Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
"
"
% ! "
&"
"
#
'
)
'
(
$
"
"
!
.
#
,
"
"
"
(
%
"
!
"
2
% .
)
. )
!
!
%
34
"
"
#
#
6
)
"!
5
!
!
"
" #!
=
!
% *
" #
(
7
#
>
:
<(
"
: "
, -
%
$
>
#
,
% *
#
: )
% *
"
"
#
(
%
<
:
@
!
!'
A
%
%
.
*
:
'#
"
*
,%
!' #
#
*
#
6
<
"
"
%
$ )
"#
1
"
&"
"
9)
&"
$
*
'# !
"
!
)
# !
!
0% *
1
%
!
.
)
!
%+
<
=%
)
3
" =
"
,
"
"'
"
B
0
6
'
*
+
%
2
$
>
" #
%
$
34
4
"
" ! "
'
" #
!
' !
=
A
"
" ! "
%
#
@
.
>
'A
7
%
'
'
C
'
)
!
)
%
!
!
'
"
" '
6
#
@
"
"
#
=
"
'
3
#1
<1
!
?
" %?
'
#
#
<C
)
!
34
,
@
-
"
< "
#$
-
) :%
"
!
< "
+
$ ))#
$ )) ) '
3
(
"
!
# !
" ! %
'
C
"
F
=/
>
*% *
34 )
?
$ ))
0
#
(
.
%
# @ "
34 )
1
$
"9
. "
#
34 !
' #
!
$ "
$ ))
%
,A
#
"
'
!
" #
3
%
!
>
!
,
)
*
%
:
'
!
#
"
@
"
"
2
"
!
# !'
$'
!
5
'
!
% .
#
!
=
"
) "
#
% +
#!
#
+
'
-
"
(
,
"
'
-
#
9
"
" 6
<
!
3
34
#!
3
!
!'
3
$ "
!
!
A
#
(
(
(
"
%6 "
$ "
:
@
$ ))
!
-
.)
!
!
! #
%
)
"
" #
!
"
'
!
?
#
(
"
"
"
'%
>
'
:
!
.
"
'
$ ))
3
3
"
"
C
'A
(
!
%
"
(
# !
" "
H
#!
" !
"
% ?"!
% 6
"
!
' #
" #
,
#
"
A#
I
C
!
3
%* !
"
#
"
!
@
3
# "
3
,
%*
" #
(
'
!
;% *
34
"
!
5
J
"
"
!
#
%3
!
" A
'
!
)'
5
"
.
#!
>
?
#!
!
% *
$ )) "
!
!
%
#
#
#
:
%
" !
!
@
"
!
!' !
$ ))
3
% ?
5
)
%"
+
5
)
!
%6
"
C
?
#!
)
#
% "
" A
!
C
#
" "
"
!
2
C
C
# "
'
-
"
!,
<*
#3
=
)
.9 9
9
!
" ) !
(
)
%:
!
(
$'
.)'
#
,
"
H
%.
<1 7
5!
.
'
)
.
$'
"
#
(
"
! #!
N
)'
(
(
#
(
# .%K DI
7
Van Ess, Theologie und Gesellschaft im 2. u. 3. Jh. H., Bd.1, S.VIII
"
<L M =%
9
%3
(
&" "
?
' O %
"
=# .%K FE%
"
4
*
C
"
"
/
%;DDT
KFS0#
6
"
>
#
"%3 "
.
" !
% 3
C
"
"
C
"% L R
#"
!
)
#" "
# !
4
%
(
"
(
! !
(
"
4
!
"
!
*
$ )
4
C
! "
&"
'
#
#
* #
# !
3)
" !
'
(
'
"
# !
"%
>
5
-'
D%
-'
&"
.)
# !
" #
%
A "#
#
#-
/;%
D% 5%
'
)
>
1
"
W M
)
"
$
M
%0
!
$
7
'
7
U
.
% %>
% *
.)
#!
'
C
8
A: #
XRL
[M "%.M
"
0%
"
0
/%
"
*
"
#
%*
,
! A# !
(
" )
!
! # !
% * ! A# !
7
J*
'
) 0 " " J
#!
/D% 5%
%0
L! #
5
7
@
6
"
J *
3"
"
-'
"
*
%
,
6
#
"
;%
!
.
"
"
"
"
"
#
% %"
)'
'
' #!
)'
C
%* !
#
)
# (
"
#!
%6
!
#
"
" %
/V R20#
&"
% ;;ST
KDU0
"% L R
"
"
QR /
#
#
!
#7
7
(
"
A
#
%.
'
"
.
J.
99
"
(
XRL
ZM L [ R9
! ;S
\ !M R2R /D% 5%
#
/
'
$ "
C
A
% % [M "%
$
1
!
%0
, %
"
[
"%
5
.
%1
"
1 R
M
,
% EUGT
YYG0
#
'
"
#!
#
XRL
+
!
1 R "
> M"
L [ R9
"
#"
Q^
*
3
)
*
4
"
7
)'
%1
#!
#!
ZM L [
*
*
;;
"
!
%.
7
3 '
" ! % "
\ !M R2R
)'
ZM
@
"
.
M
!
(
"
#
"
[M
'
C
!
"
L
% "^ CM
aR /
% E;YT
YE;0# CM]R L " _ ""M /
% F;GT
;SDG0#
"
]M /
%UFST
;FEK0;F " *
PM
\ [ R /
% FYFT
;;SS0;E
"
V " 2M />
b(
0
L
#
!
"
#
A
(
. ,
7
.
"
L R
$ )
#
3
8 *MQ "% L VMc
"^ M[ L "
M "%
"%
P
R9
"% P
R9
L R "% "R `M ";G% ?"!
L
#
" !%
XRL
ZM L [ R9
7
!
!' # '
L
" !
#
%
1 ddM
/
% ! !
DDSDEST
UEG UFG0
\M d /
% DGGT
UIU0 !
!
#
.'
#
$
"
!
"
%.
L
'
)
7
/ % %
[L R# [ X
M R0
#
L
7
3 !
!
%
CM]R L " _ ""M '
$
!
1 ddM % .
*
(
)
[L R9
/
R # L # ! L ! ! LR 0% *
#
# ! !
)'
L
C
"
L
#
# ! )'
7
%
'
?
'
% &"
)
L
!
>
)'
L
#
: '
"
%
.
A "
$
#
(
3
L
:
)
"
#
#
A
"
/*MQ "% LeVMc L
"% L6" 0
$
#
;;
ZM L [
"^ L ""M
"% L R
1 _M[R /EKD FGS %0
R [ [RL /: _M
1 _M[R0# .%FEE#
&"
*
"
*
[M "% .M
\ !M R2R# .%FEF
;D
"
1 R # # .%DGSO
*
!
1 _M[R# /: _M
1 _M[R0# .%FEE !' %
;E
3
L
#
)'
R9
%
;F
M
5
#
'
"
R9 #
)
!
R9
L
/ "
;G
.% % % "
]M#
9!
# .%;DG %
Q
[M
Mc Q
0%
"%
P
R [ [RL
Mc
6
(
XRL # !
!
#
- )
3 "
'
% 1
3
C
"
5
%3
'
7
"
3
7
!
=!
" O
#
%
1
"
"
P
>
,
# "
>
9)
#!
L
!
/;IY DFIT
KUG UIS0DS#
E%
M "% P
L "
L
"
/
-
"
*
[ XM R
*
/
%EGIT
YIK0
!
3
3
;I
L R 08
#
" %=;U
;Y
!
P
!
%+ 7
,
"
"
#
*
.
.
"
#
)
%.
!
!
"% " M R
CM
!
" %6
*
!
M !
5
)' % 3
% I;FT
;D;K0#
L
#
!
"
/ % %
&"
L
0"
#
(
2M
V `M "R9R
"
4 %3
!
!
"
,
XRL
#
P
%
&"
!'
"
)'
"
% 7
)'
!
"
'" # !
" #
" !
!
/
!
%
!
"
P
$ )
#
" !
!' % 6
$
b _
&"
"
%
7
"
"
!
7
&"
!
"
<
: R
(
"
'
< "@
(
%3
)'
# !
!
4
!
)'
+
7
. ,
%
8 3 !
)'
> M R9 #
L
.
-
;K
"
#
"
&"
#!
"
;I
> M R9
"
C
Q^ " M
*
.
#
L
"^ - _
3
"
% %
"% P
R9 #
.
"^ M[ L "
M # !
L ""M # . M "^ L ""M L "
M "%
"% L R "% L "
M "% L ""M
\ L
Q^%
17
van Ess, Theologie und Gesellschaft im 2. u. 3. Jh. H., Bd.2, S.234
18
Van Ess, Theologie und Gesellschaft im 2. u. 3. Jh. H., Bd.1, S.63
;Y
'
(
> "
)
"
c99 R#
[
20
CM
"% " M R "%
MLR "% " M R "% P
"% P
"% L R "% "R `M "
M R
%
M "%
"^
7
%.
!
>
: R
7
! A
"
)2
)
! ! A
&"
"
)
#
#
"
" "
#
"
D;
"
L R
3
( "'
%
$ )
M R M
&"
% *
"
!
)
"
#
5
!
(
"
"
(
"
CM
# !
22 f 9M "%
)'
P
"%
!,
#
CM
%
<+
!
(
!'
!,
# !'
=% >
"
#
* "
"
(
7
.
!,
% 3
'
3
[RL
# !
'
7
DD
"
#
%3 !
"
%
"
# ! !
#
%
.
%
!'
"
(
% %
"
" % *
+ '
)
)
%
*
$ )
/
# e
0#
)
=
%
.
#
5
I% 5
%
#!
1
1 [!M "% . LR
PR 9 R
#
e
#
# !
5
.
"
"
L R
!
# !
+
3
! #
'
DE
%
P 9R
#
"
"
1
$ )
"#
!
"
:
1
#!
"
,
$ )
"
%
3
,
!
#
"
<
=5
( ))
e
"
#
)
'
#
9
!
!
"
9
"
+ !
!
#
(
"
"
$
!
.
:
"
"
% .
!
(
P
P
#
"
!
$
# "
"
"
)
/
% %
"L R
LM" R
M2 #
"
)' 0
(
!
%
" "
#
"
MV
L
.
"'
%
"
L
`M "
!
:
D;
DD
+ %
* "
#
A
#
CM
"
"
"
,
DE
.%
#
<3
3
! L#
7"
)'
P 9 R# .%GE
"
1
:
4
"
$
"
"
" %
8
DF
.
"'
XRL /
3
%
.
-
:
<
$ )
#!
#
c
9
^
L
"^: 99 #
#
RZ
#
%
*
&"
'
% 3
"
)
"
"
<
)
$ )
=
!
"
*
$ @
! "
! A#
'
!
,
"
,
)
+ '
< ]!McL M
-'
$ )
!
#
'
"
! :
"
%
$ @
. ,
" #!
Q^
M R#
"
"
@
"
&"
#
#
)
L6
`M "
&"
#
!
_
!
V VM " R
$ )
#!
!
"
M" M
3 !'
"R `M "
" L
" #
"
R9 =
"
'
> M"
__
! @
$ @
A
%*
J >,
J
!
" !
"
'
#
*
!
(
"
" %3
DG
"
% "
.
#
-'
$
#
! J% 5
%3
"
&"
'
6
"
?
3
,
4 #!
% "
7
*
1
!
!
%.
+
1
>
! . 99
>
"
"
$
( ))
#
P RZ"
,
'
.)
*
#
C c
M %
"
$ "
#
"
&"
@
)
C c
M
"
! '%
C c
M
#
&"
%.
4
" #
C c
M
"
'
" #
C c
M
!
4
)
!
%
C c
M
)
3 !
% .
EE +
FS# !
aM
"R9R
"
! #
3
#
.
" !
:
/%
0#
#
)'
3 !
)
%
%
$ )
"
-MV
&"
"
"
DG
L R
"
" #
A &"
" #
&"
' !
)
&"
DF
!
!
$ )
+
$ )
/.
#!
!
0 !
^
-
-'
"^: 99 % "
b-'
T
3
&"
"
*
#
9
"
9
*
3 !
4
%
'
(
H
"
5
"
"
$
H
(
,
"
DI
5
/
,
"
>
'
"
DK
#
"
%-
:,
+ "
% $
"
!
A >
,
#
"
"
'
1
"
"
"
'
#!
,
9
7
>
$
#
H
#
%
H
34
$ "
"
' %
!
-
#
) )
A :
+ "
N
" !
:
:
:
%
#
34
W M 0%
&"
>
*
"
! % 3
" !
) %
! A
! #
#
*'
"
A
4
" #
&"
"
<( g H ) =
. 9M
) )9
%
M #
^O
^ M #)
9
!M
%3
!
"
M O
)
# ))
9#
$ )
<
)
9
. 9M
!M
26
" #
"
+ "
H
"
(
"
(
" @
"
"
3
.
%
% 1
.
#!
:
#!
:
9
3 ,
!
% 5
#
6
) "
!
!
% 1
%1
,
"
!
+
$ "
!
"
)
#
"
LM! 9 g
9
!
".
!
!"
`Mc%
%hDU
%
))
^#
. 9M
"
"
)
Siehe Raschkes Werk Das Christusmysterium. Die Kirchenvter haben die Gnosis auch mit dem Argument
bekmpft, die Kirche vertrete die wahre Gnosis, s. Rudolph, Die Gnosis, S.60
27
David Ulansey hat in seinem Buch The Origins of the Mithraic Mysteries berzeugend dargestellt, dass es
sich bei dem im rmischen Reich verbreiteten Mithraskult um eine eigenstndige Mysterienreligion handelt,
deren Entstehung aus astralmythologischen Spekulationen zu erklren ist.
28
Crone/Hinds, Gods Caliph, S.24-25
10
3
' #
"
" #"
<
)'
" %
IF
> " Mc
!
<
/: ""0
("
"
! % % <(
M R =ES% 3 "
/ M 0
"
=# <
/: ""0
=
<
/: ""0
5
=E;%
'
3 !'
<
^ M =
5 II ED%
!
'
!
%3
" '
#
* <
= !' ! %
$'
#
!
L
M
)' !
#
.
"
.
* <
=
# !'
.
#
L "
"%
!M 4
>
' EE%
<
^ M =#
- #
'
.9 "
EF
H
# " "
%3 "
"
L "
"%
!M # !
<- VR = /$ ' 0
%
"
) #
:
?
#!
"
.9 "
EG
H
!' %
!
"
/
0#
R
/
0
C
/5
0
!
% $'
"
>
4
. % *
>
DS% 5# ! $ '
)
.9 "
"
% - L "
$'
"
"
@
>
4
. %
(
5
. "
3 '
DY
'
)
,
"
1
!
'A
/ Q^
20
#
P RV!
%
"
= !
<
% *
!
%
DY
"
7
+
$
)
4
!
"
"
( '"
:
$ )
#
#
$ ))
" !
"
"
.
-
)'
# !
$'
-
34
%3
EK
>
$ )
1
4
6
$
#
7
&"
:
EI
!'
%
# " !%
"
'
'
!
" !
"
*
1
5
#
"
!
# %
!
4#
"
W M%
30
Hoyland, Seeing Islam as Others Saw it, S.693; Nevo/Koren, Crossroads to Islam, S.376-377
31
S. hierzu die Inschriftenliste bei Nevo/Koren, Crossroads to Islam, S.368-425
32
Popp, Die frhe Islamgeschichte nach inschriftlichen und numismatischen Zeugnissen, S.75 in: Ohlig, Puin
(Hg.), Die dunklen Anfnge
EE
$ ))# + 6
.M
M# .%US % 8 ?
/ %0 #
EF
$ ))# + 6
.M
M# .%YS % 8 ?
/ %0 #
35
Zu diesen Bleibullen s. Popp, + 6
.M
M# .%KD % 8 ?
/ %0 #
EI
+ % % % . a R# 6Q^ . a R# %;# .%;;F
EK
.%
$ "
_ ML "
#
# .%;FU ;KK
11
"
!
"
)'
#
E% 5% %
)'
6
E% 5%
EY
>
(
.)
%
4
"
FS
"
!
"
>
"
(
%
:
"
#
"
(
'
LM! 9 "
LM! 9
(
#
6
XRL
C c
M
#
LM! 9
"
,
XRL
!
"
'"
#
7
!
" @
%
#
%
1
1
FD
%
!
,
H
)
'
,
6
"
%3 )
:
+
F;
% *'
5 YK
!
""
7
)
"
1 !
# !"
4
)
"
!
'
%# + 6
Popp,
/ %0#
' O1 T
>
40
Crone/Cook, Hagarism, S.11
41
Popp,
/ %0#
'
42
S. Popp,
$ / %0#
'
.M
#H
"
!
.
LM! 9
; ;EGT
IDD KGD
39
#
!
#
)
#! !
. ! # .%IUK KSEO
!
# .%EIU FDGO
+ "
C
:
:
"
)
"
"
%.
"
#
"
"
%
"
"
)'
#
,
!
"
,
"
>
@
A
%(
:
:
!
)9
"
i R
%
"
)'
6 99
, .9 "
#7
"
# !
)'
?
H
!
LM! 9
%
"
.
^M "% 1 Q
%
@
# !
EU
#
$ )
*
" "
)'
.9 "
.
"
99
"
LM! 9
"
#
(
!
EU
%1
" %
LM! 9
"
"
9 #.
" 1 T
>
#
" $ ))#
# .%;I ;DE 8 ? # $ / %0#
M# .%;E DDD 8 ?
/ %0#
# .%K; 8 ? # $
# .%DUY
# .%Y;
8?
#$
# .%Y; ;SS 8 ?
12
-
# !
"
)'
)'
"
)'% *
!
7
"
# !
! 8
"
"
7
!
(
3
:
3
%
"
"
"
.
"
"
:
?
"
"
%
>
'
>
"
>
"
%
=FI%
"
(
#
!
*
$ )
, )
$ )
5
'
%
"
!'
%?
4
)
% 3
'
"
34
;%
FG
"
#
"
"
,
<
"
))
:
C
99
'
"
!
,
#
#
>
* "
>
FF
,
6
# !
>
FE
L ""M
99
6
@
)'
!
"#
"
"
#!
"
(
4
'
!
"
#
'
"
,
"#
'
%>
#
)
"
#
A
*
3
43
%
!
"
! % +,
"
"
"
#
@
'
"
"
!
*
'A
"
*
"
"
"
"
"
" %
% *'
!
#
"
'
!
'
'
. "
'
'"
"
!
Ohlig, Hinweise auf eine neue Religion in der christlichen Literatur unter islamischer Herrschaft?, S.223325 in: Ohlig (Hg.): Der frhe Islam
FF
+ % @
#
H
?
!
. L 8
.
$ )
# .%;;I 8 > "
/ %0# . RL O
$
>
% "
3 #
(
D% % E% 5% %# %;# .%EY
(
#
#
.%D %
45
Van Ess, Theologie und Gesellschaft im 2. u. 3. Jh. H., Bd.1, S.39; Crone, Slaves on Horses, S.49
46
Goodman, Avicenna, S.3
13
,
6
%. " !
"
!
A
"
"
"
*
!
&"
"
&"
"
"
"%
"
j VVM"
"
!
"
GS
$ ))
"
/
C c
M
"
$ )
!
AN
+
"
"
!
3 '
C c
M
!
!'
>
+ %1
48
#H
'
LM! 9
>
4
'
!
A
% .
"
!
>
# .%UK ;SD
$ ))# +
(
. ! # .%IYSO
LM! 9 !
:
.
@ D% N
.
E%
5
50
Crone/Cook, Hagarism, S.160 Fn.56
G;
$ ))# + 6
.M
M# .%GD ?
GD
.%
"
&"
#
!
+ '
#
f 9M "% P
# > M"
a "# .%DS
"
IDD % H %
D% >
%
=FY
"
#
! #
:
9
5 #
" %
34
FK
"
"
_ !
%
3 "
.9
$'
#
_
+
#
5 IDD#
!
.
E #+
E G0#
G;
"
#
"
3 "
!
<5
'
)
!
"
[ !
C
$ )
)
!' #
- # "
"
% .
FK
"
#
%
>
"
5
%3
%
.
C
A
"
"
!' # "!
FU
"
%
)
3 "
!
*
"
!
%
LM! 9
LM! 9
A
1
%
%
*
#
#
# .
5
4
%
3 "
FY
&"
"
P _M
( "
"
&"
,
*
,
#>
)'
$'
"
"
'
.9
:
'
!
"
,
&"
"
L6
"
" !
/
'
&"
# .%EU 8 ?
GD
"
%.
3
N 9)
.M
M# .%;DD
$ )
7"
8?
4
&"
" $ ))#
# $ / %0#
'
!
8 ;% :,
"9
/
"
%0#
9
"
/
%0#
L R
"
$ )
'
L R
" # % % %
M R
14
3
7"
%
6
!
(
!
"#
"
#
"
"
%
#
.
P _M
"
GF
GI
% 5
34
"
&"
$ )
% 1
"
7
5
!
"
"
) #
.)
@
5
6 )
"
" M9 b
.R
$
!
)
"!
!
53
(
:
%
GE
!
#
!
GG
GK
[RL
GU
)
9)
#
+
%
5
-MV
9
<
'
"
"
%.
%
"
LM "
:
,
%
3
.
3 ,
(
+
:
!
%i
R [ .R M R /YKY ;SGST
;GK; ;IFS0
"
c!
:
.
8 <
M9 9
_^L M
9
!
3
=IS%
$
(
#
9
$
)'
!
#
"
/
#5 0 #
(
!
#
*
#
%
#5
!'
9
(
#
9
)
7
"
%3
8
A
"
C
)
.R #
.R
"
(
"
9
/
3
6
"!
.R
I;
5
!
O
$ "
C
%
ID
$
H
%0
"
?"!
A
9
_
(
"
6 )
#
(
-MV
"
!
3
GY
@
C
.
#
"
"
5
(
" M=0%
(
!'
#
+
#!
_ "
A
>
#!
"
'
)
(
"
! # "
6 )
IE
"
34
3
'
(
5
"
!
$'
%
#
15
"!
(
$'
#
!
!
#
!
(
"
"
"
"
[L R
!' #
5
H
% *
#
"
!
5
/b5
"
%(
"
#P
"^
Q^
L RIG%
"
0
-
'
L R# -MV
(
(
#
! %.
)'
'
)
!
#
'
%
)'
" !
!
#
!
%
"
'
1
)'
#
#
W M
(
> ' IF%
#
(
$ )
9
!
$ )
"%
$'
"
9
!
!
)'
P
L _R
"
"
"
)
XRL
!
' 8
-MV
"R
-MV
b
! !
b5
#
'
"R M
(
, % -MV
-MV
9
# "
9
5 %
+
%
<
= "
)
-MV
# L R# P
P
"
.9
II
% "
86
#
(
$
9
'
(
#
" "
- # "
)
9
"
"
!
%
!
!
!
#
"
%6
"
#
&"
!
!
%
!'
( "
9
- #
" !
'
"
"
A
"
3
#!
"
3
@
:
# "
"
:
)
"
4
C c
M
"
"
'
%1 ,
! "
!
%
+
(
.
.
5
5
.
IF
+ %
!
!
"
#
7
.
>
,)
"
(
"
/
"
#
" 0 #!
#
%
#
"
+
#
9)
)9
7"
IK
Mb
%*
.
,
5
#
5
a
#
1 " a RT C
R# - 2 [ XRL # .%GK ISO
"
"
C
R%
IG
[L R#
2M M
M R9R # .%YO "
1 " a RT C
R# - 2 [ XRL # .%GS/
"
C
R0%
66
Vgl. Halm, Die islamische Gnosis, S.194 f.
67
Drews, Das Markusevangelium als Zeugnis gegen die Geschichtlichkeit Jesu, S.29 f.
a
"
16
$
"
)#
IU
+ "
% 3"
L R% *
"
L R
&"
" !
#
$9
"
"
,A
( ))
( '"
,A
"
)9
"
!
#
!
>
"
7"
J1
>'
'
$
)
'
!
"
L R
)'
7
9
7
) "
<( =
/
%
R9 0
)'
%
< ,
9"
(
=
# !'
%3 " " 4
%
<
"
# "
" #!
IY
7
"
^
R0
: '
$ )
!
+ !
*, <( =
!
.
+ !
(
(, , %
$
)
7
/
M
/
!
< ,
# % %
(
4
M 0#
2R2
'
%
=
9
"8
<
%
# "
#
"
!
+
!
!
#
%
!
KE
%
)'
*
(
$ 9
N 9)
"
(,
(
"
K;
"#
#"
" # .,
(,
"
D% 5
!
#
=%
>,
KS
("
H
"
!
KD
+
(
#
KF
)
%
7
$
#
!
<3
= # "
N 9) %
3
!
<
4
=KG%
$
)
!
-M M"R /DGK EEKT
UKSYGS0# " .R M /EKSFDUT
YUS;SEK0
X M" R
f 9M .
! R /GFY GUKT
;;GF ;;Y;0 "
!
7
!
! _^ /3
.
0
# !
9
"
%
!
+
#
(
"
*
KI
>,)
"
%
(
!
" L "R /GIS
IEUT
;;IG ;DFS0
#
"8
#
!
3
<.
/(
0+
+ '
"
^
'
""
#!
(
Q Q^ 0KK
=/
"
Md
* #
Q !
LM
68
$ "
! _^ %
17
7
7
.)
"
3"
!
"
"
<3
! _^
/d ^# _ R0 (
%
%6
" !
<( = !
<3
=
"
%
!
%
.
#
<( =
(
#
9 %
+ !
<( =
(
#
"
"
<3
=%
%
<3 =
"
!
#!
(
"
34
(
(
(
)9
!
5
#
" !%
)'
9
1
4
!
'" # !
(
( ,A
3
"
#!
!
7
(
@
!
" # " " "
!
"
# "
(
(
$ @
'
&"
#
+
C
)'
%
3
!
#
"
>
4%
C c
M
5
^ /b )
*
5
C c
M " 5
$ )
#
9
" %*
M M
!'
4
H
" #
"
.
*
!
5
5
C c
M
0
%3
%
)
#
#
9
9
,
%
/b
' %
(
C c
M
(
#!
C c
M
( KY% 3
C c
M
.
0
.
+
%
KU
!
#
#
?
%*
C c
M ! $
#
%3 !
!
"
(
9
'
)'
%3
"
"
"
" #
!'
"
L ""M
"
!'
!
'
' $ ,
US
> M R9 # @
@
" '
C c
M #
!
(
#
!
"#!
[RL
( ))
L
# "
: !M ]!
!
[M "% P
)
"
!
1'
UD
! \M"
\ LR
"
'
)
W M '% . !
+ "
W M
' U;%
!
(
W M
%3
W M
"
78
CM]R#
> 9M 99
18
UE
XRL
%1
#
W M
&"
3
'
7
"
+
)
)
%*
%
(
%
.
#!
*
4
C
[RL
?
*
!
*
#
#
+ "
) "
!
W M
!
>
)
1
'
!
# '
:
W M
)'
"!
)
UF
)
(
#
% *
'
""
! !
"0
! A
#
#
$ )
"
!
,
/" Mc
0
(
!
(
#
#
"
UG
"
UI
%
? > " Mc
#
% * A
"
#
'
?
>
" #!
"
3
!' !
'A
#
,
3
"
% .
-
"
%+
&"
D% *
XRL
XRL
W M "
"
1
(
W M
"
$'
%
)'
"
>
W M
#
)
'
" J1
)'
.
,
"
(
#
2
%
%
"
. " !
#
@
- 4
" #
" "
- #!
!
%
!
4
#!
,
!
'
"
!
J . " !
"
"
#
)
"
M2/UG ;GST
KSF KIK0 " !% "
[M
/
%D;ET
UDU
D;UT
UEE0 !
) #
!
"
#
$ )
# !
:
'
%
!
1
4
"
!
" ! "
!
34
#
" "
!
#
&"
(
2
% . " !
> "
8*
>
9
7
J
#
#
!
"
%
%
UE
) )
'
+ "
+ "
%*
.% * _R #
L_
_M
L "M !
!
LM R # .%UF
Zu den zwei Ausnahmen s. Halm, Die islamische Gnosis, S.31 f.
85
Vgl. hierzu insbesondere fr das Neue Testament, Raschke, Die Werkstatt des Markusevangelisten u. (ders.),
Das Christusmysterium
UI
P
R#
QM"R # .%EGF
84
19
<!
" %
#
>)#
9
"
!
&"
!
* M"
! #
"
+
.
"
&"
% .
&"
<6
-
"
= )
! "
$ )
&"
"
$ )
,
"#
"
;YIF
( "
)
"
"
<
"
"
%-
3
!
@
$'
#
(
5
@!
"
" # !
"
#
%
"
'
"
#
1
.
*
"
%*
"#
3
*
"
%
"
"
A#
"
&"
"
)
1
+ " %
A (
!'
!
! #
% .
#
#
#
9)
"
% .
"
)
)
!
# 5
$ "
"
)
#
% %
$ )
"
%*
#
"
)
"
.
"
(
4
"
%
"
"
"
>
#
"
# !
87
'
)
!
! '
)
"
"
!
(!
@
"
"
!
! #
$ )
"
" !
"
$ )
"
# "
'
% 3
"
'%
"
"
% *
$ "
% *
# "
*
"#
#
"
"
"
&"
'
# !
$ @
(
#
!
"# !
.)
. " "
"
:
' "
) @
% (
=UK%
"
1
)'
#!
"
"
#
%+
&"
! # "
'
20
"
(
"
(
2
)
#
" #
%
$
3
)
J
*
X"R1L M R/
% ;Y;F0
#
#
(
+ "
"
-
UY
:
%
#5
%
) 9
)
#
4
A '"
#
"
"
#
%
, &"
*
UU
89
)
. " "
!
'A
%
!
#
:
) 9
"
$
"
*
" :
3
%1
"
)
"
#
3
,
"
"
!' %
%6
"
!
"
:
!
3
%
*
5
(! #
"
+ "
"
#
"
"
"
"
#
'
A
# !
"
#
(
/ " " R _ 0# !
)'
#
" #
A
.R
UU
!
!
*M2 R# "
[M
` " RB 3
"# !
' #
#
!
%
"
(
!
# " !% !
#
(
!
@
+
$ )
)
.)
% "
[M
'
C
#
*
"
"
% *
!
"
7
2
#
!
"
$ )
(
%*
!
!
>
&"
3
)
#
.
$ )
)9
*
)
#
1
"
# "
'
#!
*
)
#
'
!,
%
#
'
"
!
#
'
)
"
#
!
$ )
"
" #
8*
! A #
$ )
*
"
(!
( "
!
"
#
$ )
"
3
!
%
" '
"
3
9 #
+
"
7"
I%T
K% 5% % H % ) @
%
!
8 *
"
3
#
!
(
!
&"
J
(
H
-
1 L M R# .R
1 "R# %;# .%KS
Vgl. die entsprechenden Abschnitte bei Buggle, Denn sie wissen nicht, was sie glauben
21
#
#
.
!
"
'
"
$
#
%
%*
!' % 1
!
A
)
.
3
)
"
3
%
?
) # '
#
Q M R
? "
.)
4
<
!
! 9
(
!
YD
%
!
3
.
"
" ! "
# ,
!
"
% i
#
<3
$ )
[ XR M R !
, %1 ! 9
"
% 3
L "
+
'A
R9
R9
C c
M
#
:
'" # !
#
!
Y;
%*
3
[ XR M R
'
L _R
9
3
? "
!
M \M R /U;K UYUT
;F;F ;FYD0 "
.
)
+ "
?
,
#
#
Q^
"^
C c
M
.
!
(
#
#!
A# #
" !
'
@!
)
)
"
.
#!
#!
" ! " !' % +
#
C c
M #
" '
!
)
3
#
"
.
#
*
" "
!
<! 9=#
YS
! = / [M
RL 0 "
%
"
#
"
2 c
M
4%
"
)
! 9
$ )
"@
!
C c
M
$ "
C c
M
# !'
3 )
#
"
"#
"% ?
3
"
$ )
34
#
#
$ )
)'
"
#
"
A% .
"
9
:^ R /ISF IKDT
;DSK ;DKE08
=YE
\M R
*
- Q^Q
)
'
#" @
"%1
?
"
#
Z !R
b)
/"
*
0
% *'
:^ R
!'
'
- ^M
- ^M
" L "R
!
* (
?
%.
"
"
3" %
5
" !
! #
"@
!
(
#
34
!
"
%3
#
YS
3
"@
"@
" #
"
"@
Q M R#
M # .%USY
[ XR M R#
MR
k "# .%;;U
YD
[L R#
2M M
M R9R # .%Y
93
Schimmel, The Triumphal Sun, S.369
Y;
"@
@
!
@
" !
9
!
3
" #
#
!'
,
*
%(
#
"
34
22
9
.
"@
.
3
(
(
# "
7 )
$
<( =
Q
'"
*
R20
YI
"
Q"M 0YF%
2R2 0# "
%
$
$
k M Q Q "M
:
'
6 ,
.
(
9
)
)
8 <*
9 %$
)
9
<. = / "% ! _^ # ) %
R0# <3
= / "% ]#
<
= / "% d ^# _ R0% " .R M !
YG
#
7
( 7
"
.
6
8
(
"
#
5 " 4
#
+
(
$
)
9
%
.
" 8
*
/
1
"
"
<. ,)
%) R M
0
> M"
_M
$
9
#
"
9
\
!
= / 2
^O)
" !
#
%3
YK
) T9
) YU !
)
#
"
YY
/Q
R20 "
'
9
$
'
#
!
! @
!
#
"
!
!
=
<3
" #
:
#
<
"
H
)
9
H
%3
"
YF
!
3
%
+ "
=# !'
>
#
'
"
(
)
#
#
#
"
+
T
:
'
'
'
"%3
'
"
(
7 #3
'
!
"
"
)
% *
(
#
:
)
(
#
"
.% >M[M R# !M
# .%;Y
" .R M# > M"
_M # .%;YU
YI
[ XR M R#
MR
k "# .%;D;
97
Raschke, Das Christusmysterium, S.358 f.
YU
"
$
)
9 %
A "
)
)
"
#
" "
"
:[ #
)
)'%
)
)
7
X M" R f 9M .
! R
"
$9
$ %
7
.
! R
3
* "
,
!
/
.
9 7
#
*
9 3 #
7
0% *'
$
) # % % " .R M / %
[M M !
"R M # .%EGG %# R 2M M
LM R 0
X M" R f 9M .
! R
)
"
9
'A
" /.
! R
% % P M_
VM R# %
* "
#
7
# .%ES %0# "
9
"
$
)
'A %
3)
"
%
"
(
#
)
%
YY
.%
% %
" : [ /GDSGYGT
;;DI ;;YU0
.
-Q
2M
>[ L
M _
YG
23
7
3
#!
"
@
9
!
.
"
# "
.
!!
"
% *'
/3
M " lM
%- $
%.
# !
CM[M R
= (
.
<3 =
<3
=
CM[M R /
%
#
(
;SD
=
@
8
M2
M R9 0
8
" !
+
L "
*
d ^ ^ LM M
M M
#
(
T
M0;SE%
/!
3
!
/ llM
;SS
"
"
<3
=
<3
L 99 M L
d ^0;SF%
"
7
$
#!
*
3
;S;
1
4
KEST
;EES0 "
*
$
.
% /!
*
M L
*
^ " lM R
T
+
*
T
7
T
H
/
b
2R2
R9 "
(
" #!
"
9
3"
;SG
<L
M b
(
="
%
L "
" ! ;SK%
9
;FSU0
( ;SI
)
P M_ /DFF ESYT
UGK YDD0 < M
22= /
#
4
#
"
) # " (
<
"
% *
0 (
" !
9
#
7
5
R R /KIK U;;T
;EIG
'% :^ R
*
0
" (
R
1
"
#
34
100
4
4
!
"
5R R# !
%
( #
2
=
h/
" =
O
O
!
"
0%
)
6
) 9
$
!
)
9
h%
!
"
9
9
%h
"
"
#"
)
9%
!
(
2
9# "
"
%
( #"
!
!
)
!
)
9
O
$ )
!)
)
! !
6
" 9
))
"
)
$
"
9
9
%
)
24
;SU
"
% 9
;SY
$ 9
# !
!
! _^
$
$
#
<3 =
9
$
)
<3
<3 =
+
3
$
#
+
#
<3
"
" !
#
+
" ;;;% 3
#
7
"
;;D
%
1
1
#
3
!
%
&"
#!
7
/ Mc
0
(
" #
" ;;F%
#
#
!
%
<$
7
)'
<
6
"
. ,)
=
:
)
#"
(
#
=
%* " $
"
T
'
% 3
= "
#
!
. "LR /I;E IIYT
;D;K ;DKS0
0
"
%
=0
3
3
"# !
!
#
#
*
"
!
9
$
)
)
)
#
"
;;I
'
%
"
3
)
.
"
,
"
% 7 #
(
%.
"
.
;;E
=;;G% . "
"
<3 , =#
9
6
6 )
"
6 )
,
$ )
!
9
;;S
1
<
.
/
!
%
6
*
)
)
/(
bL M 0%
!
%
%
!
9
/( 0
(
$
<
#
% 3
#
.)
8 <*
(
(
!
"
#
"
%
)
;SU
"
#
. " #
"
. "
*
"
'
3
3 !
.
3
$
*
/L
'
! "
$
" #
"
%.
*
)
C c
M
"
( #!
"
#
(
+ %H
# :^ R# .%KY
+ %
e
R# \M L
M # .%II#
= [M
k h/ % % !
(
0
[ "
%
110
Zum einen bei Plotin und Parmenides s. Stamatellos, Plotinus and the Presocratics, S.30 ff.
;;;
[ XR M R "
P
LM 9 # %D# .%DU; %#
7
!
i^R
#
(
(
3
%
;;D
+ % % %
R R#
# " . "LR 7
!
V 2
!
!
! _^ #
L_
QV
M
Q !!
R# .%DSE %
;;E
[ XR M R#
MR
k "# .% K;EO
:^ R
:
1
4
)
# %
.
#
) . # .%DFD DFF
;;F
+ % % % " L
"R# - ^ M
R9 # %E# .% DGO % - Q^Q
# .%;;F
;;G
" L
"R# - Q^Q
# .%IY
116
Damit ist natrlich nicht gemeint, es gebe eine vllig identische Lehre. Gemeint ist vielmehr das
Vorhandensein gemeinsamer Grundgedanken. Zum Gedanken einer philosophia perennis s. z.B. Aldous Huxley,
The Perennial Philosophy
;SY
25
"
# !
(
/ ^0
? "
(
#
.
3"
+ "
/"MV 0
3"
9
.
GK# + E8 <3
3
+ "
/
MV 0=%
*
"
"
"
#
'
7
1
'
"
)
)
)
#!
:
#
#
(! #
!
A
!
!
1
, ( "
)9
! ) 9
7
6
! J
* #
"
$ )
"
"
;;K
!
3
% .
6
! _^ # (
"
#
/dM 0
%.
C c
M
9
#
)
>
.
*
!
:
%
,
( "
" !
+
!
%
&"
#
3
#
)
)
* %
" #!
"
#
/ d mM
!%
*
'
' %
. !
"
% 3
8*
!
, +
%3
"
,) =;;U%
#
8<
:
3
" % >
:
"
*
"
)
#
:
"@
)
3
%
:
)
"
"
+
#
!
%1
$
#
2R /b"
+
0
"
#
>
2
!
#
"
#
@
"
+
"
!
# !
"
,
!
% 6
*
!
)
!
%
+
#
"
(
"
:
#
(
A
+
%>
%
.
+
+
" %:
.
" !
!
%:
)
#
)
)
)
% 7
:
$
)
!
#
*
# $
)
9
"
%
:
# % %
)
#
"
"
*
#
)
#
!
:
A "
+
%
&" !
:
"
"
%
#
:
7
3
!
+
#
"
"
!
%3
#! @
+
!
%
:
)
#
"
@
+
" )
!
#
,
!
:
$
)
%
;;K
;;U
C c
M
e
R#
/.
R
ED +
RV
Y0
Ld
%F# .%EIK
"
/ ^0
26
A
!
"
"
" '
) !
%6
"
3
:
H
"
3!
%
.
% ?
!
(
% +
:
A :
)
#
%3
'
"
"
+
- 4"
*
"
'
' %5
4 /C c
M
"
%
:
"
3
"
%
"
#
.
"
C c
M
#
"
+
"!
.
+
#:
"
#
'
%3
C c
M
'
C
*
#
2
!
"
.
"
%
#
"
.
.
@
'
$
!
%
C c
M
*
*
#
9
(
:
/L 20
*
#
,
"
"
>'
!
%
#
%
$
,"
>
"
#
:
"
"
#
,
#
#
*
:
7"
@
!
"
C c
M
"
# !
+
!
M RZ
0
"
# "
%
)
:
:
1
" # % %
'
%
#
"
" %
:
3 !
.
27
"^: 99 #
^8
]!McL M
R9
ML L
RZ
# G%
%#
^ %5
%
! L#
e
R#
. 99 P
%8 : M
" L
2^ R
!M #
%8
RV
%# C
@
M !
Ld
" L
!M #
^ DSSG
! _^ #
\M
M !
"
a]
c
!R
M"
L R
;FDD %
# .
^ ;YUG
^ DSSG
E%
8 \M
P 9 R#
. L
$ )
H
[L
[L R#
"^ P
# .%;SY ;EE
*
L R "%
83
>
% EE#
MLR 8
"
%0 . Rg
DSSE
2M M
M R9R ! a M
R # E%
%#
^ %5
%
#5 8
>,
-
#*
# -
N 9)
'" 8 -MV
"
#: "
8
# F%
"
H%%88
# $
T
H
# $
;YYD
%#
DSSE
#3
#*
)
# !
#5 8
H
DSSG
"
H
#*
DSSD
"
DSSG
DSSG
# H "
9# H "
DSSE
;YUS
H
#H "
H
#$
8 ( g H )
)
# ?4
!#
8.
# $ ) :%8
8
.
H
;YUK
#7
9#
%8
%8
DSSE
%8
/1 !f
1 !f
0 ?4
(
9 #5
;YDU
DSSE
;YYU
5 #5
;YD;
28
3A #
:%T
>
!
8 5
.9 "
#*
5 #.
H
H
9T
(
#1
9# $
%8 5
\M R# L "
" 6
.
8
9H
# 1 !f
#7
DSSD
DSSD
DSS;
Q^Q R [
"% " M R 8
9g 1 !+
4 # 1 !f
M 812
\R R# L "
;YYE
T
. "
DSSI
?
-
2[
Q^Q#
^ DSSG
!Ma
!Mc#
DSSS
(
#7
3%8
3%
M R M
!
22f 9M "%
7
P
8 > M"
#5 8
7 )
DSSI
a "# i LMc;YYE
6
# D%
%#
DSSI
;YUD
#
R# "^ L ""M
#:"
8
" L
;YI; /1
- ^M
"
#$
) 9
"
;YYU
%# i LMcDSSD
;YYK
)
"% L R8 L6
"R8 - Q^Q
%8
" #
QM"R # D%
. !
#3
DSSF
" #\
" L
# 1 !f
n? @
4 9#
" g
(%8 .
5!
*
% $9
R9 #
]M#
L R2M L
V%VM " R
" 2
M" M
"^ L
"R `M "# D%
ML
%# 1 _
R R#
^ DSSD
^ %5
%
"% f 9 8
9!
R[
1 R 8
" :[ #
#
^ ;YKU
"^ * R
"%
>[ L
M _
R L 2Mc
^ DSSD
%8 > M"
DSSS
2M !
2R
M"
[ [ RL !
QM # U%
%#
29
" .R M8
M > M"
%8
1 _M #
[M M !
%5
%
"R M # C
R R#
2" #
;FDE %
^ R8
8
9
M R#
:Mk"
2M
>
!M
R# "^\ L
#1
g :
:)
2 c
M #
"
;YUI
DSSU
"% f L2^"%
"% 6Q^
M R#
"
^ %5
%
# *
DSSD
;YIG
M R k R"
"
H
$"
%# C
8
)
R# H
$
>
V `M "R9R # D%
- ]8
Q !!
) 9
"%
>M[M R#
) 9# % ?%# % 5
% /1
M R# "^ - _8
#
QV
Q
5
L_
CM
;EKK
#7
"
"M R
;YYU
(
"
;YIG
Q^ "
M L "
c99 R#
M "% P
R 8
R 8
^ !R# L "
1 _M[R#
"^ L ""M
%# C
1
M_ LM # D;%
"% L R8 -
7"
P
#f
"%
%T
>
".
%#
^ ;YUS
Mc Q
# >
#5
1 "R#
^MT C
R [ XRL /: _M
1 _M[R0# I%
M 8 - 2 [ XRL #
CM
;YYD
":
0 DSSE
%;# 7
;FSU %
:
?
$ ))# +
DSSU
R# . L "% L "
%0#
<
#+
:% $
DSSK
8
# .%;I ;DE
8H
/1 !f
1 L M R# X " R8 .R
?
# i LMc;YYF
;F;U %
1 " a R#
1
8 [ XM R# i LMc;YUI
8>
T
(
%0#
' #+
DSSG
%8 +
.%;E DDD
,
.M
8?
/
C
M 3
'
%0#
#+
3
.
DSSK
.)
:
30
CM[M R# L "
.%KY
UG
M28
9M
2M
8 e M" V V R2 !
R9 !
2R2 R
L9R
99M
Mc [ X a L "
M R9 #
M2
CM[M R#
^ DSSG
CM]R# * M 8
:
)
> 9M 99 # .%;IY
#
%8
"
%0 . Rg
.)
#5
;YDF
a R#
"
;YGF
#7 )
;YKK
"%
7
DSSE
a R# "^
>
83
% EE#
) #> 8
;YE
8 6Q^
;YYS
5M
" 9;YYE
%8 6
-,
P
#H
g3
"
$ #7
^ DSSD
?
#$ "
9DSSF
.
;YYY
9
(
M
D% % E% 5% %#
D% % E% 5% %#
"% L ""M 8
.
$
7
^ DSSE
9o .
;YY;
#5 8
%8
%#
" 9DSSK
" L #
%8
k "# E%
L 2R9
# ?4
* _R # L "
MR
%8
* "
$ )
^ DSSG
5!
3 #5
?4
LM 9 R
8 $
%#
# (
9#
LM # D%
%8 1 7
"% " M R 8
" c!
%8
>, ;YU;
[ XR M R# i
%8
$ )
L_
9
) 9# H "
9
3
.
%D#
C "
;YY;
;YYD
LM R # L
M DSS;
R . RM R
0 ;YYD
!
!
1 !f
1 !f
L "M !
/
.
# 5 8 C
_M
%;#
" 9DSS;
#
" 9DSSS
)
;YKK
#>
DSS;
*%8
9#