> VWU>'
$
MIRM 
Q%> W NG/A*UWN% 3] H R S
E  / AM  ZNVNC L H R NY  7> J = R  QNJ
GI-QNWN% M
 V. Z"%^] VZ
U>' IH7>$ S'NI-QN HZE V
$ 7>VJ]% STMZ. %^]
RL
U > '  IH E-K S'NI-QN V(N
V(N IW3'^  %^ ]  V
U > '  IH7> $  S'NI-QN
QR(NV LKW. G  L%ZAIZT V ^  R^ J K G> 3  HT Z . IWX IH7> $  EUNI-QN
E
H/A
/ARZWJIVZJ>R3
> ZGNVWUIVZ%IMIWMIW;ZI3W 
J] L NSKA QNJ'  JVK J> R 3 QR(NV HNE *UWN% G  %NE GN
*
U AIWEN HRGK RIM] G K M
  QNJGK UVK H
- K %MK$ LN'GN
VKRN H] G  JT 3 P  QI;QNI-  3E
H  /A
-HZWNIGBVK]VSTMZWGNWG]IVW"NIH]VWZWNJWNIH]]G
M IWI%WVT 

206

) (NR( IUQN% JT H N3 IW3

Q%>WNG/AL
 IH WG. IWX QIGBVK HWE I-=H J^R% STMZ IHMN HK
7>M QNJ MK M
 L. H
-K M
R M
 ZRK I- 3]H. GN I%WNR% HR
 STMZ.
LK GK JT N (%. 7> a V  G W K %  IHMNA
GW>WNXG"HVW]%*G
IVTWG"WZZNX@
NMZM]
*G
IV
ZIVIW*TZNV @@QNW
R]VR] >H3Z% 
 WG ZIVZNI%M M@IWZ>HVM  V>
]NRN%NZ>XV %NVR ]3M@@
Q%>WNG/A GWK % IHMN /A I-M M" 
 Z"$ M. L
 Z"$ M. 
 I-M M"
ZIV G IW*TZ M
' 7>aV *G *NVN M"@@ NYN G
W. GN L
 ^\3Z Q]VR
M" I-%^] L
 LN'GN M" 7>MK ZIVZN% QR(NV V=VWGR3K M" 7>M ]NR
V
$ JT(H M
 IH Z>HV M>]GN M" I- IW=X H
-K ]GM %MK$@@
>ZR'NGR3%% V>Z] GN M] IW3Z I(V@WRVWN M] GN GWNM
JRZNVZ.%NV%M@@7*M>ZR'NGWHNRI3I;R]3]Z@SMTZ
WNX@
-V> H VWN IWRLNZN%G VVWN 3HVKM >  ]  HT V N%@@ IW3'W  (
ZM.EH3ZKZM.HNEKI3WNX@ZM.RWVKZTM.(N%NVZNIGBRILVNM@@
Q%> W NG/ ] H 1 7> J I(V M
'  7> a V  IZR% %NE MK Z" $  QNJ%^ ]
GR3% IGQ.UK G W VN8C JT Z NVZN %NV% G W GK 3HVKR^ J  V
$  Z R N
GN IZR% HR%N@@ G
%4. G IZR% HR% %NE LR^R MK HNRLI=;K
M
W  U K ST M Z. LK S
E   I- JT H NR ]  HNR 3HVK G H   N%^ ]  IWGN
HKVN@@ IW3'^  G  I%IRZV ZM.EH3ZK I3W G  I%IRZV ZM.HNEK
V(N
V(N Z" % ^ ]  ZM.3R3WVK G H   IWGN HKVN@@
ZZ X"W RKR] W" ^VTIZVNI*;KV@(>E] RKR] WH3IZ STMZ'M
JTZNVZ%M@@
Q%> W NG/A Z R N RKR ^ V RR^ J  IHMN L.GN M"   JT Z NVZN ST M Z GN
(^ E  RKR HMN7> $ GN M" @ @

7>JR
HV J>RN' WNH. GN NR
3J=31 M
I-QN IH 3TK STMZN LK RLU>' M" TK IW3'^ LK VU>' M"
V(N
V(N T K  I3WLK VZU> '  M"   IV] %   JT * ^  %N3WN% M% V(N
V(N I-%4 .  GN
L%ZAIZTV^ M>]GK M" G>RUN %^] JTNIHTVK WK IHMN L.GN M" G>RUN GN JVK
ST M Z. 6RJ> R 3 HNE  M"   I-M 7>   %NE JVKAJV%K GN IWWMNR
RZ%IWEN  HRGK RIM] G K M"   G> R UN V(N
V(N ST M Z G
W  $  (^ E  RKR G
QHNR IWX M%
I-M JTZN' UKVN QI;+  E
H A IW=X M" UKVN IUQN%GNVN
STMZ 6RJ>R3 HNE  HIM IRMN M" IH JTIHTVK G>RUN  V. ZRK JV%K
M" Z"$ I-GK 
%K UT*;NR% (N%  IWX SKL GK (NJ%N HRGN M.
ILV
$  RW JT N 'KQ. GK 7> V JVK M> ] G K M"   Z" $  RW I-= H K ST I MZ] Y . G
JT N 'KQ.  GN IJVN M. V(N
V(N JT N IHT V K G> R UN Q31] U K  RW GK ZNVN
M" I- G>RUN Q31]UK JTIHTVK  V
$ 7>VJ]% IV]%$ U>' RLU>' STMZ.
VU> '  IW3'^  V(N
V(N VZU> '  I3WLK  M
R  JT N 'KQ. %^ ]  HT Z . G  S] ; % IWX
S] % 4 G   M%

IUQN% U] U N

207

@IVTU>' ZNN RLU>' STMZN LK VU>'


 IW3'^ LK V(N
V(N VZU>' I3W LK  LKW %^] Z>HV
%MK$ M
' IG]G@
JIW= V R UKVN LK G  Q/ 3E
H  A IW= X  ST M Z HIM IRMN M"  IH
QRL>%C M>' V"%^] 7>M IUQN% >'N7>$UN ILG LN%' G SNQG M
R H>0
LN%'N SNHK %MK$ RIM L.GN
UKVN Q/  3E
H /A UKVN IUQN% GNVN STMZ 6R J>R3 HNE
HIM IRMN M"  IH IV] %
$  U> ' . %NE L
 H> = 0  WK M
 IRMN M"   7> M  Z" (
$  MK
M
I -QN LN' ILW $  RLU> '  ST M ZN  V
$  7> V JVK VU> '  IW3'^  V
$
JNE'AJ
3' I(VK V(N
V(N VZU>' I3W  V
$ ]MNR JRE"  GN HNR' HNE
*UWN% MK M" IFR IHMN M" IH Z"$ I-%4. IW=X %MK$ M. IH7>$IH HNE
SM>V G^R I-HKW$ STIMZ]Y G I%=L E
H IWX RIM]GN M"  M" JT]V^ Z% R^J
IWX ZL HNE MK Z%N7>$GN M" V(N
V(N IRZ
1 %NE RW JTN'KQ. V(N
V(N STMZN
LK IW3'^ LK W I3W LK %^] ]VR GK VR4. XEN7>$GN M" UKVN S
E' WNEN
STMZ HIM IRMN M" IH ZR I-=HK STIMZ]Y. G JTN'KQ. G E-K ZRK J^LN
%NE MK 3NVR Q%> H ^ E  N;%. QNR] *  M> ] G K M"   L
 W G . IW= X  WR%I'V
M" ZR Q]VRUV IL]% WK JTN'K M% 7>%4. GK S>=;K ZR M=( M" Z"$ HWE
I-HK STIMZ]Y. IW=X MK ZNIEH M. I-E-K UKVN LK Q/  E
H 
V
$   VH  IW= X  L
 WK IV] % . U> ' . RLU> ' AST M Z. LK V
$  LKW. GK
7>VJ=VK VU>'AIW3'^ LK V
$ I(VK V(N VZU>'AI3W LK V
$ ]MNR  L

H>0 WK M
 IRMN M" 7>GN Z>=\ HNR' Z"$ STMZ HNE  MK M. IH7>$IH
HNE %^] I-=H E=\ ZN%W RKR ;NRK JTN'KQ. G RKR %^] ZNRH Z"E \N'
GN 3RNJ E= I UQN M"  L
 N;H Z R K ST M Z GK  N;%N %N HRH
IVT U > ' Z-K ZNI-QN RLU> ' AST M ZN LK VU> ' AIW3'^ L K VZU> ' AI3WLK
GK N;%N HRH  6I'H EN* JT N JV HRG  M% 7>  V
$  ILQNGN H31
7>PN7>$G RIM]G M% %NE MK ]HV IG=VN M" IH I-V
$ ILQNGN EN* V.
Z" $  ST M ZAHNE  G  HGN M. JT ] V ^  Z^ R \ N;H VVWIUQN% G  Q*NW
%NE I-%4 .  IV] % . U> ' . RLU> ' AST M ZN VU> ' AIW3'^   VZU> ' AI3WLK
V=H GK N;%N HRG RIM]G M% I-%4. GK S>=;K I-%4. IV]%. JT*^Q. V=H
MK KIZV M" I- E-K I-M RN\33 >*N8 %^] ;NR' HKV M
- Z%>=\.
IW= X
$  %KX 3NVR IWR> = ;  N;%N R^ J K G> 3 HRZ HR' WNE  Z^ R \ Z" % ^ ]
STMZ  %^] WK %MK$ *LG I-MK JTZN' UKVN QI;QN-  3E
H A
V(N
V(N A VH QI;QN-   E
H  A V(N
V(N A IWX WK M" 
IWXNR HR
/ A RNW' %  *UWN% I3W LK %] ^  IZT V > ] L    QLRAQZR
RW 3 WR LN'H  *UVK HKVK K GAWNR 3K3 H= 1 H  ZRIJV HKVN
ILG  SGE  > = ;  Z $  RNW' %^ ]  G 3K3 JT N JV M
-    JT ] V ^  Z> H VK %MK$
M
- K RN\33 HMNI-QN I-M G
3  RNW' G  U> R ^ G  W  GN M"  IL %NGN%
%KZMHKZ  % WG. %^] PKH VR4. % Z0H QNJ'K 
X %NE MK VZ
U>'
>HV *UWN% I3W %^] MK J^R' JTZNVZN G=IQN V(N
V(N *
EK QNVZN RNW'

208

) (NR( IUQN% JT H N3 IW3

% 0^P U>R^GW 7>aV IW3WN HRH QNJ' LKW% V(N


V(N H>E GN %N3 HKVN
+ I-H *3ZNIURK %NZ GN N;H K IL%  I3WLK VZ
U > '  %^ ]
MK I-31 Z]% H 3K3QN' 7>aJR %^] J"R %KX %^] 3K3  HRH  NE
V= H  N;%N HKVK *UWN% I3W LK %^ ]  WX%S= ;  HRH  *ZH] Y N E"
IEQN *UWN% I3WLK %^] MK ZNR% E=UN 7>G3 I-M K IH *ZH]Y.
JT N JV HRH  *UWN% I3WLK %^ ]  ZNRH  JNRWVK LK %^ ]  JV%K S'N7^ $ UN
*UWN% 3T K  I3W LK YR G  ZNR  *= L  U-   IFR T K  IW3'^  LK %  7> 
*ZN>R %^] U]YM=( %NE %NX %XNH 7> *ZH]Y %NE *Z HKVN 7>M
I3WLK VZ
U>'  GN N;H RN\33 HMNI-QN MIR'NHI3J> % *UWN%
ST M ZN LK RL
U > '  GK N;%N HKVK V(N
V(N RN\33 HMNI-QN
+ I-=H Z$ Q=L ]%   V
$ EU*U  NE J^RW MIRG>QNR
IW= X  MIR HK J 9 KQ. 7> a V  3NVR IW;K IMV N;%N HR' WNIEQ.
%  H> ] * J> R W GK JR*K GN ] 
U  M
I -QN 7> a (  RW IVT U > '  7> J N3H
ZMNVZN L% I-3%N% HR% WNV  JM> ] X  
  IURK J> R K %N( %NUN
QNIG *UWN% T K  I3WLK VZ
U > '  G  7> J N3H V(N
V(N W" 3 '^  *UWN% 3T K
IW3'^  LK V
U > '  G  7> J NH M% JIME. I-3%N% HR% G  HNR%
%NUN V(N
V(N W"3'
$ N;^Q. IWX [
R >=; M
 IUQN EU*U  J=XK
MLNR  IVTU>' 7>JNH IZTV^ %^] JTNJV M
- L
 IWQHVK ,RNAK U=E 7>aV
MK %R] M NR HVE  QNZ  HR IG] G N M"  7> M  N;^  M"  L. RN\33 W" $
IWXNR HR
  QNZ IWQNHVK WK IHV  I-3%N% HR RM  M
'  V(N
V(N H
- K
IWQHVK QN H  HM  IH Z" % ^ ]  WK I-3%N% G  E-K (N% G '  GK IHT J N
HR
 I331NXNR G %NV HIM]G M% IH QN7> QNJ WK I-3%N% HR E7>
I-=;RA7>;=R M
 H QN7>' WNE %^] (N% G IG]G M% I-E-K JIW=VR
UKVN LK QI;QN-   E
H  A IW= X  IHMN M"  IH IL] % 4 .  GN Z R K
IVT U > ' Z-K ZNI-QN RLU> ' AST M ZN LK VU> ' AIW3'^  LK VZU> ' AI3W
LK  GK J^ L N G  G> Q NRN IUQN% MIRQN LN X> = H N M"   7> M  H W E ZN'
WIYQN-K G  *> = \   RN\33 > * NQ %^ ]  ;NR' HKV  M
-    Z%> = \ . IW= X
$  %KX
QR(NV QNZ IWQNHVK V
$  WK J= I VV > * NQ WNE   G> 3 HRZ HR% WNE
Z^ R \ Z R K *UVK WK %MK$ HRG   UKVN LK QI;QN-   E
H  A
V= H  JIW= V R UKVN LK S
E ' WNEN ST M Z  JT * ^  HIM IRMN M"  IH Z R K
*UVK ST M Z N;%N  WK XNR JT H NR G  N;H HRG  M% I-= H  V.
QNR(NR(K ;] %  EN* XNM> '  WNE  L
 W G  Z] V R. V
$  MK L] V T A Z] V T   MW%
QNIG HRG  RIM] G   M% G^  R  QNRV 3] H 1 I%WNR' G  E-K W G . G
Z] V R. GN L] V T A Z] V T   MW% QNIG HRG  RIM] G   M%  VKR  LIUQN^  L

JTZNVZN G IUQN% %^] LN%' E-K I-=6N R=\' WNE HWE IUQN%A]IUTM
HRH WHVN S' L.G M% V(N
V(N G^IRQ. IW=X IUQN% 3T31VN G QN;NR
7> a V  7> V Z S'H  IUQN%WN% S'H  QI*ZN%W= 3  *UVKMK' M
 L.G  M%
X
( IUQN%K 7>M N;H IL%4. %^] I-M IUQN% M
 IUQN IH ZN%W RKR
WNRAWNR %MK$ IZEGN M" I- V
$ JT*^ ;%N %MK$ S' JN-K V. LKW%
IWQR( M
 LN- U N IFR W G . %^ ]  JI94 Q N IL%4 .  V
$  IUQN% M
I -QN IH

IUQN% U] U N

209

ST M ZN A IW3'^ A I3W LK  IV] %


$  U> '  ST M Z 6RJ> R 3  V(N
V(N JRST M Z
QH3RJ>R3  V
$ 7>aJR J^R' STMZ GK MK *UVK HR%K XNMKGK M" M
R
GWVNW. GK %MK$ 7>%4. IUQN%K 7>GNR QNVZNW. %^] Z"$ X]UN EUGN M.
V(N
V(N Z"%^] 7>M I-E-K Q=6 E=UG M% IH 7>M IV]%
$ U>'. RLU>' STMZN
VU> '  IW3'^   VZU> '  I3W  V
$  7> a JR 7> a PH  Z R K ST M Z  N;%N V.
HR% E=U L
 M
R GWVNW. V
$ X]UK M" JT]V^ WG. IWX
8Z
8Z
8Z
 %NZ L
 HWE
STMZ GK N;%. GN Z]VR M" 7> %^] WG J94% WNE IWGWN%. % QNJ'
QNJ MK IWXNRAIWZR3 HRH  J^ R ' ST M Z GN Z] V R LN'H  NE. V= H
N;%N HRG RM JT*^ JTNJVK M
-K %MK$ M
R I;KQ. JTNJV M
 U-KQ.
IH7> $ IH JIW= V R UKVN QNI;QN-   E
H   V(N
V(N JIW= V R > L RW G
QI;QN-   Z] V R  IW= X  WRI'V V= V WGR3K ] V  %MK$ IZIEQN L

J^R' STMZ GK N;%N IV]% Z]VR %NE G=GN I-E-K IUQN%K WK TK
ST M Z HNE  N;%N HRH  L%ZAIZT V ^  G  X= H R IW= X  MK RIM U- 
I-= H  IUQN%K 7> G NRQNVZN ZM.IR3K X> ' H LK %  W G . %^ ]  JI94 Q N
V(N
V(N I-=H J^R' JT*^ *UVK GN Z]VR 8Z LN'H I-K %NZ GN LNJ %NE
NE. V= H  N;%N HKVK 7>   Z $  I-= H  ZN%;NVN X= H RWRVK RNLN K
X=HRWRVK RNLN 7> %^] HIMG M% IL GN J^RK IJT(WK 7>aV 3N3% M
W
 7>% QNJ' RNL G Q]VRUV RNILQ. %^] >=; G E-K EEHNIRQN
I-=H [
9 G UE IWX J=VR S]%4H NR RNL IWX [>ZNI-QN 3RV K IH
IL% RNLN ZN%;NVN GK U>ENZK Q;K%VN  WKHNR %N M
W 7>%^] >=;
HR%N JW U N 7> M  I- [
9   %^ ]  F9H  S] % 4  EW   IH  %  [
9 N %MK$
_I9QN ZM.IR3K X>'H LK %^] I- U=E GN JVN E=UN IUQN IH RNLN
SM> V  QI*ZN%K M
I UQN M"   IHMN IH Z" $  I- RNL  G  > = ;  %^ ]  IWHNR
HRGN M. >=; 3>R^ M
I-QN ZN%;NVN RNLN H
E  HR
9 "%N K 7>%
XNR *NU HRH  I-= H  *NU  HR
9  " % N %NE ZM.IR3K X> = ' H 7> a V
QNHRZ' HR IG= V N G^  R  JN  ZM.IR3K X> ' H LK %  QNJ'K N;%N
HK HZN-K G  %NE XNR J> V EKQ. S] S  S'N-  V(N
V(N RNLN G  XNR
$  *NU
" % N GN IW%N3 HR IG= V N
IW3 3 /A T K  ST M ZNLK T K  IW3'^ L K T K  I3WLK V(N
V(N ST M Z QV
JRSTMZ GK *UVK %NE JNJ V(N
V(N J>]% G
%4. GN FE *
U'N J"$GN M" J>]%
WRU IWX V(N
V(N JNJ %RH V(N
V(N XRNK E=\ JTN'KQ. G RKR IWX H-K
NV%NW. *
U 'KQ. J" $ GKQ. M% ILW $  IUQN%K QNVZN T K  X> ' H LK %
L
 8Z %NZ G LNJ GK HZN-K HKVK 7> %NE H>0 V. I;K 3HVK XNR
J> V EKQ. S'NH  ZNJV HR IG= V N IL %NE ZM.IR3K HMNI-QN H> 0
N;%N FE ZM.WRU IWX *
U H  IFR %RH IWX LN- U N V(N
V(N IFR
X R NKAE= \  JT N 'KQ. G  RKR ;NR% HRH  H31 7> a V  H31 M U N L

 HR
9  JT N 'KQ. " I %H.  GN ] M NR WX% %NE HKVN K 7>  GN *
U
WK *
U'N MWUN XNM H
-K MI(QNR %NE M=IVQN HR XNM WX% R^JK
VEWNR %NE G
%4. GN ZN% G]Y JT*^ IG]GN M" LG 7> ZM.IR3K X>'HLK
GN LKW H>=V G RKR IWX M
WUN 7>G IR IW=X L\Z M
WUN 7> IWX

210

) (NR( IUQN% JT H N3 IW3

HK9 S'H 7>%4. "I%H. G LKW QNJ'N JTVK3


; E"'U HG E=V 1>=1UK
HG IJ6E J"R. %^] Q;R]U M
H Q=U J"R. %NE I[9 H X=EU
 N V(N
V(N URZKARGK
GN G>\
=  QIM' 
U GRG H-K JTHNR %NE *
U' MK J"'U
I-E-K JIW= V R UKVN LK S
E ' WNEN ST M Z HNE  UKVN Q/
E
H IWX W"$ HIM IRMN M" IH I-M RW IUQN%K QNVZNW. V. %
H M% JT ] V ^  J^ R ' JT Z NVZN GK IV] %  Z] V R GK WNVIWH N;%N G=  '
WNEN V=VWGR3K ]V %N IZE' G HNR% I-M * ZRK MK Q%>VZNZ
Q3T  3 1 Z> = H VK UVK  GK QN IWX MK QN3IRV RM  QR(NV Z R K
N;%N WK Q3T  3 1 M"   I-E-K JIW= V R UKVN Q/ E
H   IWX
IHMN M" IH M QRL>%C V^] RW *NW %NE 7> J^R' JTZNVZN GK 3R%
IW= X  XEN LN ILGK IHT J N %NE V^ ]  JRZ3.VK V(N
V(N %NV% JRZ;NZ
VE
H  %^] JTNJV M
W$UN JIW=VR UKVN LK %^] TK IHT3% LK G RKR
IWX JT  V W= 3  JT W  3  M
H   W" $  ST M Z HNE  %  S
I EQN IFR H-K NE.
SNQG JIW=VR UKVN LK V(N
V(N JIW=VR XNR
$ WG. %^] ZM.IR3K IWQN LK
G RKR IWX JTV W=3 JTW3 HRH QNJ STMZ 6RJ>R3  G>QNRN IEJKS=;
WK W"$ MK HKV I-%4. IW=X JTZNVZN H"N M" IHW$ 7>GK *UVK HR%K
M"  V(N
V(N HK 7>JE=*GK M
WUK IUQN% V. J^R% WR'% M" JT]V^ J^LN GK
IW;K HWE STMZ 6RJ>R3  QR(NV L
VK I%R]L%AHNE V=H GK MK M"
J^ R ' ST M Z GK *UVK E-K JIW= V R UKVN Q/ E
H   IW= X
JIW=VR UKVN S
E' WNEN STMZ  JT*^ QNJ HIM IRMN M" J^R' JTZNVZN
GK *UVK V(N
V(N JTNJVK G E-K IH V=VWIUQN%K ]V %^] E=* E" IFR L"
7>M IW;K G=' W" HR JIW=VR UKVN LK %^] S
E' WNEN JT*^ HIM IRMN
M" IH J^R% JTZNVZN GN J^R' IUQN% V(N
V(N *UVK IW;K Z"$ %MK$ LN'GN
QNJ'K N;%N G  SNR  IWX UKVN Q/ E
H  IW= X  IHMN M"  IH Z R K
*UVK GN V. H W E I-H 8Z
 Q= \ R M"  ILGN 7> X NR' HRH  Q] I VZ
8Z 
>Q. VL% GMZ  V=H LNJ HR% %NE ZR WNEK JRZUVK %^] JTNJV
M
W  U N IFR UKVN Q/ E
H  IW= X  IHMN M"  IH L
 JT * ^  XNM' WNEK
QNVZNW. %^ ]  V= V WGR3K ] V  %MK$ IZIEQN L
 J^ R ' ST M Z GK N;%N
LN'GN M
W    I-E-K 7> M  7> G NR QNVZNW. Z R   WNEK Q%> V ZNZ
QIV[1KQN JRZUVK IW= X  MK QN3IRV M% JIW= V R UKVN LK S
E '
WNEN JT*^ W"$ HIM IRMN M" IH ZRK N;%N V
$ M
' WNEK UVK QR(NV
Z> H VK WK QIV QN3T  3 1 M" 

M
R GWVNW. RLU>' STMZN LK VU>' IW3'^ LK
VZU>' I3WLK  GK J^LN S>=;KMK' MK HRG M%
QI;QN-  E
H  IWX IHMN M" IH ILGN S]; Q/ G E
H
 V
$ EUNVNR M"A E
H  IW=X IHMN IH IVTU>' ZNI-QN L
 RLU>'
STMZN LK VU>' IW3'^ LK VZU>' I3WLK GK J^LN VH KZV M% V(N
I-%4. V
$ JTNJV I6'H *R >=\  G G>QNRN IL%4. GN IUQN% MIRQN LN

IUQN% U] U N

211

212

) (NR( IUQN% JT H N3 IW3

IUQN% U] U N

213

X>=IHQN M" Q" Q>R >*NQ %^] ;NR% HKV %KX IWQHVK G>3HRZ HR%
WNE Z^R\ Z"%^] WK %MK$ *LG QI;QN-  G E
H  IWX 7>%4.A7>%4.
*
U . GK HNZ%N G  HNR% IL%4 .  GN IUQN% MIRQN LN X> = I HQN M"  7> M
QNJ' >*NQW3 JTIRV M
 H QIUQN% Q]I;HNR WNE I%Z G QN3IRV
M
R GWVNW. %^] J^LG M% QI;QN-  G E
H  IWX IHMN M" IH
L
A L
 *UV ILAIL G W VN G  WR^ J  %^ ]  3R;N %NE J^ L 'N XNM> ] G N M"
7>A7> *UV GK 3R;N %^] Z"$ 7>K GWVN G JTVK I(R HRGN M.
QI;QN-  G E
H  IW=X IHMN M" IH 7>M IL 3R;N %NE >HV
M
H IL GWVN GK J^LN HRGN M" IH7>$IH 7> GWVN V
$ ZR G>QNRN MK
IW;N% HKV M
- H>0 I-=6V *
U. %^] JTNJV HRGN M" ILW$ Z>=\Z]VRK HM
IH %KX G QI;HNRK ZR MK %HR M% Z"$ 7>%^] H>0 QI;HNR G R=\
M% L
 7>%4. G QI;HNRKQ. G  MK QNI3TV M" 7>M EN* WK ZR G>QNRN
MK IG= V N L.GN M"   JT ] V ^  J^ R ' EN* %MK$ M"   Q/  G  E
H   IW= X
WR'% M" IH JT]V^ 7>%4. Z]GS=>;K WNIEQ. GN 7>M FE %N3WN% M>]GN M" G
WVNW. %^] J^L' WNE GWVNW. %^] JTNJV M>]G M% ZG*UV  ZVNSE]SK
L
 WG. IWX WRI'V *UVK IW;K Q%>NR *UVK HR% WNE *UV MK Z"%^]
JT N JV M> ] G   M% QR(NV HNE G  LNE IWX
$  H
- K SNMR %MK$ M" 
IW33/A Q/ G E
H A IW=X IHMN M" IH 7>M L
 WK N;%N IH
WK IJ= V R *^ V  G W KAG W VN QNIG GK J^ L N > * N8 W3 HRG  M% Z" $
STMZAHNE  MK 7>%4. Z]G S>=;K E
H. *UV.  %]^ 7> GWVN G JTVK QN3HV
HRGN M. 7>M %NGN% N;H L
 EN* GWV.WN V
$ JN7>$G M% Z"$ HNE %
 MK GWVNW. %^] H>0 3HVK G R=\K M" 7>K QN;NR 7>aV 7>%.4  G GWV.WN
G  J>LNRK GWV.WN %^] JTNJV M
 LN'U JTV
] ^ 7>%.4  S=;
> KMK' N;H. GK 7>M J^LN
 E=\ L^%KQ. IW=X LEGK MK E" LN' WNEK M" V(N
V(N L
 Z"%]^ HNE  %^] J^LG M%
7>M VJVI3EN 7>aV IFR ZR ZM.WRU STMZE
H  IW=X XE L.G M% V(N
7>V
$ SNQG L%ZAZR% IW=X MK RIM'U Z
H3 JTNJV %MK$ M
WUN *NW
QR( M" GWKAGWV.WN V(N
V(N STMZN IW3'^ I3W V(N
V(N ZNVN V
$ *UWN% STMZ
GK N;%N ILQNGN EN*GNI-H M" *E MK ZM.WRU IW=X U- N;H GN
WRU Z$ I-=H ZM.HEJ V=H WK M
 HGN M" JT]V^ ZM.WRU IW=X 3>*
HRZ. GN >=\ *
UH IFR %RH V(N
V(N M
R JTN'KQ. G RKR IW=X WK H31
SI'QN RMUN J^R' Z
H3 %MK$ QR(NV HNELNE V
$ Z>HVK %MK$

M
R  JRZN'

JIW= V R UKVN V(N


V(N JIW= V R W G . IW= X  M
R  G W V.WN GK J^ L N V(N
IJ=VR J^LN 3RN;  H=<'N V(N
V(N *^V J^LN Q(KQ. X>=H'N QR(NV F>=E
X= > U 'N IJ] Y  *RWN%N Z94 K Q. GK J^ L N  HR%N Z%4 N  HKVN M" 

JIW=VR XNR
$ WG. Q%>NR N;%. GN JTK'NZ HWE
WRUAZM.WRU JTNJVK Z>HVK %MK$
JIW= V R UKVN QI;QN-   G  E
H    IW= X  IHMN M"  IH L

214

) (NR( IUQN% JT H N3 IW3

Z%
H NZ%. HNZ  I3= ; K G  E-K Z R K J^ L N IV] %
$  W G . IW= X  WRI'V
N;%N 3NVR Q%> H ^ E  HRG  M% 7> M  QNJ'  HT Z . G  QN;NR 7> a V
ZM.WRU IW= X  QN%] G  ZN% H  IFR L%ZAZR% IW= X  QN L.G  M%
QR(NV = U  XNM  3NVR Q%> H ^ E  WK M
W    7>  GN I-= H  ZNVR EN*
]NIRH *
U WRU
WRU V(N
V(N IFR %RH V(N
V(N  E=\ L^%KQ. MK M% LG
$
V=H IV]%
$ Z]VR 8Z V(N VV W IV ]HIVH  J^R' ]V V
$ JTNJV %MK$
M>]G QI;QN- G E
H IW=X IHMN M" IH L
 I%3HNZ *NW %NE Z
RK 3NVR Q%>H^E J^LN HRG M% 7>%4. GK J^LN GK N;%N GK R=I\QN
Z" $  QNJ HRGN M. Z> H VK %MK$

3NVR IW;K IWR>=; N;%N JV% GN HNR%#


JIW= V R UKVN QI;QN-   E
H    IW= X  IHMN M"  IH L

IWQHVK M
R GWV.WN %^] J^LG M% 7>M WK ZRK HNE LNE IWX RIM'
WNEK  J^LN MK HR RM M% JT]V^ 7>%4. GK I-M J^LN QIW;K J^RWH M"
QR(NV 3NVR IWR>=; M" *NW QR( M" IH M
R GWVNWN %^] %MK$ J^L'N
XNMKGN  IH7> $ IH ] J ^ R % = U . GN *
U VN QV  > Q NZK Z" $  MK M. 7> M
*UV Z"%^] X]UK VR4. %MK$ LN'G I-E-K JV% %^] JTNJV M>]G M% %RH
V(N
A IW=X
V(N  E=\ L^%KQ. GN H31 ILW$ UKVN QI;QN-  E
H A
IHMN M" IH RW =U. IW=X JTIV3IPV QR(NV %ZNI%V IL%4. %^] =U
ZRJ' HKVK L.GK M" 7>M JTZNVZN RW UIVZ STMZ  J^R% STMZ M"
7> M  HRZN;NR S'NH  RW JT N 'KQ. %^ ]  JT G N% HRGN M"   JT ] V ^  J^ R ' ] V
%N IZE' V=H RW=U. GN *
U QN%]G  HNE Z% R^^J IW=X  MK *
UGN
M" I-E-K HIM IRMN M" IH Z"$ RW *
UVN V =U. GN WNZK M.

3RN; H=<' IJ=VR J^L'  WNE IJ=VR S'%U Z>HVK %MK$

UKVN QI;/  G E


H  IW=X IHMN M" IH GWV.WN %^] J^L' WNE
GWV.WN %^] JTNJV M>]G M% IJ=VR. %^] J^L' WNE IJ=VR. %^] JTNJV M>]G
M% *^V. %^] J^L' IJ]Y GN% HR%  WNE *^V. %^] JTNJV M>]G M% QR(NV
*^ V  S' L.G  M% 3N3VR Q%>  NR JIW= V R W G . V(N
V(N UKVN Q%>  NR
J^ L N HR% WNE  Z" % ] ^  MK JT N JV M> ] G   M% QR(NV HNE G> Q NRN I%RIZV
WRU V(N
V(N ZM.WRU QNIG G  H> 0  ILQNGN Z. Z L  HR E" $ G  M%
IW33/A ILW$ H
-K VIMKEGNR GK %HRK WNAJ^LN  HRGN M" V.
7> M  VIMKEGNR %MK$ S' HGN M. 7>  V
$  JT N JV ;] %  V(N
V(N R
L KAR
1 K
X=EUK QR(NV 7>G QN;K% MK RMUN PKH I- VR4. L
 IL GW 3TK
STMZN GW 3TK IW3'^ GW 3TK I3W GW QR(NV IVTGW  GK J^LN %HRK
HRGN M"  V. 7> % 4 .  V
$  IZE' WNE  EN* MK JT N JV HRGN M"   IVT U > ' Z-K
ZNI-QN QR(NV IV] %
$  U> '  RLU> '  ST M ZN LK VU> '  IW3'^  LK V(N
VZU>' I3WLK  GK J^LN GN I%6; JIW=VR UKVN QI;/  E
H  
V(N
V(N   V=H IW=X WK M" I- JTHNR H
-K IJ=VRN GK J^LN %HRKA
WN  HRGN M" V. IJ=VRN G H
E 6
1N IJ=VR S'H 7>%4. G H
E MK H31

IUQN% U] U N

215

*
UUN I- JTHNR H
-K *^V. JTV.  GK J^LN WN  HRGN M" V. *^V
S' U N IH7> $ IH NRN LKW% IL IW= X  QN3= H VN S'K M"  Q] V  IW= X  7> % 4 .
IW=X MK Z% FIQN RIM]GN M" IL HNR' 7>%4. H
E XEN L.GN M" H>0
GN HIM'N M" IJ=VRA*^VAGW J^LNW. WK HRG RM$U QNJ V
$ 7>JG3 E"
H N;N%. WK HRG RM.U Q"N %MK$ XEUN L
 N;%N JIW=VR UKVN
LK V(N
V(N JIW= V R XNR. W G . IWX Z%4 .  M"  7> M  HR%N 3NVR IWR> = ;
M
I -QN IL%^ ]  JIW= V R UKVN QI;QN-   E
H  A IW= X  Z%4 N
HKVN M"  L
 3NVR IW;K IVQNUH  Z%ZN%K QNXR' J^ L N  HRG  M%
7>M %N V. >\ %^] JTNJV HRG M% %N JRZUVK %^] V(N
V(N %N MK H
-K HNRL
I=; HR% WNEK I3;K %^] MK JTNJV HRG M% QR(NV LKW% IWQR( HR
L.G  M% I-E-K QRL> %  V R   E-K HRV= W  L
 N;%N G  HRZ HR%

U M%  V(N
V(N QHRV=W L
 N;%N G HRZ %MK$ HR% 
U M%  GK IWW(N
I%Z IW= X  IW= X  3NVR MK JT Z N' M% M
R  N;%N WRILV M%
I-GN JTZN' ZNRH]Y J>RN' UKVN JT" U
R\J>R V
$ JTHNI3V FN
 V  M"   IL IW= X  ZNRH] Y   J> R N' V(N
V(N ST M Z J> R N'.H I-H= P N MK
ILEG HKVN M"  IW=X WK M" IH I-=H R>XK %NZ GN N;H STMZXNRK RIMH
W G . Q%>  NR N;%N HR IRMN K LG
$  7> M   NE GN M
I -QN VG
7>%^] QNJ'  J^RWL L
 3NVR IWR>=; N;%N HRH IJ=VR S' M
- %
V(N
V(N H31 *
U RM % IG\N-K IG=V IJ=VR. % IHMN IH S1N R>XK
3NGK HRWNH NY 3RN; H=< QK$ V. G>=\K M
 RM M. R>XK IR3K %
IHMN IJ= V RZM
 W G  IW= X  HRZ H.Y ZNRU 3RN; IJ] Y  *RWN7> ' N
QNIG  %^] Z^R\N GK N;%N IHMN M" IFR QNJ Z"%^] 7> UEV 3NVR
IW;K RIMV  N;%N 7>aV IH7>$ EUN RM M
 IJ=VR S
E J>=VR I-M U=E
V. VRK =X M" IH WG IW=X V. IJ=VR J^LN *^V J^LN GWKAGWIVQ. GK
J^LN HRZ H.Y  %^] QIW=IGQN MK IHMN M" I- IW=X VI%H WK IZI(QN
%MK$ M" #I-K 7>JR
HV ZNRH]Y J>RN' IW=X I-K E\ IW=X IJ=VR. %
IHMN IH IFR IJ= V R H> 0  V. EN* IG] G   M%
IW3/AI-M QNJ'K Q1HE IJ=VR. % EUN-K M" 7>M QK$ JNE'N
%MK$ HR%K IH7> $ IH J> R N'. IW= X  QNG 3  IHK IR3K IW3 3  GN M"  L

IJ=VRAJ^L' *^V L. M


R GWAJ^L' %^] IHMN M" JT]V^ WG. IW=X JTZN' %N
M
'  G  HNR% JT * ^  GN QNG 3  %MK$ M"   I-E-K IHK ] V  L. IR3K G
HIM' %NE JT*^ GK QNIUQN GK 7>E]['N HR% %NE LN G *NUK M
W.U
I-=H Z$ I-=H IWQHVK GK G
VK I-=H J>IE (N'GNR G %NE M

U-K 7>   IWQHVK %  QNJ'  G


 V (N' G NR %] ^  IHMN IH Z R N U> Q .<K
Z"%]^ SM>V JT3N% HRGN M" (N'GNR 6+2 
 % IHMN IH ZNR E=P Z"$
QNJMK G \  EW.UN (N' G NR G
 V GK QNIUQN GN JNE' HRH  7> 
IWQHVK % QNJ' UWN<K G E=P ZNRK IR 7>aV =1 E=U' G HNR'
7>  GK IZT V ^  M
 U-K 7>   \ V R GN QI;HNRK M
'  G  HNR' 7> M  (N'N
JT*NRK QNJ' G
V %]^ JH9H IEQI-QN LE IWX >=1 IG=VN V(N
V(N 7>%^]
IZV^  G] Y  IZIEQN 7>  GN G
 V (N' G NR H> 0  Z= G G %MK$ HR IHQN
IH7> $ IH RNL  GN ] I W;N% M"  L H R H
- K IH  GK M= I VQN HRGN M"  V.

216

) (NR( IUQN% JT H N3 IW3

7>  %^ ]  3LN IZE U K 7>   %NGN% IWQHVK %  QNJ'  G


 V GK QNIUQN
Z]%H ]IW;N% *]U HR IG=VN IL HNR% LKW% V
$ M=( ;
 S"PN PKH
I- V R4 .  JIW= V R UKVNLK V(N
V(N JIW= V R W G  I-M JT * ^  GN ] I W;N% M" 
IL IW=X HWE I-=H J^R' JTZNVZN GK J^LN GN MK IW;N% M" M
R G
WVNW.A IJVR.A*^ V . GK J^ L N HR%N Z%4 .  M"  J> R N'. IW= X  IR3KQ. (N'
GNR  GN QNG3 M" ILGK QNIUQN JNE' HR% %NE JT*^ GN ]IW;N%
*]U M
' 7>aV H31 7>PN7>'N JWUN I-E-K QNZ 7>JN%N J^R' Z
H3
IW= X  SN;H M" 

IV H(N#

ZR J^L U>R^GW WNZK RNZGWN%]G GK EU*U 


E4. NE GK 7>ZR
IW=X J^R' JTZNVZN GK JTNJVK G E-K QXN%H [R IVQNUH I%=HE U-
 JTVKIG% JIM%' WNE WVR. %]^ QNJ' MK \V. G I%=H1 [' L]UE
IW=X IH IZTV J3^ GK Q(KQ. G H
E R=\ U- 3NZ %]^ [R %N JM>>]X'
G  HNR% [R WNIEQ. %  L] U E IW= X  VEN3 HKVK RNV GN Z. K
H= J 9  JIMXN'H  G> = \ K Z% %NE J3^  GKQ. QI(Q. %] ^  S= X   GKQ.
Q(KQ. Z0H X>=H IEQN V(N
V(N I-M 
IXQN IH S=XN L]UE IW=X XEN
IUQN IH IM]H J3^ % \N IEQN Q]IVZ ]HNR HR IG=VN RW
IHT Q NW. HKVKQ. V R 4 W K$ SRK QNIG HKVK V(N
V(N 3RN; WK H= < G  RM 
EU*U  NE 7>ZR JTNJV M
' G SNQG >QNZK LK QXN%H QNJ'
IJ] Y  S9N J" $ VNWN I,E4 N  I*WN%K VIM+ XR\KGNGRK MIRQN'N IW= X
JM> ] X  U-   > Q NZK LK GN SXJ% GN %NZ T K  MIRG> Q NRK LK K V(N
JIW=VR STMNZ' H>E IW=X L%Z K Z>0 GN %^] JVN X=IEQN V. Z"$ WK
GR3%N E-K JM>]X IUQN >QNZK LK GK *NSK LK L
 EU*U  NE
GK 7> Z R GK K Z" $  7>   IST ; N %^ ]  J= > I 6QN IH NY  U> R ^  LK G  [R
IVQNU' LN' G 7>JR]V HK ZIM^ HKVN 7> ISR;N % G=IQN IH Z
RN IWQNM M
I -QN VG Z" % ^ ]  G= I QN IUQN IH I-%4 .  GN I-H *N-K
MIRG>QNRK K L
 IH IM]H LN%WR % L]UE IWX \N IEQN K 7>G
3RN; H=< LN RM K Z"%^] WK I-%4. G 3RN; H=<' E-K IHMN IUQN
IST;N % G=IQN IH  3RN; V. Z"$ QNJ' M=(. %NE H=< X>=HK M. LG
$
HG FE X]UK %MK$ M>]GK L. H
-K [R GN Z"$SR ISZNR M
 L.GN M" V.
QNJ' JT
IMV U>R^ LK  V
$ HNR' J>=6G V. 7>M IHMN HRG IH MIRG>QNRK
IJ= V R SI'QN M"   7> M  QNJ%^ ]  G> = \ K HR IRMN M"   3RN;. G  H= < ' IW= X
H
-K Q3>=;K RMK M" I-WNR RW IHTQN Z"$ QNJ' M=(. %NE HR.UN
JIME. Z" % ^ ]  Z $  %MK$ IZIEQN K IH7> $ IH I-= H  IG% IW= X  H-K LU4 .
3RN; IHTQNW. HR% LN'N IJQN I-E-K S=IXQ. %^] *ILQN K VG
V=H H>0 *$1 X9N7> V. IH 7>%^] 3.V HKVN LNW VG 7>%^]  L. 
L
 WK HIM]GN K YRG *$1 HRG % IFR 3RN;. G Z$ U>R^ LK W"$
3RN; HRG % VG Z"$ IHMN ZNVN LK M>' V. 6=Y GW
 I- UKVN LK
IWR>=; N;%. %^] %MK$ V. QNJ WK JTV S'
UK UKVN QI;QN-  E
H
 >'NI-QN VG 7>M IST;N HIM' E=UK UKVN Z"$ WK J94GK M. GN %

IUQN% U] U N

217

IHMN QNJ JI94QN M" JT]V^ ZI0QN %MK$ Q=U V


$ S]G HR IG7> I-
%NGN% N;%N %^] IST;N % 7>aVR IG=VN  %N *N-K IHW$ 6=Y GW. 3RN;
H= < 'N I-M V. GKQ. J> R N'K ENU  J] T J RN M"   I-M G
3  *
E K
QNVZ.WN GN %MK$ M" I-M G
3 Z^R\ U>R^Q. %KZ MHKZ.  GN M" IL%4.
%  QNJ'  JIW= V R 3NVR. %^ ]  Z0  IS%. Z%ZN%N QNXR' J^ L N GN
ZNRU  G=   IG= V N IL HNR% %N V. H
- K HNRL I= ;  M> ] G N M"   %N
JRZUVK V(N
V(N %N H
- K > = \  MK JT N JV M> ] G N M"   JT Z N' JIW= V R UKVN
QI;QN-   E
H  A
M> '  GN GK JT N (%N M"  IH I= I \QV WRU ,R^ R  I;QN% G '  V(N
3NVRIW;K Q%>  NR N;%N HRH  J^ R % JT Z NVZN G  %NV% JRZ;NZ
3N3WVZ (N%Z  QR(NV VE
H %^] JTNJV HR
 IL%NE J^R' Z
H3
V(N
V(N JRZ 3.VK JTNJV M>]GK M" UKVN QI;QN-  E
H   I-G
E-K V= V WGR3K ] V  GK VEN HR
  UKVN QI;QN-   E
H  
I-=H 3R;NE^ % IHMN IH Z"$ QNJG V
$ 7>JG3 E" H QNJG G>QNRN
G=  K N;%N WK HRGN RM.UN V(N
V(N 3RN; WK H= < GN RM.UN V(N
V(N [R E ^
GWKAGWIVQ. %^] WK 7>JRE Z% V
$ J^LGN RM.UN I-IWX HK G
3 M"
I- GN GK JT N (%N/A ] I W;N% GK IH  WK ;NRN GN 7> E ] [ ' HR
G '  7> a V  ,N LR^ R  IZE U K I-E-K JIW= V R UKVN LK V(N
V(N JIW= V R
XNR
$  W G . IW= X  WRI'V V  WRILV IW;K G  IWJRKV N;%N HR%N
IWQR( M" JTZN' JIW=VR UKVN LK QI;QN-  E
H A IW=X 
L H
-K HM IH Z"$ HNR IW=X J"$XR 7>J=RE Z% V
$ HR GW.UN %MK$
RNZ %NZ GK U= Y K GN J" $ XR HR%N Z%4 N  M"   PKH I-  JT H NR 3NVR
IWR> = ;  N;%N MN%KHNRH MK M" 
I-H 3R;NE^  %  IHMN IH Z" $  M
R  H
- K IWHNR ZIGRNAZN QNIG
 W %  %MK$ HRGN H W E V] S NH^  SK9KAIUT 1 AM> = H N   W % HRGN M.
QNJG  G> Q NRN G=  K J^ L N V  IUQN% QIV7> V Z M"   Z" $  U> R ^  LK WK
S'NI-QN M" JT]V^ I-M IUQN% Q=L V=H IH ]V G H
E %MK$ M" Z"$ 
NE V
$ [>]Z IRMN M. V(N
V(N IV]% U>R^GW SGE X>=HN M. IHTJN Z"%^] V]SNH^
W% GK 6>=1 G GW
 SNHK * 3RV. Z]L^R M% V]SNH^ %NE *UVK IW=X
HK R> H NW1 QN7> $ GK M" 
GN GK JTN(%N /AGN % JTN(%N HKVK IH QNJ' RKR %^] QNHKL%
GK LR^ R V M"   V] S NH^  GN ;^ ] Q . HNRS%AYN-KAQHNI-Y M"  L
 F F I9Q.
%^] H]Z,
R V RHV G^I3V HRGN M" ZN%W RKR JT*^ JTNJVK V QNVZ
HIEQN' G  E-K MK JT N JV M
I -QN M"   I- IWX JT Z NVZN JN7> '  GN
RVN >3Z%N %N9K V
$ 3>R^ M>]GN M" L
 %=H G G
%
4$ 6G M% =L %^] I-9N
V(N
V(N \=S %^] IJ]U>EN HIM]G M% I-%4. G
%4. G Z=; IW=X >3Z%N %N9K M"
ILIW= X  I-H 6
1 K ^ - K QHHGHO  IW= X  ;NUN JT
'  WNEN 6 G  G  ZN%
G>QNR M>]GN M" L
 V]SNH^ G ;]^- %NE S]G M
 L.GN M" ILV
$ JT*^ JTNJVK
G ZNRU QWR
; M
 L.GN M" L JT*^ JN7>' GN RVN MK S]G M
 IUQN
V. Z%>=\K RKR IWQR( M
I-QN I-E-K JT*^ *UVK HR% WNE N;H
%^] JTVH %3KE W Q\NG ZN QNIG  JGNR(. GN RWGN I%6; M"

218

) (NR( IUQN% JT H N3 IW3

I-= H  R;NE^  %  IHMN IH Z" $  V] S NH^  JT 


U  %MK$ HRGN ZN V(N
ZIGRN  W % LR^ R  HRGN M. I- V
$  *UVK IW= X  HK R>HNW1 M"I-M
V. \N'AJK' G E-K S'N-K M" V(N J9AJIGQ. IW=X WK V. LKW M" 7>M
V. \N'N WK V. ZN *H3' V>=E M"
GN GK JT N (%N/AL H R H
- K NY  ZNVNAIJVNA*N-KA*" '  V  S= X 
QNIG %^] ZNRH \N- V. H"N E=U L"N GRG QNJ' M
W W"N LN% ISRN%
L
IWQHVKJ3^Q.%]^ZNRG
HM"HSKRWLN-%RHZ$L
HN13K3\>RN%#L

Z$ \>R. V(N


V(N 3K3 %]^ SRIMZK %NE H=1H ZN \.G M% 7>M %RH G
*NUK M
'U L"N G>=\ QNJ' S=IXQ. V ]S];KQ. GK M=IVQN GN M>> ]GN M"
Q"N MK G^R %^] LN%'N XNMK- RMK U=E J9AJIGQ. %^] \N' GK 7>%4.
%] ^  \N' GN JT * ^  GN QNG 3  M"  V(N
V(N I-M L94  L^ % K G  M% M
R  X V %
JT N 'KQ. GK M= I VQN JT * ^  QNG 3  IWR> = ;  M"   I-E-K QJRN; JNJ  M" 
ZIGRN  W % WK JT * ^  GN QNG 3  %MK$ M"   JT ] V ^  J= 3 1 Z%4 N  M"  V(N
ZN%W LKW% %]^ SRSNG HR% GN M" 3RNS JN' HKVN M
I-QN IWQHVK
H> 0  WK UEVK HR HGN M"   ZIGRN JN' ;] % AV% V JIRWNIRH 3.VK
V(N
V(N ZNL =I*QVN GK ZM. G>3Z' M" IJQNR S=IXQ. G *NWK XIR=VR
7>aV WK H>JT*NW J"$GN M" ZIGRN JN' HR% WNEN IWQHVK IH]%N WK %
H M
W JT]V^ 7>GK %N I-=LV RIM]GK M" V(N
V(N %N MK IW3WN3
I-=H Z$ I-M GN I-=H IJ]Y IW=X IV]U HR% IUQN M
I-QN K
7> IG% %3N I%6; 7>aV IV]U HKVN IV]U G 7>JT]V I-=H  NE
GK H] I %QN F> 1 A H  R
'  E= U K J> = 6 ' 7> a V  7>   S 1 K %  G= I QN IH
ZMNRNL LK Z R   IJVNLK JNEZ MWN-K Q= Y   7> a V  W;KQN % H RK HRG
M% JT]V^ NR J" GK 3RNS JK L.G M% ZRK Z]ZK G Z%4. HR% 7>aV
I-]%. H>=1G M% IH RKR 7>aV %KE GNU J" L.G M% I-=H IG% ZR
JNJN LK ZRK Z]ZK %]^ H>=1' E=U Z"$ QNJ'K Z]ZK G 7>aV IY=UH SXN8
HR% E=UK V. Z"%]^ WK H>=I1QN ZRN S>=E4 >L IUQN G IG% IW=X PKH
M
I-QN ZRK Z]ZK LK N%]^ 6=YH ZR ZNZN LK G [R XEK U-K 6
ZMK% IJ6
$ ZRK GNGK LK LNH IEQN-K V=G V=H QK$ QNJ'K GNGK LK
G  JN RM   JNJN LK %  GWN-K WK %MK$ IGWN-K WR LEGK 7>aPH
%HRK V XE U- 3NZ %^] 3RNS JK H QN7>$G QK$ IV]% *"'. M. G
 Z
R V
$ 6
1KQ. M% M>' LG
$ JNJN LK 3NZ %^] QN7>$G V. QK$ IV]% *"'. Z]L
%KX E>=H L.GKQ.
IWXNR HR
 J> ] % QNVZN8$ IL] % . S= I XQ. %^ ]  IJVNLK %^ ]  K%  %NE
EUN7>'N XNMKGN K V(N S=X IJVN LK G [R IW=X QN7>' GK RNM G?G
M% IH JNJN LK [R QN-$U FE IEQN7>'U Q=L I- ZN%W ZNL GK
G> 3 Z% 3RNS %  HK [R [NE IG= V    3RNSK IWQHVK QNJ'K V. MN%K
HRGN M"  %NE MK SM> V  IWQHVKQ. GK QNVZN %^ ]  G> \ N7> '  GN WK JNJ
IR R= \ GN M"   ILW $  JV%K G  G> = \  IWX 7>  G  ZNVNAIJVN *N-KA*" '
G> = \ K IFR QNJG  ZNVNAIJVN *N-KA*" '  GNGNAGNGK QNIG JT  3 N%
I-= H  3RNSK IWQHVK QNAJN G  *GR IWQHVKQ. GK Q3.VK GN
HNR% S'GN M"   IH7> $ IH [R IW= X  0U9N HRGN M"   JV%K V S= I XQ.

IUQN% U] U N

219

GK IXENM1 >'H U>Q.<K IW=X SXN8 HR% V. 3RNSK UE J" LN' %MK$
HR% V. %H IWQHVK %^] %K$G %MK$ QN7>$GK I- GN V
$ 7>JG3 E"'
V
$  7> J R] V  JT V KIG% 3RNS JK' WNE  EU*U I-= H  E= \  IWQHVKQ. %
RW %3KE JGNR( V(N
V(N ZN J^R' R^J IW=X IVQNU IG=VN M" V(N
V(N IL
Z$ 3NZ %^] 3RNS JTV%K GN I%TV M>]GN K M>' 7>M J>]%QNVZNW. QNJ'
S=IXQ. %NE S"PH 3]I;QN QNRVK HRG M% MIRQN'N JTG3
  V I%=H1WRVK
JT . VN IW= X  EU*U G=   M,NR IJ] Y . V 3IMR. IW= X  Q= L  WK JT V  H  IW= X
XNRAJ] L  X" $ IJQ% I-= H  %] S R G  3RNSK  7> G NMR' M% L
 RW
IWHNR. V
$  RIMV M
 H  QNJ'N ZN%W LKW% FE HR RM  M% H> 0
HIM]G M% IH QK$ I-]%K %MK$ \.GAJK$G S HG E" E"$G M. ,IMR
V. (
94N MK S>RN M" L
 *UVK W Z>=HVK IW=X SN;H M"
Z] % E7>  G
 IHE
 UT N Z [K GN MEWN S'NI-QN IV*UVK HKVK 
IFR  UTNZ SNE^ RV V]SNH^AZNAZIGRN W% V QN' 7>JN3%N HR
E-K  WK JN IG=VN 7>M V. HKVN HRNI-QN IWQR( M
I-QN I-E-K
J^R' JTZNVZN GK JRZ QH3R STMZ  GK J^LN J^R% ]V V
$ JTNJV HRH
QLKW% ZIRNGN IWX HRG RIM' %NE MK J^R% Z
H3 EN* M>]GN M"

V=VWIUQN% JTNJVK G SNQG MK *UVK QNR]* M>]GK M"#


QI;QN-  G E
H  GN *NW M" IH L
 WK QI;QNVIZH
L. ]NIRH H]Z HR * ZR ZVQ%>NR WG. IW=X WRI'V J^LN IW;K
Q%>NR MK HRZ HR 7>M 7>JNH Z>0 HNE  V
$ MK EN*NIW]V M>]GN M"
I-GN WR%' I-K QI;QN-  G  E
H  AIW= X  HKVN M"   QI;QN-
 G E
H  IW=X *UWN% HIMG M% IH Z"%^] IH %NE GB"3 L. IJQNR
%MK$ M" JT]V^ V>R]V MK HIM RM M% IH L
 Z"%^] JTZ %NE *LG M% V(N
7>M Z"%^] IJQNR M% V(N Z"$ 7>%4. %^] IJQNRN M. QR(NV Z"$ 7>%4. IW=X
M. V(N
V(N 7>M ZR IW=X M% RNU V GB"3 GN JTV=\ JTZN' M"AILW$ JTIMENG
IW3'^ LK G QN3IRV % V(N
V(N IMR'NHI3J> GB"3 HRGN K VG %RI][
R^J ;NRH *UWN% % QNJ% IJQNR *UV GK R=I\QN HKVK V(N
V(N RN\33
IMT'NHI3J> GKQ. Q.GR. H=<H 7>%^] ZNJV HKVN JTIMENG %NE JTZ
V(N
V(N IMR'NHI3J>  %NE GW" 3  JT V = ?  I= ;  M" 
I-E-K JIW= V R T K ZG *UWG UKVN QI;QN-   E
H   IW= X
IHMN M" IH V=VWIUQN% M
 LN' 7>aV MK H-K JTHNR G *TIZV HR% WNE
WX%. V
$ IW=XIEV M
-K VRK S>=;K I-H J^R' JTZNVZN IW=X IGT9VN %NE
I(R M
 LNWUK VG V^] 
UK S'UN QR(NV VG VRK Q%]% Z% %NE
I%R]    M
 H  V R K I-= H  J^ R % JT Z NVZN GK *UVK QNR] *  M
W  U K
JIW=VR UKVN QI;QN-  E
H  IW=X IHMN M" IH L" SM>V W=Y
LEN3 ILGN LE  NE V=H WK ZNJV %N M
W 
 G JTNJV M
 LN'G
IJ=6
$ 6
1N LEN3 ILGN LE  NE V=H WR?N %N M
' HNR% ZNJV
M
 L.GN M"  IW=X IL]%N JT
L% RIM L.GN M" I- JTHNR J^R' JTZNVZN
JRZ QH3R J> R 3  G  U> ' . GN IUQN% V= V WIUQN% G> Q NRN M
 LN'

220

) (NR( IUQN% JT H N3 IW3

7> a V  QNJGK QN(N M


R  IUQN%. IW= X  V(N
V(N M
R  *UWN%. M
R  G W VNW.
IW=X L" STMZN IW3'^ IW=X I3W V(N
V(N 6RJ>R3 QR(NV STMZ IW=X V(N
QH3R J> R 3 QR(NV JT S T M Z  IW= X  7> % K MK RIM L.GK M"   ILW $  6
1 N
LEN3 S>RN %MK$ EUGN JT]V^ 7>GK 3ZVN QHNV  GN JVN E=U L.GN
M" IH 7>M H]Z XEN7^ MNRN M" L
 LKW% G E-K J^RN %MK$ M" V(N
V(N SM>V
W=YN LEN3 JTNJV M
' 7>aV JVN X=E L.GN M" IH L QHNE IURUN V.
WK Z= I QN %MK$ QNW U K V(N
V(N 6
1   LEN3 %^ ]  IVQNUH  W= Y   LEN3
7> a V  QN3IRV M
 LNW U N
I-K JT H NR V= V WGR3K ] V  V
$  J^ R % JT Z NVZN G  V= V B I UQN% G
G>QNRN J^R% STMZ GK ZIMZN V
$ JTKIXV M
 LN' G IJ=6
$ N;H J^R% R^J
%NE Q%%]   Z%  7>   J^ R ' JT Z NVZN JT Z  3 WR  7> a V  RW *NW %NE
QN3IRV M
 L.GN M" 
UKVN QI;QN-  E
H  IW=X IHMN M" IH M QRL>% V^] RW
*NW %NE 7> JTZ3WR GK 3R% IW=X LN 7> JTZNVZN GK IHTJN V
$ MK
JRZ 3.VK %^ ]  JT N JV M
W  $ UN V(N
V(N 3NWV (N% QR(NV %NV% JRZ
;NZ QR(NV HG  %N %31 M
'  WNE  VE
H  %^ ]  JT N JV M
W  U N
UKVN QI;QN-   E
H   IW= X  IHMN M"  IH Z" $  V" % ^ ]  I-M RM= 
QIV U
J %K-  UKVN GN  IUQN% HIM IG= V N M> '  ILW $  V R N Z% XNM
W"N HR IH7>$IH I-M UKVN G Q]IVZ QI;QN-  G Q]IVZ E
H
X=E RM M% I- E-K IHMN M" 

UKVN IUQN%GNVN STMZ GN I-31 J^L  GW J^R'STMZ M"#


UKVN QI;QN-  E
H  IW=X IHMN M" IH RW U>JV V
$ U>JV
IUQN% I-H WNR IFR > ' H  I-MK J^ R ' JT Z NVZN ILG  IW3  IW= X
QI;QN-  E
H  IW=X IHMN M"  ZRN J=HN J^L GW M" QR(NV Z"$
ST M Z 6R J> R 3  WK 7>  K GK J^ L N HRGN M. I-M V R   IM= V  IW= X
HM.UN IH7>$IH I-MK LN'HNRK UKVN IUQN%GNVN JT*^ UKVN QI;QN-
 E
H  IW=X WK IG=VK M" IL IW=X IHMN M" IH Z"$ 7> QNIG J>R3
JTZ3WR GK 3R% IW=X M. I-E-K I-=( IHMN M" IH I-MK U>JV V
$ WK
QIVU> J V IUQN% IFR > ' 
IW33/A M
R UKVN G Q%>WNG HRVNW. % UEV Q%>WNG HKVN M"
I-31M QI Z IGT9Z I-VK# GN QR( HKVN M" IH V^] ZRN IJT M"
LGIH QR( S'GN M"
QI;QN- GNE
H
TWU>MTNVZZ*^MTR'^ZJRZZWXMI-31MQIZIGT9:
-IVVVMWH3NIZVIMVZ@
Q%>WNG/A TWU>MTNVZZ ]J^R%U
J%K
$QIVU
JK%K- Z ZR JRZZ
JRZRM=>HV IMVZ IM=VHNRH WXM WX% V V"%^] *^M IFR WH3NIZ
HM^]UN VVM I- 3R'^] >' I-VK I-MJ^R%STMZ Z ZRN IGT9Z J=HN
I%3IXV I-31M J^LGW QI M"

IUQN% U] U N

221

UKVN QI;/  E


H  IW=X UKVN IUQN%GNVN JT*^ HNE *UWN%
6RJ>R3  HIM IRMN M" IH L ZRK 3R' IW=X RIM'N M" V. ZRK J^LN Q%]%
Z% %NE HR M
R GWVNW. STMZN IW3'^ I3W  V(N
V(N IJ=VR. QNIG GK J^LN
IVQNU G IFR Z"%]^ MK JTNJV M
W$ UN QR(NV STMZE
H S' ZM.WRU IW=X
XEN LNW$UN Z"$ V"%^] V JTIV=IUQN HRGN M. V^] ZRN IJT M"$
UKVN QI;QN-   E
H   IW= X  IHMN M"  IH L  - H Z  7> 
QIGB V KQ"  QR(NV ILGK V> E %N IW= X  M
R  %N M
W   7>   I-= H  RW
3HVKZN% RW STIMZ]Y. GN RX%MNR RW G ;NR'AJ
3' HR% WNE
JTZ3WR GK 3R% IW=X LN'N M" V. ZR VR GK N;%N L
 8Z %NZ G
LNJ GK HZN-K V(N
V(N M
R  ;NRIZH 3NVR Q%> H ^ E  = U  N;%NW. Z R 
IW=X 6=Y ILV
$ V^] ZR V
$ IR'Z>HV M
 L.-$UN  7> -HZ  QIGBVKQ"
QR(NV ILGN H
- K N%K %MK$ M"    GK 3R% IW= X  WT L  LN Z" $  V" % ^ ]
RW JNJ. HNE G  IR'.  V
$  Z> H V HR G W .UN V^ ]  IX] V N ZV HR
IW3/A UKVN G M
R Q%>WNG HTV.W. % E
H  GN Q%>WNG UEV
HKVN M" WTL GN QR( QN7>'N HKVN M" LGIH WTL GN QR( LN'N M>]GN
M"   IHT I JQN WNVIWH Q%> W NG J94

QI;QN- GNE
H
TW;RZN%JIRVLZNZ-HZ3R'ZIWRL
QIMZVWNRWJNJ*MZ
H3I3NIZZN3XM@
Q%>WNG/A ZNZ ZRK TW;RZN% ]J^R%J^LNW.%]^ JIRVL IVQNUH
V]^ HWE -HZ I-=H7>J^R'JTZNVZ.GK 3R'Z 3R'IW=X IWRL LN
QMZ Z"$ VWN V"%]^ RWJNJ*M ]J^R%JNJ.V
$ Z
H3I3NIZ 6>YWN
GW.UNV]^ ZN3>XM 3
HZVHR

STMZ GN N;H STMZ %^] V(N J^R'STMZ GN N;H


J^R'STMZ %^] MK JTNJV M>]GN M"#
UKVN QI;QN-   E
H     UKVN QI;QN-   E
H  
IW= X  I%R'NI-H IUQN% M"   UKVN QI;QN-   E
H   IW= X  IHMN M"
IH ZRK STMZ GK N;%N V. HWE I-=H 8Z Q\=R M" L
 7>XNR% HRH
LNJ HR% GN M"   L
 N;H Q] I VZ > Q . V= H  LNJ HRGN M"  7> M
JRZUVK %^] JTNJV M>]GN M" QNJ'K JRZUVK %^] UKVN IUQN%GNVN JT*^
%  QI;QN-   E
H   IW= X  QIV Q%> V ZNZ QR(NV QIV [1KQN
IHMN M" 
UKVN QI;QN-   E
H   IW= X  IHMN M"  IH J^ R ' JT Z NVZN GK
JTNJVK GN HWE IV]% Z]VR 8Z VV IV G LNJ GN MK I%RG3 M" IL
IW=X 8Z LNJ STMZ GN M" VV I-M ]HIVH M" L
 JRSTMZ GN LNJ M"
V(N
V(N IV I-M WK ] H  I VH M"  L
 J^ R 'ST M Z GN LNJ M"  7>   J^ R '
JRZNVZN G V=VWIUQN% %^] V=VWGR3K ]V MK LN'GN M" 7>V
$ JTNJV
HR Z" $  UKVN IUQN%GNVN 6RJ> R 3  %MK$ LN'GN
UKVN QI;QN-  E
H  IW=X IHMN M" IH I-M IW;N% M" IH Q]V

222

) (NR( IUQN% JT H N3 IW3

Z$ IW=X N;H IL WK JT*^ GN %NZLNJ HRGN M


I-QN RKR IVQNUH
L.GN M" 7>K %^] JTNJV M>]GN M"
UKVN QI;QN-  E
H  V
$  IW=X IHMN M" IH L
 Q]V Z$ IW=X
ZRN IZR% HRGN M
I-QN RKR IVQNUH L.GN M" 7>M ZR STMZ  G
*NW IW=X *NIWV RIM]GN M" IFR HG Z%>=\ L%Z M>]GN M" V. 7>M N;H
QNJ'K N;%N STMZ V
$ MK QNR]* HRGN M" 7>GN >*NQ W"N MK M

L.GN M" I- GN JTZN' UKVN QI;QN- A IW=X WK M" IH L
 N;H
J^RW L%Z IW=X L"K WK N;%N HRH QNI-QN M" QUE L%Z IW=X WK
> * NQW= 3  W"  K MK N;%N HRGN M" 
UKVN QI;QN-  E
H  IW=X IHMN M" IH * Z$ IW=X ZRN IZR%
HR V(N >=; WK HR I%R]GM Z"%^] MK JTNJV M
W$UN
UKVN QI;QN-  E
H  V
$  VH J31 HKVN M" IH L
 N;H
Q%] %  Z% %NE JT Z  3 WR G  %NZ GN LNJ HRGN M"  7> M  GN 7>  K %^ ]
IZR% HR% WNEN JRZIGWZ J> R 3 NIV  7>   JRZ IGW J> R 3
QNR(NV JTZ3WR J^R'STMZ  %^] JTNJV M>]GN M" QI;QN-  E
H 
L
 N;H Q%NIG RW G  I%] V N 3^ \ Z V
$  QIV 3^ \ Z GN *G
;NR%AJ
3 ' HR% WNEN ^ R L GK VR4 .  W" $  JT H NI3V QR(NV V L
Z -K
RKR >HV QIUQN% R^J Q]I;HNR V
$ JR HIWZ  HIWRGW
IXGN%] G [' JT Z  3 WR GN IZR% HRGN M"   QI;QN-   E
H  
7> M  *UVK > H V IV] %  Z] V R G  LNJ GK N;%N GK 3HVK %NZ
LNJGK HZN-K  %NE Q] V  Z $  IW= X  RKR IVQNUH  L.G  Z $  IVT H > 1 K
7> a V  JM> ] X H  QI*QN3W= 3  NR %NZ GN IZR% HRGN M
I -QN 7> 
IGWR^ J  QR(NV V ,
Z -K QR(NV NHNR JRZJ> R 3  JT Z  3 WR %^ ]  MK
JT N JV M> ] G N M"   QI;QN-   E
H  

STMZ 6RJ>R3  GK N;%N Q%7>VZ [1KQN  M"#


UKVN QI;QN-   E
H   QI;QN-   E
H   QI;QN-  
E
H   IW= X  IHMN M"  IH Z" $  UKVN IUQN% GNVN  %N3WN% M.
L%ZAIZT V ^  Z R K V(N
V(N V R K GN M> ] G K RM U K H W E HKVN M
I -QN HRZ
MK JTNJV M
WUN Z
H3 %MK$ M>]GN ZRK N;% HR% WNE *E MK 7>GNR
N;H M% JT ] V ^  7> M  WK Z R K QIV [1KQN Q%> V ZNZ  N;%N IW= X  MK
IWQV M% I-E-K UKVN QI;QN-   E
H     IW= X
IHMN M" IH 7> JTZ3WR GK 3R% IW=X LN V(N
V(N ZRN J^L GW WK 7>MK
M"
JTNR(%N/A 7>JR
HV IV]% Z]VR GK N;%N Z>0 GN. G WK GN %^]
WK RNZJNE GN  G H
E 7>JE=S; M" L
 W"$ J^R% JTZNVZN HIWRGW
% QNJ'K QNVZNW. 7>aV RIMZ IGQN  HRH JTGN% HKVK M" IH7>$IH
M> '  IWXEK Z= ;  WNEK  JK94 K  X= E  RMK M"   IH7> $ IH HE> = U  G  QNR] *
IW=X QNJ' J^RWL QI=I\QV K 7> Z$ JTZ3WR G V=VWIUQN% %^]
%HEK ] V . U> R ^ Q . ZM] V N V(N
V(N QXNRKQ. %  7> J = R  %MK$ QN7> '  IG= V N

IUQN% U] U N

223

V(N
V(N HE= > U  G  Q] V  IW= X  RW IWQHVK *UVKMK' V(N
V(N ZM.IWHNRK M

LN'U M>' I-M WRVZN% GN Z. WK$ GK V


$ I=I\QH ZNL JTNR]*
M
I-QN M" I-M IWXEK Z=; WNEK  JK94K QR(NV Z%>=\ W]3 X=E IRMN M"
WNVIWH IUQN% QNJ'  GU] T ( N IW= X  IWGZN% M"   IL %^ ]  %HEK
]V U>R^ ZM]V %MK$ Z0 H IL HNR% RW *UV ZNL 3NVR
IWR>=; IUQN% G QN;NR 7>aV G]V H(NW. E
H WG  7>aV QN;NIRV M
H
3NVR IW;K IVQNUH  Z%ZN%K QNXR% J^ L N  HRH  Q%Z
E  ZN%W
LKW% IWQR( HR IRMN M" 
3NVR IW;K Q%>  NR N;%N/A
+ JIME XR' IW=X STMZ UNI-VRK Z]VR IG=VN L.GN M" L
 HZE.
%^] \
E4' GN M" 7>JG3 JTNJV HR% WNEK *UV QNVZN I-M 
XUK IH
U> R ^  LK IHMN V. RM  K IH IV] %   U> ' . RLU> ' AST M ZN VU> ' AIW3'^ 
VZU>'AI3W  GK J^LN %MK$ HR%K M" Z]VR LNJ 7>%4. G MK IG=V M%
7>%4. E-K I%WG% M" IH I-M J^LN %MK$ M" QK$ HNE G E
H IW=X RIM
RM  M. I-= (   N%] ^  L
 > I W;N XNIMGK M
W  U K 7> M  ST M ZNAIW3'^ A I3W
QNIG MK JT G N% HR'U 
L"    QK$ ISLEK GN H> % " H 3% EN*  E"  R= I \QN M"   7>  GN IS= E
\RXN  *R%N M" QK$ ISLEK WNE Z]VRK GK LN IW*NU GK J^LN %MK$
HR RM QK$ 7>GN IS=E *R.U V. MK ISLEK GN EN* IZEGN RMUN
I- JT H NR 1" E KF
%  G^ R ] X NR  GN IS= E  W JN'K GN IS= E  QNIG QGN
HRG RM.U V. N%]^ >IW;N IZEGK RMUK QNJ 3NVR IWR>=; N;%N
HRH *UVKMK' M
 U- M
 QR(NV QNJ J>]%MK' M
 U- M
 IL HNR'
V
$  QNJ%] ^  ;] %  EN* QNIG %MK$ M
 IRMN I-M GN RNZJNE GN
QNJGK UR] 1 R I,] Z  G NR  S'H  I- HNE E
H  GK I-= H  ST I MZ] Y  GK
3HVKQ. STMZ.AIW3'^AI3WAU'3AZNVN QNIG  V
$ QNJ%]^ RW >IW;NW.
J>%R JTNR]* HRWN-UN V(N
V(N QNJ% I- Z]VR G LNJ %NE I-%4. GN IS=E
*RG  RIM'N M"   L
 Z] V R JT ( Z IV > H IRV QIWUV HSKR  M"  I-M
QNJGK J^LN M" I-M J^R' JTZNVZN M" V(N
V(N VZ EN* FE  JTNJV M
W
UN VZ GN QR( QIW%N3K QR(NV N%^ ]  QIW%N3K JG JT N JV
HR%N M" I- Z]VR G XNR ZMK% V
$ SNQG QNJ%]^ IV%NZ =XN%NZ
M
R IZEUN L
 G
 Z]VR GN M
WUN 7>GN I-=H Z]VR HNE G STIMZ]Y
GN IR= '  7> V NR' GN M"   7>  GK HZN-K HRH  QK$ ST M Z 6R J> R 3
QR(NV HNE GN IR' 7>VNR%N M" IFR I-M HNE N%]^ RW JNJ. V
V

$ Z>HV
HR GWUN
UKVN Q/%] +  G  E
H  %] +  A IW= X  WR'% M" / A
QI;QN- GNE
H/
VZ-W3R'ZUX6RW*NW%*NRV
VVJT3NGNVJRNZ3.I%VZ(N%ZJTNJI3N3WVZ@
Q%>WNG/A *NRV  M *NRVC V^] RW*NW%  * JTHNR V
$ VZ  7>
QIUQN%Q]I;HNRIW=X6>=JM
-JTZ3WRGK -W MK 3R'Z 3R%IW=X U=6
LN VVJT3NGNV 7>JTZNVZ.GKIHRJN%NEMKV^] JRNZ JRZ 3.IV]Z

224

) (NR( IUQN% JT H N3 IW3

3.VK %^] V(N 3N3WVZ  GN RIM' WNEN V (N%Z  (N%A;NZAE
H %^]
JTNJ  JTNJV M
WUN
Q%> W NG/ M  *NRVC V> ^ ]  * JT H NR V
$  7>   QIUQN% Q] I ;HNR IW= X
6>=J M
- JTZ3WR GK 3R' IW=X LN 7> JTZNVZN GK IHTJN %NE MK V]^
JRZ 3.VK V(N
V(N GN RIM' WNEN V (N%A;NZAE
H %]^ JTNJV M
WUN
QI;QN- GNE
H
RW;RZN%JIRVLZNZ-HZ3R'ZWRL
QMZVWNRWJNJ*MZ
H3I3NIZZN3XM@
Q%>WNG/A ZNZ ZRK RW;RZN% ]J^R%J^LN%]^ JIRVL IVQNUH
V]^ HWE -HZ I-=H7>J^R%JTZNVZ.GK 3R'Z 3R'IW=X IWRL LN
QMZ Z"$ VWN V"%]^ RWJNJ*M ]J^R%JNJ.V
$ Z
H3INIZ 6>YWNG
W.UNV]^ ZN3>XM 3
HZVHR
Q%>WNG/ ZRK ]JR
^ % J^LN %]^ IVQNUH V]^ HWE I-=H 7> J^R' JTZNVZN
GK 3R' IW=X LN Z"$ V"%]^ ]J^R' JNJ. V
$ 6>=1WN GW.UN V]^ 3
H ZV HR
HR
7>JR
HV E
H. GN *NW QR( M" IH HNE STMZ QR(NV 6R J>R3
HIM IRMN M" IH QRL>% V^] ZRK 3R' IW=X RIM'N XNM>]GN M" V. L%Z
V(N
V(N IZTV^ S'K RMUK LHR JRZ3.VK V(N
V(N VE
H LN'N XNM>]GN M" V.
7>   J^ R ' JT Z NVZN GK 3R' IW= X  XEN LN 7>  G  E-K Z R K RW
;NRIZH J^LNW. QR(NV IV%NZ G JT(Z Z]VR G LNJ GK HZN-K ZR
IW=X 6=YH IFR RW*NW %NE 7> I-=H RW3HVKZN% QR(NV ILG
SRNSR G^RN %N M
 7> QIGBVKQ" JTZ3WR  GK 3R' IW=X XEN LN IFR
Z" $  V" % ] ^  RW JNJ. IR'.  V
$  Z> H V HR G^ ] U N V] ^  IX] V N %N HR V(N
IV%NZ G Z]VR GK HZN-K QK$ JRSTMZ QR(NV QH3R J>R3 %]^ 6=Y
GW.U IH7>$IH N%^] QH3R J>R3 G E
H V
$ M
H VE
H LN'N M" 7>GN
IHRNI-QN G ' N M"   IFR VKRN Z] V R IV3SG QR(NV NR%NZ IZE
UN L
 VE
H  IW= X  (N-KVW JT N JV HRN- U N
L H R H
- K IWQHVK IWG 3  IUQN M
W    7> a (  7>   7> a V  RHNR GN
IR=' M
W IFR WNJ WG3 QN7>'N XNMUN V. 7>%]^ JIME. 7> G3
G  IR= '  V
$  Z> H VK E" ' K M
W  U K I_R No Due Certificate  IR= '  Z> H V
JT Z N'AJ= V R JT N JV HR%N M
W  U N VG 7>  GN WNJ QN7> '  GN JNJ
R 1
S' U N %MK$ V. 7>  %] ^  WNJ %MK$ QN7> '  IG= V N LNW U N
I- JTHNR QNJ I- HNE G E
H IW=X 3NVR IWR>=; N;%N HRH
*UVK MK' IR='K M
 U- M
 JIME. QNJ%]^ 3NM^HNR S'NI-QN LNWUN
7>G E-K HIWRGW HSKR NIMS L. HIWR NIMS  % Z>0 GN ]V
RNZJNE GN  %]^ QNJ'N JTVKI%;K Representative) S'NH *ILQN M"
7> JTZ3WR GK VRF V
$ I-M GN QNJGN Guaranter) IL]ZWNR S'UN
V(N STMZNAIW3'^AI3W QNIG 3HVKQ. V
$ QNJG J>%R H>%"H3% ]JRH
GN EN*  %]^ JTNR]* HRN-UN L
 QNJ' I-%4. G Z]VR GK HZN-K HRH
IH3V. IW=X IS=E *R%N M" LG
$ V=H QNJ I-=(
$ Z>HV %MK$ M]>G VG V=H
QNJ%] ^  RW * I VH > I W;NW. L
R A3
R  %NE IZEGKQ. RIM'UKQ. V(N
QNJ J] > % GN% QNIG HRH  ILQNGN *UVK ;%K S' H
U    G^  R  3SG.

IUQN% U] U N

225

IW= X  ILW $  NY  RKR IW= X  HZE S'  M% LG


$  QK$ RKR IVQNUH
JTZNVZN H
E LNW.U V. N%]^ I-%4. HZE. IW=X
$ M
 H LN'N M" L" +Z^E
HZE IW=X U'3 LK + >WNG HZE IW=X NIWVRKASTMZN + %N*K HZE
IW=X E=H3ZK V(N IW3'^ LK + IMRG HZE IW=X JNRWVK QV I3WLK
+ H]P HZE IW=X G>RUN Q31]UK  M" I-%4. HZE. IW=X
$ QK$ VG MK
LN H.U LG
$ QK$ I-%4. GN IR=' QGN HR IGQ.U JT(Z 7>JG3 %NE
QNJG  NR  HZE I\= E  LN'U  QR(NV QNJ IR= ' Z> H V M
 LNW
U    LG
QNJ Q]V Z$ IW=X RKR 6=Y
U V. QNJGN RVN NF IZEUN QR(NV
QNJG  RW IR= ' Z> H V JT Z N'AJ= V R IVQNR IZE U N
JT ] V ^  QK$ J^ L N QJ'  Z^ E  ZNEH HIWRG W  HSKR NIMS  GK
HR%K M" ILW$ JVKWRVN JV%K J^LN V. QNJ' JVK GK HRGK M" JT]V^
(
IX=V QNGR * GN HRGK M" ILW$ GWR %^] J>=VRW=V V(N
V(N LP %^] W=Y
*N-K GK VR4 .  V(N =   W M> R   %^ ]  ZNVNAIJVN GK VR4 .  JT ] V ^  L
 *NW
QNJ' JVK IW=X M>]GN M" 7>M M
R IW=X %MK$ M
 HGN PKH I- VR4.
HSKR JTZ3WR G *UV %^] QNJ'K *UVK FE HR%K M" I-E-K IH
Q'LN' G SIMHNW IW=X %MK$ QN7>'N J^R' IW3WN3 G %NE I- GN
G> Q NRN G=    *UVK ZNRU 7> a V  E= U   RIM'N I-M *UVK RW 3NVR.
G  QN;NR 7> a V  M" 
+ G^R XR' IW=X IV%NZ JTGN% HKVN L.GN M" L
 G
 Z]VR GN
M" I-H 8Z Q8Z  G^LN VV L
 ]HIVH M" HWE N;H %^] MK G=IQN
L.GN M" 
+ VKR XR' IW=X NR%NZ IG=VN L.GN M" L
 IH IV]% Z]VR GN M"
8ZAVVAIV VVAIV ] H  I VH M% L
 N;H %^ ]  MK G=    LN'U 
I- JT H NR NR%NZ L
 IV] %  Z] V T  GN S' LN- U N  G  IZR% G
QI*QN %NE N;H JRZ IG*J> R 3 QR(NV JT Z  3 WR HIWRG W  %] ^
JTNJV M
WUN V(N
V(N VE
H IW=X JRZ3.VK QR(NV J^R'Z
H3 %]^ JTNJV M

LNW U N
IW33/ WRVZN% IW=X I-M WNVIWH N;%. Z>0GN G QIVIRHV
IHK G H
E %MK$ M" L H
-K Z>0GN V
$ X>RNH W"$ U>R^ S'H %HEK
I33 S'N IRMN M
W   V. 7>   Z%> = \  LKW% G  G> 3 Z' V
$  NW;N% RM

7> M  Q' QI;HNRK M
'  G  HNR' QNJ'N LKW% WK %31 HR IRMN M"
V(N
V(N %NGN% 3R;NE^ Q . %] ^  WK %RH GN *NUK S'N IRMN M"   7>  %^ ]  HNE
GN * I LQN G^ V  LN'
$ 

 3]HN ZN;N%#

+JT3%/A 7>JR
HV UKVN NR V
$ I=; M]>GN M" IH STMZN LK IW3'^
LK V(N
V(N I3WLK GK J^LN IWQR( M" JT]V^ Z"$ V.  NE V
$ 3TK I3WLK
GK J^LN HR IRMN M. V(N
V(N *UWN% 3TK IHT3% LK ZR SM>V IJQNR M%
Z"$ I-%4. JT*^Q. %]^ %MK$ 6=Y HGN ZRN I-%4. %NE IW33 EUN8 M
 X>=HN
M"   3T K  UKVN LK GN I%= V  JNP HRGN M. MR  RNZ MR  IHT 3 % RN;
3NZ KVNRNZ 8Z %ZM I3WN 8Z %Z
 *UWV  WN^ G  W N-  QNIG

226

) (NR( IUQN% JT H N3 IW3

%NZ LNJ HRGN M. 


Z WNR GN WRV WK R= \ GN M. HNW9 WK
IEQN7>$GN M. V(N
V(N ;NZ. 7>aV WK GN% HR% L.GN M. Z]IGR IW=X Z^RVK
J^ L N HR% WK L.GN M. WRU JT N JVK GK I-= 6 N HRGN M. V(N
JT]JRNUV J^LN G HNR' I-=H ZM]V V
$ 7>JG3 WK E" R=I\QN M"
7> a VR/A
UKVN NR
VR/A IHT J N QNJ J> % R 7> J R
H V
UKVN
NR
 %] ^  J9
4   LG V= H
VVW IUQN% V
$ J^R' JTKXV QNJ %MK$ M
W
$U VG V=H I-M 3]HN R^JK
H] Y . \= 1 HGN MK RM U N ILW $  7> J = R  7> G MNR' M"  IH 7> E = 1 N E= 1 IHQN
M
I-QN ]NR R^JK IST\ M" ILGK Z^E L94  V. J^R' JTZNVZN JTZ3WR
M" IV]%
$ U>' R^JK RLU>'ASTMZN VU>'AIW3'^ VZU>'AI3W  3N\NW.
M% QNJ%  H
- K Q] S  GN J G N ENI-QN M"   L  J G   GK L94  Z^ E  GK
I] X N-K J^ L N  HR
U   ILV
$  IST \  S' U N IFR 7>  GK 3N\NW. %] ^  FE
E=U'U 3N?N V
94' %^] (94 MK IHMN L.GN M" I-M G\

I=
I=;N SKILQN
M
I -QN *UVK R^ J K J G N QR(NV 3NVRIW;K Q%>  NR N;%N

N;%N

I- JTHNR J^LN V. J^R' JTZNVZN QR(NV Z^E GK HR%K M" IFR
HRZFE IV] %
$  U> '  ST M ZN IW3'^   I3W  R^ J K 3N\NW. %] ^  E= U 'U 
I-E-K H> 0  WK %MK 6= Y 'N M"   H W E QNJ'N *UVK R^ J K J G N I= ; N
SKL'N M"  QR(NV 3NVR IW;K Q%>  NR N;%N QNR] *  HR%K M" 
WRVZN% IW= X  RW JIW= V R *UV ZNL 3NVR IW;K IVQNUH
Z%ZN%K J^LN HR IRMN M" QR(NV *UVK R^JK JGN 7>E1N EUN R=I?QN M"
L IH % Q"N JGN SK, R=I\QN M" V. 7>%]^ Z^R\ MK IHMN L.GN M"
IHTJN G\
 7>E1N SKI,QN M
I-QN *UVK R^JK JG GN IX=VR 
I-E-K UKVN QI;QN-  E
H  V
$  IW=X IV]%
$ U>'. RLU>'
ST M ZN VU> '  IW3'^  LK VZU> '  I3WLK  GK J^ L N V= H  MK KZV S> = ; K
R=\' WNE L
 I-%4. V
$ I-ENWN IHK %]^ %MK$ J^LG M% 7>%4. %]^ RN\33
>*N8 %]^ ;NR' HKV M
- Z%>=\. IW=X
$ %KX G>3HRZ HR% WNE Z^R\
IHMN M" V(N
V(N IHMN M" IH I-M Z"%]^ WK %MK$ J^LG IFR QNJ'K N;%N
%]^ WK UKVN IUQN%GNVN JT*^ STMZ QR(NV 6R J>R3  % QIV [1KQN
Q%> V ZNZ  QR(NV IWQR( IHMN M"   I-E-K UKVN QI;QN-  
E
H    V(N QI;QN-  E
H A IW=X IHMN M" IH 7>
J^R' JTZNVZN 7>E=1 E=1H M
- IST\ GK Z^E GK J^LN HR  GK 3R' IW=X
LN 7>GK J^LN V=VWGR3K ]V G G= ZNRU %NE HR UKVN QI;QN-
 E
H   IW= X  V= V WGR3K ] V  W= E  ] H  V  HKVN M"  7>  K J^ R '
JT Z NVZN GK 3NVR IW;K Q%>  NR N;%N HR% %NE MK N;H JRZ
3.VK V(N
V(N VE
H %]^ JTNJV M>]GN M" QR(NV J^R' Z
H3 %]^ JTNJV HRGN
M"   UKVN IUQN%GNVN JT * ^  6R J> R 3AHNE  HIM IRMN M"  IH Z" $  WK
7>GK 3R' M. QR(NV ZRN WK I-31 GW 7>MK J^R' JTZNVZN M" Z"$
WK 7>  GK J^ L N HRGN M. M
R %. %] ^  WK 7>  GK J^ L N HR%K XNMKGK M" 
QNJ UKVN LK GN I%= V  JNP WK HRG  M
 V(N
V(N N;%N UKVN LK IW= X
WRI'V IW;K IWR= > ;  HRG  M
  IL%4 .  Z] V R. GN MR  RNZ MR  IHT 3 %
RN; 3 NZ KVNRNZ 8Z %Z
 I3WN 8Z %Z
 *UWV  WN> G  W N QNIG
Z] V R. GN  QNJ LNJ HRG  M
 V(N
V(N M
R  N;%N WRV HR%N HNW9

IUQN% U] U N

227

IEQN7> ' N VKR(. V(N


V(N ;NZ. 7> a V  GN% V(N
V(N J^ L N E-K LN'N U] U N
I-3%N% V(N
V(N VKR(N 7> a V  E= U ' WNEK JT * K IW= X  I-3%N% JIW= V R
UKVNLK IW=X WRI'V %N M
' G HNR% 3NVR IW;K IVQNUH Z%Z]I%QN
QNXR' J^ L N  M
I -QN IL%] ^  JIW= V R UKVNLK G  QI;/ E
H
A IW= X  IWQR( IHMN M" 

U=GK V(N ZM]V JT]JRN GK LN'HNRK


ZM]V V(N
V(N U= G K GK LN'HNRK
LN'HNRK /AIHK I-H.V (N% 7>aV L. 3IMR
W IHK IJ] Y  IW= X  H
- K ZMN% QNVZN ] V  L. N;H IRMN HRGN K
7>G RKR IVQNU' G IJ=6
$ 7>GK NG S'N-K R=\' E-K 7>G RKR
G QIV]Z ]HNR (=E 7>aV I-=H J=(R L. I-=1. GK NGUNR S'N IG=VK
L.GK M" IFR 7> JIW=VRQNVZN G Q%>N-K L. W]3L 7>GK J=(R GK
Z^RVK R=\ E"$G M% H>0 Z$ SNQG 3R;NE^ L.G M% H>0 ;]% GN%
HR% E=U L.G M% 7>%]^ Z]IGR GN R^J G IG]G M% V(N
V(N 7> ]V V
IR3K G  W] 3 L. %^ ]  ;] %  7> J RL% GN ENEX M
 L.GN M"   7> M  SIMHN7> ' N
QNR]* HRG M% IH L
 I-=( GR3% HR% QN7>$GN M" 7>%]^ J^R' Z
H3
JTNJV M]>GN M" RW EN* IZEG M% L
 I-K ZM.J>R3 G LKW% HNE
IW=X I33. %]^ IZEG K I-M Z^RVK N\3NV 7>K ]V LK %^] MK LN'

L
 I-= (   %MK$ QN- U N 7>  GN Z
H 3 ] * W %MK$ QNIGAQNIG
7> % 4 .  %NGN%. %] ^  H
- K J> = 6   IH ILW $  H
- K W" G  K 7> M  %N9K G \ H
GWN-K IG]GN K R
UK PKH M
 L.GN K 7> W"G GK IZTV^ V
$ IJ=6
$ 7>GK
Z^RVK S'NH (NIJV HRH H
-K ENEXK HM I-M Z^RVK 7> W"G WNEN
H]Z HRGK M" L
 I-G GR3% HR% QNWUN 7>M J^R' WN( M
 LNW
UN L. W"$ %HEK W"G S'H S"P LNW IH Z"$ WK GWN-K IG]GN M. JT]V^
T W  7> J XNR Q 3 ;K UT ] (  G  IWJRKV G  IRMN M"   7> M  ;
\ N G  IRMN M"
IH7$> I H H W E ;] %  7> J RL% 7>  GN 7> G  3  M"   IH  WK ] V  L. JT * ^  GK
Z^ R VK QNGR'K- $  NGUR V. M"  JT ] V ^  J^ L %K-  %MK$ M" 
Q" MK IHK ]V L. JT*^ GK Z^RVK S'NH 7>GK QN9 IW=X H
-K
J^ L NRK L. ZM] V  HM  IH Z" $  WK %NZ IG] G N M. 7> M  ZMN%> * NW RW
N;%N 7>K JIW=VR 3NVR G IWJRKV G IRMN M" L
 7> ZMN% ]V %
QNJ' Q%>*W GN IE=I\QN M" V. 7>M %HEK ]V V ZM]V W"$ WK G
3K
M"  V(N
V(N Q%> Q N-KQ. GN WK LKW% IWQR( HR% GN *NR QNJ'  3K3
7>aV E" IRMN M" ]V V. I-=H Z$ IW=X I-=H MK QN7>$GN M" 7>G ZNRU
IW= X  HR
9 . %HEK ] V  ZM] V  V(N
V(N QXNRKQN SN;H S'G  M%
IHK ] V  LK G  RKR IVQNU' G  SNQG ] V  L. ZM] V  JT ] J RN
QNR]* M>]GK M" J^RW ]V G (N% GK R=I\QN E-K I-=H JTS];H X>I'QN
L.GN M"IL%]^ ZM]V IHMN L.GN M" 7>M IRF 7> JIW=VR NGUNR GK
G\*NE HR% G E-K I%>HV HKVN L.GN M" IFR ENEX W=3 7>M W"$
MK U>R^ S' S"PGN M" V(N
V(N *UVK XNM>' WNEK IJQNRK QNVZ. 7> 7>aV
QN;NIRV M
H QNJ'N LKW% IWQR( HR L.GKQ. M% ZM]V JT]JRN GN

228

) (NR( IUQN% JT H N3 IW3

I%Z S'N R= I \QN M"  IH J^ R W ZM] V  GN JT ( Z J> = V R ZM] V  J= G  GN


QI;HNRK M
WUN XNM 7>M 3RNSK M
W XNM QIUQN%K M
W I-M *UVK
ZNRU M" I- IW=X HWE J^R' ]V MK LKW GN 7>GNR HR HGN M"
GN % G
AIV]% ZM]V JT]JRN GK J>VH J94K 7> IW=X GI\QN IH+ I-=H
G
 NE GN S=XN U=GK 7>aV ISPN IG=VN IFR 7>M W=YN M
 H %NZ GN%
HR% E=U IUQN G^RK J>VH IW=X J=I94QN IH I-=H J]L NE G S=X
G IJVN LK L
 ZM]V LK K QXN%H IZTV^ %]^ JTNJV M
 IUQN SNQG IW=X
]UV V(N
V(N 7>GK ZNVNLK % 7> J]L NEN S=X %]^ ZM]V J=G G I%>HV
HR IG= V N H> 0  NE. SNQG 7> M  U> R ^  LK S' IUQN + I-= H  ZM] V
JT]JRN G I-IVMN %]^ JI94QN IH ZM]V G H
-K ]VN% %MK$ M
-K 7>GK
IZTV^ M
 U-K *N-K GK IZTV^ JIME. M
 X>=HK K H
-K ]VN% %MK K
U= G K GK R= \ WNEK G  E-K I-= H   W H %] ^  7>   H> = E  IW= X  ] V N% M
'  V= H
Q(N-K ZM]V I%>HV HR IG=VN H>0 Z$ 7>JR]V ZM]V H>E IW=X IH
G E9HN M
I-QN Q(N-K ZM]V U=GK E" H *=L IUQN IHK M
R 3IMR
IW= X  \> G  MK U= G K (NJ%N HRH  ZM] V  S' S" P N 7> a (  %WK$ G> H N% \
E 4
E-K V(N
V(N J^RW (N% 7>aV I-=H <N-K NE GN S=XN ZM]V S'N IG=VN
+ I-= H  ZM] V  JT ] J RN GN I-VMN G I \QN IH W= Y N S 1 N [R
IVQNUH XEN IUQN 7>V
$ 6
1 %]^ ZM]V J=G 7>aV I%>HV HR IG=VN
H>0 Z$ IJ=6
$ 7>a( Z]IGR S' IUQN V(N
V(N QI;=H X94NWN *$1 J^LN GN
;]%  QN7>' E=UN 7> W=Y WNE GK ]VN% % IHMN IH 7> Z]IGR 7>aV
NYN QI;HNR M" I- HNR' 0U9N QNR]* M
I-QN U=GK 7>aV IWRNLZN%
ZM]V GK M=IVQN HR IG=VK U-K IFR 7>GN W=YN E9HN ZM]V QR(NV
U= G K GN QI;HNRK I%> H V HR IG= V N 7>  GK WK M= I VQN HR IG= V K
U-K IFR 7>  GN G^  RN *N-K U= G K 7> a V  ISPNI-QN IUQN G^  R  L

QNJ' %]^ QI;HNRK G=G % 7>%4. % %W. (N% S'NH %WK$ G>HN% \
E4
E-K I-=H G^R 7>aV Z>HGZ HRH >=\Z-K LKW% %]^ ENEX IW=X %RH
S'N IEQN I-M ;NZ IH= (   IRMN I-M V. H^ R H3 V R WNEN ZM.*NRV
G >=; GN Z"GN% M
 IUQN H>0 ZM]V. % ]V S'N7>' GK -L]K E" R=\K
M" ENE H=J9 ;NR' HRWN7>$G M% J^RW %NZ %]^ SGEH M
R %NZ R=\
IG] G   M% IFR 7> M  S%NW1K ZM] V  GN S%NW1K X E N %HEK ] V  S'NH
*
EK QNVZN G LKW% %NE I\EWN9 HRGN M" V(N
V(N Q%Z
E Z%>=\K LKW%
%]^ W"$ WK IWQR( HR IRMN M" V(N
V(N *
EKQ. QNVZ.W. G LKW% %]^ WK
%N3 HR IRMN M"  V(N
V(N ZM.JNJ GN *NUK S' IRMN M" 
IL Z$ RNLN JRKHI3V LK %]^ =J % Y='N K 7> Z$ J^R'
U> R ^  GK ,R^ R V J-K IH7> $ IH J^ R ' ] V  IS%. LKW GN HIEQN' Q] * W
M" 7> Z$ IJT(WK G RW IR3KQ. % RNLN JRKHI3V %]^ IGH3N G'
V(N
V(N = V  IG% 3T K ZG*NUWV > ; NNUR GK H(N > % N7> '  V
$  Z%4 N  HR
IG=VN IH7>$IH =VW$ IG% J

E \=>E4'K K I-K HNR' H


-K NMZ' %MK$
QNI-QN W" $  3T K ZG*NUWV > ; NNUR G  E \ H ZMNIR3K W G IWQN
LK % WK QZR=(VN IWQHV HKVK IH7>$IH IR3KL% JT*^ V
$ YR% WNE
K I-E-K WK RNLN JRKHI3V G  LKW% %NE I\EWN9 HR%N 7> I X= V

IUQN% U] U N

229

%MK$ ZI0QN
RNLN JRKHI3V LK G  HIEQN' G  E-K ZM.IR3K = > \ G W  LK %] ^
WRU V
$ S>ENI-QN IUQN IL% RNLN %]^ GKH3N IG=VK V(N
V(N =V IG%
V=H H(N >'NH RNLN JRKHI3V LK GN IL]%N 7>GNR IR3K >=\GW LK HR
HG % HKVN WRVZN% G U>R^ ]V ZM]V V(N
V(N QXNRKQN W"$ MK
JT*^ G ]IW;N% V
$ QJTKIX=V M% I-E-K I*Q]HR G
3 G JNVR S'H
G
3K M
 RM M%
Q
R
$J](SVNWMK$W] %NLN% RNM
Q%QI;HNRK H(NAJNP HR W IGH3N GW$ SM>V HRV U>%NM
WRVZN% IW= X  H(N V UT ] ( . GN JNP HR% WNIEQ. V(N
V(N %NZ GN%
HR% WNIEQ. GK SN94  LMK QN-K M
- K M"   IH7> $ IH RWJIW= V R ;RZ.
GK JIW= V R QNVZ.W. V= V WIUQN% V
$  QJT K IXV M% IL HNR% %HEK
U>R^Q. V ]V. V(N
V(N ZM]V. GN GNQ E=UN M
I-QN M" IL Z$ JIW=VR
*UV ZNL QI;QVZH V= V WIUQN% V
$  JRKIXV M
 LNW U N 7>   Z $
I-%4. %HEK ]V. U>R^Q. V QXNRKQ. %]^ E=>H' GN (N% %MK$ IZEUN
JEN% HRH  IJ= 6 N 6> 9 WN%N JW U N

JIW=VR VKR( V(N ;NZ GK LN'HNRK


IHK N;H IR3K LK % IHK (N% L. LEN3 7>aV S"PH N;%N
HKVK L. QNJ'K QI;QNVIZH 3HVK GN JT G R3% HKVN 7> M  QNJ'K
*UVK HZN-K HRH  %NE E"  IUQN V(N QNJ'  I-31 E
H  %] ^  JT N JV
M
I -QN 7>   N;%N (= E  GN SNQG IW= X  VKR( L. ;NZ %NZ IJQN
M>' H
-K 7> (N% %]^ G\' LNW IH I-=( H
-K N;H IRMN HRGN K
7>% SM>IVQ. GN HIEQN' HKVN M>' %N V. 7>a( ]V LK M" L
 7>JG
3 G W    7> M  V. QNJ'K HZN-K HRH  XEN IUQN
IWXNR HR
/A IHTJN VKR( V ;NZ %]^ MZNZGVN LN'
$ I-=H Y<
_>1 GN E
M GN U
E JNVR E=U*U  I-]X JIR;K 7>\E L"N M>]GN M" V(N
Y< _>=1 E]SN V(N  I-]X JIR;K GN U
E E
M GN Y]YNAN Z^E ILMN M]>GN
M"  L
 Z= U RK V  G> W N-KQ. QNIG H> = 1 ' G  H] Z  QN7> $ GN M"   7>  %^ ]
MZNZAGVN HIM] G   M%  I-= H  IWQHVK QNJ'  U> Q .<K GN MZNZGVN
Z]UH IEQNI-QN 7>% M=W% Z=URK H>=1K V(N
V(N Z.0 ;
H WNJ IG=VN
IL HZR IW=X 7>M MZNZ GVN R=I\QN K 7> HZR IW=X >U]; QN7>'
E=UK [R G Z"$SR. % GI\QN IH I-M >U]; IH=(
$ QN RMK M" V. JVN
X= I EQN IH MZNZGV  V
$  QN RMK M"   7> M  Z0 U-  IH U> Q .<K E"
IUQN K 7>% H
-K 3>U]; >HV WV^ H>=1K M" H>0 IG% SNQG 7>M
>U]; WK QN7>'K S]G M
 U-K
I- JT H NR VKR( W ;NZ %] ^  I-= H  MZNZGVN LN'
  L"    Z= U RK
H=>1' WNE % QNJ'K RW WV^ J^]0H R=\ E-K \NEK MZNZGVN Z
9
IG=VN M>' H
-K 7> MZNZGV %]^ >][H MK W;KQN Z]% V. %NGN%K M"
7>  %] ^  WK Z= U RK IEQN7> ' K JW U K VG J^ R ' EN* M
W  U N

230

) (NR( IUQN% JT H N3 IW3

PKH I- VR4. IHK ;NZ V VKR( 7>aV RIM' WNEK JIW=VRQNVZN
V. RNZ %NZ GK Z=URK H>=1H 0N9AJ^]0H QNJ'K RW HZN-K %]^ %NE
E" IUQN SNQG IW=X Q%LN% 3R;NE^ 7> (N% 7>aV LN' ZNVR MK
HIEQN' Z0  V. 7> % 4 .  G  ZNRU GR3H U> R ^ Q .  GK 3NVR IW;K
RIMV G=K N;%N GN JIR'NZ M" 7> ZMN% QNVZN ]V GK VR4. JT*^
N;%N HR% V
$ MK HIEQN' ]*W M" 7>G E-K V=VWGR3K ]V GK \
L
HRH  7>  V
$  7> J G 3  E"  H  QNLKW% *UVK HRH  Z
H 3 JT N JV HR%N
XNMKGN M" 3NVR IW;K Q%>H^E IV N;%N Z>0 GN G H
E 7>JE=*;
M"  IHT J N I%3> E H JT N JV HR


3TK QZR%N( ;NZ GK (NJ%N IHW$ M


-K
*UWN% 3]HRLK % JNRWVK LK %]^ -H.V (N% 7>aV 7>JG3 IG=VN
K IL HNR% %NE ZNVN JNRWVK LK I-]%K Z>HV M
 U-K IH LG V=H
JT*^ I3WLK VZ
U>'  GK IZTV^ %MK$ M
WUK VG V=H 7>ZN LK GK WK IZTV^
%MK$ M
WUK =V STMZN GK RL
U>'  GK IZTV^ G 7>JR]V *UWN% IW3'^
V
U>'  GK IZTV^ M
WUK =V IW3'^ LK GK IZTV^ G IJ=6
$ I3WLK GK IZTV^
M
WUK VG ZNVN JNRWVK LK WK IZTV^ %^] JTNJV M
WUK J^R' Z
H3 %MK$
M
I-QN IFR WK IL]%N EN* JNRWVK LK %]^ M
I-QN 7>M WK QI;HNRK V
$
Z]VR 7>JG3 E" H M
I-QN SNQG IW=X 3R;NE^Q. % 7> (N% GK NG
S'N-K R= \ ' G  E-K 7>  %] ^  > R = I \QV R= I \QN V(N
V(N GR3H LN' E= U  
ILW$ I-M GN ]V RNZJNE  (N%A 7>aV LN H IV]U HRGN
M"   7> a (  \KR V MEWN WK S'NI-QN L.GN M"   L
 *UVQNVZN 7> J G 3
JT N JV HR E" $ GN M"   7>  GN HIEQN' M
 L.GN M"   IV] U  ZNJ' G
7>JR]V RW 1"$1 QNIG 7>\N9H G^R (N% 7>aV IV]U G E-K XE
U- J^RW (N% 7>aV IRF IZ=1K L. I-=1. GK S'N-K *=PK V X>=E4 SNHK
6=Y IG=V IFR H
-K 7>K 3IMR G IWQHVK %^] HM IH QN7> QNJ%]^ 7>M
(N% IG\NH  IEQN7> $ GN M. IL= (   ] V  RNZJNE GN LK GN IV] U
M
I-QN K \KR S'K K SNQG IW=X 7>%4. *=PKQ. %^] G\' LN' WNE
%]^ %N V. \KR IZE %N MK IV]U G Q]IZTV WX% >'% %]^ IZE %N MK
7>JG3 JTNJV M
 HGN IL %NE HIEQN' M
 H 7>G E-K ]V MK
\
L 'N JW U N IL= (   IV] U  X= E  IRMN M
W    7> a (  RW HNRLI= ;  M
' U
PKH I-K VR4 .  VKR( V  ;NZ 7> a V  LN'N V. 7>   NGUNR (N%
R^JK *=PK %]^ G\' ZNVR M" I-M JIW=VR UKVN LK IW=X WRI'V %N M
'
7> a V  3NVR IWR= > ;  M
- K ILV
$  H
- K EN* %MK$ JT Z N' JIW= V R UKVN
Q/ Z] V T   
V= V WIUQN% MK% ] V . L. ZM] V . V(N
V(N QXNRKQ. G> Q NRN *RIZV
3R;NE^  VKR(. V  ;NZ. 7> a V  QNVZ HIEQN'QR( L.G  M% 3T K
QZR%N(LK GK NVRN 7>aV U- 3R;NE^ IV]%AXNR SNR SR_N%K V^_N%
IW= X  G= S H  IZT V ^  %] ^  JT N JV M
-    MR H  WNR ZR% WNIEQ. GK ] I \QN
MLNR. M>]GK K IWXNR' IW3" M" IH L 3TK QZR%N( LK G GR3% V

IUQN% U] U N

231

J^ L N EN*GNI-H M> ] G K V. HK *UWN% I3W 7> % 4 .  3R;NE^ Q . GK R= I \QN
%MK$ HRG QR(NV JT*^ I3WLK WK 3NVR IWR>=; N;%N V
$ QJT3]% M%

W"3'
$ GWK G Z]IGR GK (NJ%N IHW$ M
-K
LG VK LK 7>ZN GWK  QNJ' IJVN RNLN GH3 G MW%H]>Y IW=X
6E.U EUNH LEH IZTV^ %]^ JTNJV M
-K *UWN% I3WLK 7>GK Q(KQ.
G H]HNE %]^ Z
MW3 VK LK JNRWVK LK  LN%H G MLNR NE V=H Z
<
7>aV R=\H JNUE. W.U []>ZG RM *UWN% IW3'^ LK % >GR3% X=HR
%NE VK LK G H]HNE %^] I6]'AI*]% HR IG=VN IL=( ;9 IUIRQN 7>a(
7>%]^ LZK% IW=X U=Y IG=VN IUQN I- ;NRIZH [1%N GK NG S'N-
R=\' G E-K 7>G 7>J=R I-=H Z]IGR W.U NGUNR S'N IG=VK U-K IH
IHV QN7>' WNE Z$ IW=X H
-K I-M %N HIM GW IH J>RN' IW=X UEV
IEI\QN M"   7>   Z] I GR IW= X  I-= H  I-VRK GN IX= V R R= \  IG= V N 7>  %] ^
W"3'
$ GWK HIM' E=U 7>GK G\AR\ V 3R;NE^ GR3H. %]^ 7> (N%
GK HMN'K G=  ' G  E-K I-= H  % H  IWQHVK I%> H V HR IG= V N 7>  %] ^
M
R ;NRIZH IWQHVK H>0 WV% IG]G K SNQG IW=X 7>G W]3L. %
7> 7>aV *$1 GN%  QNR]* HR IG=VN V(N
V(N HIM' E=U IH I-=H IWQHVK
GN WJNR P= J  M
 IUQN K ZNVN G   R> J -  ] H EJ HKV   I-= H
%NRKQE X94NI-QN 7>M SM>V ;]%WN% M
 IUQN I-=H I%R]VN% G]JVK
K 7>% ZNVN G R>/ I-=H N9K I-=H 
% GN UE GN MNR X94N'
GN ] H EJ HKVN 7>  G  J> = V R M
 IUQN
I- JT H NR *
E K QNVZNW. I-%4 .  G] G  H(NW. 7> a V  QN;NIRV M
H 
QNJ'K JIW=VR UKVN LK V(N
V(N JIW=VR WG. %]^ *>=E U- IL IW=X 7>M
RW N;%N 3NVR IW;K RIMV IE\K M" $  ILG  HNR% %N H
- K > = \
M> ] G N M"   %N H
- K HNRL I= ;  M> ] G N M"   %N MK JRZUVK QR(NV Z> H VK
M> ] G K M"   JT Z N' JIW= V R UKVN QI;/ Z] V R A  I- JT H NR
IL= (   G W K GKQ. Q= \ . IURKQ. 7> a (  %" ' . G W K GN Z] I GR W IL= (   LK*
IURK 7>a( ,WNEN LK G Z]IGR V(N
V(N IL=( ;=9 IUIRQN 7>a( W"3'
$ GWK
G  Z] I GR GK (NJ%N M
- K

J>RK IW=X LU%%N( LK GN Z]IGR QR(NV ;NZ IHW$ SI'QN
7> 9 KN JT . V IWX I-= H  I-] G RGZ% %NZ GN RNLN K 7> M  *UWN%
3TK IHT3% LK GN Q%]% *UV K I-=H RNVRK %]^ 3TK IHT3% LK % RNLN
%] ^  > J %  IW= X  GR3% G H   V(N
V(N IHMN IH LU%%N( %NZ GN Z R N I-= H
Z]IGR S'WNG 3TK IHT3% LK % I-M WK IHMN K IH Z]IGR IW=X Z^RVK
J^LN %MK$ HR%K M" HWE I-=H ]V 6=Y'N M" L
 GR3H. %]^ JIW=VR UKVN
Q%>NR IUQN% JTXNR HR Z>]GR V=1 7>aV 7>M (N% WK IG\NI-QN
IL=( Z]IGR S%N7>'N K WR 7>aPH RNLN I-]GRGZ% % QNJ'K JV%K
%]^ G=IQN IH Q=L RNVRK %]^ *UWN% 3TK IHT3% LK IG\N-K IG=V Z]IGR

232

) (NR( IUQN% JT H N3 IW3

S%N7>' G E-K IHMN M" RN'K % IHMN IH 3>* HNRL IW=X GRK IH7>
RW ]J=VK 7>%4. GK MK IG=VK M
-K M" 7>%4. %]>^ MK ZRIJV HR% IW=X
HK 
X'N M"RNLN % 7> (N% 7>aV Z]IGR S'N IG=VN L
 3TK IHT3% LK
%  > J %  IW= X  Z> ] G R G  IH%NR  7> a V  IG\NI-QN K Z] I GR S%' G
Z]>GRK V^FN% 7>IPQN Z]IGR %]^ V
9 IG=VN I%3N% WK %N SIXQN IH
7> a (  Z] I GR K Q"  N RNL  %  J] L  WNR Z] I GR S'NI-QN J] L   WNR
Z>]GR % V
9 IG=VN
RNLN %  I%RN3 M
H   Z] I GR %N S%N7> '  GN I%R'"  E"  IEQN I-M

IXQN IH %N LN' Z>]GR ZR V
$ IHM9 L%Z GN JTVK3
; E" IRMN M"
H
3IRHV M
 IUQN Z]IGR %MK$ SI'QN H>0 Z$ 7>JR]V J^R' JTZ3WR
HIWRGW  L
VK I%R]L% HNE  %^] IG=V WX% Q%>NR RNLN I-]GRGZ%
G H
E QN- V(N
V(N RNLN %]^ IHMN IH QNJ Z]IGR S'WN7> M>' I-M Z>]GR
Z] I GR ZIME  %MK$ V
9  U N RNLN %  IHMN IH ] V  LK Z" % ] ^  IW3WN3
%MK$ Z"$ *UWN% 3TK IHT3% IW3'^  LK G QNG3 %NE Z]IGR S'N IRMN
M. 3TK IHT3% LK Z]>GR %]^ %MK$ R
H JN RM J]L SNR Z]IGR S'N X>=HN
M. I-M 
XH IH IHV *UWN% ZRK JTKI\QN E" RM M
' JT]V^ M>' V.
Z"$ JTKI\QN G'
U WK %MK$ IRMN M. IH7>$IH H
3 WK IR=HV M
 IUQN M"
M> '  Z] I GR S%N7> ' N Z R   W GK U= E  %MK$ RMK JT Z  3 WR %  IHMN
I-]GRGZ% IL JTZ3WR % RW STIMZ]Y. GK RX%N HKVK M" 7>MK RW
HNRL HR% IW= X  ZR= (  M"   M
R  JT * ^  %MK$ Z" $  7>   JT Z  3 WR GK WX%
3HVK JTNJV M.  Z"$ Z]>GR %]^ R
H HGN M. QNJ' QNJ%]^ 6>JN7>$G
M
- =X HIM RM %  RNLN % IHMN IH ]V LK Z"$ %MK$ Z]% HGN
IH 3TK IHT3% LK V
$ H
-K JTSE 3HVK >HV JT*^ M" LG 7>M WK Z]>GR
%]^ %MK$ R
H H V. QNJ IH \V GK Z^EK M
 Z"%]^ IW3WN %MK$ M]>GN
V  %N MK Z R K IW= V K I(VK Z] I GR ZIME  S%WN7> '  GK M"   ] V  R^ J
IW= X  QN-  HIWRG W  HSKR JT Z  3 WR  %  IHMN RNL% L  Z] I GR S%N7> '
GN Z% M
W V. ZR H
E QN LN'N Z"$ QZ^H (N% 7>aV RIM]GN M. M>'
Z]>GR Z]IGR %]^ %MK$ V
9UN I-M HIMH JT*^ XE QN-
7> RNV %]^ JT*^ 3TK IHT3%LK % IFR RNLN I-]GRGZ% %]^ GR3% IG=V
V(N
V(N IHMN I-] G RGZ% I-= H WNR IFR ZIME S'WNG   L
 V R   H
E  ] V
QNI-QN K 7>   %NE ] J RH HRH  MNI-VN GK NX%N HR E"   7> M
Q"N W"N ]V %MK$ M" 7>GK *UVK 3HVK GN H
-K WNRAJNR %MK$ M"
RNLN I-] G RGZ% %K$G V
$  LNIUQN > J %  GN J^ R N IWRV.V QNJ'K
RN'K %]^ G=IQN RN'K % IHMN JT*^ HIM RM M% V. QNJ ZV X^H
 JT*^
GN ZIME F R  S'WN IG7>   RN'K GK G*NW%N > H V WN'K > ' H  RNL
% IHMN IH M>' V. H
3 WK \NEK M
 X>=HN M" L Z]IGR %MK$ S'WN7^$UN
V. JT*^ QJT3]% M
 LN'U Z"$ V. ;RZ ]H1 IW=X F IUQN M. RN'K
% IHMN ZR H
E UIM' R=\ M% 7>%4. %NE QNN%K %NE Z]IGR S' LNW
UN QNJ I-M UIM' E7> V(N
V(N JT*^ G QNG3 GN JNE' HR
 I-M HIM]G
M
- RN'K % RW UIM' L
 [R R=\ K V(N
V(N L
 JIM' R=\ K H=<H JT*^
G I%IZV QNJ' JVK G XR'. IW=X ZRIJV HR IG=VRNLN I-]GRGZ%

IUQN% U] U N

233

234

) (NR( IUQN% JT H N3 IW3

7>   (N% 7> a V  IUQN L


 JT Z  3 WR %  ] V  R^ J  IW= X  QN H  G= I QN
KHSKR JT*^ QR(NV QNJTKIXV ]V %]^ \
LH 7> Z]>GR %]^ R
H' GK
JTN(%N HKVK JT*^ HSKR LK HIWRGW  % IHMN IH IL VRF Z]>GR
7> a PH  QN7> $ GN M"   7> a (  Z> ] G R G  IH%NR  I-= H  X R N XS^ V RN  S'WN
IG7>  IL 7>aV S"PH Z"$ JTD*^ GK *UVK HRNU. V(N
V(N Z]>GR %]^ R
HNU.
RNLN %  I-= H  W= Y   J= ( R %] ^  HNRKUR. V
$  XS^ V RN ILMN S'WNI-QN JT Z 
3WR HSKR NIMS 7>   7> a V  S" P  U-   6 W K$ SNR Z] I GR S%'N QNR] *
M
I-QN 7>K Z$ I-=H %N( JT]JRN G I=; ZMNVZN QN U- %N( LK
%  RNLN %] ^  IHMN IH RNLN SM> V  Q= 6 N Z] I GR S'WN RM  M
  I- IW= X
Z^RVK WK (NIJV HR%K XNMKGK M" Z^RVK IS%. Z]IGR H"N I-M Z
RN QNG3 M" RNLN I-]GRGZ% % M=( L
9H IHMN IH %N( LK JT*^ 3TK
IHT3%LK % Z"%]^ >J% IW=X GR3% GH Z]IGR S'N7>' GN QNG3 IG=VN K
V(N
V(N IHMN K IH I- ZIME IW=X %N V. Z^RVK R=\'K M" %N MK JN\]Y
J^LN HR%K M" RNLN GK U=E >'H %N( % IHMN >J% WK HG =X M>]G
M% Z R   QNG 3  GN JNE' HR
 V(N
V(N X] G % GK E= H 9K GK Z^ R VK LR^ R
(NIJV HR
  I-M HIMH  %N( LK IS%N LEJN' UT I M' HKV  7> ) = P  U-
 RNLN % YR G ZNR X]G% GK E=H9K Z]UWN-K V(N
V(N HNRKUR %]^ Z^RVK
S%N7>' GN QNG3 G IG=VN I-=H Z^RVK 3TK IHT3% LK GK (NIJV HR%
GN QNG3 %N(LK GN K IFR M
R U>R^Q.A]V. % RNL %]^ RN- IG=VK IH
I-H=E JT*^ IHW$ RIM'U7>M V. SERNZ %]^ GN %NE R=\G K I-=H %
IHMN *" '  > * = G RN V. *UWN% 3T K  IHT 3 % LK GK ENYEK *" '  K 7> M
QNJ' *N-K IS%. IHW$ RIM HGK M"IV]% Z^RVKQ. S%N7>' GN I%R'"
IEQN IUQN IV] %  HNRKUR I%> H V HKV   Z^ R VKQ. IVQNR M> ] G   MK
1>H9A M
 U-KQ. I- VR4. IV]% SNR Z^RVKQ. \]Y M
 U-KQ. RNLN
SM>V IX]VV M
I-QN 
IXQN ZR *NU IW=X I-M =3 V J>]% HTZ %MK$
M" Z]IGR S'GN M" 1>=1 L.GN M" M>' Z^RVKQ. 1=>1 RMKQ. M% %N( LK
R> 3 1 M
H   U-  M% L H R HMNU. IH Z^ R VKQ. 1> = 1  L.GKQ. M% V.
HIM'U  RNLN SMN%N S'N IRMN M"   IHV  Z" % ] ^  3RNJ %N G  G '  IX] V N
UT  V RNLN %N QNMNR HR IRMN M"   %N RNVRK *R %K$GT N  QN-K W
R  S X " %  QW(N IW= X  RNLGRSNR IUQN 7>  K Z $  J^ R ' JT Z NVZN
HIWRGW  HSKR JTD*^ I-=H  NE. HNRKUR GN R^J S'NH RNLGRSNR
IW=X 7>JI(V M
 U- HZR 7>aV I-=H ("EN E1HN- M
- K IL IW=X
QNRK SNMR J=31 IG\N-K G RMK K Z]%
 IS%N G= HNRKUR GN JTKX"
G RMK K V(N
V(N M
R S
EN SRZN QNIG ("E IW=X *R K HNRKUR *
 IW= X  JT * ^  %  RNLN %] ^  IHMN Z" $  > I 'QN M"  IH JT * ^  G  Z] I GR G  E-K
Z^RVKQ. J^R' %MK$ M
 RMKQ. M% Z"$  NE GN IST; M
 X>=HN M. V(N
 NE GN Q%>*W M" X]G% GK E=H9K GK Z^RVK MRH HNRKUR %MK$
S'N HGN L  QNJGK QNIUQN M
W   V.  W H 7> J I(V M"   RNL  %
IHMN IH HNRKUR QNJ ZR E-K *UWN% MK HNRKUR S'H QN- E=UG
M
 Z"$ SM>V IX]VV K 
X IRMN MK K IH H
-K Q%>*WK HNRKUR IZE
V. Z= I QN GN ZN;N% S'   QNJ LEGK Z^ R VKQ. S'N IG7>   IST ;

IUQN% U] U N

235

HNRKUR R^J IW=X QN- HIWRGW  HSKR JT*^  % IHMN RNL% Z"%]^ I-=H
HZRN G  IG7>  IL LU4 N  S" P H  Z" $  JT * ^  GK Z^ R VK IVQNR HRNU. Z" $
Q]GR V
$ GRWNLN S]G HRH 3>;VN %NE Z^RVK S'NWNU. LG Z^RVKQ.
IVQNR M
 LN'UKQ. VG GRWNLN \
E4.UN L IW=X
$ IH % \
E4 IG=VN V.
IL]%K Z^RVK S'K M" 7>%K MK RIM LNWUK RNL % IHMN L"N QNJ 7>IXV
Z0
 7>   VR4 .  HR

 IG% Z^RVKQ. S'N7>$G M
 U- V. %N( LK QN U- %N( LK %
RNLN LK V
$  J> = I 6QN IH I-] G RGZ% HK Z^ R VKQ. S'N-KQ. RNLN %
HRS= ;  M
 IHMN IH QNJGK QNIUQN GN J^ R ' JNE' HKVN IUQN M"
ZMNVZN LK JT ] V ^  G> R *NU M"  IH Z^ R VKQ. S' %MK$ JN RMKQ. M%
Q=;KQ. S'G MK 1>H9A M
 L.GKQ. %HR. V
$ Z^RVKQ. G 1>H9 %N(
LK %] ^  IW3WN3 GWN7> '  E-K IG\N-   %N( LK %  IHMN Z^ R VK LR^ R
S%N7>'K M" M>' S'N7> Z"$ G\GN M. IH Z^RVK IHW$ 1>1GK M" RNL %
IHMN IH %N( LK V% HKVN LN IRMN M" JT*^ GN *ILQN I-=H Q%>*WK
 NE GN HNRKUR S] G  HZR  IW= X  Z^ R VK S'N IRMN M"   7>  %  IHMN
M" IH Z^RVK S' LN' V Z"$ QNJ' QNJ G>QNR \
E4 GWNU. LHR IH
% IW=X
$ G>QNR \
E4 IG=VN V. IL]%KQ. Z^RVKQ. S'KQN M
'UKQ. 7>%KQ.
MK RIM LN'UKQ. Q= L  7>  %] ^  Z^ R VKQ. S'N7> $ G  M
-    IG% M
 U-
M% %N V. SNMR I%=HIEQN M" %N MK LEAJN' V(N
V(N QNMNR MK HKVN
M" %N( LK % IHMN Z^RVKQ. G\'KQ. XNMKGKQ. M% IHW$ S'N IRMN
M"   S%N' V
$  SNQG HK G \ 'N M"   PKH %MK$ S'K M
W  U K V. PKH
S'WN-$U I-M HIMH %N( LK RNLN I-]GRGZ% %]^ %NE E"H 7> HZR
G NMZ' U- IL=( Z^RVK S'N-K LN RMK K QNWNL EUN-K HNRKUR
G>QNR \
E4
 H-K SNR IHMN JT]V^ %MK$ \>IE4QN V(N
V(N L
 \1A GK QNWNL
QN RMK K 7>M WK S]G M
 U-K %N( LK % IHMN IH  NEN IST;
G= RM M
  IG% \N'NAJK'N %MK$ HKVN M" M>' QNWNL WK S]G M"
IHV  ZR %N IUQN M
W    ;= H N ZNR H  GRWNLN V
9  IG= V N G I \QN V.
IV] %  Z^ R VKQ. R= \ KQ. K IV] % . G  M= (  V  J" R  G  J] L   %MK$ S'  K
HNRKUR Q] V RI;QN% K
Z]IGR S'H IVQNR M
 IUQN M" M
R XNRN %N G\H QNJ' M=P 7>aV QI9=U
%N( LK % IHMN I-MK Z^RVKQ. (NIJV HR IG7> M
 HGN M" JT*^ %]^ I-MK
WKHNR M
W E=UGN M" 3TK IHTD3% LK QNJMK Z^RVKQ. S'NH U- M%
Z>=\ J.Y % 3>* ZM^RV H=<H QUE IG% MK Z^RVKQ. GK (NJ%N
HR IG=VK RW J.Y V(N
V(N Z>=\ J.YN V(N
V(N RNLN V(N
V(N "I%H V(N
V(N 3R;NE^
Z^RVKQ. IW=X JTN' (NJ%N HR% E-K X=E J- J^R' JTZ3WR HIWR
GW  I-=H 3^GR GN R^J ;NR' HRH Z]IGR G Z>=\ G>QNR G Z=; IW=X
Z]IGR G JN Z>=\ HRH \94 M
 U- Q"K EKE4N HR RM % Z]%
 7>%4.
%^]  IUQN% MK %N M
W IH IJ=6 V
$ JT*^ GK JTN' (NJ%N GK "%N QN RMK
M" Q=UA Z>=\ J.YN X=E IRMN K JT*^ JTZ3WR IFR WK G>QNR G Z=;
IWX MK \94 RM I%=H1 QN H Z>=\ J.Y % 3^GR R^J IW=X \94 JTZ3WR
%] ^  Q"  N ;= H N ZNIRQN IH G^ R  LNH  IUR  V(N
V(N I-H.V (N% 7> a V  3^ G R

236

) (NR( IUQN% JT H N3 IW3

EKE4N HRG M
- S"P U- RNLN IMV RW 3R;NE^Q. % Z]IGR G Q]GR
LN H GI\QN V. RW Z^RVKQ. 7> G>QNR 7>aV \94 3^GR R^J JTZ3WR
GN R^ J  ;NR' HR IEQN I- H V H %] ^  G \ H  7> J I(V IWQHVK
QX]I*V M
 U- Z>=\ J.Y. HIM' E=UN JT*^ H3>*V M
 IUQN M" IH7>$IH
Z>=\ G>QNR %^] 7> 3^GR % Q3>; HR IG=VN I-E-K RW Z^RVKQ. %
3^ G R R^ J  ;NR' HR IEQN M"   W= Y N QI%31 M
 IUQN M"   H> 0  Z $
7> J R] V  Z^ R VKQ. GN WNVIWH R^ J  M
I UQN U] U N LE %NE H-K SNR
N_ HRH JTN' (NJ%N HKVK U-K HIWRGW % IHMN QIUQN%VN V
JN\] Y WNG GK XRZ KZN G \
  HNRKUR Z^ R VK GN *UWN% S'GN M" 
IFR J^LNRK L. M
R ]V 7> Z^RVK R^JK JT*^ IW=X JTN' JN7>$GN M" QR(NV
JT*^ %]^ LKW% IG]GN M" VG 7>M IZ=1K L. E=H9K GN JTT*^ HNRL I=; HRGN
M" WNM 7>- JN\]YK7> \^S Z^R\ S'N RM M
 JT*^ JTZK QNVZ.WN %]^
Z^ R VK (NJ%N M
 LN' G  H> 0  IG% SNQG EU*U  F= > 1  7> a XN
Z]>GR GN LE 7>aIPQN IL%]^ Z]>GRK V^FN% HIM]G M% V(N
V(N SM>V WU
%NE Z]IGR W=E XIEQN NMZ' HSKR JTZ3WR XRN XS^VR  7>aV S"P
K QNJ'N I-=H M=( 7>PNI-QN ILW$ QN3KRWG IG]G M% Z]>GR 7>aP
GN 7>aIPQN RIM IUQN JRSV W.U \94N IRMN Q=U %MK$ W; IHQN
IWJR R^J S'NH Z]>GR QNI-QN V(N
V(N XS^VR 7>aV S"P JT*^ %]^ IHMN IH
*UWN% QNJ Z"%]^ RNVN G IG7> Z"$ Z]IGR V
9% L.WNU. JT*^ % IHMN
IH I-M Z]IGR %MK$ M" I-M V. ZIME QN3RZ  M" I- IW=X IWGWN%
J>R3 IRMN HRUN V(N JIW=VR UKVN LK GN IUQN% IGQN HRUN QNJGN
I-%]^ IW%N3 HR%N 3
*N %MK$ IG]GN Z]>GR % IHMN IH Z"$ LR^R V
9.UN
JT*^ % IHMN IH LN8 H' R
HGN M" Z>]GR % IHMN IH Z"$ SW=3 M
 IUQN
M. QNJGK 3HVK QJNR M" Z"%]^ RNVN
RNVN G  IG7>  JT * ^   JT Z  3 WR HSKR
NIMS %  J> = I 6QN IH QNJ Q"  N IH7> $  HR RM  M
  IWJT  R^ J  IW= X
7>JI(V Z]>GR % IHMN LG I-M 3TK IHT3% LK VTVN>=U 3TK RNZX]GR
R^ J  IW= X  QN-  K VG 7>  %  Z" % ] ^  QU%K WN' IG\NH  S> R N *EN HIMH
QJZNI%V HRH RNVN Z]IUQN K Z"$ 7> M
M JT V K3
; E"' LN IRMN M.
JTZ3WR HSKR LK % IHMN JTVK3
; V. QNJ JIME. MK E" X>=H M

QNJ% G>QNRHN %]^ Y>=S
 R=I\QN M" Z]>GR % IHMN QL J^RN %MK$ Y>=S

JNI-QN Q= ; K RIM] G K M"   7> M WK H


- K JT S E 3HVK > H V ] V  NMZ'
QN IUQN K IL HNR% Z" $  G> Q NRHN %] ^  J^ R ' R^ J  '  %MK$ ZNQ
JNI-QN M>' WK H
I33 HRGN M. V.
V. 7>;=R %MK$ LN JN IRMN M. 7>;=R
$
Z"%]^ S]%4 R=I\QN M"
   VG JTZ3WR HSKR HIWRGW  % IHMN 7>a( WK Z"$ MK JM>]IXQN K
Z"$ MK 7>M QW33 SXNI-QN K M>' LNM SNHK SXK GWNRHN WK I%=UE
E" JT]V^ 7> NGUNR %]^ 6=Y G'N IL=( 3TK IHT3% G RKR GN Q]IVZ
]HNR HKVN IUQN K 3TK IHT3%LK G Q]IVZ ]HNR (N% 7>aV W=YN
Z]IGR S'N IG=VN IUQN I-M NGUNR JTZN' SI'QN RMUN IH WNVW
IW=X 3TK IHT3%LK GK IZTV^ M
-K K V(N
V(N J]L *IVH RKR 6=Y U- K
%MK$ V. QN7>' WNE Z$ IW=X HIM'U IH 3TK IHT3% LK GK IZTV^ M
-K

IUQN% U] U N

237

MK %MK$ K  QNIUQN JTNJV HRH SNHK GWNRHN %]^ WK Z]>GR % Y
S
IEQN JTZ3WR HSKR LK HIWRGW  % IHMN M>' QNJ Q=U V
$ HG WK
I- LU%%N( Z]IGR %]^ V
9% GN V% %MK$ HR%N V(N
V(N I- ZIME V
$
G^ R  XEN LN Q"  K QNIUQN JT * ^  GK Z] % H  JT ' NZ HRH  Z] I GR V
$  Y <
IHE
Z K1R G^ R  M1 IUQN I-VR4 N  3T K  LU%%N( Z] I GR QR(NV ;NZ
(NIJV M
I -QN

3TK LU%%N( Z]IGR IW=X 6^QN6NV 3>R^ V


$ MK %MK$ M"
H>0 IG%. IJ=6
$ IL J.Y % JT*^ HSKR LK %]^ 3^GR R^J IW=X ;=HN
ZNIRQN K 7%]^ H>31 R
U M
 IUQN RW Q3;K HR% V WK W(
%MK$ M
I -QN H> 3 1 R
U  GN H31 QI;= H  V
$  QI;= H  W= ; GN MK XEN
IUQN RW 7>JN%NW. WK HKVKQ. 3TK LU%%N( LK V
$ R
A H ]H1
I%WNR% G  E-K JT N (%N HKVK JT ] V ^  * I%3FE RMK > J %  IW= X  3T K
IHT 3 % LK %  GR3% IG= V   V(N
V(N IHMN J.Y  7>   ] V  G  XR' ;
H 
XR%NQ]IZTV JN% HR IL
%]^ V^] Z]IGR G Z>=\ G>QNR V
$ ;=HN ZNIRQN K
IL%]
VG 7>G QN3KRWNG %NE VRN H>31 R
U PKH M
 HGN M" LHR 7>%
V"%]^ IMRG V
$ ZNQF HKVN V. %MK$ V. %MK$ ZRGN HK %MK$ HRGN
7> M  Z> = \  J.YN W R   7> a IPQN H-K IM
U K J.IYQ. %] ^  %NE E" H 
7> (N% 7>aV IUQN IL=( JT*^ HSKR 3^GR R^J IW=X IWRNLZN% %
IL7>$ MK J.YN JT*^ G I%=H1 QNI-QN V. JTZ3WR 7>aPH X=E J- V(N
IHMN IH M  J.Y  Z" $  V. Q6^ V  M. Z R   V
$  G^ R  RIM'N HMK$ QNJ
QJIW=VR %N M
 LN' J.YN I%=H1 JM>]IXQNJTZ3WR M
R Q=U X=E J-
VG J.YN F> 1 A H  R
'  E= U N V(N
V(N IHMN JRWRIGUNR Z R N G
3  Z> Q NF
HR IG7> VG IGQNE^ JTT*^ R>H U- J.Y % QNGR G %NE I-=H NF
WVR LZK% 7> a V  IW6NH  JT * ^  %] ^  S" P ' GK JT N R(%N HKVK JT * ^  7> 
WVR 7>aV S"P U- VG 7> J.Y % QNJ XR' ;
- V(N
V(N XR%NQ]IZTV
%]^ JNVR IW=X WNIJ JN IEQN JT*^ HSKR LK % IHMN J.Y  IG% V=H
I-%]^ JK'N WK V(N I-%N% HR% WNE LE IW=X H>0 JNH I-%N% HRG
RIM'N W $  IG% V R N H> 3 1R
U  ZNJV M
W  U N V(N
V(N IHMN IH *IW= \
IW=X WK I- LU%%N( LK G Z]IGR IW=X IH % 6^QN6NV HKVN V. 7>%]^
WK G]Y IZEUN RW 7>JI(V IWQHVKQ. % WX% IG=VN IH Q=L G
SNQG I- JIW= V R (N% 7> a V  H
- K 6^ Q NA6NV %MK$ HKVK LNW U K
IWXNR HR
/A IM]G>VN% GN I-=H MK Z]IGR Q"N M" IL=( 3>R^ V
$ MK
6^ Q NA6NV %MK$ RMK M" 
Z>0 GN %]^ WK 7> (N% %^] G\' GN QWR JTNJV M
I-QN H-K
 W H. G  %NE 7>   (= E  %] ^  G \ ' G  E-K IUQN K H> 0  JT Z N' JT N JV
HR. 7> a (  RW JT Z N' Q= L  WK NH3K IZE   IL J= ( R X R N  7> a V
S"PH HSKR JTZ3WR LK % Z]IGR %]^ SXN7>' G E-K Z]>GR %]^ R
IHQN
K 7>M Q=L WK IWGZN% M" 7>G 7>aJR I-=H NGUNR R^J IW=X U>]SG
S'N R= I \QN M"   7> a (  SM> V  J> R NV' ZM] V  R= \ WNEN  JT ] J RN %NE I-= H

238

) (NR( IUQN% JT H N3 IW3

QN3RZ WK IWGZN% M"   7> a (  EU*U  NE GN IST ;  ZM] V  LK V
$
7> J R
H V Z] I GR GK Z> ] G R V
$  R= I \QN GK LN'HNRK XNMK V. 7>  %  WK
I-MK G= I QN V(N IHMN IH Z R   J^ R WL H-K JK94 K QN V
$  I-= (   ZM] V
R= \ WNE  RM  M% I-= (   MK 3T K  ;RZGN NIMS V  7> % 4 .  GK JV%K
*UVZVK QNZ%K G W K %  RKR IVQNIUQN K G
% 4 .  GK ZN;KQ. WK
%NEA S'KQ. IG\N-KQ.
IFR QK$ 3T K  LU%%N( LK G  Z] I GR IW= X  U-   7> a (  Z^ R VK J^ L N
Q=L WK %MK$ M" JT]V^ JTGR3%K Q=L WK EUN R=\K M"
L
 IV]% Z^RVKQ. *UWN% 3TK IHTD3% LK V(N
V(N 3TK SERNZ LK V(N
V(N *"'
>*GRN LK GK Z]IGR G Q]GR (NIJV M" 7>%4. G G
%4. M=(. G J]L %MK$
M% G
% 4
$  M= (  1] > Y   M% 7> % 4 .  Z^ R VKQ. GK J^ L N %MK$ M] > G K H W E
GR3%NR( R=\KQ. M% 7>a( I-=H UNI-Y J.Y %]^ J>=I6QN IH >I'QN M"
IH I-M Z]IGR J]L WNR Z>]GR % V
I9QN K IFR J>%R V
$ S'NI-QN
K Z] > G R %  IH7> $  V
I 9QN IFR IH%  Z] > G R %] ^  R
I HQN J.Y  %
IHMN I-] % N V. Z" % ] ^  JVN %MK$ I-M NRK IHT J N LU%%N( LK GK K
7>%4. % MK Z>]GR %]^ R
IHQN K >I'QN V. M" IH Z]>GR % IV]% SNR
Z] I GR %] ^  V
I 9QN K Z" $  IFR JT 3 % HKVN JIMEK WNR MK IH7> $  %N
Z]>GR %]^ JT*^ % R
IHQN J.Y % 7>aVR IG=VN EKE4N M" LU%%N( GK
Z"$ IFR J=>I6QN I- Z]IGR IW=X 6^QN6NV M" IH %MK$7>% IHMN
IH LG
$ V
$ Z]IGR SI'QN M" I-=( H
-K 6^QN6NV %MK$ Z]IGR IW=X 3^GR
V(N
V(N J.YN I-=H (NEK L. J=VE IW=X \N'N \N HG M% H
-K Z%4. %MK$
HRGN Z" $  JT 3 % HKVN J.Y  LK IM] G ^  Z] I GR. IW= X  V. JIME. SM> V
6^QN6NV K I- IW=X IH7>$ %MK$JT*^ V. 7>MK M" J.Y GN 7>aVR K
EKE4 N  M"  LU%%N( GK
M> '  J> ] % QNVZNW. IWXNR HR% = X  %] ^  IH] % N GSNI-QN IUQN M" 
I-=H EKE4N LU%%N( GK HIMH JIW=VR NGUNR. QNGR'K-$ M% JT]V^
QNVZ HIEQN' V. HWE JIW=VR UKVN LK V JIW=VR WG. IW=X WRI'V
V(N
V(N JT Z  3 WR HSKR LK G> Q NRN IG= V   V= V WIUQN% G  Q%>  NR *UVK
N;%N HR% ZNVR MK ] * W M"   %MK$ 3NVR IWR= > ;  M
'  %NE ZN%W
LKW% IWQR( M
 LNWUN JTZN' UKVN QI;QN-  Z]VR A 3TK
LU%%N( G  Z] I GR IW= X  JT * ^  G  QNG 3  Q%>  NR JIW= V R UKVNLK G
IUQN% GK ZIMZN GN U>'UN' M
'N MK W;KQN M" V(N L"N 3TKZG*NUWV
UKVN LK IW= X  *UVK IW;K M"  7>  K VR4 .  N;%N HR% %NE MK QNVZ
HIEQN' ] * W M"   %MK$ V. LU%%N( LK G  GR3% ZNVR L. I\X9K
JTNG \N' ZNVR MK H
-K EN* %MK$ IH7>$IH I-M IHTQN 3TK UKVN LK
IW= X  WRI'V %N M
'  V  3NVR IWR> = ;  M
- K L
 QI;QN-   Z] V R
A IW= X  JT Z N' M" 

WRU GK JIR*N3N M" 


7> G MNR' WRU %] ^  I-= H  M
1 E R"  1
R " $ 1  LN'
$  ILW $  H
- K ;%K

IUQN% U] U N

239

IWQHVK URZKQ. G ZZ IW=X I3ZEN L. H>E^ Z%NEK L" 3IMR. IW=X
P]Y (N%. 7>aV L.GN M" 7>a( IHK M
1E IW=X PIMRGN M" IL IW=X
HZR GN IHRNI-QN V(N \N' GN \RXN QGN HR%N M>]GN M" G
 L. IV]%
ZMK% IW=X  L.  MLNR \RX HRH WNJ QNJ' HRZ \VR IW=X
QN7> ' N M> ] G N M"   IFR  ZMK%  Z,G^ R K IZM%V HR
  IFR  ZMK%
QNJ'K MK HZN-K \RX HRH  WNIJ QN7>   L H R IH  NE HZN-K
PKH %MK$ M
-K V. 7> G
 ZMK% G >=\ %]^ WK VR

PKH I-  JT H NR WRU LN'
$ /AI- IJT ( WK E
H  7> a V  N;%N HRH
H>0 Z$ WRU R^JK M
1E IW=X XEN L.GN M" IFR QNJ'K J>]% HZN-K
?RX HRH WNIJ %RH V(N XRNK E=\ JTN'KQ. G RKR IW=X H31
JNJHT Z  G  QN;NR 7> a V  *
U 'N J" $ GN M" 
LG V=H V=VWGR3K ]V %MK$ IZEUN VG V=H 7>JR
HV L%ZAIZTV^
V(N WRUA%RH V  X R NK E= \  L^ % KQ. GN H31 SI'QN MK RM U N
IH7>$IH HWE J^R' JTZNVZN GN IV%NZ V(N NR%NZ MK JNJ. GN %N3
HRGN M" M
R JT*^Q. GK J^LN %NE JNJ %31 %MK$ M>]G RW HRZ.
GN IL7> $  GN IV7> $  (NWV  _E MK IZEGN M" 
I-E-K UKVN QI;QN-   E
H   IW= X  IHMN M"  IH ST M ZE
H
ZM.WRU  V= H  RWE
H  %N3WN% M% LG WRUAZM.WRU MK
%MK$ RIM'U  VG N;H GN IH= (   IPHN'N M
W  U N IHT J N IWXNR HR

JT 3 %/A HK UKVN LK GN I%= V  JNP HR% GN H
- K EN* %MK$L

GN% HRG M. ILW$ H>=V %]^ R


1K *>=\ %]^ *
L% HK9KQ. %]^ QN1N VKR(.
7> a V  *] Y NRN QNIG HRG  M% HK I-M WK IWQR( M" 
7> V R/A
R/A ;NRIZH GUT D ] ( . G  JNP'AJNP' %NE IUQN%= U  GN _E
IZEGN M" =U GN _E H>0 Z. WRU L. IL 7>G3 %NE HKVN 7>GN
_E IZE L.GN M" JT]V^ Z
H3 %MK$ I%=V JNP HR% GN Z>=\ HNR' I-M
M>]GN M" IH GU]T(N IW=X L
 N;%N HR% GN I%RG3 M" V(N L
 %N HR%
GN I%RG3 M" 7>GK NG VNLN RM IHV H
-K UEVK %N M
 LNW IL
%NE QK$ WNVIWH 7>G3 IVQNUH UFEV HRH 3NVR IW;K IVQNUH
Z%Z]I%QN QNXR% J^LN  %N HR% E=U LN-K- V(N Z%>=\ LKW% G Z>=\
7>G3 GK NG S'K RM IH Z%>=\ LKW% GN Z^E 7>G3 QNVZ HIEQN'
MK M" L
 3NVR Q%>H^E N;%N %NE MK ]*W M"
ILW $  I-= H  IL] Z KGNR %^ ]  IST ;  QW(N IW= X  J> = V R GK JT N JVK M
- K
IHN% % 
IXQN IH LG V=H S=XN LWN% M
WUN QNJ'K \VKASN9K G
HNRL %] ^  ] * NE' 
U  M
W  U N IHV  Z R K IZT V ^  %N M
 LNW   I-E-K
IHN% % QNJ'N Q%>*W IE\H 6=Y IG=VN V(N QNJ' J>=VR %]^ IHMN LG
V]^ LWN% M
W$ VG QNJ' \VKASN9K G HNRL %]^ Z0' G E-K ZR I-
Q%>*W G E\ %]^ JTVKIG% J94 E"'N V(N QNJ'K \VK HR%K IJVNLK GK
IZTV^ G 7>JR]V IHN% GN J>=VR JTVKIG% IJVN LK G>QNRN IE\ Q%>*W
G E\ %]^ J94GN JT]V^ ILW$ 7> IW=X IEI\QN M" 7>$W HR %MK$ IRMN
7> M  IHN% GN J> = V R HK ;%K M
 HGN M"   HGK %MK$ W"    MK HR%N

240

) (NR( IUQN% JT H N3 IW3

XNMKGN M" L
 IJVN LK % QNJ' Q%>*W E\ IW=X IE=I\QN M"
PKH I- JTHNR JIW=VR UKVN LK G JNP %]^ 3R;NE^ I%=V HR RM
M% JT ] V ^  N;%N GUT ] (  G  IWJRKV HR RM  M% I-E-K UKVN
QI;QN-   E
H  A G  Q%>  NR IWQR( N;%N M" 
ILW $  IV] %
$  U> ' . RLU> '  ST M ZN LK VU> '  IW3'^  LK VZU> '
I3WLK  GK J^LN UKVN QI;/ E
H  V
$  V(N  V
$  IW=X Z%4N
M"  V(N 3RN; HR%N QR(NV IJ= V R J^ L N IJ] Y  *R%N F> E  Q(KQ.
X= > H H  U] U N IW= X  IHT Q N HRWN7> ' N V R 4 W K$ VNR4 W K$ ZMK%N 6ZNMK
WR3K QNIG HR%N UKVN QI;QN-   E
H   IW= X  Z%4 N  M"   WRV
R= \ 'N UKVN QI;QN-   E
H   IW= X  Z%4 N  M"   IEI\QN M"  IH M
QRL>%C 
U *UVK  %N V. ISEH>E %N \N' WNE GK WRV R=\' WNE
 I= ;  M> ] G N M"  ++++ QR(NV WRV R= \ 'N Z%4 N  M" 
*>=I\Q. %]^ *
L' G'N H>=IVQ. QNIG LKWAL]V^Q. V J3^Q. %]^ QMNR
HRN7>'N QNIG S>RN %MK$ M" JT]V^ J^R' ]V G ZNI;QNZ %NE 7>%4. GK
QNIUQN Q%>  NR GN% V(N = U  QNIG HR%N MK J^ R ' EN*GNI-H M" 
ILW$ I-=H H>=VN HNR G Q]GR ZNIEH WNEK K1 7>aV S"PH NVRN
HRGN M" H>=V GN YRN-KWR Z%>=\ M>]GN M" 7> J3^ %>]^ QNZ Z%>=\ V
$
WK ILQNGN > I W;NW. M> ] G KQ. M% QE= U  V
$  HZRN J= \ N V(N H^ E R
E= I UQN M] > G N M"  QNIGAQNIG
LG I-M %NGN% JT N 'K Z%> = \  RKR IW= X  K GN% WK HKVN JT ] V ^
Z%Z] I %QN QNXR' J^ L N  G  ZNI;QZ %NE HKVN L
 3NVR IW;K G
IWJRKV M
' G HNR' EN*GNI-H %MK$ M
I-QN JT*^ GN IW;N% M" IH L"N
WK HRZ JTN'K HRUN 7>GN FE LR^R IZEUN I-M IW;N% VG V=H ENU^
M" LG V=H V=VWGR3K ]V J^R' JTZNVZN GN ZNRUGR3H %MK$ IZEGN
L"N HRZ JTN'K HRGN M" W"N MK FE JTNJV M]>GN M" I- IW;N%
G  Q%>  NR 7> M  VKR(. V(N ;NZ. V  LN M
R  (N%. 7> a V  *] Y NIRQ.
G>QNRN H>=V QNIG %]^ R
1K JN7>' G HRZ G QN;NR 7>aV H>=V GK L^%K
IW= X  XEN IUQN 7> a (  WK HKVN HRZ IZIEQN H> = V   G  LKW% IW= X
QNJ'K J^RW L%Z GK 3>* HRZ GK HZN-K %]^ ZNJV HRH U; GK L^%K
IW=X XIEQN LNWUN 7> U; G LKW% IW=X RW >IW;NW. 6K' E-KQ.
LN'UKQ. NRN IG% IZ= 1 K H= X KQ.AJ= H KQ. I-= 1 . <
-  U N
N VGJ6XNV
M
R JTN'KQ. G RKR IW=X H31 7>PN-UN V(N
V(N %RH WK *
U'N JWUN
XRNK
=  RKR JTNJV HRGN M" IFR
NK E=\ L^%KQ. GN H31 *
UH IFR Z%>\
HK JVN *UVK S' L. %N S' ILW$ ;NZ V(N VKR( 7>aV LN' WNE G
J"R. %KX L. IL WNRK G>QNRN L.GN M" 7>G JMK- %KX IL]% WK LKW
L]V^ ZRG M% 7>GN JNJ WK VKR( W ;NZ NVRK %]^ *
U'N J"$GN M"
LG V=H J^R' ]V L
 J^R' JTZNVZN GK IV N;%N G=' WNEN %MK$ IZE
VG V=H JNJ %N3 I\ZN  %MK$ M
 HG IH7>$IH STMZN IW3'^ ZM3
ST M Z 6R J> R 3 HNE  V(N JRST M Z QH3R J> R 3  GK N;%N %NE
JNJ %N3  I\ZN  %MK$ M]>G JNJ V(N J>]% G
%4. GN FE *
U'N J"$GN M"

IUQN% U] U N

241

L H R 7> M  JT N 'K UKVN IUQN% Q%>  NR J^ R ' ] V  GK 3R' JT N JV HRH
J^ R ' JT Z NVZN GK N;%N HRGN V. L. 7> M  VE
H  XEN L.GN M"  L.
G>SNRN Z%>=\ RKR JTNJV HRGN M" J^RW J>]%. G QN;NR 7>aV H
-K ]V
IZE L.GN M" 7>M JTN'K IFR 3>* HRZ HRH JNR M
 L.GN M"
I-E-K 7> J R
H V Z%ZN%K J^ L N EN*GNI-H %MK$ M" 
JT 3 %/A
%/A UKVN QI;QN-   E
H   V(N QI;QN-   E
H  
IW=X IHMN M" IH X]UK JTHNR QNXR' IW=X IEQN- M
- G^R G ;RZ V
$
U> ' RIMV WK QNJ'N ;RZ QIV 7> V Z M"   QNJ'  ;RZ IW= X  ZR%N WK
HIEQN' HNRH M" G^R GN ;RZ *"Q %]^ G' WNEN M" I- V
$ I=;
M] > G N M"  IH L
 WK L"  K J^ L N HRGN M"  7>  %] ^  IVQNU' %MK$ XNMKGN
QNJ'  ;RZ IW= X  ZR%N WK HIEQN' HNRH M" 
7>V=R/A
/A LHR UKVN QI;QN-  E
H  V(N QI;QN-  E
H
 GN QR( I-MK M"  IH L"  K J^ L N HRGN M"  HRGN RM   7>  %] ^  ZV
IVQNU
 V. JIW=VR 3TKZG *NUWG UKVN LK G IUQN% GK HK LR^RV K
I-=H E
H MK SM>V K 3TK UKVN LK G I-%4. E
H. GN *NWQR( MK
M" JT]V^ Q%>WNG HRVNW. % IWJRKV QR( HKVN M" IHTJN I%Z% J94

7> J T
H V G
% 4 .  E
H N GN WNVIWH QR( /
QI;QN- GNE
H/A
3TN%W;TZMIWU>'MJT;TZNV>W%>I3=PVNV
W;TZ I%;%Z 3M JT;TZM *NWMM@
Q%>WNG/A IWU>'M U>'RIMVQR(NV3N3VRIW;KIVQNUH 3>W%>I3=PVNV
\>G Z%Z]I%QN Q=6K JTHNR QNXR% IW=X IEQN- M
- JT;TZNV  G^IRQ. GK
;NRIZHJ^LN%NE W;TZM QNJ'K3N3VRIW;KQ%>NRJ^LN 3TN% QVK
7>VZM"3N3VRQ%>H^E W;TZM QNJ'KJ^LNIW=XV. I%;%Z ZR%NWK
3TM  HIEQN'HNRH M" QV JT;TZM  G^R GK J^LN *NWMM  *"Q %]^ G
'WNEK M"
QI;QN- GNE
H/A
3TN% W;TZM IWU>'M JT;TZNV W%>3IPVNV
W*NWI%VZ HRZ H>RW% % QNJ%
IV IHEIS3Z@
Q%>WNG/A IWU>'4 U>'RIMV >W%>3IPVNV \>GZ%Z]I%QNQR(NV3N3VR
IW;KRIMVX]UKVR4.QNXR%HKVM
- JT;TZNV G^RG;RZQR(NV;NRIZH
J^LNV
$ 3TN% 3T3PM" W*NWI%VZ \>GMKQNJ' >*NQQ%>NRS'N-
Z%Z]%QNXR%V
$ HTZ *UVKHRZ % ZV H>RW% HR
 IHEIS3Z ILV
$
JNJ%]^ QNJ%
IV JTNJVM>]GNM"IW33/AI-GNJTZN'UKVNQI;/GE
H
V
$IW=X3J3=1M"
7> J R
H V E
H . IW= X  J= 3 1 M"  IH QNJ'K 3NVR IW;K Q%>  NR
N;%N 3T  3 1 M"  XNM  G^  IRQ. GK XZHAGZH WNEK N;%N IH] % K MK
> I %
I LV E= U    7> M  MN%KHNRH M> ] G K M" 
L"    ZNVN GN LNUR' HR% WNE  SM> V  > R KEK QNWNL IW= X  UN'N
UNH  ZNVN GK V^ V K Z%[9V HIWV.W. G> Q NRN J^ R   NLAWNL G  %NE

242

) (NR( IUQN% JT H N3 IW3

HRG  M% 7>   > W %^ I 3PVNV  W" $  I%RIZV 3NVR IW;K RIMV
N;%N V QNHRI3V M
 H QNJ'K 3NVR Q%>H^E N;%N %MK$ IVQNU'K
XNMKGK L"    H
- K N;H IV N;%N V  E= U GN M"  V. 7> M  J^ R W WNEK
3NVR IWR=>; J^LNW. %]^ IVQNU IG]GN M" ILW$ IJ=VR J^LNN
 Z]IGR QNIG
IW=X LN'N QNIG VG M
R 3NVR IW;K IWR>=; N;%N HR% WNE HIM]G
M% IH RW J^RW J^LNW. IVQNU IG=VKQ. M% QNJG V
$ RW GW R>31
M
 LN'U I-=H IWQHVK % Q"N MK HKVN K 7>GN I-=HEVN J>=VR ZR
IUQN I-VR4 .  G^  IRQ. GK 3NVRIWR> ;  N;%N *" Q  J" G N HRGK M" 
JT ] V ^  QNJ'K 3NVR Q%> H ^ E  N;%N Q] I VZ > W N V= H  HRG  RIM'N MK
HIEQN'HNRK M" 
JT3%/A
%/A Z"$ UKVN QI;/ E
H  V
$  V=H WRI'V IW;K Q%>NR
I-=H QN% 7>aV S"PH IR QNIG Q]U. %]^ Z HRH I;QN% HRGN M.
I-HNG3K GN WRV WK R= \ GN M. I-VR4 .  3.VK %] ^  JT N JV M
 LNW.U.
7>V=R/A
/A IHTJN QNJ UKVN QI;/ E
H  %]^ J94
 IL IW=X IEI\QN
M" M QRL>% I-M 
U N;%N  %N V. ILQNGN \N' WNE GN %N ISEH>E
%N \N' WNE GN WRV R=\' WNE  I=; M]>GN M" %N ILQNGN LNU' WNE
GN V(N %N MK ILQNGN ' WNE GN I=; M]>GN M" %N MK I-=H (N% V
S"PH N;%. HR' WNE GN I=; M>]GN M" UKVN QI;QN-  E
H 
V
$  V=H WRI'V IW;K GN \]Y' UKVN QI;QN-  GN E
H  V
$ 
IW=X HKVN M" IH L
 Z^R\ IWQHVK ZV HRZ I-]GTKQ. %]^ M=PJ^RWH
R
H H  QR(NV I-= H  (N% 7> a V  S" P H  IX] V % HRGN M"  7> M  JN\] Y K
HMN7> $ GN M"   I-E-K HT Z 
U K HNRL HRG A  N;%N HR% WNEN
N;H  MK 3T  3 1 M"   WNVIWH *UVK IW;K G  E-K UKVN IUQN%GNVN
JT * ^  ST M Z  IHK V= V WGR3K GK \
L  HR% %] ^  HIM] G N M"   UKVN
QI;QN-   E
H    I- V
$  I= ;  M"  IH UKVN IUQN%GNVN ST M Z
G> Q NRN G=  K U-K *UVKIW;K J^ R ' %MK$ M"   I-E-K UKVN QI;/ 
E
H  V
$  V=H STMZ 6R J>R3AHNE  G>QNRN QNJ'K N;%N GN
WR'% M"  V(N QNJ'K N;%N V
$  M
'  WNEK 3.VK %^ ]  QIV[1KQN
Q%> V ZNZ  UKVN QI;QN-   E
H   IW= X  IHMN M"   7> J R
H V
QI;QN-  E
H  V
$  IW=X IHMN M" IH Z% V(N I-]GTKQ. %]^ W=
IW= X  R= \ ' WNEN N;H I-= H  IW3 3  QN' IVQNR HR   L
 %N QI;= H
7>aXN %N QI;=H %K$WN M
W 7> QN% 7>aV S"PH Z% V(N I-]GTKQ. %]^
W=   IW= X  R\H  Z% %] ^  I-HNUR HRH  QI*QN HR   I= ; N S" P H
STMZXNRK GN JNE' HRGN M
I-QN Z% %]^ R
HH JTQN' M
W I- JTHNR
N;%N IW=X E=UN N;H ZR IW=X RIM' WNEK I%RWN'JTZNZ  QIV SLN%
QR(NV ISEH>E ZRK M
-K %NZ ZNVR  3.VK %]^ JTNJV M>]GN M" I-E-K
UKVN QI;QN-  E
H   QNJ'K N;%N IW= X  M
'  WNEK UVK EN*
%]^ QIV[1KQN Q%>VZNZ  IHMN M" I-K UKVN QI;QN-  E
H 
V(N Q/ E
H  IW=X IHMN M QRL>%C V]^ JRZ3.VK V(N VE
H %]^
JTNJV M
W$UN IFR J>%RL%Z %MK$ M>]GN J^R' Z
H3 JTNJV M
 L.GN M"

IUQN% U] U N

243

Z"$ UKVN IUQN%GNVN JT*^  WK I-K QNIG %RN' J>R3 JTZ3WR GK 3R'
IW=X M. I-E-K IGT9 I%3X" HRH 7>GK N;%N W J^LN HR%K XNMKGK M"
QNJ'K N;%N G Q1HE >HV IUQN% G QN;NR 7>aV G= ZNRU
%] ^  QI;/ E
H   IW= X  W" $  > H VVZM ZVM  QR(NV QIUQN%
Q]I;HNR WNE IWXNR IHMN M" M
R Q%>WNG HRVNW. % Z >HVVZM
ZVM#GN QR( JRZ 3T31 Z]I%QN M"#HKVN M"  LG IH HR%N K IH
I-M Z R N Q1HE EUNI-QN QIUQN% Q] I ;HNR G  QN;NR 7> a V  IG= V N
Z= V  M"   IH7> $ IH (NR( IUQN% G  IW3  IW= X  IH  V= V WGR3K ] V  V
$
LN%' E-K IHMN M"  UKVN QI;/ E
H   WNVIWH Q%> W NG
NG UKVN
QI;/ E
H   /A

IU%NZQNIJRW3NZZGUV%Q]VRQNVZ%N
3TN;WN%*LVMZNZMZ>HVVZMZVM@
Q%>WNG/A ZR G>QNRN IG=V *UVK IWXNR L
 Q1HE EUNI-QN M
I-QN
7>JR
HVE
HV
$IW=XWRI'VJ^LNIW;KL
Z"$Q%>ZN%ILMNG=IQNM"
J^R%IUQN%%MK$M"IH7$IH 3TW3NZ RW 
IU%NZ N;H.IW=X M L

3T;NWN% J^R%QN(NV
$ Q]VTQNVZ%N =XKEU%%NE ZVUV% ZRG>QNRN
IG=V *UVKZVG Q%>NR ZNZ Z"%]^ *LV *LGNM" M 7>M QNIJ *K
>HVVZM QIUQN%Q]I;HNRV
$L%ZAZR%WRUA%RHWNEKN;%.IW=X
MKEK'M"I-M Z ZRN ZVM IWXNRM"
I-GN JT Z N' JIW= V R UKVN QI;/ E
H   IW= X  V(N UKVN
QI;/ E
H   V(N UKVN QI;QN-   E
H   IW= X  J= 3 1 M" 
I-E-K UKVN QI;QN-   E
H   IW= X  IHMN M"  IH M  *NRV V] ^
RW *NW %NE 7> JTZNVZ. GK 3R% IW=X LN 7>GK IHTJN %NE MK V]^
JRZ3.VK %] ^  V(N %NV% JRZ ;NZ QR(NV VE
H  %] ^  JT N JV M
W  U N
UKVN QI;QN-  E
H  IW=X IHMN M" M>' V"%]^ UKVN QI;QN-  E
H
 IW=X WRI'V V=VWGR3K ]V IZE LN- 7>G ZUR
$ JRZJG JTZ3WR
%]^ *EK*.VK \
L%N XNMKGN M" IL IW=X U- M
- N;H IFR Z>9H WNIJ
I- ]NR IW=X %MK$ QN7>$G QR(NV L%ZAIZTV^ V
$ GN E-K Z>HV M

L.G M% IL JTZ3WR % ]NR R^JK IST? GK RX%N HKVK M" Z"$ WK 7>K
QNIG J>R3 JTZ3WR GK 3R' IW=X M. 7> GK *UVK HR%K XNMKGK M"
UKVN QI;QN-  E
H  V
$  IW=X UKVN QI;QN-  E
H 
V
$  V=H IUQN% %]^ UEV I=; HKVN M" QRL>% % J=>I6QN IH JT*^ Z%
%]^ R
H'N SM>V HIP% M" JT*^ % 7>V=R IG=VN Z% %]^ R
H'N WN^ %]^ R
H'
G ZN% M" IFR WK I-M IHMN M" IH I%R3]GM H
-K WK IWQHVK IH
Z$ I6' ZNVR HRZ HKV IS%N %MK$ RIM]GN L
 ZM.Z^R\ Z%>=\ ZV
HRZ I-]GTKQN %]^ M=P J^RWH 7>J=R V
$ R
HH Z% IW=X H>0 %N H>0 
XGN
RIM] G N M"   I-E-K I-= H  (N% 7> a V  M= P 
U  HRH  %N S" P H  ]  NIRH
HNRL HRG A  HRZ
U  N;%N HR%N MK 3T  3 1 M"   HRZ %N HR%N
QR(NV M= P 
U  %NE I-= H  (N% 7> a V  S" P H  N;%N HR% GK 7> J  H 3N
HRZ HRG A HRG  N;%N 3T  3 1 M"   I-= H  (N% 7> a V  S" P H  N;%N

244

) (NR( IUQN% JT H N3 IW3

QHT Z 'N  HR% %NE V R N LKW% I%RWNM IHW $  M


W  U N 3NVR IW;K
IVQNUH N;%N M=P
U I-=H QN' 7>aV S"PH  HR% 7>aV HRZ S];%
GN HNR% M" G^RN L
 3NVR Q%>H^E HRZ HRGA N;%. HR%N MK
3T  3 1 M"   I-E-K ]  NIRH HRZ HRGN M
I -QN N;%N HR UKVN
QI;/ E
H  IW=X IHMN M" IH >=; WK HR ZRN IZR% WK HR I-
JTHNR Z"%^] JTNJV M
W$UN UKVN QI;/  E
H  IW=X V(N QI;/ 
E
H  IW=X IHMN M" IH JT]V^ ZRK N;%N %NE M
' WNEK UVK  EN*
QIV [1KQN Q%> V ZNZ  M"   I-E-K 7>   JT Z  3 WR GK 3R' IW= X  LN
ILGK IHT J N %NE V] ^  JRZ3.VK V(N 3NWVZ (N%Z  VE
H  %] ^
JTNJV M
WUN 7> JTZ3WR GK *UVK IW;K V(N J^R'IUQN% V=VWIUQN%
IHK V= V WGR3K ] V  GK \
L  HRH  7>  V
$  J> = 6  Z" $  UKVN IUQN%GNVN
ST M Z6RJ> R 3  WK %MK$ LN'GN
JT3%/A
%/A UKVN Q/ E
H  IW=X IHMN M" IH Z"$ E
H. IW=X WG
IW=X J>R3
VZ %NZ V
$ JTI=; M. I-V
$ V. I-MK I=; M
I-QN IH UKVN
IUQN%GNVN JT*^ MK RW3HVKZN% M" V(N UKVN QI;QN-  J^R' MK
UKVN IUQN%GNVN GK MK ZIMZN HIM IRMN M" 
7> V = R /A
/A UKVN LK IW= X  UKVN IUQN%GNVN JT * ^  QNJ'K N;%N V(N
ZR= ( VN WK HIM IRMN M"  V(N %NEA J^ R ' JT Z NVZN GK ZIMZN WK
HIM IRMN M" V(N 7> JTZ3WR GK N;%N G E-K V=VWGR3K ]V G W=E
]HV HR IRMN M" UKVN QI;QN-  J^RN STMZ 6R J>R3AHNE  GK
ZIMZN V
$ JRKJ^R' M" V(N UKVN QI;QN-  NRN 7> J^R' JTZNVZN
QR(NV QNIG J>R3 JTZ3WR GK ZIMZN V
$ JRKJ^R' M" UKVN QI;QN-
 E
H  V
$  V(N  V
$  IW=X J^R' JTZNVZN V(N JRSTMZ STMZ
QNIG GN I%R'NI-H IUQN% M" 
E
H  IW=X IHMN M" IH IJT(WK V=VW %NE I%RIZV E
H STMZ G
I-= H K ST I MZ] Y  V(N JRST M Z G  = V  ] \  ST I MZ] Y  IJT ( WK V= V W %NE S'
M
' GN HNR' I-=H E
H WK IHMN L.GN M"  IW=X G
 JT*^ M% I-=H 6RJ>R3
QR(NV STMZ G^RN QH3R J>R3 QR(NV JRSTMZ I-%4. G
M. JT*^Q.
G Q]VRUV IL]% WK JTN'K M% 7>%4. GN V(N I-%4. G
%. JT*^Q. G (^E
RKR V. %N3WN% M% V(N LKWQNVZN QIW%N3K HMK U-K M" 
E
H   IW= X  IHMN M"  IH WNVW IW= X  J> R 3
V Z QR(NV RW
3HVKZN% JT Z  3 WR V. 7> J R
H V G
% 4 .  V
$  M
R MK M"   L
 JT Z NVZN IHMN
L.GN M" L
 IV]%. E
H. IW=X JTW3 HRH *GN ;NR'AJ
3' HRGN M"
7> M  WNVIWH QIW%N3K JT Z  3 WR IHMN L.GN M" 
QI;/ G  MK E
H   IW= X  UKVN IUQN%GNVN  6R J> R 3A
STMZ  QNJ'K I(VK G=G M
- HIM IRMN M" IH Z"%^] V. E
HWG G]V
H(N  G QN;NR 7>aV J>R3
VZ HIM]G M% IH7>$IH Z"$ QNJ' I-=HK STIMZ]Y.
IW=X IL]% WK JTN'K ZR QN;K% M% 7>M XNM (^E RKR IW=X %N3WN% M"
XNM QNVZ R^J IW=X QIW%N3K M% Z"$ 7>V
$ 7>VZ 3T31  M. I-E-K
Z"$ E
HWG G QN;NR 7>aV J>R3
VZ JTI=; M. WNVW IW=X J>R3
VZ V.

IUQN% U] U N

245

H
-K M
RMK JTZ3WR M" L
 UKVN QI;/ E
H  IW=X IHMN M"
JT3%/A
%/A UKVN QI;QN-  E
H  IW=X V(N  IW=X IHMN M" IH
Z R K 7> V J= V K %^ ]  H
- K %MK$ LN'GN L
 Z" % ] ^  Q%NIG QL%ZN V= V W V
$
LN'GN M" 7>M RW JNJ. V
$ Z>HV M
 L.GN M" I-V
$ J=31 M" IH STMZ
GN L%Z %MK$ M"  V(N RW JNJ %31 HR IG] G N M" 
7>VaR/A UKVN QI;QN-  E
H  %]^ J>%R J94$ ILIW=X IHMN M"
IH ZRK 7>VJ=VK %^] %N GWVN STMZN IW3'^ V(N I3W QNIG  V(N %N
ZMNIR3K LN'G  M% IH7> $ IH 7> M  * Z R   V
$  7> V J] %  M
-   M%
I- E
H WVM I=; M" IH UKVN IUQN% GNVN JT*^ GK 7>VJ=VK
QR(NV L%Z V. M
I -QN M"  JT ] V ^  HNE ST M Z  V
$  7> V J] %  G W VN V(N
IR3KL% %MK$ LN'G IH7>$IH 7>M HNE V
$ 7>VJ]% M
- M% ILW$ IJVN
G L%Z G IW3 IW=X S=X %MK$ LN'G JT]V^ IJVN GN IJVN QR(NV GNGN
LK MK G=GN M" J^R' JTZNVZN % W"$ HNE E
H IW=X JTU1 M
H STMZ
GK 7>VJ=VK G IW3 IW=X G=IQN M" IHTJNHRH J94
 I3T1K RX%N I-
J>  VH IUQN% U] U N# G  JT 3 P A V= H 
UKVN QI;QN-  E
H  GN Q%>WNG UEV HKVN M" ILW$ UKVN
QI;QN-   E
H  V(N QI;QN-   E
H   IW= X  QNJ'  QNJ%] ^
%N3WN% V(N L%ZAIZT V ^  V
$  SNRA JT N JV M
'  WNEN IHMN M"  V(N
QI;QN-   E
H   V(N QI;QN-   E
H   V
$   V(N  W
QI;QN-  E
H  A IW=X IHK M
R QIW%N3K Q%NIG JTZNVZN
G IW3 IW=X IHMN M"
I-E-K UKVN QI;QN-  E
H  IW=X IHMN M" IH L
 Z%>=\. IW=X
IWGWN% QR(NV V= V WGR3K ] V  Z" % ] ^  V(N 7>   Q%NIG WNVW IW= X
L%Z RIMV RW E
H. G ZM3WR QR(NV JTZ3WR %^] V=VW V
$ LN'GN
M"  7> M  V= V WGR3K IV IUQN% 7> X NR' HRGN M"   ILV
$  IV N;%N
HRH JNJ V
$ Z>HV M
 L.GN M" I-K GN JTZN' UKVN QI;/ E
H 
IW= X  WK M"   IHT J N J9
4  UKVN QI;+ / GN (NR( Q%> W NG
NGA
QI;QN-GNE
H
%ZIWGMM>RU'NMJT*WZ%ZMR3M
QMZQNIGMIMGWN%NZZMNR3K'NZXRW3M@
Q%>WNG/A Z ZRK JT*WZ 7>VJ=VK%]^ % % >RU'NM GWVNE
HLN'G
M%QV % % ZMR3M ZM.IR3KL%MK IWG>M LN'G M% IM IH7>$IH
QMZ Z"$ TW3M *JTHNRV
$ GWN%NZ GWV.W.GN X QV ZMNR3K'NZ
ZM.IR3KQ.GNWK QNIGM QNIGQR(NV7>VJ=VKGNHNR%M.
QI;QN- GNE
H/A
MZNZQLZQ%NIGZXWIVVE
HZM3WRZ
QZZ^9MMZRV3>RWJNJ"MJTZ>XV@
Q%>WNG/A M L
IWGWN%IWQHVK ZNZ Z"%]^ X V(N Q%NIGZ GN
RIM'WNEQR(NVJ>RNV% QLZ L%Z%E"'WNE E
HZM3WTZ RWE
H.
G ZMN% -K3WR QR(NV RW7>aX JTZ3WR %]^ WIVV  LN'GN M" M  7>M

246

) (NR( IUQN% JT H N3 IW3

ZTV3> 3N3VR.%]^MKLN%'WNENQR(NVWG.GQ%>NRIUQN%R=\'WNEN
QZZ^94  QR(NV V=VWGR3K IWGWN% TWJNJ"  ]J^R% JNJ. %^] JTZ=>XV
IWIVTVWR'%G%NEHIM]GNM"QR(NV7MKI3T31KIUQN%WHRZ.GNMK
WR'%HRGNM"QR(NVQIUQN%V
$J^R%R^JV
$Z>HVHRIG]GNM"ILHNR%
V=VWGR3K]VG>QNRNG=KWNVIWHN;%.G QN;NR7>aV *UVKHR%WNE
G RWJNJ%31M
 L.G M%#

UKVN IUQN%GNVN STMZ HNE  GK 7>VJ=VK GN ]HV


QI;/ G E
H  IW=X IHMN M" IH QRL>% ZRK 7>VJ=VK L%Z
%]^ %N V. GWVN LN'G M% %N MK ZMNIR3KL% LN'G M% IH7>$IH I-M
* Z R   V
$  J" G N M
-   M% I-V
$  J^ R ' I= ;  M"  IH ST M Z HNE  GK
7> V J= V K V. M
- K JT ] V ^  G W VN V  IR3K %MK$ LN'G   ILW $  IJVN LK GK
7>VJ=VK %]^ S=X %MK$ G= HG JT]V^ GNGN LK LN'GN M" I-JTHNR I-=HK
STIMZ]Y. G RW GWAIR3K QNIG L
VK I%R]L%ASTMZ QR(NV HNE V(N
JTIHTVK G>RUN  G ]
U %NE 7>VJ]% M
- M% I-E-K HIM IRMN M"
IH ZRK 7>VJ=VK %]^  STIMZ]Y. IW=X H
-K %MK$ LN'GN IH7>$IH *GK
7>VJ=VK ZR V
$ M
-K M" HWE J^R' STMZ MK HNE STMZ  GK 7>VJ=VK
G=   HGN M"   IH7> $ IH ST M Z HNE  GK 7> V J= V K JRZQH3R J> R 3
J^ R 'ST M Z  V
$  M
- K M"   ILGN UKVN LK G  QI;/ G  E
H  
IW= X  ST M ZGK 7> V J= V K GN JT V = \  JT Z N' M"   QI;/ G  E
H   L

V=VWGR3K QR(NV IWGWN% IWQHVK Z"%]^ V(N


V(N HGK %N L%Z E"' WNE
 RW E
H. G ZM3WR QR(NV QIW%N3K JTZNVZN %]^ LN'GN M" 7>M IV]%
WG. IR=UWG NZW G  V(N L> R W G  %] ^  LN'GN M"  7> M  V=VWGR3K ]V
M" 7>G G>QNRN G= *UVK ZNRU V
$ N;%N HR% %NE TW JNJ %31
M
 L.G  M% UKVN LK G  QI;/ E
H   IW= X  WR'% M"  IH
J^ R ' JT Z NVZN QIW%N3K V. M
R  MK M"  L
 IV] %
$  E
H . IW= X  JT W  3  HRH
*GN ;NR'AJ
3' HRGN M" Z"%]^ HNE  %]^ V. HWE I-E-K J>R3
VZ
HIM] G   M% IH7> $ IH Z" $  ST I MZ] Y . IW= X  Z R   Q;K% (^ E  RKR IW= X
%N3WN% JTN'KQ. V(N QIW%N3K LKWQNVZN V
$ 7>VZ M. I-E-K Z"%]^
E
H W G  QR(NV G] V AH(NW. GN QN;NR 7> a V  J> R 3
V Z IHMN M"  JT ] V ^
WNVW IW= X  Z" $  QIW%N3K L. JNE'HRVN %MK$ M. UKVN LK G
QI;/%]+  G E
H  IW=X IHMN M" IH RWLKW Q]% V
$ 7>VJ]% M>]G
M% Q]% WR?N V
$ M>]GN M"  WR?N =U V
$ M>]GK M"  =U 3>*HRZ. V
$
HRZ STMZ V
$ 7>VJ]% M
- STMZ QIW%N3K JTZNVZN V
$ 7>VJ]% M
I-QN
7>MK QIW%N3K RWIWQNJH JTZNVZN MK =U. IW=X JTIV3IPV M" =U.
IW= X  J^ L  M"   8MK = U . GN FE WK IG] G N M"  QR(NV WNVW IW= X
QI;= U  WK 7> M K M" 
IFR UKVN LK G QI;/ G E
H  IW=X IHMN M" IH ZRK 7>VJ=VK
JT * WZ  V. H
- K %MK$ LN'GN I-V
$  I= ;  M"  IH HNE ST M Z  WK
7>VJ]% M
I-QN M" I-E-K I-M IHV V. QNHNR IW=X WK M" %MK$ V.

IUQN% U] U N

247

IHT3% LK V. QRL>% G NMZ' MK \94 % 7>M V. HIM %MK$ HG
IH Z"$ Q%NIG QLZ QL%Z.  M. I-M RW HNE QIGT3 STMZ  MK
3TK IHT3% LK G RKR IW=X LKW( R^J JTVWV JTW3 HRH  IW=X S
EH
QNJ'K JT I V3PN I(VK  GK MK LN'HNRK UKVN R^ J  IW= X  G  IUQN
7>JT
HV IWWT' IW=X UKVN LK IW=X I=; M
I-QN IH STMZ GK 7>VJ=VK
J^R'STMZ V
$ M
-K M" I-MK JTZN' Q(>RWWG H.Y  Q%>/  Z]VR 
IW=X WK M" IHTJN I%Z% J94

H.Y %]+  Q%>WNH %]+  Z]VR /
JT 
 LNU" IWGWN%S];^IWR3WNGWN%.LI%ZNIWWIHVV
STMZ STMZ' 7>L=L*NR Z=;N%%KX"R^X"M W;N QI* JT V(@@
JT A /ALU A IWGWN%AIS] ; ^ M AIW3WNAG W N%NZALI%ZNAIWWIHVA
STMZMASTMZ'MA7>L=L*NRAZ=;NVAI%X"A7>X"MAW;NAQI*MAJTV(
Q%>WNG/A JT RWJT(Z GWN%NZ GWV.W.WSTIMZ]Y.GK LU" 7>VJ=VK
GIUQN%%]^ IWGWN% ILIUQN^*UVGN M L
 S];^M WNVIWHN(K
QR(NV J^R% JTZNVZ. MK QNJ' I%L WH %]^ LI%ZN  *GK 7>VJ=VK HTVN
QNJ' G>QNRN IRL% HKV M
- %]^ IWWIHV  \>G MK PKHA IWVNR J^RWH
G=GNM"IH STMZ'M J^R%JTZNVZN% ZI;NV QNJ'Z=;V
$QR(NV3SG
3HVK V
$ STMZM  STMZA6R J>R3 QR(NV HNE %]^ 7>L=L*NR  7>VJ]% HRH
IW3WN NR]NR%]^QR(NVNRE
H.%]^ 7>X" 7>J=RVE
HQNIG I%X"M
%KX JRSTMZWSTMZNR STIMZ]Y W;N QNJ'K;NR%HR%WNEK QI*M
QNHR3'3HVKV
$ JTV( G
%4.%]^ X]UKVR4.I(VHKVN
*NWQR(/AJ^ R ' JT Z NVZN QNJ'  G> Q NRN RXK I3T 3 1K GN IUQN%
V(N RWQNVZ. GK 7> V J= V K GN IUQN% QNJ'  I%= L K GN %] ^  W" $  MK
MK G=GN M" IH J^R' JTZNVZN % QNJ' Z=; QR(NV QNJ' RKR V
$
QNJ'K 3SG 3HVK G G>QNRN STMZ 6R J>R3AHNE  GK 7>VJVK HKVK
V(N RW STIMZ]Y. G 7>J=R VE
H QE\ E
H QUZ E
H Q%NZK E
H
QNIG V(N %KX JRSTMZ G =V ]\ STIMZ]Y V(N STMZ G  STIMZ]Y. %]^
QNJ'K ;NR' HR% WNEK QNHR3' 3HVK %NE PIMRNI-QN M
I-QN M"
ILW $  J^ R ' JT Z NVZN HSKR JT Z  3 WR HIWRG W  %  QNJ'  I%= L K
WH QR(NV 3\N 3T K  ;RZGN LK QNGR'K- $  URKSGN LK QNIG %] ^
QNJ'  G> Q NRN RXK I3T 3 1K GN IUQN% W" $  MK G= I QN 7> J R
H V W G
Z] V T  WK I-M ZR(% HR IRMN M" 
H.Y %]  Q%>WNH %]  Z]VR /A

 (WR'ZIJVRZGWS];^ZSTIMJIVZ%ZNWXUX6NV
VWZ IW3W3NZ LI%VN (NMHIWRGW
 %G*NVNW;NWN%@
MAQ(TWN'ZAIJVTZAGWS];>ZASTIMJIVZA%ZNAQWAXAUX6NVAVWZ
AIW3W3NZALI%VNA(NAMAHIWRGW4A%AG*NVAW;NWN%
Q%>WNG/A M L
 Q(WT'Z QXEQR(NVQIW%N3K IJVTZ LUVIJVN
GWS];>Z *UV.GNWNVIWHN(KQR(NVQNVZ.GNQN;NR STIMJIVZ
LUVU>R^ X V(N %ZN  IS%ZR J>LNRK QR(NV IW;KW; N;H %]^ QW

248

) (NR( IUQN% JT H N3 IW3

>R=I\QNG %NE UX6NV VE


HU- M
I-Q.%]^ VE
HE" LN'WNEN IW3W
3NZ RWSTIMZ]Y.GK LI%VN RX%NHR%WNENLUG]SNQR(NVZNVNWNE
U>'. V
$ >HV % G*NV  HNE GK VR4. ;
\N % G' WNE B;NWN%  >*NQ
QR(NVU>'.WNEN (N IL7$> GNIV7$> QR(NVW"NMK M 7>M VWZ QNJ
HIWRGWMHIWRAGWM HIWRGWM" QR(NV*N3NI*]%I- HSKRJTZ3WR
WKHIM]G M%
*NWQR(/AI- Z]VR IW=X I-M WK J=31 HR IG=VN M" IH 7> JDZ
T 3
 WR
GN %NZ HIWRGW QR(NV HSKR JTZ3WR M" IL% RWRX%N HKVK M"
L
 JT Z  3 WR QXE QR(NV WNVW IW= X  QIW%N3K UKVN QI;QN-
 E
H A IW=X WK JTZN' M"  LUVU>R^ QNVZ;NR L
 J^R' Z>HV
M
H VE
H U- M% 7>%4. %]^ VE
H E" H LN' WNEN RW STIMZ]Y. GN
RX%MNR HNE ST M Z  GK VR4 .  ;
\ N %N G '  WNEN IL7> $  GN IV7> $  7> M
QNJ HIWRGW QR(NV HSKR JT*^ M" I-MK JTZ3WR RW STIMZ]Y. V
JTN'KQ. %]^ QNJ'K 3SG 3HVK V
$ 7>VJ]% HR% G HNR% LI%VN  ZNVN
WK HIMEN7>$GN M" V(N IJVTZ  IJVN V(N S];^  *N-K WK WNVW IW=X
I-MK M"  V(N G W  JT Z  3 WR WK I-MK M"   I-E-K I-K HIWR G W
HSKR JT Z  3 WR  GK V^ V K HIRQN HRG  M% VWZ W  ZNVN X IJVN
VWZW VWZW S];^ X \N VWZW VWZW RW] ZZ GW GW I-K JTZ
3WR GK ZIMZN GN JIW= V R IR= U W G  Z] Y E %] +  > H V %] +  IW= X
IWVIRV IWWR' M" 
JT 3 %/A
W G . IW= X  HIWR QR(NV HSKR %NZ GN IWWR' IHW $
%/AW
QNI-QNW G  V. I3T 3 1K G  QNR] *  IW= X  JT N JV M
-   % HIWRG W
HSKR JT Z  3 WR  V. ] %   IW= X  7> V J] %  M
-   M%
7>V=R/A
J^R' JTZNVZN GN WNVIWH %NZ HIWRGW M" V(N 7>JZNVZH
/AJ^
%NZ IVJ>R3 JRZ QH3R STMZ J^R' STMZ QNIG M% ILW$ G3 G
JT ; N% Z] V RK LK G  RKR GN %NZ H> 0  M
R  M> ] G N M"  V(N JT ; N%Z] V RK
JT N -KZ IZI%1R QNIG JG G  %NZ M% I-MK J^ R ' JT Z NVZN HIWRG
W %NZQ] V R HRH  XNR
$  > = U . IW= X  QN-  M% V(N I3T 3 1K V  W G . GK
RX%N V
$ J^RW WK Q%NZK Q%Z  E
H IW=X ZN%W >IGT3 RKR IW=X
HIWR GW %NZ %NE IW;ZN% % 7>MK HIWRGW IFR VE
H GK RX%N
HRH VE
H IW=X IWRNLZN% M
 U- VG IJ=6$
 JRSTMZ V(N STMZ G RW
E
H. V WG. GK RX%N HKVK I-E-K WG. IW=X HIWRGW GN IWWR' M"

HSKR NIMS G>QNRN IW*K3' V(N ZG


GRK %^] 3R' IW=X E"'N#
JT Z  3 WR Z> I %] G R Q%E QR(NV %E V(N Q%KE QR(NV %KE %] ^
3R' IW= X  E" '  V
$  7> J R] V  3T K  E] H N IW= X  U-   7> a (  I-= H  JRZ *UV
X] G RIWL"  LK GN 
E 4 .  G=  . GN J> ] % K JIRWNR RIM] G N K 7> M  *N1
LNVK IW=X 7>VJ]% J>]%HRZK JTN'K % JTZ3WR Z>I%]GR HIWRGW  LK
GN 7> J G 3  > ' H  J^ R   JIRWNR %  %NZ GN% JT N JV HKVN JRZ *UV
X]GRIWL" LK GK JV%K *UVZVK HRZWVK E]HN G RNLN RNW' GK RN'K

IUQN% U] U N

249

Z] G
G RK G  H
E  % H RK  W N  HRGK K RN'K Z] G
G RK %] ^  M]  KAZLNH
X] U  A Z] G   X> 1 HE  > ' NH  7>  GN Z] %
R ] L % HRNI-QN HRGK K *UV
X] G RIWL"  RNLN RNW' G  H
E  GRSNR IW= X  % H RK  W N  HRGN K
RNLN GK WIYQN-K G  UN'  > ' NH  JT  ] %  HRGN K
*UV X] G RIWL"  GK JV%K *UVZVK HRZWVK JT Z  3 WR V
$  7> J G 3
JTNJV HR% V
$ 7>JR]V RN'K Z]G
GRK %]^ JT*^ GK XRXN L
 I3T31K RX%N
QNJ'  IVU> R ^ G  W  Z> I %] G R LK V
$  > ' K K JT V KIG% > % N7> '  E= U K
 *UVZVK Z] G
G RK RN'K %] ^  QN%] G  QN7> '  E= U N H-KA [] I 1Q.
V= H  JT * ^  GK IV H(N %] ^  *UVZVK HRZWVK > % N7$> G K RIM] G K V(N
Z]G
GRK GKQ. Q=\. IW=X
$ M]0^ WIM]G RIM]G I-=H IG% RN'K Z]G
GRK %
HRZWVK V
$  J> = I 6QN IH QNJ%  I-M IUQN% IHV
$  > I 'QNQNJ V.
SM>V Q%NJA3%NJ U=E. HIRQN HRGK K I-]%N SGENW JTZNVZN V>E
]V IS%N %MK$ M
 HGN VG HRZWVK % G=IQN IH QK$ I-=H JRZ
] V  V
$  M> '  A  7> J G 3  IEQN M"   RN'K Z] G
G RK %  ] V  G  GR3% GK
QI*EN3N IWQHV HRG M
- IHMN QNJG U>R^ M>' GK SNR QN7>' V.
7>%4. %]^ NY [R S>ENQ H IEQN7>'N QNJ'K ZNEIH% GN QNG3 JTNJV
HRH 3K3 0>HNQ H IVHNR J^RWH IHMN IH I-M L
 QNJGK QNIUQN
QNJGK %HRN%K 7>MK HRUK ZRK I-=H S%VK M" IH HIM]G M% IH ]V
%]^ QNG3 J^RWH %MK$ S>EN7>'N XNMKGN 3W"$ LNH GR3% HR%N 3T31
M]>GN M" V(N ILW$ QNJGK QNIUQN 7>W$ MK M
WUN ZM.RN'K Z]G
GRK %
IHMN IH M>' I-WNR QNJG U>R^GW LK QN7>' V. Z"%]^ G='N Z"$ W"$
GR3% HR.UK JT Z  3 WR %  IFR 3T K  E] H N IW= X  IHT J N HKVK Z] G
G RK
RN'K %  7> J G 3  JT N JV HKVN H> 0  Z $  7> J R] V  QNJ'  IJT    G W R 3T K
*UV IW*K3' LK %^ ]  7> J G 3  IGENN *UVZVK Z] G
G RK 7> J G 3  JT N JV
HRH QMI%T3 JT*^ IZR% IW=X EK% RIM' E=UK QNJ' JVK RNW' %]^
WK IVU> R ^  Z> I %] G R LK V
$  7> J G 3  JT N JV HR% GK JT N (%N HKVK JT ] V ^
RNW' %MK$ Z] I %QN V(N IHMN HRGN K IH Z" $  JRZ3HVK ZM 3 WR
IZT V ] > L "  I3WLK GK *UVK HKVK M"   I-G  V> E  H
- K 3HVK %MK$ M" 
QNJ%] ^  IH  %  SIMHN IEQN M" 
H>0 MK Z$ 7>JR]V S%WN JTNJV 3TK KVN LK GN QJMR' HRH
RNW' % QNJ' %$ E=\N SNU IW=X H"G HR IEQN *UVZVK Z]G
GRK G
SNRA JT N (%N HR% 7> a V  WK RNW' %  ZNVN KVN LK %] ^  WNIJ 6= Y H
QN7>'N WKHNR %MK$ HKVN VG *UVZVK Z]G
GRK LK % QNJ' U>R^ G
W Z> I %] G R LK %] ^  IHMN ZMNRNL LK Z R   JVK %  IHK GK Q R V GN
QJMR' HR IEQN M" ZR V
$ IM' %MK$ M
 IRMN M" 7>M 7>%]^ WNIJ
6=Y H QN7>'N IHK HKZV 7>aV WKHNR %MK$ HR IRMN M" QNJ IGQN
HR
 ZR JT*^ Q=L V=H LKW% IW=X Z"$ QILMN G>=\ %MK$ GI\QN K
JTZ3WR Z>I%]GR LK % IHMN IH S1K Z]G
GRK I-M QRV H
-K QNZ
I-VRK %MK$ M" 3TK IW3'^ LK %^] 3RNJW=3 IJT(WK 7>aV QN7>'N IJQN
M" 7>M 3TK RNLN G3R( G J>=VR RNZX]GR Q
I;QNWNK M% I-%4. %]^

250

) (NR( IUQN% JT H N3 IW3

 NE GN S%WN JT N JV M"  V(N E= H 3ZK LK W" $  KVN R^ J  S'NH
I-GK JV%K R^ J  IW= X  S%WN IW= X  K 7>  %] ^  RNW' I-= H  N;^  * 3
S'NH ;
\N GH 7>PN IEQNI-QN M" 7>M W"$ E=H3ZK MK KVN LK M%
I-%]^ LEGK WNIJ HRH I\ZN NX%N HRH QNJ' LKW% GK I*I\QN
NX%N RNW' HR  V. I-K IW= X  I-GN 3> *  M" 
*UVZVK Z] G
G RK %  Q% H . WNR JT N (%N HR% %NE RNW' %MK$
Z]I%QN V(N IHMN IH 7>M G
 ZHR L]UE IW=X [>]Z' WNE ZRN HK IWUN9
HG M% ZR H
E Q'IU'V "%N M" ZR I-=H E=\ J>=VR V(N WN E=\
%NVK M% ZR J>=VR Z[%N( % WRU G RNLN I-]GR %]^ JRNIL=V HR
7>GK J>=VRK %NE IWQNM HR R=I\QN M" VVK HR
9 GWV.W. %]^ QK$ H"G
HR R=I\QN M" V]^ Z"%^] 7>%.4  G
 SMNRN IFR RM S'WNKQ. %]^ *UWN% G=H
YRN7>'N XNM]>GK M" I- I-VRK %^] WNIJ %MK$ HRNU.
Z] G
G RK %  *UVK ZNRU GN IUQN% L
 QNJ'  J^ L  U> R ^ G  W  V
$
>I'QN K RNW' %]^ SM>V Z0NI-QN IW*K3' % WK QNJ' W=Y *N-K
%]^ Z0NI-QN RNW' % QNJ' *N-K IW*K3' %]^ ZNIRQN V(N IHMN V]^
ILQNGN 3TK RNZX]GR GN J=\JNV HR IRMN M" 7>G H
E MK XEN LN
I-=H IG% *UVZVK Z]G
GRK % QNJ' J^L U>R^GW %^] JTN(%N HKVK IH
M U>RG
^ W
  ZRN >MNU 7>L9 IRMN M" I-=HWNR QNJ WK ZR JVK %]^ Z0N G
W
 L 7>M QNJGK U=E %MK$ Z]%U
 N V. Z"%^] IW;WN M
' GN G>\
=  %MK$ M
WU
 N
QNJ'K S 1 K Z] G
G RK GK JT N (%N WKHNR HRH  RNLN RNW' G
GRSNR G  NMZ'  \94   M
H   G> W NRJNE. %] ^  RNLN RNW' %] ^  IZE' GK
JTN(%N HKVK GWNRJNE. % IHMN IH IR3K LK I- Z$ NY RNLN LK
QNJ'N GRSNR EUN-  M
-   M% I- Z $  Q] G R GN ] G  3  SNMR QN
HGN M" SNMR WNEN ]G3 Q]GR %MK$ LN HGN QK$ SW=3 M. VG
J^ R ' JT Z NVZN Q] V RI;QN% M
-   V(N RNLN RNW' G  GRSNR IW= X  JT U 1
M
 U- RNW' GK IGT31K IR3K 7>aV U-K URL HRH J=>I6QN IH I-M
IR3K %^ ]  Z R K QNIUQN V
$  IS%. IH%  Q] G R QN7> '  IG= V N M"   7>  %] ^
IEQN H ZR NMZ' HVE HR IG7> VG JTZ3WR % IHMN RNL% QNJ
G G>WNRJNE. % 3J=31 Z%4N HKVN K 7>%4. %]^ JVN %MK$ Z"$ IHW$ Q]GR
QN IUQN RNW' %  J> = I 6QN V] ^  Q] G R IHW $  QNI-QN VG J^ R ' JT * ^
Z>>I%]GR *3 IW=X QIGT3 M
H J>%R JTU1 M
 U- V(N IHMN IH Z"$ Q"
QN IUQN RNW' % J>=I6QN IH QN7>' GN HNR' G=
 VG JT*^ % IHMN
QNJ 
;N M
H I-=H QSEN GN QJNMR' HR IEQN- M
 I-M QNJ GK
3N% V  ^ R WKRVN G  IWJRKV M"   7> M  H
- K QNZ Q R V %MK$ M"   7> M
W"$ E=H3ZK LK GN QWVNR M" 3TK RNZX]GR LK L
 I-G JVK M% 7>M
W" $  IW3'^  M% I-%] ^  WNIJ HRH  QNJ'  LKW% GK I*I\QN Z] U

I-  IW= X  QNJGN *EN M"   I-] % N > ' H  VZ
U > '  *UWN% I3W  GN
7> J NH RNW' HT
I ;V M
H   %] U K VEWNR E" H   I] [ N% V
$  IGMN9GN
M
I-QN H>=IGQN V(N 7> %NGN% JTN'K % VEWNR G Q];N ;>]G  WNR
IR3K LK %]^ ZNR% G E-K HKV JTZ3WR Z>I%]GR LK % I-=H 0N9^ GK

IUQN% U] U N

251

K\ M=( IW=X F9K M


-K K 7>%]^ <NE GK VR4. Q=U HR IG=VN RNW'
G WNR 7> %NL>H K\ 7>aV E=U I-VR4. QNWNL M
-K ILW$ E
M G
\]* IJ=ER  7>aV VEWNR E=U RMK M
W K\ 1 V
$ Z %MK$ M
-K
RNW' %]^ JK% QN U- IFR WK 7>M M]HNRW=3 %MK$ Z]I%QN I-M V.
LN' IEQN IH I-M H
-K QNZ IR3K %MK$ M" IHMN IH Z"$ QNJGK I-=H
WK U= E  %MK$ > ' %K QNJ LN HG  M
  JT Z  3 WR Q] V RI;QN% M
 U-
V(N Z]G
GRK %]^ RWIWRV.V >'NH JT(N% HKVN RN'K Z]G
GRK % IHMN
U>R^GW M>' Z"%]^ IW;WN M
' GN H
-K H31 %MK$ M
WUN
3TK RNZX]GR V RNW' GN >=; M
I-QN RNW' GN W; M
I-QN IL
E] H N G  RNL %^ ]  RNW' %  VZ
U > '  *UWN% I3W GK HIP% N;%N HRH 
GWNR 3K3 I%6NWR HRH JTNJV HKVN K 7>M RNW' GN 6I'H >=\ WK
XEN IUQN V(N %RH GN *NUK M
I-QN I-G IWJRKV J^R' JTZNVZN
G IV%NZ N;H IW*K3' %]^ IS%. HP
R N;%N HKV J^R' JT*^ GK IHTJN
%NE E] H NG 3  GN RNL WK JT N JV M
I -QN MLNR. NE. V= H  IW*K3' %
E]HN GN RNL GN >=\ *
IUQN V(N JT*^ IHTJN %NE RNL IW=X J^R' 3.VK
RMK * RN\33 S= > ; K G  IWQHVK IW%N3 %] ^  JT N JV M
 X> = H   %
*UVZVK Z] G
G RK V(N *UV IW*K3' V(N JRZ *UV X] G RIWL"  LK G
JIRWNR G  J^ R    Z" $ SR V(N M
R  IL%4 .  %  J^ R ' JT Z  3 WR GN
GN 7> J G  3
JTNJV HRH QLKW% ZIR
 NGNW=V IV*UVK HKVK 7>M RW N;H I-=(
ZIR
IJT(WK 7>aV WK >=\K RM V(N Q]V Z$ JTZ3WR G IWZN% IW=X S"PH
VE
H  3N3WVZ (N%Z  XE  U-   I-E-K JIW= V R UKVN QI;QN-
 Z]VR  V
$  IW=X IHMN M" IH IV]%
$ U>'. RLU>' STMZN LK VU>'
IW3'^ LK VZU>' I3WLK  GK N;%N V
$ IZE' WNEK 6I'H >IW;NW. G
G>QNRN IL%4. GN IUQN% MIRQN LN X>H
= N M" 7>M RN\33 >*NQ WNE Z%>\
= .
IW=X %KX G>3HRZ HR% WNE Z^R\ Z"%]^ HNEASTMZ  %]^ WK %MK$ *LG
IFR UKVN QI;QN-  Z]VR  IW=X UKVN S
E' WNEN HNEASTMZ
JT*^ HIM IRMN M" IH H
-K I-=H 7>GNR QNVZN ZRK STDMZ GK  MK N;%N
HRGN M"  IH7> $ IH 7> % 4 .  %] ^  V= V WGR3K ] V  %MK$ IZIEQN 7> M  WK % H
QNVZNW. ZRK Q%>VZNZ  QIV Q3T31 UIVZ  Z>HVK GK I(VK IW=X
QN3IRV RIM U-   7> M  WK J^ R ' Z> H V %MK$ M% I-E-K JIW= V R
UKVN QI;/ Z]VR  IW=X IHMN M" IH M QRL>% V]^ RW *NW %NE
7> JTZ3WR J^R' JTZNVZN V=V STMZ  GK 3R' IW=X LN 7>GK IHTJN
%NE MK V] ^  JRZ3.VK V(N VE
H  QR(NV %NV% JRZ;NZ %] ^  JT N JV
M
W  $ UN
I-E-K J>]%QNVZNW. %]^ I%WG% M" IH Q=L I- GN% G WK GN
G  H
E  J^ R ' JT Z NVZN JT N JVK GK WNVIWH IW;K JT N JV M"    I%3> E H
7> J G 3  E" H   EN* 7> P N7> 

GBNJR >=U IW=X I-]GRZVK %]^ 3R' IW=X E"'N


GB N JR> = U  IW= X  X] G RIWL"  %NZ GN I-= H  RNLN K 7>  GK JV%K

252

) (NR( IUQN% JT H N3 IW3

I-] G RZVK SM> V  MK ;NRIZH JT I WRVK GK Q R V K ] V AZMNVZN GN


SM>V QNGR HIRQN HRGK K 7>% I-=H U>R^GW WK S'N R=I\QN K
7>%4. G U>R^GW % G=IQN K IH N;^A]V. GK WN HR%K XNMKGK M"
]V. %]^ *
L% I\EN7>' %NE SM>V EN* M>]GN M" -HNG3K GN WRV Z]VR.
G LNJ QNIG N;%. L
 U>R^GW % G=KQ. M
-KQ. K 7>M *UWV *UVK
IW=X SM>V IGT9VN %NE E=UK M
-K K U>R^GW % G=IQN K IH ]V. %]^
*
L % I\ENI-QN HR $ UK V. Q= U   WK RN'K S' LN- $ UK QV  V" % ] ^  WRU
JT N JV M
W  U K RN'K %  
I XQN IH JT V KIG% I-= H  ] V  %] ^  *
L % LR^ R
I\ENI-QN HR.UK 7>  %  JT I V= I UQN Z% IW= X  PN% E-K IH Z" $  \N'N
SNQG IW=X \NI-QN HR.UK JIME. ]V %]^ \N'N I\ENW.UK I-V
$ Z"%^]
NG S'K RMUK IHV Z"%^] *>=E %N J" LNW RN'K JTVKIG% JIME I-=H ]V
%]^ *
L% I\EN7>$GK IFR W"$ \.GK NE. V=H I-M HRZ X=EGN IRMN
I-= H  Z $  MIRGWNR IW= X  H> ] *  G  Z E   GN ] 
U  M
I -QN IL] %   WK
IVTU>' ZNI-QN G 7>JNH ]V K * U]UN I-%N% G E-K JR*K E"'
G E-K  JT(N% HR U- I- HNR' H-K IG% RN'K %^] *
L% HRN7>'
E-K ]V %MK$ IZIEQN RN'K I-]GRZVK % W"$ WK *
L% %MK$ HKVN
X( IG% QNJ'K S.GK %]^ IHMN IH S.GK G\ E" H
-K ]V IZE LNW V.
%MK$ V. Q=L VRK RN'K LKWV %MK$ RMUK Q=L ZR JTN' I%HE LN'U
JT ] V ^  Z" $  \N'N %MK$ \NW.UK 7> M  GK% IGQNE HSKR JT Z  3 WR QNJ'
J^RW WNE *UV %]^ 3R' IW=X E"' G E-K %N LN' HK HNR' S'N IG]G
M%S.GK %  7> J = R  Q1NRK 7> a V  X= 9 4 H   G I \QN IH NMZ'  V
$  I-= H  ] V
QN IRMN K FG H=J9 K GWNJR >=U IW=X JTZ3WR HSKR HR>'NZ
 %NZ %NE QN-  K S.GK %KX  QN-K QV  RN'K %] ^  IHMN IH I-= H
IWQHVK M" L
 N;^ L"N %LR QN7$GN M" RN'K % IHMN IH LEGK %NE
S>ENQ IEQN S.GK ZIME V
$ SNMR U-K V(N JTN(%N HKVK IH NIMS
QNJ%]^ NYK RN'K % NG HKVN M" HR>'NZ NIMS % IHMN IH RN'K
% Z"%]^ IH7>$ NG HKVN M" ZRN QV RN'K GN HK ]S]; M"%HRN%K %
NRK U= E  G=  K HR> ' NZ   HSKR  NIMS %  IHMN IH RN'K %] ^
QNW3HVN M"  V. I-= (   QN LNW   Z" $  I-= (   \94 N  M. V] ^  S.GK QV  7> M
RN'K Z"$ 7>a( LNW. QV L 7>M HIM G IH QNJ%]^ IH% S>ENI-QN K
L. 7>GN RNLN MK HIM GW QV S1K ]V. GN Q%NGR SM>V JNJGNI-H
M>]GN M" S.GK IFR WNIJ QN-K QV RN'K %^] * WNRVN HIM >'N-K
VG RN'K % IHMN IH S.GK ZRN M=( JH9 7>aV X=E L.G MK RN'K %
G] Y WV JT ' NZ HRH  JT N (%N HKVK IH M  JRWRIGUNRC XNM] > G K V. I-M
M. IH QNJ%] ^  H]; 7>aV ISPN EW. HR>'NZ NIMS % IHMN S1KC Z"$
I-MK G\'N XNM>]GN K IH VR IW=X H
-K 3R;N WK M" L. W" MK *>=\K ZR
RMK M" RN'K % QNJ' M=(K$ \N'N S'NI-QN HR>'NZ R^ J  IW= X  QN-
HIWRG W  %  IHMN IH Z" $  \N'N %MK$ \.GN Z R N RKR \N'N \N' GN
%MK$ M" VG RN'K % IHMN Z"$ WK \N'N %MK$ \NW.UK HR>'NZ NIMS
LK % IHMN IH PKH M" S1K \N'N IEQN7> \N'N \.G M. IH7>$IH ZR(

IUQN% U] U N

253

7>K %]^ HIM]G M% L


 L
 XNM 
 HR HR>'NZ NIMS % \N'N \NQ
IEQN IFR RN'K V
$ J=>I6QN IH L
 V]^ I-M N;%N HR RMK M"$ I-M V"%]^
IH% G=K M" RN'K % IHMN IH ZR U>R^GW % QNG3 IG=VN M" HSKR
NIMS % J>=I6QN HK QNG3 IG=VN M" VR U>R^GW %I-]GRZVK % IHMN
STMZNAIW3'^AZM3 GK J^LN I-HNG3K GN WRV VKR( *TZ' GWK J^LN
3RN; H= < 'N Z] I GR IW= X  LN'N ] V . GK  W N HR%N HR> ' NZ 
HSKR  NIMS % IHMN IH L
 N;%N VR U>R^GW % IG=VK M" V"%]^ L%Z
QV  IZT V ^  V(N WRUA%RH V  X R NK E= \  L^ % KQ. G  H31 V
$  Z> H V
%MK$ M
 HGK RN'K %  IHMN IH ZMNRNL LK IL] %   WK ] V  M%
QNJ'KA JT * ^ V N QNJMK S'N7> '  QN7> $ G  M% Z R   U> R ^ G  W  G  SNR  H> 0
%N HM
U    Z" $  XNM  Z> H V M
W . L. %N M
W .
M>' HR>'NZ HSKR  NIMS 
XG M% IH I- *
E LKW %]^ IHW$
Z0NW. 7>%4. % L
 J^]6 JH9 E-K 7>%]^ 6=Y %MK$ HG ZR HG M%
HR>'NZ NIMS % IHMN IH S1K W" V. VRK I-=6N M" Z"$ I%]GN %MK$ HR
IRMN HK Z"$ QNJG U>R^GW %]^ UNEK IG=VK M" L. S>RN IHMN M"Z"$ V.
*UVKZNRU G= IRMN M. I-M *UVK 3NVR IWR>; M" V"%]^ JNR %MK$
M
' GWUK QV %N MK VRN H
-K QN7>' WNEN HRZ G]Y H=1UN QV >'
E" Q=L V
$ VKR IG% VRK IZTV^ M
 LNWUK %N VRN U>R^ SXN HUN QV
%N VRK I-M %HEK N;%N SXNQ HUK LG ZR% GK SNRK QN7>$GK
M" V. IFR LKW %]^ YR E=UGN M" W" V. %MK$ Z]%G  RN'K % 
IXQN IH
]V 0^P %MK$ S
EG IHV QILMN %N M
 IH Z"$ JR
$ MK ZR LNW. I-
YR %NE HR>'NZ NIMS V
$ J=>I6QN IH ZRK LN% SX HGK M"HSKR
NIMS HR>'NZ  % IHMN IH SX HGK M" LHR V]^ ZR V
$ 7>JG3 EW
$UK ZRK I33 S'UK IJ6EKQ. J^LNW. IVQNU$UK VG VRK LN% SX
UK I-]GRZVK % IHMN Z"$ >I'QN M" IH U>R^GW %MK$ SGE'N XNMKGN
JNJ E=UGN M" HSKR NIMS HR>'NZ  % IHMN %MK$ J>=VRK I-M WK
VRN *TZ M" I-=H W"G YNH1R  V
$ GWN-K %N E=U V. G^R V
$ %MK$ E"$G
 I-=H J]LWK HEN GN QI;QNJH M]>GN M" IFR I-=H 7>X HEN GN
QI;QNJH M>]GN M" S1K QUEK HEN IW=X LN'N M
WUN HK NRK 7>ZR
J]LWK$ HEN IW=X MK E=UK RMUK I-%]^ 6=Y'N JWUN V]^ M>' Q=U GK
J94N-K J94 Z"$ J94N7>' QNI-QN M. W" V. %MK$ Z]%GK JT]V^ IZTV^ IG\'
E=UK IH ]V HIM IRMN M" V. IHV U=E %N IWU9 LNW Q"N IWXNR HRH
I-] G RZVK %  IHMN IH ILW $  QNJ HM
U   Z" $  W"    MK HR.UK HR> ' NZ 
HSKR  NIMS % 7>JG3 IG=VN IHMN IH VKR IG% ZR R^J IW=X HNE
QNWUN V]^ 7>%^] S
E'N ZV L
 Z"$ %NZ IG=VN M" G
 IZ]1 V=H I-GN LNJ
HR%N G
 IZ]1 G SNQG 7>%]^ G\'N 7>G SNQG IVHNR HR%N M"
W" V. U>R^GW QN7>' V. QIV 3K[R XR'. IW=X IUR LN'N XNMK- I-M
ZRN HWE I-WNR QNG3 M" RN'K % IHMN PKH M" LK
M>' RN'K %]^ V. IX]VN S'K M
-K K 3R;N %NE LNJ HR RMK K
HSKR NIMS  HR> ' NZ   NIMS GN R^ J  S'NH  U> R ^ G  W  R^ J  IW= X  HNE

254

) (NR( IUQN% JT H N3 IW3

QNI-QN QNWNL EUN-K I-] G RZVK I-] G RZVK M> '  7>  %] ^  V. JIME.
MK YR K IZR% HRGK RMK K HNE GK VR_ %MK$ GI\QN G
 IZ]1
G SNQG LG GI\QN V. HNE GN WR^J SGE IUQN HNE GN IL7>$ GN
IV7> $  IXMRN IG\N-K G '  E= U N HR> ' NZ   NIMS GN R^ J  %MK$ IRMN
LG HNE % GI\QN IH VRN V. WR^J SGE IUQN 7>M LN' IUQN IH
I-G H
E H
-K 3HVK >HV Z]VR M" I-M HIMH XEN IUQN IH V"%]^
IFR G \ .UN M> '  V. SX U-K RN'K SM> V  \> 3  M
- K F> E K %MK$
ZN-K HGK QNJ'K S.GKQN %]^ HIM' E=UK IH ZRK IZTV^ M
'K K Z
R U>R^GW % Z"%]^ SXNQ IEQN RNLN G H
E U-K V(N IHMN IH Q=L Z
RK IZTV^ M
'K K ZR U>R^GW % R=I\QN HKVK Z"%^] E"' G E-K HNE
QNI-QN K RNLN % IHMN IH V]^ Q" MK YRNZ HRGK RIM]GK M" HNE
QN7>$GN V. HK V"%]^ 6=Y L.GNI-M ]V W" SIMHN IG]G M% M>' I-
U=E %]^ 7>M IHW$ Z]% \>3KA IW=X RN'K E1 U-K H>0 GR G SNQG
=J S'H IFR HNE QNI-QN QV RN'K %]^ Y= IEQN IL7>$ MK =J %
Y=IQN V. RN'K %]^ JVN E=U IUQN RN'K L
R %NE IXEN-K Z"%]^ =J%
Y= IEQN %HR *=L G\G MK G\G I-=H Z
RK JN'K I%HE' GN 6
1N
6 G  IW= X
$  = J  I%= H E IUQN QNJ'  U> R ^ G  W  %] ^  J> H NRH  RN'K S M
3  M

U-K HR>'NZ HSKR NIMS  7>a( JTU1 M


 U- E
H. %]^ IG\N7>' G
E-K Z]VT S
IEQN 7>M V. IS%. Z]VR WK LKWV HR HG M% IH WK
L]VRAZ]VR GK H
-K LR^RV %MK$  I-]GRZVK %]^ LKWV HR IG=VN RN'K
% SM>V 3>HR Z%NI-QN IH M S]GK6
9 L Q=L QNJGK 3R' IW=X %N M>]GK
V. ZRK IZTV^ M
 L.GK NIMS % IHMN IH I-]GRZVK I- HNE %]^ Z"$ V
R [R IW=X [>3' WK %N IG]GN VR 7>J=R I-M MZEN WK %N HRGN JT]V^
V"%]^ IW3WN3 %N M>]GN V]^ I-M 
XGK IH ZR 7>J=R H
-K Z>KSV %MK$
QN7>'K K U>R^ LK % Z"%^] SIMHN H %NZ G IG=VN I-E-K V"%]^ (
94NAN
01HN IG\NI-QN M" %MK$ V. S1K V" % ] ^  IW3WN3 %MK$ M> ] G N
;RZGNM.[%NQ];RNIS%JRXLKWZHNXRN@
HSKR NIMS HR> ' NZ   %  IHMN IH M> '  LG Z" $  XNM^ ] U N VG V
RK IZT V ^  M
W  U K URKSGN LK HIM] G   M%/
URKSHNEYRHRVNRL"L"L"LUGK3LRNLRK0N9VKJURLYNR3K3@

I-M HNE HSKR *UWN% HSKR JT Z  3 WR  V


$  YRGN M"  QV  Z V
HSKR NIMS G L>=V 0N9GK M" QR(NV %HR V>=E M" IFR 7> ;^E %]^
QNJ'  IR 7> a V  EUN7> $ GK M"  IH QNJ IL%] ^  ZNR% GN QNG 3  GW
U 
7>  G  JN LNW.UK %MK$ V. Z" $  %MK$ LNW.UK

URKSHNEL
 JK JK%NLRNM" JI%MNR
G
QEZL^RM"$ZRNIMSHGRSNR@
I-M HNE L
  STIMZ]Y. GN *UWN% STMZ  M" L
 STMZN IW3'^ ZM
3 GN IJVN M" I-M V. ZR HSKR NIMS GN QN1N JKGN M" QR(NV J=HN
%HR M" QV LRN ZV  ZR HSKR NIMS GN JN'K *RGK M" QR(NV I-=H
IW33 %HRN%K M" I-M G
 QE ZL^R ZR NIMS G GRSNR IW=X M% H>0

IUQN% U] U N

255

IG%. G SNQG NIMS IFR QN- RN'K I-]GRZVK %]^ IV%NZ JTGN% HKVN
IFR H>0 Z$ SNQG HR>'NZ NIMS % RN'K I-]GRZVK GK QIV
3R;N G\H NR%NZ IG=VN 3SG GK 7>JE=S;K HRWN-K  LG NIMS
L.G RIM]G K V. I-]GRZVK JTN(%N HIRQN HRGK K IH ZR JVK RNLN
%]^ Z0N7> ZNIEH 7>M WK Z]% LNW QNJ G XR'. IW=X QN LN' V.
ZRN LKW% FE M
 LNW X]GRIWL" %]^ HSKR NIMS % JTN(%N HKVK IH
QNJ WK %NZ E" E7> I-M G
 IG% GN RNL QV PNP M" IFR XRNK E=\
L^ % KQ. IW= X  JT N 'K XEN LN- U N X] G RIWL"  %  IHMN IH *UWN% Z" $  V.
%NZ %MK$ E"$GN QV QNJGK I33 %]^ Z%4N HR.U. %MK$ HSKR NIMS
HR> ' NZ   %  J> = I 6QN QNJ %NZ IH7> $  %MK$ EW
U    X] G RIWL"  RNLN %
IHMN IH Z"$ V. W=YA RNILQ. GK JNR1KQ. IW=X %NZ HK S]%4' HRUN
*N IW= X  LN8 7> a (  HNL^  \N8 G> = ;  JK E8 3RSV L^   JK E8
3RNS ZV JT
U HR
 3RNS JK'N ZM.JNJ M" JT]V^ RNLN %MK$ Z]I%QN
RN'K GK JT N (%N 7> a V  HR> ' NZ   HSKR NIMS  %  RNL  %] ^  IFR
Z0NI-QN IH %NZ G IS%. I-M LKW% IWQR( M
 LNWUN QNJ %NZ
E" E7> RNL % IHMN U>R^ LK Z"%]^ %NZ G E-K %N HIM'N QNJGK I33
%]^ Z"$ Z%4N %MK$ HRNU. XNM IH]%N WK GN% HR IH]%N IV]U HRN-
 NIMS % IHMN IH S1K I- G
 IG% G >=\ %]^ G\H I-GK S=>;K *T31
M
 X> = H K M"   V] ^  JT * ^  G  XR'. IW= X  E= U K RIM QNJ'N QNVZHIEQN'
HRWN I-=( H
-K IH GN JVK %MK$ H
-K IH GK JV%K %MK$ G
 IG%
GN ]S]; M" QNJ'N HRZ S'N S1K LG I-]GRZVK  NE GK SL>RU
M
 L.GK M" IH=(  NE GK 7>ZR IW=X ZR LN'N K LG RKR WK
IM= E ' E= U NVG HR> ' NZ   NIMS S
E   M> '  S
E  I-] G RZVK V] ^  HK XNM> ] G K
M"  X= E 'N XM> ] G K M" $  VE
H  I-] G RZVK %  IHMN NIMS IVQNR M.
ISEH>=E IVQNR M. GNVN HR>'NZ NIMS % IHMN VRK J
V L. J
VK
IW=X H
-K ZZVN V. %MK$ M"RN'K % IHMN ISEH>E %MK$ NIMS QNJ%
IUQN% MK Q"  N I%RZE G  IG= V N I- U] G   E
H  GK HK I-= 6 N HR.
HSKR NIMS HR> ' NZ   LK %  IHMN X= E  S 1 K RN'K JT N ' IVQNU
U-K NIMS HSKR HR>'NZ  RN'K I-]GRZVK GK QNVZN %]^ 7>J=R E"
U- I- STIMZ]Y IW=X I-=H ZN%R
WR M" 7> ZN%R
WR 7>aV LN H
QNVZN %]^ I-%N% HR%N M>]GN M" I- JTN'K %]^ 7>a( NIMS H>0 Z$
V=H R=\G M% M>' J>=6G M% IH IFR G=G VRK H
-K I-=6N M" V. G>>SNRN
L%Z E"'N JWUN LHR Z% IW=X I-=6N RIM U-K V. VE
H %MK$ LN
HGK I-] G RZVK %  IHMN NIMS QNJ V. Q] V RLNZK M
 H
- K I-= 6 N
%MK$ M" QNJG XR'N GK I-=6N M" EIH% Z% IW=X I-=H 3]HN S'K M
-K
M" IH ZRN L
 JVK K 7>% Z"%]^ IHK WK ;NRIZH HRZ IW=X HG Z%4N
%MK$ HKVN %MK$ V. Q= L H= E  G  JVK QNJ'KQ. JV%KQ. %] ^  R
H  IG] G 
M% LHR 7>M Z"%]^ Z%4N HR IG]GN V. Z"$ QNJG XR'. IW=X %MK$ E=U
HGK K Z R N HIEQN' %MK$ M
' N K 7>  GN I- 3> *  HRZ IW= X
IM
U  GN H> 0  EN* IZEGN M"  V. HGK WK 7>   7> J = R  IGQN HR%N

256

) (NR( IUQN% JT H N3 IW3

GNVN M>' NIMS % GI\QN IH I-M %NGN% V. I-G IJ=6 IFR E1H
U-K NIMS S
E PKH M" S1K QL V]^ G
 XNR NE I-=( RIM
M> '  G
 NE IJ= 6
$  RNLN ZR% E= U N IH7> $ IH %NZ %MK$ E"  R= I \QN
K Z G G^V QN- RNLN X$H IW=X X=HR \N H IUR IUQN Z G
G^ V . %  7>  GK URG% %] ^  GSNI-QN RNL  GN 1= 1 K QV  J" 3 NS I%HE
IUQN HR>'NZ HSKR  NIMS % RN'K %]^ IHMN G\ VR RNLN GK HK
MNEV M
 RMK M"7>a(
$ NIMS IG\N RM M% VG RN'K % IHMN IH G
\ IE7> GNVN LHR 7>GN *UVK IW=X IM
U GN H
-K FE S'GN M" V.
IGQN HR IG7>   RN'K GK IFR WK (
9 4 K AILMK ZZVN S'K K HSKR
NIMS HR> ' NZ   %  
I XQN I-M IFR HNEALNE IW= X  F U K I-M

X H  ZN%R
W R V
$  7> a (  U-  IL= (   RNLN X] G RIWL"  QNJ'  ZIME IW= X
QX V  IJQN K ZG^ V  7>  G  JT N ' H= <  RM  % HSKR NIMS G
QN7>' %NE ZG^V I-VR4. QNHN3 IW=X 7>aY U- ILW$ Z>RG 7>V
$ IU=;
7>9 L.G M% X]GRIWL" M
3 IW=X QN IUQN NMZ' HR>'NZ NIMS
\94 K HWE X]GRIWL" %]^ IG\N-K G RM % M
R IH %]^ IG\N-K %MK$
G  RM  % X] G RIWL"  XR'. IW= X  IURH  Z> Q NFK Z] U ' E= U N IH Z" % ] ^
Z>QNF HR IG7> GNVN ZRK LN% SXN7> IH7>$IH 7>% GI\QN IH M>'
VRK LN% LN' WNEK M" LG I- LKW GK Q=\ \>E4GK M" IH I-M V. U=E
IWU9 U-K  Z"%]^ Z>QNF HR G
 GNVN ZRK LN% SXN E7> ZNIEH HSKR
NIMS % IHMN RNLN Q=L WK 7>MK U=E M" 7> IG% WK 7>MK U=E K
%NZ E"'N JWUN RNLN % IHMN %NZ E" EWNU. LK M>'K EWNU. %NZ
HSKR NIMS %  %NZ 7> J G 3  IG= V N V(N IHMN M> '  Z" $  V" % ] ^  G
 NE GK
7> Z R IG] G N M. L  I- IW= X  I-= H  NM WK \NEK XEN IUQN V. IFR
HRZG] Y  RIM LNW U N
HSKRLKW%V
(
9N*ENLV>ZR%M
EN\SRHNLKW%NE\;R%NH
@

3>*HRZ IW=X IM


U IG=VN M
I-QN IJ6EN HRZ QV %NE MK 3R;N
%NE G
 NE G IZR% %NE V(N IV]%
$ %NZ JTGN% HRH HSKR NIMS
X]GRIWL" %]^ WK JNR HR E" U- S
E
IVU>R^ GW HK L L S]GK 6
9#
JTZ3WR HSKR NIMS LK =X 3R;NE^ GK 7>ZR W;N IG]G M% V(N
7>  G  JIRWNR GK WK R= I \QN HRG  M% 7> J R
H V IWWR' %NE I= ;
M
I -QN I-M JT Z N' SM> V  JIME. G  M% WRVZN% IW= X  N;NR%
IWQHVK IW3WN3 %MK$ HRGN WRVZN% IW= X  HSKR NIMS GK 3HVK
GN Z>0 GN G>QNRN M
- H31 I%WNR' V(N 7>ZR W;N7>' G <R NR
JT Z N' J94
  J>  VH JT Z  3 WR GN NR ] G  3 #

JIW=VR J>RN'. GN RM=#


J> R N'. %] ^  Z0' E-K IHT J N I;QN% RM  IH 3T K  ST M ZJ> R N' 3T K
IW3'^ J>RN' V(N 3TK I3WJ>RN' STMZ GK EKE4N V
$ QNR]* M]>G M% IL%^]
JT(Z QIWQHV UKVN QI;/ E
H  IW=X IHMN M" L
 UKVN QI;/
G E
H  IW=X HIM]GN M" IH
IH Z"$ HNE M.# I-%]^ 6RJ>R3 V(N L
VK

IUQN% U] U N

257

I%R] L % WK IHMN L.GN M"   I-MK GNI3W HNER^ J K ST M Z WK HMN7> $ GN
M" I-MK STIMZ]Y IW=X I-=H STMZE
H GK RX%N HRH 7>G 7>JRK IM=
IW= X  RIM] G N M" 
I-MK ZM.IW3'^   ZM.ST M ZN V(N ZM.I3W HIMEN7> $ GN M"  V(N 7> 
\ V R %] ^  HN3K WK HIM] G   M% 7>    IW= X  RL
U > '  JT ; N% VU> '  JT ; N%
VZU> '  JT ; N% IV] %  (N% S'NH  QNJ'K JV%K G> R UN ZM.E= 6 ZK$  %] ^
%NE R= \ H  IV] %  J> = V R. RLU> '  3T K  ST M ZN LK VU> '  3T K  IW3' LK
VZU>' 3TK I3WLK GK 7>VJ=VK HRH QXV HR IG]GN M" QXV QW(N
IW=X MK 7>%4. GN JTWIR3 HRGN RIM]GN M" LWN% M
' V STMZN LK %]^
HZE G F>=E 7>aV 3TK IW3'^ LK %]^ 33 %NU 7>aV V(N 3TK I3W %]^ H"EN3
JRWV 7>aV XV HR IG]GN M" I-%4. IV]%. JT*^Q. %]^ W"$ IUQN% %MK$
IH NYN 7> V J= V K HRVN H '  M"  I-MK HNE R^ J K ST M Z MK IW3'^  R^ J
;NR' HRH QNJ'K %N*K V
$ HZE 7>VJ]% HRH 7> 7>aV 3TK STMZN LK
%]^ R=\H M
3 IW=X HR IG]GN M" 7>M LG XNM 3TK STMZN LK 3TK IW3'^
LK V(N 3TK I3W LK GN R^J ;NR' HRH IGT31KU
XR M]>GN M" 7>M HNE
QNJ' WNVIWH R^J IW=X HG JTU1 %MK$ M]>GN L
 HNE % 3TKZG*NUWV
UKVN LK GN IUQN% IG]G Z$ IG\NI-QN K UKVN QI;QN-  V(N
 IW=X JTZN' M" 3TK ZG*NUWV UKVN QI;QN-  E
H A IW=X
IHMN M" M QRL>% I-M ZRN WNVIWH HNE R^J VR V
$ QIVIRHV %N
V. JIME. IH % GI\QN M" V(N %N MK Q=U H
-K G\ HGN M" I-M
V. Z"$ VR 7>J=R Q%>UTIM HRH IG\NI-QN M" I-M Z>0 STMZ GN MLNR
*^LNW. V %VT. QNIG WNEN HNE R^J WG. IW=X WRI'V IW;K %NE ILW
$ = U  8Z %NZ G  LNJ QNIG %NE HG  %MK$ G I \QN LN HGN
*NWQR( M"  IH W G . IW= X  WRI'V IW;K V
$  JT * ^  JT N JVK %MK$ M" 
I-E-K IR3KQ.AZM.IR3KQ. % WG. IW=X 8Z
8Z %NZ %]^ JT*^ JTNJVK GN
LN'H JT*^ JTNJVK G E-K =U V(N 8Z %NZ G LNJ GK [
R N;%NW.
HKVKQ. JT]V^ STMZ# G GR3% %MK$ M
- IH % HZE. GN JTHN3 G
\ IEQN IH % RKR IW=X L
VK G\K V(N IH % ;>]%. >'K L
 HNE
ST M Z  GN 6E M"   IH A  %  M]  GE HZE GK I-= H  MLNR L
V KQ.
IW= X
$  I%HE IRMN JT H N3 G \ H  JT * ^  GK JT N JVK Z] %  E-K ILW $  IH
(N% 7>aV I-=H MK R]U G MLNR S=ES I-=HAG^L G %NE EUNH "a1 HR
U
E NHNR IW= X  LUN R= \   M
'  G^ R
$  G \ ' WNE  %] ^  I-= H  JT H N3 Z^ M  MK
IG\N-K IG]GN M" QIVI%=H1 LN' 7>aV JVN E=UGN M" IH I-M V. S=ES.
EN1^ Q .  GN JT H N3 M" 
I- JTHNR H>0 N;H MP
U HRH RKR IW=X Q]VRZ>=\ M
H H>0
QNIV3SNLK %]^ G\H JT*^ JTNJVK Z]% E"G M% 7>K HNE LNE %]^ QN%]G
Z] % H  QNJ'N Q%Z
E  LKW% %31 HR L.G  M% W G . IW= X  J= 3 1
IEI\QN M"  IH JT Z  3 WR IMRKR M"   L> R W G  QI;QN-   Z] V R 
V(N QI;QN-   Z] V R  IW= X  JT Z N' M" A
QU% V%>RQIIW'W VWN
ZV%>RQI

258

) (NR( IUQN% JT H N3 IW3

ILGN 3SGQR( M"  IHA/JT Z  3 WR IMRKR M"   7>   RWJNE'


HRVN QZR J> R 3 IVJ> R 3  GN RKR M"  QR(NV JT Z  3 WR QNHNR
IW=X M" I-E-K IR3KQ. % JT*^ GR3% G E-K [
R N;%. HKVKQ.
JT]V^ WG. IW=X WRI'V IW;K V
$ JT*^ JTNJVK %MK$ M
 HGK I-E-K Q=L
V=H RW N;H.IR3KQ. QNIG % QNJ' Q%>*W GK J>VH. GK RX%.
HR IG=VK L
 WG IUQN% IWR>=; M" M>' NRN
NRN *UVZNL JIW=VR WG. G
(N% 7>aV M
R ZM.IR3KQ. L. ]V. G Q%>*W V
$ S'K J>VH. G IUQN%
7>aV QN;NIRV M
 X>=HN M"
JIW= V R W G . V(N 3T K ZG*NUWV UKVN LK GN IUQN%GNVN ST M Z
HIM IRMN M"  IH IV] %
$  U> '  RLU> '  ST M ZN LK VU> '  IW3'^  LK V(N
VZU>' I3WLK  I-31 R^J IW=X J^LN G 
U %MK$ M% IH7>$IH I-M WK
%N3WN% M% V(N HRZ GN FE IL7> $  GN IV7> $  IG] G   M% JNJ I\Z.
%N3  %MK$ HR HG   I-%4 .  G  J^ L NRK *UV. %] ^  JT N RS= ;  IW= X  IE\
H31. %] ^  *
U 'N MK J" $ GN M"   I-%4 .  IV] % . JT * ^ Q . GK N;%N V
$  6I'H
]NIRH >=\ V. JTNJV M
 L.G M% JT]V^ J^R' Z
H3 %MK$ M]>GN V(N I-%4.
IV] % . JT * ^ Q . 3T K  ST M ZN LK 3T K  IW3'^  LK 3T K  I3WLK  V
$  IZE' WNE
6I'H EN* 7>aV IL%4. GK QN(N S'K M" 7>M RN\33 >*NQ %^] ;NR'
HKV M
- M% Z%>=\. IW=X
$ %KX G>3HTZ HR% WNE Z^R\ Z"%]^ HNEASTMZ
%^ ]  WK %MK$ *LG   JT Z N' 3T K ZG *NUWV UKVN QI;/ E
H  A
V=H  IH7>$IH STMZ N;H ILQNGN Z$ V=H STMZE
H IW=X S' ZM.WRU
IW=X QNJ'K %NZ V J>]% GK HZN-K G QN;NR 7>aV RIM]GN M" I-E-K
HNE HIM IRMN M" IH IV]%
$ JT*^Q. V
$ H>0 I,QNGN RNMV Z"$ G HGN
M. JT ] V ^  I-M ST M ZE
H  V(N HNE ST M Z  WK %N3WN% M% UKVN
QI;/ E
H  IW=X IHMN M" STMZE
H V=H RW E
H %N3WN% M% V(N
UKVN QI;/ E
H  V(N QI;/ E
H  IW=X W"$ UKVN IUQN%GNVN
ST M Z HIM IRMN M"  Z R K WK L%ZAIZT V ^  M> ] G K M"  QR(NV %N3WN% M.
I-E-K JIW=VR UKVN QI;/ E
H  IW=X IHMN M" X( JTHNR G Z
R STMZG  N;H L
 IUQN%K M% 7>M WG. G IUQN% G QN;NR 7>aV
LN' E" $ G  M% IH H W E I-= H  MK J^ R ' JT Z NVZN MK I-31 G  R^ J  IW= X
J^L M" 7>MK JNJ%N3H J^R' Z
H3 GNI-H M" V(N ZN%W RKR JT*^
JTNJVK G E-K MK IZIEQN M" 7>%4. % WG. GN W"$ MK I%3HR3 H=<
IEQN IH 8Z# I-MK I-=H Z]VT M" L
 JT*^ JTNJVK GN M" I-K 8Z# Z]VT
G LNJ %NE MLNR. NE N;%. HRH QNJ' RKR %]^ WK I%3NWR HR
IG=VN JT]V^ JT*^ GR3% %MK$ M
- M
R 7>JE=*;KQ. M
 U-K H>0 I=;KQN
JT N JV M
 U-KQ. V(N WRUAZM.WRU QNIG IW= X  7> X  JG JT N JV M

U-   I_R *L% HZN-K V(N J> ] % . GK HZN-K ZNJV M


'  7> a V  J> % R
L%ZAIZTV^ V(N XRNK E=\ JTN'KQ. G RKR. IW=X [
R H31 V(N %RH
IW= X  JNJ HRZ GN FE *
U  WK SI'QN IRMN
JIW=VR L>RWG QI;/ Z]VR  V(N JIW=VR UKVN QI;/ Z]VT
 IW=X 7>JR
HV G
%4
$ 3NVR. GN IUQN%GNVN STMZ HIM IRMN M" IH

IUQN% U] U N

259

7> J^R' JTZNVZN G IW3 IW=X Z"$ HNE R^JK STMZ  %MK$ LN'GN 7>
JTZ3WR G IW3" IW=X J^R' LN'HNRK QR(NV V=VWIUQN% V(N 7> JTZ
3WR GK JT N JVK GK IW;K QR(NV J^ R ' Z
H 3 ZNRU GK LN'HNRK G
E-K V=VWGR3K ]V GK \
L HR IFR 7>M ILW$ N;%. G=' W" HR
7>G SNQG 7> JRZJG JTZ3WR GK \
L HR%K XNMKGK M" IL IW=X
U- M
- N;H IFR WNJ ]NR IW=X %MK$ QN7>$G QR(NV J^R' Z
H3
JT N JV HRH  GN G  E-K L%ZAIZT V ^  V(N X R NK E= \  L^ % KQ. G  H31
V(N %RH GK JK94N G H31 V
$ Z>HV M
 L.G M% V(N J^R' 3.VK JTNJV
HRH 3N3WV (N%Z  QIW%N3K E
H QR(NV VE
H %]^ JTNJV M
 L.G
M% JTZN' UKVN QI;/ E
H A V(N UKVN QI;/ E
H  V(N
IR= U W G  Z] Y E  > H V  Z] V R A 
V=VWGR3K ]V G %N IZE' G HNR' RW IR3KL% WG. Q%>NR
N;%. HRH  WK ZM.H31 IW= X  MK RIM L.G  M% I-E-K UKVN
QI;/ E
H  IW=X IHMN M" IH L
 IUQN%K QNVZN M% 7>M M% V.
7> G NR IH7> $ IH JT * ^  JT N JVK G  E-K V%AZ%A;% %NE W G . Q%>  NR
N;%. HRG  M% JT ] V ^  7> M  WK Z" % ] ^  HNE  ST M Z GK Q%> V ZNZ
QIV[1KQN UVK QR(NV N;%. V
$  IZE' WNE  EN* 7> a V  MK QN3IRV
M% ILV
$  I-%4 .  GN J^ R ' Z
H 3 %MK$ M
 HGN L%ZAIZT V ^  V(N M
R
JT N 'KQ. G  RKR IW= X  V(N %RH IW= X  HT Z QN;NR 7> a V  H31 HG
ZNJV %MK$ M
 HGN
L
VK I%R]L% HNE R^JK STMZ  % HZ\N;K M" IH Z"$ HG WK IHK
%] ^  IH  WK N;%. %NE QNJ'  WNVIWH HNER^ J  IW= X  GR3% %MK$ G
W.UN I-E-K I-MK HNE R^JK STMZ MK QNJ' J=>VR. STMZN IW3'^
ZM3  G R^J IW=X IG\N-K GH M
R XIR=VR HRGN M" IL HNR% %NE
M
R L% 
XG M% IH I-M EKE4N *UWN% IW3'^ % HKVK HG HIM]G M%
IH I-M EKE4N 3TK STMZN % HKVK HG HIM]G M% IH I-M EKE4N 3TK I3W
% HKVK ILW$ QNZ IWQHVK HIM]GN M" IH 3TK STMZN LK GK 7>VJ=VK 3TK
IW3'^ LK G %N*K HZE V
$ M
-K 7> Z$ 3TK IW3'^ LK G R^J IW=X HNE
%  QNJ'K %N*K V
$  HZE JT U 1 HKVN K
STMZN J>RN' I3T31K GN WR'% %NZH QI;QN-  IW=X 3TK E
ZMR3'
IR3K IL%] ^  ^ V  LK WK IHMN L.GN M"  %  QNJ'  U> R ^ G  W  3T K  IWQN
IR3K V
$  > I 'QN IUQN% IHMN M"   3T K  IWQN LK %  3T K  %NRG LK V
$
> I 'QN V(N 3T K  %NRG LK %  QNJ'  IJVN 3T K  ST M ZN LK V
$  LN'HNRK
JT N JV HKVK K 3T K  ST M ZN LK %] ^ >  W" $  IUQN% %MK$ Z" $  IH= (
$  7> V J] %
M
I-QN 3TK GWK ZM.J>R'  H]G  I-GN *NWQR( I-M %MK$ M" IH
J>RN'. GN IUQN% UEV M" L
 IUQN% 3TK STMZN LK % M
3 IW=X QN7>'
V
$ IJ=6
$ IHMN M" 7>M 7>K VR V=H V. MK M" JT]V^ XV M
' %NE
J^ R W GN IUQN% G] V  H(N E
H W G  M"   L
 J^ R ' JT Z  3 WR %  JT ( Z
V= > U  IW= X  IV> H IRV %NZ %NE JT U 1 M
H   V= V WGR3K ] V  R^ J  IW= X
V=VWIUQN% V(N WNVIWH I3T31K RX%N GN IUQN% 3TK STMZN LK V(N

260

) (NR( IUQN% JT H N3 IW3

Z]%^ LK QNIG %]^ IG=VN K 7>%4. % >'H Q%>I'QN HR IG=VN K VG
IJ=6
$ LG 3TDK STMZN LK V
$ I- G W]3L J>=6' E=U V. 7> >' >'N-
IUQN% G  QN;NR 7> a V  H> 0  IZENW1 HRH  J^ R W GN IUQN% IHMN M" 
IL HNR' H
- K J> R N' I%R'NI-H IUQN% > H V %MK$ M"   IHK J> R N'
G QN;NR V
$ I=; M>]GN M" IH 3TK IW3'^ LK GK 7>VJVK 3TK STMZN LK V
$
M
-K IHK J>RN' V
$ I=; M>]GN M" IH 3TK STMZ. LK GK 7>VJVK 3TK IW3'^
LK V
$ M
-K QNIGA I- HNR' * IR3KL% V(N STMZN IW3'^ V(N
I3WLK WK 3= H  IW= X  MK M%

3TK STMZN LK V(N 3TK IW3'^ LK GN >=;#


  3TK I3W J>RN' IW;3WR ]IMVN QI;QN-  Q%>WNGH GK% IGQNE
3RZN JT H N3H RNZNI-' JT " a  Z] > S -K JT 3 1  V(N ] J NGH J] I YV
RNZEU% J.Y IW3NRG# JT H N3H NIW= V R PNH> R  JT H N3% R= ( NVRN
WNRN'KST . XA%N1K I-ZEK WNRN'K G  IW; 3 WR ] I MVN QI;QN-  
JT 3 P  V(N 1KHNHNR YN+ ST M ZN%] G  IVT J NPK NIMV QN> R W I GH
L
I V3 QXNRKQN Q" Z +-   JK+Q" a X+YK+ YK+Q"  + K+- +  JT H N3H
X
\ ] S N ]  IHT V  JT I V3PN%  ^ + - + LWNMR %UR S] U E
 R
Y  IG= E K
]  IHT V  IMV I3W J> R N' G  IW; 3 WR IMVN QI;/ JT 3 P  V 
   3TK STMZN LK 3TK IW3'^ LK G H
E QN- 7> Z$ 3TK IW3'^ LK
E=H3ZK IMV 33%NU GK 6, 7>aV 
- M
- % %NE MK Q%>XR WK
S"P % 3TK STMZN LK % 3TK IW3'^ LK %]^ IHMN S1N 7>aP G\ VRN SNJ
QNI-QN M. Z"$ VRN JT*^ M. I- 7>aV IW3'^ LK % IHMN QN8 S"P

Z"$ VRN IJVN M. VRN Z>=\ 1<N IH7>$ M


 IUQN STMZN LK % IHMN M
J>=VRC M>' V"%]^ QI*ZN% M
 IUQN M" Z"$ VRN R]H3H MK %MK$ M. JT]V^
ZV LUV GN IJVN M. 3T K  IW3'^  LK %  IHMN R  X
R C V] ^  QNJ'N
W=YNJ% HK IG\N7>$GN M"$RW LUV V. ZR IW=X I%WN HRGN M" V]^
ZRK %N*K HZE V
$ 7>VJ]% M
I-QN V(N ZR %NE MK Q"K U=EN HR IRMN
M"$ I-]%N HIMH G
%4
$ JT*^ QNJ IW=X MI(QNR. %NE E94% E=U I-=HAG^R
G WH3 (E 7>aV QN[NV HKV I-M G\H GNI3W HNE R^JK STMZ  %
I-=H VL
Z-K IE]U 7>%4. G
%4. G Z=; \94N HR IG= V N VG 7> % 4 .  GN > = ;
ZNJV M
I -QN I-M 7> J R
H V IWWR' UKVNJT " a  U
R \J> > R  WNEK
I3WJ>RN' V
$ H=< R=I\QN M" JT]V^ Z^E ]IHTV IMV L
 7>J=R IE\K M"
V(N
V(N JT H N3H. WNEK I3WJ> R N' IW= X  MK M" 
V(N M
R  G
 ] J NGH. V(N
   IWXNR HR
/A3TK I3WJ>RN' 3TK IW3'^ J>RN' V(N 3TK STMZJ>RN' V(N
3TK GWK ZM.J>RN' IW=X IV]% JT*^Q. V(N GNI3W HNE R^JK STMZ  V(N
G W K I3WNAJT I HT V K  GK LKW% EKE4 N  M% I-%4 .  G  QN;NR %^ ]  NR
IR3KL% W U>R^L% IUQN% >'NI-QN HRG % L H
-K JIW=VR J>RN'N
V
$  I*] %  IUQN% HIM] G N M"  7> M  JNPHRZ G  IWR> = ;  IUQN% M
'  HRH
IWQR( M" 

IUQN% U] U N

261

   7>JR
HV >=; GN IWWR' JIW=VR I3WJ>RN' V
$ M" IL IW=X G
%4
$ JT*^
J]L NE G S=IXQ. GK VR4. 0U9 RM M% 7>M HIM RM % V]^ ZRN S
1N G^LN HIM]GN M" V]^ ZRN S1N Z"$ VRN SNJ IFR I-=HAG^L GN IUR
SN% F9H  Z> = H   V  E= V . %NE 0U9N HRG  M% I-MK XIR= V R IVT E
H K
%N(. GN M" 
   7>JR
HV IV]%
$ J>RN'. 3TK STMZNJ>RN' 3TK IW3'^J>RN' V(N 3TK I3W
J>RN'  GN QNR]* GN HNE R^JK STMZ QR(NV L
VK I%R]L% V
$ MK M]>GN M"
L
 ST M ZE
H  IW= X  ZM.ST M ZN ZM.IW3'^  V(N ZM.I3W R^ J  ;NR' HRH
RIM] G N M"  V(N QNJ'K EKE4 N  WK 7> J R
H V R^ J  IW= X  HRGN M"   QNJ'
WNVIWH HNE R^J %]^ 6>JNH R=\GN M" V(N SNQG IW=X IWWR' RLU>'
STMZNLK VU>' IW3'^LK V(N VZU>' I3WLK GK EKE4N GN M" 7>JR
HV
IUQN% G QN;NR 7>aV JIW=VR J>RN'. %]^ Z0'N QIV QNN% M
 LN-UN

3TK IW3'^ J>RN'#

Q%> W NGH 3T K  Z> % KENE U> J V JT H N3HAU


I W] G  *W% HNRNE
UKVNJT "   U
R \J> R
3TK IW3'^ J>RN' GN IUQN% 3TK JNRNR IR3K % QNJ' I33 3TK
Z"VT IR3K LK %]^ IHMN M"
3TK JNRNR IR3K LK % 3NGK M>]G MK [R IVQNUH W' IW=X N;%N
HR% GN IGT 9  ] H EJ HKVN 7>  GK ;RZJV%K %  IHMN M> '   V. 3NGK
M
-K M" M>' QNJ [R IVQNUH LN RM M
 ]VN% 7>VJVK HRH IFR
N;%N E-K LN'N VG 3TK JNRNR IR3K % IHMN IH N;%N HR% V
$
IJ=6
$ ]VN% 7>VJ]% HR% %NE %H ]HNR GK ]VN% 7>VJ]% M
WUK Z"$
H>0 Z$ SNQG QNJG E-K QNJ'K 3HVK WKR,  IHK J]6K G>QNRN *
L GWNU. QNJ 7>  %] ^  UT I M' HR E" ' N I-M HIMH  [R IVQNUH
WN'JT( M
IUQN I-=H NE N;%N V
$ SNQG QNJ'N WKR, H=<H I-=H
R>=\ G J=V IW=X S]G HRH QNJ'K Z]VT 3HVK %NE 3>HRN'^ RH3N HRH
I-=H H. %]^ IHMN I-M J=VN ZRK JV%K %]^ GH QN7> H. 7>%]^ E" GIRQN
G 7>aJR
$ 7>IYQN LN IRMN K 7>GK X]>0 IW=X
$ 7>M J=VN GIRQN IW=X
IUR IUQN 7>  %] ^  I-H Z6EK %  \N IEQN H> 0  ZMK%  SNQG 7> 
Z6EK %] ^  I-= H  ZENM %  F9H  H= I 1QN 7>   IW= X
$  I-= H  E9HK I%HEK
ZENM % E9HK GN %NZ IVQNWVK R=I\QN 7>MK E9HK Z=6K G 7>GR
7> V J] %  M
' G  HNR%  Z6
G RK %NZ %NE WK LN'K L.GK K %NIWH %
IVQNWVK %] ^  QNJ'K J= > V RK R^ J X JNIEQN
H. %  WNJ LN H  JNRNR LK %] ^  RW IWRV.V G= I QN LG
N;%N ZNJV HRH 3TK JNRNR LK  NE 7>JR]V WNJ QN RM %
GIRQN JNR HR% E-K ZENM %]^ J>HNRH IHMN IH Z"%^] LEGK GIRQN G
JNR HR ZRK JV%K ZRK JTVKH3N HR RMK M" 7> Z$ ZENM \N'N
\N IRMN K V(N 3TK JNRN>R IR3K G SK, V
$ Z6EK V
$ 7>VJ]% NE
GK LWN% H] I %QN QNJ'  IJVN GN \N'N E"  H  7> a (  MK 7> J I(V K

262

) (NR( IUQN% JT H N3 IW3

ZENM %]^ IUQN% K IH N;%. VJ=IQN HRH QN7>' WNEN IR3K I=;K
> H V M> ] G N M"   QNIUQN GN LEGK JNE'N %N HR% G  HNR% 3RNJ G
IG] G N M"   ZENM %  IHMN IR3KWR Z" $  \N'N \N IRMN M. Q= ; ^ R N \N'N
6=Y'N Q]% GW GN QJZN% M]>GN M" Z"%]^ JNJ E=UUN JT]V^ 3TK JNRNR
% I-=H WK %MK$ >'K IR3K %]^ QIV 7>VNWEN LN'H ZENM % QNJ'K
LWN% J> = V RK %] ^  IR3K LK %] ^  JNR 6= Y ' %^ ]  IHMN IJVN LK GN QNG 3
JTNJV HR J>=VRK %HN IW=X IR3K JNRNR LK %]^ E" H X=E J-K GIRQN
G Z=; LN' V
$ SNQG IR3K JNRNR LK % QNJ'K MK SKL 3HVK %NE
Z=6EK V
$ 7>VJ]% QR(NV QNJ'K MK J>=VRK %NE G>3HRZ HR% GK I-=6N
IWQHV HKVK E9HK WK QNJ' JNEH IJVN ZENM V
$ IR3KQN G HT
;
%NE IG= V   3RNJ V
$  G> = \ K IWQHVKQ. GKQ. H(NW. > I 'QN HRGK K
3RNJ G YR %NE H]SGK M
-K H]I%QN % IHMN IR3K LK QNJ STNMZ' M

Z" $  I-= H  3^ G R GK J> = V RK M. IR3K JNRNR %  IHMN IH H
- K IX] V N
%MK$ E9HK %  QNJ'K I-= L V R= I \QN E-K I_R I-= H  SMN%N HKVN IH
M  IR3KWR Z R   RKR V
$  Z= 6 EK GK G> R U] ;  I%HE RMK M"   IR3K
JNRNR LK % QNJ'K I=;K 3HVK %NE G>RU]; ZNJV HR IG=VK IFR
E9HK %  IHMN G
%
4 $  IH%NIRQ. 7> a V  IWQHVK G \  RM  M% IR3K
JNRNR LK % U]UN GIRQN GN LE M=( IW=X X>=HH QNHN3 W=E >=I1QN
V(N QNJ'K I= ; K 3HVK %NE ;> ] ;  7> V J] %  HR IG= V K QNJ'N Z%
R (
J^RN HKVN E9HK % QNJ' JNEH IJVN %]^ QNJ'K ZNVN G ZNI;QZ V
$
NRK [1%N V
$ QWUV HRN IG=VN V(N G=IQN IH IR3K % QNJ'N %NZ
JNRNR G= I QN V(N IR3K WI33P LK GN J
V RN J
V N  G= I QN K
Z $  QN7> '  7> a V  H> Q NRK G  UR* IW= X
$  IWQN IR3K 7> V J] %  M
-  
7>K 3TK JNRNR G>QNRN 3TK IW3'^ J>RN' LK GK RX%N M
-K 3TK
JNRNR LK % G=IQN IH M Z"VR L
 IUQN% Z"$ V"%]^ >%N7>' LN IRMN
M. I-MK JT]U GH3QNIG Z>%KQ. % %TZGN V=1 7>aV RNLN J>R^H>V %]^
>'NI-QN K J>R^H>V % NRWV %]^ V(N NRWV % Z"%]^ IHMN K
3TK JNRNR LK % 3TK IW3'^ J>RN' G JT(Z QI;/ E
H ]I\/ JT3P
] I \/ IW= X  IHMN M"  IH I-M LUV IW3'^  V
$  7> V J] %  M
I -QN M"   7> % 4 .
IW= X  I(V M"   7> M K I-GK I(VK V(N E" Q  G  HRVN M% QI;/
E
H  A JT 3 P  IW= X  IHMN M"  IH M  IGB L C JT S T M Z GN JT ( Z R^ J
J>R3 QR(NV *UWN% ILMN E=UGN M" JT]V^ IWQHV ZM.IW3'^ R^J IW=X
JT U 1 M
' N  V(N QIWQHV QIGT 3  R^ J  IW= X  WNVIWH HNE R^ J  IW= X
W$ STIMZ]Y IW=X RIM'N  7>G M
R R^J M% V(N HNE# 7>GN JRZ
R^ J  M"   *UWN% IW3'^  L
 HNE R^ J  IW= X  IWQHV V(N QIWQHV R^ J
IW=X I(V M>]G M% 7>M 7>%4. GK SNEWV EKE4N M"
QI;/ E
H  JT3P  IW=X IHMN M"A M Z"VTC JTE HNE IW=X
JT ; N% QR(NV JT I HT V K G  NZ QW(N IW= X  I(V M
 LN' 7> a V
QR(NV J>R3 G JTIHRVK %NE JT(H I(VK M
 LN' 7>aV IW3'^ *UWN%
GN HNE R^J JTWRV M]>GN M"

IUQN% U] U N

263

QI;/ / A JT 3 P A/VGQ] V R RUHNE 7> J I(V M


'
7> a V  7>   JRST M Z JT Z NVZN IW3W R^ J  RWIWQNJK RW*^ V  3 WR
RWQNVZN JT Z  3 WR %  QNJ'K I-= 6 N V
$  IWHNRK JT ; N% QV  QIWHNRK
J> R 3 IW= X  JT I W31 M
H   7> % 4 .  %] ^  33
I *V HKVN@A@IL JT H NR
IHT Q N3KE % M
'  7> a V  WK U] ;  QNJ'K ] I %] I ; ZNVR V
$  MK JT ; N% W
QIWHNRK J> R > 3  %] ^  JT  I RV HRG  M%
IW33/AE
H ]+ A IW=X J=31 HKVN M" IH JTIHTVK G>RUN
V(N
V(N J> R > 3  HNEAJT * ^  V
$  IS%. H
- K M
R  JT Z  3 WR M"  L
 I-%4 .  G
% 4 .  %] ^
J> % R I3T 3 1K RX%N G  E-K JT  I RV HRGN M" 
QI;/ JT 3 P  7> a V  E
H   IW= X  IEI\QN M"  7> M K JT * ^  IW3'^
I3T 3 1N ST M ZN  M
H   QNJ'K I3T 3 1K HRG  M% E
H  ] I \QN IW= X
IEI\QN M"   *UWN% IW3'^  MK ST M ZN QNIG QW(NW. G> Q NRN RX%
WNE  M% 7> M K RX  L.G  M% V(N W" $  MK M] V  QR(NV ZRG  M%
QI;/ E
H  JT3P  7>aV IEI\QN M" IH H
-K M
R JTZ3WR M" L

ST M ZNIW3'^  I3W QNIG -K3WR. G  WK -K3WR M% QI;/ E


H
A   JT 3 P   7> a V  IEI\QN M"   IJT ( WK S
E KAM  HNE
WR^JC QNJ%]^ %ZHNR M" M JT*^C QNJ MK LUV GK I3T31K QNIG G
E-K STMZN IW3'^ QV R>GR R^J ;NR' HR% WNE M"$ QNJGN L
 R^J
QWVNR R^J IW=X JTU1 M>]GN M" 7> GK GWU' J^LN HRG M% QNJ MK
Q $ HNR M
  QI;/ E
H   JT 3 P  7> a V  IEI\QN M" A IFR 7> 
*UWN% MIR % RL
U>' >HV M
H XV>RZ=\ ;NRK STMZN R^J ;NR' HRH
I3T 3 1K GK RX%N HKVK
7> J R
H V IWWR' V
$  I= ;  M
I -QN IH IR3K JNRNR LK %  > I 'QN
> ' NI-QN IUQN% QR(NV E
H W G  G  QN;NR 7> a V  3T K  IW3'^  J> R N' GK
RX%N HKVK M"   IH7> $ IH WNVIWH IUQN% J^ R ' JT Z NVZN %  JT ( Z
V>=U IW=X W"$ JTU1 M
H 3TK STMZN LK %]^ IG=VN K 3TK STMZN LK %
H>0 IUQN% V(N H>0 HNEJI%H IUQN% QNJ' W]3LN %^] G=IQN I-=H
G^R V
$ >'GA>'.G MK E
HWG 3TK JNRNR LK %]^ JTDNJV M
I-QN 3TK
JNRNR LK %  IW3'^  %] ^  HNE WK IHMN M"  V(N JRST M Z WK IHMN M" 
7> J R
H V IWWR' V
$  I-M WK I= ;  M
I -QN IH IW3'^  QR(NV ST M Z
WR^ J  HNE QNJ'K 7> V J= V K ST M ZN IW3'^  V(N I3W R^ J  IW= X  HRH
I3T31K 7>VJ]% HRG M% STMZ HNE  MK STMZ E
H IW=X IV]% R^J IW=X
JT U 1 M
H   EKE4 N  HRH  6E HRGN M"   7> a (  W" $  WK ZRGN M"  IW3 3
LN'HNRK G  E-K IHTJN J94
 JTE GK LN'HNRK# J>VH UIMRK %,R
UKVN Z$ QI;/ E
H   GK IWQNI\QN IW= X  7>  K ST M Z E
H  IW= X
IV] %  (N% S'N-  M% I-= H  RL
U > '  JT ; N% 7>   IW= X  I-MK HNE R^ J K
STMZ QNJ'N STMZN R^J ;NR' HRH RIM]GN M" V(N QNJ'K JV%K G>RUN
%]^ WK %NE R=\H I-=H RL
U>' JT;N% J>=VR 7>VJ]% HRGN M" 7>>GN %NZ
STMZN R=\GN M" 7>K V
$ I-=H STIMZ]Y IW=X 7>VJ=VK HRWN7>$GN M" I-
JT H NR 7> M K ST M Z E
H  IW= X  VU> '  JT ; N% (N% S'NH  W" $  QNJ'N

264

) (NR( IUQN% JT H N3 IW3

IW3'^ R^J ;NR' HRH RIM]GN M" V(N QNJ'K JV%K G>RUN JTIHTVK  %]^
JV%K R^J IW=X R=\H I-=H VU>' >HV J>=VR 7>VJ]% HRGN M" 7>GN
%NZ IW3'^ R=\GN M" 7> J=>VR V
$ I-=H STIMZ]Y G IV]% E
H. IJT(WK
JNVNE WRU  IW= X  I(VK S'N-K R= \ ' GN HNRL HRWN7> $ GN M" 
JT Z N' I3W J> R N' UKVNJT " a  U
R \J> R  V
$  JT H NI3V Q%> W NG M%^ ] Z N%
JTNG JGNR IXZ% ENE U
WNZK R>GR ]IMVN QI;/ JT3P A
STMZE
H IW=X MK I-=H VKRN (N% VZU>' JT;N% RXH 7> IW=X
?>G I3W R^J ;NR' HRH RIM]GN M" V(N QNJ'K JV%K G>RUN JTIHTVK
%]^ %NE R=\H JVKAJV%K G IWWMNR %NE 7>K VR4. VKRN J>=VR VZ
U>'
>HV 7>VJ]% HRGN M" 7>GN %NZ 3]HR I3W  R=\GN M" I- J>=VR
V
$  IV] %  E
H  G  JT N 'KQ. GN ] M NR HRWN7> $ GN M" 
IW3'^  J> R N' X QI;/ V= H  L
 IUQN% M"  7> M  HNE R^ J  ST M Z
QR(NV L
VK I%R]L% GN M" QI;/ G Q=U GN IZENAL>EN IUQN% HNE
G J>=VR VU>' IW3'^ GKQ. EKE4NW. GN M" V(N
V(N 7>K G QWVNR 3TK RNZ
3TK IHT3% QNIG GN IUQN% M"
IW33 IWXNR HR% GK U=E I-M M" IH 3TK IW3'^ J>RN' GN WHVN
3T K  JNRNR IR3K M"   I-MK IUQN% GH3QNIG IR3KQ. V
$  J> R ^ H > V  %
>I'QN J>R^H>V V
$ NRWV % >I'QN V(N NRWV V
$ 3TK JNRNR
IR3K % >I'QN 7>M IUQN% 3TK IW3'^ J>RN' IW=X IE=JKS=; HKVN IUQN
L
 Q= L  QNJ'  HRHZE. IW= X  M"   I- IW= X  IRF I-= H  ST I MZ] Y  GN
IUQN% WK Q= ; ^ R N M"   3T K  G W KJ> R N' 3T K  I3WJ> R N' QNIG J> R N'. GN
IUQN% WK STMZN LK GN IG=VN M
I-QN M" 3TK JNRNR WNEN IUQN% 3TK
ST M ZN LK G> Q NRN IG= V   IUQN% G  ZN% %MK$ M
 HGN I-E-K 3T K
IW3'^  J> R N' %] ^  Z0' G  E-K G W K J> R N' V(N 3T K  I3W J> R N' GN
IM
U  IEQN LNW U N IH7> $ IH I-M IUQN% GH3QNIG IR3KQ. G
IJVN 3TK STMZN LK GN IG=VN M
I-QN M" 3TK GWKJ>RN' V(N 3TK I3WJ>RN'
%]^ Z0' G E-K 3TKZG *UWG UKVN V(N XNR
$ WG. GN IM
U IEQN
LNWUN IH7>$IH I-M IUQN% W"$ *UWN% HNE R^JK STMZ G>QNRN IG=VN
IUQN M"   L
 ST M ZN IW3'^  V(N I3W LK GN 7> V J] %  HRVN M"  QR(NV
IJVN M" JIW=VR WG. V(N JIW=VR 3TKZG*UWG UKVNLK G IUQN% %]^
Z0' G E-K WZWG QR(NV ^?3Z WG GN IM
U E"'N M
WUN L

HNE R^ J K ST M Z G  7> V J= V K HRVN QR(NV IJVN JRZQH3R ST M Z


HIWRG W  GN IG= V N M
I -QN M"   L
 HIWRIUT * KM  HIWRWN'K G> Q NRN
W"$ IVJ>R3 % JTU1 M
H S
IEQN K IR=UWG Z]YE  >HV  Z]VR
 QV  V=H JTZN' M"

3TK STMZN J>RN'#


I- J> R N' G  WHVN 3T K  E
Z MR3' IR3K LK M% L
 3T K  IWQN
IR3K G I33 M
- M% IL%4. %]^ ^V LK WK IHMN L.GN M" 3TK E
ZMR3'

IUQN% U] U N

265

LK ^ V  LK  %  G= I QN IH I-M IUQN% JIME  3T K  ST M ZN LK %


GH3QNIG 3T3 1 Z>% KQ. %]^ >'NI-QN K 7>MK Z"$ >'N7>$GN M. I-
J> R N' G  I3T 3 1K G  WR'% %NZH QI;/ IW= X  JT 3 P A V= H
IHMN M"  IH 3T K  IW3'^  LK RW IW3W G  QN;NR M% L
 ST M ZN IW3'^
V(N I3W R^ J  V
$  LUV GK 7> V J= V K V(N JNE' V(N ] M NR HRG  M%
7>   *UWN% IW3'^  %] ^  Z R N %ZHNR M" 
L
 I%=V GV WR^J V(N HNR'*^V QIWQHV JTIHTVK M" 7>K %]^
JT ; N% HIM] G   M% 7>  K V
$  J> R 3 %  I- IW3W GN I%RZN' HKVN M" 
QIZV V L =  WK ST M ZN LK %] ^  MK J> R 3 Z0
  7> M  ZV JT N 'KQ. GK
I3T 3 1K HR% WNE  V(N *UWN% %NRNI-' G  QN3IRV M%
W" $ *^  *UWN% %NRNI-' %  LE GK I3T 3 1K HKVK %NRNI-' V
$
7>VJ]% M
' G HNR' LE %]^ %NR IHMN LN' E=UN *UWN% % RW JT(Z
LE 7> a V  IW3RNZ HKVN I-E-K *UWN% %^ ]  %RNI-' IHMN L.GN M" 
*UWN% % LE IW=X QNJ'K 3HVK 6=YK 7>V
$ I-=H >WR'Z-K Q]Y JTU1
M
I-QN 7>K IW=X W"$*^ STMZN LK GK 7>VJ=VK M
-K Q"N >I'QN L.GN M"
I-=H NE V=H Q]Y IW=X I%WN HRH 3TK STMZN LK % 7>G G
 1>H9 HR
IG=V I-=H %NE ;^E
H S' IUQN QV G^R %NE *^E
H
VGJ6XNV STMZN LK % QNJ' R
3 V
$ R>GR JTU1 HKVN
HKVN 7> J R
H V
IUQN% IR3K 3T K  E
Z MR3' ^ V  LK  GN IHMN M
I -QN M"  L
 > I 'QN
> ' NI-QN E
H  W G  M"  L
 J^ R ' %MK$ M"   IH7> $ IH WHVN HIM IRMN M"
IH Q"N >I'QN M" I-E-K J^R' LN'HNRK G E-K 3TK GWKZM.J>RN'
3T K  I3W ZM.J> R N' 3T K ZG *UWG UKVN V(N XNR
$  W G  QV  J^ R '
JT Z NVZN G> Q NRN V= V WIUQN% L
 WZ W G  QR(NV HIWRWN'K HSKR
SN'K  IHMN L.GN M"   7>  G  E-K IHT J N J94
 UIMRK %,R UKVN Z
$#JT Z  3 WR GN NR ] G  3 # JIR*N3N JT * ^  HK V(N I-K J>  VH
(NR( IUQN% JT H N3 IW= X 
WNVIWH IUQN% %]^ W"$ HE>=U IW=X JTU1 M
H HIWRGW HSKR
JT Z  3 WR  %  QNJ'  \N  W H 3T K  ;RZGN NIMS LK S.;WU94  WNE
 %] ^  J> % R PKHA G= I QN L
 I-  J>  VH IW= X  I3T 3 1K RX%N IW= X
WRI'V M"   IHT J N 7> a (  J94

3TK JNRNR LK % HNE STMZ %^] JRSTMZ WK IHMN M" V(N STMZ WK
V(N IW3'^ WK IHMN M" V(N I-K %]^ Q%NIG QR(NV QZR WK IHMN M"
I- STMZ QR(NV HNE GN L%ZAIZTV^ %MK$ M]>GK I- V
$ IR3K GK SNE
S>=;K I=; M>]GK M"
IWXNR HR
A  IW3'^  J> R N' GN IUQN% I-= H  IR3K G> Q RN IHMN M"
IL%  E
H W G  > '   'N-  IUQN% QR(NV G] V H(N  G  QN;NR 7> a V
IHMN V(N ST M ZN J> R N' GN IUQN% 3T K  E
Z MR3' IR3K %  GH3QNIG
IR3K V
$ >I'QN K 7>M IEI\QN M" I-E-K 7>JR
HV G
%4
$ IW3'^J>RN'
W STMZN J>RN'  %]^ Z0' G E-K 3TK GWKJ>RN' V(N 3TK I3WJ>RN' GN
IM
U IEQN LNWUN L
 W"$ TK STMZN LK % QNJ' J>=VR %NRG LK %]^

266

) (NR( IUQN% JT H N3 IW3

> ' NI-QN L


 3T K  IWQN IR3K G  G> Q NRN UT I M' M
I -QN V(N IEI\QN
IUQN M" M
R J>RN'. GN IUQN% 3TK STMZN LK G IUQN% ZN% %MK$ M

HGN I-E-K M
R  J> R N'. %] ^  Z0' G  E-K 3T K  G W K J> R N'# V(N
I3W J> R N' GN IM
U  IEQN LNW U N IH7> $ IH I-M IUQN% GH3QNIG
IR3KQ. G IJVN 3TK STMZ. LK GN IG=VN M
I-QN M" 3TK GWK J>RN' V(N
3TK I3WJ>RN' %^] Z0' G E-K 3TKZG *UWV UKVN V(N XNR
$ WG. GN
IM
U  IEQN LN- U N IH7> $ IH I-M IUQN% W" $  *UWN% HNE R^ J K
ST M Z G> Q NRN IG= V N IUQN M"   L
 ST M ZN IW3'^  V(N I3WLK GN 7> V J] %
HRVN QR(NV IJVN M"   JIW= V R W G . V(N JIW= V R 3T K ZG*NUWV UKVN
LK G  IUQN% %] ^  Z0' G  E-K WZ W G  QR(NV 3^ ? 3Z W G  GN
IM
U E"'N M
WUN L
 HNE R^JK STMZ GK 7>VJ=VK HRVN QR(NV IJVN
JRZQH3R ST M Z HIWRG W  GN IG= V N M
I -QN M"   L
 HIWIUT * KM
HIWRWN'K G> Q NRN W" $  IVJ> R 3 %  JT U 1 M
H   S
I EQN K IR= U W G
Z] Y E  >HV  Z]VR  V
$  V=H  JTZN' M"  V(N 3TKZG*NUWV
UKVN IW=X *UWN% HNE QR(NV STMZ % QNJ'K I(VK W"$ G=K M" L

IV M" 
UKVN QI;QN-  E
H  IW=X IHMN M" IH Z"$ HNE R^JK STMZ
QNJ'  STIMZ]Y. IW=X IL]% WK JTN'K M% 7>%4. V
$ 3T3P M. 7>M XNM
(^ E  RKR IW= X  %N3WN% M% XNM  QNVZN R^ J  IW= X  QIW%N3K M%
I-E-K E
HWG >' >'N- IUQN%  G QN;NR 7>aV Z"%]^ J>R3VZ Z]%G
M% WNVW IW= X  J> R 3 V Z V. Z" % ] ^  6R J> R 3 QR(NV HNE  G  V(N
QH3R J> R 3 JRST M Z  V
$  WK M
R  M"   7> M K WNVW IW= X  JT Z NVZN
QR(NV *UWN% IHMN L.GN M" IV]% E
H. IW=X JTW3 HRH *GN ;NR'
J
3' HRGN M" 7>MK WNVW IW=X QIW%N3K JTZ3WR M" UKVN QI;/
E
H  A  UKVN IUQN%GNVN ST M Z W" $  HIM IRMN M"  IH M
QRL>%C VR V(N ZR SM>V L%Z M
 X>=H M% V]^ %MK$ LN'GN Z"$ LN'GN
M. 3T K ZG *NUWV UKVN QI;QN-   E
H   QI;QN-   E
H  
IW= X  JT Z N' M"  V(N QI;QN-   E
H   IW= X  QNJ'K N;%N %] ^  WK
Q%> V ZNZ  QIV Q3T  3 1 IHMN M"   I-E-K QI;/ E
H   IW= X
IHMN M" IH M QRL>%C RW *NW %NE 7> JTZ3WR GK 3R' IW=X LN
ILGK IHTJN %NE MK V]^ JRZ3.VK %]^ JTNJV M
W$UN V(N HG % %31 M
'
WNE E
H QR(NV VE
H %]^ JTNJV M
-$UN QI;/ E
H  IW=X IHMN
M" IH LG V"%]^ V=VWGR3K ]V JTNJV M
 LNW L
 UKVN QI;/ E
H 
IW=X V(N QI;/ E
H  IW=X WRI'V M"  7>G SNQG 7> JRZJG
JTZ3WR GK \
L HR%K XNMKGK M" ILIW=X U- N;H WNJ E1H ]NR
IW= X  %MK$ QN7> $ G  QR(NV J^ R ' Z
H 3 JT N JV HRG  M% IL JT Z  3 WR
V
$  I-M RW ]  NR 7> V J] %  M
I -QN V(N 7> M K RW GN ;NR'AJ
3 '
HR% WNEN M" Z"$ UKVN IUQN% GNVN STMZ R^JK HNE  WK 7>K QNIG
J>R3 JTZ3WR GK 3R' IW=X M. J^R' IW3WN3 G %NE 7>K GK *UVK
N;%N QR(NV J^ L N HR%K XNMKGK M" 

IUQN% U] U N


267

3TK GWK ZM.J>RN' V


$ IUQN% UTIM' HR
#

   GWK ZM.J>RN' V
$ Q.I3H E\ QV NR IWXNR#

     ]?IJV 3TKZGGWK*NUWV IX=VT Z


1N 1NI-J HWE IM]GK
         ]JNGHAM%^]ZN% JTNG JGNRIXZ%ENE U
WNZK
         JTHN3HAU
IS]G*W%AHNRE UKVNJT" U
R\J>R

@3T K LUG] I SHN-  %ZM@


3TK GWK ZG*NUWV
VKRN H] G

RNLN JRKHI3V %  3T K  IWQN LK V


$  ST I MZ] Y  RX%N G  IW3  IW= X
J>=I6QN 3TK IWQN LK % IHMN RNL% Z"$ I-MK JT3% IR3KWR %NRG LK
V
$ J>=I6QN K 7>M WR'% QNJLK %]^ G=GN M. Z"$ 3TK IWQN LK  %
3TK %NRG LK V
$ J>=I6QN I-=H STIMZ]Y G RXNI-VN H
' M"H
-K V. 3]HR
*UWN% %] ^  I-GN RXNI-VN Z] % G  M% H> 0  3T K  IW3'^  LK %] ^  V(N H> 0
ST M ZN LK %] ^  V(N SM> V  NR  QXNRKQN *WN%K %^ ]  RW Z%
R ( J^ R '
HR% WNEK G=G M% 7>M QNIG ZNI-QN ZM.3HVK M% V(N JRZJ>R3
G %NE RIMH HNRL ]JNG% HR% WNEK JTIHTVK M"$ STMZ G %NE 7>GN
Q* G  ] S ] ;  M"   JT 3 P 
%NRG % IHMNAIWQNLKC JTNXK% Z$ GK U=E M" AI-MK ]GM ZR
IMRG IW=X WK 7>VJ]% M
 IUQN K VG Z"$ QNJ' IJVN QIZV VL=WK
STMZN LK G (N% 7>aV IUQN 7>%4. V
$ I- Z$ IL G IW3 IW=X QNJ
ZR V
$ J>=6 RM M
 7>K IW3 IW=X Z"$ J=>I6QN Z"$ IHMN IJVN LKC I-M
]J^R% STIMZ]Y IH(
$ V
 7>VJ]% M
I-QN I- GK RX%N QNJ HKVK M" L.
3TK IW3'^ LK % L. 3TK 3]HR LK % IHTJN =XA G=

ST M ZN LK %  IHMN A JT 3 P  V
$   V(N   
  S1NC Z"$ I- JT3% GN HK 7>V=R GW.I-M JT3% S9N MK LI1=E
M" J^RW HNE IW=X RWVR LEAMKALE K VG HZE V
$ ZRK 7>VJ=VK
M
- K Z" $  HZE GK HN'KHNJR 7> a V  S" P H  IWXNR HR% E= U NAI-
QNUN; LE IW=X Z"$ IHW$ 7>VJ]% M
 IUQN H' ZRN RH3H M" HZE
GN Y]YE F9H LE IW=X 7>V=IRQN 7>a( Z"%]^ 333N-K *UWN% IW3'^ GN
Z"%^] GR3% M
I-QN 7>M 
U I%]GTN G W=3K*^V M
H UN9K %K$G IW=X 
-
M
- K I-]% IW=X *UWVK 
U I%]GTN NG QN U-K Z"$ 7>GN VW%
HKVN VG 7> M  HIEQN'Z-K *UWVK 3T K  IW3'^  G  IWUT I M V
$  I%HEH
QIX]V R^J ;NR' HRH QNHN3 IW=X IWRNLZN% M
 U-K IGW QN*^3'
7>GK 6WK W;N RM K LG 
U I%]GTN *UWN% IW3'^ LK G RKR V
$
QE=U M
H QNHN3 IW=X IWRNL' E=UK VG V>R]V MK 3TK MRK 7>aP S"P
 M>' 7>a( Z"$ QV *UWN% IW3'^A G
 K 7>a( R>GR WK JTU1 M
 U-
N%^] IV]%. %]^ GWK % IHMN STMZN IW3'^ QV ZM3WRC QNJ *EK*.VK
NW;N% M
H QNJ'A H]Z. IW=X ]EU% M
 LN7> I3T31K I(VK V(N
]MNRA I-M QNJG HNRL M% I-]% IW=X I-=H ]>GR IWZN% QNHN3 V
$

268

) (NR( IUQN% JT H N3 IW3

7> V = R  QNI-QN VG 7>   G W K %  N%] ^  QNIUQN IG= V KAG W VN7> $ C I%R*"
M
H I-=6NJ^RW I- IWZN% IW=X JTW3 HR LN7> STMZN IW3'^ V R>GRC
Q= L  Z" $  QNJ%] ^  I-= H  QG*> V  IGT 3  IG\N7> $ GK M.# N%] ^  IV] % . G W NVNW.
%]^ 7> 7>aV S"PN G\H GWK % QNJ'K ZR=(N %NE IWZN% %]^ QNHN3
IW= X  7> Y N IG= V N
I-] %   IW= X  NYN IWZN% V L K %NE X= E  IJQN QV  7> M  IGW;NZA
STMZE
H IW=X LN JM>]XN 7>a( I-=H G^R STMZN IWRNLZN% K 7>%4. %]^
G\H *UWN% 3]HR QV IW3'^ %]^ SM>V M"RN%K M
-K *UWN% 3]HR QV
IW3'^ % ZR V
$ J=>I6QNA IH XV>RN%]%C I-M QIW%N3K STMZN H
' M"
Z"$ 7>V=R IG=VNAZ"%]^ H>0 JVN %MK$ I3T31K G QI;3PNVN I-M H
' M%
*UWN% Z" $  H
'  M. QV  NYN 7> G  3  HK M" A I- 7> E 0' IW= X  Z R N Z%
X= H R H= 1  IRMN M"  #
I-]% IW=X Z% G ZN% VKWRUNZK$ %NE 7>M IWZN% V>R]V 7>a(
$ X=E
IJQN QV H"EN3 G >RZ I\R 7>aV LN JM>]XN 7>a( IWZN% G JM>]XG
MK I-=H *IWQN *W% V
$ IVT%VT;NRK *UWN% 3]HR I%HE 7>M %]GK S"E
7> a V  S" P   K
I6'*R G SNQG MK 7>M IWZN% 7> I\R V
$ WK JW% V
$ WK V
L XNE %NE 7> a IYQN QV  S" $ H> ] P  E
H  IW= X  JM> ] X  IUQN IL= (   *UWVK
EH3ZK GN IWENA*W% K S1N %NRGC 7>a( Z"$ L
 ]ZJ=VK G\K 7>
GN WR'% HR%N ZR E-K Q]*W M" 7> 7>VZ J>RK %]^ G\H IW3'^ GN
Z% QN3XRK- G Z]>GR IW=X U
V \N' E=UN 7>a( HZE E
X% 3DTK MRK
IWRNLZN% % XNR *> L NW. K
I-]% IW=X JW% %NE U=E. HRGN 7>M IWZN% V>R]V 7a>Y IUQN Q=U
Q]IZTV G ZN% IZ=P LE WNEN Z]>GR IZIEQN 7>a( I-=H Z%
MR GKJ
K 7>K GKJ IW=X I-=H Z]UEZ Z%
MR JE][ IW=I6QN K 7> 7>VZ
JE] U  7> a V  I-= H  IG*RZ'K S" P K K QK$ QNJ IW= X  HIM' E= U 
IHAI-M >]GRK H' M" QV I-GN HK %NZ M" QK$ I-G IW3 IW=X
ISEH> = E  Q'LN% M.#
%NRGC 7>M ]GMUTV M
H QK$ E
H 7>a( MK R>H RM VG IW3'^
*UWN% %  7>   XNR^  NIM%K *UZVK %] ^  G \ H  IWW H J^ R WH I%3X"  HR
IEQN IH I-M *UWVK LUG] I SHN M" $  VG 7> % 4 .  %  IHMN I-M *UWVK
NYK *GK QIGHNR' M" $  ZM.IWIGQN QV  ZM.ZNI-QN I-G  %NZ
M% I-M J^ R ' JT I HT V K M" $  I-M IW3W 3 WRK# W G UT * N# V(N
I3WN# HIMN7> $ GK M" $ 
I-M 7> M K IGW.U%N M" $  ILG  JT E NWR' IW= X  Z" % ] ^  GR3% M
- 
K 7> Z$ Z"$ SNEHR^J IW=X K Z"%]^ JNE' 7>aV 0>ENQ RMK K
W1IST? G J=V 7>aV I-=H >IGT9 3"N IW6K K 7> 7>aV E1H Z"$ J"R
G Q]U^P %]^ QNJ' HZEAL" Z>=\ IW=X E" H X^ IRMN K V(N \E4 IRMN
K I-M GWK UNA H Z"%]^ 0>EN7>$GK K 7>MK I-M GWK M"$ I-IW=X
H
-K 3]GM GK U=E %MK$ RMK I-%4. %]^ G\H Z"%]^ JIME. GK U=E NG QN

IUQN% U] U N

269

U-K IH I-M NYK * GK L%%K M"$


3T K IW3'^  LK %  Z $  Q%>  NR 7>   *UWVK *> W % 3 WRK GK V^ V K
QNR] *  HR IG= V K *UWN% IW3'^ A  S
E   JT I HT V K G W K %] ^  %ZHNR M" 
*UWVK IW;NVRK %] ^  I%R] V R %Z3HNR M"   QNJ 3> ;  WR^ J N M
  I-M
NRN ]  NR QNJV
$  MK 7> G *NIV M
 IRMN M"  Z" $  ST M ZN QV  3] H RA
QK$ * QNJGK IHT J N %NE MK IWGZN% M. NYN QNI*R*NW QV
IVR
*NW M
I-QN HRGN M" HWE QNJMK I%=V M
 LUVL%%K M
 JTIHTVK
QV %NV%K GWK M

*UWN% 3]HR S
E AGWKC LHR ZM.*NU IW3'^ QNJ V
$ MK JTU1
M
- M% V. 7>%4. G SNQG 7>VJ]% M
' WNE STMZN WK QNJG SNEH M
-
 IFR Z"$ VZ
U>' EKE4N HR% WNEN 3]HR HK QNJGK ]VN% %MK$ M
I-QN
A QR(V Z"%]^ WK 7>VJ]% HR% WNEK QNJ MK M
 I- ]NR GK I3T31K
I(VK V(N ] M NR QNJG  U>' GN ZR=( M% 7>%4. MK IV]%
$ U>'. V
$
7>VJ]% QK$ STMZN IW3'^ QV 3]HR I%Z Q%>NR HNRL E-K IVQNR
RIM]G M. Z"$ STMZN QV I3W IWZN% V X94H LN RM K N%]^ RNV
IW= X  %W $ A LUV IG\N-K IG= V    *WN%KC *E   HM
 V. 7>  %] ^  IH%
S'NI-QN M"  I-E-K I-MK JT Z N' G \
 3T K  ZGG W K*NUWV ZM.J> R N'
>*N3I1HZ ZMNVZ \ZRNL 3TK IHT3% GN JTHN3% Z>]S-K I-IW=X
]IHTV IMV IM]GK Q%>WNG HKVN M" VKRN H]G QI;/ JT3P 
E
H /A
STMZ.AQIMZ-K3WRMIFEV JT*NWNVRW IW] LI%^VN%GNV^
I%IVQNM H Q%] >RNM 3VZ\ JTZ>=\NM X I%IVQN I%IVQN VWZW L%%K
JTIHTVKM J>RN'N  
*NWQR(AM ZNVNCSTMZN Z"$ V(N I3W QNJG MK JT*NW V
$ L%ZWN%
M. I%= V  %MK$ M. QR(NV QK$ QIW%N3K %MK$ M. IFR M
R  I-] G R
QNIG G^R GWVN IH JTHNR I%=V M
 HG M% QNJMK QIW%N3K M

JT I HT V K V(N %NV%K G W K M
 
JT 3 PA QI;QN-   E
H  /ANIG
/A
IGNGT Z %. % G. ISH
H(ZM]IWIMV4XVZ
U>'MHZEL3XRL
U>']*W4>IWIMVMIHZ^VWU>'
$MIRM 
*NWQR(A*UWN% 3]HR S
E/AM ZNVNC L NY 7>aV QNJ IGQN>HV
M
 V. Z"%]^ VZ
U>' IH7>$ S'NI-QN HZE V
$ 7>VJ]% M
' WNE STMZN %]^
RL
U > '  IHE-K S'NI-QN V(N IW3'^  %] ^  V
U > '  IH7> $  S'NI-QN
QR(NV LKW. %] ^  L%ZAIZT V ^  R^ J K G> 3 HRZ IW= X  IH7> $  EUNI-QN
E
H /A
/ARZ WJ]IV J>R]I3 GNVW UIV]%IM IWMIWGZ I3W 
*NWQR(AQNJ'  JVK J> R 3 QR(NV HNE *UWN% G  %NE GN
*
U AIWEN HRGK RIM] G K M
  QNJGK UVK H
- K %MK$ LN'GN
STMZN LK HIM]G M%A Z"$ WK ZM.ZNI-QN LUG]ISHN G XR%. IW=X
IUR IJQN QV Z"$ 7>%4. %]^ IHMN ZNVNC WG HIM]G M% -
HZWNIGWVK]
# M" V. HK 7>M QNVZR^JN QNJMK M
 L. 7>M H
-K M
R MK J>R3
STMZ#
M" 

270

) (NR( IUQN% JT H N3 IW3

GWK % IHMNAZ"$ QV STMZ I-=H MK M. ZR QV I-]%4. STMZ IW=X
HGK IH] I XVZNVR WK * G  %MK$ M"   U R K ST M ZK R G RK SNRNMK
W" 3 'WK I3WN WNR^ ' K H S  R K %RI] [ K QV  WNSK A NR  Z R   R^ J
M% STMZN LKC I- 3HVK %^] QNJ QNJ'K I-VRK S'N7>ZM.RWVK
%NZ V
$ IWI\QNV I-M ]>GRK M>' GN VRK I-VRK M
H RMUK *UWVK
LUG]SN % *UWN% IW3'^ %]^ IHMNAIW3'^C Z% %]^ Z>U; HR% WNEK I-
ZM.EH3ZK
ZM.EH3ZK  %]^ E"H M>' QNJ WK J;NR
 I-M GN QNJG WH3 (E
IW= X  IWRNLZN% RM U K
G W K %  IHMNA3] H RC Z% %] ^  Z> U ; HR% WNEK I-M ZM.HNEK
URKA%NZ V
$ IWI\QNV M" QNJ I-%]^ JV%K R^J IW=X IWHNR HR

M>' ZRN HNRL I=; HR% G E-K IWZN% V S"PH QNJ E
H LEGK
J;NR
 H
-K HIP% HNRL M
' 7>aV LG
$ QNJ Z"%]^ ZR' HR
U VG Z"$
NMZ'  QN LNW.UK G W VN8C Z R N V(N %NV% JT Z NVZN GN I;QN%
QNJ%]^ GN HRG RIM'N XNMKGN M" NY G
%4. GN IZR% HRG RM
U
V. QNJG  HNRL I= ;  M
'  IW= X  R= V K*R WK ] G  M  %MK$ RM U N
STMZN LK HIM]G M%AI- JTHNR HIMH *UWVK LUG]ISHN % N%]^
IWGN HR IG=VN 7>%4. % 3>; QNXNRWNEK 3HVKQ. IW=X *UWN% IW3'^
G  E-K ZM.EH3ZK %] ^   3] H R G  E-K ZM.HNEK %^ ]  QV  Z R   E-K
ZM.RWVK %] ^  JV%K S'% GK QNIUQN G  IG= V K M> '  7>   (N% V
$
QK$ X=E J-
NR IWXNR /AI-= H  ST I MZ] Y  GK WNVIWH I(VK V
$  ZM.IR3K
IWQN LK ZM.IR3K %NRG LK V(N 3TK STMZN LK 3TK IW3'^ LK V(N 3TK
3]HR LK WK Q'I*=L M% I-M WK J=31 M" IH G>RUN %]^ JTIHTVK WK
HIM]G M% V(N G>RUN V(N STMZ L
VK I%R]L% HNE  GN JVKAJV%K GN
]S]; WK M" I-E-K IEI\QN M" IH STMZ G %NE JTIHTVK GN Q*G ]S];
M" ILW$ JV%K %]^ QR;.U'K WK HIM]G M% 3TK STMZN LK %]^ QNJ WK
%MK$ JVN Z" $  IH= (
$  7> V J] %  M
I -QN MLNR NE V= H  JN'K IW= X  IJT ( WK
GK \
L HKVK JT]V^ %MK$ IZEK VG QNHN3WN'K G QN;NR 7>aV MLNR
NE V=H VJ HKVN HZE GN Y]PE JH9H %KX 7>aVIRQN V. 7>a( 3
3 %NU GK 3, 7>aV *UWN% IW3'^ SM
3 J- % 3TK IW3'^ G RKR
IW=X
$ I-=H GWK I%HEK JTV%K GK VR4.  L
 ]>GR QN*^3' JIM% QNHN3
IW=X IWRNLZN% M
 U-K VG 3TK IW3'^ LK M
3 X QN- I-]% IW=X 3]HR
LK WK 7>a( QN U-
7> J R
H V IWWR' V
$  I= ;  M"  IH IV] %
$  *UWN% S M
3  HR R= \   K
IFR > X  V  HKV   QNHN3 V
$  IWZN% QNI-QN G W K %  IV] %
$  JT * ^ Q . %] ^
IWZN% IW=X S"P' GN QNG3 IG=VN IWZN% %]^ QNHN3 IW=X 7>YNI-QN
7> J = R  I-= H  ST M ZN I-= H  I3W V(N I-= H  IW3'^  M
R  G I \QN L
 ST M ZE
H
IW= X  K
IWXNR HR
A STMZE
H IW=X L
 G^R STMZN IW3'^ V(N I3W IG\N-K
G RM % I-M L
VK I%R]L% STMZ  GK MK HENSN,K M" 7>MK M
R IV]%

IUQN% U] U N

271

R^J ;NR' HRH STMZE


H IW=X IV]% U>JV (N% I-=H RL
U>' JT;N% ?
VR I-=H VU>' JT;N% ?VR I-=H VZ
U>' JT;N% ?VR  S'NH RIM]GN
M"  V(N JIHT V K G> R UNAQ31] U K  %] ^  QNJ'K JV%K R^ J  IW= X  R= \ GN M" 
LG I-M G
%4
$ RL
U>' JT;N% (N% IW=X M]>G M% VG I-M ZM.STMZN V(N
G> R UN ZM.NIWVRK HIMEN7> $ G  M% I-%4 .  G
% 4 .  G  ] L
U  %NE L
 J> = V R
I- RL
U>' JT;N% ?VR IW=X 7>VJ]% M>]GN M" 7>M RL
U>' JT;N% M>]GN M"
7>GN %NZ STMZN R=\ IG]G M% V(N LWN% M
' V=H QXV HRH JTWIR3
HRG RIM]G M% IFR HZE G F=>E 7>aV R=\H XV HR IG]G M% LG
I-M G
%4
$ ZM.IW3'^ V(N ZM.EH3ZK R^J IW=X HNEASTMZ V(N G>RUN
V
U>' JT;N% ?VR IW=X RIM]G M% VG G
M. G JVKAJV%K G IWWMNR
%NE L
 J> = V R 7> V J] %  M] > G N M"   I-M V
U > '  JT ; N% M] > G N M"   7>  GN %NZ
IW3'^ R=\ IG]G M% H>0 IG% G SNQG SNEH %]^ QXV HRH LWN% M
'
V= H  JT W IR3 HRG  RIM] G   M% IFR 3 3 %NU GK 6-KQN V  > E NQ IG] G 
M% IFR >XV HR IG]G M%  I- JTHNR LG I-M G
%4
$ VZ
U>' JT;N%
\ V R IW= X  RIM] G   M% VG I3WN QR(NV G> R UN V(N ZM.I3W QR(NV
GNI3W G JVKAJV%K G IWWMNR %NE L
 J>=VR I- ?VR IW=X 7>VJ]%
M] > G N M"   7> M  VZ
U > '  JT ; N% M> ] G N M"   I-GN %NZ I3W R= \  IG] G   M%
I-%] ^  WK LWN% M
'  V= H  QX V  R= \ G  M% I_R LWN% M
'  7> a V  > X  V
HRG M% IFR IV]%. %]^ I-H=PN HRH IWZN% IW=X ISPNH 7>J=R G E
H.
G IGT3 IG\N7>$G M% IHV I-M QNJ' QNJ%]^ RW7>VZ %N Z]% S"P'
U>' JT;N% ?VR %]^ Z0' G E-K I-=H 7>GMNR' M"A IHK ZHN% IW=X
IV]% HZR M% I-=H HZR IW=X G3 *UV. 3MKG. G IX=VR E=U M
'
LG IWQHVK 7> HZR IW=X L.GN M" V. 7>G IWXNR WK G3 *UV. ILM
M
 L.G M% G^R HZR IW=X N;^A]V. IR3KQ. QNIG G IX=VR E=U
M
' 7> HZR IW=X JTW3 HRG MK Z% 3.V V(N JT*^ *UVK W=E E=U
L.GN M" VKR HZR IW=X Q3EKE QR;%]U I-VRKAJ>R3. G IX=VR
E= U   M
'  V. Z% IW= X  SHWN [R HR% E= U  M"   I- JT H NR 7> J = R
ST M ZE
H  IW= X  HNE R^ J K ST M Z %  IV] %  (N% I-= H A U> '  JT ; N% S'N-
M% IV] %
$  JT * ^  RLU> '  ST M ZNLK VU> '  IW3'^ L K V(N VZU> '  I3WLK
QNJ'  U> ' . GN JT * NW IHW $  JN7> $ G  M% 7> G NMR'AILW $  R
- K[R
IZRX. GN V9HN SLK IW= X  EUNI-QN IZRX. G  U> '  %NE *
HZIRQ. G  IWQHVKQ. %] ^  I6= H . QN7> '  E= U KQ. ILW $  NHNR WV^
IZRX V. R
-K IW=X K JT]V^ 7>GK I%RNHNR 3HVK QR(NV U>' % G^R
S"P IWQHVKQ. %]^ JT*NIWV HR IG=VN PKH I- JTHNR IV]%
$ JT*^ 3TK
STMZN LK RLU>' 3TK IW3'^ LK VU>' V(N 3TK I3WLK VZU>'  QNJ'
AQNJ'  E
H . IW= X  RIM] G   M
-   IV] %  E
H  IJT ( WK E
H  JNVNE E
H  V(N
WRU E
H  G  JT N 'KQ. %] ^  JT * NIWV R= \ G  M% ILW $  Z
S NI-E F %  GK
R"$L %NE F
% HNRL HRGN M" I-K JTHNR QIGT3 3HVK R^JK U>'. %NE
IV]%
$ GWVN QNJ' IJVN HNE GK I3T31K 7>G QNMNR G E-K XEN RM
M% G>RUN GN QNJ'N QE=U E
H WK M" ILIW=X I-M QNJ' WNVIWH

272

) (NR( IUQN% JT H N3 IW3

R^ J  IW= X  GR3% IG] G K M"   IFR I-%4 .  GN IWZN% G> R UN G  GKJ IW= X
JM>]XN VG L
VKAI%R]L% QR(NV HNER^JK STMZ % IW3'^ LK %]^ SXJ%
GK NG JTDGN% HR IG=VK VH 3TK IW3'^LK %
%  G= I QN IH I-M G> R UN
QNJ'  IV] % . GK ZNVN M"   Z" $  SNEH R^ J  IW= X  JNE'  IW= X  IJQN K
I-M Z" % ] ^  E
R K G H   0> E NQ RMK K VG 3T K  IW3'^  LK %  IHMN IH M
G>RUN QNJ NYK ZNVN M
 Z"$ IW3'^  STMZN V(N 3]HR V.
L%ZWN% M. NYN V. QIWR*NW QR(NV L%Z V(N IVR
*NW
QR(NV IZT V ^  M> ] G K M"   QK$ QIW%N3K %MK$ M. QNJ JT I HT V K G W K
M
  I-M U= E  3T K  3] H R %  WK WKHNR HKVK V(N IHMN Z" $  VZ
U > ' K
EKE4 N  HR% WNEN 3] H R WK QNJGN MK J> = V R M. 3T K  IW3'^  LK V(N
3T K  ST M ZN LK WK QNJG  V
$  7> V J] %  M
-   M%
IFR I-%4 .  IV] % . G W VNW. GK 3NGK G> R UN %  HKVK
HKVK JT I HT V K G W K
G> R UN  %  QNJ'K 3SG 3HVK %NE QNJ' MK M
R IV]% R^J ;NR' HKV
 3TK STMZN LK GK 3NGK NIWVRK %NE 3TK IW3'^ LK GK 3NGK EH3ZK
%NE V(N 3TK I3WLK GK 3NGK 7>ZN QR(NV HNEK %NE HRH IWZN% IW=X
ISPNH I-%4. G QE=UA GKJ. E
H.  IW=X *L IG=VN
L
V K I%R] L % HNEAST M Z  %  QNJ'  W.N G> Q NRN Z] > G R IW= X
XNR WG 6=>JN IG=V IFR JT(Z NUR Z](% G Z$ 7>aV JTU1 HR IG=V
L
VK I%R]L% HNE  G QNG3 %NE G>RUN % XNR
$ WG STMZN LK %^] IG=V
 STMZN % G>RUN QNJ'K ZNVN  V
$ J=>I6QN IH WG. IW=X L
 STMZ JT*^
IHMN M" 7>M QNJMK M
 L. H
-K M
R J>R3 M"
G>RUN % HNE G YR %NE WNVIWHVN 6=>J7>' GK H
I33 HRG M
-
IHMN Z"$ V(N STMZ I-=H MK M. H
-K *G %MK$ IFR WK WNVIWHVN
%MK$ 6> J K G> R UN %  IFR IHMN QNJ IV] %
$  Z R N V(N ST M Z GN GN
IZR% HRG RIM'N NY G
%4. GN IZR% HRG RIM' 7>aV LHR H
-K
HIP% HNRL M
WUN V. Z"$ V>R]V NMZ' QN LN7^$UK
IW33A IH7>$IH HNE % G>RUN %]^ HIM R=I\QN M" IH ZRN *G IH
%] ^  %MK$ HIM'N I- YR %NE G> R UN RW LUV %] ^  WNVIWHVN V
$
QJTKXV R=\GK M" 7>M QNJ' J>=VR. %]^ WK ;
\ IW=X R=\G M% I-GN
HNR% M"  IH HNE %] ^  3RNJ E= I UQN M"  IH I-= H  E= \  ZN%W RKR;NRK
JT N 'KQ. G  QNMNR I%= V  HR% GN I-E-K QNJ'  IV] %
$  J> = V R. V
$
QNJ'N QNMNR IVQNR HRWN7> $ GN M"   3T K  ST M ZN LK G  RLU> '  V
$
JT*NIWV HRH RW JTN'KQN V
$ ]VN% 7>VJ=VK HRWN7>$GN M" 3TDK IW3'^
LK G V
U>' V
$ I-=H G^R IW=X Z
M 7>VJ]% HRH I(VK QR(NV HNE
LNE IW= X  R
H  H  R= \ GN M"  V(N 3T K  3] H R LK %  VZ
U > '  %NE ] M NR
HRWNH  QNJ'  QNMNR IVQNR HRWN7> $ GN M" 
IFR IV]%
$ JT*^Q. %]^ WK ZNRH \.GN M" V(N %W$ J]>% HRZK JTN'KQ.
IW= X
$  IV] %  J> = V R 7> V J] %  HRH  QNJ'N HNRL LNRK R= \ GN M"  V(N J^ R W
WNE IV]%
$ STMZN IW3'^ V(N I3W XRNK E=\ L^%KQ. V(N WRUA%RH
IW=X HRZ G QN;NR 7>aV X=HR EUN7>$G RIM]G M% I-MK JTZN' I3W

IUQN% U] U N

273

ZM.J>RN' R>GR ]IMVN JT(Z I3T31K  \]Y QI;/  V(N  IW=X
WK M" 

3TK I3W ZM.J>RN' V


$ NR IWXNR#
I3W ZM.J> R N'#

3T K  I3W ZM.J> R N' Q%> W NGH / 3T K  M%^ ] Z N% JT  NG J G NR

JT H N3H / U
I S] G  *W% HNRNE UKVNJT " a  U
R \J> R  Z
1 N 1NI-J
QI;QN-   R> G R] I MVN JT ( Z \] Y  I3T 3 1K  %NE I%3HT 3 #
QNJ' J>=VR 3TK %NRGLK G 3TK I3W QV 3TK I3WN G IW3 IW=X J>=6'
V  3T K  ST M ZN LK %  IHMN IH JT 3 P A  IL JRST M Z G  IW3
IW= X  IUQN% QV  QIUQN% V
$  J^ R ' > H VKQ. G> Q NRN I- JT H NR
IWHEJ HKV  L.G  M% L
 I%RNHNR JRST M Z M"  7> M K NHNR R^ J  IW= X
GNI3W R^ J  ;NRH  Z%> = \  R^ J  IW= X  JT U 1 M
I -QN GNI3W %  QNJ'
RKR V
$ I-=H I-VRK %]^ 7>VJ]% HKVN IL%]^ JT;N% JTIHTVK Q]ISHN
IVTGW L%%K STMZN IW3'^ I3W GK ZNVN  IHMN LNGN M" IL GKQ.
Q= P  *> L NW. M%

3TK IW3'^ LK GK 7>VJ=VK#

L
 7> M  GNI3W M"  7> % 4 .  %] ^  JT Z J> R 3 -K3WR I3W 3] * ^  QV  ZM
3WR HIM] G   M% 7> M  QNJ'  NR  Q] U . IW= X  *Z RZN-  RIM] G   M%
7> HNE R^JK STMZ % I-=H I3WE
H %NZH STMZ E
H IW=X VZ
U>' JT;N%
? V R  ;NZ S'NI-QN7>  %] ^  HN3K HIM] G   M% I3W V(N I3WN %
JVKAJV%K R^ J  IW= X  RIM] G   M
-   I-= H  J> = V R GK 7> V J= V K HKVK ILGN
%NZ IW3'^  R= I \QN QI;/ R> G R ] I MVN I3W ZM.J> R N' JT 3 P


3TK STMZN V(N I3W GK 7>VJ=VK#


QI;QN-    JT3P A  3TK STMZN LK % G=IQN IH 3TK
I3W V(N I3WN HNE R^ J K ST M Z V(N JD T I HT V KAG> R UNAQ31] U K  %
JVKAJV%K IWWMNR %NE Z R K WK 7> V J= V K HKVK V(N IFR Z" % ] ^  QX V
HRH  HZE IW= X  R= \  IG= V NI-MK HNE ZM.IW3'^  R^ J  ;NRH  QNJ'K
%N*K V
$ I-=H HZE 7>VJ]% HR E"$GN M" STMZN Q=U HIM]GN M" IH IFR
Z" $  M
3  IW= X  QNI-QN HZE GK Z^ E  %] ^  E= * 'N XNIMQN JT ] V ^  QFE
IRMN IFR VJ HR% GK QNHN3SN'K M
-K VJ HKVN IFR ZRK V(N
IW3'^ GK IH U=E 7>aV E9N-K M
 U-K IWWR' I- J>VH G JT3P
 7>aV  VG NY IW=X I-=H VL
Z IE]U JTU1 M
IUQN V(N 8ZA8Z
GN %NG JTU1 M
I-QN V(N 7> IE]U 7>aV QA8AZ IV]% Q=\R WK IE\
% IFR R>GR R^J ;NR' HRH GNI3W J]L Z>=\ WNE ZN%W R^J IW=X
JT U 1 M
-    7>  G  %NE I3WN G> R UN  WK K
IFR 3] H R %] ^  QXN%H JT U 1 HKVN IH7$> I H 7> M  JIME. QX V  K

274

) (NR( IUQN% JT H N3 IW3

IFR > X  V  HRH  IV] % . %] ^  I-= H P  HR IG= V N  V(N IHMN IH QNJ IV] %
$
I3T 3 1KAI(VK V(N ] M NR GN HNRL ] * NE

RLU> '  JT ; N% ST M ZNLK VU> '  JT ; N% IW3'^ L K V(N VZU> '  JT ; N%
I3WLK M% I- JT H NR IV] % . G W VNW. IW= X  U> '  M% JT ] V ^  I3W HNE
R^ J K ST M Z  U> ' NVKV Z] %   U-  M% JT 3 P 7> a V 
NR IWXNR/A7> J R
H V IWWR' V
$  J= 3 1 M"  IH HNE R^ J K ST M Z
QR(NV GNI3W V(N JT I HT V K G> R UN  3T K  ST M ZN 3T K  IW3'^  V(N 3T K
I3W  G  ZNVNAIJVN M% G> R UN I-%] ^  JT I HT V K V(N JT ; N% WK HIM] G 
M% I-GKQ. Q= P  *> L NW. M% I-M GNI3W QR(NV L
V K I%R] L %
HNE G  RKR QR(NV J 1  IW= X
$  I%HEK M"   ST M Z QR(NV HNE V(N
JTIHTVK G>RUN  RW JTN'KQ. %]^ *RIZV R=\G M% QNJ' J>=VR. %]^ WK
WNVIWHVN %MK$ G=G HNR% M" IH IHV HNE STMZ  G  STIMZ]Y
G  JT N 'KQ. %] ^  JVN E= U  LNW  IH QK$ VJVI3EN 7> a V  *> ] % 4  H  HNE
ST M ZAL
V K I%R] L %  \.GN M"   I-E-K L%ZAIZV^  V(N M
R  G> \ GN-K
,^%KQ. IW=X JK9V HRGN M" V(N QNJ' IV]%
$ J>=VR. RLU>' STMZN LK
VU>' IW3'^ LK V(N VZU>' I3W LK V
$ 7>VJ=VK I(VK JNE' V(N
] M NR HRWNH  QNJ'N QNMNR IVQNR HRWN7> $ GN M"   IH7> $ IH HNE %] ^
I-=H E=\ ZN%W RKR;NRK JTN'KQ. GN QNMNR HR% GN 3RNJ E=UN M"
IHT J N 3T K ZG *NUWV UKVN LK IW= X  G \
 HNE ST M Z  V(N JT D I HT V K
G> R UN  G  JVKAJV%K HRZ V
$  RLU> '  ST M ZN VU> '  IW3'^  V(N
VZU> '  I3W GK 7> V J= V K M" 

IV]%
$ U>' HK M% JTZN' IMV#
IV] %
$  U> '  RLU> '  ST M ZN LK VU> '  IW3'^  LK VZU> '  I3WLK
M% ST M Z HNE  V(N JT I HT V K G> R UN  V
$  7> V J] %  M
-   M% V(N IV] %
$
MK %N3WN% M%#
JT Z N'/A UKVNJT " a  U
R \J> R  V
$  JT H NI3V 3T K  I3W ZM.J> R N' ILG
]JNGH M% 3TK M%^ZN% JTNG JGNR JT3P ]+ QI;/ R>GR IMVN
I- JTHNR STMZNAIW3'^ V(N I3W IV]%
$ GWVNW. X U>' M% JT]V^ I3W
ST M ZAHNE  U> ' VKV IHMN IUQN M" 
G^  RN JT Z N'/A UKVNJT " a  U
R \J> R  V
$  JT H NI3V 3T K ZG G W K*NUWV
J>RN' ILG ]JNGH M% 3TK M%^ZN% JTNG JGNR IXZ% ENE U
WNZK
VKRN H] G  QI;/ JT 3 P/A *UWN% IW3'^  %  G> R UN GK 7>  V> V K
HKVK/ IHMN IH Z" $  IW3'^  ST M ZN V(N 3] H R QNJGK IHT J N %NE
IWGZN% M. NYN V. QNI*R*NW L%Z  V(N IVR
* NW IZT V ^  M] > G K
M" QK$ I%=V QIW%N3K  %MK$ M. QNJ MK I%=V M
 LUV L%%K M

JTIHTVK V(N %NV%K GWK M
 *UWN% 3]HR % IHMN/ L *UWN% STMZN
V(N IW3'^ QNJ V
$ MK 7>VJ]% M
- M% V. 7>%4. G SNQG 7>VJ]% HR%
WNEN Z" $  WK VZ
U > ' K EKE4 N  HR% WNEN 3] H R HK QNJGK ] V N% %MK$

IUQN% U] U N

275

M
I-QN QR(NV Z"%]^ WK 7>VJ]% HR% WNEK QNJ MK M
 I- ]NR GK
I3T 3 1KAI(VKA] M NR QNJG  U> '  GN RWGN M% I-%4 .  IV] % . U> ' .
%NE 7> V J] %  QK$ ST M ZNAIW3'^  V(N 3] H R I%ZQ%>  NR HNRL E-K
VVJR RIM] G   M.
7>JR
HV I-M IWWR' HWE IM]GK IW=X Q%>WNIGV 3TKGWK ZM.J>RN'
V
$ M" IL IW=X H>0 V=(. %]^ 6>JNI-QN IUQN M" I- E-K I-MK JTZN'
G \
 3T K  ZGG W K*NUWV ZM.J> R N' > * N3I1HZ ZMNVZ \ Z RNL 3T K
IHT 3 % GN JT H N3 Z> ] S -K I-IW= X  ]  IHT V  IMV IM] G K Q%> W NG HKVN
M"   VKRN H] G  QI;QN-   JT 3 P  E
H  /A
STMZ.AQIMZI-3WTMIFEVJT*NWNVTWIW]LNI%^VN%GNV^I%IVNM
HQ%] >RNM3VZ\JTZ\
>= NMXI%IVNI%IVNVWZWL%%KJTIHTVKMJ>RN'N 
Q%> W NG /AM  ZNVNC ST M ZN Z" $  V(N I3W QNJG  MK JT * NW V
$
L%ZWN% M. I%=V %MK$ M. QR(NV QK$ QIW%N3K %MK$ M. IFR M
R
I-]GRQNIG G^R GWVN IH JTHNR I%=V M
 HG M% QNJMK QIW%N3K
M
  JT I HT V K V(N %NV%K G W K M
  
JT3P A QI;/ E
H /ANIG
/A
IGNGTZ%. % G. ISH H(ZM]
IWIMVMXVZ
U>'MHZEL3XRL
U>']*WM>IWIMMIHZ^VWU>'
$MMIRM 
Q%>WNG /A*UWN% 3]HR S
E/AM ZNVNC L QNJ NY 7>aJR IGQN>HV
M
 V. Z"%]^ VZ
U>' IH7>$ S'NI-QN HZE V
$ 7>VJ]% STMZN %]^ RL
U>' IH
E-K S'NI-QN V(N IW3'^  %] ^  VU> '  IH7> $  S'NI-QNQR(NV LKW. G
L%ZAIZT V ^  R^ J K G> 3 HRZ IW= X  IH7> $  EUNI-QN
E
H/ARZWJ]IVJ>RI3]GNVWUIV]%IMIWMIWGZI3W 
Q%> W NG/AQNJ'  JVK J> R 3 QR(NV HNE *UWN% G  %NE GN
*
UAIWEN HRGK RIM]GK M
 QNJGK UVK H
-K %MK$ LN'GN

I%3HR3#
3TKZG*NUWV UKVN GN IUQN% WK I- HNE R^JK STMZ % 3TK IHTD3%
LK G  RKR IW= X  JT  V W3 JT W  3  HRH  S
I EQN K 7> J R
H V JIW= V R
J> R N'. %  JT Z NI'V HR IG= V N IH JT I HT V K G> R UN %^ ]  HIM] G   M% V(N
GNI3W QR(NV HNE R^ J K ST M Z V(N JT I HT V K V
$  RLU> '  ST M ZN LK
VU> '  IW3'^  LK V(N VZU> '  I3W LK GK GK 7> V JVK JVKAJV%K
IWWMNR V
$  M
- K I-  GK 3NH3K 3T K ZG*NUWV UKVNLK WK M"   3T K
UKVN LK RW 3VR. GN NR M"   I-E-K I-IW= X  ] \  I JV IWWR'
] H  I VH 3SG. H
Y  WRYL  IW= X  M"   IL%^ ]  VVWGR3K ] V  MK Z0N
HGN M"   M> '  IHT J N HRH  JT W  3  HR% JIW= V R 3T K ZG*UWV UKVN
LK#IW= X 
QI;/ E
H  A IW= X  JIW= V R 3T K ZG*NUWV UKVN S
E ' WNE
HNE STMZ % 3TK IHT3% LK G RKR IW=X JTVW=V JTW3 HRH IHMN M" IH
JT I HT V K G> > R UN  V. Z R K JV%K M"   Z" $  ST M Z 7>  GK  % K IW= X  SK,

276

) (NR( IUQN% JT H N3 IW3

(NJ%N HRGN M. ILV


$ RWJTN'KQ. GK 7>VJ=VK M]>GK M" Z"$ * GN
IJVN V(N JTIHTVK G>RUN  * GK ZNVN HMN7>$GK M" JTIHTVK G>RUN  V
$
7>VJ]% IV]%
$ U>' RLU>' STMZN VU>' IW3'^ VZU>' I3W  LKWQNVZN
%]^ HRZ QN;NR 7>aV RKR. IW=X S]%4G M% QR(NV I-M IV]%
$ MK RW
JT N 'KQ. %] ^  ]  HNR G  QN;NR 7> a V  7> V J= V K I(VK V(N ] M NR HRH
FNH  R= \ G  M%
QI;QN-  E
H  IW=X IHMN M" IH Z"$ HNE M. RW %]^ \N'
G E-K JTU1 M
I-QN M. QI;+ E
H  IW=X QRL>% HIM IRMN M"
IH QNJ V. IR3KQ. %]^ WK \N RM M
 GWVN V(N I=; QNJG V
$ Z]UE
QR(NV R= I \QN GK NX%N HR RM  M% W G . G  T
V . G> Q NRN QNJGK
V>VK HR RM M% JT]V^ QNJ RW %]^ \N RM M
 H>0 QNJGK LN94 IW=X
E1H M
- IG\N-K IG]G M% H>0 QNJ IW=X JTW3 HR RM M%

RLU>' 3TK STMZN LK VU>' 3TK IW3'^ LK V(N VZU>'
3TK I3W LK IVTGW. GK J^LN IWQR( HMK M"#
I-M UKVN IUQN%GNVN JT * ^  3T K ZG*NUWV UKVN QI;+ E
H
A V= H  HIM IRMN M"  IH IV] %
$  U> '  RLU> '  ST M ZN VU> '  IW3'^
V VZU>' I3W  GK J^LN HR% WNIEQ. GN IUQN% MNIRQN LN X>=HN M"
I-M V. I-%4 .  V
$  7> J = R  Z R K *UVK J^ L N WK %MK$ HRG   IV] %
$  JT * ^ Q .
STMZNA IW3'^AI3W  V=H GK N;%N HR% WNE RN\33 >*NQ %]^ ;NR%
HKV  M
-   M% Z%> = \ . IW= X
$  %KX G> 3 HRZ HR% WNE  Z^ R \ I-%4 .  IV] % .
V
$  7> a JR Z R K ST M Z GK J^ L N WK %MK$ HRG 
3T K ZG*NUWV UKVN G  IUQN%GNVN JT * ^  %  QI;+ E
H   IW= X
QNJ'K *UVK %] ^  WK Q%7> V Z [1KQN  IHMN M" 
I-E-K QI;QN-   E
H   V(N QI;QN-   E
H  A
IW=X IHK M
R JTZ3WR GK 3R' IW=X LN' %]^ IHMN M"
IL Z$ UKVN LK GN IUQN% S
IEQN LN IRMN K 7> V
$ JIME.
%N V. QP4NR. J>RN' K V %N MK H
-K IUQNR4. 7>JI%3G V 6 3NVR
MK K L
 SNQG IW= X  IR3KQ. %  QNJ' A QNJ'  Q%> * W. GK J>  VH.
RXKQ. M% 7> Z$ HWE JIW=VR XNR
$ WG MK 3NVR R^J IW=X ZL^G
% V(N 7> % 4 .  XNR. JIW= V R W G . GN 3NRQ] 3  JIW= V R UKVN LK IW= X
WRI'V M" 

IUQN% U] U N

277

3NVRQR( IW3 #
3NVRQR( % JTZ3WR G V=VWIUQN% %]^ 7>E0NI-QN#
   3NVRQR( IHW$ M>]GN KA
G
 IWGWN% JT 3 %A7> a VR HIRQN HRG  % V(N R
V NL' WK SM>
] I \QN IW= X  3NVRQR( JT 3 %7> V = R  > % ' G  E-K IWRNLZN% M] > G 
% MNR IL=V GN F"EN R
IVQ. G M=( X M>]GN K IL%4. %]^ \>G WK
IUQN% %MK$ M]>GN K IH I-M HK HIM RM M%IL% ILQNGN ]IHTV
EUNVNR 7> X NR% HKVK R
V NU' VN9K WLNH  IWL"  M
'  GN JT Z N' IG] G 
% I-VR4. IWGWN%N GK MNRAIL=V GN F"EN QIWGWN%N G M=( IW=X
K
JTZN'/AJ>VH3TKZGIGQN%]GJTHN3#E\H3TK=IVQN%]GLKZMNRNL
JTHN3HRWGI3HQNIRQNJTVKI%;K*NZM.IR3KIGQN%]G*W%RNZEKE4N
Z"GN%%WKIG=EKAU]UNH.YQ=PW.RUFN7>aV IL7>$GNIV7>$E\/A
IV]%IG%V=HJTVK3NZIHTD3%N%]GLKVWNZKLKGN3NVRQR(M>]GNIRMN
I-=HIG%3NVRQR(G Z$IH % IHT3%%]GLKV
$NHNRWNGGNQWE]S%
HKVNI-K7>aV3N3VRQR(XENI-QNWNZKLKGNV.I-MZ%A*N7>$GNIW3
K7>%4N%;NRNJTWNM]IHTVS
EGM
-I%RNHNRI];.V7>aVWG.V7>JI%3GN
GJTZN'.GKI-=HE9KJR
IG=VKQVIHT3%N%]GLK%]^7>GNQR(Z]%'GE-K
ZLS^RHKVNIHT3%N%]GH
-KJTZN'%NG IHQNHWEUKVNGNI-ME
H
GNGNIM;RZUENI%*RWVK*NRV#E
H.GJNZ^]MHRHJ94%E=UN
WNZKLK%URLHIHMNQNJWNGZR%NEHRGM
I-E-KZ"%]^MKLWNS
IG7>#JT]V^7>GV.IWXNRMK7>\9U-K7>MX$H9KMK*>=EX>=IHQNK
Z]^MIW=X0=UQNU-KUEIW=XI[=UKS'U-KIXMRNIF=HNJ"IUQNIHK
JTHNRENLRIMLNWI-V
$7>% VRHA3N3VRGK3R'E" IHWNZKLK%]^
IHMNIHQ=6NE=6'GNE=6'G=
#WNZKLK%7>V=RIG=VNILW$HNR%GN
HNR% %MK$ 7> VR4N E=6' GN E=6' %MK$ M"# E
H. % QNJ'K MNK %NE
IHT3%N%]GGKMNRJTHNI3VHRIG=VKQV 7>M[SRNH 7>a(
$XEGNSI'QN
7> J R
H V E \  IW= X  J= 3 1 M"  IH IWGWN%. GK MNRAIL= V  GN I%R'"
QIWGWN% HRG K WNZK IGQN%]G LK % EUNVNR ]IHTV S
E IG=VK
R
VNW. % M]K HR IG=VK V(N ZMNIR3K IGQN%]G LK %]^ IWLVN [
I3V
HR IG= V N V(N JT Z NVZN I%RNHNR Z] %  IEQN LGIH L> R W G  QI;/
Z] V T   V(N L> R W G  QI;/ Z] V T   IW= X  J= 3 1 M"  IH JT Z NVZN
IMRKR M"  V(N QNHNR IW= X  M" 
WNZK IGQN%] G  LK ]  IHT V  *N3N IW= X  JT W X% HRG  % GN
JTZN'/AA =
=IVQNR( JTHN3# GK *^IZHN JT3P  7>aV WNZK IGQN%]G
LK % IHMN M" IH JIMEK WNR =IVQNR( JTHN3 6IJQN K 7> Z$
Z" % ] ^  IM] G K X] U K VR4 .  %MK$ QN7> $ GK K IH7> $ IH SXJ% V
$  ] %  
] W V   V= H  ]  IHT V  IW= X  MK *N3' HRGN K I-V
$  I= ;

278

3NVRQR( IW3

M
I-QN IH WNZK IGQN%]G LK ]IHTV *N3N IW=X MK 3NVRQR( HRG
K ]WV  ]%   IW=X
X =IVQNR( JTHN3 %]^ G>SNRN 6JWN7>'
G E-K I-=H NE SNQG ]%  IW=X WNZK LK GN I%;% M
 IUQN
J=31 M
I-QN IH I%;% G I-=H NE J^RW MK WNZK IGQN%]G LK %
IM]GK *N3N %]^ LNI'QN I-V
$ J^RW ]IHTV IW=X JTWX% IWQNI\QN%
HRG K T
VNU' ]IHTV V
$ QNJTKIXV M>]G % V 7>M WK IWGWN%. GK
VR4 .  MNRAIL= V  GN F"  EN HRG  %
M> '  I-M GN. GN WK GN RNZJNE GN  XNM] > G N M"  IH RW
JIW=VR ;RZ. GK JT*^ XNM>]' WNEK J]>% QNVZ.-$ V=VWIUQN% V
$ JTKIXV
M
 LN' VG QNJ ENE V ENE9K GK JR\ JIMXN'  HR IEQN HR%U

H(N /A I-=H P G G
 J=>VR % I-=H  NE GN G^RN  NE
GN K IJVNLK GN GM.V M
 IUQN S=IXQ. GK ZNVN LK % I-=H H=J9
IW=X IEJ1 ENE QNJ' S=IXQ. G M=( 7>aV R=\ V(N IHMN IH J>=VR
$ I-M
ENE E" LN7> V(N QNJ' VN7^ LK IJVN LK G W=Y *N-K  %]^ HIM'N IH
NY  H
E  J"    %MK$ M% I-M ENE QNJ'  H
E  R= \  E7>  V(N IW7> J NR
IW= X  NYN IM=  N HR E7>   QK$ I-= H E  SNEH WJNR %MK$ HR HG 
G
%4. S=X ZNVN LK G IG=V M
- ENE. %^] E" H QNJ' VN7^ LK G H
E U- V(N
L
 ZNVN LK % IHMN K JTN(%N HKVK 7> P VN7^ LK  % ENE. %]^ G
I\QN V(N S=IXQN GK JTN(%N IWHNR HRH IHMN J>=VR I-%4. ENE. %]^
QNJ'K ZNVN LK %] ^  G  QN7>   7> M  ] * NEH  R= \  EW U K QNJ Z R   %NE
G^R 3IMR IW=X X=E
 Z"%]^ SM>V 7>;NR ZNE IZE L.GN M" WNJ QN H
I-%4 .  ENE. GN JT 
U  HR EW.U 
G
%4
$ SNEH VN7^ LK G %NE G^R 3IMR XE U- I-=H IG% VN7^
LK % I-=H ENE S=IXQ. %]^ IG=VN V(N IHMN J>=VR
 I-M ENE M" I-%]^ 7>
P %]^ G H QN7>'N IL V
$ H=E  MLNR GN ZNE 7>;NR IEQN K V(N
HIM'N I-M ENE R= \  E7>   QK$ WNJ QNH  QNJGN IR' X> H N G W .U
V(N QNJ'N ENE WNJ E"  EW.U 
G
%4
$ S=IXQ. % P %]^ 7>JR
HV IWWR' IHMN VG P % I-=H LMRK
%]^ S>ENI-QN LMRK % ENE %^] JR? H G=IQN IH I-M ENE %MK$ M"
I-M V. ENE9K M" L
  R>J- GK WK %MK$ M" ENE GK HKZV V. 
E=\ R>J- M>]GK M" P % *EKAS>RK HIM]G M
- 7> ENE9K %]^ UEK IW=X
>=1 IG=VN S=X 7> ENE9K %]^ X>=HH QNJ' VN7^ LK Q]HE  G H
E QN-
 Q=\. IW=X M]0^ *R M
- RW IWRV.V >'NI-QN IH I-=H IWQHVK %
G= I QN IH I-M ENE %MK$ M% I-M V. ENE9K M" 
VN7^ LK Q]HE  % IHMN J>=VR 7>M LMRK K 7>M MK HIM IRMN
K I-M V. WNVW IW= X  ENE9K M"   I-GK HKZV V.  R> J -  WK
%MK$ M" J>=VR
 ZR V
$ ;
\N M
I-QN M" ENE V. I-M M" UEVK %NE Z"$
MK QNJ%]^ ENE9K G IG=VK M>' LN7> V(N P GN HIM'N ZR VN7^ LK
Q]HE  ;
\SNL %MK$ M% ENE G ;
\ X ENE9K G IG=VK G
%4
$ *N-K

IUQN% U] U N

279

IFR 7>   WJNRK G  H


E  U-  V(N IHMN IH Z R   VN7^  LK Q"    ;
\  S NL
IWQHVK %MK$ M%  P  LK UEVK %NE ENE G  (N% 7> a V  ENE9K G
IG=VK K I-M E7> ENE LMRK % G=IQN WNVW X I-M ENE M" 7>M
ENE9K K
ZN% E"  H  QNJ'  3IMR WNJ QN-   VG VN7^  Q] H E LK  %
IHMN J>=VR
 QNJ'K ZNVN LK V
$ ENE E" QN7> 7>;NR ILQNGN M
 U-K M"
G
%4. S=IXQ. % QNJ'K ZNVN LK V
$ ENE E" H H=J9 IW=X
$ H=<H GI\QN
V. 7>M ENE9K K ENE I-=H WK %MK$ K VN7^ LK % S=IXQN %]^ ENE
V(N ENE9K GK JIMXN' HRWN IG= V K K G
% 4 .  J> = V R. %  QNJ'K ZNVN
LK %]^ IHMN IH ZNVN LK I-M V. ENE9K M" ENE %MK$ M" G
%4
$ S=X WNJ
VN7^ LK G H
E QN- V(N IHMN ZRK Z. V. SM>V *
EK M" 7>M ENE V
ENE9K GN IUQN% %MK$ LN'GK I-M ENE %MK$ M% ENE9KQ. M% 
P % IHMN J>=VR
 7> IG% WK ENE9K MK KIL IG% ZR H
E E" H QN-
K L Z"$ ENE9K HIM IG]GN V. QNJGK ZNVN HIM]GK ZRN JVK %MK$ M"
I-E-K I-M ZR ENE. %]^ WK ENE9K G= IRMN M" J>=VR
 Q=L Z"% QNJ%]^
MK ENE V(N ENE9K JR? JIMXN'  HR%
U S'N IG=VN QNJ% QNJ
F"  EN HR IEQN
IW3 3 /A I- JT H NR I-M GN I-MK XNM] > G N M"  IH V= V WIUQN% %] ^
L%A,% V= H  JM> ] X NW. V(N
V(N 3NVR. G  JT Z N' G \ H  QNJ W" $  JR?
JIMXN'  HR% 
U M
 ]VAQ]V %^] JIMXN' H
$
3NVRQR( IWGWN% HK HRG  K V(N MNRAIL= V  GN F"  EN
QIWGB N %N G  M= ( . IW= X  K I-M GN XNM> ] G N M"  IH JIME. JT * ^  JT  Z K
J> ] % QNVZNW. 3NVR Z0' IFR \> G  LN' LN'U  IH ] V  V  ZM.IR3K
LK HK J94 N -K J94 N  RM  M%

3NVRQR( ZMNIR3K RWN%] G  V(N JT Z  3 WR HSKR


HIWRG W  GN#
I-= H  RWN%] G  %NZ G  ZMNIR3K K 7>  GK J^ L  ZNVN 3T K ZVK
3NRGN GWK JNJ HRZFE V
$ JK9V K 7>% RW J^LNW. W L]VRAZ]VR
H31 I%WNR' G E-K H-K NE HKV RKIRH JK9N I%WNR% G E-K
W" G . GK GWN-K WK \N-K JT ] V ^  H
- K RNMV %MK$ IZEK 7>   Z $  G
ZM.IR3K V
$  7> J G 3  WK JT N JV HKVNJT ] V ^  RW ZM.IR3KQ. %  IHMN IH
S 1 K 3NRGN I-M QNJGN JNJ HRZG] Y  JRNRS= ;  HRZ GN M"   I-M
Z>QNF %MK$ M
 HGN I-M *
U'N MK J"$GN M" *UWN% 3TK RNZ % SNEK
GN W; HKVN K 7> JNJ HTZ GN G]Y 3TK RNZ IW3'^  WNEK QNVZN
% 3TK IHT3% S'H *
IUQN 3TK SNEK WNEK QNVZN I3HNRK S'K IL%
3TK IHT3%LK G J"R IW=X ,IMR WNEN VKR ZNRH W; HKVN I- JTHNR
U>R^ LK ZM]V. V ]V.AIR3KQ. G IWXNR >'H G>\K Z% %NE *UVZVK
3NRGN JTNRS=; JNJHTZ GN H31 R
A H *
U RMK K I-=H IG% IH
I%=LK IR3VGNR G HIM' 7>aV H.3K IW=X W"$*^  W"$ IMRKR JTU1

280

3NVRQR( IW3

M
-   HIWR G W  HIWR JT Z  3 WR QR(NV HSKR JT * ^  V
$  7> J G 3  JT N JV
HKVN V(N 7>K IG% H31 V
$ Z>HV M
 U-K IH7>$IH JIW=VR L>RWG
QI;/ Z] V T   IW= X  IEI\QN M"  IH HIWR]
HIWR] [ NIRRI# QR(NV HIWR
HSKR JNJ GN Q] [ NIR  JNJ GN 3VR^  QI  M"   IFR I-K JIW= V R
L>RWG QI;/ Z]VT  IW=X IEI\QN M" IH JTZNVZN -%M -%M
Q;RZ G Q;RZ QR(NV JNJ. G WK JNJ [
R JNJ %]^ WK ZNJV HR
IG]GN M" JT*^ HIWRGW HSKR JTZ3WR  % IHMN IH S1K 3NRGN I-M
>=\ QNJG *NU. IW=X %MK$ K Z"$ QNJ' H
3 V
$ JTGN% HKVN M" V(N
IW%N3H M
'  GN JT Z N' IG= V N M"   QNJGN J> = V R ZMNIR3K RWN%] G  LK
IHMN HRGN M" IH JT*^ JNJ Z>QNF IW%N3  %MK$ HR HGN V(N QNJ
ZR V
$ %NZ 7>JG3 JTNJV HRH QNVZ HIEQN' HR
 *UVZVK 3NRGN
LK % QNJ QNH JTZ3WR HSKR JT*^ HIWRGW  V
$ 7>JG3 E"H QNJ'N
HIEQN' HRWNI-QN ZMNIR3K RWN%]G LK %]^ L
 *UVZVK 3NRGN GN
J>=VR K 3N3VRQR( GN SM>V XNQ K 7>% QNJ' ZHNEK RW
IWGWN%. %] ^  3N3VRQR( HRH  JT N IL= V  HR IG= V N IFR 
I XQN IH
L%A,% %]^ HIM'N J"$GN M" IH Z"$ RW IWGWN%. V
$ IWL" JTNJV HR E-K
M" IH7>$ %N QNJ'K ZNVN LK V
$ QNJ'N %NZ RWLKV R\WN EW. I-M

XH QNJ'K ZNVN 3TKZVK 3NRGN LK H
E LN H JTN(%N HKVK IHMN IH
ZNVN LK ZRN %NZ SGEH RWLKV R=\ GW
 ZNVN LK % IHMN IH S
1N RWN%] G  HK S> R N %NZ M"  ZMNIR3K RWN%] G  LK %  IHMN IH ZNVN
LK Z" $  NR  IWGWN%. %] ^  3N3VRQR( IW= X  JT N IL= V  HR IG= V N M"   I-
E-K ZRN %NZ RWLKV R=\ IG7> ZNVN LK % IHMN S1N I-=H IWGWN%
ZR U>R^ ZMNRNL HIWRGW HSKR JT*^  %]^ WK JTNIL=V HRG IFR QNJ'
J>=VR GN %NZ QN7>$G MK RWLKV R=\ GW.UK ZNVN G I-M WX% >'H
RWN%]G JIME. V. M=IQN IFR IHMN ZNVNLK QNJ WK *
EK M
 7>M
L>ENMN ;N'H  HSKR V. QI=I\QV M" 7>%]^ HK MRN7>'N M>' IUQN
M> '   QNI-QN
ZMNIR3K RWN%]GLK RW 3NVR. %]^ I-=H S"E 7>aV R=\H HIWRG
W HSKR JTZ3WR  GK 0$J9K G NMZ' IUQN JTZ3WR HSKR LK GK
;RZ GK S 1 K HZNEK JIME. \^ M  7> a V  IZEK IFR G> Q NR 7> a V  QNH
IHMN QN7> ZM.IR3K LK I-MK M" JRZIJVN HSKR GN [R 3TK RWN%]G
LK %  E9HK HZNEK %] ^  QNJ'N E
1 N JN'K %NE I-] % N *RNI-QN L
(94NAIL]%N LE M
R JN7>$G V. SNMR I%HE LNW V(N IHMN IH S1K I-M
E
1N ;KRA LN H HSKR %]^ G V(N L
 7>V=R 7>M GW 7>M Z"%]^ G='N
E9HK HZNEK G> Q NRN IEQ.G  E
1   IW= X  JT Z  3 WR HSKR HIWRG W  LK
% I-=H H=J9 I7>' WNEK W=YK ^-K JN IG=VK H>0 LE E
1 V
$ SNMR
I%HEH ,ZK% 7>aV IUR IUQN V(N IHMN J>=VRK I-M E
1N 3TK RWN%]G
LK %]^ G IG7> E
1N WNJ E" H QN-K E9HK HZNEK V
$ RWN%]GLK %
J=>I6QN HK 7>V=R IG=VN HSKR %HZNEK % JT*^ G>QNRN ^-K JN7>' GN
IWRV.V > ' NI-QN VG ZM.IR3K RWN%] G  LK %  JRZ J^ L  HSKR

IUQN% U] U N

281

JT Z  3 WR HIWRG W  V
$  J= > I 6QN IH QNJ%  Z R   JT 3 % GN HK 7> V = R
IG= V NJT * ^  HSKR LK %  J> = I 6QN IH HK JT 3 % K QNJGN
3T K  RWN%] G  ZMNIR3K %  IHMN
Z" $  RW IWGWN%N %] ^  3N3VRQR(
IHMNZ"
IW=X JTNIL=V HR IG=VN M" Z"$ QNJ'K ZNVN LK %]^ JTN(%N HKVK K IH
ZRN %NZ RWNLKV R=\ GW
 ZRK ZNVNLK % QNJ %]^ MRN7>' V
$ SNQG
ZRN %NZ JTKWRV% HR% %]^ IHMN M" QNJG H
E E
1 %]^ J^R' R^J' LE
%NE *RH *L' GN ZVES M" IH Z"$ IUQN% %NE Q" JTKJ^R' M. L"
E
1 N LE %NE I-IW= X  M
R  LE %MK$ ZN- U N7> M  SNMR MK IUR U N
QR(NV Z R   %NE IUQN% XRXN HR% %NE H
- K EN* %MK$ M
-  U N
QNJGN IUQN% Z R   Q] G R %MK$ ZN- U N IWQR( MK (> = H  Z= (
U  
I-E-K MNR IE\ IG7>   I-K IW= X  QNJGN IM= V  M" 
J^L HSKR JTZ3WR HIWRGW  % IHMN QNJG LE %NE JRKJ^R'
E
1 IW=X E
M GK ^-K JN7>' GN QI*JTN- M" IH ZRN IUQN% V=VWIUQN%
I-]%N *NRK =X  M" IH ILW$ ^-K E
1 G LE %]^ SNMR H=<GK M
-K %KX
LNH  R> H K M"   I-K JT H NR Z R N V= V WIUQN% QNJG  QIV IUQN%
E
H W G  %] ^  H= < H  QNJG  IMRG  IW= X  ZN LN- U N
ZMNIR3K RWN%] G  LK %  IHMN JT 3 % HR
  I-= H  SM>  XRIX= V
IWGWN% %] ^  L> E NIMQ. ;N'H.  G  Z> M = E   HE
% K  IW= X  QNI-QN G \ H
QNAJN G  *
E  A *NE  QI= I \QV L> E NM  3N3VRQR( > % ' G  E-K
I-H= V R M
 U- 
J^ L  HIWRG W  %  JT 3 % HKVN/
H
'STMZNHNIJVNM"H
'IW3'^ HKZ.
3]HRHNGNGNH'M"RWN%]GG SVN-@
7>V=R ZMNIR3K RWN%]G LK GN/A 3TK STMZN LK RL
U>' M% V(N 3TK
IW3'^  LK VU> '  > H V M% V(N 3T K  I3W LK VZ
U > '  > H V M% I-M
IV] %
$  QLRAQZR QR(NV QIW%N3K M% RW 3 WRAZM 3 WRAIZT V ] > L 
M% I-%4 .  G  ZNVNAIJVN H
- K %MK$ QNJ QIUQN%K M
  QNJ%
3N3VR. GN IUQN% %MK$ M"   Q" $ W  MK 7^ 1 AJ1.U JT 3 % HKVN M" 
RW7> J I(V T
V NW. %  VN9K WLN-K V(N ZMNIR3K RWN%] G  LK GN
ZR= ( % HKVN
J^ L  HSKR JT * ^  HIWRG W  LK %  IHMN IH ZMNIR3K LK QNJ
3T K ZGG W K *NUWV J> R N' G  VKR  H] G  V(N 3T K  I3W J> R N' GN W.
V(N W. R>GR ]IMVN QI;/ JT*^ %]^ UWNM R=\H UKVN LK 7>aV M=( R=\H
J94
 V(N Q%> W NG > ' N7>   ZMNIR3K RWN%] G  LK %  JIW= V R UKVN LK
7> J = R  M= (  R= \ H   $ M E-K IH MKA > ' N7^ $ UN
JIW= V R J> R N'. %] ^  JT * ^  HSKR HIWRG W  LK G  HIM' V
$  SNQG
I;QN% J^ R W JI94 Q N 3T K  I3WJ> R N' UKVNJT " a  U
R \J> R  V
$  JT H NI3V
ILG  Q%> W NGH M% 3T K  M%> Z N% JT  NG J G NR  IW= X  JT 3 P %] +  V
$
 7>aV IEI\QN M" IH GNI3W QR(NV HNE R^JK STMZ V(N JTIHTVK
G> R UN  G  ] 
U  JVKAJV%K IWWMNR  V
$  VU> '  3T K  IW3'^  LK

282

) 3NVRQR( IW3

RLU> '  3T K  ST M ZN LK V(N VZU> '  3T K  I3WLK GN L%Z M
I -QN I-MK
JT I HT V K G> R UN  L
 Q31] U K HMN7> $ GK M"   IVT G  W  L%%K IV] %
$  ST M ZN
IW3'^  V(N I3WLK  GK ZNVN HMN7> $ GK M" 
JIW=VR 3TKZGGWK J>RN' UKVNJ"T U
R\J>R V
$ JTHNI3V Q%>WNGH
3T K  M%> Z N% JT  NG J G NR V(N IXZ% ENE U
 WNZK  VKR  H] G  IW= X
JT 3 P %] +  V
$   V= H  J= 3 1 WR'% M"  IH *UWN% IW3'^  LK HIM
RM M% IH I-M JTIHTVK G>RUN  NYK IV]%. GK L%%K M" Z"$ I-%]^ 7>
Z$ GI\QN K LG Z"$ 6
1NAILMN S=XN K ZNVN GK 7V>VK HRG M
-
3T K  IW3'^  LK %  IHMN IH M  ZNVN Z" $  IW3'^  ST M ZN V(N I3W V.
%N3WN% M. NYN V. QIWR*NW L%Z  V(N IVR
*NW IZTV^  M>]GK M"
QNJ JT I HT V K G W K M
  *UWN% 3] H R %  IHMN M  ZNVN L H R ST M ZN V
IW3'^  QNJ V
$  7> V J] %  M
-   M% V. Z" $  3] H R WK QNJ V
$  MK 7> V J] %
M
I -QN M. QR(NV QNJ Z R K WK ZNVN M

ZM.IR3K RWN%] G  LK JIME. > '   > ' N-  Q;^ R   3NVR IWR> = ;
IUQN% E
H W G  G  QN;NR 7> a V  IV] % . ST M Z. IW3'^  V(N I3W  %] ^
QIW%N3K V QL%ZN IHMN HRGN K J>RN'. %]^ J94GN WK K IFR WK
QIUQN%K MK K IH7> $ IH ST M Z HNE  JIW= V R UKVN LK IW= X  HIM] G N
M" IH RW JTN'KQ. L
 ZR  STIMZ]Y. IW=X ZR QN;K% M%  GK S>=;K
M. LG XNM IUQN% JTGN% HR GW. V(N LG XNM QIUQN% *R GW.
7> Z$ J^R' JTZNVZN G HIM' G SNQG HNE STMZ  GN GSNW M1
IUQN V(N RWN%]G LK %^] 3J=31 IUQN% M
I-QN QE IW=X QILMN
MK IEI\QN M" JT]V^ ZN% MN%K G *"Q V
$ IHMN IH Z"$ * J94 IEQN
QILMN IHV  %MK$ IEI\QN M"   HIWRG W  HSKR JT Z  3 WR  %^ ]  IHMN V] ^
0^PN M"$ V]^ HK LN' 3NVR. G IW3 IW=X QK$ JTVKIG% J94G M. IFR
HK K RWN%]G LK % ;NRN JTWNIMH ]IHTV S
E' 3>R^ HR IG=VN 
IZ]1 V=H H]P3( HKVK M
-K H
-K M
R MK WGWN'K S
EGN IRMN J>RN' %MK$
> ' NI-QN
NR Z
L^G *
EA*NE T
VNU' L
 7> ]IHTV %]^ Z0 WK %MK$ RM
% JT * NIWV M
H   RWN%] G  ZMNIR3K LK G  ZR(% IW= X  WNMA
ZM.IUQN%K HIM' E= U    *NWQR( M"  IH JT Z  3 WR HSKR HIWRG W
LK %]^ JTNIL=V HR IG=VN V(N
V(N ZMNIR3K RWN%]G LK %]^ IWL" [
I3V HR
IG= V N JRZJ^ L  HSKR JT Z  3 WR HIWRG W  LK %  IHMN IH RWN%] G
LK QNJ' JIW=VR UKVN LK GK HZ \N-K K 7>M WK *=>E U- LG
QNJ NMZ'  IE\K 3NVR. GK = X N-K %] ^  WK %MK$ Z] % G  M
 V. Z" $
MNIRQN QNJ IL= V  
I-= H  I,] Z KGNR GN J> = V R = V WK$ HEN IW= X  J94 G N K 7>  %  H> 0
Q]URLK *N3N %^] LN' IEQN K I-=H IG% G
%4
$ IJVN J>=VR \V. IW=X
S"EU=YK E"H LN RM K NMZ' I-=H Q]URL QN IUQN 7>% S"EU=YK
WNIEQ. V
$  Q] U R L K *N3N IW= X  RNVN LN%'N XNIMQN IJVN %  J> = V R
%^] IHMN S1N I-M Q]URL QNJ' QNJ %]^ ILQNGN I=I\QV I=; HR%N

IUQN% U] U N

283

XNM>]GN M" QNJ WK V. Q]URLK *N3N LN'G M


 H=<G I-GK ZT
9 >'N
G Q]URLK S
EH IHN% G E9H % Q]UTLK *N3N IW=X ISZNRK GK 6=>1K
G E-K JTN(%.AJ=VR J^RK >'N IG=VK Q]UTL 7> %NGN% S=X GK %NGN%K
7>aV IH J=>6 IRMN M. RNVN >'N IRMN ISZNRK 6>=1K GK JTN(%NAJ=VR
QNJ'K HNR E"H Z=( IW=X M=( ZNRH X=E IJQN IHN% % QNJ' IWL
VN J>=VR GK HZR (=JA(JN-K V(N IHMN WNM J>=VR ZRN V. LKW% FE
HR IG=VN Q=L V^] Q]URL %]^ Q]URLK *N3N IW=X JTNIL=V HR IG=VN VG
J> = V R %  IHMN IH IJVN LK ZN-K S" 3 1 _R" $ Y Z R N ?N G
 V %NZH
JTVNW  WK NG K 7>M >' IG]GN V. Q]URL HNR 6=YH *=L L.GN
I-K JTHNR HIWRGW LK J>=6 H>0 RM M% V(N RWN%]G LK 7>V=R H>0
G  RM  M% I-M 3N3VRQR( %  [R [NE R= \   M%
JRZ J^ L  HSKR JT Z  3 WR HIWRG W  %  IHMN IH RWN%] G  LK
QNJ IL=V Z"$ MNIRQN ZM.IR3K RWN%]G LK % IHMN IH IE\H G
 Z"$
H=XN H]Z %MK$ HRGN JTZNVZN HSKR HIWRGW  LK % IHMN IH I-M
IHTJN WK QNJ HR IG7> IE\ E7> L
 IE\'N M" Z"$ Q]U^PN EUN GW.UN
ZMNIR3K RWN%] G  LK %  IE\ IEQN IH 3N3VRQR( IW= X  RWN%] G
IWL  K V(N HSKR NIMS JRNIL= V  M
I -QN V(N HSKR JT Z  3 WR V
$
Q]U^PN EUWN IEQN QNJ'K ZNVN LK G H
E LNH RWN%]G LK % IHMN
ZNVN LK E8 QNJG U>R^GW %]^ JTNIL=V HR% GN JTZN' *UVZVK 3NRGN
LK % IHMN J>=VR J94H >%N7> LG RWN%]G LK % JI94QN V. 7> IW=X
IEI\QN K IH 3N3VRQR( IW=X RWN%]G JTNIL=V V(N HSKR JTZ3WR
HIWRGW  IWLK M
I-QN RWN%]G LK GK ZNVN LK % IHMN IH J>=VR
QNJ V. HIM RM K Z"$ IWLK M
I-QN M. JT]V^ QNJ V. MNRH QN-
M
 ZMNIR3K RWN%]G LK % IHMN ZNVN LK Z"$ H-K IG%. V
$ EUNVNR
3N3VRQR( IW=X IWQV K I-E-K %K$G W= M
H ZR V
$ IE\' IW=X
UEVK E=UK M" IFR L.GN M. V(N MK IE\H IEQNW.UN ZNVN LK %
3RV R=\K K IH IWL"K M
' H
-K IE?V JTZN' GW$UN V. Z"$ Z]%.UK
Z I \H %MK$ ZM.IR3K RWN%] G  LK G> S NRN U-  V(N IHMN IH HSKR
NIMS Z R   IE\' IW= X  VR> = 1 K RIM U-K M"   G> S NRN IE\'N JW U N 
NIMS HSKR LK % IHMN IH I_R IE\ E7> RWN%]G LK % IFR IE\H
Q] U ^ P N EUWNH  ZNVN LK H
E  QNI-QN V. IFR IWJRKV MK JNI-QN
IHMN ZNVN LK IFR L.GN M. VKRK SNR IE\H IEQNI-QN V(N ZHN%
IW=X JTW3 HR% V
$ JIME. JI94QN PKH IEI\QN K RWN%]G LK % E
\ V
$  IGT 3 1K V(N X= E H  QNJ'  ZHN% IW= X  JT W  3  HRGN M
I -QN HIM'
E=UN IH ZNVN LK >%NW. I-M HIMH J94% E=UN V. 7>GKQ. Q=\. G
NMZ'  Q= \ R SGE U-   VKRK SNR IFR I-MK JT Z N' IEI\QN IUQN
IH 3N3VRQR( IW= X  RWN%] G  JT N IL= V  M
-   V(N HSKR NIMS IWL  K
M
- RWN%]G S
E %MK$ JNI-QN VG ZNVN LK % IHMN IH J>=VR S
EGN
IH7>$ %MK$J94H >'N HK IEI\QN M" ZNVN LN'GK K IH %NGN% J>=VR
JMN9 %NE 1HRN7>' LN IRMN M" ZNVN LK % RWN%]G LK %]^ IHMN IH

284

3NVRQR( IW3

J>=VR JTZ3WR QN- M% LNH XR%. IW=X IURH QNJ'K UEVK GK I\ZN
NX%N HR E" V(N 7>JG3 E" H QNJ'N LKW% FE HR E" RWN%]G
LK QNJ'K ZNVN LK G XR%. IW=X IURH R
' E=UN V(N IHMN ZNVN LK
I-M V. QNJ JT*^ QN- M% QNJ ZR %NE X=E
 Z"%]^ 3RZ E=UGK M"
RWN%]G LK GK ZNVN QNJ' J>=VR %^] %NE E"H JT*^ HSKR G H
E U-K
V(N RWN%] G  LK %] ^  HSKR JT Z  3 WR V
$  7> J G 3  IGENI-QN VG 7> 
ZMNIR3K HMN7> '  WNE  %NGN% JT N 'K GN J^ R ' JT Z NVZN G  XR%. IW= X
QN7> '  %NE MK 7> G NR M
I -QN J^ R ' ST M Z HSKR JT Z  3 WR HIWRG W
% IHMN RWN%]G QNJ' QH3R IUQN% G QN;NR 7>aV WK 3N3VR. %]^
%MK$ ZI0QN IH7$> I H Z R K 3R' IW= X  QN-  IS%. ST M Z HNE  IHK
GK S=>;K %]^ J^R' IWHIV M
' %MK$ IG]GN M>' IFR J94
 I-%4. JIW=VR
WG. V(N UKVN LK V(N JIW=VR J>RN'. %]^ M>' QNJ STNMZ' M
 U- M

ST N MZ' 
- K ST M Z JIMXN% #  IWGWN% 7> M K M"  L
 J^ R ' JT Z NVZN %] ^
JIMXN' E"   IFR QNJ'N HIEQN' HRWN8
IW33/A Q=L V
$  NE J^RW I-MK JIW=VR WG. JIW=VR UKVN
LK V(N JIW= V R J> R N'. IW= X  IEI\QN IUQN% HSKR JT Z  3 WR HIWRG
W  LK % QNJ'K N;R% SN'K IW=X WK IG=VN K L
 7> Z$ V
$ V(N
Q= L  V= H  G  ZM.IR3KQ. %  IWQNHR' VR> 1 K > H V *N3N HIMH  J94 % N
WK ,R^ R K %MK$ ZI0QN K V(N IHMN IH HSKR V. QIUQN%K M" 
I-%]^ QH3R IUQN% V. M" MK %MK$ I-M HK LN' ]IHTV *N3N IE\
3NVR. IW=X 6=>J U^9 RM= %]^ QK$ IWGWN% M. L
 QK$ HIM]G M.
7>M * 3NVR. IW=X IEI\QN M" V(N 3TK STMZN LK 3TK IW3'^LK V(N
3TK I3WLK G H
-K ZNVNAIJVN %MK$ M% I-M V.
QL] % ZNAQLRAQZRAQIW%N3K V(N RW 3 WR ZM 3 WR ZRV> ] L   M" $ 
RW I3T31K RX%MNR M% IV]%
$ U>'>HV M% QNIGAQNIG IWQNI\QN
P
HH M>' V=H HIM]G RM Q=L 7>MK JIW=VR 3NVR QNJ' H
E M%
IL IW=X IV]%
$ JT*^Q. 3TK STMZN LK RLU>' 3TK IW3'^ LK VU>' V(N
3TK I3WLK VZU>'  G ZNVNAIJVN GN J=31 IWWR' M" 7> Z$ QNJ'
J^RWL QI=I\QV K V(N I=I\QV WRU %]^ 3N3VR. GN J^R' IUQN%
%MK$ K IFR WK HSKR JTZ3WR HIWRGW  G>QNRN G= VIUQN% %]^
LN' S>0H 0^PEN IG=VN IH HSKR 0^P HIM IRMN M" IHK 3N3VR IW=X
%MK$ IEI\QN IH 3TK STMZN LK 3TK IW3'^ LK V(N 3TK I3WLK G H
-K
ZNVNAIJVN M% LG IH JIW=VR J>RN' 3NH3K M% IH 3TK STMZNLK 3TK
IW3'^LK V(N 3TK I3W LK GK L%ZAIZTV^ M>]GN M" I-M QIW%N3K %MK$
M% V(N I-%4. IV]%
$ GWVNW. GK ZNVN JTIHTVK G>RUN  M" V(N IJVN L
VK
I%R] L % HNE R^ J K ST M Z M" 
Q=L RW ZN%W ZNL *N-K A *"' SNEH V LWN% V(N SL>RU
S 1 N V(N S 1 K I3= I \QV M% Q= L  H
- K I-M %MK$ SIMHN HGN IH
3N3VR. IW= X  QILMN %MK$ IEI\QN ILW $  HSKR JT Z  3 WR HIWRG W
NIMS LK GK Q] I ZT V SN'K IW= X  IEI\QN M" 

IUQN% U] U N

285

Q] I ZT V SN'K J^ L  HSKR JT Z  3 WR HIWRG W  GK/A


;RZGN M LU SRN%N H
-K %N LN% JG I%RNWN%N@
QS Z"$ V>Z HM
$ IXVN-K IVTGW% HK 7>VJ=VK *N-K@
IUQN%K >% 
 IMRG EUN-K Z^R\ >% 
 UZ %N JN-K@
Z. Q31] U K IJVN I%R] L % W  LZ GNR> '  W] 3 % Q] L %@
JIME  HK%M I%R] L % RN-K JK6    ZNI-QN 7> J LN-K@
;RZRN- HK%MN *
U IWENN ZNI-QN H
 RMK VS QNN@
VK% J>=VR Q31]UK LN- STMZN IW3'^ I3W %NZ ;RN-@
VK% G W  IWVNR XEN-   I-%Z  M LU ;
\ N \N- @
VK% E
H QJ% >V GK%MN ]>% I%R]L% SNN IE%MN@
QE\I%R]L%>]%IPHN%NSTMZNIW3'^ I3W*G%NLN%N@
QE\ I%R]L% S9N S1JNRN VK% E
H LKW HK%M QMNRN@
STMZN IW3'^ I3W %MK$ SXN- HE \N- J^% ;^R 7>9N-@
IV%H  > V  M" $  VK%
$  G W N Q.;R LKW HRV M" $   W N@
V K %
$  G  W Q
R  Q  V N R N   VN H
 * L    H E   ]  N R N @
VK%
$  U> ' HN  M  IWVNRN ;RZGN Z" $  HM
$  J> H NRN@
U > '  I V ] %
$  HK  * U V K  Z " $   * ^ E  JR
  ]  N R @
H M "  H S K R  I% L  % N Z  IS % N   H"    7 V R  $  J N R @
7>JR
HV Q]IZTVWN'K IW=X JTZ3WR HSKRNIMS LK QNJ' I%LK WH
3TK ;RZGN NIMS LK %]^ HIM RM M% IH
IH ;RZGN I-M RW ]  NR
V=VWIUQN% G Q*NW V
$ IWXIEV M" IHK %]^ J^R' Z
H3 ZNRU V(N
J^R' I3T31K RX%N GN IUQN% %MK$ M" I-E-K Z"$ QNJ%^] ZR G>QNRN
RXK I3T 3 1K GK H(N > ' N7> $ GN M. S> = ; KZN% IWQHVK V. V> R ] V  Z0
LN'U JT]V^ L
 RW JTZN'. %]^ G\H WK %MK$ Z]%UN V. 7>M %NGN% JTN'K
HNE V
$ JT*NIWV M% 7>M *UVK 
U %MK$ M" M>' Z"$ G=GN M. IV]%
$
*UWN%. ST M ZN LK IW3'^  LK V(N I3WLK  HK 7> V J= V K IHW $  M
- K
I-%4 .  GK ZNVN V. Q31] U K G> R UN  V(N IJVN L
V K I%R] L % ST M Z
HNE  M"   JIME  ST M Z GK Q] Y   V
$  7> V J= V K M
- K G> R UN R^ J  7> a V
QN3HV M
H   HNE ST M Z  %  UEVK 6 9 A6N9  HKVK VG G> R UN
JTIHTVK  % I-G J1 IW=X 3R' E-K Z"$ 7>a( IUQN IL=( L
VK I%R]L%
HNE K VG *WN%K %]^ STMZ G 7>GR IW=X
$ H<H  STIMZ]Y ZV 
]\ H
 G^RK 7>aV *L IG=VN L
VK I%R]L% % JTIHTVK G>RUN  G %NE
*
U AIWEN HKVN I-%4 .  G
M . G  ] 
U  %NE IV] %
$  U> '  RLU> '  ST M ZN
LK VU> '  IW3'^  LK VZU> '  I3W LK  GK 7> V J= V K M
- K I-M IV] % .
U> ' . RLU> '  ST M ZN LK VU> '  IW3'^  LK VZU> '  I3W LK  GK MK
N;%N HRH  RW JT N 'K HNE LNE IW= X  _  M% LG V= H  WNVIWH
Z] V R %MK$ IZE U N J^ R ' Z
H 3 IHW $  M
W  U N

286

*1IHQ. %] ^  IVZNRU

*1IHQ. %]^ IVZNRU#


*"' -K3W]VK GK GRG *RK QNVZ H(N#
   Z"$ *UVZVK -K3W]VK GWK JV%K 3TK *UV >R3 GN QMENWV J>=VR
3T K  JT V NJ I] [  QMENWV JN%N U] L N IJ] Y AYKUE I,E4 N A0= 0 R IW= X
RIM] G K M. M  S] G K6
9  IVU> R ^  RNZJNE LKC Z" $  QV  Z R N JIRWNR
QNJG XR%. GK ;^E M. QNJ% N%]^ 7>M >=\ IG=VN ILGK QK$ QNJ'
I- LKW% IW= X  HG  HEJ%N WK %MK$ HR HG  K Q= L  Z" $  QNJ'K
QNJ SKVK I-=( IE\ RMK M. ILGK QNJ% NY 7>aV IHTJN S?K M" V.
IH NYK I- G> = \  *RK HMN'K %] ^  J94 H   NY  W.U G> = \ K JIRWNR WK
QNJG  QN3KRWNG V
$  HIEQN' HRWN H   NYN LKW% ISEH> E
Q] I ;HNRZ-K K L H R QNJG  XR'. IW= X  %MK$ QN7> $ G  V. Q= L  QK$
LKWV %MK$ M]>G
Z" $  ENI-ENL R
U  V
$  JK9V K Z R N *N-K *NJ9
G N I%WNK
8>ZJTHN3 J>=VR 3TK IGQN%]G RNPK L
 MIRQN'N J>IE IW=X %HRK HRGN
K WK I- SKZNRK %NE IZTV^ %]^ JTNJV M
I-QN K Z"$ WK I- 1L
7> a V  JM> ] X  X> = H K K Z" $  I- MNEV IW= X  JM> ] X  X> = H K K IH M= (  J" R
ISEH>E EHWUTV WRU M
 U- K QNWNL I%HE'K S]G M
 U-K K
LU4 N ALU4 N  YNH1R. V(N IQNI'QN %] ^  IG\NI-QN E I H% * LU4 N
I%RN3N MK M=( E=UK ZR JVK I-]%K 3RNS JK$G K IH LG [R QN7>$G
VN S=X YRG ZNR Z]L %KX E>=H L.G K [R G NR SRV% V=H 3RNS
G E-K WX IG=V QV IR HRLN X=9NQ IEQN UW.<K WK V]U K I-=H
IG% V. %3 GK MNEV IW=X I-M Z"%]^ YNEN' JN% G \^M IW=X >1' XEN
IUQN K ZM.JNJ 8JRK MWN % IHMN IH IHGK HK X=EUK Z"$ I-
[R %] ^  SRSNG HRH  MK 6= Y .UN Z R   *N-KQ. %  Z R   7> J = R  < R  NRN
J"  N YNH1R. V  IQNI'QN G  X= H R IW= X  SRSNG HR IG= V N JR Z" % ] ^
H
-K FNI-GN %MK$ M
I-QN ZRN JVK 3RNS JK$GN K V(N S=X 6
1A6
1
K >RNE IW=X H
-K MNRN %MK$ K ZRN *N-K >\SKR L
 YK+1K+K+
IW=X YRNI-WR M" 7>% JRZ J^L'K-$ IVU>R^ RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL V
$
%NZ 7> J G 3  E"  R= I \QN M"   7>  %  IHMN IH *" '  %] ^  ] V  RNZJNE LK
ZMNRNL V
$  %NZ 7> J G 3  GWN IG] G   M. ZR%N V. I-%  M"  MK I-= H
QN\RK 7> J NQ HR E" $ G  M. I- 7> a V  Z R   IJVNLK IGQN%] G  RNPK %
IHMN IH IHV H
-K %NZ 7>JG3 %NE PKH M>]GN M" I- 7>aV ZR *N-K %
I-%4. * %]^ %NZ 7>JG3 GK ZIMZN G SNR IW=X Z0NI-QN 7>G IJ=6
$
* % IHMN IH G\ E"$G M. I-M HIMH Z"%]^ ]V RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL G
XR'. IW=X E"H U- 7> Z$ IVU>R^GW IJ]Y J]LNS \
94 H
E IG=EK IW=X
IV]U HR RM K J^RN JIRWNR Z"%]^ E"H RNV  WL ZMNRNL LK G
XR'. X U-   I-M U= E   IG] S R  GK M" 
ZR *N-K % J^L RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL %]^ ZRK G>\GN-K H(N G=K

IUQN% U] U N

287

U>R^ LK % RNV  WL IV]U IW=X MK %NZ 7>JG3 GK IHTJN S\3K
7>V
$ JIME. ZRK L>SN% S]G M
 X>=HK K LK* WK %MK$ 7>PGK K LG
 G] S R GK W R  Z" $  7> P K V. QNJ'  QNJ%] ^  PKH MNEV IW= X  S
E G
JNI-QN V(N QNJ' *N-K %]^ G=IQN IH I-]% NE SNQG Z"%]^ E=U IRMN
M" IH Z"$ QNJ' RKR IW=X M. V(N ZR RKR V
$ ILW$ H
-K *NR 7>VR
IUQN M
W    Z" % ] ^  S
E G  G \  Z R N *N-K > \ SKR M" R N% RIM IUQN V(N
IHMN IH ZMNRNL RNZJNE LK V. 3N?3NV HSKR JT Z  3 WR QN-  M%
Z"$ SK9K JK$GK K 7>K IG% 6=Y IG=VK [R QN- V. ZRN JVK *UV
>R3 % IHMN IH V]^ HK %NZ E"H QN-K M. Z"$ G\GN M. QNJG %NZ
IW=X HK 3HVK M"QNJ'K Z. %]^ IHMN IH I-M X]UN %NZ E"H QN- S=X W
R U>=Y ZNRI%]U GK LU4N IV NIMS# HIM' E=U U- M% *UV >R3
I-= H  NE V= H  I-] 0  MK 3RNS JK$GN IRMN V(N [R IW= X  0U9N HRGN
IRMN
I-=H IG% I-M S]GK 6
9 HSKR NIMS URKSGN LK NIMS V ]V
RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL GKQ. VWKR. %]^ V
9% G E-K \94N M
IUQN VG
Z""$ M=( L
9H S]GK6
9 %]^ JTN(%N HKVK IH QNJ MK I-GK S=>;K %]^ H]1T
E
IW= X  HR HG  M
  VG S] G K6
9  QNJ%  MK I-%4 .  %] ^  QILMN XZVHNR
IG\NI-QN IH ZR JVK >R3 % J^LN WNEK (N% 7>aV WNJ F
1
 R=\
IG=V V(N 7>E1 J"RK$ LN H G]YWV JT'NZ HKVN VG V
$ E"H Q=L V=H
7>%4. % 3RNS SK9K QNIG * S>RN-KQ. %]^ IVQNU IG=VN I-%4. *GN
UWNM JN%N U]LN V YKUE IJ]Y M" Z"%]^ J>%RL%Z IZIEQN G\H ZR
G> = \  IW= X  G> = \ K Z R   *N-K RNIL] G R I] [  RNPK YK+Q"  +JK MIRQN'N  V
*N-K JT  Z  JT H N3 RNPK Q" Y W
H  1  IG= E K  IMV J^ R   JIRWNR %  WK
%NZGN% E"  IEQN %NZ 7> J G 3  E" '  V
$  SNQG HSKR JT Z  3 WR %  Q"  
AQ" G >=\ IG=V IH ILGK HEJ%N WK %MK$ HKVK LN HGK NYK Z=0
%  = J  \N IEQN K Z= 0  GN ISEH> E  S> R N MNE K YNH1R %] ^
IG\NI-QN V. 7>% G=IQN IH I-% H
-K ,IMRKEK WV^ \N E-K V(N
 I-]L"aH3% EUN IG=V QUE IG% Z=0 GKQN Q=\. IW=X
$ %KEN JN'K
WIM'N 3>R^ M
 IUQN V(N Z=0 Q]%4K M
 U-K YNH1R WK M=( \94 HR U-
 VG RNV IW=X >J% IW=X IVU>R^ GW RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL %LR QN-
 7> % 4 .  %  Z= 0  G  RKR V  M= (  F I RQN W R   7> a P  V. QK$ V(N
UW.<KQ. % QNJ'KQ. Q=\. %NE Z=0 G Z]^M IW=X =J %]^ GI\QN V(N
7>  %] ^  SNMR H= I <QN Z= 0  PKH M
 U-K V(N J^ R N G= > ;  G '  E= U K Q"  
AQ" JVN %MK IH]% >=\ QNJ% N%]^ IG=V M% H=E V=H NY H
E 
R>J- V=H %MK$ M]>G K JR Q=L I-%4. \V. IW=X ;]% 7>JLGN M" V(N
IH G Q=U M=( F"EN7>' GK LR^RV %MK$ RMK UW.<K HIM]G M% IH
QNJG  U> R ^  LK MK QNJG  E-K MK RNZ M%  QIUQN%KQN G> Q NRN
SIMHNI-QN M
I -QN *
E NA*NEN ZNL HK LN'  QNJGK ZIMZN %] ^   ] V
RNZJNE LK G IWR
;K V. IRF IX=H9 7>6NE'N LN'G M% ILG %NE
U>LRGK M" 7>MK G= HGN M" 7>%]^ QNJV
$ HK H>0 IZIEQN M" QK$

288

*1IHQ. %] ^  IVZNRU

QNJ%]^ I-MK JTN(%N HRG M. IH N%]^ QNJ' XR'N IW=X MK R=\'N V(N
QNJ MLNR. NE I-VR4 .  MK G> \ KQ. GN MNRN S'  RM
  IVU> R ^
RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL J^ R ' JT Z NVZ. GN QWVNR QN-  M%
QNJGN %NZ E" '  G  SNQG NY  [R IW= X  I-] % N > = \  IZIEQN JT Z 
3WR L
 IH QK$ WR'% %MK$ HR HG   IFR WK WR'% HR% GK
H
I 33 HR RM  M. Z" $  QNJG  V
$  ] %   IW= X  %NZ 7> J G 3  IEQN
7>G HRKS Y< NE G SNQG I-=H [1%N [1K L
 I- JTHNR M"A
I-=H RNV Z"%]^ I-M * IG\N-K IG=VN IH Z"$ IJ]Y IW=X 3Z3N% J>=6
RMK M. IH IH=( M" Z"%]^ G=IQN V IHMN IH QNJ H=E I-=( MK QN7>'N
M" 7>M Z>]YN' JN% GN 3Z3N% K LG WR M
-K V. Z"%^] M",N M
IUQN
Z" % ] ^  I-] % N ILQNGN IR IW= X  GRG M
 IUQN IH Z" $  1= H R ZNRH  ZR
LNW. ZV G NR HNR' J^R' M
 U- YNH1R %]^ S>ENI-QN IUQN V.
7>%4. % I-]L"aH3% EUNI-QN 7>G SNQG YNH1R % G=IQN IH I-M
V. ZR X>=HK M" 7>G SNQG XNR G^V IG\N-K IG=V IFR 7>%4. % IHMN
Z"%]^ G
%
4$ VRF
$ JH9 IEQN QV S
E N%]^ *UWN% % *ILQN M" QNJ%]^
E"H LNW.U QNJGN Z. J^RN M
IUQN M" Z"$ IHMN IH ZR U>R^ LK %MK$
E" H   LN' G ' U   IFR 7> % 4 .  %  IHMN IH QNJG  U> R ^  LK HK HR'U 
QNJGN Z. J^RN M
IUQN M" QK$ I-VR. HR.U IH QNJG M=( %NE
MK QNJGK ZV HRWN GW.U 7>G SNQG ZR G
%
4$ M=(. % UE %]^ S9K
L
R %NE GSNI-QN IL %NE ZR JTN' Q=\. IW=X QN U- Z"$ IH %]^
S
E %N HK S]GK6
9 HIM]G M% IH QN Z VR [1 % [R"$ V]^ RNZ
HIM' %N JN- U N# I-M I(VK Z R   %NE M
 U-K 7>  V
$  SNQG HSKR
NIMS HZE G F>E V ZR H
E JTU1 M
- 7>V
$ SNQG ZR Q]GR J^L
IGU>R^ RNZJNE ZMNRNL GK QNWNL QN-K IH I- E9HK %]^ IHW$ E"H
LN7>$U QK$ I-%]^ %MK$ LN' GW.U I-%^] V. QK$ XNM.U VG E"H
LNW.U I-GN LHR J"R WK H=1 IG7>$U V. QK$ 7>M WK L
9 GW.U
 %NE MK U>R^ LK % HNFK U=E. HMKQ. L
 * WR'% %MK$ JN RMKQ.
M% 7>G SNQG Z G G^V *=L U- 7>G SNQG U>R^ LK % Z"%]^ IHMN
YR ZV V R K Z V  %] ^  QK$ 1NE IG= V N M"   M> '  QK$ XNM.U  VG E" H 
LNW.U 
NYK I-=H Z=0 IL%]^ S=XN M
' WNEN K 7>M I-=H IG% ISEH>E S>=V
GK VR4. M
 U-K YNH1R %]^ S>EN H IEQN- V. YNH1R % Z$ V
$ JIME.
MK M=(. %NE S=XN H=I<QN 7>G SNQG Z=0 % LR %MK$ JN-K IHK G
HIM' V QK$ L
 (
9KAILMK LR SNMR M>]GK M" 7>V I-=1 S]% IG=VK V.
7>M LR 1=>1 U-K LR G 1>=1 LN' G HNR' Z=0 GK MNEV SM>V \RNS
M
 U-K * HIM' E=U IH I-M Z=0 M>' SX %MK$ HGK QK$ [SRNH
RNV %]^ J]L YNH1R. G H
E U- ZUR I-=H WK YNH1R %MK$ QNI-QN
HIM' E=U I-M H I%J1N7>'N NY W= GK U=E %MK$ M" M>' JTZNVZN
MK SXN HGN M" 7>G SNQG SM>V MK G>\K M
H Z"$ QN3N 6=Y IG=VK
IH Q=L Z=0 %]^ H
-K %MK$ SXN HGN IFR Z"$ IHMN IH *UV LK QN3N

IUQN% U] U N

289

%N 6= Y
  QNJ'  S] G K 6
9  S PKH HR'U   7>  G  SNQG S] G K 6
9  G
NMZ' G]YWV JT'NZ HKVN V(N JTN(%N HKVK 7>G SNQG WR I-=H
YNH1R G H
E U- V. 7>% QNH GI\QN V. IHMN I-M SXUK %MK$
I- VR4. MK NYK Z=0 G %NE M
I-QN K W=Y YNH1R % SM>V H
I33
HKVK JR %MK$ SX JN-K 7>G SNG HIM' E=U JTZ3WR GK IGQN %NE
SX WK U-K V. G>; %MK$ GWUK 7>G =V IG% SNQG U>R^ LK IG\N-K
IG=V Z=0 GK Q.V9KQN IW=X
$ LR H=< RM M% WR Z=0 % LR H=<K
V(N 7>M PKH M
 U-K QV  IH=E
 G=>; G' E=UK I-M NY S]GK6
9 GK
IHT J N M"   LG IH A UW.<KQN GKQ. Z= 0 . I- SKZNRK %NE ZR
X> = H KQ. %
Z R N 6
1 N E9HN ILGK 7> Z R NE M"   7>  GN %NZ %W%KV M" A
I-%]^ SXJ% 6 ZMK% GN K VG  V
$ MK I%Z
%KQN M
 IUQN K J]L
NE V= H  7>  GK SKZNRK ?VZ %MK$ M
- K Z R   MR ] * W H
I 33 HR%
%NE V(N YNH1R G Z%4N HR% 7>aV WK Z"$ MNR %MK$ Z]%K I-=H IG%
Z"$ 7>%]^ VU>R^GW RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL V
$ %NZ GN% IGENI-QN 7>K
IG% V
$ Z]%
 ZR S=X %]^ H
-K SKZNRK K MK %MK$ M>' 7>M S=XN Q=L
QNJ'K 7>ZR G * S=IXQ. W.U V]GR>V M" I-M * XZVHNR NY
IVU> R ^ G  W  RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL GK QKZ IHT J N %NE M" 
I-=H IG% J^RI%ZN G IV]U G Z$ NE  IW=X SRNV %N
M
' G HNR% NYK FE XNWE  >=H RMK K V %IMR WK QN H XEK
U-K K I-=H ZMK% SNQG G>SNRN %IMR QN7>'K K 7>a( I17>SW"aE
V
 JN'K G' GN N;% %MK$ K QK$ IRF %IMR V
$ MK KZV K
JT ] V ^  J^ R I'ZN G  IG% QK$ QN3RZ IW= X  IV] U  ZNJV M
'  G
SNQG LG \V %]^ G\' U- V. NY <N-K -H9 ,ZK% ;N' WNEK  U
Y
AU
Y JN'K %NE *RK M
-K K I-M HG >J% IW=X WK %N M
' WNEN H]Z
K L
 NY IVU>R^GW GK IHTJN %NE M
 IUQN V(N NR \V G UW.<KQ.
% QF
 HKVN IH I-M %IMR V. QNJG U>R^GW % IR_ QNJG E-K
S>EN-K M" NR E
H. GK FE IW=X ILQNGN V
$ ILQNGN  Z% ;N% MK
M
I-QN LGIH IVU>R^ GW GK IHTJN %NE NYK  Z% JTIV -H9 M
-K
Q%H. Q%H. >=\ NY S]GK 6
9 IVU>R^ RNZJNE LK % N%]^ IG=V
M% Z R   G
% 4
$  J> = V R *UV QIZV V(N %W%KV  Z-K  %^ ]  IG= E K
J>IE IW=X %HRK E=U U- ZRK V(N ZR JIRWNR W=E
$ NR JNPH. %]^
JTN(%N M" IH QNJ LEGK VE
H QN3RZ HR$(N IW=X QNH ]V RNZJNE
LK ZMNRNL V
$  Z> F V %NZ JT N JV HR
  Z%> = \  LKW% IWQNR( %N
HR
 HSKR JT Z  3 WR HIM] G   M% /A
HEHR
QNLHRQNLHR
QSJEZ"JTEM
-UKSM>RHR
UHS@
IV NIMS C L" S]GK6
9 C IVU>R^ RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL HK L" C
 7> a LI9QN JIRWNR WIQN#
Z"$ *UV RZ3 J>=VR 3TK 7>ZG I][ IJ]YAJ1WN9 VIM+M.K I,E4N

290

*1IHQ. %] ^  IVZNRU

IMNR GN RIM' WNEN M. M>' I-]ZJEN-KL HE


%K LE G NMZ' LK$G
IW= X  IM JIRWNR RIM] G N M.
%NZ E"' V
$ JIME. QK$ *^V. GK J^LN HRG K NY IJ]Y SNSN
RKQN GK ZN%VN K IL 7>aV QK$ JTVH ZMK% GK J^RI'ZN %]^ L
VK
EUN7> '  L.G  K QK$ 3> H RWNR L%ZQ31ZK I3WRNVRK GN WRV
WK HRG  K IJ= V R. G  IJ] Y  GN% QV  3RN; WK H= < G  K IFR WK
NYN [R ISEH>E 7>L9 X>=IHQN K LG Z"$  NE GN K VG ZR
IJVN LK GK IZTV^ M
 U-K K [R IW=X IV]% Z"$SR K IV]%. GK QNJ
IW= X  E9N-K RIM] G K K IV] % . %] ^  *^ V AJT  V  SM> V  G> \ K HIRQN HRG  K
V(N IV]% SM>V ILQNGN SKZNR RIM]G K JIME YNH1R. %]^ IG\NI-QN
JR H
-K QNRNZ %MK$ M
I-QN IFR WI9Q. G H
E U- H
-K HIM]GN
QNJ  R> J -  G  IG7>  Z" $  QNJ%] ^  ISEH> E  PKH HR GWNU. H
- K
HIM] G N QNJ  R> J -  G  IG7> 
QK$ ISEH>E 7>L9 X>=H K JT]V^ H
-K QNRNZ %MK$ M
I-QN ZR
IR3V G NR *UV R[> S KR I] [  IJ] Y  H $ ( HE. WNE  G  SNRA HIM'
7>aV ZRK ZNVN LK % ]%  IW=X ]V RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL V
$ %NZ
E" IEQN ZRK JV%K %]^ J]L NE 7>JR]V WK H
-K ]VN% 7>VJ]% %MK$
M
-K K ZRK ZNVN LK G HIM' V ZRK JV%K % WK ]V RNZJNE LK
ZMNRNL V
$ %NZ 7>JG3 E" IEQN %NZ GN% E"$G MK NE G Q]GR ZRK
JV%K %  I-= H  E9H  %] ^  L%Z IG= V N Z R N *UWN% V
$  IW3WN 7> a P
X>=IHQN K I- HNR% Z"$ %NZ %MK$ IEQN V(N QNJ'K ZNVN V JV%K
%]^ ]V LK G H
E LN' V
$ Z%4N HRGN K ZRN E9HN L
  IG% GN K
SM> V  ILQNGN SKZNR M
 IUQN YNH1R. %  HIM IG= V N K IH I-M
E9HN W R  V= H  ZR LNW U N I-%] ^  E"  LN7>   3NZ %^ ]  I-= H  *UV %
S]GK6
9 IVU>R^ RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL G SNR G=IQN IH QN3RZ LK$G
IW=X QN- M% 7>M J^R' ]V M% V 7>M MK I- S=X %]^ PKH HR HG
M% QK$ YNH1R. V WI9Q. G H
E LNH (=H X>=H K ZRN *UWN%
V
$ IW3WN 7>P IUQN K Z"$ 7> *UV %]^ Z%4N HR IG=VN JT]V^ 7>G
G>SNRN IFR JTN(%. HKVK IH W"$ S]GK6
9 *UWN% MK ;RVK 7>aV QN-
M
- M% LHR I-M IGQN HR G' V. I-M E9HN PKH M
 HGN M" 7>
*UV G I-]% IW3WN G %NE HIM' 7>aV Z"$ QNJ'K ZNVN LK %]^ Q%>ZVK
G IG=VK ZRK Z. % E9H %]^ E" LNH IVU>R^ RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL G
XR%. IW= X  R= \  IG= V N QV  R
$ G  M
-   JT N (%N HKVK IH ZMNRNL LK I-M
S= X N ZR X> = I HQN M"   M> '  QNJMK I-%] ^  PKH HR HG  M% VG
S]GK6
9 IVU>R^ RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL % IHMN IH HSKR JTZ3WR GK RLN
%NE I-M PKH M
 LNW U N QUE  IG% LG S= X   %^ ]  ZR'N K 7> M  PKH
M
IUQN@S
E
 S]GK6
9 IVU>R^ RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL GK L"@
NYN 7> a LI9QN M
I -QN [R S] G K6
9  IVU> R ^  RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL
GK IHTJN %NE G>SNRN S IUQN I-]% XZVHNR G\ HR WK JNJ HTZ.
V(N *^V. GK J^LN MK
GK WL4N V
$ Z"$ %NZ %MK$ IEQN V J^RW WNEK J^LN V(N

IUQN% U] U N

291

HRGN IRMN NY [R 7>aV S]GK6


9 URKSGN LK ZMNRL GK SN'K GN
JNP ]V RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL HRG K QV Z"$ SNMR LNH 3RNS JK$GN
K IFR I-=H NE SNQG I-=H IG% NY [R JNP M
 IRMN K VG 3NZ
%] ^  S] G K6
9  IVU> R ^  RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL %  IV] U  HKVN VG Z" $
IV]U >I'QN QV %NZ WK E" IEQN IFR NY [R IW=X G>=\ %NZ GK
XKL %MK$ RMK ZRK ZNVN LK % IH G SIMHNW IW=X QNH %NZ \]IYV
HR IG=VN H>0 Z$ SNQG ]%  IW=X ZRK Z. %]^ QXN%H J"R X
LE% M
' E=UK YNH1R. %]^ IG\NI-QN 7>%4. % G=IQN IH SE=Y H"$R
M" I-M A IG% IW=X ZR LNWUK LHR JK+LK+QN-K+ X]YKU94 IW=X
E" LN7> V. 7>a( Y< E=\ R>J- EUNH I-M ILQNGN V
$ ILQNGN I-=H NE
LKWV RIM HGK M"   JT ] V ^  GRG [= 1  %MK$ M
W  U N S] G K6
9  IVU> R ^
RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL % G=IQN IH QNJGK ZNVN % %NZ \]IYV HR IG=VN
M" ILW$ ISLEK GN ISE %N *R% %NE H>%"aH3% H=1 LN' %NE IZE'
WNE  EN* S] G  M
 L.G  M% 7>  %] ^  IFR XNR^  HRN7> ' N J" $ GN M"   Z R K
ZNVN LK % QNJ'K UEVK GK Z>QNFK Z]UK ZMNRNL LK % G>SNRN %NZ
IG=VN V(N IR 7>aV M=( R=I\QN IR 7>aV M=( R=\G MK J"R GK LE%
V(N GRG S]G M
 IUQN IFR EU*U G
 NE G SNQG LN9 H=<WN7>'
G HNR' LN9 IW=X \^% I%HE' E=UN YNH1R % GWN-K IG=VK QV 1.H
EUN-   JT ] V ^  \^ %  I%HE'N S] G  %MK$ M
I -QN IFR YNH1R %  7>  GK
ISZNRK X"H HKVK QV G=IQN IH I-%]^ SE=Y H"$R M" QV I-M F>=1
X>=HN M" M>' I-M PKH %MK$ M
 HGK I-%]^ [R E" LN7> I-M \^%
I%HE' %NE G
 IG% IW= X  ZR LNW U K IFR QUE  IG% I-G  IJ3NS
QV E"1RK% IW=X WK \^% QN7>'N 3>R^ M
IUQN VG Z"$ IVU>R^ RNZJNE
LK ZMNRNL LK %]^ F
% 7>aV G=IQN IH YNH1R % IHMN M" IH G
 IG%
IW=X ZR LNWUK VG IVU>R^ RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL % IHMN IH S]GK6
9
L
 HR%U  PKH HR%U   IFR QUEK RNV %] ^   WL  7>  %] ^  ZG^ V  E" '
E-K QN- ZRK Z. % IHMN IH VR IJVN LK L
  NE JIME. U>LR
X=>H K  Z"%]^ E"' G E-K QN- M
- M% I-]%N HIM]GA 7>M ZG^V Z
RK Z. G  Q] G R JT W  3  HR IUQN QV  HIM' E= U N IH Z" $  I-%] ^  E" H 
LNWNU. I-GN Z. J^ R N M
 IUQN M"   Z" % ] ^  XNM IJEN7>   VG QK$
7>G E-K XNM S'N7>' G E-K R=\K MK K I-]% IW=X 7>M ZG^V HIM'
E=UN IH JVN %MK$ QNJG [R IW=X IH]%K W=YK 3HVK M" 7>M Z"%]^ ZNR
RMK M" Z"$ I-=( M
R %MK$ R>H HGN Z"%]^ LEGK %NE XNM IJEN7> Z"$
LN IRMN M. QV  URZ XNM MK JK IUQN L.G  M
-   HIM' E= U N IH
QNJG [R J^R' JTZNVZN \94 M% Z"$ I-%]^ %MK$ E"H LN HGN I-M
HIMH 7>M XEN IUQN I-=H IZ]1 SNQG MK \^% S]G M
 IUQN LK* QV
G]G L
 ISEH>E HNE M
 X=>H % 7>M ISEH>E N_ M
 U- QV S]GK6
9
IVU> R ^  RNZJNE GK IHT J N %NE 7> M  JIME. %NE
$  ILQNGN W( M

U-K JTZNVZN HSKR NIMS LK % ZRK ZNVN LK GK  NE 7>ZR W;N
IG=VK  L>EN-K  %]^ =XK *UVK HRH VE
H JT(N% HKVN S
E

292

*1IHQ. %] ^  IVZNRU

S] G K6
9  IVU> R ^  RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL GK L"   IV NIMS@

U>RG PKH HR%N V(N 3"VN% %]^ I-%N% S'N7>'N#


Z" $  *UV LUGK3 J> = V T  T K  JT * ^ R NZ IJ] Y AJ] L NS \
9 IG= E KA
YK+1K+K+ IG=EK 1T.J
R1 HNRJ
R3%  IW=X ZH"I%H M. Z"%]^ 3RNS %
RN\33 IWRVK GN I-] % N% S'N IG= V N K 3RNS JK'N Z> R UN \N'N
IUR1 JK'N M> H N JK'N
Z"$ %HRK V
$ 3NZ %]^ EU*U  L.  WL QN L.GN K H-K SNR
[R QN7>' 7>aV 3RNS ILQNGN JK' 7>aV  L.  WK W=L L.G %
3RNS IW=X JNUE M
I-QN I-=HWNR 7>;R E9\9N7>$G M
- J"R. %NE [R
JM>]XGN K QN7>$G MK JV%K QV S=IXQN %]^ H>1'N 3>R^ HR G'N MR
R
L [R IW=X HIMR M>]GN K IL%4. S=IXQ. %]^ IJQNR %NE 6NVK %NE
EUN7>'N XNMKGN K 7>M ZN^Z S=X Z"%]^ G\H Z]L %KX E>=H L.G %
S= X   QNJ'  IJVNLK G  [R QN7> '  GK RNM G \ G  M% IH JNJN LK
QN7>'U NY E-K \N' GK H
-K XKL IEQN7>'U JT]V^ Z"$ \N' GKQ.
XKL. GK SLN- 3RNS IW=X JNUE M
I-QN ENE Q=\. %NE 7>%4. %]^ ZNR%
E=U L.GN K
G^R JN ZRK ;RZJV%K >IZVRN GWK WK QNJ' G>=\K LKW% G
%NE \VR%NH ISZNRK %NE L^0GK M
-K QNJ'K NM J^R HR RMK K
7>G G
%4
$ U>RG \RNS M
 X=H % YNH1R. % HIM IG=VN K IH GWN-K
\.G RM
 JT]V^ 6 ZMK% V
$ ILQNGN I-M IL]G. %MK$ RIM HGK QNE
I-]YKQN Z"YKHE V YN+RNZ Z%
MR E
MKQN MN=IJ1E IG=EK V
$ WK I-M
IRJ
R1 IZEK IH U>RG \RNS M
 X=>H M% QV 6 ZMK% V
$ ILQNGN LKWV
%MK$ RIM HGK QV %NE MK GWN-K Q]V Z$ V=H \N'K JWUK 7>%4.
ZN^Z S=IXQ. GN HK MNE M
WUN ILGN IJVN 3RNS JK$G. M
W Z. ZV
G  Z^ ] M  IW= X  M
W    H
- K WL% GN H] Z  WK %MK$ HR HGK V. 7> % 4 .
S=IXQ. %]^ LG I-M JVN X=IEQN IH 7>%4. GK Z]ZK ZNVN LK  6 ZMK%
V
$  ILQNGN LKWV %MK$ RM U K V. 7> % 4 .  S= I XQ. GKQ. Q= \ . IW= X  M] 0 ^
WIM]G RIM]G K I-=H V. IJVN LK 3RNSK QV G^R JN NYK ZNVN
LK LN%E W N SKZNRK V
$  JK9V NYN HK M
W  U N IV] %   E9H  V(N I-= H
E9HK QNJ'K ZNVN LK G H
E QNH R
' E=U V(N IHMN IH M *UWN%
N%^] * %^] *K NYK ZNVN LK G %NE MK QNJ' JN S>EN E"'N I-=(
IHG  MNR  LKW.U 
JTZNVZN % 7>%4. S=IXQ. GK WK J>HNR >'K QV NY 3>* HRZ 7>G"
M
-   NY  U> Q .< IW= X  MK *UVZVK I%MNEK G W K %  QNJ'  U> R ^ G  W  ] V
RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL GK QNIUQN Q%>  NR AA L%WRK  %] ^
IVU> R ^  URKSGN LK ZMNRNL LK GK Q] I ZT V SN'K GN IV] %  IG% GN
QN\]Y JNP QNJ' [R HRWNI-QN IL IW=X ]V RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL
%  IG]SR  %]^ RNV IW=X  V
$  WL V=H IV]U HKVN Z
RK ;T Z JV%K > I ZVRN G W K WK UQ.< IW= X  IV] U  > % ' XEK U-K

IUQN% U] U N

293

(
94K GR SNQG Z"$ LUGK3  WK QNJ'K %HRK V
$ [R QN IUQN [R
QN7> '  V
$  SNQG S= I XQ. V
$  JVN E= U N IH NYK ZNVN LK U> Q .< IW= X
ZN-K I%MNEK GWK G [R IV]U >%' G E-K U-K M" I-M >'H Z"$
SM>V HT
I;V M
I-QN IH IH=( JN\]YKQ. G H
E XEK U-K Z"$ M>' 7>%]^
H> = 1 G  M
-   [R IEQN7> $ GN M. I-M IWXNR HRH  Z" $  *UVZVK I%MNEK
GWK G [R XIEQN IUQN Z"$ 3RNS JK R=\K K LG Z"$ I%MNEK ZN-K
G  [R JM> ] I XQN V. ] V  RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL IV] U  HR RM  %
SM>V ]I\QN IW=X *UVL% IV]U >' RM % 7>%4. * %]^ G\H Z"$
H>0 %MK$ S
IEQN V X>=JXNJ *V
$ IJ=6 S"P IUQN Z"$ IV]U >I'QN
IV] U  IW= X  ZMNRNL LK %  G= I QN IH/
3RNS JKW H9WN JN%K =VR L%Z 3WN% G LN%K
U R K S   
 % N R K  LN R K  HR    > R N J N %  
 S N R 
I - = H  IX E Z  M > = H N  * R    Y^ S   H N E K  ; N R @
HSKR ZN%>   L%Z JN-  HR %MK$ *L  MIR %NZ@
L" H>QN LE IS%N  \>GWNI-QN IH HNZ@
ZMNRNL LK % IV]U IW=X G=IQN IH IL%4. S=IXQN %]^ IJVN LK %^]
K%  %NE EUN7> ' N XNMKGN M"   7> M  3RNSK IWQHVK %^ ]  G \ H  S= X 
XNRJN-K G %KX 6>J L.G M% 3RNSK IWQHVK QNJWK G>=\K ;]%MN%K
ZNL IW= X  I-= L V \VZ V(N JIRWNR V(N U> Q .< V(N IR3V G NR. V= H
%]^ JT3N% HRH SG G>QNW. JTNJV HRGN M" ILW$ 3RNSK GK JV%K W
S=X V. HIMR GN I3HNR M]>G M% JT]V^ JV%K G ZNVNAIJVN *"'A*N-K
WK IG%ARNV IX]VV RIM]G M% RW JNJ GN *NR 7> %NGN% 3RNSK
G  3K3 7> a V  QN L.GN M"   Z%> = \  L%Z JT * ^  %  *UVK HRH  QNVZ
HIEQN' G  E-K IG= V N M"   I-%] ^  3RNS QNIG IW= X  %31 %MK$ HR%N
XNMKGN  ILW $  S= X N H^ E  IW= X  I= I \QN UT I M' %MK$ HRGN QWNRN
UTGK IW=X []>ZGN RIM]GN M" 7>M I=I\QN V
$ W]IXV RIM L.GN M" IFR
NRK 7> Z R ZLG^ R K HRH  LKW% I%T W NM HRGN M"   IFR 7>  %] ^  NG
QN7>$GN M" IH L Z"$ QWNRNURGK %N HRGN V. Q=L QNJ' IMJNPKQ.
GK VR4. W=YN QI;HNRK M>]GN JT]V^ M>' HK S' I-M V. 7> Z$ 
X'N
K
HSKRNIMSHIM]G M%IH/AQ=6 IG%JK6 U-U>R^  IHQN%NMVQS
J6VN-IHQNHRLSIX9KQ.X>UU-K$\V@

I- JTHNR LHR Z%>=\ L%Z IW=X L


 JTN'K JT*^ *UVK %MK$ HRGN
7>M J3^AJ]6KQ. GK L^%KQ. %^] JTNJV M>]GN M" L
 IWQHVK 3RNS JK$GN
M" 7>M 3RNS G %3 IW=X \N' GK *RK (NEK %]^ E=V ZNRGN M" *UVK
%N HR% %NE I*] % A JT N 'KQ. GKQ. L^ % KQ. IW= X  H31 7> P N7> $ GN M" 
HG 7>M H=>V GK L^%K ;NR' HRGN M" H>=VN NRK RNV RGK IW=X UEK
IW= X  RIM] G N M"   7> a JR V
$  WR\N V(N RGK GK RNV IW= X  ZM.H31
7>PN7$>GN M" WR *>=\ VN7>$GK M" IH [R GK R
-K IW=X [>3' GK
H
I33 HRGN M" [RWNE Y]YN L. J=(R ZNRG M% H>=VN SM>V GR V=H

294

*1IHQ. %] ^  IVZNRU

IXEN7> $ GN RIM] G N M"   IFR M


R  [R IW= X  W9GN M"   7> a (  %N LN'  R
1 K
IZE U K L. 
1 K Y] Y N  L  7> a (  WK Y] Y N %KS IW= X  M
I -QN V. 7> M
3RNSK L
 M> '  H> = V N SI'QN M"   IJ] Y  G  SNMR L.GN M"   *> = \  %NE
IWQNH> E  M
I -QN Z%> = \ . GN ZE \.GN M"   L H R 7> M  %NGN% JT N 'K LG
Z%>=\ RKR IW=X K IV]U IW=X QN7>$GN X]U IWXNR >'GN S>RN-K
IVQNUH  QNJ'N HIEQN' HRWN7> $ GN V(N S= I XQ. %] ^  X] U K I= I \QN
V(N JT * ^  GK GKH3N JT G N% HRWN7> $ GN GN > = \ K M
 L.GN 3RNS GN
%3N H>0 Z$ RIM]GN M" JTZNVZN G %NZ *L% %NE M
- >=\ GN QN%]G
GN %NE RIM] G N M" 
7>JR
HV V]U QNGR'K-$ ]V RNZJNELK ZMNRNL GN >'H ZRK
3RNS 6^ Z]VT M
 U-K Q=\. IW=X
$ M]0^ SIM X=E [R XEN IUQN %K$G
%N QN-K  L%WRK  G>JIMR / WL QNJ'K JV%K %]^ %NE E"H
]V RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL G H
E IUQN 7>%4. V
$ QNVZ HIEQN' G E-K
7>JG3 JTNJV HKVN 7>G SNQG Q=L   V=H 3RNS V]SNH^ V(N
ZN 6^IMQN WK %MK$ ZRK JV%K % WK IVU>R^ RNZJNE LK V
$ 7>JG
3 IEQN 7> IG% G SNQG 7>M ISEH>E PKH M" YNH1R. G I-ENL
V(N Q" H AR  QNIG GKQ. IRJ
R 1. Q= L  WK NY  [R R= \ KQ. M%
L%AL% %] ^  IG\N7> $ G  M.
ZRK RW %]^ JDTN(%N M" IH QNJ WK JT*^ G XR'. IW=X QN7> ]V
R^ J  IW= X  QN-  JT Z  3 WR G  ] G  3  WNMH ] V  RNZJNE LK %] ^  JIMXN'
 
Z> F V %NZ 7> J G 3  JT N JV HRH  IHT J N QNJ'N HIEQN' HRWN7>   IV
NIMS@
*UV LUGK3

*^V. V R
U. G VN- JIRWNR %]^ QNSNG HR%N#
  *UVZVK QJE3 GWK JV%K 3TK RNZMR J>V= R TK W+ Z.URNZ IJ]YAIZRX

VIMKE XR\K GNGRK ILE4N I*WN%K MIRQN'N 


   Z"$ QJE3 GWK QNJ' G>=\K LKW% GK 0EH QNJ%]^ G= RMK M. Z"$
QV ZR S=X RNM>E QV L
VK M% L
 SKV Z$ G S>R MNENV. %]^ NG
HRH YR L.G M% ILGN WR'% HRG Z$ HELN Z]^M %]^ QN7>$GN M"
 IG]SR  GK RNV %]^ SGZN3. % ZR JVK %]^ IY7^1K G GRN%
LN% V
$  ZNR IG= V N K E I H% 7>   J^ R ' JT Z NVZN HSKR NIMS  %
NYN I;QN% R= I \QN QV  Z R   JVK %] ^  LKW% GN% IG= V N L
 Q= L  N%] ^
JIRWNR IMV S] G K6
9  U> R ^  RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL GK IGQN %NE J^ R '
JTZNVZN G XR%. IW=X (N% IZE IUQN M" NY JIRWNR IW=X ZR JVK
%^ ]  NF H= J 9  JN7> $ G  MK H> 0  G R  SNQG Q] Y RWKQR G  7> a JR G  IM=  
7>aV IL=( RS9 GN %NEN M>]GN M" 7>M XNR
$ JNI7> \^% %NE H=J9 R]UK%
M
 L.G K V(N S=IXQ. %]^ WK SEUZ G %NE \^% QN7>$GN K QV Z"$
WK I-=H NE V
$ MNR1 IGE  GK ISZNRK V
$ SM>V JT3N% M
 X>=HK K

IUQN% U] U N

295

ILG  E-K NE. V


$  GWN-KQ. \N RMK K Z R N JVKG W  IG= E K J> I E
IW=X M% ZR NR RKR 7>aV F
9AIF%KQ. M
 L.G % [R IW=X JT
3N%KQ. G HNR% ZR JVK RNZMR GN IGZNUK ]V>E% WK IWU9 IUQN
K
QK I-%4. JT3N%KQ. G E-K ]%  V
$ L>EN-K  V=H GTL%
V
$ WK ILQNGN E]U9 E
*K V ENEXK U>R^Q. G GRWNL \9A\9N- V(N
*NRV G  * VKR( (N%. ILW $  LZ> % N U] U N MIRG> Q NR LWNEN LK
XNZ] > Y N IX] V J> R 'K %URH
1  SNEN LK Z $ MGK J> R  V(N U> Y U.WN WNEK
ZN-K V(N U
R \ I1= E N RNL(N% WNE  JT V  H  (N%. V  S= I XQ. IMV
X= H R EUN7> $ G  RM  E I H% N%] ^  H
- K RNMV %MK$ IZEK
I- JTHNR NY JIRWNR GK MNEV I-=(
$ V=H QN X>=HK K IH QK$
M
EK W IGWNEK WK IH ZILG IW=X S"PH ISVN7>' E=U K
QK$ SM> V  \> 3 %KS M. L
 N%] ^  ] V  RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL G> Q NRN
JRZJ^L HSKR NIMS GK 3R' IZE U-K M>' IH=( U- HNE G G^V
V(N NYKQ. SKZNRKQ. IL%4 .  GN I-ENL QNE I-] Y KQN MNIJ= 1 E IW= X
X=E IRMN K L
 IVU>R^ GW G XR%. GK ;^E G Q=U I1H %MK$ JN-
 FRWRK  %] ^  I-= H  HNE GK J^ L N HR% WNE  IQN'  %
1"EKF
% HRH J=>I6QN IH QJE3 QNJGN %NZ M" Z"$ IHMN IH M. QNJ
QNJ'N %NZ G=
 VG 7>M IQN'. HIM]GN M" IH I-M SEWN% H' M"
QNJGN HK E=UGN M" Z"$ IHMN QNJ H' M
 QNJGN HK %NZ M" V(N I-M
* IH7>$ J>6'N XNM]>G M
 VG 7>M IQN'N HIM]GN M" IH S1K ZRN %NZ
%N J> = 6
  Z" $  G=  'N %MK$ XNM> ] G N V(N Z" $  M.K V
$  S
E  IRMN M. 7> M
SEWN% QV  7>  G  %NE I-= H  QNGZK QNI-QN G
% 4
$  Z" % ] ^   R> J -
QNJG 7>aV [NE [EWN7>' G E-K G U- % Z"%]^ QNJGN F
% %]+ WK
SEWN% V
$  MK IEQN K IH Z" $  J> 6 NU. IH 7> % 4 .  GK G> R UVK M
- K L.
%MK$ ZR H
E QNJGN F
% %]+ %MK$ K SEWN% % MK IG=VN K L
 Z"$
I-M S>RN HNRL RNV IW=X HKVN EIH% ILW$ MK Z"$ 
' E=IUQN V. Z"%]^
_G H=JI9Q. IW=X IL U>R^ GK J^LN QNJ HRG M
 7>M IG\N-K IG=V
IL]%4. % Z"%]^ IHMN G= IG=VN IH I-GN JIR'NZ V>]^ \>G *
U$UN I-M
JIRWNR RW3HVKZN% RWH31 MR' JRZJ^ L  HSKR JT Z  3 WR GK
3R' IW=X M" QNJGK V. QHNV MK HK M" I-=(
$ GN ;RZRNL WK I-
JIRWNR GN H> 0  WK %MK$ IWUN9 HGN
URKSLZL
RNLN YR"$IZ1$HRZH E\
QGEKQGEHSKRM"$H>EH GU>R^ -H@
JRZ J^L HSKR JTZ3WR LK V
$ Z HNE V(N HNE G G^V  V(N
ZV WK YRGK M" 7>M J^R' JT*^ JNJ HRZ G G]Y G E\ %]^ WK ZNJV
HR IG]G M% I-G SNQG 7> IQN' % IHMN S1K V]^ I-M G=G V]^
IL GW J>R3
VZ GK J^LN HRG M
 7>M SM>V JRSE3HVK M% Z"$ 
NE V
$ I-M [NE [NE' GN HNRL HR IRMN M. %N LN' IH]% JIRWNR
7> L N9 X> = I HQN M. JT ] V ^  Q= L  JIMEK WNR Z" $  MNR \N-K M"   S 1 K 7> 

296

*1IHQ. %] ^  IVZNRU

3HVK %]^ ZV 6=Y G'N %MK$ V. ZNR \N LN7>U QNJG IW%N3 G E-K
SEWN% QNIG []> Z RM M% Z"$ IHMN IH QK$ J^R' JTZNVZN GK J^LN
HRG M. SEWN% ZR JVK GN W=YN *RN M" NYN LN%K G>3Z' SI'QN
M
I -QN M" 
QK$ Q=L I-]% \>3%KS M. IH NY IGE IW=X IH WV^ LN H]Z
GK LR^RV M]>GK M" 7>%]^ IVU>R^GW IV HSKR NIMS J^R' HR IG]G
M% Q= L  U> R ^  U
I W] G  G
%
4 $  \9 4   MZ IHH  ENU  J. MZ SIEMNRK
IVU> R ^ G  W  RNZJNE LK G  XR%. Z $  IL%4  $  JT Z  3 WR GKQN IZEN- 
M  *N-K8 V(N *" '
$  NYN NRN JIRWNR IZEH  QNJ%] ^  I-M ] G  3
IG]G M. IH L QNJ%]^ VE
H GN ZNRU J^R' Z
H3 V RW >=\ JTNJV
HR% M
W   QV  ]  NIRH G> = \ . V
$  6> 1 HNRN JN'N M
W   V. S] G K6
9  ] V
RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL V
$ IV%NZ JTNJV HR E"'N QV QNJ'N Q%Z
E Z%>=\
L%Z FE HR E"'N
@IV NIMS@
                 *UVZVK QJE3 GWK

*UV VK3 GK QNVZH(N#

Z" $  *UV VK3 GN  " H 1R  QNR+H + J> R Z %WK$ IG= E K GN
RIM' WNEN M. 7> J R
H V J] H VKQ. NY  LKW% IW= X  XIR= V RQR(
M> ] G KQ. M% IH7> $ IH VU> R ^  S] G K6
9  RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL GN G] S R
]%  IW=X JTKVZJ>RN IG=EK IW=X IV]U M
I-QN K V. QK$ QNJ'
I-=H G

V G HIM' 7>aV IV]U >%' U- JT]V^ JT]JIRH J^LNW. 6=Y' GK
U=E >'% G SNQG IV]U IW=X IG=E %MK$ E=UN IVU>R^ LK 3N3VR.
IW=X
$ J94A N%]^ Z0N RM K V. ZR Z% IW=X QNI-QN IH IHVNS. V.
QK$ [R IW=X WK J94 HG M. I- JTHNR L
VK I%R]L% HNE  % NYK
S=>;K I(R HR IG=VK QV NYN *UVK X"a%E S]G HR IG=VN
IVU> R ^  N%] ^  Z0N7> $ G  M% IH /A
U>R^IS%IH]%4$%NJNI-QNIUQN%NIL7>$(
(N*^69IHN%N
U>R^ IS% *RZ %N 6^1$ *N-K H
I1 7>JN- HR
 XV>RN-K@
I- JTHNR NYK S>=;K I(R M
' GK WL4N %NE QK$ I-=;RA7>a;R
GKQ. U=E. HRG M
- WNJ QN U- ]%  IW=X ZRK JV%K 3TKZVK
Z] L ^  %] ^  ST  %  I17^ Z R IGZNUK H" $ R  M
 IUQN ILGN N%] ^  FGRU] L
MNIJ=1E IW=X %RK\' W I-ENL G Z$ JVN X=IEQN I-G SNQG Z"$
7>%^] J]V MNIJ=1E V(N A.I.I.M.S. %WK$ IG=EK QV 7>V
$ SNQG QJ
E

MNIJ= 1 E %WK$ IG= E K IW= X  WK YNH1R %] ^  IG\NI-QN * YNH1R. %


V>R]V QJT3% GK ENM IG]G M
- IHMN IH QJT3% G GRN% I-G I-=H
M=( IW=X J"RNEN-KI M
 HGN M" QJ
E
 MNIJ=1E G YNH1R. % V.
IRJ
R1 G\' G SNQG I-=(
$ V=H IHMN IH I-GKQ. G
%4
$ Q=\. M>' V=H
PKH IHW$ M% QV 7>K Z$ QN-K J"3IE31 V
$ 1"1 HRWN7>' E-K
IHMN Z"$ VGK X"aH HRWN-K VG QN-K J"3IE31 QV I%7^R
 R,%
%  ENM IG= V K IH MR  IG%. SNQG I-GKQ. Q= \ . GK L.X

IUQN% U] U N

297

HRWN7> $ G  RIM'N HG  WK ?VZ M


 HGKQ. M% IH7> $ IH ST  %  I17^ Z R
Q"K LU4N V M" ZRK JV%K QV Z"$ G
%4
$ MK J"R. V
$ IWHE.U M. QV
M=( QV Q=\. ?VZ M
' GK U=E >'H NM 7>J=R GN 7>J=R QV %KX GN
%KX RIM IUQN EIH% H
-K XNRN %N JNH Q]V IW=X J]V MNIJ=1E %WK$
IG=EK IW=X QNJT3% HRWN7>' GK 
XK QV YNH1R G HIM' V INMAS
MNIJ=1E IVZNRJ>R IG=EK V
$ M.R.I HRWN E-K M
R NR 1"1 WK HRWN
E- HWE QNJT3% GK VNRK\ E"'KK K N%]^ J^R' JTZNVZN V=VWGR3K
]V RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL G JIME >' IV]U GKQN I-M J]HVKQ. NG
QN-KQ.
IL%IZEV>\7>JL"IZ1$H
I17>JN;*>W%XV>RG3<]>I<
$JRZ%MKN;@

QV  NYN *UVK X" a %E JT Z  3 WR %  QN% HR IG= V N QV  Z% IW= X
*NW%N 7>VJ]% M
-K IH QJT3% V
$ JIMEN %NZ E"H G\ E"$G M. IFR
Z"$ QNJ' G
V G %NE JTKVZJ>RN IG=EK IW=X LN H  FRWRK  %]^
J^ R ' JT Z NVZN V= V WGR3K ] V  RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL V
$  %NZGN% E"
IEQN J^RW WNEKQ. * J^LN 6=Y IG=VKQ. IVU>R^ LK % QN\]Y JNP
HRWN7> '  GK ENM IG] G   M
-   IHMN JT Z NVZN %  XNMN V. QNJT  3 % 1E
LNWUN QV * H>0 PKH M
 LNWUN QK$ IVU>R^ GK QNIUQN Q%>NR
[R IV] %  IG% GN QN\] Y  JNP HRNI-QN QV  7>  G  SNQG YNH1R V
$
QNJT  3 % GK VNRK? E" '  J] V  MNIJ= 1 E %WK$ IG= E K U-   L
 YNH1R
JIME. QNJT3% GK ENM G RM % 7>MK YNH1R G^R Q"Z+QNR+QN-K
G\H HIM' E=UN IH M>' QNJT3% GK H
-K LR^RV %MK$ M" VG IVU>>R^
GK SN'K NG QN-K IH/
IVU>R^ GNVNM" HIEZ.IMJTN'7>;NR%7>VR .-K
IVU>R^ GNVNGK%IGQNE]LZIH]HRH V
9 LNE]@
QV QK$ IVU>R^ %]^ NG HRH F>=1A_>=1 R
' E=U IH M JTZ3WR
QNJGK ZIMZN %]^ IHM9 3SG. IW=X IWI\QN% HRK- I- JTHNR J^R'
JT Z  3 WR HSKR NIMS G  QWVNR V= V WGR3K ] V  RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL
GK IHTJN %NE NYN QNJT3% 1E IUQN QV 7>V
$ SNQG QK$ I-=H J"
GK U
EK GWN-K WK %MK$ \N;K M" QV 3>=\Z-K LKW% LKQ RM M.
 %W] S R  GK RNV %] ^  HNE G  0J= 1   G  HNR% Z R K JV%K
IZTVH ZN% M
 U-K K JTZ3WR GN Q]IZTV LE IJEN7>' G SNQG M
3
QNI-QN IFR QK$ 7>%]^ IVU>>R^ LK G H
E E"H QN- V. IVU>R^ LK
% G=IQN Q=L I-%4. GK IZTV^ M
'K K HSKR JTZ3WR % I-%4. GK 7>ZR
W;N IG= V K M"  QV  M> '  I-%] ^  *UVK HR%K XNMKGK M" 
IFR  %W] S R  %] ^  Z R K JV%K %] ^  
% KJ= V  IV] U  IW= X  MK
EHW J"RNEN-KI  GN Q1"H M
I-QN QV 7>GK WL4N %NE 7>G M=(
GK VNHV ?VZ M
' E=UK QV 7>K Z$ IVU>R^ LK GN M=( QNJ' M=(
IW=X IG\N-K G' E=UN QV EU*U  IZ]1 V=H IG\N-K IG]GN IRMN LG
EHW J"RNEN-KI  GN QR ZNJV M
 IUQN VG IVU>R^ LK GN M=(
WK QIGT3 M
 IUQN QV Q=L V=H 7>M ISEH>E PKH M"

298

*1IHQ. %] ^  IV ZNRU

IVU>R^ V=VWGR3K ]V RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL L


 HSKR JTZ3
 WR G IL7>)$
G IV7>)$ QWVNR QN- M% % N%]^ I=; HR IG=VN IH
URKSLZL
RNLN YR$IZ1$HRZH Q]H
HNULHKR$GRUMG-K$X
GMH
I1%NX]J@
VK3 H> Z NR ZIMRN
 RLF-907\17,RNL 1URA@JNEZ HE
% K
 %WK IG= E K Z
+ 

*UV RNZR^J GN GK QNVZH(N#


S]GK69 HSKR NIMS HK L"

Z" $  *UV RNZR^ J  J> = V R Z] U V RNZ S9 E K I,E4 N AQ] S NEN GN RIM'
WNEN M. Z"$  NE V
$ ;]%A;]% IVU>R^ V
$ %NZ E" R=I\QN K  NE
JIME. ZR M=(AJ"R H]Z HR%N 6=Y U- % HZR V
$ %KX ZRN NRN
RKR ZV JT N  M
 IUQN K Z R   G
% 4
$  E9H  Z" % ^ ]  Q] S NEN RHNRK
MJVNE IW=X E"H U- I_R JTN-KW1 YNH1R. %^] WK IG\NI-QN I-G
SNQG Z"%^]  NE V=H I-ENL G E-K I-=;RA7>a;R E" LN' G SNQG Z"%^]
P.G.I. X]YKU94 WK E"H U- 7>a( I-=H NE IW=X ZR G
 1"a1 HKV U-
IH7>$IH IL Z3K% %NE ZR 1"a1 M>]G % 7> IW=X ZRN %]SR I-=H
ZMK% IW=X QN7>$GN K 7> GK 1"aI1]U _K 6 MLNR :J- K 7>a(
Z"%^] G
%
4$ WNR GK 1"aI1]U IW=X ISZNRK G HNR%. GN JVN %MK$ E=UN V.
G
%
4$ WNR ZR IR GN QNJT3% HR% %^] IHMN IUQN IL IW=X ZRK LN%
GN \VRN G= I QN QV  J^ R ' PKH M
'  GK H
- K UR.1K %MK$ M"  Q"  N
IHMN 7>G SNQG [RG Z"%^] SNSN RNZGW G QN3RZ IW=X WK E" H
U- 7>a( H>0 IG% I-ENL M>]GN IRMN H
-K QNRNZ % M
' HRH Z"%^] [R
E"  QN-   I_R Z" % ^ ]  0N9A_^ H  HR% WNIEQ. G  H
E  J] L NSAMIRQN'N
QNIG (N%. V  E"  U-  7> a (  WK Z" % ^ ]  H
- K QNRNZ %MK$ M
I -QN QK$

X IEQN IH M>' LKW% MK (
94 IG% GN M" LG Z"$ * JNI8$ I%RN3
M
 IUQN V. Z"%^] ZRK E9HK ILGK 3NGK 3NMJ>R Q]SNEN  IW=X M
-K K
7>  %  Z" % ^ ]  7> a (  S> E NI-QN Z R   LZN-K ] L ^  %  H> H ^ A *UV G  SNR  IW= X
G=IQN L
  QUV  %^] Z"%^] E"H SRWNEN QN3RZ IW=X IVU>R^
S]GK69 RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL G H
E E"H QN-  QUV  %^] Z"$
%NZGN% IEQN 7>  G  SNQG Z" % ^ ]  QNRNZ M
'  E= U N U> R ^  LK GK IHT J N
%NE M> '  Z" $  QNJ'  \ V  IW= X  QNJ 1T " H 1R XENI-QN QV  QNJ'K NRK
LZK% GK S>SN-K GN H]Z HKVN ZMNRNL G QN3KRWNG %NE Z"%^] G>SNRN
LKW% GN% IZIEQN ZMNRNL S] G K6
9  %  L
 IHT J N HKVK 7>  %^ ]  L> S N%
%NE ISQN% %MK$ HR HGN U>R^ LK QNJ VE
H V
$ ZRN LKW% GN%
G' G E-K QN- M
 H
I1AH
I1 G]YWV JT'NZ M"
                   L S]GK 69 HK
QNJGNGN
                               *UV RNZ R^J GN
                          IJ]YA S9EK I,E4NAQ]SNEN

IUQN% U] U N

299

*UV SMKG \. GK QNZH(N#


S]GK69 HSKR NIMS HK L

S] G K6 9  IVU> R ^  RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL G  XR%. IW= X  H


I 1AH
I 1
G]YWV JT'NZ Z"$ SMKG \. J>=VR Z>]6K \. IJ]Y V VIM+ ZMU.W I,E4N
I*]Y Z=;JTG3  GN RIM' WNEN M. Z"$  NE V
$ 3\V ISZNR K Z
RK G
%
4 $  IHY%KQ. ?RNS K Z" $   NE UWNEKQR IW= X  W= Y  A W= Y 
M.B.B.S. YNH1T. V
$ I-ENL HRWNI-QN JT]V^ H
-K RNMV %MK$ IZEK 7>G
SNQG UWNEKQR G  YNH1R. %  Z" % ^ ]  IG= E K A.I.M.S. QNE I-] Y KQN
Z"YKHE  G E-K R"_R HR IG=VN 7>a( YNH1R. % * L.X G SNQG
G= I QN IH  S
V E ?^ %  XNMKGN M"  JIME. QNJGN ?^ %  I_E1R M
-  U N
I_R QNJG  JIRWNR G  IHK Z" $ SR GK IHY%K H= < H  QNJ%^ ]  QJT  3 %
G>QNRN EUN-K LN-UK QJT3% GN \RX  E=\ E=UUN Z"$ :/ G' IW=X
QZR= (  K I-E-K IG= E K V
$  QNJ'  [R WNIJ QN IUQN V(N
QMN M
H IZTV^ GN I-]VLNR HR% E=UN IH7>$IH \N'AJK' XE'AI_R'
W 7> a P'AS" P ' IW= X  QZR= (  M
 X> = H N K
I_R IHK IWQHVK G>QNRN JVN X=IEQN IH MIRQN'N IW=X SRWNEN
I,+IMNR G Q]GR JTZNVZN QN- M
- M% L
 QN; R
U. %^] JTZNVZN
GK *UVK %NE PKH HRG  M% I-M > ' H  AA %^ ]  QNJG  XR%.
IW= X  JM> ] X H  %NZAGN% E"  IEQN %NZ GN% E" '  G  SNQG Z" % ^ ]  QNRNZ
M
' N 3> R ^  M
 IUQN QV  ;KR A ;KR  I-= H  ZMK%N WK %MK$ E= I UQN Z" $
QNJGK IHTJN %NE ISEH>E PKH M
 IUQN ZR IVU>R>C JTZN' G E-K
ZRK ISZNRK G * 1"1 W HNULNV ZR H
E ZL^G M% M JTZ IJVN
JTZ3WR QNJ' L
 LKW% Z"%^] IG=VN 7>GN QIMN% Z"$ HGK %MK$ 7>VNR
JN7^ $ UN Z R   IVU> R ^  QNJ'  GN 7> a V  IHT J N HRH  Q"    MK QNJ'
XR%. IW= X  EUN-  R= \ 'N#
                           QNJGN GN SMKG \. J>=VR Z>]6K \.
                          VIMKE IJ]Y W YNH\N%NAZMU.W
                                     I,E4N A I*]Y Z=;JTG3
                                     _
% %]+ 

*UVZVK VNRN H=1N 7>aV QKZ IHTJN M


-K#
S]GK69 VU>R^ RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL G XR'. IW=X H
I1A G]YWV
JT ' NZ Z" $  VNRN H= 1 N L"  J> R  I%WNK ]  IHT V  IW= X  Q" a Z+ - +  M.
RNL(N% ^%KWRI1K V
$ SK+- W ]IHTV IW=X WR' JGH JTNJV M"
Z"$ 6 E\H. GK UKVN 7>JI%3G J>RN' W NR GR3% 3NVR W *
U> R ^ Q . G  JT W X% > '   JT ] V ^  ] V > 3 1K %MK$ M
- K I-= H WNR L"  J> R  IW= X
*NHR *UV X"a%E V IVU>R^ RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL GN JT
URNZ GI\QN
V(N V(N  %W]SR  IW=X %NZ 7>JG3 IEQN 7> Z$ IW=X SM>V
ISZNRKQ. V
$  JT  3 N% K Z-K  IW= X  Z" % ^ ]  SN
J K 1" a 1 G

300

*1IHQ. %] ^  IVZNRU

ZNI;QZ V
$  JVN X= I EQN IH Z" % ^ ]  QER I 1W H
E N-KI1 Ulcerative
colitis 
 %NZH ISZNRK G=K I- IW=X W=YK Q.V IW=X 6NE M
 L.G M%
V(N E"1RK% IW=X \^% QN7>$GN M" V(N I- SNR IW=X YNH1R % G=IQN
IH I-GN IHV  WK I-ENL %MK$ M"   Z" % ^ ]  AA IW= X  Q.V IW= X
QER cm V=H W; U- % AA IW=X U>R^ LK G HIM' 7>aV
Z"$ GWN-K S]G HR IG=VK I- IW=X  1"SE"1 V
$ Q"K K IL]%4. G SNR
IW=X YN+ % IHMN K IH QUR LKWV RIM'N M" V. J^RK IL]GUK \N'K J-
UK AA IW=X ZR lungs __I9Q.  IW=X Infection M
 IUQN LG
Z"$ YN+ G H
E I-ENL G E-K U-K V. YN+ % ZR Q"HR G\H IHMN IH
QNJ Q"K ISZNRK %NE UTV M
 IL IW=X QNJ%^] S>\NR M
'N XNMKGN M"
W,% [=1 M
'N XNMKGN M" V(N \^% GK HZK M
'K XNMKGK M" EIH% QNJ
ISEH> E  W( M
  Z" $  IHMN I-M Z R   VU> R ^  RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL GK
IHTJN HRZ GK ZNR V. ZR 7>aV QN7>'N XNM>]GK M" EIH% ZR U>R^GW
HRZ GK 7>   ZNR %^ ]  Z R   7> a V  JT * NWK %MK$ M
'  G  RM   I-K JT H NR
QNJ' *UV GK JTZNVZN R=I\QN HRG M% I- V
$ YN+ HNFK JT*NIWV
M
I-QN I-=H WNR Jan  IW=X JTXNR G E-K LN'N K RNV *R \^%
GK IJXHNRK X= E K > S NM 
I XQN ZR%N V. M"  MK JT X NR HRG A  ZR
LNW. VKR IG% IS%. GWN G PKH M
 U-K YN+ % I-=H WNR S
IEQN
IH H
RI1^% 1KRN-KY Cortisoon Stiroid 
 RKR %^] XEN7>' G E-K R
,
E"'K JWUK EIH% IVU>R^ RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL G HIM' 7>aV Z"$ NRK
GWN-K 6= Y  IG= V K Z" $  I-= H  WK GWN-K %MK$ E-K QV  M> '  Z" $  IVU> R ^
RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL GK IGQN %NE ISEH>E W( M. I-]% E]S Z
$ V
$ X=E RMK ISZNRK U>R^ GW GK 3R' IW=X QN7>' %NE ISEH>E PKH
M
 U-K Z R N HIM'N M"  IH Q"  N IV IUQN% W IV*UVK ZNRU
IJT ( WK 7> a V  M
R  IHV  %MK$ M"   IVU> R ^  RNZJNE LK ZMNRNL N\3NV
J^ R ' JT Z NVZN M% IV NIMS
                         IVU>R^ G XR'. IW=X G]YWV JT'NZ
                                      *UVZVK VNRN H=1N
                                    _% %]+ A 

U>R^IHTJN GK ZIMZN#


Z"$ IVTE
H GN S"RNUK UTNZ <KZR?9N ILE4N A H1%K Z=;JTG3 GN
I%WNK M. Z"$ IG%.H AA %^] %NZ GN% IEQN K LG Z"$ %NZ
GN% IEQN K VG Z"%^] JVN %MK$ K IH %NZ GN% %MK$ SEIH Q]IZTV
E" IRMN M. ZRK U=E QNJ %^] QIV ]
IHV E=UUK EIH% H3Z Z"%^]
U>R^GW G XR%. GK I- IW=X Z"$ L
 *K Q%>*W HKV M% L. L
 *K JTZN'
Z R   NMZ'  M
-    Z" $  HEJ%N *K %MK$ HKVK K IH Z R   %NE Q"  N
XZVHNR M
-UN %NZ GN% E"' V
$ 6 ZMK% SNQG ZRN J>=VR ISZNR M>]GN

IUQN% U] U N

301

M" ILGN L]%Z J]L J>=VRKQ. G SNQG M


I-QN K Z"$ QNJ' J>=VR GN
I-ENL EUNVNR I-=H ZMK% V=H Q"aZ+SK+SK+Q"a+ YNH1R. H
E
$ HRWN7>$GN
IRMN JR I-=H ZMK% V=H SNEH PKH %MK$ M
I-QN QXN%H ZR SNEH
%  I-= H  IG% > S NM / WL  Q= \  S] G  HR E-K ZVES S M
3  M

IUQN Z" $  7>  %^ ]  E" H   7> Z IRNJN% *= I LQN 7> a (  G  * YNH1R. %
I-ENL HR% V
$ Z%4. HR IG=VN Z"$ 7>%^] E" H IM
RN IUQN * LU4N
Q"aZ+SK+SK+Q"a+ YNH1R M% ZUR J>=VR GK MNEV G\H * % I-ENL
HR% V
$ Z%4. HR IG=VN Z]%
 7>M G='N XM>]G % IH VR J>=VR GK IZTV^
M
 X> = H K M"  J> = V R GK 7> Z R IRF I-= H  NE GK K IM] Z V S] % 4 H   I-= H
YNH1R % IHMN IH QUR 7>%^] QNHKL% IZE LN- V. 3NI-G H>0 M

HGN Z" $  V> R ] V  I-= H  F R  W4 K ER IR,RW HKVK QV  LSEJ> R  G  E-K
*=ILQN L
 IH S=IXQN GN IR3RX "$1R M" 7>a( G YNH1R % S=X GK
MNEV G\H IHMN IH I- IW=X H
-K MEXE %MK$ M
 RMK M" IHV *K ^-K
EUN7>$GN I-%^] H>0 ZNE^Z %MK$ M
 IRMN M" *RVK HR%N ZR E-K IRH
GK U=E M" Z"$ IHMN *RVK HR
 QV *RVK HRH I-ENL 3>R^ HR
 SNHK
* JTZNVZN 7>aV 6=Y IG8 YNH1R % IHMN QUR I- %^] 6 []1 IW=X
M
3 QN IUQN V. 3NI-G SX LN- %MK$ V. Z>3IHE M" >SNM %$ WL X>=H
% JT]V^ SNEH M
3 IW=X QN IRMN K E9H GK Z. % QV Z"$ R
'N 3>R^
HR IG= V N Z R N I;QN% QXN%H IUQN% U] U N# V  *UVK 3 G NUR H

3] G  3 # IW= X  IE\  M
-   XZVHNR. GK VR_ IUQN L
 *UV. G  %NE M
- 
M% Z"$ QNJ' QNJ %^] ]*NIEQN QV QNJ' QNJ %^] U>R^ G XR%. IW=X
ZRIJV HR IG=VN IHMN U>R^ LK ZR J>=VR GK R=I\QN HR
 QV Z"%^] L

IW3WN3 K U>R^ GK ZIMZN 7>aV 7>GK ENL R=\


 E=U*U  WL LG
YNH1R RN7^ $ Y 7> a V  QNI-QN V. HIM] G N M"  IH S= X   GK MNEV IW= X  HK
> ; NR M"  Z" $  IHMN L"  N W R   K W"  N M> '  *K M"  YNH1R %  I-] L " H 3%
Z]UNI-QN QV SNEH GK L.[ 7>aV I-],"H3% EUNI-QN I-],"H3% EUG
MK SNEH R
' E=UN ILW$ 7>M I-]L"H3% ?>G U>R^ LK % EUNI-QN M
W
 J^R
MNE IW=X ?>3K GK EIMR G9 U-K YNH1R % ZR IR 7>aV M=( R=\H
IHMN M>' VRN SNEH M
3 IW=X QN IUQN M" Q" ZR, WNE SNEH SM>V
[= 1  M
3  IW= X  QN7> $ G  M%
IWXNR'K-$ M" IH I-]L"H3% GN QR V. G L. SKM IZ]1 G SNQG
M>]GN M" E9HN I-]L"H3% GK ^-K G GRG %NE MK R
 7>aIPQN I- V
$
3J1 M"  IH I-M RW HZNE JT Z  3 WR HSKR LK GN M" 
IVU>R^3R'Z$QN'QN-K1E"SENL"*NUZ$IZTV^M
H.1Z$1ELN#

U> R ^  LK HIM] G   M% IH HH G  %NE Z] V R LNJ HR% %NE L

XZVHNR M
I -QN Z" $  G] U  RIM IUQN Z" $  MNIJ1E IW= X  U> R ^  LK G
XR'. GK S]G%N HKVK QV ;]%WNG IG]G M
- R
 IJQN YNH1R % IHMN
IH I- %^] EUNVNR Q=P IG% G I-EN, GK ,R^RV M" XSK []1 GN J]L
M,NR E= U  IRMN K Z" $  YNH1R %^ ]  IHMN Z" % ^ ]  W R   6> = 1 K XNMKGK M"
YNH1R % IHMN I-%^] QUR QNJ [R E" U- V. I-M SNEH ZR HGN

302

*1IHQ. %] ^  IVZNRU

M" IH7>$IH M>' M


3 IW=X QNI-QN M" Z"$ IHMN L
 M
-UN GI\QN LN-UN
S= Z"%^] 6>=1K XNMKGK M" Q=L SNEH %^] 6 ZMK% 7>aJR M
 U- S>?NR *K
%MK$ QN IRMN Q"K ZIMZN G\H Z"$ ;]% M
 IUQN ZRK N-KHE E"'
GK IM]ZV %MK$ M>]GK K IH7>$IH ZRK JIRWNIRH I(VK PKH %MK$ K
QXN%H 11 S"$H G Z"%LR % IHMN HK QNJ S"$H V
$ E
% E"'N J]G
HR
$ U  Z" $  IHMN QUR IZE LN-  V. I- V
$  W= ;  H  M
R  HK M"  Z R K
JIRWNIRH I(VK >;NR LN-UK S"$H Z"%LR % Z"%^] Y< E=\ R>J- GN
E
%  G  IG= V N N-KHE %N \T K G JN7> '  WNEN QNGZK QXN%H 
R>J- HK MKR
 M.Y. U=YK E" QNI-QN Q=L Z"$ 3N% %NE U=YK IW=X [>]ZGN
M. Z"$ 3NHK H^E IW=X XJ9NK G JG 7>aV HNRHRV K %HRK
HRG Z"%^]  NE U>LR X>=H % EIH% ZRK JIRWNIRH I(VK PKH
%MK$ M
- K LSEJ> R  ] * NU V
$  JT Z
3 % M
-   QV  Z R N I] U E JT Z
3 %
M
I -QN Z" $  XJ9NK V
$  SNS^  M
 IUQN ,ZN%  %^ ]  H> R K R= \ ' WNEN
QNGZK$ \> G  NIMS S'H  H> R K 7> a V  S" P  IUQN Z R N W V % I-] % N M

IUQN IL] % N Z" $  


I XQN %MK$ K Z R N 6
1 N *N-K SK+Q" a Y+ GN QNRN
6=YH ZN^3 M
 IUQN K I-=H IG% QXN%H 7>G H
E HN7^$IE]U E"1R
QNI-QN 7>%^] IW3WN3 MK %MK$ M
I-QN IH7>$IH 7>%^]  Q]H IZE M
-
% QV SK+Q"aY+ HR% G E-K  Q]H V
$ 7>aJR XNMKG % EIH% I-
WNR  Q]H WNIEQ. %^] E" IEQN IUQN IL HNR% HRH  Q]H M
'
GK WL4N HRH 7>%^] ZHN IZE IUQN QV Q=L 7>M SK+Q"aY+ HR IRMN
M" I-M XNR XZVHNR Q" M
- IL]%4N G SNR IW=X Z"$ HGK 
IXQN %MK$
K ZUR RZNI-' IW= X  IE\K Z" % ^ ]  7> M  NG QN U-K IH ZNVAIJVN
U>R^ HK SN'K IS%. IWXNR HR
 3>* LN%K# I-M * XZVHNR I-=H NE
G Q]GR M
- M% JTZN' G E-K/A
 A *NRV MNIJ= 1 E YNH^ Z " $ 1
 A U=YK G NR HNULNV
 A JTZ
3% GN QNG3
 A SK+Q" a Y+ GN HN7^ $ IE] U  E" 1 R
   I-M * XZVHNR %NZ GN% E"' G 6 ZMK% SNQG M
- M%
E I H% IR_ %NZ GN% E" '  V
$  _NI-GN %MK$ SEIH U> R ^  G  G=    ZNRU
7>aV X=E'N J"$GN M" MIR R^P U>R^ PR M" U>R^ R^P" %MK$ PR#
U>R^ GW LK G XR'. IW=X I33 G Q%>*W NGR ZRIJV M%
                    *UV IVTE
H GN S"RNUK
                     MN+ UTY A 
 3N+ 7> a X+ ZN;IZH IW;NE Z> R WNRK
                   VM+ A <KZR?9N I,E4N A H1N%K Z+ JT+
                       Z
S+ %]+  

Note : For circulation amongst like minded person only

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen