Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Quality Management
in the Automobile Industry
6
Product Audit Part 5
Guidelines
7#&3,%&*,4
G0=(5&+.' 8!!> 1(
M:,5$%% =503#O'&0*
?@7&"(#.' .A +%(1.'(#3#&#-B
W.&4 6I/ 30O#-,*' &4 $ 5,O0--,*3$'&0* U.&O. &4 T5,, T05 $*(0*, '0 #4,9
/*(0*, #4&*+ &' -#4' ,*4#5, '.$' &' &4 $==%&,3 O055,O'%( &* ,$O. &*3&:&3#$%
O$4,9
W.&4 6I/ 30O#-,*' '$P,4 $OO0#*' 0T '., %$',4' 4'$', 0T ',O.*0%0+( $' '.,
'&-, &' &4 &44#,39 W., $==%&O$'&0* 0T '., 6I/ 5,O0--,*3$'&0*4 30,4 *0' &*
$*( U$( 5,%&,:, '., #4,5 0T .&4 0U* 5,4=0*4&1&%&'( T05 '., #4, 0T '.,
30O#-,*'9 W0 '.&4 ,X',*'; '., #4,5 $==%&,4 '., 30O#-,*' $' .&4 0U* 5&4P9
W., 6I/ $*3 '.04, &*:0%:,3 &* 35$U&*+ #= '., 6I/ 5,O0--,*3$'&0*4
3,O%&*, $%% %&$1&%&'( &* $*( O&5O#-4'$*O,49
C%A%+%'7%( -. (-;'$;+$(
W., &*3&:&3#$% 4'$*3$534 5,T,55,3 '0 1( '.,&5 I2? *#-1,5 $*3 '.,&5 3$', 0T
&44#, $5, Y#0',3 U&'. '., =,5-&44&0* 0T '., I2? H7,5-$* <'$*3$534
2*4'&'#',J9 2' &4 ,44,*'&$% '0 #4, '., %$',4' &44#, 0T '., 4'$*3$534; U.&O. $5,
$:$&%$1%, T50- Z,#'. 6,5%$+ 7-1N; D![[8 Z,5%&*; 7,5-$*(9
D.1B+#>E-
W.&4 30O#-,*' &4 =50',O',3 1( O0=(5&+.'9 2'4 #4, 0#'4&3, '., 4'5&O' %&-&'4 0T
'., O0=(5&+.' %$U4 &4 =50.&1&',3 U&'.0#' '., =,5-&44&0* 0T '., 6I/ $*3 &4
=#*&4.$1%, 1( %$U9 W.&4 $==%&,4 &* =$5'&O#%$5 U&'. 5,+$53 '0 O0=(&*+;
'5$*4%$'&*+; -&O50CT&%-&*+ $*3 4'05$+, $*3 =50O,44&*+ &* ,%,O'50*&O 4(4',-49
F+;'(&;-#.'(
W.&4 30O#-,*' U&%% $%40 $==,$5 &* 0'.,5 %$*+#$+,49 E%,$4, O0*'$O' '.,
6I/C")G T05 '., %$',4' =04&'&0*9
M#5 '.$*P4 $%40 +0 '0 $%% U.0 .$:, +&:,* #4 ,*O0#5$+,-,*' $*3 $44&4'$*O,
&* +,*,5$'&*+ $*3 &-=50:&*+ '., 30O#-,*'9
J 6+%A;7% K
O 8"$#- 1+.>+;2 J)
A9D 2*=#' O5&',5&$ DR
A98 b$(0#' &*4=,O'&0* DL
A9B <=,O&$% G0E HO0*T05-&'( 0T =503#O'&0*J O.,OP4 DL
A9A <'&=#%$'&0*4 5,+$53&*+ '., $#3&' =50+5$- DL
A9R cX',*' 0T $* $#3&' =50+5$- D@
A9L /#3&' =50+5$- 5,40#5O,4 D@
A9[ 2-=%,-,*'&*+ '., $#3&' =50+5$- D@
A9> )0*&'05&*+ $*3 ,:$%#$'&*+ '., $#3&' =50+5$- 8!
P 8"$#- 1&;' )J
R9D G.$5$O',5&4'&O4 '0 1, O.,OP,3 $*3 4=,O&T&O$'&0*4 8D
R98 G.,OP&*+ -,'.034 F ,Y#&=-,*' $*3 5$*30- 4$-=%, 4&a, 88
R9B ^,Y#&5,-,*'4 T05 '$P&*+ =$5'4 d '.,&5 &3,*'&T&O$'&0* 8B
R9B9D W$P&*+ =$5'4 8B
R9B98 23,*'&T(&*+ =$5'4 8B
R9B9B W5$*4=05'&*+ $*3 =$OP&*+ =$5'4 8B
R9B9A ^,'#5*&*+ =$5'4 T05 #4, 8B
R9A ^,T,5,*O, 30O#-,*'4 8A
K C%1.+-#'> )K
[9D ?0',4 0* O%$44&T(&*+ 3,:&$'&0*4 $*3 '.,&5 ,:$%#$'&0* 8>
5 D.++%7-#,% ;7-#.'( N4
>9D 2--,3&$', $O'&0*4 BD
>98 _*0U%,3+, '5$*4T,5 BD
J4 C%A%+%'7% $.7"2%'-( NO
<&*O, '., $==,$5$*O, 0T '., T&54' ,3&'&0* &* /=5&% D@@> O0*3&'&0*4 T05
-$*#T$O'#5,54 $*3 4#==%&,54 '0 '., $#'0-01&%, &*3#4'5( .$:, O.$*+,3
-$5P,3%(9 /#'0-01&%,C4=,O&T&O 5,Y#&5,-,*'4 %$&3 30U* &* 4'$*3$534 U&'.
&*',5*$'&0*$% :$%&3&'(; 4#O. $4 2<MFW< DL@A@; *0U T05- '., 1$4&4 T05 Y#$%&'(
-$*$+,-,*' &* '., $#'0-01&%, &*3#4'5(9
W., *,U ,3&'&0* &4 1$4,3 0* '., 5,Y#&5,-,*'4 0T 2<M D@!DD ] e7#&3,%&*,4
T05 "#$%&'( $*3F05 ,*:&50*-,*' -$*$+,-,*' 4(4',-4 $#3&'&*+e9
f*%&P, '., T&54' ,3&'&0*; '.&4 O#55,*' :0%#-, 30,4 *0' O0*'$&* O0*O5,',
,X$-=%,49 2*4',$3; $ O03, 0T =5$O'&O, .$4 1,,* O5,$',3 T05 '.,
-$*$+,-,*' 0T =503#O' $#3&' =50+5$-4; U.&O. U&%% ,*$1%, O0-=$*&,4 '0
3,:,%0= '.,&5 0U* 4(4',-4 '0 4#&' '.,&5 =$5'&O#%$5 =503#O'49
/4 =$5' 0T '., =50O,44 O.$&* '., =503#O' $#3&' 4.0#%3 &%%#4'5$', '., Y#$%&'(
%,:,% 0T '., =503#O'4 -$*#T$O'#5,3 &*C.0#4, $*3 0#'4&3,9
4'
W.&4 8*3 ,3&'&0* 0T 6I/ 60%#-, L9R ] eE503#O' /#3&'e 5,=%$O,4 '., D
,3&'&0*9
E50O,44
"#$%&'( 6I/ L E50O,44 $#3&' 6I/ L $#3&' T05
$#3&' E$5' B T05 =503#O'&0* =503#O'4 F 4,5:&O,4 E$5' [ =503#O'&0*
,Y#&=-,*'
H6I/ LJ G03, 0T =5$O'&O, T05 Y#$%&'( 4'$*3$534 &* '., $#'0-01&%, &*3#4'5(
D!
Covered by the requirements (e.g., monitoring process Covered by the requirements of
of ISO/TS 16949 and VDA 6.1 parameters, SPC, tensile ISO/TS 16949, Section 8.2.4.1
strength, torques, etc…)
Purpose The purpose of a product audit can be : Process control To demonstrate compliance with the
• to identify the potential for improvements customer's specifications
• to play the role of the customer, (internal
& external) regarding the finished product
• to take account of items relevant to the
customer (e.g., consider feedback from
the field)
• to prove reliability requirements
• to prove the interplay of product
characteristics (function check)
• to demonstrate characteristics not
checked in the production control plan1)
• to demonstrate product characteristics
which may influence customer
satisfaction
• to demonstrate product characteristics
checked via equivalents in in-process
checks2)
• to demonstrate packing and labelling
Frequency of To the internal audit program and as • to the production control • to the production control plan
execution required plan • Repeated periodically, generally at
W., T0%%0U&*+ 4O.,-$'&O 4.0U4 '., &*3&:&3#$% 4'$+,4 0T $ =503#O' $#3&'9 W.,
4'$'#4 &* ,$O. O$4, &4 &*3&O$',3 &* '., T0%%0U&*+ <,O'&0*4 0T '.&4 30O#-,*'9
/#3&' =%$* B
/#3&' =%$* 8
/#3&' =%$* D
E$5$9
R
E$5$9 [ ^,=05'&*+
/#3&' =%$* B
/#3&' =%$* 8
/#3&' =%$* D
E$5$9
R
E$5$9 [ ^,=05'&*+
W., $#3&' =50+5$- T05 =503#O' $#3&'4 O0*'$&*4 $%% '., $O'&:&'&,4 5,Y#&5,3 &*
',5-4 0T =%$**&*+; 05+$*&4$'&0* $*3 ,X,O#'&0*; 40 '.$' '., =%$**,3 $#3&'4
O$* 1, O$55&,3 0#' ,TT&O&,*'%( $*3 ,TT,O'&:,%( U&'.&* '., 4=,O&T&,3 '&-, =,5&039
W.&4 $%40 &*O%#3,4 '., =50:&4&0* 0T =,540**,% $*3 O.,OP&*+F&*4=,O'&0*
5,40#5O,49
^,4=0*4&1&%&'( T05 '., $#3&' =50+5$- %&,4 U&'. '., =,540* 5,4=0*4&1%, T05
Y#$%&'( -$*$+,-,*'9
W., T0%%0U&*+ +,*,5$% &*=#' O5&',5&$ $5, '0 1, O0*4&3,5,3 $*3 -$( 1,
,X=$*3,3 '0 &*O%#3, 0'.,54]
2* $33&'&0* '.,5, $5, &*C.0#4, O0*3&'&0*4 $*3 O&5O#-4'$*O,4 U.&O. $5, '0 1,
'$P,* &*'0 O0*4&3,5$'&0* 3#5&*+ =%$**&*+; 4#O. $4 ]
/4 $ 1$4&O 5#%, $ -$*#T$O'#5,5 -#4' ,*4#5, '.$' .&4 =503#O'4 O0*T05- U&'.
%,+$% 5,Y#&5,-,*'49 f4&*+ G0E O.,OP4; =500T O$* 1, =50:&3,3 T05 $==50:$%
=#5=04,49
W$P&*+ '., 4#- 0T P*0U%,3+, $:$&%$1%, $*3 1$4,3 0* '., $#3&' =50+5$-;
'., =503#O'4 '0 1, $#3&',3 $*3 '., $440O&$',3 01j,O'&:,4 $5, 3,5&:,3 T05 '.,
=503#O' $#3&'49 / -$'5&X O$* 1, #4,3 '0 4#==05' '.&4 =50O,44; 4#O. $4 '.,
,X$-=%, &* W$1%, B9 W0 4&-=%&T( -$'',54; =503#O' T$-&%&,4 O$* 1, 35$U* #=
T50- '., T#%% 5$*+, 0T =503#O'4 -$*#T$O'#5,39
Evaluation
Evaluation
Evaluation
Evaluation
Yes / No
1,3, 9
1,3,9
1,3,9
1,3,9
1,3,9
Info Info Info Info Info Y/N Info Y/N Info Info
Confirm long-term
3 1 12 ppm 1 1 1 26 N Y Life test Yes
resistance
1 1 0 ppm 1 1 1 18 N N No
New engine
New bearing concept; new Noise generated
9 High volume 1 25 ppm 3 9 1 60 N N Yes
suppliers materials in under full load
valve drive
Durability
New processing requirements and
3 9 3% scrap 3 9 New patent 1 52 N N Yes
centre drawing
dimensions
the product
description
Evaluation
Evaluation
Evaluation
Evaluation
Evaluation
Evaluation
Evaluation
Part No(s).
Product
1,3, 9
1,3, 9
1,3,9
1,3,9
1,3,9
1,3,9
1,3,9
Info Info Info Info Info Info Info
Quiet
Expiring Not Not
1,9 T FDQI M1050 Jones 1 1 1 3 Average risks 1 No complaints 3 operation; 1
model significant significant
noise pattern
Customer
Software
Comfort expects High-value
Error codes conversion No audit
"Y" series YP14xx Davies 9 Image carrier 3 3 functions 9 9 9 optimum 3 product; low
in memory identified as carried out yet
criticized subjective quantities
problematic
quality
BA bearing bushes
1st
RA 12 mm 12124- application of Not No audit
Scott 9 1 1 None as yet 3 Average risks 9 1 3
series 12254 new significant carried out yet
generation
….. …….
Table. 3 : Example of a decision-making matrix for setting out the audit program
G0*4&3,5&*+ '.&4 ,X$-=%,; '., T0%%0U&*+ O0*O%#4&0*4 O$* 1, 35$U* T05 '.,
$#3&' =50+5$- ]
− S05 '., D9L WI [[P\ #*&' $* $#3&' &4 &*O%#3,3 &* '., $#3&'
=50+5$- 0*%( T05 5,Y#$%&T&O$'&0* '0 '., =503#O'&0* O0*'50% =%$*
− ?0 $#3&' &4 =%$**,3 T05 '., D9@ SI"2 &* '., =%$**&*+ =,5&03
− E503#O' $#3&'4 $5, =%$**,3 T05 T#5'.,5 =503#O'49
W., 01j,O'&:,4 T05 '., 5,%,:$*' =503#O' $#3&'4 3,5&:,3 T50- '., &*=#' O5&',5&$
H,9+9; O.,OP '., 4#1j,O'&:, Y#$%&'( 0T '., =$44,*+,5 O0-=$5'-,*'ei
eI,-0*4'5$', '., 5,Y#&5,3 *0&4, %,:,% T05 #*&' ol` U.,* &* 0=,5$'&0*ei
05 kJ 4.0#%3 1, #4,3 $4 &*=#' 3$'$ U.,* 35$U&*+ #= '., $#3&' =%$*4; '.,
4,%,O'&0* 0T $#3&'054 $*3 3,O&3&*+ 0* '., ,X',*' 0T '., $#3&'; ,'O9
2* $33&'&0* '0 '., &*=#' O5&',5&$; '., T0%%0U&*+ 4.0#%3 $%40 1, 4=,O&T&,3 &* '.,
$#3&' =50+5$- ]
− <,%,O',3 =503#O'4 T50- '., 0:,5$%% =503#O' =05'T0%&0
− W., 01j,O'&:,4 $*3 ,X',*' 0T '., $#3&' $4 =$5' 0T '., $#3&' =%$*
− ^,4=0*4&1&%&'&,4 H,9+9; U.0 35$U4 #= '., $#3&' =%$*J
− ^,40#5O,4 H,9+9; ',4'F&*4=,O'&0* ,Y#&=-,*'i $#3&'054J
− W&-&*+F T5,Y#,*O( 0T '., $#3&'
− ^,=05'&*+ 4(4',- $*3 5,O&=&,*'4 0T '., 5,=05'4
/* &*',+5$% =$5' 0T '., $#3&' =50+5$- &4 '., 4=,O&T(&*+ 0T '., 5,40#5O,4
5,Y#&5,3; 4#O. $4 ]
− '., =503#O'4 '0 1, $#3&',3
− '., $#3&'054 O$55(&*+ 0#' '., $#3&' HY#$%&T&O$'&0*4 '0 1, 3,T&*,3
&T $==50=5&$',J
− '., 500-4; O.,OP&*+ ,Y#&=-,*' $*3 O.,OP&*+F',4' T$O&%&'&,4
W., :$5&0#4 T$O'054 -#4' 1, =5&05&'&a,3 '0 -,,' O0-=$*(C4=,O&T&O
5,Y#&5,-,*'4 $*3 -#4' 1, 30O#-,*',39
/* ,:$%#$'&0* 0T '., $#3&' =50+5$- 4.0#%3; T05 ,X$-=%,; '$P, '., T0%%0U&*+
&*'0 $OO0#*' ]
8"$#- 1&;' N
8"$#- 1&;'
8"$#- 1&;' J
6;+;*
P
E$5$9 [ ^,=05'&*+
W., $#3&' =%$* +,*,5$',3 T50- '., $#3&' =50+5$- 3,4O5&1,4 $%% '., $O'&:&'&,4
$*3 5,40#5O,4 5,Y#&5,3 T05 O$55(&*+ 0#' $ =503#O' $#3&'; '0+,'.,5 U&'. '.,
'&-&*+ $*3 '., *#-1,5 0T 5$*30- 4$-=%,4 '0 1, '$P,*9 \&'.&* '.,
T5$-,U05P 0T '., ',4'F&*4=,O'&0* =%$**&*+ &' &4 $%40 4=,O&T&,3 U.&O. O.,OP&*+
-,'.03 $*3 ,Y#&=-,*' $5, '0 1, #4,3 '0 O.,OP '., =503#O' O.$5$O',5&4'&O49
^,4=0*4&1&%&'( T05 35$U&*+ #= '., $#3&' =%$* %&,4 U&'. '., $#3&' =%$**,59
− O05504&0* 5,4&4'$*O,
− 5,$O'&0* '0 ',-=,5$'#5,
− 4'$'&O $*3 3(*$-&O =,5T05-$*O,
^,Y#&5,-,*'4 5,+$53&*+ O.$5$O',5&4'&O4 '0 1, O.,OP,3 $5, 4,' 0#' &* O#55,*'
',O.*&O$% 30O#-,*'4; $4 %&4',3 1,%0U; $*3 -#4' 1, '$P,* &*'0 $OO0#*' &* '.,
$#3&' =%$*]
\.,5, Y#$%&'$'&:, O.,OP4 $5, '0 1, O$55&,3 0#'; %&4'4 0T 3,T,O'4 $*3 %&-&'
4$-=%,4 4.0#%3 1, #4,3; T0%%0U&*+ $+5,,-,*' U&'. '., O#4'0-,59 W0 ,*4#5,
O0*4'$*' $*3 5,%&$1%, 4'$*3$534 T05 '., ,:$%#$'&0*; $ 5,+#%$5 $%&+*-,*'
O.,OP 0T '., %&4'4 $*3 4$-=%,4 4.0#%3 1, O$55&,3 0#'9
W., 5$*30- 4$-=%, 4&a, :$5&,4; 3,=,*3&*+ 0* '., O.,OP&*+ -,'.03 #4,3;
'., =503#O' $*3 =,5&=.,5$% O0*3&'&0*49 G0*4&3,5$'&0* -#4' 1, +&:,* '0
=503#O'&0* :0%#-,4; '., =503#O'&0* =50O,44,4 $*3 '.,&5 O0-=%,X&'(;
4'$'&4'&O$% 4,O#5&'( $*3 %,+$% 5,Y#&5,-,*'49
\.,* O$55(&*+ 0#' $ =503#O' $#3&'; 5,T,5,*O, &4 -$3, '0 $%% '., ',O.*&O$%
30O#-,*'4 &* U.&O. 3,'$&%4 0T '., Y#$%&'( 5,Y#&5,-,*'4 $5, 4=,O&T&,39 2*
3,'$&%; '.,4, -$( &*O%#3, '., T0%%0U&*+ ]
− I5$U&*+4
− <=,O&T&O$'&0*4
− S)c/4
− E503#O'&0* 4,Y#,*O, =%$*4i =50O,44 3,4O5&='&0*4
− W,4' 4=,O&T&O$'&0*4
− b&4'4 0T 3,T,O'4
− b&-&' 4$-=%,4 $*3 %&4'&*+4
− ^,Y#&5,-,*'4 O0:,5&*+ '., ,:$%#$'&0* -,'.034
− c:$%#$'&0* F Y#$%&'( 4'$*3$534
− )$',5&$% 3$'$ 4.,,'4
− /==50:,3 =503#O'&0* 3,:&$'&0*4 H4=,O&$% $==50:$%4J
− ^,O0534 0T O#4'0-,54h ,X=,O'$'&0*4
− <'$*3$534
− b,+$% 5,+#%$'&0*4 H,9+9; *$'&0*$% %,+&4%$'&0*J
− 75$3&*+ 0T 3,T,O'4; &T $==50=5&$', HT05 ,X$-=%,; &*'0
-$j05 $*3 -&*05 3,T,O'4J U&'. ,:$%#$'&0*4
− I,%&:,5( $+5,,-,*'4
− ^,+#%$'&0*4 O0:,5&*+ '., #4, 0T 5,T,5,*O, 30O#-,*'4 $*3
'., O%$44&T&O$'&0* 0T 3,T,O'4 H4,, <,O'&0* [9D] e?0',4 0*
O%$44&T(&*+ 3,:&$'&0*4 $*3 '.,&5 ,:$%#$'&0*eJ9
/#3&' =%$* B
/#3&' =%$* 8
/#3&' =%$* D
E$5$9
R
E$5$9 [ ^,=05'&*+
E503#O' $#3&'4 $5, O$55&,3 0#' &* $OO053$*O, U&'. '., 5,Y#&5,-,*'4 4,' 0#'
&* '., $#3&' =%$*; 1( 4=,O&$%%( '5$&*,3 $#3&'054 H4,, <,O'&0* @ ] e"#$%&T&O$'&0* 0T
'., $#3&' =%$**,5 $*3 $#3&'054eJ9 \.,* $* $#3&' '$P,4 =%$O,; '.,
3,=$5'-,*'4 &*:0%:,3 $5, $3:&4,3 $' 4.05' *0'&O, '.$' =503#O'4 U&%% 1,
5,-0:,3; 40 '.$' '., =503#O'&0* T&+#5,4 O$* 1, O.$*+,3 $OO053&*+%(9
2T '., $#3&' &4 1,&*+ O$55&,3 0#' T05 $ 4=,O&T&O 5,$40* HT05 ,X$-=%,; $
O0-=%$&*' 05 5,j,O'J '., 1$'O. T50- U.&O. '., =$5'4 $5, '$P,* O$* 1, .,%3
#*'&% '., $#3&' &4 O0-=%,',39
2T =501%,-4 $5, T0#*3 U&'. 5,+$53 '0 4$T,'(C5,%,:$*' O.$5$O',5&4'&O4;
&--,3&$', $O'&0* -#4' 1, '$P,* $4 400* $4 '., =501%,- &4 3,',O',3 H4,,
<,O'&0* >9D ] e2--,3&$', $O'&0*4eJ9
$ 2*T05- '.,
$5,$4 &*:0%:,3
O 23,*'&T( '.,
=503#O'4
, ^,O053 '.,
5,4#%'4
/#3&' =%$* B
/#3&' =%$* 8
/#3&' =%$* D
E$5$9
R
6;+;* K C%1.+-#'>
W.&4 30O#-,*'$'&0* &4 #4,3 '0 4,' 0#' O055,O'&:, $O'&0*4 '0 4,O#5, '.,
=503#O' $*3 '0 $O.&,:, =503#O' &-=50:,-,*'49 W., $#3&' 5,=05' -#4' 1,
3&4'5&1#',3 '0 '., 5,%,:$*' 5,4=0*4&1%, $#'.05&'&,4 $*3 $5O.&:,3 &*
$OO053$*O, U&'. 5,+#%$'&0*4 U.&O. .$:, 1,,* %$&3 30U*9
c:$%#$'&*+ '., 5,4#%'4 0T =503#O' $#3&'4 U&%% :$5( T50- 0*, O0-=$*( '0
$*0'.,5; $*3 U&%% $%40 3,=,*3 0* '., =503#O' $*3 &'4 $==%&O$'&0*9 W.,
&-=05'$*' =0&*' &4 '.$' '., -,'.03 0T ,:$%#$'&0* 5,-$&*4 '., 4$-, 0:,5 $
%0*+ =,5&03 0T '&-, '0 ,*4#5, O0-=$5$1&%&'( &* '., %0*+ ',5-9
2*3&:&3#$% 5,=05'4 O0*'$&* '., $#3&' 5,4#%' 0T $* &*3&:&3#$% O.,OP9 W., 5,4#%'
&4 $:$&%$1%, =50-='%(9
W., O%$44&T&,3 $*3 U,&+.',3 5,4#%'4 0T '., =503#O' $#3&' O$* 1, O0*3,*4,3
&*'0 Y#$%&'( -,'5&O4 &* 053,5 '0 =,5-&' O0-=$5$'&:, ,:$%#$'&0*49
Y;';>%2%'- +%1.+-(
2* 053,5 '0 4'5#O'#5, 3&TT,5,*' %,:,%4 0T O0-=%$&*'4 &' &4 5,O0--,*3,3 '.$'
+5$3,4 0T O0-=%$&*'4 O%$44&T&O$'&0*4 1, #4,39 2* $* $#3&'; '.,5,T05,; $*(
3,:&$'&0*4 3,',O',3 O$* 1, $%%0O$',3 '0 $ 3,T&*,3 O%$44&T&O$'&0* H-$j05 $*3
-&*05 3,T,O'4J9
− )$j05 3,T,O' /
− )$j05 3,T,O' Z
− )&*05 3,T,O' G
/#3&' =%$* B
/#3&' =%$* 8
/#3&' =%$* D
E$5$9
R
E$5$9 [ ^,=05'&*+
6;+;* 5 D.++%7-#,%
;7-#.'(
2T 3,:&$'&0*4 $5, 3,',O',3; O055,O'&:, $O'&0*4 -#4' 1, O$55&,3 0#' 0* '., ',4'
4$-=%, $*3; &T *,O,44$5(; 0* =503#O'4 -$*#T$O'#5,3 &* T#%% =503#O'&0*9
\.,* 3,O&3&*+ 0* O055,O'&:, $O'&0*4; &' &4 ,44,*'&$% '0 &*:0%:, '., T#*O'&0*$%
3,=$5'-,*'4 0T '., O0-=$*( U.&O. -#4' O00=,5$', &* ,%&-&*$'&*+ '.,
O$#4,4 0T '., 3,:&$'&0*4 U.&O. .$:, 1,,* 3,',O',39 W., =50O,3#5,4 T05
=50O,44&*+ '., O055,O'&:, $O'&0*4 $5&4&*+ T50- =503#O' $#3&'4 -#4' 1, 4,'
0#' &* '., 3,T&*&'&0* 0T =503#O' $#3&'4 &* '., O0-=$*(h4 Y#$%&'( -$*$+,-,*'
4(4',-9
W., 5,4#%'4 01'$&*,3 T50- $ =503#O' $#3&' $5, $* &*3&O$'05 0T '., %,:,% 0T
=503#O' Y#$%&'(9 W., ,:$%#$'&0* =50O,3#5,4 %$&3 30U* 1( '., &*3&:&3#$%
O0-=$*( T05 '., =503#O' $#3&' ,*4#5, '.$' '.,4, 5,4#%'4 $5, &*O%#3,3 &* '.,
$#3&' 5,=05'9
W., ,X=,5&,*O, 01'$&*,3 &4 &*O%#3,3 &* =503#O' $*3 =50O,44 4=,O&T&O$'&0*49 W.,
',5-4 eb,440*4 %,$5*,3e $*3 eS50*'%0$3&*+e $5, #4,3 '0 3,4O5&1, .0U '.&4
P&*3 0T ,X=,5&,*O, &4 $%5,$3( 1,&*+ #4,39
W., '$4P 0T '., $#3&' =%$**,5 &4 '0 &-=%,-,*' 4'5$',+&O 5,Y#&5,-,*'4 $*3
=,5&=.,5$% O0*3&'&0*4 T50- '., $#3&' =50+5$- &* 0=,5$'&:, $#3&' =%$*49 W.&4
&4 ,44,*'&$% &* 053,5 '0 =%$* '., 0='&-#- #4, 0T ,X&4'&*+ $*3 *,O,44$5(
5,40#5O,49
W., $#3&' =%$**,54h P*0U%,3+, 0T '., =503#O'4 '0 1, $#3&',3; $4 U,%% $4 '.,
O#4'0-,54h 5,Y#&5,-,*'4 $*3 ,X=,O'$'&0*4; -#4' 1, 1#&%' #= $*3 -$&*'$&*,3
1( 5,%,:$*' '5$&*&*+9
M*) 8"$#-.+(
2* 35$U&*+ #= '., $#3&' =%$*; 4=,O&T&O 5,Y#&5,-,*'4 $5, $%40 %$&3 30U*
5,+$53&*+ '., =503#O' $#3&'059
/#3&'054 U&'. $ 5,Y#&5,-,*'4 =50T&%, '$&%05,3 '0 '., &*3&:&3#$% $#3&' =50+5$-
$5, 5,Y#&5,3 '0 O$55( 0#' =503#O' $#3&'49 W., Y#$%&T&O$'&0* 0T '., $#3&'054
-#4' 1, 3&5,O',3 '0U$53 T#%T&%%&*+ '.&4 5,Y#&5,-,*' =50T&%,9
W., T0%%0U&*+ 5,Y#&5,-,*'4 -#4' 1, 105*, &* -&*3 U.,* 4,%,O'&*+ =503#O'
$#3&'054]
J4 C%A%+%'7% $.7"2%'-(
W.&4 6I/ :0%#-, '$P,4 $OO0#*' 0T '., 5,Y#&5,-,*'4 4,' 0#' &* '., T0%%0U&*+
30O#-,*'4]
D.6
G0E &4 '., $115,:&$'&0* T05 eG0*T05-&'( 0T E503#O'&0*e n '.$' &4 '.,
O0-=%&$*O, 0T =503#O'&0* U&'. %,+$% 5,Y#&5,-,*'49
/:$&%$1%, T50- ]
W,%9 ]QA@ H!J LD[D @D 88C!9 S$X ] QA@ H!J LD[D @D 88CDA
cC-$&% ] &*T0q:3$CY-O93,; 2*',5*,'] UUU9:3$CY-O93,