Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Frankl
Frankl
Departmentof Physical Education, California State University, Los Angeles, CA, USA
Abstract Zusammenfassung
The purpose of this project wasto introduce water safety princi- PROJEKT DES SCHWIMMENS UND WASSER-
ples, and teach swimmingand diving skills to children-the major- SPRINGENS FUR DIE JUGENDLICHEN: FER-
ity of whom come from low-income families-with the intent of TIGKEITEN UND DIE ENTWICKLUNG VON
enhancing self-esteem through the mastery of swimming and SELBSTACHTUNG
diving skills, Second, third and fourth graders (N=210) received
twenty-one 35-minute swimming lessons at a community swim- Der Zweck dieses Projekts war sowohl die Einfuihrung von Was-
ming center during one school year. Measurements included sersicherheitsmaBnahmen, als auch das Lehren von Schwumnm-
swimming skills, self-esteem, and selected attitudes toward swim- und Wasserspringfertigkeiten bei Kindern, die meistens aus den
ming and diving. Upon completionofthe program,the participat- Familien mit niedrigem Einkommen stammten, mit der Absicht,
ing classroom teachers were surveyed by an open-ended die Selbstachtung durch Beherrschung vono.a. Fertigkeiten zu
questionnaire which related attitudes toward the project, and erhohen. In einem Zeitraum von einem Schuljahr haben die
performance of the swimming & diving instructors to the chil- Schiiler aus derersten, zweiten und dritten Klasse (N=210) 21
dren’s classroom performance and academic achievements. Schwimmunterrichtsstunden in einem Schwimmzentrum besucht
Post-test scores for three intact classrooms (N=78) revealedsig- - jede Unterrichtsstunde dauerte 35 Minuten. Das Messen um-
nificant improvements in swimmingability for all participants faBte Schwimmfertigkeiten, Selbstachtung und die ausgewdhlten
(t=15.49, p<.0001). The combined group of second andthird Stellungnahmen zum Schwimmen und Wasserspringen. Nach der
graders demonstrated increase in self-esteem (n=47, t=3.31, Beendigung des Programmes wurden die Lehrer mittels einer
p<.002), as measured onthe Battle self-esteem inventory and as offenen Umfrage befragt, ihre Stellungnahmen sowohlzum Pro-
reported by the classroom teachers. Based onthe available data jekt, zur Arbeit von Lehrern als auch zur Leistung von Kindern
and the teachers’ comments it was concluded that the "prime im Unterricht zu GuBern. Die Resultate des Testsfiirdrei gesamten
teaching time”lost to swimmingin the morning hours was recov- Klassen (N=78) haben eine bedeutende Verbesserung von
ered with a much improved afternoonsession. In addition, the Schwimmfihigkeit bei allen Teilnehmem(t=15.49, p<0.0001)
participating classroom teachers reported overall improvement in gezeigt. Die kombinierte Gruppe, die die Schiiler aus der zweiten
classroom performanceand a higherself-esteem in particular. und dritten Klassen umfa@te, zeigte die Erhéhung der
Selbstachtung (n=47, t=3.31, p<0.002) in den Tests fiir die
Beurteilung von Kampfbereitschaft und Selbstachtung. Diese
Keywords: children, swimming & divingskills, attitudes, self-es- Erhéhung warauch in den von den Lehrern geduBerten Meinun-
teem gen erkennbar. Die uns zur Verftigung stehenden Daten und die
Meinungen der Lehrerzeigen, daB die beste Zeit ftir das Lehren,
die morgens verwendet wurde, in Nachmittagsstundennachgeholt
werden konnte. Die Lehrer haben auch die gesamte Verbesserung
von Leistungen bemerkt, und besonders die Erhéhung von
Selbstachtung.
14
Frankl., D.: SWIMMING AND DIVING PROJECT... Kinesiology 28 (1996) 1:14-19
Compared to above average and/or high income fami- donation of bussing services by the Passadena school
lies, children fromlow income families, are less likely to District and a $10,000.00 grant by the Wingart Founda-
be involved in extra curricular activities since such en- tion made this projecta reality.
deavors require a substantial commitment of time and The purpose of the swimming andself-esteem project
money (Coakley, 1987, 1994; McPherson, Curtis, and was to (1) introduce water safety principles, (2) teach
Loy, 1989). The limited access to youth sport programs swimming and diving skills to children-the majority of
in low income neighborhoods makes the role of the whom come from low-income families, and have no or
school’s physical education curriculum central to their very limited access to a swimming pool and swimming
health-related and skill-related fitness preparation and and diving instruction,(3) enhance self-esteem and
maintenance. Serving as student teacher supervisor I achievement motivation through the mastery of swim-
have witnessed,over the last few years, an increase in the ming and diving skills, and (4) provide an additional
number of students per class along with a steady de- mode of exercise for the development and maintenance
crease in days and/or number of hours dedicated to oflife long health-relatedfitness. Based on theliterature
weekly elementary and secondary physical education review, it was hypothesized that a program providing
programs. swimming and diving instruction to childrenat risk will
Out of concern about overemphasis on academics, and (1) achieve gains in swimminganddivingskills, (2) boost
insufficient amount of exercise, French physicians and self-esteem, and (3) enhance motivation and thus con-
educators in the early 1950s decided to study the effects tribute to improved academic performance.
of a revised curriculum that would include 1 to 2 hours
per day (as contrasted with two weekly hours in the
regular program) of physical education. As reported by
MacKenzie (1974), a numberof experimentswereset up Method
in 1951 at the Vanes Primary School situated in the
southern suburbs of Paris, France, to test the hypothesis Subjects
that physical education, at the expense of the academic
program, will enhance rather than impede academic Second, third and forth graders (N = 210) attending an
performance. "By 1960, the results of the experiments elementary school at the Pasadena Unified School Dis-
more than confirmed the basic hypothesis. Not only were trict took part in the 1993-1994 swimming and diving
the health,fitness, discipline and enthusiasmsuperior in project. Approximately 80% of the students participated
the experimental schools, but the academic results sur- in the lunch program and some 25% werebilingual and
passed thoseofthe controlclasses... Similar experiments received Spanishservice.
were then repeated in Brussels and Japan, with similar
results (Bailey, 1976, p. 88)." Measures
At the onset of this project, it was hypothesized that at
SwimmingAbility Measures. The evaluation of swimming
risk children from predominantly low income families,
skills was in accordance with the Red Cross testing
who have limited access to youth sports programs, will
guidelines. A nine point scale ranging from levelI, or the
greatly benefit from an activity that will provide them
equivalent of a non-swimmer, through level IX, or the
with physical exercise and the acquisition of new and
equivalent of an advanced swimmer, with level VI being
unusual skills. The selection of swimming and diving
the equivalent of a proficient swimmer was utilized to
skills, over other activities was done since swimming and
assess swimming progress.
diving skills can contribute to drowning accident preven-
tion, and provide the individualwith a lite long important Self-Esteem Measures. James Battle’s (1992) Culture-
mode of exercise that can improve and maintain health Free Self-Esteem Inventory (CFSEI-2 FormA,grades 2
related physical fitness. Overcoming fear of water and through 9) contains a total of 60 items underthe follow-
fear ofheights, and the acquisition of new and unusual ing subtests:
skills can contribute to feelings of competency and thus - General self-esteem (20 items)
result in a morepositive self-esteem in the project par- - Social/peer related self-esteem (10 items)
ticipants. Hopkins and Fleming (1983), for example,
- Academic/school-related self-esteem (10 items)
reported significantgains in self-esteem in a Melbourne
primary school resulting from a ten day swimming pro- - Parental/home-related self-esteem (10 items)
gram. - Lie/Defensiveness subtest (10 items)
Children that possess a higher or morepositive self-es-
teem, according to Weiss (1987), are more likely to Attitudes Toward Swimming and Pool Activities. State-
interpret successin athletics and/or in school work to be ments (10 items) relating to pool and/or swimming ac-
a result of their talents and hard work(i.e., attribute their tivities that students were asked to complete by checking
success to internal, stable and self-controllable reasons). one of the following three options: "T like it," "I don’t
Children with low self-esteem, on the other hand, are know,"or "I don’t like it." For example, "When wego to
morelikely to interpret success in terms of "It was too the pool...;" "When I wear my bathing suit...;" "When it is
easy" or "I was lucky" (i.e., unstable or uncontrollable time to use the diving board..."
factors) (Weiss, McAuley, Ebbeck, & Wiese, 1990). Questionnaire for the Classroom Teachers. An open-
Finally, the availability of the AAF Rose Bawl Aquatic ended questionnaire probing issues, such as, student
Centerwith its professional staff for a minimal priceof classroom related performance and academic achieve-
50 cents per child per day coupled with an in kind ment, attitude toward the project, performanceof the
15
|
Frankl., D.: SWIMMING AND DIVING PROJECT... Kinesiology 28 (1996) 1:14-19
AAFRBACstaff, project related activities that took 7, and five level 8 swimmers. The average pre-swim level
place in the classroom, and overall evaluation of the for the present sample was 4.26. By the completion of
project. the project there were one level 3, seven level 4, seven-
teen level 5, twenty onelevel6, six level7,fifteen level 8
Procedures
and one level 9 swimmers. The average post-swim level
was 6.06. A paired samples t-test between pre-and post
The project’s research director instructed the program swimming performanceyielded at value of 15.49 with an
director at the AAFRBACinall matters of data collec- associated probability of occurrence of .0001. Clearly,
tion and provided him with all the necessary forms. The participants made substantial gains in their swimming
AAFRBACprogram director trained his staff and the skills throughout the program. Nosignificant sex differ-
participating classroom teachers, and supervised both ences in swimmingability were detected at the pre- and
skills testing and self-esteem data collection. post-program swimmingskills evaluations,
Children participating in the project received twenty one
35 minute swimming lessons at the AAFRBACduring Self-Esteem Inventory
one school year. The program included basic and ad-
vanced swimmingskills, water games, fundamentals of
A one-way ANOVA comparing pre- program self-es-
spring board diving, and lap swimmingforhealth related teem scores revealed significant differences between the
fitness. Students were bussed in from their elementary boys’ (n=39) and the girls’ (n=38) scores
school to the AAFRBACin Pasadena 2-3 times a week. F(1,76)=4.6472, p=.034. The mean pre-CFSEI score
Students left school, swam, and were bussed back to
was 35.57 for girls and 39.25 for boys. Thesex differences
detected on the CFSEI pre-test diminished by the end
school. While the project was an integral part of the
everyday curriculum (no extra time was allocated forit) of the program. The post-CFSEI meanscore was 37.80
a little more than one hourof the academic program was
for girls (n=36) and 39.80 for boys (n=40)
missed on pool days. The project was executed by certi- F(1,74)=2.3123 p=.1326. An independent t-test be-
fied swimming and diving instructors employed at the
tween the present project’s post-CFSEI combinedscore,
AAFRBAC. Thestudentinstructorratio at the pool was
and Battle’s(1992, N=1,679, M=35.37) mean values re-
vealed that our sample’s CFSEI meanscore wassignifi-
1 to 6or7.
cantly higher (M=38.81, t = 4.93p.001).
The CFSEI-2 was administered to small groupsin grades
2 & 3 with assistance to select individuals, and to the
Attitudes Toward Swimming and PoolActivities. A t-test
wholeclass in grade 4. The teachers read the directions
for paired samples between students’ feelings about the
aloud as the children read silently. The teachers told the
pool and swimming during the second week ofthe pro-
children not to hesitate to ask if they had any questions
gram (M=5.31) andthe last weekofthe program (6.83)
about what was to be done. The same procedure took revealedasignificant positive changeinattitude (L = 3.7
place once during the second weekof the project and a p=.001).
second time during the last week of the project.
Questionnaire for the Classroom Teachers
The questionnaire probing general attitudes toward
swimming and poolactivities was administered along In our open-ended questionnaire for the classroom
with the self-esteem (on a separate form) questionnaire. teachersparticipating in our project, the teacherof the
Shortly after the conclusion ofthe project the participat- 4th grade group provided the following comments about
ing teachers completed and returned the classroom her group:
teacher questionnaires. > This is a gifted and talented cluster class. Fourteen
Data analyses were derived through theStatistical Pack- of the students are identified [gifted] and the other
age for the Social Sciences/Personal Computer en- 21 are over-achievers. They are all “leader types,”
hanced edition (SPSS/PC+ 6.0) (Hedderson, 1991: and academically talented. The swimming lessons
Norusis, 1990). The critical level for rejection of the broadened their approachto all areas of the curricu-
null-hypothesis was set at .05. However, exact prob- lum. They became more mature andself-confident.
abilities are reported when appropriate.
If you had a chance to repeat this program, would you
choose to do it? Why?
Results
> Yes. Ifeel the children are learning good skills in a
Completed forms and data including pre- and post-test friendly atmosphere.Fora few of mychildren, it in-
data were returned byonly three of the seven participat- troduces themto skills & a sport they have never
ing classroom teachers. The following evaluation and tackled before.
analysis, therefore, discusses the 78 complete or nearly
complete available records. Subjects who dropped out >» Yes. Great carry overinto all aspects of curriculum
andgreat growthin self-esteem.
before completion, and subjects whojoinedin late in the
program,and had three or more missing test items, were
excluded from the data poll. The differences between the second and third graders’
CFSEIs and the fourth graders’ CFSEIs became evident
Swimming Ability as wetallied the CFSEI forms. Rather than analyzing the
whole sample as a homogeneousgroup, which obviously
At the project’s onset, there were twolevel1, six level2, it was not, a second analysis with the second and third
sevenlevel3, twenty nine level 4, twenty level 5, one level graders as one group and the forth graders as a separate
16
Frankl., D.: SWIMMING AND DIVING PROJECT... Kinesiology 28 (1996) 1:14-19
17
Frankl., D.: SWIMMING AND DIVING PROJECT... Kinesiology 28 (1996) 1:14-19
Table 1 T-test for paired samples between the pre-and post-test Table 3 T-test for paired samples betweenthe pre-and post-test
swimming skills self-esteem scores for the combined sample
Swimming CFSEI-2
Skills Pre-test 4.26 1.49 pre-test 37.4800 7.745 894
70 75
Swimming CFSEI-2
Skills Post-test 6.06 1.39 oeeineen 38.8133 5.786 668
t-value df 2-tail Sig t- value of 2-tail Sig
15.49 69 p<.0001 2.11 74 p<.038
18
Frankl., D.: SWIMMING AND DIVING PROJECT... Kinesiology 28 (1996) 1:14-19
willing to admit. seven classes that included 210 students, proper data was
While the preliminary findings of this ongoing project available for this report for only three classes or a total
are very encouraging, the results of the present study of 78 records (37%).
need to be interpreted with caution. Out of a total of
References
1. Armstrong, C.F. (1984). The lessonsofsport: Classsocialization in British and American boarding schools. Sociology of Sport
Journal, 1, 314-331.
2. Bailey, D.A. (1976) . The growing child andthe needforphysicalactivity.In J.G. Albinson, & G.M. Andrew (Eds.). Child in sport
and physical activity. Volumethree: Internationalseries on sport sciences(pp. 81-93). Baltimore, MD: UniverityPark Press.
3. Battle, J. (1992). Culture-free self-esteem inventories (2nd ed.). Austin,TX: Pro-Ed.Coakley,J.J. (1987). Children and the sport
socialization process. In D.Gould, & M.R. Weiss (Eds.). Advancesin pediatric sport sciences. Volume two: Behavioralissues
(pp. 43-60). Champaign, IL: Human Kinetics.
a Coakley, J.J. (1994). Sportin society: Issues and controversies (Sth ed.).St. Louis, MO: C.V. Mosby.
6. Hopkins, K. & Fleming, L. (1981). Impact of learning to swim on children’sself-esteem. Australian Journal of Science and
Medicine in Sport, 1 (1), 26-27.
7. Hovell, M.F. (1978). An evaluation of elementary students’ voluntary physical activity during recess. Research Quarterly for
Exercise and Sport, 49, 460-474.
8. Logsdon, B. J., Barrett, K. R., Ammons, M., Broer, M. R., Halverson, L. E..McGee, R., & Robertson, M. A. (1984). Physical
education forchildren: A focus on the teaching process (2nd ed.). Philadelphia, PA: Lea & Febiger.
2, McPherson, B.D., Curtis, .E., & Loy, J.W. (1989). The social significance of sport: An introduction to the sociology of sport.
Campaign, IL: Human Kinetics.
10. Nieman, D.C. (1990). Fitness and sports medicine: An introduction. Palo Alto,CA:Bull.
11. Norusis, M.J. (1990). SPSS/PC+ 4.0 base manualfor the IBM PC/XT/ATandPS/2. Chicago, IL: SPSSInc. Office of Disease
Prevention and Health Promotion, Public Health service (1985, January). Summary of findings from National Children and
Youth Fitness Study, Journal of Physical Education Recreation and Dance, 2-90.
12. Ross, J.G., & Pate, R.R. (1987 November/December). The nationalchildren and youthfitness study II: A summary of findings.
JournalofPhysical Education Recreation and Dance, 51-56.
13. Tucker, L.A. (1982). Effect of a weight-training program onthe self-conceptof college males. Perceptual and MotorSkills, 54,
1055-1061.
14. Tucker, L.A. (1983). Effect of weight-training on self-concept: A profile of those influenced most. Research Quarterly for
Exercise and Sport, 54, 389-397.
15. Wall, J., & Murray, N. (1990). Children & movement: Physical education in the elementary school.
16. Dubuque, IA: Wm. C. Brown.Weiss, M.R.(1987). Self-esteem and achievementin children’s sport and physical activity. In
D. Gould & M.R. Weiss (Eds.), Advancesin pediatric sport sciences,Vol.2: Behavioral issues (pp. 87-119). Champaign, IL:
HumanKinetics.
and
17. Weiss, M.R., McAuley, E., Ebbeck, V., & Wiese, D.M. (1990). Self-esteemand causal attributions for children’s physical
social competencein sport. Joumalof Sport & Exercise Psychology, 12, 21-36.
19